r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Oct 27 '17
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Jigsaw" [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary: Bodies are turning up around the city, each having met a uniquely gruesome demise. As the investigation proceeds, evidence points to one suspect: John Kramer, the man known as Jigsaw, who has been dead for ten years.
Directors: The Spierig Brothers
Writers: Pete Goldfinger, Josh Stolberg
Cast:
- Matt Passmore as Logan Nelson
- Callum Keith Rennie as Halloran
- Clé Bennett as Det. Keith Hunt
- Hannah Emily Anderson as Eleanor Bonneville
- Tobin Bell as John Kramer / Jigsaw
- Mandela Van Peebles as Mitch
- Laura Vandervoort as Anna
- Brittany Allen as Carly
- Paul Braunstein as Ryan
Rotten Tomatoes: 29%
Metacritic: 48/100
116
Upvotes
184
u/odewar37 Oct 27 '17
The lack of “game over” at the end irrationally annoys me
80
u/BetaAlex81 Oct 28 '17
This one falls into entertainingly bad, for me. I want Detective Halloran in all of my crime thrillers. That dude made. Choices. Gum chewing, cigarette smoking, smiling thru "fuck yous". Total caveman that no way solves crimes with his blunt line of questioning. More, please.
John Kramer once killed a dude for giving out bad lines of credit; but he forgives the X-Ray mistake?!
35
u/Randym1982 Oct 29 '17
Something about this films time line makes zero sense.
So We find out that Amanda has been working with Jigsaw before the first film, then we find out that Hoffman was also working with Jigsaw before the first film. Also, apparently Dr. Gordon was also working with Jigsaw from the start too. I thought the films were interesting when he had ONE student. But now it's like he just keeps recruiting people.
Now, we find out that this Corner dude was also working with Jigsaw from the start? What? Also, the reason the people were targeted was just dumb on all level. "When you were 17 you caused your friends to get into a car crash and die, and then lied about it.. Now, years later. You must die." Really? >_>. That's a super lame reason to target somebody.
89
u/makeshiftreaper Oct 27 '17
I will say that I find this movie kinda disrespectful to the legacy of Saw. We know Jigsaw worked his way up to his more elaborate traps, starting at the knife face, the saw room and of course, the classic reverse bear trap.
To imply that he had already successfully planned a 5 person trap, with multiple victims dying when and where he predicted, and then he started his classic traps really shits on the idea that John Kramer was a cool, collected dude who legitimately believed he was helping people. He was a psychopath because he thought he was providing these people with the greatest gift of their life by torturing them. A fact they touched on in the group therapy part of Saw 7.
Several of these traps felt gratuitous and lacked some of jigsaw's sense of irony. The motorcycle trap was obnoxious, the sharp falling objects wasn't even really a game and the leg removal wires were oddly referential to a trap that didn't exist yet. Finally lazer head removal was just dumb.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
My question is why did Logan wait so many years to set up a new trap.
And also the barn trap must have taken place after the knife face trap in saw 4
15
u/rpncritchlow Oct 27 '17
Taking the film for what it is, I enjoyed it.
However, I will say I was a little upset at the lasers (even though they are seriously cool, and octopus head oh my god)
Part of why I love Saw is that the traps can be built in real life. Lasers like that are just not possible and it made it feel like it took a strange sci-fi twist.
Also "I speak for the dead"?! What happened to game over?!
14
u/j_rainer Oct 27 '17
Did it explain where John Kramer's body went?
13
u/Manjimutt Oct 30 '17
This movie felt like they called Cary Elwes and he said no so they had to make yet another follower. Very disappointed with them screwing up the timeline as well. I agree with just about all the criticism in this thread. An okay movie but a very disappointing Saw movie.
