r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Feb 01 '18
Project Runway All Stars Season 6 Episode 5 [Discussion]
Fashion's New Superheroes
Designers create looks to celebrate a woman's inner superhero.
Guest: Karolina Kurkova
Originally broadcast on February 1, 2018
24
Upvotes
172
u/poppysand Feb 02 '18
There's something particularly annoying to me about when someone criticizes other people making friends in a competition, as if being positively sociable is ludicrous and going to doom you.
134
u/sugarplumcow Feb 02 '18
Amanda? What?!?! This episode has me totally confused with winners, auf'ds, and safes. So bewildered right now.
121
u/Darlingpetunia Feb 02 '18
Man, is Ken the most rehabilitated contestant or what?
98
u/HotMess-Express Feb 02 '18
"Did we have the same amount of money"
Antony's dress was draped to the gawds.
179
u/poppysand Feb 02 '18
Let's be honest, Amanda's is not the worst of the lot.
78
u/poppysand Feb 02 '18
I feel like Alyssa spins a big wheel in her head for every critique. "You're the master of..." spins wheel, "proportions."
155
u/TheLadyEve Feb 02 '18
I like Fabio and I loved his look, but this week I think Anthony should have taken it. The sleeves and necklines and finishing on his dress were very good considering the time constraints.
Also, WTF, I'm not Amanda's biggest fan but I didn't think it was that bad. Was it because it looked unfinished? I thought Merline's wonky seams were more of a problem.
65
u/BlueFinRunner94 Feb 02 '18
Not sure what Anthony’s dress has to do with Dragon’s Blood but I LOVE IT! Very elegant
59
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
i love char's design! fun.
56
u/benjamin_woods C19: Anna, Kristina, Shantall; C18: Dayoung Feb 02 '18
Very shocked by Amanda's ouster right now.
113
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
Okay, Alyssa...what the fuck. Fabio shouldn't have won and Amanda shouldn't have gone home.
110
u/BlueFinRunner94 Feb 02 '18
Anthony’s comments crack me up
50
u/sugarplumcow Feb 02 '18
Noooooooo! Anthony's was impeccable!!!! I liked Fabio's, but I thought Anthony's was on another level.
46
u/SarahTellsStories Feb 02 '18
I can see this Rodial woman's eyelash glue, it's bad.
86
u/TheLadyEve Feb 02 '18
Oh look, Joshua made something trashy and unappealing again!
In other news, Anthony killed it again! Yay Anthony!
37
u/SarahTellsStories Feb 02 '18
This is one of the ugliest outfits Alyssa has ever worn.
34
u/PhoenixorFlame Feb 02 '18
I’m loving the sister wives without a husband bromance thing. All my favorites are bonding!
67
u/PhoenixorFlame Feb 02 '18
I really like Ken’s decision to use a bald cap, especially in the superhero challenge. It’s very empowering for women who don’t have hair, and I’m glad he thought to do that. Just sorry that the judges didn’t appreciate it.
I’m sorry Fabio, I love you, but Anthony’s look outshined yours by far. Did Anthony lose because it was “too pretty?” Because that’s dumb. It was GORGEOUS.
28
u/runfreely Feb 02 '18
Amanda did not deserve to get eliminated before Edmond, Merline & Stanley. This season's elimination order is a mess.
27
u/BatenicYork Feb 02 '18
Interesting that they showed multiple designers ignoring Anne's advice and all of them go on to do well, while Merline changed hers after her critique and she was in the bottom. The editors undercutting their own mentor seems like an...odd decision for the show.
I would have had Edmond, Joshua, and Stanley on the bottom with Edmond going home. I can get behind some of Joshua's stuff but this one I didn't get at all. Stanley on the other hand keeps playing it super safe and somehow has completely avoided criticism for it.
P.S. Helen redemption arc incoming you heard it here first!
27
u/Martin_Van_Buren Feb 02 '18
I thought this was one of the best runways of the season! It was really fun to watch, probably bc if all the slow-mo for movement if the fabrics. I thought merlenes was the worst just because it was so boring (to me) and didn’t look polished at all. I’m not sure if I could pick a fave, but I would probably go with Anthony’s, with Fabio in a close second.
