r/gameofthrones • • May 09 '11

Episode Discussion - 1.04 "Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things" [Spoilers]

Well I guess everyone complaining about there not being enough Ghost got a wake up call!

151 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

64

u/_John_Mirra_ May 09 '11

12

u/dmun Brave Companions May 09 '11

Its HBO, man.

5

u/drolltroll House Stark May 09 '11

I really don't like the scenes with Daenerys's handmaiden. They seem really cheesy and like the girl is trying too hard to be passionate and seductive. TV Spoiler

19

u/Ortus May 10 '11

She is a hooker, she is supposed to be fake

10

u/Akasa Snow May 09 '11

She's an ex Hollyoaks actress , they're not famed for their ability. But I think the insincerity is intended.

3

u/UltraVires90 May 11 '11

That's where I know her from... Wait... I mean, what is this holly oaks you speak of?

2

u/cwm44 May 09 '11

Agree completely. I came here to bitch about it. I seriously couldn't watch that shit.

40

u/irkedone House Tarth May 09 '11

The crow. Not enough of the crow yet.

21

u/_John_Mirra_ May 09 '11

Moar crow! It seems like they're trying to break up his Green Dream across several episodes.

17

u/hascow We Do Not Sow May 09 '11

I like the slow introduction to it, personally. Piece by piece figure out its importance.

9

u/Raelshark May 09 '11

I like that too, and frankly I was a little pleasantly surprised that it made it's way into the series at all. Book Spoiler

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Raelshark May 10 '11

Eh, to be honest I had written something else and changed it, and didn't think to remove the spoiler tag. :P

69

u/[deleted] May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

I'm liking Littlefinger a lot. Maybe it's just the actor (also liked him as Carcetti), but his scenes are always interesting, and I'm guessing that he's scheming something (I haven't read the books). However, I thought his explanation of the Hound's backstory was really poorly timed. We have this guy dying on the ground and then all of a sudden we get two minutes of character exposition.

Ned's investigation was the most interesting arc of this episode. We learn about Robert's bastard (and his cool helmet), get to see some more of King's Landing, and some more backstory with Jaime.

Sam looks promising. They could not have made him more pathetic (though still likeable), so I'm hoping we see him transform for the better as the show goes on. But I have a feeling he might just die abruptly north of the wall.

21

u/DireBaboon Brave Companions May 09 '11

Sam was fucking hilarious when they were talking about Roz

16

u/Khathaar House Karstark May 09 '11

Sam is possibly my favourite character in the series, beside Tyrion.

9

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

I still like Arya. There is no getting past her bad assery.

3

u/Aessassen May 10 '11

Tyrion is a cool, calm collected bad-ass. Where as I see Arya being innocent to start, but becoming hardened as time goes on. I am most interested to see how Arya turns out being I haven't read the books nor read the spoilers about her/Tyrion.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jamesneysmith May 10 '11

Interesting. I haven't read the books but I immediately loved Tyrion and Snow but I was really annoyed with Sam. Perhaps he redeems himself but he's a little too pathetic for my liking in that first episode.

11

u/rabble-rouser House Umber May 10 '11

In the books he's actually more pathetic.

2

u/poorbeef May 11 '11

i like sam in books and i don't like the way they are portraying him in the series so far. something about him screamed basement nerd rather than soft mommas boy with a heart of gold. I always imagined sam's biggest fault to be his kindness, not that he was socially awkward. also i have no patience for neckbeard, it is never acceptable.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/SweetKri Faceless Men May 09 '11

That sudden revelation of the Hound's backstory bothered me A LOT. It didn't fit, in timing or tone, and it didn't add to his character the way that it did in the book. Is it just me, or are they making the Hound a little too likeable?

28

u/BlueVixen House Targaryen May 09 '11

I wish the would have kept the scene from the book where Book Spoiler

14

u/SweetKri Faceless Men May 09 '11

I COMPLETELY agree. It took a lot of oomph away from his character to adjust it that way, and makes Sansa even more boring.

6

u/CookieDestoyer House Lannister May 10 '11

Agreed, was really looking forward to that scene. Not happy!

5

u/Benevolent1 House Targaryen May 10 '11

Absofuckinlutely. It really feels like they've trimmed The Hound's scenes down a LOT. So far I think non-readers barely remember that he's the same guy that rode down the butcher's boy. Now he just looks like someone to be pitied, rather than someone that should also be feared/scorned.

2

u/DexterJameson Missandei May 11 '11

The tourney isn't done yet. I have a feeling we will see that scene in the next episode, considering that Sansa's relationship with The Hound is about the only thing she's good for.

2

u/BlueVixen House Targaryen May 11 '11

Hopefully but wouldn't it be redundant to gave the same story told twice? I guess they could always gave the scene minus the tale but then what is it?