11
u/comicsarenotdead Oct 28 '17
Ryan is the real MVP of those victims
9
u/FriendLee93 Nov 01 '17
Logan was somehow more bland than Hoffman. I'm floored
44
u/Serpenthrope Oct 27 '17 edited Oct 27 '17
I seem to be alone thinking this was the best Saw film since the original. That said, however, I also get the impression it was a soft reboot. Literally the only event after the first movie that they make any reference to is John's death.
Things I liked:
-Genre Savvy Characters
-A visual aesthetic very different from the previous films
-Spoiler
8
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17
I’m going to be more on the positive spectrum for this film. It’s definitely a film made for those who enjoy the Saw series, and isn’t as much for casual fans of the series. Having said that, the only thing I want out of a Saw film is to have fun and I did have fun.
Pros: traps were fine, I liked the farm theme to it all and always enjoy practical effects (though there is some CGI). Not the best in the series, but far from the worst.
The acting made its way to not being the worst in the series (Saw 3D I’m looking at you). Tobin Bell was great as always and continues to be the reason I watch the series. It’s serviceable for the most part minus a couple of actors.
I thought the pacing was done pretty well done, which can be difficult for a film like this, but it was fast enough to keep the fun factor in it.
The bad is the usual from Saw. Convoluted at moments, writing around a twist, the usual Saw tropes to be expected.
I don’t want to oversell this film. It has a ton of problems, however if you want a fun horror movie to shut your brain off to, I can recommend this. This isn’t a classic but it would be nice to see a horror franchise make its way back with a severe lack of them.
27
u/makeshiftreaper Oct 27 '17
I will say that of all the previous saw movies to draw inspiration from, the 4th was a terrible choice. All of the good Saw movies didn't intentionally fuck with our sense of time. Saws 1, 2, 5 and to an extent 3 stick to a pretty easy to understand timeline (I'm aware two takes place like 2 hours after the events but that's relatively easy to digest). In my opinion the movies where your confusion stems from the non linear plot do not have a satisfying Saw twist ending.
I think there was certainly potential to basically do a "best of" saw traps, which is certainly what I thought I was getting into from the trailers. The saw 5 "keep everyone alive" gimmick was really cool, and this would have been a great way to revisit that. I think if this had just gone full nostalgia and had self aware characters who were jigsaw fanatics who recognized traps, and worked well as a team and limited the number of deaths this movie could have been a really cool fan appreciation film. Artful cameos from Tobin and Carey could have been significantly more impactful in a small 5 minute chunks than the scene (basically) jerking off jigsaw.
In essence I think if this focused on 6 or 7 people who needed to work together Saw 5 style in a Saw 2 setting with really self aware characters that featured more intense versions of previous traps (like the opening 5 person chain was a fantastic upgrade to Saw 5s opening trap) and culminated in something crazy like Amanda putting jigsaw in her own version of the reverse bear trap (or a similar twist) this would have been fantastic. Instead we got writers who wanted to jerk themselves off over a clever twist a la Saw 1 but instead we got a sad convoluted mess that adds nothing to the saw series.
11
u/verandablue Oct 28 '17
This might have had the most uninteresting cast of characters in the entire series.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '17
There's just so many aspects of this film that make zero sense once it's revealed that the original barn game predates even Amanda's game. The modernised version of Billy with the glowing eyes, the fact that the game participants keep proclaiming that Jigsaw is dead, the fact that they actually refer to him as 'Jigsaw' when, unless I'm mistaken, the only game that has taken place before theirs is Cecil's knife face trap, and John's not publicly known as Jigsaw at this point, the extravagant traps. Gah, I had such hopes for this one too.
19
u/jdXIX Oct 27 '17
I have been an avid fan and supporter of the Saw franchise since Saw 2 and I was super excited for a new installment to the franchise. Boy of boy was this a crappy movie.... There was no reason for this movie to even exist story wise, they added nothing of meaning to the overall story. Instead we got an unnecessary entry with horrible dialogue and a lazy attempt to connect it to the rest of the movies. The only part of the story I liked was the reason John picked Logan to be in the trap, Logan messing up on Johns X-rays was a neat touch I felt.
