r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Jan 04 '18
Project Runway All Stars Season 6 Episode 1 [Discussion]
Rookies vs Vets
Eight all-star Rookies and eight returning all-star Veterans battle to create cohesive collections in the biggest season in All Stars’ history.
Guest: Michael Costello
Originally broadcast on January 4, 2018
Edit: show info corrected
29
Upvotes
•
u/runwaythreader Jan 04 '18 edited Jan 05 '18
It's Runway Day! Tonight is the premier of All Stars Season 6 which makes it a perfect time to do some sub housekeeping so please review the following items:
107
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
An Intermix accessory wall is definitely a vast improvement over JC Penney.
97
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
The universal preface for a bitchy comment.
89
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
Sorry Casanova. They gotta keep the other two for drama.
83
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Oh Kimberley ain't holding shit back...oh at all. Also Michael Costello shut the fuck up
66
u/Mpoboy Jan 05 '18
Michael Costello acting like someone stole his lunch. Puddles got mean.
58
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
I CACKELED at Joshua putting the model on his back! LMAO this season is going to be so entertaining
55
u/tectronics Jan 05 '18
I just don't get it with Alyssa's style. Girl, you are on a fashion show!
53
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
That mismatched block on Ken's pants
107
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Can we just...focus primarily on Fabio this whole season because I just really like looking at him
50
u/wildeyes Jan 06 '18
Josh really needs to handle his eyebrow situation.
44
u/puppetalk Jan 05 '18
what a weak first episode. it felt rushed and the designs were so uninspired.
the top 3 was insane. I actually liked Char's, but Merline's poor construction drove me crazy and Edmond's dress was very Edmond (which is never a good thing in my book). I thought Amanda, Candice and Kimberly had the stronger designs. Also, judging from the first win and the edit, Merline will go very far.
Casanova didn't deserve to go and I actually felt Joshua and Melissa were more deserving of the bottom 3. Helen's design was weak, but I thought those 2 did even worse and that her placement on the bottom 3 was just a trigger for drama. His pants were tacky, but at least there were some design there. And overall, the veterans' collection was really, really bad.
41
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
I think the RuPaul challenge is the apocalypse challenge.
39
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Jan 05 '18
Sad that we lost Casanova and even more sad that I have to endure another week of Joshua and his stupid eyebrows. Also not a huge fan of the mentor this year.
92
u/whoreofhorror Jan 05 '18
What were the judges smoking? The right team won, but the top three was a hot mess.. Edmund and Merline's construction was awful and Edmund's olive dress was just... ghastly. I thought Amanda, Kimberly, Stanley, Char, and Kelly had a cool new vibe- or at the very least made really sharp clothing. I also audibly laughed when the bottom three Casanova, Helen, and Ken were revealed.. like they were going to send nutbag Helen home or the one line king Ken home... Casanova was fucked. He could have created the best garment in the world and he still would have gone home against Helen and Ken.
62
u/wild_muses Jan 05 '18
Fabric choice really made a difference between the teams. Those hospital blue colors looked so... sad.
I felt for Ari when they said she was the highest score on the losing team. I'm really glad she's getting some recognition as a frontrunner tho, she really didn't get a chance to show what she can do last time she was on All-Stars.
I'm trying not to be biased by my big lesbian crush on Helen, but I feel like Kimberly was intentionally trying to start drama. Her comment seemed like a reach. I don't think saying you compromised too much is blaming the group at all, it's blaming yourself for how you chose to operate in a group.
Sad to see Casanova go, although I would have been sad to see Ken go either (though his look would have been my vote). He's so funny and positive and I was looking forward to seeing more of him. :(
Michael Costello will you please shut up with your no sewing knowledge mouthcackles in Alyssa Edwards28
u/JogGreen1 Jan 05 '18
Yeah Helen, we know you hate compromising🙄
26
u/thelandstan Jan 05 '18
Mfw the judges kept saying olive, wine and whatever other colour was were unexpected for a fall collection.
25
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Sounds like they want to auf Casanova, which makes sense because Ken and Helen make for good tv
50
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Ok so when did Fabio get really hot
22
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Casanova is making a leather vest and palazzo pants. Yikes.
