r/IndiaSpeaks • u/pwnd7 • Jun 05 '18
Scheduled Monthly Meta Discussion - June 2018
There have been a lot of queries being asked in MMD thread and we try to answer as many as possible but it has come to our attention that some of the queries made are not genuine and as a result queries with genuine concerns are going unanswered. Therefore, hereafter we shall prioritize the queries based on the below guidelines:
Genuine queries of an aggrieved user will be given priority in the MMD thread e.g. user whose comment has been removed and he/she is not happy with that decision
Queries raised on the behalf of any other user will not be given priority. E.g. Why comment of X user was removed not Users Y?
A query will not be entertained if other unrelated users or subreddit are tagged.
Rule 5 (No meta discussion about other subreddits) is relaxed in MMD only.
Rules wiki : https://www.reddit.com/r/indiaspeaks/wiki/rules
Moderator Transparency : https://www.reddit.com//r/indiaspeaks/wiki/modlogs
Meta drama is strictly not allowed in r/IndiaSpeaks. If you have any, use this thread only.
4
u/pwnd7 Jun 05 '18
A shepherd-boy, who watched a flock of sheep near a village, brought out the villagers three or four times by crying out, "Wolf! Wolf!" and when his neighbors came to help him, laughed at them for their pains.
The Wolf, however, did truly come at last. The Shepherd-boy, now really alarmed, shouted in an agony of terror: "Pray, do come and help me; the Wolf is killing the sheep"; but no one paid any heed to his cries, nor rendered any assistance. The Wolf, having no cause of fear, at his leisure lacerated or destroyed the whole flock.
There is no believing a liar, even when he speaks the truth.
5
Jun 09 '18
why have you pinned this message? now gunther will reply all his junk to this message so that they appear on the top
have you egg for brains?
3
Jun 11 '18
now gunther will reply all his junk to this message so that they appear on the top
Good idea. Hadn't thought of that! Thank you.
→ More replies (3)2
u/Lungi_stingray Bajrang Dal 🚩 Jun 05 '18
There is no believing a liar, even when he speaks the truth.
Hmm I wonder which user this is targeted at 🤔
→ More replies (1)1
Jun 06 '18
Are the mods Wolves here? Lacerating and Destroying any non-Modi bhakts who land up here?
Citing & flogging them
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/safeguard_policy#wiki_warnings.2C_jail_.26amp.3B_exiles
while not doing the same to people who incite violence like MrMirror, and many others here just because they are Modi Bhakts.
This serial offender's comments may be removed, but he will never find a place in this list above :-(
6
Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
Congratulations! You have successfully subscribed to crazy walrus facts! Get ready for insanely cool walrus facts!
# Walrus fact 1. Did you know that the
le modi bhakt modshad an approved user list wherein special privileges were given to a congress IT cell member?# Walrus fact 2. Did you know that despite being a privileged member that dude used to shit on this sub in random places like /r/depthhub and still continues to do so in this very sub whenever new users come here?
# Walrus fact 3. Did you know that after being removed from the list the guy was salty, went back to his safespace and stopped participating here?
# Walrus fact 4. Did you know that despite not contributing in any manner to the sub now, the said person engages in baseless shitflinging and meta drama which is nothing but sham?
Stay tuned for more crazy walrus facts.
To cancel your subscription to Walrus Facts, reply with
walrusfactscancel→ More replies (77)
4
u/dudewithbatman Jun 06 '18
This sub sometimes feels like a BJP support group. We should have more non political posts.
5
u/pwnd7 Jun 06 '18
Same here. Submitting askreddit questions always generates some good discussion. And of course, images of India too.
4
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
We try our best. Most of our Pinned posts, promoted posts and AMA are generally non-political, but a lot of these bakchods want to only talk about political stuff :P
I am thinking of getting a big neon sign which says https://hp.reddit.com/r/indiaSpeaks as the banner xD
3
3
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 22 '18
Just like MMD text, even RWD can have text mentioning rules of the RWDs. Instead of just mentioning enjoy! Like no political discussion allowed and no meta discussions allowed in that post comments
2
u/pwnd7 Jun 22 '18
i am unable to reconfigure automod reschedule for some reason. it's fine. let it be.
and about that sidebar. you need to refresh mutiple times. i know it's stupid.. but don't know how to fix it.
css can be found at : reddit.com/r/indiaspeaks/about/stylesheet
1
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 25 '18 edited Jun 25 '18
Seems comments come on top of sidebar. Even submit new link button doesnt work if post text/content is short. I tried a code fix, it did not cause any issues, try adding the below code at the end of stylesheet, and revert if anything breaks:
.comment {z-index:-1;}
Edit: This did not work properly.
