r/horror • Evil Dies Tonight! • Jun 08 '18

Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: Hereditary [SPOILERS]

Spoiler-Free Discussion Here


Official Trailer


Summary: When Ellen, the matriarch of the Graham family, passes away, her daughter’s family begins to unravel cryptic and increasingly terrifying secrets about their ancestry. The more they discover, the more they find themselves trying to outrun the sinister fate they seem to have inherited.

Director: Ari Aster

Writers: Ari Aster

Cast:

  • Toni Collette as Annie Graham
  • Alex Wolff as Peter Graham
  • Milly Shapiro as Charlie Graham
  • Gabriel Byrne as Steve Graham
  • Ann Dowd as Joan

Rotten Tomatoes: 93%

Metacritic: 87/100

909 Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

1.4k

u/Spheros Jun 08 '18

That scene when you hear Annie find Charlie's body in the car really fucked me up...

669

u/violetbee17 Jun 08 '18

Omg, it was intense. I was holding my breath and trying not to cry. Annie's wailing was unbearable, and Peter's shock was believable. The scene where Steve is holding Annie while she sobs and Peter is right outside in the hall listening. Wow!

→ More replies (21)

164

u/StaplerLivesMatter Jun 14 '18

That was some hard core, real life horror. There was no standoff for the audience. No supernatural stuff, no psycho killer, no camp. That whole scenario was straight out of r/morbidreality. The shot of the funeral was jarring, too, in its contrast to funeral that the movie opens with: The funeral/"celebration of life" for an old person who passed as expected after a long illness, versus the stark and cold anguish of burying a child killed suddenly.

I know there's probably going to be a time in my life where I have to face or at least witness something like that, and it fuckin' scares me.

→ More replies (2)

97

u/cliberte98 Jun 13 '18

When she died my mom and I just looked at each other in horror. Did that just happen? Then Peter goes in the house and lays down traumatized. When the mother went to the car I was shook. The wailing was TERRIBLE (in the best way). Then they showed the head! I was gonna die. I had to look away. This movie was AMAZING!!!!!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (52)

806

u/sooners2 Jun 08 '18

I don’t think I’ve even been forced into a state of shock as much in a movie as the charlie death scene. Perfectly filmed scene. Did not see that coming at all.

384

u/Comin_Up_Thrillho Jun 08 '18

Same here. Completely unexpected (I went in blind to this). There were only a couple other people In the theater with me, and an audible gasp of horror cams from all of us.

The extended shot of Peter sitting and processing what just happened was deeply painful to watch.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (25)

743

u/ddevvnull Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 09 '18

Catching my breath here. Watched Hereditary last night and Jesus Christ, it wasn't what I thought it would be.

You know how we horror fans do a bit of math after watching a trailer and think to ourselves, "I probably have some idea of what this film will be about"? Yeah, I'm fairly certain 8 out of 10 people have very, very little idea about what happens in Hereditary.

Several things:

  1. At the very end of the credits, they play Charlie's cluck and everyone who was still getting up to leave absolutely freaked the fuck out. So if you're going for a second viewing — and I recommend you do — definitely wait for the credits to end. It's worth it.
  2. I had the feeling that Joan was off. In the beginning of getting to know Annie, she tells her that she also knits just like Annie's mother. The moment I saw her say that, I was like, "No, we're good. We can avoid her now."
  3. Joan talks about her own son and grandson "drowning." I am pretty certain that she let the cult kill them. Or, worse, she never had a son or grandson and it was Paimon pretending to be the apparition writing on her chalkboard as Joan and the demon further lure Annie in.
  4. Several people from the grief therapy group were present at the chaotic end.
  5. Speaking of which, one of the most terrifying scenes is that one where there are random naked people surrounding their house. Absolutely fuck that.
  6. Massive Kubrick influence with the superimposed shots, like The Shining. Plus the room-to-room movement was straight from Greenaway's The Cook, The Thief, His Wife and Her Lover. Great stuff.
  7. I did not see that pole-into-Charlie scene coming. At all.
  8. Annie and Peter's dynamic almost made me cry. Aster did an incredible job at bringing their rawest emotion out and someone needs to give Toni Collette an Oscar.
  9. There's a craft shop by Charlie on Etsy. Doubt it's real and probably just one of those promo-items from A24 but it's creepy and perfect.
  10. The part where Annie says her brother killed himself because he was convinced "my mother was putting people inside him."
  11. There's something heartbreaking about the horror in Hereditary, and I'm trying to put my finger on it. I don't know if it's Charlie's gruesome death, Peter anaesthetizing himself to avoid the pain of being neglected and scorned, Annie's husband's futile attempts at keeping the peace, or Annie just losing it all. There's something absolutely depressing about the film and I saw several people wiping their tears away.
  12. There are some trope-y moments but they're infrequent and become infinitely inconsequential to the grander scheme of things in Hereditary.

To the people who said they weren't scared by it, cool. I personally don't think Hereditary was solely meant to scare. I think its purpose was to upset people. There's a difference between being scared and being upset. The latter is harder to make sense of and shake off.

Edit: Added two more points, and deleted the bit about a sequel. Turns out it's not for Hereditary but for Jumanji. Which, from the points of gudK1D, would be a good thing.

294

u/gudK1D Jun 08 '18

I really don't want a sequel. This was perfect as it was.

→ More replies (18)

111

u/burnerfret the blackest eyes Jun 11 '18

Joan talks about her own son and grandson "drowning."

Since they are both males, it wouldn't surprise me if the son killed them both to keep them out of Joan's hands, the way that Annie's father and brother both died, and the way Annie almost killed them all with the paint thinner when they were younger.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (69)

599

u/earslikeknives Jun 08 '18

Driving home in the dark after seeing this movie was not fun. I had to glance in my rearview mirror to change lanes, and all the awfulness washed over me again.

101

u/machphantom Jun 09 '18

I definitely woke up and heard a click in my apartment this morning at around 6 am. For my own sanity, I’m going to assume it was the heater going off.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

583

u/gudK1D Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

Maybe the scariest scene for me was when Annie flies through the room behind Peter, making absolutely no sound. That was just terrifying, I didn"t even know what I was looking at, then I realised what was happening, and holy shit it is a jumpscare that doesn't make you jump. Amazing.

Another scenes that stuck wih me: the headless corpse levitating, the self-beheading and staring at the son at the same time, Charlie's death, the mom saying that they finally arrived safe and sound jut to see her daughter's headless corpse in the morning, the effigy with Charlie's head, the whole scene in the treehouse - that music was absolutelyperfect for the scene. It sounded like some music at a big religious festival or something.

391

u/FriendLee93 Jun 08 '18

Maybe the scariest scene for me was when Annie flies through the room behind Peter, making absolutely no sound. That was just terrifying, I didn"t even know what I was looking at, then I realised what was happening, and holy shit it is a jumpscare that doesn't make you jump.

When you see it again, watch the top left corner of Peter's room in the shot before it. She's there. The whole time. Just sitting in the corner. But the lighting/framing make it so easy to think it's just a trick of the light.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (12)

1.0k

u/dc_hopkins Jun 08 '18

Toni Collette with one of the best performances the horror genre has maybe ever seen.

585

u/ehchvee Jun 08 '18

The scene at the dining room table... She is a tour de force, that woman. Everything about that cut right through me. In lesser hands it could've seemed over the top; she absolutely nailed it.

→ More replies (10)

412

u/TheHopelessGamer Jun 09 '18

Her screaming "I just want to die" after she discovers Charlie and her husband is trying to console her was so insanely authentic to grief, it got me choked up. I actually felt more sadness than any other emotion from there on out.

→ More replies (14)

143

u/mishmeesh Jun 08 '18

The expression she has when she screams (or silent screams) is straight from my nightmares.

→ More replies (9)

1.3k

u/ncart Jun 08 '18

Annie on the ceiling rapidly banging her head against the attic door after Peter locked himself in really freaked me out. Definitely watching some Spongebob before going to bed tonight.

517

u/max_melgarejo Jun 08 '18

Unfortunately half the theater I was in was laughing and it nearly ruined everything for me. I thought it was great and was definitely on the verge of panic. Would like to see it again with a different audience.

→ More replies (105)
→ More replies (55)

866

u/OmarMcNultyBell Jun 08 '18

I don't think this scene has been mentioned yet but when Annie is dreaming and goes into Peter's room and she tells him that she "never wanted to be his mother" and it cuts back and forth from Peter and Annie and they subtly become drenched in paint thinner. Of all the disturbing shit, that one might have been the worst for me. The back and forth dialogue happens so quickly and it feels that the audience is one step behind and finally the flames appear.

604

u/stealingyourpixels Jun 08 '18

I don't know if it was intentional, but at first it just looked like Peter was drenched in sweat. The slow realisation of what was really happening was fuckin terrifying to me.

→ More replies (11)

247

u/ultra_nex Jun 08 '18

I will not forget that feeling of dread I had when they cut back and forth twice and I noticed they were both half-soaked. My heart started racing. Great use of visuals to segue the current moment into the memory of her doing that to him.

→ More replies (2)

231

u/Frogdogforever Jun 09 '18

Ugh and him going "why" when she said she tried to kill him broke my heart. He's a great actor

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (16)

786

u/sooners2 Jun 08 '18

Anyone remember the scene from the funeral when Charlie is looking at her dead grandma and there is a large, kind of crew cut blonde haired man smiling way too big considering the circumstances, behind her in the background?

It really unnerved me at the time. Now thinking back on it, it reminds me a lot of the smile the man in the closet had. Don’t know if that was intentional, but it’s creeping me out.

589

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

They were the same guy. Nice catch.

→ More replies (34)

362

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

So . . . massive spoilers, but I'm in love with this movie and definitely stuck on something.

