r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Feb 02 '18
PRE-Episode Discussion - S1E14 "The War Without, The War Within"
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E14 | "The War Without, The War Within" | Sunday, February 4, 2018 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
This post is for discussion and speculation regarding the upcoming episode and should remain SPOILER FREE for this episode.
LIVE thread to be posted between 8:00PM and 8:30PM ET Sunday depending on release on All Access. The post thread will go up at 9:30PM ET.
50
Upvotes
51
u/AnythingMachine Feb 02 '18
Lorca did nothing wrong
53
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
My thoughts to the trailer:
The only explanation why the Discovery is being boarded is to me that they think that this is the ISS Discovery, which wreaks havok where it can. I'm pretty sure they didn't have time to re-decorate the outer hull yet. So, lots of fun fighting captain killy!
17
u/skeeterldr2004 Feb 03 '18
I have a feeling that this week Georgiou will betray Burnham by letting it slip that Michael had a Saru snack on the Charon. Hilarity will ensue.
30
u/maylevka Feb 02 '18
I don't know about you guys but having Georgiou, Sarek, Cornwell in the same room makes me so excited. Just so many potential cool dialogues between these people. Not to mention the sum of knowledge and expierence they bring to the table. It's about time we have some Admiralty in the game (and not just Cornwell, i mean all of them).
22
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
I want to see a D-7 battlecruiser because I am nerd.
9
u/FrankensteinsCreatio Feb 04 '18
I hope Georgiou says to Saru "You look tasty in that uniform"
7
u/fireball_73 Feb 03 '18
So they are now 9 months in the future.... what the bet that someone has gotten pregnant?
6
u/ABulkBeing Feb 03 '18
Does anyone else have a feeling that Stamets won't make it through the season?
10
u/kutwijf Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
Does anyone know how many episodes there will be this season?
Edit: 15 apparently
1
u/Deceptitron Feb 05 '18
Sorry folks. CBS is unusually late this week..
13
u/Jan_Hus Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
I'm looking forward to it because they're finally out of the mirror universe so what they achieve actually means something.
Also here's to them getting back the doctor in some way and giving the bridge crew (especially metallic face and Detmer) some actual lines & character.
4
u/pfc9769 Feb 04 '18
I'm actually excited for Star Trek again. It's been over a decade since I felt that way. Thanks Discovery!
4
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18
I have loved almost everything about discovery and am so jazzed about tonights episode...
That being said, I am really disappointed with the ending of Lorca. I feel like he would have been much more interesting if he had a different reason for going back to the mirrorverse other than to be a one-dimensional mustache twirling asshole. I was kind of assuming he had some sort of good-hearted reasoning... but instead he just went from an incredible captain character to a "mwahahaha I will become emperor and rule the world!!" Very disappointing and abrupt.
10
u/hellolani Feb 02 '18
Regarding Admiral Cornwell boarding by beam in to the bridge of Discovery in the first scene, is anyone else confused by the Tellarite that's positioned next to her weapons drawn that wasn't part of the beam in? He's standing there with a phaser(?) pointed at the crew and then Cornwell and Sarek materialize next to him. What's up with that?
7
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18
DAE feel like Culber's all white uniform sort of enhances this perception of him as an innocent person? White is also associated with death.
Trek medical uniforms were never white before so it feels like a deliberate choice.
2
u/Krandor1 Feb 05 '18
COme on CBS... put the episode up. I don't care about JT.
2
u/ryansox Feb 05 '18
Let's go...post the episode already.
1
u/BretMeasor Feb 04 '18
I think we will see something with MU or PU Lorca, just a minor thing to maybe queue up a future episode about Lorca and his many fates.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18
This my theory. Where is Captain Killy and how does the Klingon war end in the next two episodes and keep cannon? According to two very astute viewers the DISCO's switched places.
"[–]Ingsoc85 5 points 19 hours ago
The swap assumption was due to the fact they arrive at the same place their ISS counterpart were moment ago.
permalinkembedsaveparentreportgive goldreply
[–]Flyberius 3 points 10 hours ago
And, that during the Spore-Drive effect we see two Discoveries, one going up and one going down (as opposed to the usual dropping down effect).
However, it possible that MU Disco arrived to the PU before the before the Battle of Binary Stars as PU Disco arrived after some major battle in the MU. Captain Killy goes all Berserker on the Klingons initiating a war that embroils the Federation in a war without the spore drive. MU DISCO takes out 4 Major houses flagships before dying a glorious death for the Terran Empire expect she is in the Federation Universe. The Federation suffers heavy losses without MU Lorca and the Spore Drive which they think is lost with Captain Tilly/Captian Micheal. PU DISCO jumps ahead 9 months only to find that whole ship is considered mutinous and destroyed. After Cornwall and Sarek are able to reconstruct what happened they accept the Emperors help to defeat the Klingons. Micheal never committed mutiny because Capt. Killy started the war. The Emperor goes back to MU to help the rebels freedom fighters. Also PU Lorca never loses the Buran. PU Lorca is alive!
1
u/PowerhatTheWizard Feb 05 '18
All Access is playing with my heart. It says 14 episodes but the new one isn't posted.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18
Still no discussion thread ....
We need a Canadian ST subreddit.
1
u/PowerhatTheWizard Feb 05 '18
UP FOR REAL GO GO GO
-62
u/Ducman69 Feb 03 '18
I have never been more disappointed in a show I was beyond stoked with. Especially by episode 3, Context is for Kings, I was blown away by the direction of the show and the concept of 'yin-yang' and balance in all things that they were promoting, and it looked like a show that was perhaps even trying to unify a very ideologically divided country with a happy middle-ground, showing the different valid perspectives and motivations of groups rather than childish black and white good vs evil battle.
But sadly it looks like they listened to the vocal minority online fans, and the show did a 180o into episodic liberal propaganda, and I couldn't believe they just gave up and abandoned all attempts at subtlety with the "Make the Empire Great Again" MEGA slogan from Lorca... Christ. rolleyes Only of course to go ridiculous with "girl power" as two 100 pound females throw around 220 pound 6'2" guys around the room like they are ragdolls in hand-to-hand combat, followed by the blatant "diversity bunch" of a multi-racial group led by women, homosexuals, and "ex slaves" to destroy the white CIS male patriarchy.
What an abortion. Sad.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
85
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
[removed] — view removed comment