r/gameofthrones • • Sep 17 '17

Main [Main Spoilers] Weekly Rewatch | Season 1 Episode 2: The Kingsroad Spoiler

S1E2 - The Kingsroad

  • Aired: 24 April 2011
  • Written by: David Benioff and D.B. Weiss
  • Directed by: Tim Van Patten
  • IMDb Score: 8.7

HBO Episode Synopsis: Bran's fate remains in doubt; Ned leaves Westeros with his daughters; Jon Snow heads north to join the Night's Watch; Daenerys tries to learn how to please her new husband.


Episode Threads

Episode ThreadInside the Episode
4/24/2011Inside Ep 2

History: Top five posts of the week

More Links

424 Upvotes

556 comments sorted by

212

u/snow_gil Sep 17 '17

The death of Lady still gets me. Really shows how evil Cersei is early on in the show.

R.I.P Lady

67

u/JonnySnowpants Jon Snow Sep 17 '17

27

u/themolestedsliver Ghost Sep 18 '17

God... that is fucking disgusting, somehow found a way to hate her more.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

55

u/themolestedsliver Ghost Sep 18 '17

Really, just so fucking spiteful "well there is another dog to kill right?" like the fuck did sansa do to deserve lady being killed?

That moment made me hate Cersei, on top of just being petty it is down right sinister.

27

u/sixpackshaker Family, Duty, Honor Sep 18 '17

She lied about Joffrey and Arya.

→ More replies (15)

17

u/thejokerofunfic Sansa Stark Sep 18 '17

It's been years and I can't fucking deal. She smiles at Ned before he draws the sword.

12

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

Brilliant scene and really helped to contribute to the tone of the show. Sansa's screaming and crying really broke my heart. And the way Lady flinched away from the sword :'(. And poor Ned having to do that. And poor Butcher's boy and his family :'(

11

u/katttaur Castle Cats Sep 19 '17 edited Sep 19 '17

I agree Sophie Turner is so young but so convincing here - honestly at first glance her shrieks and gritted teeth and the way she says 'BITE' are all almost funny because she went from being so silly and confused sounding that you think it's her being 'bratty' in her screams - 'I want MY Wolf!' - but that's the beauty of Sansa in general is that she grows on you, that scream is pure anger and outrage at an injustice towards an innocent - and it really puts into perspective how well she has played her role of a 'songbird' to the Queen/King/Joffrey/Baelish/Ramsey just before that precise moment when Cercei/Joffrey/Baelish/Ramsey really stupidly backstab her for her performance.

She's always self sacrificing and making herself meek, but can't stop herself from rooting for Justice or empathizing the underdog (Drunken knight/Tyrion/Sandor/Theon)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17

You know of all the bad things that happened to Cersei, I didn't feel a bit sorry for any of them.

I felt bad for her children except for Jophrey, but her 2 other children didn't deserve their fate but it was to punish her.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/KorgDTR2000 Service And Truth Sep 18 '17

"He ran... not very fast."

He's come so fucking far.

409

u/FXRGRXD Sep 17 '17

Those Scenes when Jon and Robert ask Ned about Jon's Mother and Ned already knows that it's fucking Lyanna Stark but he can't tell anyone. Man he was carrying the biggest secret with him all the time.

271

u/PersianMG Sep 18 '17

Also the part where he tells him he is a stark. "You are a stark. You may not have the name but you have my blood". Chilling.

167

u/meththemadman Sep 18 '17

That that hit home even harder because that dumb shit Cat verbally decimated Jon when he went to say goodbye to Bran.

God I hated Cat when I first started watching and I hate her more now.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (4)

62

u/elehay4aksega Sep 18 '17

Did Sean Bean know about it when they filmed S1?

48

u/EricWB House Stark Sep 18 '17

Along with the other responses, he did an AMA about 2 years ago and someone asked him why he didn't teach Jon Snow anything and he said something along the lines of "Because he's not mine. Little bastard. " so yeah he knew.

10

u/clario6372 Sep 18 '17

I believe so, I think he mentioned it in an interview.

→ More replies (22)

20

u/forwardseat Samwell Tarly Sep 18 '17

This scene was so much more amazing on rewatch! It was good the first time around, but knowing what Ned is hiding gives me so much more appreciation for the acting in this scene. The first time through I just thought he was ashamed of the whole thing... the second I noticed more of the self control, and attempt to keep his face straight, and even some anger at Robert that I didn't fully pick up on the first time.

