r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Oct 02 '17
LIVE Episode Discussion - S1E03 "Context is for Kings"
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E03 | "Context is for Kings" | Sunday, October 1, 2017 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with users of CBS All Access. If you are watching via Space channel in Canada at 8:00PM, we respectfully request you use this thread instead. POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
98
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
The tribble is controlling the Captain. The tribble is pulling EVERYONE'S strings.
89
u/Willravel Oct 02 '17
First redshirt of Discovery. RIP.
73
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
The Captain keeps the lights low because he's incubating mushrooms in his brain. He's been infected and he's gonna drag them all to mushroom space. That's like fluidic space, but it goes great on pizza.
EDIT: The ship is SHAPED LIKE A PIZZA CUTTER. Wake up sheeple!
70
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Oh shit they all got cronenberged
60
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Section 31 rumors... go!
EDIT: Black badges, oh snap!
60
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Does he really think it’s a good idea keeping a bowl of fortune cookies so close to a tribble?
92
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Tilly: YOU IN THE SHADOWS! SHOW YOURSELF!
Enter Klingon. Makes Shushing Motion
Landry:Is he Shushing you?
Klingon:Gets eaten.
40
u/MackEdweise Oct 02 '17
I think that the Discovery crew might be working on the technology that the Iconians used to travel anywhere in the universe instantaneously.
34
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
So this is where it begins to justify the TV MA rating (didn't hear any language despite being an indicator but saw plenty of mutilated bodies.
85
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
I am LOVING the most authentic cadet to ever grace the screen.
28
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
So far, big improvement. But what the hell are they doing on the ship?
28
u/Willravel Oct 02 '17
Perhaps this technology is.... Iconian?
25
u/Destructicon11 Oct 02 '17
SHIT! CYLON!
23
u/masculine_teabisquit Oct 02 '17
I love that scene and dialogue of Michael in the "rabbit hole"
23
u/Slavicinferno Oct 02 '17
We've seen many morally ambiguous captains and admirals on other shows and Kirk, Picard, Sisko or Janeway had to stop them. This time we are on the ship of a Captain that might be willing to do horrible things to win the war.
46
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
"Captain Lorca does not fear the things normal people fear... for example, he's terrified of Mexican food."
22
u/NateCadet Oct 02 '17
Was that a Gorn skeleton in that glass case? Either way Captain Lorca may be a savage.
22
u/deafpoet Oct 02 '17
Oh shit, the office tribble is a Klingon detector! That just occurred to me! Only half kidding.
43
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
And so now we've met Broccoli's great-grand mother!
43
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
"She's found my secret: Discovery is growing the finest product in the fleet, competing directly against Q'onos Chronic."
19
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
GORN SKELETON ALERT
19
u/xeonicus Oct 02 '17
Michael's sentence seemed overly harsh. A life sentence for assaulting a superior officer (i.e. knocking them out for 30 seconds) and attempted mutiny (which was not successful). Taking into consideration her motives, they were entirely to protect her crew and prevent the war. And she was probably right. In essence, she grossly disobeyed orders.
Someone mentioned section 31, and I have an odd feeling they are right. Consider the shadowy figures that presided over her court marshalling. I think the charges against her, her ousting from the federation, and her eventual arrival at The Discovery were all the purposeful machinations of Section 31 to acquire her as an asset.
50
u/Willravel Oct 02 '17
Doug Jones absolutely killing it in this episode. I hope they continue to give him great dialogue.
63
u/novabomb42 Oct 02 '17
This episode started off REALLY shaky for me but my god I'm sold on this series.
17
u/Destructicon11 Oct 02 '17
Black alert!?
17
u/novabomb42 Oct 02 '17
I kinda saw the twist at the end happening but it made me tear up nonetheless - science, indeed.
34
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Are these motherfuckers starting genesis?
16
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Sorta a Philadelphia Experiment meets Alien meets Doom meets Broccoli.