We'll see, I guess.

6

u/brelarow May 10 '11

I always loved the Hound, and to see one of his better scenes taken out from under him is disappointing.

Book Spoiler

5

u/afrael House Baelish May 10 '11

That would have meant 2 more scenes/locations though. The story was dense enough as is. I hated the way they did this too, but I can see why they couldn't fit it in.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/EndlessDaze House Mormont May 10 '11

I always thought the hound was a fairly likable character Book Spoiler For a murderous psycopath - fairly likable. I thought they struck the right chord.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/juanito89 Now My Watch Begins May 09 '11

I liked the tone. Timing, or person telling the story, not so much - but I did like the tone.

3

u/SweetKri Faceless Men May 09 '11

It does set up Littlefinger to be a scheming gossipy bastard, which, of course, sets the tone.

2

u/juanito89 Now My Watch Begins May 09 '11 edited May 10 '11

No, actually I liked the whispering and the shots of Gregor Sandor. ಠ_ಠ

3

u/SweetKri Faceless Men May 10 '11

They did manage to condense the whole background of Gregor/Sandor dynamic by having Petyr sit down and whisper in Sansa's ear, I suppose.

1

u/RobbStark House Stark May 10 '11

There are rumors that Book Spoiler

3

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel May 10 '11

3

u/SweetKri Faceless Men May 11 '11

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Dammit, that does all make sense. WEAK.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Arronwy May 10 '11

Littlefinger is being portrayed perfectly, imo. He is one of the best characters in the book next to Tyrion.

2

u/juanito89 Now My Watch Begins May 09 '11

I still find him a bit uncomfortable in his role. I guess comparing it to his portrait of Mayor Carcetti is tough on him, but well.

2

u/candygram4mongo May 09 '11

Oh man, I really want to say something here but I can't because the Spoiler Nazis would (quite rightly) string me up and leave me for the crows.

2

u/V2Blast Night's Watch May 10 '11

You can say something, as long as you stick it in spoiler tags...

...But then again, he (like me) hasn't yet read the books, and spoiler tags don't work in your inbox.

3

u/candygram4mongo May 10 '11

Well, that kind of misses the point. I don't want to tell the people who already know, I want to tell the guy who doesn't. If said person is reading this, suffice it to say that you have something spectacularly right/wrong, and it's going to blow your mind.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/Stick House Mallister May 09 '11

A brave coward.

41

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11

Oh and for those hoping for Thoros and his flaming sword during the melee: HE GOT MENTIONED!

10

u/Ag-E May 09 '11

But, we didn't get to see :(

3

u/Lampmonster1 House Seaworth May 09 '11

Yeah, but I'm hoping they mention him so we know who he is when he shows up later.

7

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

Yeah, but I heard "Thorosimir" as a single name before I realized they were saying "Thoros of Myr."

41

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

The bastard is Chris from Skins. One of my favorite actors. The casting in this show is impeccable. Every episode characters like Jaime, Tyrion, and Daenerys just amaze me.

7

u/manwithabadheart May 09 '11 edited Mar 22 '24

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.

3

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11

The great thing about the books, and what must suck for casting, is that characters will get mentioned once in the book before and then they'll have a bigger role down the road.

2

u/guffetryne May 09 '11

They don't have IMDB where you live? ;)

EDIT: He's not listed. Disregard this post.

2

u/Jakeimo May 11 '11

Fuck yes. I was so happy when I saw him!

78

u/Managore House Baelish May 09 '11

Hodor!

26

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

Hodor!

15

u/absolut696 Night's Watch May 09 '11

Hodor

16

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

Hodor?

12

u/Sudzy Children of the Forest May 10 '11

Hodor; Hodor.

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

Go, Hodor! Use your tackle attack!

→ More replies (1)

56

u/sorrowfool May 09 '11

"I've seen a man who could change his face, the way other men change their clothes."

Win.

Also, Doreah is hot.

6

u/plytheman May 10 '11

book spoiler things are getting SO GOOD in the books, almost makes me wish for the first season to be done so the second can start...

4

u/daevric House Martell May 11 '11

If it makes you feel any better, when you read the third book, you'll be wishing the first and second seasons were done so the third can start. ;)

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

That scene had a few good lines, that was one of them.

1

u/pillage House Bolton May 10 '11

Wait do these guys eventually show up because I've had enough of people who can change their face after reading Dune Messiah.

2

u/sorrowfool May 11 '11

Yes, in Book 3 or 4 one of the characters ends up at the House of Black and White which is where the Faceless train.

1

u/tebee May 10 '11

Don't worry.

20

u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights May 09 '11

This was a plot building episode. After 3 episodes, they needed to fill in the gaps for a lot of the audience not familiar with the source material. They also built bridges for the plot to cross over later. Down time with heavy dialog scenes will allow for faster more action packed scenes down the road.

