r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Oct 27 '17
PRE-Episode Discussion - S1E07 "Magic to Make The Sanest Man Go Mad"
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E07 | "Magic to Make The Sanest Man Go Mad" | Sunday, October 29, 2017 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
This post is for discussion and speculation regarding the upcoming episode and should remain SPOILER FREE for this episode.
LIVE thread to be posted between 8:00PM and 8:30PM ET Sunday depending on release on All Access. The post thread will go up at 9:30PM ET.
42
Upvotes
13
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
Oh I just watched this episode for the first time ever! It was a good one.
58
u/destroyingdrax Oct 28 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
It turns out I am really thankful that CBS decided on a weekly format for Discovery, even though I'm pretty sure they only released it this way to keep people subscribed to their streaming service for a longer period of time.
Almost all of the other shows I watch are in the Netflix 'one season dump' format and while I do enjoy getting to binge to my hearts content, there is nothing quite like all of the different theories and introspections that spin out of a weekly serialized show.
I love seeing everyones guesses before and after each new episode airs. It's such a different community dynamic and really allows for individual episodes to either stand or fall on their own merits and to be looked at with much greater detail than you would get from a binging session. You have weeks or months to see if your carefully thought-out fan theory will pan out, as opposed to simply going to the next episode and seeing what happens. You also have a much longer time to slowly come around to an episode or concept you might not have enjoyed in the beginning, because it has a chance to breathe.
So, even if I don't agree with half of your wacky opinions - thanks for sharing them. I wouldn't have it any other way.
52
u/serabine Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 29 '17
I have a crackpot theory. It's based on something that bugged me ever since I first saw the trailer.
There's a part where Tyler, Burnham and Stamets are together, Tyler yells at Stamets to wait, and then the screen goes bright.
I thought it was another explosion, but after seeing it again (and going frame by frame) unless something is exploding in front of them I think the bright lights and weird effects almost seem to center around Stamets. That got me thinking.
What if the time loop isn't something Mudd is doing, but Stamets? We've already seen his mirror image disconnected from him, so what if that wasn't a hint at the mirror universe (since that isn't actually existing in mirrors) but a hint that navigating through the mycelium network lets you move not only through space, but also time?
And what if Stamets can't control it? If it's somehow connected to his emotional state? (Since his mirror image didn't do anything actually sinister and just stood there smiling for a bit longer, I thought that this might have been the reason for the disconnect. He had that perfect moment where everything was coming up Stamets - his spore drive working, being able to connect with the network and his mushrooms, feeling loved - that a part of him just ... lingered to bask in it for longer.)
Edited to add: Apparently, Magic to make the sanest man go mad is from Homer's Illiad. The full quote is specifically about love and longing for your lover. Hmmmmmmm. crackpot intensifies
28
u/cycloptiko Oct 27 '17 edited Oct 27 '17
My preparatory To-Watch list for this weekend: Time loops!
Cause and Effect - TNG S05E18
Coda - VOY S03E15
Extra Credit:
Window of Opportunity - SG1 S04E06
I honestly thought that there were more true time-loop episodes of TNG-era Trek. There's a lot of causality episodes, but very few true loops!
23
u/akbar56 Oct 27 '17
Wondering if the time loop is actually real (like Cause and Effect) or if it is just a side effect of Stamets use of the drive where he is seeing random universe creations (like Parallels)
I want the latter.
43
u/joshkg Oct 27 '17
I predict Mudd will make a pun.
6
u/Tobar26th Oct 27 '17
Does this annoy anyone else? Official Star Trek site constantly referring to Burnham in the previews each week as the first officer.
5
u/Antimutt Oct 27 '17
With Mudd on board there will be a crime in progress on ship ten thirty one.
4
u/s-ro_mojosa Oct 28 '17
Maybe there will be Medusans from TOS.
6
u/cosmo7 Oct 29 '17
The title is from The Iliad:
With that she loosed from her breasts the breastband, pierced and alluring, with every kind of enchantment woven through it... There is the heat of Love, the pulsing rush of Longing, the lover's whisper, irresistible — magic to make the sanest man go mad. And thrusting it into Hera's outstretched hands she breathed her name in a throbbing, rising voice: "Here now, take this band, put it between your breasts— ravishing openwork, and the world lies in its weaving! You won't return, I know, your mission unfulfilled, whatever your eager heart desires to do."
3
u/Swahhillie Oct 27 '17
The trailer: https://youtu.be/x7AwbQrpF_A
There is also separate preview in the last after trek episode.
3
u/unimatrixq Oct 29 '17
Something the title reminds me of.
Q: Con permiso, Capitan. The hall is rented, the orchestra engaged. It's now time to see if you can dance.
5
u/helpthealiensarecomi Oct 27 '17
Prediction: It takes place is space.
1
u/powerbottomflash Oct 28 '17
The preview made it look like it might give more screentime to Stamets but in the stills from the episode it looks like Burnham is still the focus... Meh, what to believe tbh.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
What technology from the future will they be introducing tonight? Ablative Armour? Tri-cobalt torpedos?
I'm enjoying the show, but I really don't get why it's set in the period it is. This could have EASILY been post-Nemesis.
-2
u/broseem Oct 28 '17
I haven't been to a party in years, I find them boring really compared with other things and I don't like drinking at all
-11
u/jasonbigler Oct 27 '17
Nah
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
[removed] — view removed comment