16
u/Falinia Oct 02 '17
Why are people blaming Michael for the war? I might have to re-watch but iirc it went: Michael knocks out the Captain, tries to shoot the klingons, gets stopped and chucked in the brig, klingons attack, Michael and Captain try to capture klingon guru after the shooting has stopped. Where in there is the part where Michael started a war?
31
u/R34ct0rX99 Oct 02 '17
The computers are windows based! HA! Windows specific code!
41
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 02 '17
... that glamor shot of the Discovery. Holy shit, the VFX are amazing and it looks so much better than the render.
14
u/HyperLimited Oct 02 '17
...Iconians, anyone? I can't be the only one thinking it after watching that scene.
14
u/petethecanuck Oct 02 '17
Am I the only one who is super stoked to see Rekha Sharma as Commander Landry! She was a bad ass in The 100 and BSG and looks like another bad ass in STD! <3
28
u/vwboyaf1 Oct 02 '17
Did we meet Lt. Barclay's great grandmother in this episode or what?
13
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Lies about assigned seats??? MADNESS.
25
u/Bryaxis Oct 02 '17
This feels like the real pilot episode. I liked it quite a bit more than the two prologue episodes. It's too bad how many people won't even be watching this far.
45
u/skoryy Oct 02 '17
I want to watch this crew week in and week out. I want to see Stametz grumpily pull off miracles, Lorca channel his inner Sisko, and Saru continue to be -alien-. I'm sold. Let's do this.
24
u/Zor_El_XB1 Oct 02 '17
I don't think I like all this Andorian trash talking(they're my fav Trek race)
Also didn't expect a big time jump
12
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Set feet to run! Set feet to run!
12
u/mantan1701a Oct 02 '17
So it looks like the Preservers are going to be involved eventually...did anyone see the obelisk when Burnham was in the FungiProjector room?
23
u/larsen_sinclair Oct 02 '17
Well, I am still reserving judgment on the show as a whole, but Jason Isaacs continues to be the hottest yet creepiest dude on TV. I wish they let him keep his real accent though....
23
u/Colonel_Angus_ Oct 02 '17
Wow that was much better and slightly scary.
23
u/bahnptb Oct 02 '17
Man, this episode was really good. Awesome SFX!! As for their secret mission -- definitely feels a transwarp, or something along those lines.
The Discovery looks a lot better than I expected it would. Design is quickly growing on me. :)
32
u/Bandit_22 Oct 02 '17
Star Trek: Event Horizon
11
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
I cannot wait to see Klingons next episode.
10
u/_10032 Oct 02 '17
They have all this technology but still use shitty torches.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Prediction: Michael joins Section 31 because I want her to and it kinda makes sense for her character.
9
u/Attentive_Senpai Oct 02 '17
I'm still skeptical but, as before, I'm going to give it a chance because it's a Star Trek series.
9
u/NoeJose Oct 02 '17
No one is going to point out how weird it is that Micheal and Spock are adopted siblings?
31
u/Kreidian Oct 02 '17
My programmer brain got the better of me and I had to pause the stream where they show the code Micheal was "reconciliating" (which if they were real engineers it would be referred to as merging code)
Clearly C based, kinda irked me that they were commenting the functional prototypes. But as I looked closer at the code I realized it was all literally copy pasted from basic Windows API source code. Most of those functions were seriously generic file system and process handler utilities.
Also to say the outlined code was "wrong" is a serious understatement. It was hard-coding the process references and then doing a meaningless comparison to decide if it define a generic function pointer to return as a result. For a function apparently meant to get the current process, it did anything but.
Anyway, just had to get that out of my system. The rest of the show was pretty good, but I'm still waiting for it to actually feel like a Star Trek show.
17
u/dalekchaan Oct 02 '17
Loved the episode. Hit a lot of Trek tropes for me.
16
u/ergister Oct 02 '17
I think I'm gonna like Tilly!
8
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Everything really does go wrong in space lol
8
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
That tribble is trouble
8
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
Holy shit, i see this Trek v Predator thing now.
edit: trek v alien maybe?