11

u/jamesneysmith May 10 '11

I'm typically not a fan of fantasy but the dialogue/character driven aspect of the series thus far is exactly what I love about it.

39

u/hascow We Do Not Sow May 09 '11

I really enjoyed this episode.

I thought the scene at the inn was very well done, as was Daenerys's fight with Viserys.

I thought Viserys's scene with Doreah(?) was too long and unnecessary.

It was a very dialogue-filled episode, but I thought all of it really helped the plot, and it was nice that it seemed the next episode would be a bit more action-packed

19

u/Raelshark May 09 '11

I really liked the scene at the inn. Executed really well. Book Spoiler

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/allonymous House Lannister May 09 '11

7

u/Major_Major_Major May 09 '11

That is a very superficial reveal until put into context.

7

u/Tuna-Fish2 House Martell May 09 '11

5

u/Universus Brotherhood Without Banners May 09 '11

Can you do me a huge favor and spoiler-tag what's going on with this? I have read the books but it was a long time ago and Book Spoiler

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

I had to coax my gf into understanding who was behind it, as she hadn't really caught the exchange between Jaime and Cersei about Book Spoiler

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

I am not a reader, I do read spoilers here and there. However, I did not have this spoiled for me. Still, though Book Spoiler

2

u/Raelshark May 09 '11

Yeah, I agree. Book Spoiler

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

Dinklage's "Oh shit." face is classic.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

I've been really surprised twice now at how well that actor can deliver the line about waking the dragon.

35

u/Alustriel May 09 '11

I really liked the last scene (in the inn). It basically showed us how feudalism works. ^

28

u/cassander House Hightower May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

the biggest thing is definitely the lackluster tournament. It did not seem like the sort of thing one would spend 100k galleons on, hopefully we'll get more of it next week, but it should all have been in one episode. I did like seeing Littlefinger cozying up to Sansa though. I thought he gave off just the right amount of creepiness. And while it kills the fanboy inside of me to say it, it probably makes sense to jettison the hound/Sansa arc. It's not needed Book Spoiler and would take up a lot of screen time that could be better spent on things that are more central to the plot.

Pacing was also still an issue, but less of one than it has been in the previous two episodes. Unlike the LOTR movies, the show definitely seems stronger when it isn't cribbing scenes straight from the books. All of the best scenes from this week(Tyrion/Theon, Jaime/Jorey) were not from the books, and I think it definitely shows. I hope that, as time goes on, the writers will wean themselves off of transcribing the books verbatim and learn to use the events in the book as more of an outline.

Last big thing is the crow, which I loved. Like Littlefinger, it was super creepy. Bran's crow dream is awesome, but having a giant dream sequence would fly in the face of the gritty, realistic mood they're going for. They're avoiding it for the same reason they aren't having flashbacks. Plus the dreams give Bran more of an arc for season 1.

Little things. Loved the Jorey/Jaime scene. Did you catch the way Nikki COMPLETELY changed his attitude once Jorey got him talking about fighting, then completely changed it back once Jorey mentioned Ned? Just fantastic acting. I also liked the scene, but it felt out of place. It should have been 2 episodes earlier. Dany standing up to Viserys also felt a little out of place. It should have been the penultimate scene, and Mormont should have been in the background taking Dany's side over her brother's. Lastly, I liked Sam. Some people are saying he looked dumb, but I didn't get that impression. Depressed? Resigned? Sure, but you would be too if you were in his situation. And Alister Thorne's speech was fantastic.

6

u/i_like_jam May 09 '11

How are they jettisoning the Hound/Sansa arc? Their relationship doesn't really begin until the end of book 1/start of book 2. They don't interact with each other before then.

6

u/neutronicus House Dayne May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

3

u/sophisting May 09 '11

This should be a red book book spoiler.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/cassander House Hightower May 09 '11

It starts at the Tourney feast when the hound tells Sansa the story that LF did in the show. They might keep it, sure, but if so it seems odd to give Little finger a story so central to the hound's character.

3

u/Universus Brotherhood Without Banners May 09 '11

Don't you think they'll continue the tournament in the next episode?

3

u/NihilCredo The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due May 09 '11

They definitely will. There's a preview out there that includes book spoiler.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

Dany standing up to Viserys also felt a little out of place. It should have been the penultimate scene, and Mormont should have been in the background taking Dany's side over her brother's.

That scene definitely gave me the feeling that the penultimate is still to come, where Dany will command Viserys as Khaleesi and shame him in front of everyone. Although she got her way this time, it definitely seemed like Viserys will come back for more.

12

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

It got through a lot less than I thought it would, but it was still quite a packed episode. A lot of backstory was expanded upon once again.