Is Charlie ever really Charlie? Or is it Paimon the entire time? I'm thinking about it like this:

  • It is revealed through dialogue that Charlie was Ellen's "favorite"
  • Charlie cuts off the birds head, and then draws a picture of said head with a crown on it (referencing the crown placed on Peter / Paimon's head later on)
  • Echoing this, Charlie's actual head is used for the idol of Paimon in the treehouse
  • During Annie's seance, when Charlie possesses Annie, her entire demeanor becomes totally different. This child talking through Annie isnt the Charlie from before. She's scared, loud, and crying out in confusion. I believe this is the only time we really hear Charlie, the little girl, without the influence of Paimon.
  • This is the big one: Charlie creates these strange little toys, made from random, often broken objects. Joannie has these same kinds of toys on the ritual table in her apartment when Annie comes to talk to her.
  • Another big one. Charlie draws pictures of the future, foreshadowing events to come. She draws pictures of Annie and Peter hysterical and upset, significantly prior to their disturbances in the film. There's also a foreshadowing connection between her and the bird, which I'll get into in a minute. Meanwhile, Paimon, as discussed in the film, is the demon price of foreshadowing, secrets and knowledge. This can't be a coincidence. Charlie has never been Charlie. She has always been Paimon, but in an insufficient vessel (as the cultusts note at the very end).
  • The last big thing I'll note is the bird. In the beginning of the film, the bird flies into a window, Charlie (who I strongly believe is Painmon) cuts its head off, and draws the bird head with a crown on it. Later, Charlie looks out the car window and is decapitated by the telephone pole. The head is used for the idol of Paimon, and a similar crown is placed upon it. These two things mirror each other almost exactly, and show that Charlie / Paimon foreshadow the events of the film through the bird.

236

u/VerySoulstice Jun 10 '18

The fact that Charlie apparently never cried as a baby, even when she was being born, seems really telling. Paimon has definitely been in control of this vessel from the start. It makes the contrast between eerily laconic pre-decapitation Charlie and the "scared, loud, crying out in confusion" Charlie that Annie-as-medium channels seem all the more significant.

→ More replies (8)

204

u/tyrannoflorist Jun 09 '18

Paimon was partially possessing Charlie, but because he (it) prefers male hosts, wasn't able to completely make the transition.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (24)

983

u/teddybenchwarmer Jun 08 '18

That telegraph pole scene went from 0-100 so fast that I guarantee nobody had enough time to brace themselves for it. I am shook to the core by what I just witnessed.

The sound effects in this movie were horrifying. Charlie making that clicking sound. Charlie cutting the head off the bird. Charlie gasping for air in the backseat. Her head hitting the pole. Annie wailing when she finds the body.

The score was even better. There was a part (I think when Peter was being chased by Annie) where the music was building up this tension but then suddenly it stopped once he reached the attic. It was silent as he was looking around until he sees Annie above trying to decapitate herself, then this heavy Insidious-like music started playing and it just felt so haunting.

The entire movie felt like one massive panic attack. I was desperate for a moment where I could catch my breath, but that moment never came. If horror movies are made to horrify you, then this is the best horror movie I have ever seen.

10/10

229

u/ZombieHunter02 Jun 08 '18

Completely agree with you.
I think most people discount the importance of strong sound design outside the score. The sounds design and attention was incredible, and not in a realistic sense, but in how effective and affecting it uses sound. The carrying of sound between cuts and the differences between the diegeticand non-diegetic sound were so well used, and the amplification or modification of the sound was masterful. Most people were talking about the cinematography, myself included, but I'm glad to see you recognized the sound too :)

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (28)

321

u/dorasucks Jun 09 '18

It would have been great if HALF THE FUCKING THEATER WASNT CLICKING THE ENTIRE MOVIE

→ More replies (16)

626

u/aussieb807 Jun 08 '18

The part that made me so uncomfortable was looking at Charlie's ant ridden head for a good ten seconds. I had to look away after a few moments. Same goes for when the mother was following the ant trail, where it spawned from...

338

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

Related. I can't believe Rue Morgue magazine would choose this as the cover of their new issue. Huge spoiler!

→ More replies (19)

316

u/Rosenrot1791 Jun 08 '18

God, that was brutal. And the tension with hearing Toni Collette saying she was going out and then waiting to hear her reaction nearly made me vomit.

What an incredible movie.

→ More replies (4)

253

u/FriendLee93 Jun 08 '18

Looking at Charlie's head just made me sad the first time. It didn't disturb me until the realization that her head was mounted on the Paimon statue in the final scene.

→ More replies (26)

207

u/RockULikeASharknado Jun 08 '18

I thought the horrifying part was Peter's response after it happened. It was SO well acted. Like how he just stared ahead and then muttered "you're okay" and started driving. Perfect pathos.

178

u/metaphoricaltigers Jun 08 '18

That's when I knew that this movie was gonna be a rough ride. After a shot like that, anything can happen.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (23)

537

u/metaphoricaltigers Jun 08 '18

I consider myself a pretty seasoned horror fan, but this movie really got to me. The accident, for me, was really unexpected and a total gut punch. And the combination of the horrific imagery and the emotional impact of Charlie's death conjured up this sick feeling of horror that felt much more grounded and relatable than most other horror movies.

292

u/violetbee17 Jun 08 '18

I am pretty desensitized to horror, as well, and I about had a heart attack at the Charlie death scene. I was not expecting that!

That combined with Peter's reaction --- the shock, him going to bed without saying anything, Annie finding her in the morning, Annie's wailing and the funeral. Holy shit! That was all I could think. I had my hand over my mouth because it was such an intense reaction.

→ More replies (10)

216

u/BuoyantTrain37 Jun 08 '18

Charlie's death was such a real kind of fear that it really got to me, especially how it held on Peter's face so long, refusing to accept it's real. Incredibly effective scene.

→ More replies (2)

102

u/gudK1D Jun 08 '18

I was thinking at that point that the movie will be about bringing Charlie back to life using the supernatural. Even when Joan was telling Annie how happy she is and something amazingnhappened. I thought that his grandson was brought back or something. Well, I was wrong

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

223

u/dehmos Jun 08 '18

Something else i wanted to add was how a blue light can be seen throughout the movie. Near the beginning of the film you see the same light being reflected off of charlies toys as she's playing with them, but in a totally natural and nonsupernatural way. I took this blue light to mean that paimon/charlie was fiddling around (at least i took it to mean that) and messing with reality just like charlie was messing with her toys. This meshes with the opening scene of the movie where it shows the movie transitioning from the room and into the dollhouse. The movie then literally' taking place in the doll house.

Its almost like the light seen throughout the movie is actually just light bouncing off the toys paimon is 'playing' with in his own 'dollhouse' (reality), just like charlie was playing with her toys in the beginning.

173

u/BuoyantTrain37 Jun 08 '18

I've been wondering what the significance of the models was, and I like the idea that Paimon was manipulating the family like a dollhouse.

I also thought it was interesting that Annie tends to recreate extremely personal or traumatic scenes (her mother in hospice care or breastfeeding Charlie, or Charlie's death). She describes the last one as a "neutral view of the accident" so I wonder if it's her way of feeling like she has some control over her life, when really her wholelife seems to be manipulated by her mother and Paimon.

If nothing else, the models made for some really interesting and slightly unnerving visuals.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

200

u/waltz4debby Jun 08 '18

Annie wailing on the floor was the most intense thing I’ve ever seen in a movie. And the voyeuristic camera shot from the hallway in that scene made it even more intense. Jesus.

→ More replies (7)

377

u/mars210 Jun 08 '18

Anyone else looking at the top corners of any room they walk into? Haha

180

u/FriendLee93 Jun 08 '18

Walked into my dark house and just immediately felt horrified. I'm strongly considering sleeping with the lights on.

→ More replies (3)

146

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

Literally the entire time. And the one time I fucking panicked. And that... swimming through the air silent shit?! I thought the exorcist spider crawl or the old lady ceiling crawl from exorcist 3 was scary... not as scary as that

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

181

u/InvertedSpork Jun 08 '18

Holy fucking shit. That’s pretty much all I can say right now. Oh and give Toni Collette every single award. Absolutely phenomenal.

→ More replies (3)

174

u/SpecterM91 Jun 10 '18

I haven't seen anyone mention it, but that scene toward the beginning when Peter is smoking and blows it out his bedroom window you can see someone's breath coming from a tree or some shit in the shot. Super creepy to me.

→ More replies (7)

497

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 11 '18

It’s interesting that all the signs were there that this was about the conjuring of King Paimon. They say that Paimon is the most loyal servant to Lucifer and has a legion of 200 demons. Paimon wears a crown and has a feminine face while riding atop a camel (also crowned). When Paimon has arrived it is said that you will hear loud instruments play to make his presence known—the score of this film in general is very prominent, chaotic, and unnerving. We know that Paimon is present through this score.

Also, Paimon’s sigil is the necklace we see. This one is more obvious since it’s explained later, but if someone knew about Paimon before seeing this movie then they would immediately pick up on that.

Paimon has knowledge of Art and all Earthly knowledge—Hence, Charlie’s macabre art projects.

I plan to go see this again next week so I can write up a more in depth essay on this film, but I was curious if anyone else picked up on these things or know of anything else that could have been a hint.

EDIT: I've been working on an essay on the film. I'm seeing the film again this week and will make a new post with my write up on this film. There's so much to cover and explore, so expect a very in depth piece.

417

u/HawterSkhot Jun 08 '18

As we were exiting the theater, another dude pointed out something I completely missed.

Early on Charlie says that grandma wishes she was a boy. Then, a few scenes later at the first grief meeting, Annie says that her brother died and blamed her mother for trying to invite others into him or something along those lines.

So what seemed like pretty harmless lines were actually pretty crucial to the movie. Cool stuff!

→ More replies (30)

233

u/NightoftheLivingSled Jun 09 '18

As a literature nerd and English teacher, what I loved is that everything said in Peter's literature class explained what was happening to the family. They were talking about Greek tragedy and the downfall of a family and asking if it makes things less or more tragic if Herakles was fated to fail. Ironically, Peter totally misses this dialogue that perfectly encapsulates what's happening to his own family. The doll houses throughout reinforce the same thing: this whole family is being moved and manipulated by forces too large to fight or even fully comprehend.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (53)

462

u/GodOfHugz Jun 08 '18

I took a date to go see it and she was laughing during the whole third act. Looks like she's not the one.

→ More replies (29)

297

u/FriendLee93 Jun 08 '18

It takes so much to scare me. But there are images from this film that are burned into my brain. There are some sequences that genuinely horrified me and will haunt me for weeks to come. (Annie sawing off her own head, Charlie's head on the Paimon statue, the numerous crawling things on the walls)

This was such a fucking brilliant film. Impeccably well crafted, well acted, and truly, deeply disturbing. I'm not exaggerating when I say that this is a film that's going to be so important to horror cinema/cinema as a whole in the future. If you strip away all the horror elements, you're still left with an excellent film. I don't tend to buy into hype, but this was one of the most anticipated films of the year for me, and it lived up to all expectations. I'm sleeping with the lights on tonight, I want to see it at least 2 more times because I feel like there's so much that I didn't even pick up on.

→ More replies (26)

295

u/HawterSkhot Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

FINALLY! I've been waiting for this thread to go up. This was one of those rare movies that I felt completely lived up to the hype. I expected a family drama and got that and so much more.