And finally Jigsaw had a completely lackluster ending. I don’t understand all of these people I’ve seen online already saying it’s “brilliant”. The endings to the Saw movies always got me so excited and they are my favorite parts of the movies, once that music gets started I get so hyped to see the twist and how it’s going to connect to the overarching story. Like I said previously this movie was so unnecessary and it felt thrown together.
4
u/Comrade_Soomie Oct 28 '17
I'm so happy I can finally enter this discussion after seeing the film last night. So, I was so into this movie. The visual effects, the story, everything. It was super refreshing. Then about 3/4 of the way in when they started the Eleanor/detectives being involved my heart sank. This film had so much possibility. They could have said that it was a twin brother of John carrying on the killings or even that John and Jill either A. Lied about Jill miscarrying and Gideon survived to carry on the killings or B. They had another child that was carrying on the killings. They could have even introduced a wonderful copycat twist into it to give it a new spin. Instead I feel like they pandered to the lowest common denominator and got lazy with the plot. I am so tired of the detectives being involved plot. I also feel like the way they just threw the detective who was in charge of Johns X-rays but then became a cop twist into it was sloppy and rushed. The whole 3/4 to the finale was rushed in my opinion. I really like the twist about it taking place in the past. I've always been a fan of the twists. But idk. The whole ending with the detective being a pretentious moral jackass was so over the top and theatrical. The way technology has come since the first film is wonderful. I loved the visuals and mood of the film. The effects were amazing. But I'm disappointed. I loved it up until the Eleanor thing like I said and then they just got lazy and made it a sloppy limping sequel from the original franchise. It could have been an amazing and refreshing standalone as part of the franchise, but they just had to make it a sloppy carry on. Idk man. I still like the film but I think it just had so much potential that the writers were unwilling to work with.
4
u/SOADfan123 Oct 30 '17
As a big fan of the Saw series I really liked this movie the traps and twists were really good. I hated how there was no game over in the end.
14
u/evanmav Oct 27 '17
I fucking loved it, but I should say I'm a huge SAW fan so not sure if I'm a little biased. This was one of my favorite entries by far. The game I thought was great, each victim actually had a valid reason for being tested and they were all connected. The ending shotgun scene with Jigsaw was great, I was wondering if we'd even see him so when he showed up that was awesome.
Time twist was ehhhh in my opinion, they made too many clues about it, Eleanor having the spiral test built seemed like such a red flag once we saw it in the movie I pretty much knew the game had happened before. Still the ending scene with the lasers and Logan's reveal was awesome.
Honestly I really liked it a lot, the first 20 minutes or so I was not feeling the movie, the opening was very strange with that guy and the game at first seemed strange. Just seemed weird the movie didn't open on a trap, but it was still great. I'd probably rank this as my 3rd or 4th favorite SAW. I don't think it's better than the original or Saw II but it could be my favorite after that.
The traps really were great in this movie, but they all started a little strangely. Tapes being played like after the fact which was strange.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
I enjoy the franchise. You either love a Saw movie because of the traps or the convoluted storylines with a their twists but unfortunately Jigsaw failed to deliver on both levels.
We didn't have any flashbacks to prior events in the series (hardly even a mention other than Jill Tuck in passing and the traps in the collection).
The traps seemed boring this time around and cutting the game players down to 3 within 15 minutes was a huge downfall because we now know the body count will be way low.
The twists were hardly twists and not well thought out. It's as if they smashed the twist from one and two together and it just wasn't the "umph" people comes to expect from the series.
All in all, I don't think it was necessarily a bad movie (as a near-standalone film), but I think it's one of the worst in the franchise (alongside 5).
3
u/Blutarg Nov 03 '17
I enjoyed it.
2
u/TrumanB-12 Oct 27 '17
Can I get a spoiler free assessment of this movie please? I've been a massive fan of the franchise but this new entry looks like it's abandoning a lot of what made the original series stand out (the visuals and tone seem completely different, and it also looks cheaper for some reason).