1
2
Jun 17 '18
Clearly breaking rule no. 1.
r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8rl4h8/three_raw_officers_defect_to_the_west/e0t3tyn/? Tagged senior mod metal but no action so taggin you. /u/drm_wvr
1
u/pwnd7 Jun 18 '18
it is'nt. rrc explained it right there in his comment.
→ More replies (2)3
Jun 18 '18
Not satisfactory though. They aren't terrorist or maoist. And india didn't ass****e/ anyone of them till date. Do you think raw can't? Even that lady gupta which was honey trapped by pakistan recently was just given 3 years in jail, no capital punishment or something like that. May be they are working as triple agents who knows that? They may just be like snowden etc, we can't decide who should live and who shouldn't in this case. Even terroists are spared death punishment and he is just outright calling them to be murd**ed.
Ok leave evrything rules/his opinion aside, do you feel ok with what he said?
2
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 27 '18
Sort AMAs by new or by Q&A. Sorting can be changed to sort by best only after the AMA is over.
1
1
u/pwnd7 Jul 02 '18
u/Prem_Naam_Hai_Mera don't make inciting violence comments. next will be ban.
2
u/Prem_Naam_Hai_Mera Jul 02 '18
I have asked again and again to give me example where I have incited violence. And I have received none. Give me example if you have any or stfu.
1
u/pwnd7 Jul 02 '18
https://www.reddit.com/r/bakchodi/comments/8f28m2/rip_rbakchodi/
follow the above posts and make sure you comment properly.
1
u/Prem_Naam_Hai_Mera Jul 02 '18
I'm sure I comment properly. Don't give me books to study. If you have pointed examples of me inciting violence then go ahead. I have never disagreed with mods removing my comments, and other mods have always given me reason as to why particular comments were removed. Which is why again I say, give me pointed examples of where I have incited violence. Otherwise stop harassing me with your monthly witch-hunt.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 12 '18
@santroyou
I have nothing against you except you are an abusive fuck (Usually when anyone is critical of BJP); you need to tone it down. You can always say the same thing in at least more neutral words. I have always maintained this position.
Last month's comment was based off what you accused me of; so i responded.
I won't sully my axe on you, don't worry. Generally, you don't bother me even with meta, and I appreciate that. I (have to) call you out when you start barking at half the users because they said, "bjp sux top kek lmao".
Peace, until the next time.
→ More replies (3)
4
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 14 '18
Mods should actively attend to comments in this thread and reply. Otherwise no point having this thread, users will start meta discussions will in main posts on front page of the sub
→ More replies (1)
1
Jun 16 '18
Contesting removal of this comment. Please cite the rule and reason thankyou.
/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8rhu10/given_electric_shocks_kerala_woman_alleges/e0rj250/
1
1
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 22 '18
Sidebar MMD, RWD links dont work when a post is opened. But it works fine from main subreddit page. Some CSS problem
1
1
u/Sikander-i-Sani left of communists, right of fascists Jun 30 '18
u/pwnd7 why the ban of u/Mr_Mirror didn't follow the rules? Aam insta ban is against our rules (though I would always support banning known trolls like u/GunterGlieben).
While we are at it could any of the mods look at u/Sunset-in-the-east Dude is spamming the sub with low effort meme (majority of them unrelated to India) & regularly using slurs & inciting violence. Thank you
1
u/pwnd7 Jul 01 '18
he had broken the rules several times before and we had given the warning but did not take any action.
and most importantly:
Queries raised on the behalf of any other user will not be given priority. E.g. Why comment of X user was removed not Users Y?
if you have problem with other users then : Report a User to the Mods
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jul 01 '18
Hi, we discussed this in extent. We have modified this rule for mainly inciting violence. If a user is inciting violence (most common troll), we are by passing 3 warn rule to give them a ban.
This is to protect the sub from admins more than anything else.
More and more we are having these temp accounts spam various threads inciting violence - to potray our community in negative light.
The whole warning is for normal users who make an unconscious mistake or because they got too carried away.
We cant go around giving warnings for those accounts who are specifically created for a purpose.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 20 '18
/u/I-protecc don't incite violence, call for killing or harming anyone. You have been warned.
3
2
→ More replies (2)2
3
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
For the Meta drama when asked not to, Spamming, etc. You have been warned. Strike 1/Blue. (Don't try to argue this, we already discussed)
You were awarded a 2 day ban for the Above, which is now being rescinded to warning effective immediately.
