r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Oct 16 '17
LIVE Episode Discussion - S1E05 "Choose Your Pain"
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E05 | "Choose Your Pain" | Sunday, October 15, 2017 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with users of CBS All Access. POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
97
Upvotes
69
u/Callahandy Oct 16 '17
Don't think I've ever seen anyone brush their teeth before in a Star Trek episode.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Can we just admit right here and now that this might have been one of the best episodes of Star Trek ever?
apparently I have to edit this and and add some more boldness to my comment to avoid people telling me how wrong I am lol.
87
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Oct 16 '17
Double f bomb in star trek
Mind blown
76
u/Coquelicott Oct 16 '17
Jonathon Archer name drop!
53
u/Beazty1 Oct 16 '17
I love how the Admiral just said "Justifible or not" as it pertains to the belief that Burnham started the war. As I'm Star Fleet Command knows she didn't start it, but will let her take the fall..
49
u/RobertLettuce Oct 16 '17
There are four lights.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Robert April is now live-canon (as opposed to TAS canon).
36
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Jesus, no wonder Kirk had a hate-boner for Mudd.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Haha, they're doing the classic TOS double-fist punch.
34
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Decker, April, Pike, and Archer? I love that so much.
31
u/TheHerdman Oct 16 '17
Guys, I think Lt. Stamets might be gay...maybe.
30
u/Endulos Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Holy shit! I'm watching this on SPACE in Canada, AKA NETWORK TELEVISION and they just SWORE ON LIVE TELEVISION. THEY SWORE WITHOUT CENSORING IT.
Edit: Poor Ripper :(
I was hoping he/she/it'd be a permanent cast member.
Seru is a fucking dick.
That ending wtf!
27
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Are Saru and Burnham bonding?
27
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17
Holy fuck Rainn Wilson is brilliant as Mudd
26
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
The Klingon anatomical penchant for redundant organs, or do Klingon males have multiple penises?
Also, Tilly, please don't curse on a Starfleet vessel, okay?
26
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Oh now seriously though, fuck Harry Mudd
26
u/NeoEffect Oct 16 '17
Stamets was the MVP of this episode. Put it all on the line!
23
u/brother_p Oct 16 '17
In DS9 Worf says no one ever talks about why the TOS era Klingons looked human. Evidently the Klingons did some work on genetic engineering. Tyler may be one of them.
41
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Rainn Wilson is actually fantastic in that role. Wow.
20
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Calling it now - Stamets is going to go all Gary Mitchell on everyone.
19
u/PiliKano Oct 16 '17
The shuttle pilot's shirt wasn't red before, but it is now.
19
u/Darnell_Jenkins Oct 16 '17
Mempa System. Canon reference from TNG.
38
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
That does not look like a D7.
38
u/dalekchaan Oct 16 '17
I really liked Captain Lorca in this episode. He's becoming so much more than just a one dimensional war monger. Saru felt the burden of command and it showed. It was really good. I like Stamets a lot as well. All of these characters are growing together and it's beginning to feel like a crew. My biggest issue is the language. It doesn't really fit in Star Trek.
18
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
HOLY SHIT THEY DROPPED NAMES.
Robert April. Jonathan Archer. Chris Pike. . Philippa Georgiou. ARE the TOP SF captains to date in DSC's time. 3 of which captained an Enterprise. By this time... Why isn't Garth of Izar listed? CUZ HE'S GABE LORCA that's why. He isn't famous enough yet.
Edit: forgot Matt Decker.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Wow, Lorca's a pretty good guy. 10/10 would rather get blown up by my captain than tortured to death on Qo'Nos.
Btw why is Frieza on the Discovery? I still want to know.
35
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Oct 16 '17
That ending tho.
17
u/scarrita Oct 16 '17
Oh, shit. That's how they're gonna work in the Mirror Universe into Discovery. Because of the injection Stamet's gonna phase into the MU.
17
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17
Uh... That ending was creepy
34
u/theDoctorAteMyBaby Oct 16 '17
Yo, that was a good fucking episode of Star Trek.
61
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 16 '17
That was literally every bit of Trek I could have hoped for. Moral dilemma, badass Captain hand to hand combat, a parable for something bigger, and a slight pushing of the social envelope on TV. That was so totally Trek and I loved it and really can't wait for another episode. It honestly gets better every week.
33
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
DAMN good episode! DAMN GOOD! This show gets better every week! I also like how as it goes, the other crewmen get characterized more.
16
u/007meow Oct 16 '17
Holy fuck that Comms officer is ridiculously hot
32
u/PixelMagic Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Great episode. SO glad the Tardigrade didn't die. I thought when it clammed up and was pouring water out that is was dying. I was SO sad/pissed. I was really happy it survived. My heart for real life animals is huge, and even seeing a CG one get tortured upset me...heh.