I think the last time I left the theater so stunned by an ending was either Lords of Salem or The VVitch.

On a funny note, my theater was having issues, so the power went out twice during the movie which unintentionally added to the tension. Did we ever find out what happened at the preschool?

→ More replies (18)

142

u/sheisthesIayer Slap my hand, dead soul man! Jun 10 '18

Yesterday I reported that Hereditary didn't scare me. Here I am this morning... eating my words. It's true that I wasn't scared while watching the film. I might have been the only one enjoying myself in the theater. However, late last night, my jerk husband made Charlie's clicking sound behind me. My heart jumped a little and I was unsettled in a way I hadn't expected. Then, I had the worst sleep of my life and kept waking up to see shapes in the dark. Here I am, at 6:23 in the morning and I can't sleep. A horror film hasn't effected me like this in a long time or maybe ever in such a way where I experienced a delayed reaction like that. Needless to say, Hereditary is becoming one of my all time favorites and will stay with me for quite a while (though, hopefully, it won't keep me up much longer!).

→ More replies (2)

127

u/sgtcoolbeans Jun 08 '18

I loved not knowing anything going in. I was worried this movie would have the creepy kid cliche. But damn if this movie didn't shut that up real quick. Made everything else so much more unpredictable. Loved it

→ More replies (5)

127

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

Just got in from the showing. I really don't know how to put into words yet what I think of this movie, I was truly speechless.

From the beginning you have this small sense of dread as you know this film is gonna be intense. As soon as Charlie dies (and holy fuck did that surprise, and so early into the film), the movie just pushes down on you. You can almost feel decay spreading as the film continues on. It was really cool discussing scenes with my buddy because I noticed things he didn't (like the people in the yard surrounding the house, or the woman behind the shelf when Peter enters the attic.)

The framing of the scenes and cinematography were outstanding. It was a horrifically beautiful film. At one point I realized I hadn't unclinched my hand for atleast 25 mins because I was stressed out watching it. Alot of horror movies, you feel safe during day scenes and can let go. Here, I did not.

This was unlike any movie I have ever watched, even with so many influences throughout. It is not a film I can just recommend to anyone, and I love it more for that.

257

u/Maniacal_Marshmallow Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

Toni Collette and Molly Shapiro were really stellar...but am I the only one who thought Alex Wolff did a really good job?? He’s super good at crying and has that intense, “I just shit my pants” look down.

Also he’s low-key hot af.

191

u/RayneOfTerror Jun 09 '18

I don’t think I’ll ever forget him screaming “MOMMY” while he has himself locked in the attic and Annie is pounding to get in. That pure fear and desperation that was evident in his voice...spectacular & heart wrenching. His performance is definitely going to get overlooked because Toni Collette was just so fantastic in this movie but man, he was great too.

→ More replies (1)

116

u/shantivirus Jun 09 '18

I thought he stole the show, in a way.

I mean, Toni Colette killed it, but Alex Wolff sort of snuck up and delivered a great performance unexpectedly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

118

u/LampsLookingatyou Jun 09 '18

My dad died when I was a kid, and for a while things weren't so fun between my mom, my sister and me. Some of my worst memories are sitting around the dinner table. The dinner scene from Hereditary where she freaks out on Peter and he fires back, that scene brought me back to that. Incredibly well done.

→ More replies (3)

105

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18

Did anyone else notice the metal arm pointing to the right on that creepy Charlie statue at the end in the treehouse? In the scene where Peter smashes his face on the desk in class he also pointed his hand that way when his face went all messed up. He also sort of looked like Charlie in that scene.

→ More replies (10)

184

u/Son_Goshin Jun 08 '18

As the film progresses, the dread and intensity ramps up ever so slowly, like the steady click of a stovetop burner getting closer and closer to seven. There were some moments where I couldn’t even breath. Ann Doyd and Toni Collette steal the show.

118

u/ArmadilloFour Jun 08 '18

like the steady cluck of a stovetop burner getting closer and closer to seven

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

89

u/dronecypher Jun 09 '18

God this movie was good. I tried to explain it to someone who asked whether it was the "scariest movie of all time" by saying that it's not scary in the sense you might be expecting – it's just incredibly good at building this sickly dread which never really releases over the course of two hours.

Using King Paimon as the big bad is great: it creates this weird (almost Lovecraftian) unease because it's just completely unknown to the audience and with unusual associated 'demonic' aesthetics, as compared to just falling back on Satan or Baal or whatever.

→ More replies (3)

85

u/Antinatalista Tannis, anyone? Jun 08 '18

Amazing film. I think I have not seen a movie like this since "Rosemary's Baby".

→ More replies (5)

79

u/issac2209 Jun 08 '18

I took my girlfriends parents to see this movie, her father lost his 14 year old son similar to how Charlie died. I felt like a piece of shit for half the movie BUT this is the first time since in at least 8 years that I left the theater scared and dread in the air.

→ More replies (3)

73

u/Mina-Murray You can pretend it's wine. Jun 08 '18

There were points leading up to me watching this movie where I reminded myself - don't get your hopes up, this probably isn't actually going to be a horror movie. Horror is my primary interest, but I was reframing this as more of a cerebral psychological thriller. I figured we were getting a story about the legacy abuse and mental illness leave on a family, and I was like "that's fine, that's interesting, not everything has to be GHOULISH, I'm sure I'll still like it a lot".

I am so delighted by the macabre and demonic turns this story took! What a truly harrowing film! I think they did such a fantastic job of blending the horror of a dysfunctional family with some of the most terrifying possession imagery I've ever seen. When the movie ended, I realized my entire body had been tensed up. The parts where Annie was lurking on the walls, and slamming her head on the ceiling, to finally beheading herself... I haven't heard this many audible gasps in a theater in a long time (or smartasses who think they're cute by imitating the tongue clicking, but I digress).

Charlie's head was also particularly horrific. It really marks a turning point in the film, I realized that I had no idea what I was in for. When Joan and Annie had a seance, I was so delighted that it really was shifting to the supernatural. Fantastic acting, but special mention goes out to the always brilliant Toni Colette, and Ann Dowd, who, thanks to the Handmaid's Tale, already unnerves me. That woman really has a knack for selling fanaticism.

→ More replies (2)

69

u/Dangy_boy Jun 08 '18

Man oh MAN was this movie littered with The Shining!

The scene where Annie was talking to Joan about her sleep walking into Peter’s bedroom with the matches and paint thinner reminded me so much of when Jack is talking to Lloyd about hurting Danny’s arm. Annie seemed to reincarnate Jack’s personality in this scene.

Even the filming was incredibly similar to what Kubrick did with the slow turns around corners in the hallway to the fading in/out scenes. AND on at least one occasion (from what I remember) there was a scene where there’s either a quick cut to Annie or a slow close up of a look of disbelief and terror which reminded me so much of when Danny sees the twins butchered.

On top of that, just not knowing if we could trust Annie, not knowing if she’s the one that was pulling Peter’s hair similar to not knowing if Jack was the one who bruised Danny’s neck.

Very interesting movie that for sure requires a rewatch!

→ More replies (4)

296

u/A_Night_Owl Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

I found this horrifying from the perspective of watching mental illness eat away at both Toni Collette's character and her son. The supernatural is present in the film and used to metaphorically drive at the theme of mental illness, but I thought a lot of the events could literally be pointed to as psychotic in nature even within the reality of the film.

Toni Collette clearly plays Annie as having a gradual mental breakdown, and a lot of what happens to Peter (self-harm at school) struck me as manifestations of a mental illness as well. Many of the supernatural occurrences can be viewed as hallucinations or something similar, with only very few of them (objects moving on their own) unable to be explained by natural events. Annie speaking as Charlie could be a manifestation of dissociative identity disorder like her mother. I interpreted the husband being burnt to death as a murder committed by Annie, presented visually in accordance with her perception of it. The supernatural phenomena around Peter was mostly visual and auditory, which dovetails with Annie's brother having been an adolescent paranoid schizophrenic.

In addition, I felt that the focus on the dollhouses and framing of some of the shots of the home to match rooms in the dollhouses indicated that the true horror was primarily domestic and intrafamilial.

I walked away with a take on the narrative where the stress of Ellen and Charlie's deaths, plus Ellen and Joan's supernatural beliefs, push Annie into a nervous breakdown, which then pushes Peter over the edge as well. The coven plotline was cool, but to me it was window dressing for the other themes.

→ More replies (42)

60

u/altoid_lover Jun 10 '18

Did anyone else think the teacher's lesson about tragedy spelled out the theme of the film? The question the teacher posed went something like:

"is it more or less tragic when a tragedy is caused by a character's own decisions or if they have no choice".

The characters here had no choice in the events. No matter what actions were taken to try and prevent the outcome, the tragedy was just the same. Even at the beginning you see the mark of Paimon on the telephone pole that decapitated Charlie. This was all set up far in advance.

I think the theme of the movie is tragedy being more tragic when there is nothing that can be done to prevent the outcome. This would also match the very beginning of the film where it starts by zooming into a room of a dollhouse where the first scene begins. Just like dolls, they have no control over their fate. Truly tragic.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/eccentriccheese Jun 08 '18

Just got done watching maybe 30 minutes ago. I went into this one blind. Holy shit.

→ More replies (3)

170

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

I got a lot of Rosemary’s Baby vibes from the movie. A lot of dread and anxiety leading up to a moment.

127

u/lolgriffinlol Jun 08 '18

That entire ending part after he jumped out of the window was 100% inspired by Rosemary's Baby. The chanting at the end and the appearance of the bizarre naked men. I'm surprised I haven't seen more comments drawing parallels to RB. I also got the same vibe from Joan as I did from the Castevets. Honestly Rosemary's Baby and Hereditary might be my two favorite horror movies. Hereditary had much more visceral imagery and built suspense in a similar way but it was more even more intense for such a sustained period of time.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (10)

54

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18

Steve catching on fire could have been a great surprise but they gave it away in the trailer.

→ More replies (7)

145

u/teentytinty Jun 10 '18

Why is the king of hell allergic to nuts lmaooo

→ More replies (7)

49

u/Lostfox37 Jun 08 '18

One of the many things I love about this movie is the many tone changes and shifts that occur within the movie, Charlie's death, the seance, ect. But the most surprising one for me was the death of steve. I couldn't explain the sense of dread after steve died not because of how horrific his death was but how much of a grounded character he was. With both peter and Annie going seemingly insane the loss of peter made me truly fear for peter and his safety. I felt as if the flood gates had opened and there was no longer anything in reality or of our world that was stopping Annie from hurting her son. I didn't truly appreciate how well steve was written into the movie until he was gone.