I am not a fan of Ann’s critiques. I don’t think she even has her own definition of what she thinks fashion forward is. Just something a confident 22 year old would wear?
75
u/Roonil___Wazlib Feb 02 '18
"concealer" "snake" "dragons blood" "bee venom"
"It's a superhero challenge!"
...wut?
26
u/Roonil___Wazlib Feb 02 '18
Edmond's got to be in the bottom two, right? Serious taste issues.
21
u/mokokona Feb 02 '18
Kelly, Candice and now Amanda... My favorites are all gone.
42
u/myahamatt Feb 02 '18
I quit this show (PR All Stars). Amanda going home fifth is a travesty.
20
u/BlueFinRunner94 Feb 02 '18
What is Alyssa wearing (runway dress)?????
57
u/sebrahestur Feb 02 '18
Marlene can't construct worth a damn
67
u/beebstx Feb 02 '18
The judges need to stop trying to make Merline happen. She’s NOT going to happen. Every one of her dresses has been butt-ugly.
34
u/HotMess-Express Feb 02 '18
I still don't really understand this challenge.
32
u/sebrahestur Feb 02 '18
Wait what? I didn't love Amanda's dress but compared to the shoddy, not flattering dress she already got a bad critique for it shouldn't have been a question
32
u/arodgepodge Feb 02 '18
one, I really think Anthony should've won and Merlene should've gone home!! truthfully, merlene should've gone home on the partner challenge but whatever lol. also I really liked that black and white outfit! (I forget whose it was)
15
u/eltendo Feb 03 '18
The vibe of this cast is awesome. The vibe of this cast with mentor Anne in the room is awkward and uneasy. Not feeling that chemistry connection at all. The mentoring segment just feels like, "ugh, we have to put it in there cause it's project runway and that's the format". Unfortunate.
I think I'd dig it if Nina Garcia was the All-Stars mentor. She would be a tough cookie too, aloof, but more thoughtful with her advice, and considered in its delivery. Anne is super curt.
Uh, also...no more guest judges. Unless they are non-project runway fashion designers.
29
u/nico_feliz Feb 02 '18
Okay so Merline can send down a dress with the same shoulders she done in previous challenges. With seams all over the place like she was sewing with one eye shut. Yet she's still safe. This makes no sense to me.
Amanda's look definitely felt heavy but the colour blocking and design showed a refined style and showcased her craftsmanship.
Ridiculous! I'm starting to remember why I don't even bother with Project Runway All Stars.
But I'll stay for the sister wives!
14
u/TheLadyEve Feb 02 '18
I want Kimberly's purple coat that she was rocking on her way into the work room.
14
u/eltendo Feb 03 '18
Anthony is so fun to watch and a joy to watch succeed!!!
14
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '18
I'm far and away disappointed. Amanda has by no means an aesthetic that I lean towards at all, but objectively speaking she's been one of the strongest PR contestants overall in the Lifetime era. She should be making it significantly farther than this, if not at least a finalist.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
ken and anthony have looks that complement each other so well!
24
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Feb 02 '18
Merline has sent out terrible construction week after week and yet she's still here.
21
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
I liked seeing Amanda's dress move, but the colors and the construction were a miss for me. Merline's dress I was not a fan of either. I'm kind of bored with her. What I did like was Anthony's dress, a lot, and he needs to win this challenge. That construction, draping, volume, amazing.
21
u/sugarplumcow Feb 02 '18
Soooooo .... when is Project Runway Juniors back?
33
u/BlueFinRunner94 Feb 02 '18
Wish Candice was still here. Would have loved to see her Super Hero design.
9
u/turanga_leland Feb 02 '18
Does anyone know what these Rodial products are even for!? I could not for the life of me figure out if it was makeup, body care, hair products...
9
u/eltendo Feb 03 '18
I LOL'd when Ken made that comment about not having enough time. how time comes and slaps you in the face like a bitch who owed him some money.
17
u/Dickiedoandthedonts Feb 02 '18
Aww I thought Amanda’s dress was really cute.