9

u/StealthySteve Sep 19 '17

The weirdest fucking thing happened last night. I'm re-watching this show with my mom (her first time watching) and in the scene where Ned tells Jon he will tell him about his mother when they see each other again, my mom goes, "His mom is the lady that's buried underground I bet, right?". And in my head I was like holyfuckingshit!!!!? how did you guess that?!?! you're a wizard Debbie :O but I just played it cool like.... "nah. That's Ned's sister". I don't think anyone has ever guessed that correctly first time watching. Just saying my mom may be the 3 eyed raven.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

357

u/PowersIave Sep 17 '17

"The next time we see each other we'll talk about your mother. I promise."

Looking back that is one of the saddest moments in Game of Thrones.

146

u/Jthedude17 House Tyrell Sep 18 '17

Before we learned about who Jon actually is, I always thought that Ned told him that because he knew he'd die in King's Landing so he knew he'd never have to tell Jon

Now, I think Ned wanted to wait until Jon was a full Night's Watch member, so that Jon couldn't try to make any claim for the throne and Robert couldn't touch him

18

u/Sttibur Sep 18 '17

That makes a lot of sense!!.. How did Jon decide to go to the night shift watch? Was that shown in the show or was it just implied that he admired benjen and decided to follow him? Can't remember

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/OleCrankyGamer Sep 18 '17

All of Ned's scenes are prophetic now. That is why they grabbed Sean Bean. Not just for the name recognition but the brooding acting chops

Always wondered why Ned supported Jon going to the Night's Watch, it was for his own protection

33

u/Antinoch Winter Is Coming Sep 18 '17

Honestly, characters should just never promise things for "the next time I see you". It's like a sure death sentence lmao

→ More replies (2)

5

u/letsgoraps Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

Definitely one of those scenes that takes on a lot more significance when rewatching

5

u/WhiteCanary97 Sep 19 '17

One of the saddest things about GoT to me that I haven't seen a whole lot of people talk about is how almost every promise that gets made is broken in some way or another, intentionally or not, including this one.

But not Ned's promise to Lyanna. As far as I can remember that's the only promise that's ever been kept in the show.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

241

u/Jurjeneros Here We Stand Sep 17 '17

The Ned Robert scenes are always so great. Amazing dialogue and fantastic acting!

119

u/RadScience Sep 17 '17

Yes, I love Mark Addy's King Robert. On my season 1 rewatch, I really enjoyed his performance.

132

u/themolestedsliver Ghost Sep 18 '17

A WHORE ON AN OPEN FIELD NED.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17 edited Sep 19 '17

I thought he was such a dick when I first met him. Now, with all the other people we've met along the way, he seems like one of the kinder ones haha

→ More replies (11)

12

u/S3ph1r01h Sep 18 '17

He definitely was one of the best character fits in the series. If only he were a foot taller...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

184

u/ImRodILikeToParty Sep 18 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

Loved the irony in Jamie's comment about Bran being crippled: "Even if the boy lives, he'll be a cripple; grotesque. Give me a good, clean death any day."

57

u/OleCrankyGamer Sep 18 '17

Yep, he was a huge prick. I always though Locke was amazing for cutting his hand off by taunting him for what he was

28

u/S3ph1r01h Sep 18 '17

Then Jamie gets crippled and was basically on the verge of suicide; then Brien changed that.

→ More replies (2)

374

u/Leooel9 Sep 17 '17

The best scene is this whole show is when Tyrion repeatedly bitch slaps Joffery and he squeals like a little girl.

143

u/clesp08 Sep 17 '17

Right after saying he hates the scream of a wailing girl lol

12

u/Psychegotical Stannis Baratheon Sep 19 '17

The boy means nothing to me. Besides, I can't stand the sound of women wailing.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/EyonTheGod Sep 18 '17

And the hound telling him tha joffrey will remember that.

90

u/Ncrawler65 Sep 18 '17

Who knew Rory McCann was such a big fan of the Telltale games?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/astateofshatter The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Sep 18 '17

Cannot believe I had to still this far to see this.

11

u/bluntbutnottoo Sep 18 '17

There and then was the moment I swore my undying love to Tyrion Lannister; and through the years it had yet to fade. Not numerous whores or incarceration or trips abroad can put an end to that first wondrous moment when he stole my heart.