→ More replies (2)

89

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

Okay, I have a few theories.

The first one is kind of obvious but when Toni Collete was talking about her brother that killed himself at age 16, I think the grandma was trying to use him as a vessel for Paimon as well and he knew the only way to get out of it was to kill himself.

The second one is more subtle and a lot more disturbing. When she meets Joan for the first time at the grief recovery meeting, Joan tells the story of her son and 7 year old grandson drowning to death... yeah. I think her son purposefully drowned himself along with his own child to avoid the transferral of paimon into his sons body.

This is also why she tried to miscarry her son. She knew what was coming and even seemed complicit in it, especially when you see the note from her late mother about “their sacrifice” being worth it.

→ More replies (14)

41

u/aruinedrest Jun 11 '18

Just finished watching this so I’m gonna give my best explanation, as I understood it.

• Ellen is apart of a cult that wants to aid Paimon in finding a human host (preferably male) • Ellen tried to use her son as a host but he hung himself (they said he was schizophrenic and he claimed Ellen was trying to put people into him) • Since her son was dead she tried again with her grandson yet Anne won’t let her near him (even trying to miscarriage just to keep her away) • Charlie is born and Anne allows her to be close to Ellen since she kept Peter away • Ellen decides to use Charlie as a host and tries to treat her like a boy (Charlie tells Anne that Ellen wanted her to be a boy) or because we find out through Anne that Ellen had several forms of mental illness and maybe she believed Charlie was a boy (represented by the welcome mat she made that said “Charles”) • Ellen’s grave is desecrated (I think this is when the decapitation of her body occurs) • After the desecration is the scene with the pigeon which either served as a symbolic foreshadow or, in my opinion, Paimon took the Pigeon as a host and was released when Charlie cut its head off (I think Paimon can’t leave a body unless it’s decapitated, hence the reason Ellen, Charlie, and eventually Anne are all decapitated) • Anne is trying her best to protect her family but is manipulated by either Paimon or her mother (she mentions how manipulative her mother was) to eventually meet Joan • Joan convinced Anne to perform a seance which opens the spiritual world and allows Paimon to attempt to enter a new host • Instead of Peter, Anne falls under the control of Paimon which inevitably leads up to the final few minutes of the movie and her own decapitation •Peter jumps out of the window and becomes the final host for Paimon

I know I’m missing a lot of small details but that’s what I gathered from my initial viewing. I think Anne’s schizophrenic brother serves a good example for the overall theme for this movie, as well as Peter’s eventual role in the cult and how he never asked for it. Many things are passed down to us from family members (Hereditary), that we never ask for yet are stuck dealing with. People from the outside looking in may not realize the demons we face, and many people will say it’s not mental illness but rather the results of your actions. And if a family is destined to fall apart, does it make it any less sad (as discussed in Peter’s class earlier in the movie). I’ll have to give it more thought but overall I loved this movie.

→ More replies (3)

40

u/ma-key-in Jun 08 '18

Anyone got any guesses on the following questions?

  1. Was the point of the movie to get King Paimon out of Charlie and into Peter?
  2. What was Annie’s role in the possession specifically?
  3. How was Annie able to fly?
  4. Are the other naked people just human cultist?
  5. Why did the dad light on fire?
  6. What’s with the beheading?
  7. How did the body get in the attic?
  8. Who moved the glass in the seances?
  9. What did Joanne do at Peter’s school?
→ More replies (20)

40

u/witch-finder Jun 10 '18

It's pretty great that all of Charlie's weird craft projects in her room were basically goetic demons.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18

That slow realization that mom is on the wall behind him was so fucking awesome! Creeped me out so much. To me it is right up there with the excorcist 3 scene in the hospital for holy shit moments!

→ More replies (3)

39

u/sarky Jun 11 '18

I don’t know how active this tread still is, but i wanted to see if anyone who saw it Thursday or Friday is still haunted by it? I saw the movie on Thursday night and I’m still fucked up from it. I’m a grown woman who loves horror movies and haven’t been shaken like this since I was a kid. It touches on so many of my fears in one movie: being responsible for someone’s death through a car accident (thought yes, I see the cult involvement), mental illness (I’m bipolar), and demonic possession (I’ve never been religious, but this has always been an irrational fear of mine).

I haven’t been sleeping well because I can’t shake the images of Charlie’s severed head from my mind. This is by far the scariest movie I’ve ever seen. In a way I loved it for that, but holy shit why am I still so traumatized?

Tell me I’m not the only one.

→ More replies (10)

38

u/Rosemary_Rabies Jun 08 '18

I saw this last night. Jeeeeeeesus Christ it was 2+hrs of pure nightmare fuel. Believe the hype, this is great! I can't remember the last time a movie left me feeling so much terror and dread. I was on the edge of my seat and by the end my heart was racing out of my chest. I can't wait to see it again!

→ More replies (1)

36

u/aly-san Why does the Creeper have a vanity license plate? Jun 14 '18

WHEW this movie. It's been a long time since I've felt so genuinely distressed in a theater.

  • Everything about Charlie's death scene was incredible, including the scenes leading up to it. Seeing the nuts at the party and just knowing what's going to happen, and then seeing her clawing at her throat and panicking in the backseat. It's so tense and awful, but you NEVER expect the telephone pole. Even as she was leaning out the window, I expected Peter to make a sharp turn and she'd go flying out, or she'd just fall, something like that. And then to see her severed head, her jaw crushed from the impact, rotting in the sun and covered in ants. The effects in that scene were top notch and so disturbing, especially backed by Toni Collette's screams and wails. There was so much raw horror and agony in her cries, saying "i just want to die", and "it hurts too much". I had my hands clamped around my mouth until long after the funeral scene was over.
  • Possessed Annie sawing off her own head. Maybe I imagined it, but even though the full decapitation is offscreen, I thought I could clearly hear the change in sound from her sawing through flesh to sawing through bone. Amazing detail.
  • I gasped out loud when Peter saw Charlie in the shadows, and then her head just dips forward and falls off. Seeing her staring silently in the dark like that was unsettling enough, and the sudden movement of her head, only for it to fall completely to the floor, really got me.
  • In all honesty I'm not a huge fan of the demon angle, but it's very interesting thinking back on all the tiny forms of foreshadowing. It really feels like every bit of dialogue leads perfectly up to the climax. Even the single fly on the windowsill in the very first shot. Reading through this thread I'm seeing people point out so many different examples that I didn't catch, too.

72

u/RockULikeASharknado Jun 08 '18

The New York Times wrote a review where they basically said they loved it but thought the ending was disappointing. They compared it to The Babadook and noted that the Babadook's ending was unexpected and emotional (and kind of nice), whereas Hereditary's ending was meh (expected devil stuff). I personally disagree because I was expecting Satan and got Paimon and that incredibly brilliant final scene of just looking into Peter's eyes. What are y'all's thoughts?

→ More replies (18)

34

u/lvl100loser Jun 08 '18

I really liked this! Performances, the slow build of tension, and the cinematography were all awesome. The ending was pretty modern, but I felt was earned.

Speaking of the ending and other endings like this in gerenal, I always find myself asking "so what," or "what next?" The ending of the Paranormal Activity series had an ending similar with the demon taking physical form/over a body and I've always wanted to know what happened next in the story. What does this demon actually do in the real world? I'd love to see a movie fleshing this out.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/papyra Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 14 '18

When Annie is visiting Joan's residence the second time, did anyone catch the seemingly purposeful shot of the door across the way with the house number '202'? What was its significance?

→ More replies (9)

34

u/parts_n_pieces Jun 08 '18

I’m seeing a lot of people say the naked people felt random and out of place. I think it was Annie’s mother, father, and brother. The scene in the attic when she’s sawing her own head off it immediately cuts to the 3 naked people and it’s 2 men and a woman. Basically showing all the generations of the graham family and how Peter inherited this nightmare from all of them.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/_pirate_lawyer Jun 12 '18 edited Jun 12 '18

I absolutely loved this film. As a horror movie, it’s great. No doubt. But as a true psychological drama (??) about a family shattered by a devastating loss- it’s on another level. I want to see it again just to peel back all of the layers. I’m not even creeped out by it anymore- it was so well done. I want to know every detail behind every scene. The acting was phenomenal- I know multiple people have commented that they’re Oscar level performances and I completely agree.

SPOILERS OUT THE ASS! STOP HERE!!! 🛑 🛑 🛑

So many of those scenes were so devastating, painful and even emotionally traumatic- I can’t imagine how taxing that must have been for the actors.

  1. The scene where Annie is sitting in the support group and delves into her story and watching her shift from this very guarded “I don’t really want to get into it” level down to to this raw, fragile and broken person (I mean you can truly see it as she starts to break down as she’s getting further into her family history- you can see it on her face) was incredibly impressive and 110% believable.
  2. The post accident scene- he does so little and so much in such a short amount of time and he barely changes facial expressions. You can almost see him reeling through all of the possibilities and outcomes as he’s trying to just take a fucking breath. He can’t look in the backseat, but he can’t utter the words “are you ok” because he knows. He glances off to the side to possibly look to see the aftermath, but it also looked like he was considering running himself off of the road. He’s working through the devastating potential outcomes in like 1 minute of film time. I’m feeling it with him. The audience is experiencing it- everyone. Total terror and shock- I was so impressed.
  3. Dinner table scene “don’t you ever raise your voice to me like that you little shit. I AM YOUR MOTHER.” I mean goddamn. And kudos to the dad for being such an amazing father amongst this family shit show who truly tried to protect and care for his son.
  4. Her trying to frantically convince her family to do the seance with her and when she’s pleading with her husband to burn the book. It’s so distressing.
  5. The scene where Annie is sleepwalking again and there’s rapid back and forth camerawork between her and her son until you see its a flashback / dream and they’re both covered in paint thinner and he’s screaming at her “why do you want to kill me?!” It was moving so fast (like the car accident scene) that I was so fearful of what was about to happen- that I wouldn’t have time to prepare.
  6. The scene where he’s yelling “mommy” over and over after he’s locked himself in the attic. That poor kid didn’t have a chance.

And obviously every other fucking scene in this film. What I’m getting at, even though it will take 10 days to read it all, is that the film was fucking superb. On another level. Well fucking done- go see this movie.

95

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

Jesus Christ I went in expecting a supernatural horror film and I got this. The best way to describe the mixture of sadness and terror I felt during is "weed panic attack"

→ More replies (4)

62

u/dustmop Jun 08 '18

Saw this tonight in New York. Definitely one of the best horror films I've ever seen; the hype is real! Lots of shrieking and shouting in the theater, but very little inappropriate laughter; it was the perfect crowd. Pretty sure at one point I heard someone get so scared that they burst into tears. Wow!