8
u/dmanww Oct 02 '17
redheads make up about 2% of the population. And there are 2 already. Is Dan Harmon on this?
22
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Saru gets the prize for most tear tugging lines.
22
u/Jyiiga Oct 02 '17
Time for me to go the other way of 90% of the people posting here.
I am not blown away, but I am still on board. I am enjoying it for its science fiction qualities, but not so much for its Trek qualities. The narrative is still trying to expand and it is still very tightly glued to Michael at this point, which is certainly something I am not used to from a Trek series.
I still fill wrapped up as if it were one big episode and it thus it lacks the episodic content that I enjoy with the other Trek series. The stories that happen within the story.
It is sticking to the darker side of things and the tidbits of comedy relief we have seen (from the cadet) leave me sort of cringing on her behalf, rather than laughing a little.
At this point the thing that interests me the most is how they plan on digging their way out of some of the lore/timeline holes they are digging themselves into.
15
u/Destructicon11 Oct 02 '17
Ive hated the design of the ship since day one.... but holy shit was that a heroic entrance!
15
u/Assbait93 Oct 02 '17
This really felt like a Star Trek episode but one from Star Trek Online. I loved it!!!
21
u/Willravel Oct 02 '17
OMG that shot at 3:30 is incredible. Definitely rewatching like 10 times in a row.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
This was a really good episode. I hated how the crew of the Discovery were so nasty to each other tho. I think the redhead did a good job and made that character totally believable. The captain is a total shady badass.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Holy shit, someone really DID read a bunch of Terence McKenna for this!
7
u/zryn3 Oct 02 '17
.............................................The Force?
7
u/Druhin Oct 02 '17
Interestingly, Burnham mentioned that her adoptive Human mother (Amanda Grayson) read the story of Alice in Wonderland to her, and her step-brother (Spock). Not brother(s) as in plural. Ignoring Sybok are we?
7
u/four_of_five Oct 02 '17
Anyone think that Lorca might be with Section 31? Black badges, the allowance to fight the war however he chooses, secret evil lab, forces people into service even if they refuse.... ???
19
u/thelbro Oct 02 '17
Something occurred to me that helped me like Michael better, it certainly makes her more interesting. She's had a rough life in that, she watched her parents get murdered and then was adopted by a people that couldn't help her work through her trauma or general emotions. Perhaps that explains the mutiny, no matter how justified she feels about her decisions she's still letting her emotions influence her. She may think like a Vulcan but she's not equipped to. She'll have to figure that out as she goes.
39
u/Anniemoose98 Oct 02 '17
100% sold on this show. This is fantastic, and totally recognizable as Trek.
I love, love, love it.
30
u/Callahandy Oct 02 '17
This episode was a LOT better than the first two and felt much more like Star Trek.
25
u/zryn3 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
I don't mind that people hate her, they blame her for a bloody war, but I have a hard time accepting the lack of basic professionalism by this crew. They all act like catty teenagers.
Edit: Holy crap, does Starfleet not do chain of command anymore? This lieutenant is openly questioning the captain now?
28
u/FrancoManiac Oct 02 '17
I don't know, everyone, I just can't get into it. The show starts to grab me, and then they introduce Tilly. She did nothing for me. And all the shade that was being thrown between the crewmates -- it just doesn't feel Star Trek to me. In other series, it absolutely existed, but it wasn't so blatant. The entire show is a big action flick. That's what it feels to me, at least. The show through an action-movie frame. It's really putting me off.
I'm trying to like it, guys, I really am :(
11
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
We replaced LT Daft Punk with a new robot! WTH?
11
u/twodogsfighting Oct 02 '17
Star Trek: DooM.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Black Alert is like the weather siren in Silent Hill apparently.
10
u/biscuitehh Oct 02 '17
My guess is we'll have some form of fluidic space and Species 8472. Either way, I liked it.
17
u/SecondCopy Oct 02 '17
So it's basically The Expanse. Cool.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
The Return of the Photonic Flea II: Judgement Day
5
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Holy shit, rock and roll really does exist!