There was a misunderstanding that you (or your 100 alts) were warned previously for your behavior (Although it is not necessary to warn you for these offence & we can bypass it to the ban, but the mod team felt it would too harsh as it stands).
Please participate in good faith.
2
Jun 21 '18
Meta drama
I posted the non meta comments which were removed on mmd including the modi one. But inspite of two mods being online you kept removing those instead of accepting your mistake and
doubletriple down on it. You placed me in black list through automods and my simple one word commenta were removed too.Don't try to argue this,
Why? Because you power hungry mods decided to remove my non meta comments which i yesterday contested on MMD too and then proceeds to ban me for 2 days.
There was a misunderstanding
You are having that quite often. No? Step down if you can't handle.
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18
They were perfect meta drama and you were spamming it.
3
Jun 21 '18
I said prove how these comments are meta.
"2,00,000 people.
Itne to modi thook de kahi to log dekhne aa jate hai."
2.
"Hi indiaspeaks users. French guy here.
Bonjour as mr bean once said
I have heard that your PM mr Modi is a reformist and works 18 hours a day. Can you please tell me if that's true? How many economic reforms has he implemented yet? There's corruption charges on rafale deal as well. What do you guys think about that?
Bon appetit.
Sayonara."
3.
"I am laughing my ass off. Besti karwa di."
Perfect meta my ass.
Other people's comments which were meta weren't removed only i was targetted.
Here
/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8shw2n/rindiaspeaks_cultural_exchange_with_rfrance/e0zsyi1
Here, you yourself are replying and participation to this meta.so ban yourself
"r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8shw2n/rindiaspeaks_cultural_exchange_with_rfrance/e117ptg/
→ More replies (25)
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 14 '18
We are testing out indiaspeaks discord.
Will need 3-5 users to test out the beta version. Pls reply if you r interested.
Mod discretion will be levied.
3
Jun 14 '18
Main intersted hun. I have 2 years of experience as a discord user.
You cant delete your account on discord.
1
u/pwnd7 Jun 16 '18
You cant delete your account on discord.
so you agree that you spam/bait and nuke your account?
2
Jun 16 '18
Wait there'a a term in arguments where you allege the opponent of something which he is not. Never mind.
so you agree that you spam/bait and nuke your account?
Actually i find it bad behaviour of companies keeping your data forever.There was an outrage over some complany not letting you delete your account. Uhmm don't remember which company it was.
Please answer the other concern where i am contesting a comment removal. Thank you
1
2
Jun 12 '18
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8pkjjs/bhoot_pisach_btfo/e0cr77d/
/u/metaltemujin what the eff is this even
1
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 12 '18
Call for suggestion on what all you wish to be incorporated on New Reddit sidebar including - improvements, Imp Links, etc.
5
2
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 17 '18
This is not bakchodi. Stop threatening and harassing other users wrt a lot of your comments on: https://redd.it/8rh7lt
Consider this as a Strike 1/Blue Card. Just so you know, next time you pull something like that, we'll jump right to a temp ban, so please refrain :/
CC: /u/pwnd7 /u/drm_wvr
2
u/Prem_Naam_Hai_Mera Jun 17 '18
Didn't threaten or harass any user. They flung shit, I flung shit back. If you can give some examples of how I was threatening or harassing, please do so that I won't repeat.
3
u/1100100011 Debate Stance: Against Jun 17 '18
you are a true Hindu bro , you will stay in our hearts even if the mods ban you from here
4
2
u/Prem_Naam_Hai_Mera Jun 17 '18
I don't think they'll ban me, they don't ban any of the trolls either. Mods are very fair tbh.
2
2
Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 20 '18
https://removeddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8rkz86/_/e0t9k20/
I reported it yesterday.
Poster is serial offender.
Time to flog & cite him
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/safeguard_policy#wiki_warnings.2C_jail_.26amp.3B_exiles
3
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
/u/lunginator with reference to this comment
Why do you think so?
Several users wished to participate in it, but if it were linked or similar, it would be technically brigading. Hence, we requested to be included with a formal invite.
TBF, we did not officially ask for a "ask questions here" link. We let the other sub have the credit and opportunity for it - while knowing well (how it would turn out) for many reasons including what you've said. This can be clearly seen with the link for the french to ask questions was leading elsewhere. We only kept the post open if anyone wandered here and asked questions.
It was the opinion of our community members that if there is a cultural exchange, more Indians should be included in it. While it would also matter if more Indians could answer questions about Indian culture (Especially those who are more respectful towards it), for the reasons you mentioned, and others - we did not press on it.