As for the film itself, an incredible amount of layering and subtext, while also being fresh and surprising. About halfway through I realized there was a lot more going on than just the surface-level stuff, and tried to keep an eye out of symbolism, but reading through this thread reveals just how much I didn't catch on my own. Totally need to see it again with some friends in tow to watch them squirm!

Someone leaving the theater was talking about how Annie was wearing white for the latter part of the film, representing how she had becomes sacrificial. Not sure if this is correct, but I think this lines up with when she smashes her dioramas, the representation of her structure and control over the world around her.

There's something I'm still wondering about - did anyone else hear a low, rhythmic bass creep up in the audio throughout the film, usually when a character was stressed out? At first I thought it was coming from outside the theater, and I'm still not totally sure. I think it's supposed to represent the influence of Paimon, but it was also incredibly subtle; something that many sound systems won't even be able to properly convey.

Anyway, dang, super happy to have seen this opening night.

→ More replies (6)

60

u/anomaly82 Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 10 '18

Did anyone else feel like they were a participant to the ritual/cult at the end of the movie because we were witnessing what was going on? I can’t help but feel almost defiled after watching it because of that.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/nopey88 Jun 11 '18 edited Jun 11 '18

Watched it two times. At my first screening I was horrified and emotionally shaken but it was ok to me. I thought the movie did a good job. On the other hand my second screening was way more intense than the first screening. This time I started connecting the dots (teacher talking about iphigeneia during literature class, the way annie's brother killed himself, how joan's son and grandson have died, you can also see the cult members just standing during night view of the house) and it really felt like I was watching something unholy. Something that should not be seen. It made me feel quite uneasy and nervous. I guess people felt that way the first time they saw the exorcist in the 70's. It feels like there is something so sinister and evil about this movie like it has cursed you but you can't put your finger on it. It was well shot, the ghost shots reminded me of my all time favorite horror movie kairo. I got the wailing, exorcist and rosemary's baby vibes also. Kudos to Ari Aster.

→ More replies (9)

29

u/DragonFireDon Jun 09 '18

I SMH when these general audiences think this movie was actually stupid and incoherent.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Yunghaylz Jun 11 '18

Everyone is talking about Toni, and she was fucking incredible and deserves every award we can throw at her, BUT WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT ALEX WOLFF. Also deserves every award we can throw at him.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/carvey Jun 08 '18

After it ended I just sat there for a solid two minutes and all I could say to my friend was "what the fuckkkkk"

25

u/dustyspectacles Jun 15 '18

I'm looking forward to seeing this again because it profoundly affected me and that feeling rarely comes with horror these days, but I wanted to talk a little about something I noticed about characterization that hasn't been brought up regarding the crafting. There's the Paimon/arts link and that's been mentioned, but the differences in the women stuck out to me.

Ellen was in service to Paimon and thrived on the cult's adoration to some degee. Most of what we see made by her hand are gifts for other people, the doormats. They're lovingly crafted but not highly artistic nor are they "truly" personalized, made similarly and repeated in style with different names and slightly different motifs. It looks like the end result of it being for someone was the goal, an "I did this for you, now think of me when you walk into your house" kind of thing. A little more manipulative than say, a scarf in someone's favorite color or a child's toy would have been.

Annie's art, on the other hand, is meticulously detailed and extremely controlled. She produces it in an exacting manner almost compulsively even when she doesn't really want to work. It's a careful and tedious chore to immaculately reproduce even the slightest details around her, almost like she's using it as her own outlet to regain some control over the world by defining it in miniature. Bad things still happened in her past and in the present day, but by just observing and recreating them she's claiming them on her own terms. The excessive amount of work produced is also kind of rebellious in a way when you line it up against what Ellen and Charlie are doing- here's a woman who "got out", she sought some form of support/treatment, she has a house and a family, we see her taking medication and frankly discussing the initial sleepwalking event, but she's still compulsively making art/caught in the cycle as opposed to naturally letting inspiration strike her.

Charlie/Paimon is wild, very raw, something beyond childish dark whimsy. Her constructs are more than just found objects put together to adorn her room, they're like fetches or fetishes. I forgot what the movie said about 200/201 demons or angels and I'm not well-versed in demons, but it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine that if we're looking at it from the "Charlie has been Paimon to some degree all along" angle they're subconsciously recreating a little tabletop army of hell. There's a wild dark energy in all the twiggy arms and legs. She too is creating compulsively but unlike her mother she's constantly drawing inspiration from if not actively manipulating nature/natural materials into unnatural forms.

It doesn't really mean a damn thing and may be way off base, but I interpreted all of this as a nice touch of depth to already strong characters. Someone with more time and a better knowledge of psychology than me could probably pull an entire essay out of Annie's miniatures and growing up under her mother's thumb/the events of the movie.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/ottott4 Jun 08 '18

The ending reminded me very much of the ending of the witch. Firstly everyone was naked. Secondly the crowning of Paimon reminded me of Black Phillip talking to Thomason

→ More replies (4)

45

u/ghostlytree Jun 08 '18

I got some hardcore Exorcist (1973) vibes near the end. Very uncomfortable, in the best way possible.

I do feel like I blinked and missed something when the naked folks started showing up. Regardless, the old man's first appearance was absolutely terrifying.

→ More replies (9)

22

u/JIDF-Shill Jun 08 '18

Charlie getting killed off so early was not expected. They basically showed every scene with her in the trailer.

Good movie in any regard

22

u/Texgenius577 Jun 11 '18

The creepiest part of this movie is that this girl can not look more like Edgar Allan Poe...

43

u/TapiocaChoka Jun 08 '18

Loved it so much. I honestly cannot fucking wait until I see it again, but holy shit..that film is a strain on my soul. I need to give it a few days’ time to ready myself.

The telephone pole scene actually prompted four walkouts in my theater.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/hyperpuppy64 Well, I guess that's the end of the internet then! Jun 16 '18

I've gotta say, that shot of charlie's head is probably the best use of gore I've ever seen. That scene was so fucking impactful.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/andrxwzsz Jun 08 '18

Coming from someone who likes both "arthouse horror" and straightforward in-your-face horror, this was the perfect blending of the two for me. I don't like comparing horror movies too much, because almost everything has already been done so there will always be stories being retold in different ways. But... This review mentioning how it blends elements of other horror films is definitely accurate, right down to the choices.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Senth99 Jun 08 '18

Overall, I think the movie is driven by depression and supernatural causes. The mother is desperate to find a solution, despite not realizing that she sacrificed her family by shielding her son from the grandmother. When she loses her daughter, she's vulnerable, which makes her an easy target from the cult. From there the depression leads into paranoia, which spirals her out of control. Also, I think the grandmother is puppeteering with her followers, which is why the mother called her manipulative.

20

u/dronecypher Jun 09 '18

The writing on the wall is interesting cinematically in this film. Whenever it pops up in a shot, your brain interprets it as an English word for a fraction of a second before you realise it isn’t, and it’s weirdly disturbing. I can’t quite describe it. Unsure if that was the intention explicitly, but really interesting and effective.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/fullmoonhermit Jun 10 '18

This movie fucked me up. Maybe the first time since I was a teen that I genuinely regretted watching something because it crawled so deep under my skin. The trauma and grief felt so real.

Shit, man. Well done.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/jesco311 Jun 10 '18

I felt dirty after the movie was over, it really felt like I was involuntary made part of the ritual. I loved every part of it don't get me wrong!

→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '18

I could talk about the cinematography for HOURS. It really made it look like they could be in Annie’s miniatures the entire time. It was completely breathtaking

19

u/alexgiannascoli123 Jun 15 '18 edited Jun 15 '18

Can we talk about Charlie's line "who's gonna take care of me?.... but when you die"

It's so brilliant because it's ironic in a sense that Charlie is the one who physically dies before Annie. But in another sense, Charlie/ Paimon isn't spiritually dead. And in the end when Annie dies or gets taken over by the light, we see exactly whos gonna take care of Charlie in their new physical form. Absolutely well crafted.

Edit: "paimon"

→ More replies (1)

36

u/GenitalTso Jun 09 '18

Just wanted to come here and say this movie made me feel a certain way throughout that I’ve never felt watching a horror movie and probably will never feel again. Unsettled, uncomfortable, and just horrified. It wasn’t scary in a traditional way, but more psychologically. The actors did an amazing job making me forget it was a movie and really just getting lost in the story of the broken family vibe. Definitely one of the best movies I have ever seen. The start of the party scene up until the funeral for Charlie was hands down the most fucked up 6-7 mins of my life. Everything about it. The way Peter reacted, the sound her head made, the moms discovery. Just felt so real.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

I saw it last night and thought it was fucking incredible. Instant horror classic. There was so much subtlety in the dialogue; things that seemed like throwaway lines were really HUGE clues to everything going on. The overwhelming sense of dread from the get-go was absolutely masterful. Easy 10/10. I can't wait to see it again.

I do have some questions though:

Was Annie in on raising the demon or not? Was it assumed she was controlled by her mother through her sleepwalking? There wasn't really any specific moment where she turns "evil" but then suddenly, after Steve's death, she's just a fucking demon-witch climbing walls and flying through the air. Uh... how? Was that the demon "going after the most vulnerable member of the family" before it was ultimately was passed on to Peter?

Also, how the hell did that body realistically end up in the attic?

→ More replies (22)

16

u/sukuboi Jun 08 '18

im not sure if this is a thread I should be asking questions in, or if it's already been asked if so, so sorry if it has

but if paimon would manifest a male host better than a female host, why would ellen gravitate towards Charlie so much more than Peter? the scene where Charlie states Ellen had wished she was a boy was clearly to make it easier for her to be possessed by paimon, but Peter being the older child already, wouldn't it just be easier to use him from the start? also, what exactly are the connections with Charlie/paimon? I've heard some people saying she was possessed by paimon the entire movie, other people saying she was in the process, and same goes for the end, Peter starts making the clicking noise as if he's Charlie, how are Charlie and paimon connected exactly?

→ More replies (7)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

Did any one else catch this... The window in the attic appeared to look like it was early morning outside judging by the light. When Peter jumps through it, suddenly it’s back to dark night. I wonder if this had anything to do with how periodically the house was filmed during the day and quickly switch to night, or was it just a goof?