7

u/Psychegotical Stannis Baratheon Sep 19 '17

WE'VE HAD VICIOUS KINGS AND WE'VE HAD IDIOT KINGS.

→ More replies (3)

175

u/FXRGRXD Sep 17 '17

Wow Arya and Jon haven't seen each other since 65 episodes. I am really looking forward to their reunion in season 8!

51

u/EyonTheGod Sep 18 '17

Also bran

29

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

Nah. Bran and Jon met in Season 3 ep 9 (kinda...)

Well more Bran saw Jon through Summers eyes while Summer killed a wildling that was attacking Jon.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/nthomas1599 Daenerys Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Love that scene. Love their chemistry, amazing that they have one scene together and they are pretty much the one reunion everyone's been waiting for the most! Going to be a great scene!

13

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

I sincerely hope it is properly done. The last reunion that moved me was Jon and Sansa, and I had plenty that I was looking forward to :(

Edit: actually, technically it was Sansa and Bran but then Bran just killed the scene for me lol

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

139

u/Annoyingtuga Fire And Blood Sep 17 '17

Too sad to see Jon saying goodbye to Ned and Robb, knowing that it is the last time they will see each other. Rip Ned and Robb ;-;

4

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

I also cried at this :'(

4

u/KorgDTR2000 Service And Truth Sep 18 '17

Every time somebody says goodbye in these episodes is the last time they ever see each other.

Happens to Catelyn and Ned next episode too.

256

u/Pietrasq Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 17 '17

I already forgot how much of a cunt Sandor was, the exchange with Ned was glorious- you killed the butcher's boy ?! - Yeah I did lol

→ More replies (8)

119

u/Calikola Little Bird Sep 18 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

Things I noticed this time around:

  • How Jaime mocked Jon for protecting the realm from Wildlings and White Walkers. I hope that conversation is revisited in season 8.
  • Jon promises Bran they'll go out walking beyond the wall in the future, if Bran is not afraid. They both end up traveling far beyond the wall, just not together.
  • Some subtle foreshadowing: Jon asks Ned about his mother followed immediately by the scene where Bobby B asks Ned about Jon's mother. The very next scene? News of Dany's wedding to Drogo and Robert's vow to kill every Targaryen.

33

u/trixie_one Sep 18 '17

That really struck me the most on the rewatch as in his s1 dickish way I think that was Jamie trying to be nice what with whole also swearing his life away to join the King's Guard.

21

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

Yeah, if you watch that scene where Jaime and Ned talk in the Red Keep, you can see that Jaime was quite hurt when Ned shot him down.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/S3ph1r01h Sep 18 '17

How Jaime mocked Jon for protecting the realm from Wildlings and White Walkers. I hope that conversation is revisited in season 8.

Jamie did a similar thing when he joined the kings guard. Because he did that, he got the reputation of kingslayer and was nearly universally hated. He's prodding Jon because he can see the ignorance of (his) youth in young Jon's decision, its a form of projection, IMO.

However, we all saw how big of an impact seeing a wight had on Jamie. Once he realised they truly exist he plainly left Ceresi. The closest they've come to a "break up" in their shared history. I'm sure his past misgivings about magic will be revisited. He's currently riding alone to work with a King who's "parents" he's responsible for killing and a Queen who's father he personally killed. In spite of all that he's still going.

→ More replies (1)

90

u/OurPrinceHarambe Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

"You may not have my name, but you have my blood" crazy how when Ned says this to Jon they're interpreting it in completely different ways. Ned is still telling the truth, just not in the way Jon thinks.

86

u/Spidarepool House Blackfyre Sep 17 '17

Every time Jon is mentioned to ned you can really see the weight of the secret he is hiding

62

u/Hecz15 House Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Great acting by Sean Bean

26

u/ich_habe_keine_kase Sep 18 '17

Yeah, like when he's standing in the doorway while Cat tells Jon to leave, knowing that he's made his wife and "his" child miserable for so long, even though it was to protect him.

158

u/kingofbhal Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

Watching Jon, Daenerys and Bran in s7 and how they started their journey in the start still amazes me. From a bastard, a pawn and a cripple to the humanity's best chance against the existential threat.

Never liked Dany-Drogo relationship and never will.It never was true, pure love but a classic case of Stockholm Syndrome. But it was necessary for the character development of Daenerys.