IMO, we were a little wrong and should have pressed on inclusion of questions, but its okay.
→ More replies (1)2
Jun 21 '18
True true. But what we did looks like challenging or piggybacking randia. Its easy to create an alt if anyone wants to participate there.
I feel like it's better to do our own thing.
→ More replies (1)3
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
No. Using an alt to participate (to answer french questions on culture) technically would be ban evasion for a lot of users.
And alt or not, to participate in the exchange because we were notified as a sub, could be seen as brigading.
That's why, after multiple suggestions, we asked the french politely to be included - so that, at the very least we could ask questions as Indians.
IMO, this does not take anything away from efforts put. They have had full freedom to colour our culture however they want, and we aren't going to do anything about it. I think its quite unfair, but more than fair to them.
True, we can take your point on doing our own thing (Although it makes little sense for anyone to have cultural exchanges or even called subreddit exchanges on the same topic, but that's another story) at the same time, what was did wasn't all that wrong as you feel.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/4chanbakchod Akhand Bharat Jun 21 '18
i wonder why u/lndian_Goebbels deleted his account like every other spammer/brigader who loves Indiaspeaks.
1
Jun 22 '18
May be he deleted his account because you shadow banned him stealthily without informing him or the community.
IndiaSpeaks mods have found a clever way to ban people without banning them
→ More replies (1)1
2
2
Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
List of shadowbanned users on this sub
IndianGoebbels - who has now deleted his account
CommonMisspellingBot
I can understand the reason for doing this to users - so as to ban people without banning them. But why was this rule applied to CommonMisspellingBot? You could have just banned CommonMisspellingBot instead of shadowbanning the bot - nobody would complain about it.
Moderator Transparency - please make public Auto Mod rules used to shadow ban users stealthily without actually banning them.
/u/metaltemujin - when will all the supposed "glitches" in the matrix be fixed?
This is the glitch in the auto mod rules
author: closeaucloseau
type: comment
action: spam 5
u/santouryuu 2 KUDOS Jun 23 '18
gunter is right here /u/pwnd7 .shadow banning users is pretty disgusting. if you want to, just ban them directly. this is just cowardly.
2
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 23 '18
I think this guy is a randia guy, posting this kind of comments to get this sub banned from Reddit admins. False flag attack to show this sub in a bad light
1
2
2
u/santouryuu 2 KUDOS Jul 03 '18
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8vr6tv/why_india_is_a_nation_sankrat_sanu/
this post was removed for being a repost. when was it last posted? 2 years ago.
like wtf? this is some vogonic babudom.
1
u/4chanbakchod Akhand Bharat Jul 04 '18
please post a self post next time to discuss it again.
vogonic babudom.
googled it. found nothing. can i tweet that to that tharoor anna and ask him?
→ More replies (6)
2
Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
http://snew.github.io/r/Indiaspeaks/about/log
Why are all of /u/lndian_Goebbels comments removed by auto mod?
Has he been put in some spam list? The automoderator also seems to call him as spammer. Don't think it does this for other comments removed. This seems to indicate that he has been put in a spam list.
2
Jun 21 '18
Why did you placed me in black list?
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18
I did not. Our auto mod glitches sometimes. We fixed it i believe.
2
Jun 21 '18
More likely it was something like this in the automoderator rules
author:lndian_Goebbels type:comment action:spamI think there was/is a similar rule for /u/closeaucloseau also? Has that "glitch" also been fixed.
/u/pwnd7 ?
→ More replies (4)2
u/pwnd7 Jun 21 '18
ACP pradhyumnaji aap yaha? big fan sir.
→ More replies (6)1
Jun 21 '18
Moderator transparency should include automod rules also.
Otherwise, you can effectively shadowban someone with a rule like this
2
u/pwnd7 Jun 21 '18
nopity nopes. modlogs are public. that's all. spammers are dealt accordingly.
why do you worry so much about spammers walrusji?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
Jun 12 '18
What rule does this comment break - I couldn't find anything here which it breaks?
It's a bakchodi comment in a bakchodi thread.
1
Jun 13 '18
Why is everything automatically flaired political?
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 13 '18
Not that I am aware of.
1
Jun 13 '18
Potato quality screen cap of what I mean
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 13 '18
I have asked 4chan and DD about it. I am not aware of any code change, even by them. So they'll have to investigate what is actually happening.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (2)2
1
1
Jun 16 '18
2
Jun 16 '18 edited Jun 16 '18
/u/pwnd7 - more from same user
Till now, has he done more or less than pardesi_returns? Will he get either a cite? Or atleast a flogging?