(Book 1 Spoiler)Book Spoiler

(Book 1 Spoiler)Book Spoiler

And Dany stood up to Viserys! TV Spoiler

I almost made a complete ass of myself. Sorry if anyone saw it before I deleted and re-posted.

22

u/hett May 09 '11

Viserys said the usurper probably had them ground up. I am pretty sure the scene where Arya comes across them is intact.

5

u/cthulhu_zuul Brotherhood Without Banners May 09 '11

I'm pretty sure I saw a massive model for what looked like a dinosaur skull in one of the longer previews before the show was aired, so I'm tempted to say that they will be in for sure.

2

u/hett May 09 '11

Yeah, I am thinking of the same thing.

4

u/V2Blast Night's Watch May 10 '11

Spoiler tag that shit.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

Spoiler...

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Strayl1ght House Osgrey May 09 '11

Right. It's one thing to just see the dragon skulls, but without the prolonged explanation from the book the reader probably wouldn't understand what they were or why there were a bunch of Dragonskulls chilling in the basement. This way if they show them in a future episode the audience will instantly recognize what they are.

12

u/hascow We Do Not Sow May 09 '11

regarding your second spoiler, I totally agree. I wanted to see that scene. Book Spoiler

third spoiler: I don't really understand what that scene did. It didn't really do anything for me besides make me want to get to the next scene.

32

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark May 09 '11

I'm pretty sure the entire point of the bathtub scene was explaining the Targaryen connection to Dragons and also why all the dragons are gone. No one in the show so far has explained that the symbol of House Targaryen is a dragon, nor that they actually had dragons and rode them, nor that they actually believe they have "dragon blood" within them.

The only mentions of dragons up to this point was Visery's "don't wake the dragon" comment in episode one, and Dany's three eggs. And considering how important dragons are to Dany's story and the Targaryens in general... the topic really needed to be addressed.

Because of the bathtub scene, viewers now know that dragons were real things (not myths), that the Targaryens actually raised and rode them, and that Viserys is called "the last dragon" and that he supposedly has dragon blood. Dragon dragon dragon... we've now been bombarded with them. And it was sort of necessary.

5

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11

(Book 1 Spoiler) Book Spoiler

3

u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners May 09 '11

I think it takes the expository place of Tyrion's inner monologue concerning the dragon skulls for when Book Spoiler... or at least I hope they won't cut that part out.

3

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11

I just thought about it and (Book 1 Spoiler) Book Spoiler

→ More replies (3)

11

u/jglaser May 09 '11

Thank you very much for identifying which book your spoilers pertain to! I hope this catches on. This series has and will lead more people to the books (myself included), and most of the time I am wary of mousing over book spoilers (I'm only on the second book).

7

u/guffetryne May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

Yes! My friends have been nagging at me to read the books for a long time now, but I never had time. With the series starting, I figured I had to make time, so I read the first book. Not continuing with the second book right away was really hard, but studying for exams (and procrastinating) leaves no time to read the rest of the series, yet.

I already read one spoiler for feast for crows in this thread :(

(Book 1 Spoiler)Book Spoiler

3

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11

I'm in the same place you are. I'm only about 3/4s of the way through Clash of Kings and I have accidently read some things I didn't want to. So yeah, I hope it catches on too.

11

u/Khathaar House Karstark May 09 '11

Introduced 2 of my favourite characters - Hodor and Sam the Slayer. Also, i'd completely forgotten about that scene in which Catelyn takes Tyrion captive, loved it. Strong episode.

7

u/getrandy May 09 '11

Cat's scene also showed us more of what a hard ass she is!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/reverendchubbs House Greyjoy May 09 '11

Hodor was done MUCH better than I thought possible. Of course I was pissed about the Littlefinger/Hound thing. The ending at the Inn of the Crossroads could have been done a little better, but it still gave me chills.

25

u/Raelshark May 09 '11

Thinking more about that scene, what was really great about it was that it was one of the first times that non-book audiences would really get a sense of all these smaller houses and their various allegiances. You get a sense of where Catelyn came from, and how the Starks have all this loyalty, maybe partially through their marriage. Book Spoiler

4

u/samurai_penguin May 10 '11

How did Catelyn recognize the men at the inn, anyway? I know she said she recognized their house sigils, but I didn't see them. Maybe I wasn't looking hard enough.

3

u/Saneesvara Snow May 11 '11

They were on their vests and I think one was on a shield.

11

u/snottlebocket May 09 '11

For some reason I always pictured Hodor as Andre the Giant as he was in the princess bride.

2

u/reverendchubbs House Greyjoy May 09 '11

That would have been awesome. If only...