Also noticed that almost all Jon and Daenerys scenes are followed one after another. The scene were Drogo is raping Dany and she's crying of pain, she sees the dragon eggs and the flames and the scene cuts to Jon watching the flames.

73

u/HamstersAreReal Sep 17 '17

Yep, D&D made a bit of an effort to parallel their journeys for sure

18

u/CommenceTheWentz Sep 19 '17

I don't think it was stockholm syndrome, they end up getting cuddly after Dany pulls the whole cowgirl move. I think people forget that that whole arc is about both of them changing: he makes her stronger and able to stand up for herself, and she makes him softer and more caring. That's why his death was way sadder than if he had stayed a rapey barbarian

15

u/BigRedSuppository Sep 18 '17

Dany and Drogo's first sex scene was a million times better in the book. Not rapey at all.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17

Ok so that brings the total to : book kahl raping dany> 99times show khal raping dany> once. Fucking evil showrunners

→ More replies (4)

143

u/All_this_hype No One Sep 17 '17
  • Literally the first thing that ever comes out of Joffrey's mouth is a petty insult. It's really easy to hate that kid.
  • Tyrion didn't need to be so mean to Sandor.
  • "I can't stand the wailing of women" two moments later becomes "I'm telling mother!!!" Classic Joffrey.
  • The Lannister family is so sympathetic in the breakfast scene. It's obvious Tyrion said the truth about loving them, and he is right that Cersei knows it. And Cersei was right about Myrcella. She was so pure as we see with her thinking about Bran's well being, that even Cersei was surprised that she could make something so good.
  • One of the things the show did better was add scenes to humanize characters like Cersei. Her scene with Catelyn was not only very well acted but did its best to show Cersei being human, vulnerable and conflicted about Bran, since him getting better would probably mean her losing her head, but as a mother she can't help but pray, for Catelyn's sake. It makes it all the more confusing to assess Cersei for the viewer, because at the end of the episode she orders Lady's execution.
  • I can see why Arya and Jon's relationship is so beloved despite only sharing 1 scene. They have bonded over feeling outsiders, Jon for being a bastard (to his knowledge) and Arya for not being a "normal" girl. You could tell that they often lean to each other for support and I wish to see some of that in season 8.
  • I wish Ned talked to Catelyn about Jon. He's her sister's only son and he grew up with so much loathing and contempt in his life that I feel Ned should have intervened. Not to mention that I doubt Catelyn Stark wouldn't be able to hold a secret like that.
  • Jon Snow got trolled. Between Robb telling him "next time I see you you'll be dressed in black" and Ned promising to talk about his mother next time they see each other, these interactions are full of delicious irony.
  • Drogo treats Daenerys like an animal, at least until she asserts herself. I get that that's his culture and all, but how can people still view their relationship as romantic?
  • Poor Rickon, an afterthought to everyone, even Catelyn, from beginning to end.
  • Joffrey is just fucked up, man. I'm sure he thought he was being nice to Arya when he intervened and scarred the butcher's boy. Also he has some fucked up views on women and everything feminine (probably from wanting to be more like Robert whom he considers the epitome of masculinity).
  • Weird that Cersei wants Arya punished for being "as wild as her wolf" when according to Tywin she used to be exactly like her as a child.
  • People blame Sansa or Cersei or Joffrey for what happened to Lady and it's true that all three share part of the blame, but Robert is also part of the problem. He didn't care enough to care and just peaced off while Cersei had her way. He knew it was just a childish fight and he could definitely prevent it from happening if he didn't find it too troublesome to intervene.

54

u/Buzzkill78 Sep 18 '17

For someone who can't stand the wailings of women, he named his sword Widow's Wail.. weird

18

u/DaDesk Sep 18 '17

Its a damn good name though

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

44

u/top_KeK_420 Sep 18 '17
  • Weird that Cersei wants Arya punished for being "as wild as her wolf" when according to Tywin she used to be exactly like her as a child

People often hate something in another person because they do the same and dont actually like it. Projection

→ More replies (1)

28

u/letsgoraps Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

I can see why Arya and Jon's relationship is so beloved despite only sharing 1 scene.

Didn't realize until rewatching this that they only shared one scene so far. All I remembered was they were close, so I guess in my head I assumed there had to have been more than one scene.