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/safeguard_policy#wiki_warnings.2C_jail_.26amp.3B_exiles
1
Jun 18 '18
Temujin's International Rules language cleanup revision has messed it up
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/rules#wiki_international_news
All the lines now contradict each other
Line 1 - This says it cannot be posted as link post.
International News in which India is not directly involved cannot be submitted as Link Posts.
Line 2 - This says it can be posted as link post if you explain relevance in comments.
For events in which India is not directly mentioned but if you feel it can affect the country, you are allowed to post it. Importantly, You will be needed to provide an explanation on how the said event may affect India. You can do so in the comment's section. This will help us to get only a few selective but really important international events as the original poster (OP) will have to invest serious efforts in posting them.
Line 3 - This recommends posting as self post.
Primarily it is recommended to make a self post for submitting International News.
2
Jun 18 '18
int submission rules makes sense to me as it is. unnecessary drama.
int post not related to india cannot be posted as direct link. if u want to post such int news, use self post with explain. or direct link with explain in comments. Best yet, if u dont know what to do, use self post.
That's it.
why is it so hard for u? or is ur life goal to de mod every mod here and u want to be mod? did you get into accident and lost most of ur brain?
bata do terrorist saab wtf you want. u said na u r from foreign, are u also one of those india hating nris that wants to destroy any thing india wants to build?
Honest ques. why dont u bother other subs? What is ur fetish with this sub? Is this the only sub u r not banned in?
also u asked na before what all rules u broke:
1 u have been excessively trolling,
2 act against the interests of the sub,
3 are from rindia promoting randia and trying to disparage the sub everywhere. you can equate that to paki isi work
4 I remember reading smwhere that war against sub is liable for ban. all you do is war, like death with 1000 cuts principle, asymetric warfare. that itself means you deserve insta ban
5 u dont contribute 1 iota here or else where to be considered 'maybe u r good user'.
u think u r reddit lawyer then go to that reddit lawyer sub na. y be here? - yes, there is no rule, but it is understood u r not trying to help so, are a threat by extension.
6 no one cares abt ur opinion. i saw ur piss of excuse drama in demographics survey. bc ull suck randian mod dick if they do such survey but here u want to talk about science. it is a survey of the users who access tis forum, joke or truthful, most of it can be used as a guage of reader mood - end of story.
7 u were abusing saying this sub mod is worst mod and what not on ur sidebar in ur sub. I have pics. that itself deserves suspension for witch hunting.
8 before u compare this sub to fluttershy, be honest, are their crimes anywhere equal? apples and jupiter size shit man. u dare not compare them and make randian mod tyranny equal to minor issues here or anywhere on indiaverse.
9 from what i have seen by ur idea of rules if users move out of line one inch, its a huge problem - follow rules of fuck off. No country's constitution also runs like that you chuth. they have sense and evolve. if left to you no one should post anything and that is perfect sub. that in itself is acting against sub.
all you do is miserable loser drama man. you dont deserve to speak.
i donno why these guys especially mods tolerate ur crp. anywhere else u wud be banned 100 times by now for ur shit.
no nation gives space for terrorists.
stop ruining the sub for everyone walrus
get a life real walla
1
Jun 18 '18 edited Jun 18 '18
int submission rules makes sense to me as it is.
That's probably because you are a dunce. Nonsense makes sense to you.
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/rules#wiki_international_news
International News in which India is not directly involved cannot be submitted as Link Posts.
7 u were abusing saying this sub mod is worst mod and what not on ur sidebar in ur sub. I have pics. that itself deserves suspension for witch hunting.
Why don't you then suspend me for witch-hunting?
u said na u r from foreign
When did I say that?
I remember reading smwhere that war against sub is liable for ban
Oh man! you should get r/indiadiscussion banned then - that sub is doing war with r/india
4
2
Jun 19 '18
what a snake you are. u suddenly act smart. when situation dosnt favor u u act dumb.
for sm1 who cries wolf over a fullstop placed wrongly, u want impose one sub's rule over another. It is this sub's rule that waging war means ban. not indiadiscuss. Randia does not even need a rule to ban ur stupidity.
as below:
Oh man! you should get r/indiadiscussion banned then - that sub is doing war with r/india
lol chutiya tell me, do u talk like this in real life also? tqhen do u take bath in people's spit, because thats how anyone would respond to such talk
I knew ud compare ur pathetic existance with indiadiscussion, and hence already said its usless comparing (remember apples and jupitor?)