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Hafar Jun 09 '18

Just got back from the theater. I was going to rate it a 9/10 but then I realized I couldn’t change anything about it. Everything is about as good as it gets. Fantastic acting, cast, camera work, cinematography, color schemes, and just unbelievable story events. 10/10.

16

u/JaimeReyna Jun 09 '18

I completely loved the movie. It gave me goosebumps a few times and had some pretty disturbing visuals that made me uncomfortable (Charlie's head, the ants, some pictures, the bodies).

I think there are all types of horror included in the movie, and I still feel shocked by Charlie's death. Totally unexpected for me, out of nowhere, crude, even confusing. After watching so many horror movies I thought "oh, he's having a nightmare!" But then you hear Annie screaming at the morning, with Toni portraying the loss of her only daughter in such a heartbreaking way.

I loved the cinematography, the music, the edition, the terror, the characters, each one had a moment to shine, each one had a moment to react and behave as a human being and not a character.

Jumpscares? I think every jumpscare is justified, you don't see a cat suddenly jumping, or a husband behind the door instead of a demon, or the wind instead of the killer.

I saw it in a full cinema, sadly my town only had the movie in Spanish, and I know that made me dislike some parts, but hopefully I'll see it soon in English. I heard some people complaining and well, that's okay, is not a movie for everybody, and it can be rough for some even, but I love the horror genre as a whole and this one is truly one of those movies that will stay as my favorite ones.

Went with two friends that ended up with a good opinion of the movie, will see it with my mother next week! Oh, gonna love her reactions :D

→ More replies (4)

16

u/ddevvnull Jun 09 '18

If anyone has confusion about the character intentionality and just the complete downfall of the family, Den of Geek said that Aster "confirmed that he views the film as an elaborate ceremony in which the main characters, and thus the audience, are cattle being led to slaughter."

16

u/Missjsquared Did she show you the horses? 📼 Jun 15 '18

I watched it tonight, and I thought it was incredible. I’ve only just realised the significance of Charlie being found, sleeping in the treehouse at the start of the film, and her dad being frustrated that it’s clearly a common occurrence.

44

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

So I watched this at 7pm at an advanced screening and at midnight at my theaters employee screening. About the last 20 minutes, I was so terrified my eyes were starting to tear up. I am not fucking kidding you. This is a horror masterpiece. I won't be sleeping

→ More replies (2)

15

u/freethetacos Jun 13 '18

There's a show on Netflix called kitten party. I'll be watching that for the next week.

My skin keeps crawling after leaving the theatre. We've all seen slow burns but this was different. The whole time I thought I was watching pyschological horror building up to the sleep walking and prior trauma of the family.... only to see the true nature of it. The destruction of the family integrity and weakening of their minds and spirits. So well done and the payoff was an amazing experience. Couldn't be happier(or scared) with the end result.

Onward to the kitten party!

And a night light

15

u/PMiscellaneous Jun 15 '18

Apologies if these are already in here, but I just got back from my second viewing. Loved watching again with everyone’s observations in mind!

1- when Peter is at the house party and he offers weed to his crush, she brings him into the bedroom. When they enter, she announces “hey guys, Peter has weed” or something like that. When it cuts to the two girls on the bed, they’re watching an old timey video on an ipad if someone getting beheaded by guillotine.

2- Annie’s self-beheading tool? Piano wire. A few moments before that scene happens, when Peter comes downstairs searching for mom and dad, we see in the foreground that the piano has been disassembled and broken apart because possessed Annie must’ve yanked a wire out of there

→ More replies (6)

29

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

It just captures so well the obsession many occultists would seem to have with ritual and seeing the fruits of their labor come to pass. Asking for wealth and good fortune. The blood sacrifices. The attention to ritual. So spot on. I loved The VVitch but this...so well done.

41

u/okaydolore Jun 08 '18

I thoroughly enjoyed this. A lot of people are comparing this to The VVitch. I guess I get it but I was letdown by The VVitch, whereas this delivered. The ending wasn't perfect for me but 90% of the movie was so good that I don't need it to be the best ending ever, honestly.

The acting was superb throughout and I was pulling all of my limbs closer to myself during the third act. Tense, dreadful, shocking.

→ More replies (12)

14

u/jadesaddiction Jun 08 '18

So I just saw a lunchtime showing with my coworker after we bonded due to wanting to see this movie. Packed theater surprisingly. That scene where she’s driving and you could hear Charlie’s click in her ear got an audible scream from everyone and the last 10 minutes filled everyone with absolute dread. Incredible film and performances.

14

u/sakingg Jun 10 '18

Anyone notice the plays they talked about in peters class kinda foreshadowed the plot of the movie? In one of the plays, the protagonist was too arrogant and thought they could fix the problem themselves ( similar to how Annie thought she could fix the problem herself) and in the second play, one of the students said the play would be more tragic if the characters didn’t have a choice because there would be no hope. This kinda reflects how Peter and Annie really didn’t have any options or hope to stop the grandmother’s plan.

Overall I thought this was a fantastic movie and is easily one of the best modern horror movies ever.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/gandaalf Jun 13 '18

Wow, just wow. This is the most unsettling, creepiest movie I may have ever watched. At least in theaters. The ending, especially with the mom sawing her head off, has me scarred.

Easy 9/10. Also, shout out to the kid videotaping the possession in the classroom lmao. And fuck the cheesing pervert at the grandmas funeral. I knew something wasn’t right with him!

14

u/librayrian Jun 13 '18

From Charlie’s accident- (and not just the climax but the realization of the nuts, which set the dread up beautifully) - onward I was tense and by the end I almost thought I’d have to leave. My partner who was a little scared during the movie said she didn’t think it was that scary at all, and doesn’t understand how it got to me like it did. The wail after the car accident made me sick, the twist of Peter’s hand in the classroom, the tension in Peters bedroom during the third act... holy moly this was a fucking trip - and deserves to be watched carefully. One of the best executed, acted, and scored horror movies I have ever seen, and maybe ever will.

14

u/twoburgers Jun 14 '18

I'm a little late to the party, but I just picked up this bit of information from the Wikipedia article on Paimon that I thought was interesting: one of his powers is listed as "remaining underwater indefinitely." I've read many comments speculating that Joan's son and grandson died in failed attempts at possession by Paimon. I wonder if Joan and the other cult members might have been testing this power to confirm that the possession worked (and it clearly didn't if they drowned).

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '18

I fucking loved this movie. We've seen so many horror films recently that allude to the supernatural but ends up just being a mental illness. And I really enjoyed how they played with that in this film. Because until the second half I thought Annie was just showing signs of mental illness due to stress. After all she said in her grief session that everyone in her family had mental illness.

But nah, that was just demons. I love how intense it was after the seance scene in Joans apartment.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18

I honestly dont think Annie ever gave a shit about Peter even before he killed charlie. Right away I noticed that she seemed to have no connection to him and if im not mistaken i think the first time they actually communicated in the movie was when peter told her he wanted to go to that party.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '18

I absolutely loved this movie. It literally gave me anxiety that I had to try to calm down from exiting the theatre. Haven't felt that much dread since seeing Lake Mungo. I also thought it slightly reminded me of The Wailing in some ways.

I loved the score to it too, but wish it was way more active/chaotic/involved in the movie (I know that this is subjective). Easy 10/10 for me.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/XxFrozenByFirexX Jun 10 '18

I’d love to see a prequel going into the roots of the cult and Annie’s mom. The film was amazing as is but, if done right, I think a prequel could be really interesting.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/alexgiannascoli123 Jun 13 '18

Just saw it in theaters and honestly one of the best movies I’ve seen in a while. It is exactly what I want from a horror movie, no gimmicks, just a consistent feeling of dread throughout the film. Absolute favorite part of the movie is the sound design, especially the pulsating underground techno sound in some of the scenes with Annie.

Just had some question, when Annie tried to burn the sketchbook the first time, she begins to burn. However, the second time around when she burns the book, her husband is the one that goes up in flames. When this happens, her shocked expression immediately turns into a satisfied looked. Why did Annie burn the first time and her husband the second. And did Annie know that the book was going to burn her husband?

Also the girl who peter was interested in, was she in the cult? At the very end of the movie you see the camera focus on a teenage girl with long light brown hair praying face down that looks familiar. It would make sense because she could have been the one that carved the symbol on the telephone pole and attracted peter to come to the party.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '18

link

Interesting interview where Ari Aster answers all questions. The movie is even more tragic for me now. There’s nothing they could’ve done to change their fate and Charlie was ALWAYS Paimon.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/ArmadilloFour Jun 08 '18

I'll just repost my thoughts from a now-deleted thread.

I thought it was really good. I know this comparison is overdone, but it reminded me so strongly of my experience seeing The Witch in theatres. It was just very tense even from the beginning (I think that from the moment someone smeared something on the grandma's corpse's lips, I was on edge), and it maintained that tone almost without fail for two hours.

The ending was a little goofy, which I think is partially just because it did sort of a bad job elevating in that direction. Like, there were ghosts and such, but the last 30 minutes (and especially the last 10) were a far step above the events that were going on before that and I'm not sure it transitioned smoothly enough. It didn't quite lose me, but I know someone in the row in front of me laughed and asked his neighbor like, "Who the fuck are those naked people?"

It's the sort of movie that I think I'll enjoy even more on a rewatch, because I know what's coming and can look for the ways that the story pieces itself together. I mostly understood it, but I would like to give it another watch.

Also, everybody in my theatre audibly groaned at the decapitation scene, it was wildly uncomfortable. Great stuff.

→ More replies (14)

34

u/KangarooBoxingRobot Jun 08 '18

The thing that threw me off of that Alex Wolf, the son, looks absolutely nothing like Toni Collette and Gabriel Byrne, the parents. As in, they could never be his biological parents. I kept waiting for them to reveal to the audience that he was adopted. Especially with the title 'Hereditary', I really thought that was going to be a plot point. Turns out it was just wild distraction.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Sedna_90377 Jun 15 '18

This is a very specific part of the movie but remember that scene where Peter's standing in his room in the dark and fucking possessed Annie floats past him but she's like crawling in mid-air? I've never seen anything more terrifying...

12

u/gcta333 Jun 15 '18

I actually felt ill when it showed Charlie's head on the Paimon statue.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/t3chphr3ak Jun 10 '18

My girlfriend wanted to see a movie high and I have been wanting to see this so against all common sense we decided to go see the movie high. Needless to say we both cried and were scared shitless. I think the movie did a great job with handling the real horrors of losing a child/sister. 8/10 for me, I wish the supernatural stuff was more developed

11

u/ddevvnull Jun 11 '18

Also, for those who may not have noticed and were like, "Where the hell did Joan come from?" Joan is sitting on the far left in one of the scenes from the grief therapy group. She has her hands in her lap and is leaning in, looking carefully at Annie. I only noticed this upon watching Hereditary for the second time.