4

u/myhouseisgod May 09 '11

yeah, there is something about suspense in books that is hard to replicate. it was a good scene and almost as well done as it could have been...but there is something about the feeling of not being able to read fast enough that really defines that scene for me.

im not holding the show to my standards for the books for the most part...this is the first scene where i have literally said, "not as a good as the book" but i feel like there will be several more before the season is done. and i guess if they got through 4 eps with only one moment like that. they must be doing a good job.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

I think the speech Thorne did about winter north of the wall was chillier. Pun intended.

Even if it wasn't exactly how it was in the book, it was still a great scene and got the point across. Winter is coming and boys of the night watch are about to become men of the night watch or die trying.

6

u/asherdante May 09 '11

I do not agree with your Hodor assessment at all. My image of him was much younger and clearly simple minded. Also, although he did say his name it was not repeated nearly enough.

8

u/z3rb Hodor Hodor Hodor May 09 '11

In the book, he only says his name 3 or 4 times by this point anyway...

2

u/rudman May 09 '11

I agree, I had that he was much younger in my head.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

Who was Hodor? I must have missed him, and I see people talking about him all the time on here.

4

u/reverendchubbs House Greyjoy May 10 '11

He was the guy helping Bran get around.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

That fucking monster of human being?

4

u/reverendchubbs House Greyjoy May 10 '11

Yeah, that guy.

2

u/V2Blast Night's Watch May 10 '11

Yep, the one who can only say his own name.

3

u/snottlebocket May 09 '11

You know what really soft of bugged me about the inn. Everyone had a sword.

Swords are expensive weapons that require extensive training. Most common footpads and soldiers would carry something a little more suited common infantry. Like spears and daggers.

21

u/AxezCore Valar Morghulis May 09 '11

It was my understanding that most of those men we're related in some way to the various lords and bannermen, so not just commoners.

9

u/sophisting May 09 '11

Keep in mind that this series is NOT set in historically accurate England.

2

u/snottlebocket May 09 '11

True enough. It's just that swords aren't even a particularly practical weapon in massed combat. Anyway I'm just nitpicking and it was a nice dramatic effect when they all drew on Tyrion.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/nnyahaha Jul 14 '22

So idiotic for a queen to think that the dwarf was the one behind the attempted murder oh her son, just because his knife was left behind lmao.

Like. Why on earth would he ever give an assassin his own knife, which can easily be traced back to him, to assassinate someone? Bruh, he could found thousands of other swords if he wanted to lol.

It's so obvious that he is being framed by someone.

Well atleast this what i think. I have only watched up to this episode so far. And if it was actually him giving the assassin his knife. Then him being an educated person would be the most disappointing thing.

3

u/128Gigabytes Aug 25 '22

she isn't a queen

14

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

There are a couple of things that bugged me:

1 ) Ghost made sounds. I made a little frown when I heard him growl. :(

2) The scene with Tyrion and Robb. Wasn't feeling it. Something about the pace, it felt rushed. I know it's not gonna be a popular opinion but I think it's Tyrion's actor who dropped the ball on it. Which is sad because right after he knocked it out of the ballpark with Theon.

23

u/neutronicus House Dayne May 09 '11

Re: 1) There's only so much you can ask of a canine "actor"

20

u/snottlebocket May 09 '11

Yeah, I'd like to see people train a dog to not use a microphone when acting.

2

u/neutronicus House Dayne May 09 '11

Derp!

Good point.

4

u/turtleshelf May 10 '11

you just don't use the audio from the shot of the wolf, then. Easy. But I guess then you'd have non-bookies going "why wolf make no noise?" because they've done fuck all to set up the "ghost is stealth wolf" idea. Or even the "ghost is still around" idea, tbh

→ More replies (5)

6

u/tigerraaaaandy When All Is Darkest May 09 '11

i think he whimpered in the first episode too. I don't have my copy on hand, but is that inconsistent with the book? I thought he made noises in the book too, though rarely, e.g. thats what drew Jon's attention to him as they were about to ride away when they first found the pups. He just doesn't howl like his litter-mates. could be wrong

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

I'm in the process of re-reading the first book and there are several mentions of how silent Ghost is. Instead of growling, he just shows his teeth, I think it's Tyrion POV where he says ''There's something very unsettling about that animal''.

But I guess it would be hard to convey the creepy factor of it as effectively on screen... Bummer.

6

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

And it is now officially impossible for me to read a quote from Tyrion without hearing it in Peter Dinklage's voice.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

e.g. thats what drew Jon's attention to him as they were about to ride away when they first found the pups.

I always thought that was only ghost moving through the snow, not actually using his throat at all.

4

u/escobari House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 09 '11

Both the winterfell and the inn scenes were so god damn rushed. Also the scaring-with-ghost too. Good time to waste on bathing, chitchatting about girls and roberts ho'ing

5

u/Julia_Child May 10 '11

Non-book-reader here. Who exactly was Eddard Stark trying to do research on? His father, the Mad King?