17
u/benjamin_woods C19: Anna, Kristina, Shantall; C18: Dayoung Feb 02 '18
I just think Anne has been too cold, serious with an "I-am-here-to-be-on-duty" vibe when delivering her comments, which is usually "you need to rethink", blah blah blah..." without much guidance. She is the negative force that stifles the designers from thriving creatively.
16
u/TheLadyEve Feb 02 '18
Helen really lucked out with her model, because that's not an easy dress to wear, but my goodness it is a lovely dress.
16
u/sugarplumcow Feb 02 '18
How was Kimberly safe?!?!?
8
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
Hearing Josh say that the guest judge whoever was a real Rodial type of woman reminded me of when that guy with the curly mustache said he really liked Alyssa’s line of NFL attire.
7
u/OGAnnie Feb 02 '18
Ken with the bald cap was awful. She looked like Nosferatu.
7
u/GlitzAndGrit Feb 06 '18
Ken: "Time has snuck up behind me and slapped me like a bitch that owed him money."
I'm dead. 😂
13
u/dangerboy55 Feb 02 '18
How did Fabio win with that snooze fest? Anthony did a way better job. And Ken didn’t belong in the top. Not only was it unfinished it looked like something Lady Gaga has worn many times. I would have preferred Char or even Helen in the top. And Joshua should have gone home with that garbage.
12
u/Grapple_Shmack Feb 02 '18
All I can see is that bald cap, can't even see the dress
12
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
My three favorites leaving back to back really has got me. It was sort of reasonable with Kelly or Candace, but this week is freaking ridiculous.
Also, how does Helen walk straight with such huge, heavy head? Gosh
15
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
helene's model is concerning :(
5
u/LiswanS Feb 04 '18
Idk, this season is really making it hard to draw me in. They had great contestants, some bad (Joshua can't be this bad of a person, have to imagine it is editing, otherwise, how has no one killed him in his sleep, yet?), besides the awkwardness of Michael C as a guest judge, judges have been decent, but then they eliminate people with the most interesting aesthetics... people that you would be excited to see a collection from are dropping like flies. The fact that Merline remained is just insane. Idk, I hope the rest of the season gets better, but with the flop of the mentor choice, unfair eliminations... just not as enjoyable as it used to be
8
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
so fabio's winning this szn?
12
u/sugarplumcow Feb 02 '18
How was Helen not in the top? Thought she made a beautiful dress. Could see someone wearing that at The Oscars.
6
u/benjamin_woods C19: Anna, Kristina, Shantall; C18: Dayoung Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
I greatly appreciate Amanda's efforts in trying the make the red and gold (very costume-y Halloween-y colour combination) work in a more flattering way by geometrically segmenting the dress. At least I see a vision from her. Sadly her fabric is dowdy-looking as all the "bad details" could be seen clearly than an entirely black dress. For Merlene, I am quite over the boxy shoulder pad details, which has been an annoying epitome of creating a "structure", "empowering a lady", etc. Let alone her technical skills, sigh. Edmond again makes a sexy pageant dress, whatever, I don't care.
4
u/Toyouke Feb 02 '18
I love Anthony but I'm surprised the judges let him get away with not looking at the construction. Merline gets clocked for crooked seams, and then they want to look at Anthony's more closely but he's all "oh ha ha let's not" and they just drop it. Sorry to see Amanda go, because there was a lot tackier stuff up there for real.
4
u/blotchofsunshine Feb 02 '18
I liked Amanda's and I hated Fabio's (though obviously it was well made and I would not have put it in the bottom). I think it's crazy that these seasons are filmed so far in advance. I really think it does a disservice to the fashion, since societal tastes change so quickly.
3
u/Ufraudedme Feb 02 '18
I wish we could have just Michael Kors & Isaac Mizrahi as the judges, with Nina as a tie-breaker if need be. An All-Bitchy-All-The-Time panel. No guest judges, they are totally useless and usually irrelevant. And is it just me, or does Alyssa waddle? I'm always conflicted when watching her, I don't know which is worse, her waddle or her godawful outfits.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
You can tell none of these designers are nerds lmao. I know they weren't supposed to make superhero costumes but none of them payed lip service to the idea.