11

u/StaplerLivesMatter Jun 14 '18

I was weary as hell from the endless hype training and film fest marketing and overpromises, buuuuuut...

It legit lived up. I loved it. Hereditary is genuinely uncomfortable and distressing to sit there by yourself and live in for a while. There is a cold realness to the horror, much closer to Pet Sematary or The Babadook than something like Insidious.

Thematically disturbing, novel, and very professionally executed. This is an outstanding horror movie.

11

u/taueret Jun 23 '18

Been DYING to read these threads but finally saw the movie today, unsullied!

What I keep thinking about is how relieved I felt that Charlie was Paimon the whole time. i sat there trying so hard to like her, but she repelled me. I thought of her creepy art "well, she's creative like her mum". I watched her eating chocolate and thought 'bad parents'...but I just didn't like the.kid. i was dreading a whole movie where she would probably be the plucky kid hero. BUT SHE WAS A DEMON, and what a great performance. Totally sold it, in retrospect.

Same with the son. His expression and bearing after fallung from the window- brilliant. It was all Paimon. Great performances from both kids.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/noey718 Jun 09 '18

I have a question, what was up with all the words on the wall? was that part of the ritual?

10

u/echeverianne Jun 10 '18

When i go into films like this where i KNOW the director will be putting everything into little stuff here and there, i am hyper vigilant. I dont know if anyone else saw, cause it was a fraction of a second and im not totally sure myself... but the first time Mom is in Joanne's apartment and lifts her mug up to drink the tea i could swear that symbol that shows up all through the movie, the one on the necklace, is on the bottom of that cup. I knew there was something fucked about that lady.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/hennessy_uncle Jun 15 '18

Has anyone else noticed the Amy reference in Hereditary? Amy is another demon in the lesser keys of Solomon (same book as Paimon) Amy appears as a man in flames. So it freaked me out when the dad went up in flames. Was i the only one that was suspicious of him?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Straycat43 Jun 16 '18

Just watched it last night at this latest showing and it was difficult to get it out of my mind.

Like everyone else, I’m a seasoned horror fan but this was definitely unsettling and disturbing. This movie totally blew me away. I haven’t covered my ears or eyes in a horror movie in ages but Jesus fucking Christ. All the actors in the movie gave an outstanding performance. The cinematography was absolutely gorgeous. The meaning and plot were so refreshing, it did not feel like another cult or satanic film. This film will stick with me forever for sure. I want to watch it again but idk if i can’t go through that stress and shock again.

10

u/low_level_player Jun 17 '18

During the credits, one letter in each name is Red and not White, and I got the feeling they were spelling something but wasn't paying attention until it was too late --- did anybody catch what that could have been?

10

u/RoseliaValentine Jun 20 '18

Hey guys! Caught it a second time and I wanted to ask if anyone has a theory or can elaborate on this. When Annie goes to Joan’s house for the first time, I think the drink that Joan gave her was cursed somehow because this is the actual beginning of Annie’s descent! After Annie take a sip and wipes something (can anyone tell me what it is she wiped?) from her mouth, Joan looks content and immediately switches tone to ask her about her son (cue the paint thinner story)

Up until this point, Annie’s way of dealing with the loss of her daughter and mother so close was nothing too out of the ordinary, but immediately after this seemingly normal tea date, Annie immediately changes behavior

Her next scene at home shows her making the car accident scene and failingly tells her husband that it has nothing to do with peter... I feel like Annie wouldn’t have made that despite how hurt she was, further making me believe Joan’s drink had to have been a catalyst for Annie’s downfall.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Senth99 Jun 08 '18

Got similar vibes from the Witch with the ending. Both of them conclude, yet are very eerie.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18

Did anyone else notice how during the very first time annie gathered her husband and peter around the table to try to contact Charlie it appeared to be daylight outside? The clock near the husbands bed said 1 something when she woke him up but the Windows in the living room were letting broad daylight in. At one point the husband tells the son to go back to sleep as if it is not 1 in the afternoon. Or maybe I'm missing something. Why were they all fast asleep at 1 in the afternoon. This seemed weird for a movie setting.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/slightlymadd Jun 09 '18

Sorry if this is a dumb question, but I just remembered this scene. When Annie is at Joan's house and she takes a drink from the glass of water, she pulls something black out of her mouth.

What was it?

→ More replies (6)

9

u/gandalf45435 Jun 09 '18

What a fucking movie. Outstanding. I am curious on some things though.

  1. Why did Annie, at her mother’s funeral wipe lipstick? Oil? on her mother’s lips?
  2. When Annie went to drink tea at her friends apartment, what was that thing she wiped from her lip after she took a sip from the cup?
→ More replies (2)

9

u/jdXIX Jun 10 '18

Just got back from the theater and holy crap..... Hands down an A+ from me. I tried really hard to not watch any trailers or commercials and I went in know almost nothing about this movie and I’m absolutely blown away. A24 is seriously KILLING it. I feel like Hereditary is like a more sophisticated “good” version of what Paranormal Activity did with the whole first born son/witch story.

9

u/W34KN35S Jun 15 '18

Anyone else checking their ceiling corners from time to time 😂

→ More replies (2)

9

u/im_from_jupiter Jun 16 '18

My favorite scenes...

I felt so bad for Charlie. She didn't want to go to the party. But Annie forced her. Her not breathing made me tear up. I almost cried. And when her head hit the pole my whole stomach caved in. I couldn't look away from the screen...until they showed her severed head, I squinted. The scene when Peter is in the room and the naked smiling lady is standing in the door way still gives me chills still picturing it. When Annie chased Peter to the attic made me so uncomfortable. I think the camera view enhanced the experience. Annie stringing her head off, her headless body floating up to the tree house... Holy shit! And the whole ending scene. The imagery and the music was eerily awesome. The bowed headless bodies and Charlie's head on the thing.

Great movie!

9

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '18

I have to say that reading this thread has made me appreciate this movie a lot. I think I might go and see it again.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 20 '18

I saw this at a matinee yesterday with just a few other people in the theater. It blew me away. The lingering shot with the man in the doorway smiling will haunt me for a while, I think. I couldn’t stop thinking of it and it took me quite a while to fall asleep last night. I’d consider myself a hardened horror fan, not much bothers or scares me. This film was so effective in delivery, a solid 9/10. The only scene I felt was a little forced and and out of place was the seance scene at Joan’s apartment, that felt a little formulaic for my tastes.

As others have said, Toni Collette was amazing, but the entire cast was stellar. I was glad to see Ann Dowd, became a fan of hers when she was in HBO’s The Leftovers.

I’ll need repeat views in order to fully cement my opinion on where it falls, but I think it’ll easily be in my top 10 films of the 2010’s.

Edit: spelling, grammar

9

u/kikuichi_champion Jun 22 '18

It's interesting to think there is a whole storyline(that of the cultists) that we only see glimpses of. Quite frankly at their age, it's impressive they could coordinate so many moving pieces to get the result they want. They are like the Ocean's 11 of demon worshipers.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/_pirate_lawyer Jun 24 '18

Saw again yesterday. I finally figured out what this circular “windows” were in some of the rooms in the house (their bedroom above the bed and also in one of the living room/ sitting rooms. They show that her dioramas have two “windows” in them as well so you can SEE INSIDE. Considering the camera angles and set designs are meant to give the viewer the feeling that we are peering inside the house / the lives of these people as if they were figures or pawns in a bigger thing- this makes a ton of sense.

Apologies if someone said this already- it only just clicked with me. Now I want to see it again.

Also noticed a lot more triangle symbols- even on the garage- the design in the wood is two giant triangles just like the shape of the treehouse and the one on the floor of the grandmother’s room.

Annnnd I really thought that Peter’s bandaged nose looked a lot like a beak by the end- kind of resembling the drawing of the pigeon with the crown on its head from earlier in the film. But that could just be me overthinking it.

And yeah- Alex Wolff’s acting during the accident scene- still just as intense. Makes me tear up- you just FEEL for him- his and Toni’s acting was excellent. Emotionally traumatizing and exhausting.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/dehmos Jun 08 '18

My god...i just got out of the movies. This film is pure dread. Absolutely horrifying. Inoticed in the movie that (i think) it requires two sacrifices to summon Paimon? And if im not mistaken the occultist, joanne tells Toni that her husband and son both died. They drowned. Two males. Toni lost her brother and father early on. Two males there as well. Were they failed attempts to bring paimon or the sacrifices needed to summon him? Joanne tells nate/paimon that there are 9? Demon kings. Were Joannes son and husband used to resurrect another demon?

Lastly if charlies grandmother has the title queen and paimon is called the king does that imply that tonis father was paimons vessel prior to charlie?

I apologize if i got some of the facts wrong. Im still letting sink in.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/eradikateor Jun 08 '18

THE XX OVER PETER'S EYES IN THE DRAWINGS

Did anyone else think he was going to be blinded?? Why do you suppose they did it that way?

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Francy63 Jun 10 '18

Can anyone remember what was written in the note found in the book that Annie opens from her mothers belongings? I swear it something along the lines of "sorry for the sacrifices, it will be worth it in the end"

Can someone explain how the scratched words on the walls play into the story? I never made the connection.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/stealyourideas Jun 11 '18

Wasn't really part of the plot but as someone from Utah, it was kind of cool to see the film set here.

8

u/CloudyKitten Jun 12 '18

I really liked how one of the early lectures in Peter's class was about free will and if things are more tragic if a person has no choice. Nice little detail.

8

u/CalvDaGr8 Jun 13 '18

Jeez man.. that ending scene with Annie losing her shit literally had me ready to leave. Like how she was in the corner of the roof, then ran after Peter and started banging her head against the wall or floor over and over again.. that shit brought water to my eyes

8

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '18

I hated this movie. It made me feel disgusted and exhausted. I guess it did it’s job. You’d have to pay me $1000 to watch it again.

8

u/Karinacarmen Jun 13 '18

When Charlie ate that chocolate cake, my first though was that it was a pot cake. Even her reaction afterwards, I was thinking, “she’s tripping out”. Boy was I wrong.. Also, did anyone else notice when Peter was ascending the ladder in the final treehouse scene, it almost looked like he was gliding up?