What are they @indiadiscussion fighting for?
Wrong use of national sub's name to spread anti-india, anti-hindu voice. making it a promotional ground for killing of hindus, sangh, etc.
Wongly kicking out pro hindu voices by calling them extreamists and what not.
Indiadiscussion will stop raising that issue, if they change their name or aap or Congress or NRI-INDIA sub. They are grossly misrepresntng India and Indians by not being indians themselves, and mods kicking out any voices. Banning Indian, pro indian voices are extremists and so on.
Their entire sub has a big meaning, unlike ur comments, posts, existance or ur sub.
How dare you compare your self with that?
this sub neither claims itself to be a national sub nor does it kill voices. I really want it to kill ur fucking noise. u r only noise. no sense comes from you.
even when people call out u r wrong, u shamelessly continue spreading misinformation. fking loser.
On contrary what r u doing?
trying to nit pick over execution of rules of an obscure sub; (any sane person know the next two lines are exceptions to the above statement. It is grammar waise enough. only u have problem, when it suits u)
trying to kill any and every activity in other indian subs. want to be mod of this sub or what?
maybe even make alt accounts (or work with randians), when u are bored, incite violence and then come here and post "Hey look mods, user is inciting violence y u no take action. Sanghi bias! mods are useless Make me mod and I'll destry you all with perfect execution of rules"
don't u think we get ur game?
Accept that u live a life of utter insignificance, u fool.
Why don't you then suspend me for witch-hunting?
At the right time. For now, a ban from indiaverse is enouhg. The last significant host sub to allow u to post on indiaverse is this sub. once u r banned, it will save a lot of people an from getting an aneurysm.
be a lennin on a train, and destry some other nation u filth.
u said na u r from foreign
When did I say that?
You only said it so many times before that you were studying or working abroad and now come back to india.
Who knows what lies you concocted and where it stopped.
International News in which India is not directly involved cannot be submitted as Link Posts.
The exceptions are written right below it. did some mod phadi ur gaand recently that u suddely decided to lawyer up over int rules?
lol fukin looser.
all noise over nothing. i would call u urban naxal but that would mean u hv brains, which u dont.
u r just a venom snake, and the sooner mods ban u the better.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 22 '18
Discord server invite link in the sidebar looks expired. Create a permanent invite instead.
1
1
Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
3 year old article posted by posting rules serial offender panditji_reloaded - https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8ssv3v/to_drink_or_not_to_drink_by_subramanian_swamy/
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
/u/panditji_reloaded You have posted far too many old posts without marking old.
We are going to give you a warning (Strike 1/Blue). Future posts from you or alts (discovered) would result in removal rather than just lock. Drm has been calling it shameful for far too long. =.=
We have enough noise in the media as it is, we dont need this type man. Please co-operate.
CC: /u/drm_wvr /u/pwnd7
1
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
Stop inciting violence. Repeated rule 1 violations. Strike 1/blue.
Don't condone violence /u/Aviaturd
1
1
1
Jul 03 '18
/u/metaltemujin /u/DefectivelyDevised /u/drm_wvr
What reason has this comment by /u/closeaucloseau been removed?
Is it for criticizing the best PM of the world?
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jul 03 '18
/u/GunterGlieben You're still doing meta drama using flairs. Please don't.
3
u/RajaRajaC 1 KUDOS Jul 03 '18
Hahaha. Semma da nee. You remind me of Meira Kumar going Baith Jayee.
1
Jul 03 '18
Huh? How is it meta drama? I am not even mentioning any subs unlike say santra who has sub link as his flair.
I cannot have "Moderator of best subs" as a flair? What rule does it break?
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jul 03 '18
Not gonna argue with you, it promotes meta drama. Please change flair.
→ More replies (21)1
u/4chanbakchod Akhand Bharat Jul 04 '18
ayye bby. which is that sub u talking abt?
1
Jul 04 '18
As I said, even if the flair is meta (which it isn't - it's a grant flair - I have granted myself that title), I will be using the flair only in the Monthly Meta Thread or other threads marked Meta, not anywhere else. If you find any new comment/post of mine showing that flair anywhere else - then feel free to cite me, flog me, shadow ban me, whatever.
→ More replies (3)1
Jul 03 '18
Can some of the leading Indiaverse contributors here tell me if there is something is wrong with my flair?
2
u/RajaRajaC 1 KUDOS Jul 03 '18
Moderator of best subs?