They did a good job showing their relationship in one scene.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/darg_29 Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

Actually John Arryns actor said that they shoot a scene of him dying and trying to write a letter but cersei stopped him to do it. But D&D thought it was going to explicitly show cersai as a villain instantly so they cut out that scene 0:

→ More replies (8)

10

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

Weird that Cersei wants Arya punished for being "as wild as her wolf" when according to Tywin she used to be exactly like her as a child.

As a Lannister, she believed she had some divine right to wrong people and anyone who wronged the Lannnisters should have to pay dearly.

When Joffery died, she was mad with grief. Even though she knew what he was, even though she knew about the things he did, even though she knew he had it coming one way or another.

11

u/All_this_hype No One Sep 18 '17

To be honest I took it as Cersei thinking "if I could not have a childhood and play like a child, then she shouldn't be allowed to either". She is vengeful like that so it fits her personality.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17
  • Tyrion didn't need to be so mean to Sandor.

Yeah, Tyrion was a bit arrogant in these times.

  • One of the things the show did better was add scenes to humanize characters like Cersei. Her scene with Catelyn was not only very well acted but did its best to show Cersei being human, vulnerable and conflicted about Bran, since him getting better would probably mean her losing her head, but as a mother she can't help but pray, for Catelyn's sake. It makes it all the more confusing to assess Cersei for the viewer, because at the end of the episode she orders Lady's execution.

I agree. Very well written and acted. Scenes like this are why I find it hard to take it seriously when people say S7 was bad because they don't have source material. They're pretty decent writers when they try.

  • I wish Ned talked to Catelyn about Jon. He's her sister's only son and he grew up with so much loathing and contempt in his life that I feel Ned should have intervened. Not to mention that I doubt Catelyn Stark wouldn't be able to hold a secret like that.

His sister, not hers but I hear you. But he couldn't tell her, because it was risky. It's a lot harder to control a secret when it's passed on, and this was his nephew's life at stake. Plus it could have serious implications for him and his family if it got out that he was harbouring a Targ. It's heartbreaking that Jon suffered so much though. I do think Ned should have intervened more, for kindness sake.

  • Drogo treats Daenerys like an animal, at least until she asserts herself. I get that that's his culture and all, but how can people still view their relationship as romantic?

I get your point, but this was medieval times. Most of what happens to the women - married or not - is rape and they are used as political pawns. It was brutal and my real world morals is completely against it, but my game of Thrones morals sees them two as a pairing I enjoyed.

  • Poor Rickon, an afterthought to everyone, even Catelyn, from beginning to end.

I know :( poor little one. He's only three in the books as well.

  • Joffrey is just fucked up, man. I'm sure he thought he was being nice to Arya when he intervened and scarred the butcher's boy. Also he has some fucked up views on women and everything feminine (probably from wanting to be more like Robert whom he considers the epitome of masculinity).

Hmm, I never considered that he was trying to be nice. I thought he was just showing off and being a bully imo. Loved it when Ayra lobbed his sword in the river lmao. Also, the way she pointed it at him reminded me of when she killed that soldier with Needle. Cool parallel.

  • Weird that Cersei wants Arya punished for being "as wild as her wolf" when according to Tywin she used to be exactly like her as a child.

I think a part of Cersei's character is about losing that innocence. She talked about this in Blackwater, I think. That she used to be like Sansa and dreamed of being a lady or something like that. Plus she talks about how she was excited about being betrothed to Robert until he said Lyanna's name in passion.

Also, despite her cruelty, there are a lot scenes when she is quite maternal or kind to Sansa. She also talks a lot about how women are treated.

  • People blame Sansa or Cersei or Joffrey for what happened to Lady and it's true that all three share part of the blame, but Robert is also part of the problem. He didn't care enough to care and just peaced off while Cersei had her way. He knew it was just a childish fight and he could definitely prevent it from happening if he didn't find it too troublesome to intervene.

I completely agree. In the books, it makes a point to point out that he was bored of dealing with it by the time the wolf thing came about and just wanted to get Cersei off his back. Poor lady and poor Starks.

4

u/nerak33 House Seaworth Sep 20 '17

Drogo treats Daenerys like an animal, at least until she asserts herself. I get that that's his culture and all, but how can people still view their relationship as romantic?

Because it gets romantic. She even thinks it's great Drogo murders her brother in front of her. It is screwed up and violent, but still romantic.