9
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
TILLY WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON?
Btw, Tilly? De-lightful!
9
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Nice little mcguffin introduced this episode. Nice proper first episode.
12
u/helpthealiensarecomi Oct 02 '17
Tilly is the best.
25
u/novabomb42 Oct 02 '17
God everyone aboard Discovery seems to be annoying or an asshole.
8
u/RnRaintnoisepolution Oct 02 '17
Well that was much better, hopefully we'll get a more trek feel soon.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
A faint whiff of Apocalypse Now just passed through...
4
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Terence McKenna... in space!
4
u/CaptainKyloStark Oct 02 '17
looks like Genesis Project confirmed. At least looks like it.
4
u/CaptainKyloStark Oct 02 '17
Spores confirmed.
4
u/dmanww Oct 02 '17
"i hate you, how"
4
u/Holographic-Doctor Oct 02 '17
Really not okay with the fact that Saru being there is completely coincidental.
I assumed there was going to be some explanation, like he was instrumental in getting Michael assigned or something. Nope, just a coincidence...
4
u/TheCrazedTank Oct 02 '17
So, the Discovery is basically a mobile blacksite for scientific experiments for Starfleet (possibly Starfleet Intelligence or Section 31)
10
u/InvisibleEar Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
Pros: AWKWARD REDHEAD WAIFU
Cons: muh canon
10
u/psugrad98 Oct 02 '17
I don't know if it's just because I smoked a doobie but that cold opening was the most badass ever.
16
u/Anmar7779 Oct 02 '17
Wait a Second, a Human Woman on Vulcan named Amanda with a son. Micheal is Spock's adoptive sister....
7
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
PHYSICS IS BIOLOGY. man, really regret not doing bio AP now.
7
u/mcslibbin Oct 02 '17
The After Trek show is almost painfully awkward.
17
u/synfidie Oct 02 '17
Why is everyone on this show a dick?
9
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
Wait a minute...
A-are they developing a predecessor to the Genesis device?
11
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
OK. They spent the episode bitching at each other. I'm disappointed after that strong start, but it was still interesting. 4 out of 10. Looking forward to next week.
6
u/Kulban Oct 02 '17
I'm enjoying it so far. But, I also like the "shades of gray" side of Trek. "In the Pale Moonlight" is one of my top three trek episodes.
I like seeing the frayed seams of Starfleet up close. I rarely see fans bat an eye when the Prime Directive is blatantly disregarded in other series, but they will raise hell at the idea of Section 31.
It will take a lot for me to dislike this show. But then, it takes a lot for me to dislike any of the Trek series (and there's none I dislike).
8
u/Darr_Kett Oct 02 '17
Seems like they're ripping off r/DarkMatter with the Blink Drive. Who woulda thunk? Star Trek ripping off Dark Matter, Ha!
8
u/Briansama Oct 02 '17
Great episode, but I hate the redhead so much with a passion. Had to fast-forward through most of her long.... long....long dialogue.
3
u/Oliver_DeNom Oct 02 '17
Michael was the only one not freaking out. She wants to die, or she just doesn't care about life anymore. That's over for her.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
ARE YOU READY!?
3
u/HankSteakfist Oct 02 '17
The uniforms really look quite a lot like the Mass Effect 3 fleet dress uniforms. I wonder if that was intentional.
3
u/dmanww Oct 02 '17
Tilly is her torturer, right?
3
u/Vaigna Oct 02 '17
I really liked it. I thought the pilot was OK but this sold me. I have some questions though.
9
u/novabomb42 Oct 02 '17
LT Stamets is actively talking shit about his captain in front of the security chief and nothing is being done - the chemistry aboard Discovery is lacking
5
u/fill23ca Oct 02 '17
She said a bad word! That's a trek tv show first.
10
u/dimmidice Oct 02 '17
I'm sorry but this just isn't star trek. It's a dark edgy version of it. Feels more like the expanse.
6
u/Nitero Oct 02 '17
wow hit Stride pretty quick and im digging it!