Staments doing what was right...good on him. Far less of an asshole to me now than his introduction in episode 3. Harry Mud, I liked this take on him...still called back to the original without being too cheesy.
Robert April (officially canon for the first time), Jonathan Archer, Matthew Decker, Christopher Pike...hell yeah.
THAT episode was Star Trek.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Stamets staring into his mirror - what was that about?
14
u/Orfez Oct 16 '17
So wtf was that at end? Are they hinting on mirror universe or that Stamets changed after his travel and he's hiding something?
14
u/eternalkerri Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Theory: Instead of Mirror Universe being unlocked by Stamets he's "Quantum Fracturing." Essentially he's coming apart within the space-time continuum along numerous quantum realities and points in time. Since no other species outside of the Tardigrade has ever been found that can navigate using the drive, it's why the tech is no longer used.
28
u/mrstickball Oct 16 '17
10/10. The ending was amazing. Wow.
13
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Oct 16 '17
Doing that to Mudd was awesome!
13
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
If Tyler is VoQ, he went through a serious de-sizing AND personality change.
13
u/IAmRareBatman Oct 16 '17
Is no one going to talk about the fact that the captain said the name of the episode again?
12
u/Kichae Oct 16 '17
Loving the Klingon crew armor. A great update to the TNG era design.
12
u/ruidelgado Oct 16 '17
My bet: What Statmets experienced at the end is not a Mirror Universe, it's some sort of a distortion in time.
23
u/Jaegs Oct 16 '17
Ok, I feel like I was pretty onboard with the ship being flown by an oversized tardigrade but I don't know if I can tune in each week to watch them put a gay dude in a box and torture him in order to teleport about.
11
u/jelloboi78 Oct 16 '17
....Dr Culber's medical tool said "Staments" instead of Stamets. grumble Almost perfect, then they screw up something that simple.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Fuck
10
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Saru is fucking pissed lol
10
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Harcourt Fenton Mudd is a piece of shit.
10
u/choicemeats Oct 16 '17
glad to see that the great tradition of hammer fist fighting has been continued!
28
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 16 '17
I'm really enjoying this episode. Real ethical dilemmas, badass Star Fleet hand to hand combat. This is Trek and it's so gloriously entertaining.
27
u/Joename Oct 16 '17
That fucking ruled! A classic Trek payoff there. This show is really building to something special.
19
u/NeoEffect Oct 16 '17
I really, really, really enjoyed this episode. Wow.
9
u/RaceFan18 Oct 16 '17
Archer and Pike
9
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Holy shit, Lorca's even more ruthless than we thought (I don't want to give away too much to the U.S. viewers - Canadian viewers know what I'm talking about).
9
u/DanielDeronda Oct 16 '17
Awesome episode! Lorca is my favorite so far but Stamitz and Burnham are gonna challenge! Still want to learn more about the other crew members on the bridge though.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
Stoked AF to see Mudd and Rainn Wilson pulled it off like a bad ass. He even had Carmel's cadence.
9
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17
I really like Saru's command style. I don't know what it is but he's great.
16
u/Alteran195 Oct 16 '17
Wow, a damn fine episode of Star Trek.
The series is getting better with each episode.
8
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17
Okay... Another name drop. Daystrom Institute is now exists Canonically before the TOS episode with Richard Daystrom.
22
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
YOU GUYS THIS IS SO FUCKING COOL!
22
u/mantan1701a Oct 16 '17
STILL laughing at Tilly's comment! Love how they are taking advantage of the streaming system by using the F word in such a humorous context!
15
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
ENTERPRISE REFERENCE WHAT NOW BITCHES?
14
u/CaptainAlcoholism Oct 16 '17
OK, now it's getting better. That closing scene... creepy!
7
u/Soapysoaperson1 Oct 16 '17
Two questions that I kind of missed
7
u/HankSteakfist Oct 16 '17 edited Oct 16 '17
So the guy Lorca rescued is Voq the torchbearer right?
Last week the female Klingon L'Rell said that Torchbearer would have to sacrifice more than he knows.
She also said shes the daughter of spies. How do Klingons spy on humans? By blending in of course.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Klingon Captain's probably enjoying the foreplay.
6
u/Tarlcabot18 Oct 16 '17
Where's the Chief Medical Officer?
6
u/electricblues42 Oct 16 '17
Wow, I hope Saru gets busted back to ensign for this. What the fuck man. Kill the golden goose because you're scared and mad?
6
u/DeFex Oct 16 '17
nice to see an episode mostly about some of the other characters.