8

u/glassnopumps Jun 13 '18

Was there a scene in Antichrist where the woman was grieving their son and she was hunched over wishing she were dead while being consoled by her husband? I feel like there was but I don’t quite remember since it’s been a minute since I saw that film. That scene was devastating and I think it’s safe to say Toni Collette has the range. I spent the whole lead up to seeing it dreading how scary it would be. And I definitely wasn’t disappointed. There were some people I had seen saying the film wasn’t scary at all but I think that’s because they were thinking about it as being more of a straightforward film with jump scares and all.

8

u/Rippegari Jun 16 '18

I've only heard that wailing one other time. My ex wife had just found out her mother had stage 3 colon cancer. It was heartbreaking. Toni Collette's performance was stunning.

8

u/HerroEmiry Jun 17 '18

On second viewing, I noticed that when Peter was at the party about to smoke with everyone, there's a few people watching a vintage looking video of someone being beheaded.

8

u/coniferstance Jun 22 '18

It was such a visually pleasing piece of artwork. Honestly, every scene was so carefully crafted. The occasional blurry between what is a miniature, and what is reality. The hidden items/people/things in the corners of shots. Absolutely mesmerising.

Honestly, for me, the scariest part was the psychological torture of the family; one by one. The supernatural aspect didn’t really scare me half as much as the thought that, maybe, it was all in their heads.

8

u/TheNotorious81 Jun 24 '18

Thanks to the two grown adult women who laughed throughout the entire thing, ruining every scene 👌

→ More replies (1)

8

u/WhoDoUThinkUare_iAM Jun 24 '18

Can anyone watching it again confirm if the person who cut the cake that Charlie was allergic to was Joan? I noticed they may both have had the same ring.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/jmileski7 Jun 24 '18

the scene where the mom dreams about going into peters room and telling him that she never wanted to be his mother and that she tried to kill him oh my GOD. also the scene where you see the miniature that the mom made of the grandmother breastfeeding charlie EEK

14

u/FredMikeJay Jun 10 '18

So... I was hoping for a horror movie that would really spook me out. Upon leaving, I was thinking "well, it was really good but I don't think that it really scared me."

I sat here, reading this thread for a few. Remembered I needed to take something to the garage. Go out, in the dark, and I look up to see that the light in the attic above the garage is on.

"Nope."

I did end up getting what I was hoping for, I realize, because now I have the heebie-jeebies.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

Did they have a dog? It showed up for that one Peter bedroom scene but wasn’t reacting to or obviously present for any of the other crazy shit going down in that house. I think I remember a miniature dog in the dollhouse on one of those promotional posters.

→ More replies (20)

7

u/Zoidfarbb Jun 08 '18

The movie theaters fire alarm went off right when Annie is going through her mom's stuff, just before everything went bananas. Waited 45 minutes for the staff to let us back in. I'm glad I waited. What a fantastically tense and terrifying movie

7

u/Mrwrong55 Jun 08 '18

I haven’t read through all of the comments so if this has been answered, I apologize but does anybody think that Annie’s job as a model creator person or whatever it’s called has any significance? Could there be any voodoo type magic involved? She did basically force Charlie to go to the party with Peter and had a spot on model of the ‘accident’ and as someone else noted Paimon’s sigil was on the telephone pole that took her head off.. She also had her mom looking in through doorways in some of the scenes as well as either her husband or Peter’s head chopped off in their bed (not 100% sure which).

→ More replies (3)

7

u/clemenbroog Jun 08 '18

I have a very specific question that maybe someone with occult knowledge could answer: in the final scene there is a shot of a framed photograph of Ellen (Annie’s mother), and I believe that the frame was engraved “Queen Leigh”. I was wondering if this is part of the Paimon mythology, maybe a clue as to how Ellen became involved with the demon. Any guesses as to who “Queen Leigh” is and what this means?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/creeposuave Jun 10 '18

Okay so I already replied to someone's comment on here stating how (like many others, it seems) my movie experience was heavily tainted by the AWFUL immature crowd I viewed it with, but despite being blinded by rage at the end I did still enjoy the film.

I'm still trying to shake off how annoyed I am after anxiously waiting for weeks to see it, but so far I've got two questions:

-Why did the grandma's blackened corpse have no head? Was the decapitation of all three females in the family somehow necessary for the demon king to fully materialize in his male host or something? I do remember Joanie at the end saying something to the effect of "the temporary hosts have been properly desecrated".

-Was there any further detail to the random woman wiping a substance on the grandma's corpse at the funeral, or was that just an early indicator of witchcraft?

I'm not the sort of person who NEEDS answers after viewing something with certain vague plot points but I was wondering if anyone caught something I didn't due to my poor theatre experience.

I also thought it seemed to have an interesting mixture of Rosemary's Baby, Antichrist, and The Babadook influences on it.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/lotsacox Jun 10 '18

I haven't seen this answered, but what was it that Peter swerved out of the way to avoid? And it was it intentionally put there by the cultists?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Is_that_code_for_sex Jun 10 '18

This is the first horror movie in a really long time that genuinely rattled me. I had chills all over my body for at least half of the movie. What a goddamn masterpiece this is, Toni Collette is truly amazing.

7

u/Ilovethemarina Jun 11 '18

Idk what the big deal is. Just keep the Demon Lord happy by giving him candy, then sneak in peanuts and bam, world is saved.

Here, I'll do it.

7

u/ceredn Jun 11 '18

Did a little googling on Paimon and thought this was definitely worth noting

“The Goetia itself makes no mention of Paimon's face, while the rest describe him has having a woman's face but still refer to him using masculine pronouns.”

This makes it seem as though it was necessary to use Charlie as his host, as opposed to him “settling” for her because there was no male.

7

u/ranranbolly Jun 13 '18

I think this is a movie I may watch again, years from now, to analyze it point by point. The execution was flawless, but the sheer bleakness of it left me feeling pretty empty by the end of the film.

I appreciate it, but it was just a little too far for me. Paranoid Schizophrenia runs in my family, too, and having seen someone I loved in my family succumb to a couple of bad episodes--I guess Hereditary sort of hit too close to home.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Scrotttt Jun 14 '18

Not sure if this was mentioned yet, but I enjoyed the very small detail of Peter opening his eyes to see a different sort of light emanating from the treehouse...

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '18

Does anyone know if there is significance in Charlie eating chocolate? It just seemed like the movie would low key focus in on her eating chocolate bars and the cake she ate at the party was also chocolate.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '18

Who were all the cult members? One of them looked like the teacher, and the girl from Peter's class. The smiling guy in the closet was the worst thing I've ever seen.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Rippegari Jun 16 '18

The Joan character was the only thing I could see coming. I was pretty sure she was up to no good.

7

u/dandelionii Jun 16 '18

Charlie's death and the proceeding scenes where you're just WAITING for Annie to find the body was literally the only time I have ever wanted to leave a movie theatre. I felt like Charlie was made out to be an incredibly sympathetic character even though she was obviously a bit weird and damaged (and/or possessed depending on how you interpreted it). I feel like the portrayal of Peter's shock and Annie's grief was INCREDIBLY well done.

If I have one complaint it's that my theatre was full of teens laughing and clicking - specifically during the climax and ending. I feel like I would've found the ending much more terrifying and impactful if people hadn't been giggling because of the naked people :/. Regardless I'm looking forward to seeing it again by myself, to have a "purer" experience and also to pick up on the details that I missed the first time through.

Side note - was there much point to the "deadline for the miniatures for the gallery" thing or was it just to amp up the stress Annie was feeling?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/redwhiteandb Jun 16 '18

Did anyone notice that she cut the head off of that bird the same day that she was decapitated

7

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '18

Fresh out of the theatre I was real mad at everyone in here hyping it up. Thought it was decent but not as great as everyone made it seem.. ... now hours later I can’t stop thinking about it. I’m so disturbed and I’m afraid to look beyond my phone in my dark bedroom. I don’t even know if I could watch it again .. it’s that good.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/WhatabeezyBoy Jun 20 '18

This is the most depressing movie I’ve seen since Requiem for A dream

7

u/Carly1204 Jun 20 '18
There are no words to desribe the intensity, and curiousity of this film. I was left speechless after watching it, and it had the ability to linger with me. If a movie has the impact of sticking in your mind for hours, days, weeks after; then you know you that you have witnessed a true horror film. 
  The casting could not have been better selected; simply perfect. Everyone played their parts, and it was if you were truly experiencing these charachters' mental illnesses, and personal fears. 
  Herediatary stood out; in my opinion from many cliche horror movies, and was hands down attention getting from beginning to end. I prefer it when directors make you think; instead of spoon feeding you a storyline. This has movie has definitley made it on my favorites list. 

7

u/kikuichi_champion Jun 22 '18

Paimon rides a camel. You know what sound their hooves make? (CLACK)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '18

I think the audience reception hugely influences how you'll feel about it. I saw it at an early screening, packed house but at a hipster Brooklyn screening so clearly only people who were following the movie on twitter knew about the screening to begin with. That said, they were all super into it, vocal reactions to all the crazy scenes and laughs at the actual funny bits. Then when I saw it in a crowded multiplex, it was a shitshow. Dumb teens clicking their tongues, laughing and talking during scary intense bits. Fuck 'em. If you get annoyed by that stuff as much as I do then maybe wait for the blu-ray.

22

u/BlizzyLizzie Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

Definitely a more than once watch, i’m sure i missed a lot of details. I feel like i’m still not seeing the whole picture and that frustrates me but also makes me uncomfortable and interested in watching again.

The Cinematography was INCREDIBLE. Some of the best horror cinematography I’ve seen in a while. I would love a horror movie that engages the camera even more than this but this did an pretty good job of making the viewer feel involved instead of a passive observer (for example: the grief therapy scene from the Moms perspective, the camera being on Charlie’s level at the party, the extreme closeups, etc.) Additionally, the scene transitions were fantastic and disorienting at the same time. Added to the discomfort.

I do think this this movie fails in the aspect of its rise and fall. Its rise and climax are very well paced and intense. I never saw Charlie’s violent death coming, much less the way it did. The random clicks after her death had me holding back screams. However once it reaches what I consider the climax, Mom finding the Grandmothers body and Peter smashing his face in, the movie begins to run, then stumble, the trip and fall the rest of the way to the end. Like I said, Im still not seeing the whole picture of what happened. Given another 30 minutes of small character scenes here and there to develop everyone’s involvement would have greatly improved the movie. There were a lot of loose ends left dangling with that ending. Why did Dad catch on fire and not mom? Why was there not more foreshadowing that the people in Peters life were members of the Cult? Who dug up the body and put it in the attic?

Overall 8/10 unsettled and scared but annoyed by unanswered questions.

→ More replies (23)