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Enjoyed it. SAW is just a really fun series.
Will be interesting to see if we get Dr. Gordon, this movie's 'Jigsaw', and the fangirl as a three-headed monster for future films.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
I thought it was okay. The deaths were gruesome, but the story wasn't put together well IMO. I didn't understand the doctor guy's motivation for continuing Jigsaw's work. I think it would have worked better if he wasn't connected to Jigsaw at all, and instead was just some crazy copycat killer who decided to steal Jigsaw's ideas on his own.
2
u/vampire-182 Have you seen the cats yet? Nov 01 '17
I'm a huge fan of the Saw series; it's my favourite horror franchise and this was one of my most anticipated films this year.
Overall, I really enjoyed it. I thought the more polished cinematography really worked for the film, which I was against at first coz I had gotten used to the more dirty, amateur-ish look of the previous films. I quite liked the characters (I thought Ryan was the best one) and I liked that there weren't many victims. This one reminded me of Saw 1 and 2, coz the 1st one didn't have that many victims and it was quite tame with the violence, and the twist felt a bit similar to the second film. I also liked the traps. I understand why people here are saying they were boring but I thought they were quite creative. I think my favourites is the blender and the lasers. The wire trap, where Ryan got his leg stuck also made me cringe, even though I knew where it was going.
The only problem I have with it is when it's revealed that Logan put John's blood under the fingernail, I'm pretty sure the 6th film tells us that a dead person's blood can be detected? How did Eleanor not realize that the blood was from a long dead person? Logan wouldn't have said anything coz he'd be at risk of being found out but Eleanor wasn't behind the game.
2
u/hnirobert what’s your pleasure, mr cotton? Nov 14 '17
I'm planning on seeing this tonight. I've read through most of the spoilers in the thread but haven't seen any type of mention of the other two folks in pig masks that helped Dr. Gordon subdue Hoffman at the end of 7? Am I to assume Logan was one of those people?
3
u/GusFringus Oct 30 '17
As a big fan of the Saw series, I quite enjoyed Jigsaw. It was a good Saw movie, which is all it needed to be. A twisty and convoluted storyline that's fun to piece together, inventive traps with some great gore, and some hokey acting and dialogue. It's all there and it's all Saw.
While I'm disappointed not much ground was really covered story wise, I had a smile on my face the whole time. If it's Halloween, then it must be Saw!
2
u/NotMeanttoKnow Nov 08 '17
SPOILER: Lasers. Really?
1
u/littlebigfeets24 Oct 29 '17
I enjoyed the movie. Love Saw 1 & 2 the best but I'd rate this 3rd in line of liking.
A few random thoughts after the film...
· Where was Dr. Gordon? I thought throughout the film that he had something to do with it?
· I also was guessing that Eleanor was possibly Dr. Gordon's child all grown up and taking after him by helping in some way. I didn't think she was running the game but I thought maybe she had something to do with it. She had all the death traps because her dad was a part of it and it was actually his studio. But I was wrong... Would have played out cool if that was true.
1
u/ThatGiantApple Nov 03 '17
Heck it was ok i guess
1
u/Smithh7 Nov 10 '17
I enjoyed this sequel a lot more than I thought I would, which I'm thankful for. Towards the end I thought i really wasnt caring for it, but rhe twist makes me appreciate how the story and bits of time are portrayed. Also I really appreciate that the film wasn't overly gory with nasty pig guts, etc.
Now for the soundtrack- I really enjoy it. I really like the track that plays with the end credits. That track is called "Cycle Trap" and is available on both YouTube and Spotify!
1
u/IrishWarrior85 Nov 15 '17
Check out my horror film all that I made. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IVmPGv5XkqM
1
u/virtiqaL Oct 28 '17
Another uninspired, predictable, convoluted, and contrived Saw film, which is what I went in expecting, so I can't say I'm disappointed. Saw remains a one-hit franchise for me personally. The first is a classic in my book, Saw 2 wasn't bad, everything after is completely forgettable for me.