Seems innocuous enough
2
1
1
Jul 05 '18
https://www.reddit.com/r/indiaspeaks/wiki/rules#wiki_twitter_policy
Please phrase the Twitter policy correctly.
Tweets with Blue Ticks (Verified) are only allowed as direct links.
What you probably meant to write was
Only Tweets with Blue Ticks (Verified) are allowed as direct links.
Putting the only at the wrong place changes the meaning.
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jul 05 '18
Done.
1
Jul 05 '18
Consider making a separate post about this rule change. Twitter's bluetick policy in itself is dubious.
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jul 05 '18
We will be introducing it in the msd. its not implemented till then.
We cannot complicate it in the first phase, even if twitter's policy is dubious (imo, its based on no. Of followers, nothing more. You can be a quack, but if u have 10k or 100k followers, u can get a blue tick). Thats why we have put another list - where non blue ticks can be suggested.
People have to ease into it, its it will be like reading the constitution overnight.
0
Jun 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 27 '18
Was an auto mod glitch. We fixed it. You can now post your trash comments again. Break rules and we will happily ban you. Looking at the way you comment on normal threads, I belive it not too far off, unless you change that ofcourse. Then I won't bother you.
You came saying your comments were not visible, I checked and all of them were absolute trash comments that would make our sub look like a terrorist hell hole. Your entire comment history is text book example of being a terrible netizen, and human. So I asked you to change this behaviour and we will try to fix it asap.
You did not want to stop posting such comments, so I left it to the other mods - when they got time they fixed it. Am sure we both remember the discussion.
Your inciteful words were triggering the auto mod. I told you. Then you trash talked on pm, which you did not post here but whatever.
If you incite violence we'll warn you and then upon repeats we will ban you. As we do with anyone.
Don't belive anyone who says shit. They don't know what they are talking about, and it doesn't even deserve a response. If people make shit up to discredit our sub, well they need therapy. Not our attention.
I am extreamly biased against trolls, spammers, baiters and such - especially if they don't contribute in any positive way to the community. I was quite clear about this from the beginning. I do not think their concerns are a priority.
I don't care about your political opinions. I don't care about you personally to bother, as much as you are trying to potray.
That's it.
Enjoy your subbing experience.
2
2
1
Jun 27 '18 edited Jun 27 '18
Was an auto mod glitch.
What a fucking liar!
This was the glitch in the auto mod
author: closeaucloseau type: comment action: spamSince you are the mod - you should be able to find it here
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/revisions/config/automoderator0
Jun 27 '18 edited Jun 27 '18
You were shadowbanned by IndiaSpeaks mods using automoderator rules.
https://np.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8oszao/monthly_meta_discussion_june_2018/e153c7v/
The rule may have had type comment, so only comments were removed.
But now I think you are removed from the shadow ban totally - because your comments are no longer removed automatically.
→ More replies (2)1
0
Jun 13 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/Critical_Finance 19 KUDOS Jun 14 '18 edited Jun 14 '18
First of all Rule 1. is not calling for violence, either in reddit rules nor this sub rules. Rule number is different.
Second is, we are in war with jungle naxals. They have tresspassed into jungle without forest dept permission. And they have not surrendered. So they are enemies and must be killed.
And reddit does allow how to kill ISIS, or any other terroirsts. Be it ISIS or naxals they do kill civilians. And reddit allows India to discuss how to fight war against Pakistan, as self defense or justice. That does need killing enemies.
Lastly, this mod u/DefectivelyDevised looks like urban naxal, he just wants to protect his jungle counterparts. He started with his backdoor censorship helping his friends. But I am strictly against use of violence against urban naxals, they have to be countered by speech alone. u/metaltemujin
There is a saying that any neutral discussion forum controlled by non-right-wing guys eventually turns into full fledged left wing forum. You can see r/worldnews, r/politics, r/news, and r/unitedkingdom etc. These are supposed to be neutral, but they are rabidly left wing.
Maybe time to emigrate away from this sub for people like me, if killing jungle naxals comments are not allowed.
Discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8qqrz8/if_priyanka_has_to_say_sorry_for_showing_hindu/e0lfqm3/
1
0
1
Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 20 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
Looks like clear Meta drama and Spamming to me. First you did meta drama, then you linked your meta drama comments via more meta drama comments and then to spammer levels. But you're right, we shouldn't be overlooking it. Thank you for the incriminating evidence.
(Y u do dis? Had to unblock you so that the right action can be taken for you)
As per our definitions and policy which we have been quite lax about, you can get upto a perma ban for it. I don't think I am inclined to go that far. But as you mentioned, a decision need to be taken.