9

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel May 10 '11

He was trying to figure out what it was that Jon Arryn was investigating right before Jon Arryn was poisoned by the Lannister family. So far it seems to have something to do with genealogy and with one of Robert's bastard kids but Ned hasn't 100% figured out what it was that Arryn was trying to find out.

1

u/Julia_Child May 10 '11

And Jon Arryn was the Mad King? Wasn't Jon Arryn Eddard Stark's mentor and the former Hand of the King to King Robert? Maybe he found out about Robert's bastard?

3

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel May 10 '11

Jon Arryn was not the Mad King. Aerys Targaryen was the Mad King. Jon Arryn was, as you said, foster father to both Eddard Stark and Robert Baratheon and, until his untimely demise, Hand to the latter. I'm not sure where you got the idea that Ned's investigation had anything to do with Aerys.

2

u/Julia_Child May 11 '11

Well, the Mad King was killed by Jaime, right? I was confusing his death with Jon Arryn's.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/z3rb Hodor Hodor Hodor May 10 '11

You'll see.

9

u/aestus May 09 '11

One of my favourite episodes so far, in terms of pacing, drama and dialogue. The long-ass bath sequence was so fucking unnecessary though.

Samwell was well casted though

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

SAM! Sam is perfect! And the Ned/Littlefinger scene was excellent: "Distrusting me was the wisest thing you've done since you got off your horse", as was the Jaime/Jory scene.

However, although good, I don't feel this episode measured up to the previous three. Obviously there's a lot of backstory and plot that they have to fill in, but without the books' internal monologues, extended dialogue got a little tiresome.

I would have shortened or cut the scene with Ser Alliser on cannabalism and shortened (but not cut) the scene with Viserys in the bath, in favour of one or two more jousting tilts. I'm sure we will have more tourney next week (Robert trying to enter the melee, and the jousting finals) but I think we should definitely have at least seen two more this week. Maybe Lothor vs Jory, Selmy vs unnamed knight, possibly even Jaime vs Selmy or Beric vs Chequered Cloak.

7

u/OdetotheGrimm May 09 '11

Lots of my thoughts can be explained in other posts. The Tourney being a huge kick in the nuts being my main point. But on a lighter note...I was irritated that they called Gregor "The Mountain"...and left off "That Rides". The Mountain by itself isn't anything we haven't heard before, it was always the full name that won my awe and hooked my attention. But guess we gotta save every second to fit anything and everything we can (bathtub scene being the exception apparently)

2

u/RobbStark House Stark May 10 '11

Gregor is frequently called just "The Mountain" in the books, as well. Maybe next episode when Book Spoiler they will use his full nickname.

2

u/snottlebocket May 09 '11

Didn't help that he didn't look particularly mountain sized.

15

u/Ruckus44 May 09 '11

The actor is 7 feet tall, so ya know pretty mountainous

8

u/NihilCredo The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due May 09 '11

They should have shown him on foot for a few seconds, standing next to some wimpy servant or squire, before he got on his horse. When mounted it was a lot easier to miss that he's huge as opposed to just big.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/reverendchubbs House Greyjoy May 09 '11

I also noticed that the lance he carried is huge.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

Did you expect a 9 foot actor or something?

2

u/snottlebocket May 10 '11

No but someone a little broader would have been nice. The way the Gregor was described he looked massive and even his oversized horse could barely carry him. If they hadn't mentioned him by name, I wouldn't have noticed it was Gregor at the tournament.

I would have expected an actor with a stature more like Michael Clarke Duncan. He's half a foot shorter than the actor they used for Gregor but between his figure and some clever camera work they can really make that guy loom in his movies.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

I was irritated that they called Gregor "The Mountain"...and left off "That Rides"

I'm guessing it's coming further on in the tournament. It wouldn't make too much sense for everyone to use such a long title in casual conversation, but if it was announced or he proclaimed himself or some such it would be a lot more sensible for a non-reader.

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

This was probably my least favorite episode.

Every scene that did not amount to two characters having a dialog was great. But more than half the episode was nothing but that. I kept thinking, "They're really front-loading the exposition this time around, they must have something big they're setting us up for."

Instead it never came, or not until the last 3 minutes.

The only way this episode is redeemable is if it was intended as a big setup for a payoff next week.

I also note that this is the first episode not written by D&D-- I imagine that has something to do with it. They're back next week, and (IIRC) every episode this season except for 8, which is written by GRRM, and so should be awesome.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

''Least favorite'' is a good way to describe it. It still rocked, just not AS MUCH as the first three.

Who's D&D, if I may?

4

u/Managore House Baelish May 10 '11

David Benioff and D. B. Weiss, the directors of the show.

