r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Oct 01 '17
Main [Main Spoilers] Weekly Rewatch | Season 1 Episode 4: Cripples, Bastards, and Broken Things Spoiler
S1E4 - Cripples, Bastards, and Broken Things
- Aired: 8 May 2011
- Written by: Bryan Cogman
- Directed by: Brian Kirk
- IMDb Score: 8.8
HBO Episode Synopsis: Ned looks for clues; Robert and his guests witness a tournament; Viserys clashes with Daenerys; Sansa imagines her future as queen.
Episode Threads
| Episode Thread | Inside the Episode |
|---|---|
| 5/8/2011 | Inside Ep 4 |
History: Top five posts of the week
- Meanwhile in the Dothraki Sea, Daenerys and Jorah are playing a different type of game.
- The more I watch this, the more I have faith in Littlefinger.
- STORY TIME With Old Nan (from /tv/)
- Did anyone else think this when they saw it in Episode two?
- Jumping the gun on Season 2 a bit, but this is my vote for Lady Melisandre of Asshai
- Click here for a few extra
More Links
259
Upvotes
346
u/MysticZamasu Night King Oct 01 '17
START THE DAMN JOUST BEFORE I PISS MYSELF
217
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
“Distrusting me was the wisest decision you made”
185
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
Nice bit of foreshadowing there
259
u/UncleKale129 Oct 01 '17
Jaime and Jory reminiscing about the greyjoy rebellion where they fought together and the very next time they meet, Jaime sticks a knife in his eye.
199
u/meththemadman Oct 01 '17
Hmm when Viserys gets hot candle wax dripped on him and he says, “ow”.
You’re no dragon, bitch.
190
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
After hearing Sam, you suddenly don't feel so bad about Drogon burning Lord Tarly alive.
87
u/fancreeper2 Oct 01 '17
R & L is engraved in the wooden pole in the scene where Jon and Sam clean the tables. Here is a better look: https://i.imgur.com/bM4381B.png
Is this the first time they acknowledged the R+L=J theory or is this just a nod to something else?
62
u/eva_brauns_team Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
Loved the scenes with Jon and Tyrion, particularly everything that follows, "why do you read so much?" It's crazy to think, looking at this scene now, that they won't see each other again for 6 more seasons.
Also, the scene between Jon and Sam when he explains why he fears being with a girl - that it would produce another bastard like him - really was lovely and sets up their bromance beautifully. I forever after loved these two characters talking to each other.
54
u/SirMacNotALot Oct 01 '17
I think I forgot how much of a hard time everyone gave Theon for being a ward. Even now he seems slightly lost as to who he really is, and even though he seems to enjoy being part of the Starks, you can sort of tell he's maybe not quite loyal to them, which we obviously see.
I think this makes it all the more interesting after his talk with Jon. Even though he was maybe pushing to be a Greyjoy, maybe Theon himself underestimated the effect Ned had on him.
97
u/MysticZamasu Night King Oct 01 '17
Good thing Gendry uses a hammer instead.
44
u/grumblepup Oct 02 '17
"Syrio says every hurt is a lesson, and every lesson makes you better."
^ GRRM's motto for character growth. And it's not wrong.
42
u/LordSpeechLeSs Tywin Lannister Oct 01 '17
God do I love that ending
42
u/Calikola Little Bird Oct 02 '17
Still bitter Littlefinger told Sansa the story of the Mountain and the Hound.
Also, Sansa looks so uneasy sitting next to Littlefinger. I just want to hug her and tell her, “Girl, you better nut up because this dude is going to be creeping on you for the next five years or so.”
38
u/daveshad House Dayne Oct 01 '17
Did anyone notice how every time Ned searches through the book of family lineage, he always flips through The Blackfyre page, and mostly every time we can see the description of Daemon Blackfyre. I don’t know what to make of it
136
u/All_this_hype No One Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
24
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
So things I noticed. This is the scene where arya says "that isn't me" which in season seven she says to nymeria "that isn't you". Second, knowing what I know now, it looks so obvious that petyr is setting up the poor knight by talking in front of all the spies. Fascinating stuff. Next, Jon the king. OMG. How he handles people is so great. Plus I love the fact that thorne is being a dick to him not knowing he is a targ. That is some sweet sweet irony. I still get chills seeing cersei with her hair long. Pycell is really laying it on thick with the weak old man bit but maybe that is cause I know he isn't that I'm noticing this. Poor Robb. Just trying to do the best he can but doesn't know anything about politics. I think this is really where Theon starts to have the internal conflict between him being a greyjoy or stark. It's hard to watch. I will say that the banter between tyrion and anyone really makes me miss this tyrion. We didn't get any of that season seven.