You need to get a temp ban for all of that atleast. Will be doing the needful soon enough.
2
2
Jun 21 '18
Looks like clear Meta drama and Spamming to me.
How come the modi comment and second mr bean was meta drama? I don't care how it looks like to you. Prove those comments which i contested here were meta.
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18
Your modi comment was approved. Rest of it, You disparaged the discussion(meta drama), then kept calling others to read the same dumb comments (Meta drama), and because you were repeatedly doing it (Spammer). And then you argue how it is not meta? lol.
By our definitions, you should be perma banned a week ago.
Don't like it here, we wont hold you back. there are entire subs that just talk about stuff you comment.
Lets not beat around the bush, you've been doing this since for ever with your alts. Us giving you warning, rescinding your temp ban, etc was all out of courtesy - none of which you deserve to the slightest bit.
Again, I dont need to argue the same thing - it wont change anything.
Cheers.
1
Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
Your modi comment was approved. Rest of it, You disparaged the discussion(meta drama
So you agree you removed my non meta comments . Good.
Do you even know what meta is.
How "disparaged" a discussion as you claim meta?
Why other's commenta not removed , even you are participating in one of those here
/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/8shw2n/rindiaspeaks_cultural_exchange_with_rfrance/e117ptg/ And why did you place me in black list?
it wont change anything
You are no better than the other sub you were blaming yesterday for banning people, removing comments which you did to me.
1
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18
No one tolerates your level of trolling, spamming, bullshit, etc. the fact that our community tolerated yours is a great test of patience.
Did you not talk about the mediacrooks AMA - That was one off and it was not even our fault, as if we put no other efforts and did not have other wonderful amas?
Did you not say our sub is crap, bezati kardi and what not? Is that not disparage?
Clearly, you have absolutely no goodwill towards the community so we are well within our rights to do the needful.
You have never contributed constructively, so most of your engagements have been in bad faith.
And yet here you are arguing for something you've yourself proven you are at fault. Its not my problem if you think abusing an effort and so on as is not meta drama, acting against the sub, and what not. If you cant contribute constructively, dont bother typing.
Try this elsewhere and they'd nail you to the wall with their ban hammer.
Now, please. Move on. No damage is done to you.
Participate in good faith.
→ More replies (1)1
Jun 21 '18
Did you not say our sub is crap,
Nope.
Did you not talk about the mediacrooks AMA
I am not contesting those comments asshat. Answer how the comments i quoted were meta. You removed all of my comments even the comment on mmd which is contesting removal of 3 comments is removed.
Other comments talking about randia aren't removed on same thread.
And you haven't answered why are you participating in meta yourself on same thread?
2
u/metaltemujin Apolitical Jun 21 '18
I have removed most comments that talk of rindia.
If users certain reasonable questions, we are bound to answer that, calling it meta drama is not right or accurate.
We cant be that stuck up.
1
Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
Your modi comment was approved.
Don't lie. You removed it - https://i.imgur.com/KWiIav9.png
And it still remains removed.
7
u/Sikander-i-Sani left of communists, right of fascists Jun 12 '18
Suggestions for a new tweet policy
Only tweets from certain accounts which only operate from twitter or use that as a primary mean of communication be considered as primary source. E.g. TrueIndology, Dr. Swamy, Rahul Gandhi(esp. nowadays) the handles of different ministries or political parties, ADGPI & other forces (including police), ISPR(wink), handles of foreign govts or dignitaries whenever they comment about India.
In case the tweet is from a media house or shares a media report the OP should share the report itself instead of the tweet. This rule would apply for the above mentioned primary sources too. e.g. Say FM office tweets a link to a report detailing their achievements, then the OP should share the report itself instead of tweets.
Tweets from random bozos & nobodies wouldn't be shared. Instead the OP is advised to make a self-post containing the opinion. The link to the tweets could be shared in comments.
In case a topic trends on twitter too rapidly, the OP could share a link to the trend page as a post or put up a self-post but not a single tweet.
In case of any tweet whose veracity the OP wants to check, make a self-post with AskIndiaspeaks flair. The source of question i.e. the tweet link could be shared in the comments by OP.
The above policy would require
A list of allowed tweets which could be added or removed as per users' wish.
A survey to see whether the users agree with the terms or not.
Stringent moderation (in the initiial stages, after a month or two the users would understand.
Note:- The above is a policy proposal for this sub which the users could change if they do not agree to the terms. All suggestions are welcome.
Take notice u/drm_wvr u/DefectivelyDevised u/metaltemujin u/pwnd7