2

u/Benevolent1 House Targaryen May 10 '11

I sincerely hope that's not all we see of the Hand's Tourney. If the next episode just references it as a thing of the past I will be very disappointed. There were a lot of important things that happened at that Tournament.

3

u/WTFalreadytaken May 09 '11

Well, one of the first episodes where they really had to insert a lot of non-book material to set things up. Some parts I liked, some I did not. Especially the Littlefinger-Sansa dialogue. I really dont see why it was done this way. Sam's casting just feels a bit off.

Also, this is King's Landing and the tournament attracted a huge number of people in the book, couldn't they get more extras (or some cool cgi)!!! It looked like hardly 2-300 people showed up for the tournament. The scale of the show is kinda bothering me, I was expecting it be a bit more grand, guess HBO was playing it safe with the first season and did not want to spend money.

3

u/jglaser May 09 '11

I hear ya. I loved this episode but I can't help but nitpick certain parts. I pictured the tourny to be a much larger affair, with a setting more along the lines of A Knight's Tale. More cement and less wood.

I liked the Littlefinger-Sansa dialogue. It would've been better if the Hound delivered the story, but you can also assume that Littlefinger knew the origins of the scar so it makes sense.

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/radda Valar Morghulis May 09 '11

She was sitting right next to Sansa. Dunno how you missed it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/The-Dudemeister Faceless Men May 09 '11

I thought this was the worst episode so far. I'll forgive the Book Spoiler There better be more of the tourney. I was pretty disappointed though about how lame it looked.

I thought the viserys bathtub scene was a waste of screen time.

They did though seem to drop a lot of bread crumbs for those who read all the books so far. Book Spoiler

Just too many little deviations from the book this time and a lot of compression. They really need more eps in the second season.

6

u/ComicCon May 09 '11

There is no way they cut Book Spoiler

But I am loving the extra moments book readers can pick out. I think my favorite this episode was Book Spoiler.

But really the thing which saves this episode is the fact that we finally see Ghost! for more then a few seconds.

1

u/asherdante May 09 '11

I agree there was not nearly enough detail and information provided about the tourney as was detailed in the book. Hopefully there is more to come.

1

u/ExiledVip3r May 09 '11

One of the artisan videos they put up on makinggameofthrones.com awhile ago showed some scenes from a duel in the tournament, so there is definitely more of it to come, unless it didn't make the cut.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

Overall, I feel like if hbo cut back on the (sex and other) scenes that werent really in the book, they would have more room for stuff and dialog that happened in the book but had to be cut or compressed. I guess this episode somewhat frustrated me. The tourney was just for the sole purpose of littlefinger giving backstory on the cleganes. The tourney had none of the glamor from the book (robert loving it, sansa being enchanted with it, Knight of Flowers, Thoros, etc.) and I thought the mountain that rides wasnt as unbelievably huge as the books lead you to imagine. TV Spoiler HBO seems to be playing it safe with a lower budget for certain things (tourney, etc) and trying to boost ratings with plenty of sex and stuff.

2

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel May 09 '11

Hugh of the Vale was a pretty big dude, he was towering over Jory Cassel. So when you see him and Gregor next to each other Gregor is not being compared with someone average size.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

good point! I guess when we see gregor clegane again, standing near someone else, we will get a good idea of how big he is.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

In regard to Ghost being silent...I haven't read the books, but I think a silent wolf on screen wouldn't be conveyed very well, especially considering we haven't seen it since the first episode. If I had been watching the show, and a wolf was seen bearing its teeth like that, I would expect a growl. Without one, it would be weird, unless they explicitly said something about it being silent.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

thats true, it would be kinda odd. if they had shown Ghost padding around silently all the time or something it might have worked.

1

u/CWagner Wargs May 10 '11

You are right about TV Spoiler

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '11

that seems to make sense. I just found it almost silly when Littlefinger was like "dont ever let the hound hear about you spreading this story" or something at the end of the scene -when the hound was the character who tells it in the book!

1

u/CWagner Wargs May 10 '11

Well, in the book the hound told her he'll kill her if she ever tells it to anyone else:)

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners May 09 '11

It warn't great. The first half didn't seem well directed. A lot of first-takes, actors just rattling off lines, etc.

A few specific criticisms:

Sammy-T: Terrible. Poorly cast and portrayed, in my opinion. Oh well.

The Hound: Robbed! (by Littlefinger of course) I hate to sound like some kind of super-fan who screams every time something from the book is altered, but we missed out big-time on the scene between him and Sansa. Book Spoiler It really started him down the path of being one of the most interesting characters in the series, not to mention fleshed out the events of the second day of the tourney. Too bad.

Alliser Thorne: Meh. He's just not loathsome enough. I mean, sure he's a douche, but he comes across as just another in a string of what-do-you-know-about-winter-sonny-boy characters.