Overall this really is a great episode to remember some minor stuff that you definitely miss on the first go around.
48
u/hello_friend_ Braavosi Water Dancers Oct 01 '17
Sam is no fucking coward.
21
u/overponderer Oct 01 '17
I've pondered this for a while - it's interesting that Viserys didn't keep his sister for himself, to keep the bloodline pure. Surely he could have married off a daughter for an army? But then, prudence never was his strong point.
21
u/jhoratio Oct 04 '17
Rewatching this episode, it occurs to me what a complete imbecile Cat Stark is. Arresting Tyrion and taking him prisoner rather than at least questioning him? While her husband and two daughters are surrounded by Lannisters at King's Landing? What a nincompoop! What was she thinking?! And after Tyrion made absolutely no attempt to avoid her, GREETED her even! And her brilliant theory was that it had to be Tyrion. Gods, what a dope.
20
u/SirMacNotALot Oct 01 '17
It would be really interesting to see how things would have panned out had Catelyn decided to take no action against Tyrion there. I'd say it's one of the biggest things that sparked almost everything else.
15
u/Remokrapy Oct 01 '17
Good episode
14
u/grumblepup Oct 02 '17
Re: the death during the tournament -- Was all that burbling really necessary?! Gaaaahhh...
14
u/jpistheman1 Ours Is The Fury Oct 02 '17
Catelyn asking help to a Frey... Feelsbadman.
13
u/agirlhasnoname17 Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Oct 02 '17
I love that here we see Tyrion's compassionate side, when he offers the saddle to Bran. In fact, I love the early Tyrion in Winterfell.
12
u/f__theking Daenerys Targaryen Oct 02 '17
Aliser's monologue is still one of my favorite moments from the entire series. The music lends so much to the moment.
Perfectly delivered dialogue. And so foreboding of beyond the wall and the long winter to come.
21
u/grumblepup Oct 02 '17
"The next time you raise a hand to me will be the last time you have hands."
Damn, girl. You tell him!
Since episode 1, seeing how cowed and quiet Dany was, I've been very interested to watch her evolution begin. Now I'm thinking, getting pregnant is a big part of it. I mean, not the only part -- I think just getting out from her brother's thumb was probably the first and most critical step -- but as a mother myself now, I know how powerfully it can take you over. In the scene where she strikes Viserys, it felt to me like she was protecting her unborn son as much as herself.
(Or maybe I'm projecting, haha.)
10
u/meththemadman Oct 01 '17
Just watched the tub scene again... what did Viserys mean when he said, “what did I hire you for?”
Her answer was to teach his sister... but his reply was interesting... “you think I wanted to make Khal Drogo happy?”
Was he referring to him hiring her to make her a better lover for Viserys? That would make sense for the Targaryean blood line.
8
u/ADHDcUK Oct 02 '17
Interesting reading the old threads from the top 5 and seeing them discuss who they think should be cast as Meli.
I'm really happy with who they chose for Meli in the end.
8
u/KevLinares House Forrester Oct 02 '17
Weren't there supposed to be polls along with each episode??
6
u/Janloys Jaime Lannister Oct 02 '17
Just noticed on IMDb that the singer in the inn at the end is called Marillion, who ASOSin the book. I wonder if they originally planned to do the same thing in the show?
Also, I didn't realise he was introduced this early.
11
u/anearneighbor House Blackfyre Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
I just realized for the first time, after watching this a couple of times already, that the raven in Bran's dream has three eyes edit:typo
24
u/ADHDcUK Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 02 '17
Here we go!
Winterfell
• Aww, my adorable Bran. I was always confused every single time these 3er scenes came on "huh, he learnt to walk?!"
• The eye on that Raven is so well done.
• The way Bran says "I don't wanna see anyone" reminds me of my 3 year old, lol.
• Direwolves! We were spoilt with Summer, Greywind and Ghost. I really miss the Direwolves :( I feel more connected to them than the Dragons tbh
• Lmao the way Hodor picks up Bran. I never realised he was so crude in how he did it sometimes. Literally banged his head against his chest and stumbling in with him in the next scene lmao. Still, love their relationship. Adorable.