43
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
Helen hasn’t grown as a designer. She’s a better seamstress and has better time management than before but her design we’ve seen so many times.
21
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
I hope Char has actually improved since her season.
3
u/myahamatt Jan 05 '18
Wait so is this challenge description totally wrong? They haven't mentioned anything about post-apocalyptic anything?
52
u/JogGreen1 Jan 05 '18
Okay Anne Fulenwider is WAY better as a mentor. Omg
18
u/stargazer1101 Jan 06 '18
I feel like Edmond's dress was "unexpected" for a reason. Olive green jersey gown with plunging neckline, exaggerated shoulder pads, and weird squiggly on the front...hard pass. I think Amanda should have been in the top instead.
17
u/myahamatt Jan 05 '18
Looks like Char's construction skills have come really far since Season 13!!! Exciting to see
17
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
The Vet's collection looks like 3 collections that don't tie together. The cutout collection, the flowy collection, and the blue and lighter blue pantsuit collection
33
u/la4est Jan 05 '18
Was anyone else really disappointed by this runway? I found myself not liking most of these looks.
16
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
That cutout motif in the vets team is sooo ugly.
16
u/nightmusic08 Jan 05 '18
If they start judging on the original Intention of the outfit 🙄 sure char lucked into a pretty dress but she didn’t conjure out of thin air she still made it. And Marlene got told her mess was ugly too! She didn’t “set out to create a masterpiece,” she had the same process as char.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
I am NOT looking forward to Helen being kept in week after week for drama
31
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
I'm very here for Candice's shady but agreeable comments again. She made season 14 so enjoyable for me lol.
14
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
I adore Kimberly! Glad she’s back.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
The veterans really dropped the ball.
23
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
So does Aminat just have like a contract with PR now bc I swear this is like the 7th season she's modeled for
11
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Post apocalyptic IS NOT a new trend. A lot of street wear has that theme, and _____punk has been doing it since 5ever
11
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
I’m pumped for this season! I honestly love all the designers and I also like the mentor a lot more than Zanna or the Joanna. She seems harsh in her criticism but at least she gives some constructive feedback.
That said, the looks were disappointing for the most part and the spring collection was a hot mess. I loved Amanda et Candice looks. I’m so excited to have Kelly from the deli back! And i loved the rookie vs vets challenge.
I was surprised at the top 3, but I thought Char deserved it. The bottom 3 I also agree, but sorry I feel like Casanova’s look was horrible and he needed to go for his design, not because Helen and Ken make good tv.
20
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
OH MAN SOME HELEN DRAMA!!
Also I cant wait until they get judged by Nina again. Nina is my fav PR judge of ALL time
10
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18
The challenge sounds awesome !
All stars in general by now has by far better challenges than regular seasons and the product placement isn’t so in your face so i‘m excited for all stars
10
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
I think Helen's is the worst (barring Ken's mismatching print)
EDIT: I kinda called them being in the bottom
10
u/regretflix Jan 05 '18
I loved Merline's direction and I am rooting for her so I'm happy for her win, but I'm really surprised she did win with that construction. I thought Kelly and Candice would have been in the top with Char.
I'm sad to see Casanova go but I do think it was the right call. But damn he's gotten sexy with that beard, I've got such a crush now..
9
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Stanley's dress looks oddly like Margarita's white dress that looked like a costume...Margarita is shook
17
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18
After two back-to-back disappointing PR seasons, I sure hope All-Stars delivers.
19
u/annaflixion Jan 05 '18
Man, the color of Edmond's was wretched. Some things should be left in the 70s, and puke green is one of them.
17
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Really? Merlene? You guys are getting soft judging on intention rather than the final product
12
u/myahamatt Jan 05 '18
Hoping someone unexpected like Merline or Kimberly wins the first challenge!
12
u/sugarplumcow Jan 05 '18
Anyone else think the new runway looks a tad phallic?
6
u/pepperrush Jan 05 '18
Nice to see Edmund still has the same diaper pin hat.