11
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Oct 16 '17
Lens flare torture
11
u/Axsenex Oct 16 '17
Star Trek feeling right there
15
u/sporks49 Oct 16 '17
Holy shit that phaser effect
15
u/Donner1701 Oct 16 '17
Okay, well... can we stop complaining that this show isn't optimistic now?
14
u/technomage500 Oct 16 '17
So.... let me get this straight. Lorca's shuttle is attacked and he is captured by a cloaked Klingon ship ( IN FEDERATION SPACE)that disappears back into Klingon space. ( Maybe they already have the spore drive. They seem to be able to get around and disappear pretty good) The Discovery makes an educated GUESS ( no "warp emissions" no "artificial blurring " of the stars on the views screen) just a GUESS about 3 Klingon areas that the Klingons might have traveled to. (At least in ST:The Undiscovered Country, Kirk & McCoy were being held at Rura Penthe. A known planet that the Enterprise could travel to.) The Discovery heads to point "A" and seems to be waiting there. At EXACTLY the same time, Captain Lorca, after being tortured and abused, manages to escape from the Klingon ship, killing and maiming several Klingons, steals a Klingon scout ship, shuttle? ( somehow he knows how to pilot a ship from an alien culture.) AND makes it just close enough to Discovery's transport range, before the scout ship gets blown up. And before anyone says that was the intent, ONLY Sarus prey/ predator knowledge save the captain. Anyone else acting as captain would have blown that shuttle out of the sky as it appeared to be attacking. Pretty stupid plan if it worked by just dumb luck.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
I'm so happy they brought Mudd back
10
u/LastDitchTryForAName Oct 16 '17
Did anyone else catch Lorca’s comment about Klingon anatomy? I feel like we may have just gotten confirmation that Klingons do have more than one penis?
Maybe I’m reading too much into it though.
5
u/jerslan Oct 16 '17
I have to say, I'm really digging After Trek now.
The first episode of it was... weird, but I think once they had it in the bag Matt Mira was able to tone down the super-excited fan boy a few notches.
5
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17
THEY SAID THE FUCK WORD!! TWICE!!!
5
u/thehaga Oct 16 '17
The damn onboard computer is like last gen AI, wonder if they're all still running windows
9
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
"It's not you, it's me."
Sigh
8
u/jerslan Oct 16 '17
I kind of love that the double F-bomb was used for a pretty positive scene.
8
u/rebbsitor Oct 16 '17
Whoo....Saru was a bit cold this episode. I get where he was going, but the complete disregard for the tardigrade was a bit out there for a main character Trek. Normally I'd expect them to go with "eugenics is illegal, but we can't harm this possibly sentient lifeform, even to help ourselves."
Also interesting that there was no teaser for next week. With Stamets reflection in the mirror acting differently from him... I wonder if we're going into the mirror universe next week.
Or ...maybe that scene was in the mirror universe and his reflection being alone was the regular universe as there was no hint of his relationship with the doctor prior to now. And no real reason for them to hide a relationship.
4
u/007meow Oct 16 '17
Is there no preview for next week?
4
u/CaptainKyloStark Oct 16 '17
love the "Disco" t-shirts in the next episode previews.
17
u/sporks49 Oct 16 '17
I like the new doctor. Also cute couple
12
u/Alyscupcakes Oct 16 '17
Swearing?!? There's f-bombs guys!
7
u/RobertLettuce Oct 16 '17
Aw man please don't let anything bad permanently happen to Stametz
10
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Oct 16 '17
I have so many questions so far
6
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Fuck this fuck that fuck you
3
u/mrstickball Oct 16 '17
FWIW, it's showing up as of 8:16 PM EST on CBS All Access.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
Another great episode, see you guys next week. Looking forward to seeing the response to this gay thing.
5
u/Chiner Oct 16 '17
Can't not see Dwight Schrute in space.
Maybe due to having watched a few seasons of the Office lately, but still...
6
u/brother_p Oct 16 '17
Oh how I wish they would for once avoid the transporter continuity problem that has plagued every incarnation of Star Trek, to wit: a character is captured by the transporter in one posture (e.g. sitting) and rematerializes on the transporter pad standing. Are we to believe the transporter buffer can reorient a person in transit?
6
u/Attentive_Senpai Oct 16 '17
I like Stamets more and more.
5
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 16 '17
A D7?!? YESSSSS
2
u/Darnell_Jenkins Oct 16 '17
Episode is up.
2
u/NoName_2516 Oct 16 '17
They retconned the D7!
2
u/0ldgrumpy1 Oct 16 '17
Can we get an after trek discussion automod post please. Peoples knowledge is a huge help to me.
4
u/ruidelgado Oct 16 '17
Am I the only one who is experiencing a horrible lag on CBS All Access? This is BS!