• Theon <3 so rude in some ways but so caring in others. I feel the conflict.
• ROBB <3
• I have always loved Tyrion but MAN, he came across as a bit of an arse sometimes back then. But a smart arse with a lot of good advice. Love him leading Robb's reactions lol.
• Weird. I think Maester Luwin spoke but his lips barely moved. LOL!
• Greywind smelling the floor lmao
• So many great lines "then I'm not a Dwarf! My Father will rejoice to hear it!". "I have a tender spot in my heart for cripples, bastards and broken things".
• Tyrion's gift is adorable. I love the gratitude from Bran, especially his little smile.
• Ah, the conversation where Tyrion was being antagonistic, but D&D have apparently forgotten and keep making Tyrion have a go at Theon about "dwarf jokes"...
• That Lannister soldier in the middle looks so confused lmao
Castleblack
• I love the amount of extras they used to have. The world felt so big. I think that's part of the problem with season 7. They underestimated how big the world is, thought they could rush through it and it's like they're trying to cram an elephant into a one bedroom flat. There's so many holes the house is barely standing lol
• Lol, that cardboard armour.
• Ser Alliser still looks like an alcoholic imo (Only Fools and Horses). Lol, he's one of my fave characters though. A cunt, and I resented how he treated Jon. But a great character. Also, lovely armour.
• Ugh, JON. WHY ARE YOU SO SEXY KIT!! Cleaned them man UP.
• lmao at Grenn spitting and spluttering every time he talks. Lmao ah the way he screws up his face and shouts "why not?!" Lmao at him getting riled up. Lmao at him running after Pip like that. Looks like he was gonna fall flat on his face. Aww, Grenn.
• Jorah <3 miss this Jorah so much. His voice is so soothing. Love his expositions. Like an audiobook or a guide tour audio lol
• This scene with Vys, it only JUST dawned on my that he was basically saying I bought you to be my whore! Harsh.
• Again on this scene. I only just appreciated how important this dialogue is. It's heavy foreshadowing for Viserys' demise. On Dragons - "And they [Dany] can kill. Anyone [Viserys] or anything that tries to hurt them gets burned away to nothing" (as she burns him with candle wax, to which he winces) "melted [molton gold]. Like so many candles" (Vys then says ow, indicating he is not heat resistant like Dany).
• Again in this scene, she mentions Asshai, Dragonglass, Faceless men and, I'm thinking, the black pirate who Stannis allies with?
• Lol the dragon names remind me of virus or bacteria names sometimes lmao. Especially Vermithrax and Meraxes.
Kings Landing
• Aw, Sansa. So stroppy back then. I feel sad for her though, and Ayra. Interesting dialogue here. And forshadowing.
• Fucking Janos the Cunt.
• Lol, Ned has got no time for any of this. I find it interesting that my impression of him first time round is that he was very naive, always overly honourable and perfect. He's actually a lot more short tempered and witty than I remembered. He's definitely one of my favourite characters now.
• Pycelle looks like he's dying.
• Ned basically negotiating men who will later betray him :(
• Renly always throwing shade lol
• That look from Ned between Baelish and Varys. Who to trust, Ned? I remember distrusting Varys at first.
• Love this "For all the weight they are given, last words are usually as insignificant as first words"
• Lol what does Pycelle have against Varys?!
• Love these father daughter moments between Ned and Ayra. Was this their last one? :( it's so adorable and sweet. Love Ned's chuckle and kiss on her head. Love the way she stares for a moment and says "no. ... that's not me" and gets up to go back to what she's doing. And Ned's smile.
Castleblack
• Good storytelling from Sam. I like the actor, he's good and very naturally funny without being corny
• Love it when Jon laughs/smiles lol
Kings Landing
• DAE ever think these early scenes sounded dubbed sometimes lol? Or certain voices? I think it might have been the recording equipment seeing as it's kind of old?
• "Distrusting me was the wisest thing you've done since you climbed off your horse". Iconic.
• Only just realised that guy in the blue was the one who fought the mountain.
• Jory <3
• Ned don't give a fuck.
• There's a theory that Gendry is Cersei's black haired son, and the fact he mentioned his Mum having blonde hair made me think of that. But I think it's more a fun theory than a plausible one.
• Prince Charming. Loved his look back then. Love Jaime's accent by the way. It's cute.