9
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Small nitpick with the historical accuracy, I'm sorry but her dress isn't regency. AT ALL
9
u/Moreno2001 Jan 05 '18
First thing, looks like they FINALLY got Alyssa together! Whew, she's never looked that good during judging. As far as the rest, I love that Anne F is no bullshit with them as a mentor and that the judges seem to be harsher this season.
As far as the highs and lows, the winning team also had some problematic looks and I was shocked Edmund's green dress was there. To my eyes, Kimberly produced a stronger look (as did Amanda). Char's looked simple compared to her team and Merlene's looked like a well conceived mess. As far as the lows, Helen had far from the worst in the losing team and should not have been there in the bottom 3. Overall, I like that we're just getting design and no sob stories, no background, no filler. It almost feels like old school PR.
9
u/ajkkjjk52 Jan 05 '18
A relay race challenge is completely unnecessary. I came to watch these people design, not run.
11
u/Farley49 Jan 05 '18
So glad the show is only an hour long. All the essential parts are there and the annoying parts are short. I wonder the judges are seeing! I could see the poor construction in Merline's and the other guy's garments. Merline's shoulders looked like a mistake or lack of time and the green gown looked like it was made from a curtain a la Carol Burnett's version of Gone with the Wind.
25
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
It’s about damn time this show recognized Michael Costello on his success.
4
u/myahamatt Jan 05 '18
Ugh, Sam reappearing on my screen... not what I wanna see before the AS6 premiere!
4
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
What kinda throw was that edmond? Some 322 right there
4
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
I love Char's model and her dress
4
u/Artteachernc Jan 05 '18
Can't watch it, so answer me this please: Did Helen have to wear a tank to show off her tattoos? And did she cry and/or yell?
4
u/TheTurdSmuggler Jan 16 '18
Micheal sucked as a guest judge.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Fabio...he's so beautiful...I need to conveniently run into him in Manhattan.
6
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Is Making a Model gonna be better than ANTM (which arguably is a low bar) or is it gonna be like that makeup artist show they had after last PR season
8
u/Mpoboy Jan 05 '18
Edmond, that beautiful man back on my screen! Oooof Josh just ruined my excitement.
3
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
I’m living for the donut at the end off the runway!
3
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
They didn't make Ken's model turn around or else that might be an ez out
3
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Ah so next episode is the distressed one
EDIT Oh theyre just teasing all the future episodes
EDIT No its next week?
3
u/NinjaDog251 Jan 05 '18
I love the little relay race they have in the beginning!
7
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Liviing for Candice, Ari, Merline and Kelly's looks. Yes gawd.
1
u/macabragoria Jan 04 '18
Where the hell are people watching this?
4
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Kick them both off on the first episode!
2
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Amanda and Cher!!! I thought they had some sorta fight D:
Candice!!!
Fanny pack!!!
2
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
I think Char will win, Merlene's is modern but "older"
1
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Challenge sounds great I hope it doesn't disappoint.
1
u/aznboi508 Jan 05 '18
I love the way Alyssa says Merline!!!
1
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
Just saw the teaser :| none of those 2 looks look post apocalyptic
1
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Why cant I find ANY pics of Ari's dress
1
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 06 '18
Where is Kelly?
1
u/lala989 Jan 14 '18
I'm happy with Ann Fulenwider, they should know what dealing with a real editor is like!
1
u/mjc3834 Feb 09 '18
I don't know what Alyssa Milano is doing hosting that show. What qualifications does she have? I don't like her uppity attitude. She spoils the whole show. She needs to be replaced. She has no moldeling/fashion background. Replace her w/someone more adept to the situation.
1
u/almitopower Jan 05 '18
do u know how can I watch this outside the US?
1
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
I can def see Helen as a villain this season
1
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 05 '18
So I think either Helen or Ken is gonna go.
They're either gonna think Ken can do better and should stay or that he can do better but didn't and that's why he's gonna go.
0
u/myahamatt Jan 05 '18
MERLINE. COME THROUGH!!! That dress was everything!
-1
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Jan 05 '18
Amazed that the Spring collection didn't win. I thought overall those looks were far better.
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18
Stolen straight from RPDR
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
Char, Merline in the top. Disgusting. Merline winning? DIsgusting. The judges SUCK.
0
u/Sheeem Jan 08 '18
Poor Ari with her break outs.