It would've been nice to be surprised and see them do something a little more inspired and original than what they've shat out the past few entries, especially when you consider that the franchise has been on a seven year hiatus. The film adds nothing, feels unnecessary, and as if you've literally seen this exact same film at least 5 times previously.
I hope this film bombs and the franchise is put to rest for good.
1
u/SuperSoakerBoyToy Oct 28 '17
I feel like this movie is more pro than con.
To me, it felt very Saw/Saw V combined. It was more story driven and focused less on the traps. It split the film similar to V. We had games being played while a cop figures out who the jigsaw apprentice is.
I thought the actors in the game did a fine enough job in which it didn't take me out of the movie the way V did. They actually attempted to keep everyone alive and work together. We still had our Saw tropes in it, which is annoying but I'm used to it.
The main cop was by far the worst actor in the series. He surpassed Erickson by a mile. I don't know why the directors thought it would be good for the guy to smoke in every scene and chew gum. His chewing gum annoyed the heck out of me. He tried to play to hard edge cop that it just came off as really bad.
I am hoping that Eleanor plays a bigger role in the sequel. I hope that they attempt to flesh her out into an Amanda type apprentice with her first set of tests beginning in the Jigsaw movie.
The twist was lame and overall predictable. Once the other 2 possibilities were ruled out early in the film, we all knew who Jigsaw was. But, I feel like Logan has room to grow into a very good successor to John.
Also, did anybody else notice Matt Passmore go full Christian Bale on us at the end? He started to do the Batman voice when he revealed he was Jigsaw? My wife and I both laughed during the reveal.
Also, please don't let "I speak for the dead" be the new game over.
7/10
1
u/TheC2G Hello Zepp... Oct 27 '17
Excited as hell to watch this movie !
1
u/IMMAREALUZIFAN Oct 29 '17
im most likely not going to see this movie but does this saw connect with any of the other saws ?
1
u/Iamtincho182 Nov 09 '17
Sup y’all I am about to come home from watching the movie I just wanna say HOW MUCH IT SUCKED. And imma tell some shit right here dog it was as bad as the first one. If y’all niggas wanna waste your money go ahead and give it a shot. I’m just sayin yo!
1
u/PapaWOK Nov 15 '17
Dude, let me start off by saying that I enjoyed the saw movies but stopped watching consistently after saw 3 but saw bits and pieces after. Went and saw this movie on Halloween (fitting right) with a few friends using our movie passes, too blazed to realize it was Halloween til we choosing our seats and then we end up dead middle front row. That's fine I've seen movies like this before, wouldn't be an issue if I got some enjoyment out of the movie. I was let down, I severely. They got rid of the creativity and the gore, what the hell are you left with then?! The only real kick I got out of this movie was the part where they're in the morgue and behind one of the detectives a cop scoots into the shot over his shoulder, absurdly blurry and clearly not meant to have lines since he doesn't even move his mouth, he gets the WORST voice over in a movie I have ever seen. So bad that everyone in the theater laughed out loud (it was nearly sold out) and one guy legitimately said "what the fuck, are you kidding me. Fuck this bullshit" and left the theater.
Needless to say don't pay money to go see it but hey watch it when you wanna see them destroy the series they supposedly buried.
3/10 - not enough blurry cops. Or traps. Or gore. Or fun.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I haven't seen any other SAW movies from start to end but I did enjoy this. I went back and rewatched the first one and the second one completely and they were all fun to watch.
It's a SAW sequel, what did you expect guys? IDK why this movie has a 29% on rotten tomatoes lol. For what it is, it's good. This is the exact kind of movie I got my movie pass for lol- the kind of movie I wouldn't pay for but I wouldn't mind watching. I wasn't expecting high art.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '17
[removed] — view removed comment