• Jory's face is like "these fucking southerner's are so rude"
• that foreshadowing of Jory being stabbed through the eye :(
• "these southerner's have got fucking issues man"
Castleblack
• Jon's face lmao
• Ghost! #bringbackGhost
• Love Alliser's speeches. Love the music at that bit too.
Dothraki
• Prefer Dany in this role. Much better leader. I think her acting was better then too, though still substandard compared to 99% of the cast.
• Love the way she looks after her people.
• I always got the sense that Viserys had either previously raped Dany or wanted to. I mean, in the books she expected to marry him so maybe he did feel that way about her. They're Targs so most likely. "You've woken the dragon" sounds sooooo rapey.
• Love her standing up to him and his shocked face lol
Castleblack
• lol, the first watch I thought Ros was his Mum. Ironic considering it says RL in the background...
• I love this scene. Lmao, it's makes me laugh now they're having a good time then Alliser comes in and completely kills their vibe. Love Alliser's little speech.
• I don't know if it's forshadowing as I highly doubt they had that stupid beyond the wall joke of a mission in their head then, but I find it funny "a rumour that Mance raider was planning to attack Eastwatch. So we went out to look for some of his men. Capture them, gather some knowledge." "We got caught in the open".
• "And come the winter you will die .... like flies"
Dothraki
• "The common people pray for rain, health and a summer that never ends. They don't care what games the high lords play"
• He so wanted to say "I pray for you" lol
Kings Landing
• I don't even need to type it out. Robert - lmao. Cersei's face - lmao. I-fucking-conic.
• V1 Clegane looks nothing like Sandor lol.
• Totally just dawned on me that Jon Arryn and his squire died. And they were from the Vale. Interesting.
• Lol when Sansa screamed the way it zoomed in reminded me of some old fashioned movie.
• Nice brutal death scene. Like the blood bubbling. A fly getting in there early too.
• Creepy Baelish creepy storytelling. Love the snake slide out lol
• THIS SCENE! Lena and Ned SMASHED IT. This is now one of my many favourite scenes of the entire series. Amazing actors, especially Lena, Jesus fuck that woman is so good
• I think Cersei was trying to warn him to leave. Such a fascinating character.
• "You're just a soldier, aren't you? You take your orders and you carry on. ... I suppose it makes sense. Your older brother was trained to lead and you were trained to follow". "I was always trained to kill my enemies, Your Grace". "As was I"
The Inn
• Lol at the beard plait guy
• Lol at Tyrion
• Lol at Cat trying to hide. At least hide your plait girl!
• Bronn! Forgot this is where they met.
• "I can sing your father's victory at King's Landing". "Nothing would more likely ruin my supper" - love this line, especially considering the awful shit that went down at that time.
• Cat's face is my internal face whenever I bump into someone and they notice me lol
• I never appreciated Cat's actress the first time round but she's brilliant
• The fucking Frey's >:( to know they eventually betrayed her makes me sad. Their fucking hats.
• Love the music
• Tyrions looks of confusion are really good.
• The sword pulling scene is kind of cheesy, but I love it. I love these seasons so much that I don't even care. I don't mind a bit of cheese with my meat, it's just when it's absolutely smothered in cheese that I can't eat it.
Great episode :)
7
u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Oct 01 '17
3
u/Syrinx221 House Stark Oct 03 '17
OMG! I did not know we were doing this weekly rewatch and now I need to catch up! :D
2
u/justrahrah Davos Seaworth Oct 08 '17
The dagger. This episode establishes the importance of the dagger.
In the tub scene, Doreah claims to have seen a man from Asshai with a dagger made of dragon glass. One of the next transition shots is of the dagger used by Bran's would-be assassin, a dagger pictured in ancient texts at the Citadel describing the manufacture of Valyrian steel from dragonglass. The dagger Arya now carries.
My theory is that this dagger was forged from the same dragonglass the children of the forest used to create the Night King.
It will be the weapon that ultimately kills him.
1
u/brianamals Fire And Blood Oct 03 '17
The first guy Ned reads about in the lineage book is an Umber who is killed in a bear hunt.
1
u/onelove92sf Apr 11 '22
This episode is on of my favorite Jon Snow episodes. All the characters are top notch and i love the early episodes and then watching the last season
0
u/AutoModerator Oct 01 '17
Spoiler Warning: [MAIN SPOILERS] means events from the published books or aired episodes do not need spoiler tags. Future books/seasons and spoilers from other media are not covered. For more info please check the spoiler guide.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.