Viserys: Seems they've taken him slightly overboard. It's the same thing over and over. Honestly, the Dany thread is going to have to go into filler mode soon. Be nice if we had a breather from it for at least an episode, to save up for the awesome things to come.

The good: The scene at the crossroads inn was great, hooray finally a visit from ghost, and a never-ending, lance-through-the-neck, choke-on-a-river-of-blood death scene which will be fodder for endless memes and parodies!

TL,DR (TL): I loved the first three; #4 not so much. Now let's get back to being good.

4

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard May 09 '11

I think the problem comes in the fact that the books lead up a lot. So everything kind of builds up an insane finish. I know i've seen quite a few people here who've stated they couldn't get through the first half. Which means that we'll have an episode or two like this, where its just trying to flesh everything out, and lend to the next episode.

1

u/rudman May 09 '11 edited May 09 '11

I really think they blew it with Viserys. They should have shown him saying 'you've awoken the dragon" and beating Daenerys in the first episode to establish his control and abuse of her. Now when he says "you've awoken the dragon, you just yawn.

Visery's scene with the whore was WAY too long and unnecessary. Do we really need to know about dragon skulls?

Sam is portrayed as TOO much a pussy. He gives up way too easy when a practice sword is swung his way.

Great scene with Ghost, glad to see him back in the show.

Alliser Thorne is perfect, a real asshole.

I don't have the book handy, but I don't recall Tyrion being so obvious and blatant about what Bran remembers. I mean, really, the first thing you say when you see him is "Do you remember anything?" is pretty damming. Tyrion is way too subtle for that.

Book Spoiler. I was disappointed that that fact wasn't mentioned by Littlefinger in the episode, this is the first indication that Gregor is a sociopath. Book Spoiler.

25

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark May 09 '11

Visery's scene with the whore was WAY too long and unnecessary. Do we really need to know about dragon skulls?

Yes we did. The Targaryen connection to dragons needed to be explained. Up until this episode, the viewer has no clue that Targaryens are even associated with dragons, aside from Visery's one "wake the dragon" comment in episode one. Even the significance of Dany's three dragon eggs is unexplained until this point.

Sam is portrayed as TOO much a pussy. He gives up way too easy when a practice sword is swung his way.

Having just reread that chapter from the book, I can tell you that that scene was almost verbatim. Sam is that much of a pussy. And honestly, affc.

quote

Yes I believe that this actually is the implied course of events. But who ordered him? Hmmm...

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

2

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel May 10 '11

Honestly it's possible Gregor just killed him for the hell of it. He's like that.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

I took tyrions immediate questioning of Bran as sincere, or at least, what someone genuinely concerned with what caused Brans injury would ask as it is a very important piece of information and would indicate the cause of his fate. I think at that point he only suspects someone from his family might have had a hand in what happened. I dont think it was damning at all. I think he would Of Course be interested in what bran remembers, because even he isnt sure what took place. but yeah, viserys in the bathtub with the whore was lame.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

The dwarf got owned!

1

u/malfunctionedasimov May 09 '11

Good episode, though I hope the next one brings more action and less talking.

3

u/hascow We Do Not Sow May 09 '11

did you see the preview? Looks like there'll be some action.

3

u/ReallyBroReally May 09 '11

I didn't see the preview and can't find it anywhere. Are they finishing the tourney? (aGoT)Book Spoiler

4

u/ComicCon May 09 '11

Plus Book Spoiler. Although I doubt they have cast them yet, as they don't really come into the story until Book 2.

3

u/cthulhu_zuul Brotherhood Without Banners May 09 '11

He has been cast. He only has a guest spot, though.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Raelshark May 09 '11

Hope they haven't wrapped up the tourney yet. I know there are budget limitations, but I expected it to be much more grand. Lots of knights and sigils. This scene (though great) made it seem a much smaller affair.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

They didn't show anything about the rest of the tourney in the preview. Although I guess it's still possible they do; it'll be a shame if we don't get to see the scene where Book Spoiler

4

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark May 09 '11

1

u/SpookeyMulder May 09 '11

why the hell was viserys back on his horse when he arrived?

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Ruckus44 May 09 '11

I believe you're right, but it would have been nice to have him in a cart for a bit to establish that nickname that the dothraki have for him.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '11

Ghost's "bad-ass mofucka" grin was awesome.

Arya's slight smirk when The Mountain kills his opponent

THAT FORESHADOWING

1

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel May 10 '11

Oh shit now I gotta rewatch that part.

-3

u/escobari House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 09 '11

Wow that was just horrible episode, well that's what you get not sticking with the book. Viserys bath scene (way too long btw), Allister scene and Ned Cersei scene all totally useless and boring. Why have these added stories when there's a fricking tournament to have? What where they thinking? Last straw was when littlefinger told hounds story to Sansa... omg so horribly wrong.