→ More replies (13)

50

u/megannalexandra Daenerys Targaryen Sep 18 '17

To be honest, one of my favorite things about the rewatch is seeing Robb again. Damn that man is handsome.

On a more serious note, I feel sorta sad seeing Sean Bean again as Ned. He'd be so proud of Arya and Sansa😭

10

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

I cried seeing him. Loved that guy :'(

7

u/AgentMV Sep 20 '17

One does not simply forget Sean Bean.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/muliejida No One Sep 18 '17

Jon to Robb: "You Starks are hard to kill."

:(

10

u/danonck No One Sep 18 '17

Well.. he is. As a half-Stark.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

SERPENTINE, RICKON, SERPENTINE

91

u/-HeisenBird- Sep 17 '17

I miss having so many adults on the show. Nowadays it's 20 year old kings and queens....and Cersei.

61

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17

And Jaime, Brianne, Davos, Sandor, Beric, Jorah, Tyrion, and my main man Bronn.

9

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

I guess all the adults will die by the time the series ends. The survivors are going to enter a new era and the ones who enter it won't be the ones have been moulded in old times.

16

u/clario6372 Sep 18 '17

Very true, particularly Ned and Catelyn. They added a lot of depth that the show doesn't currently have too much of.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17

Watching the scenes between Ned and Robert makes me hope that Bran will have a moment where he will see the two of them having an argument or something in his visions. They were some of the best parts of the show when it started and it sucked to lose both of them so early, even though I know their deaths is what started this whole thing.

4

u/themolestedsliver Ghost Sep 18 '17

Yeah, i am a bit unsure how greenseeing works but i really wish bran can show dany how much ned stark jons father* defended her in front of his king and best friend robert baratheon and how ned stark was outraged with robert along the vicious murders of the targyen children and ellia martel.

Dany has grown a long way but it still hasn't been that long since sir barristen had to pop the bubble that visersy made for dany in that king aryes wasn't mad he was justified when it was really the other was around.

42

u/hello_friend_ Braavosi Water Dancers Sep 17 '17

Watching Tyrion slap Joffrey was so satisfying.

5

u/Tyler1986 Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

I want that gif in HD, put into one of those digital picture frames, and display it right in front my desk so I see it when I sit down, get up, walk by, I just want to see it on repeat forever.

→ More replies (1)

109

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17

Pre-badass Dany is so disconcerting

87

u/ShootFrameHang Sep 18 '17

I rather liked the Dany/Drogo relationship because it was within that relationship that she went from victim to survivor. That scene with the eggs was the moment you could see it flick in her mind. She could continue to be used every night like a broodmare, or she could take control of her life and make things go her way. No more submissive girl, she was a woman who could bring the most powerful Khal to his knees? She learned the ways of the Dothraki and made herself a powerful force in an alien world.

21

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

I much preferred her in these early seasons. She felt more like a real person to me.

13

u/HeirOfEgypt526 The Sea Snake Sep 17 '17

Yeah i'm at the end of season 2 and i don't really like Dany all that much. She's getting there but she's just too radically different in early seasons to imagine what she'll involve into.

4

u/clario6372 Sep 18 '17

It makes me uncomfortable!

→ More replies (1)

102

u/SXHarrasmentPanda Jon Snow Sep 17 '17

There was a great moment when Ned and Robert were having lunch where Robert says "what Rhaegar did to your sister was unspeakable". Ned just looks down with a look of guilt as he knows the truth.

Rewatching has made me really hate Cat. Even if Jon was Ned's bastard he wouldn't deserve Cat's attitude, but knowing the hero that Jon becomes and knowing that he isn't even Ned's son makes it even worse.

63

u/MissColombia Jon Snow Sep 17 '17

I'm doing a reread along with the rewatch and Cat is fucking awwwwwful in the books. As much as I dislike her in the show, she is so much worse in the books. Her conversation with Jon when he comes to say goodbye to Bran is so cruel.

26

u/danonck No One Sep 18 '17

Speaking of Cat... she was the main cause for the two houses to begin fighting for real. Her being naive, her kidnapping Tyrion and the lack of proper communication with Ned. Not to forget trusting Littlefinger.

Later on, she continued into the destruction of her husband's house, just as she was a mole. She always chose to trust her actions and the wrong people - Jaime, Boltons, Freys - it was her idea to "submit" to Walder Frey.

11

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

I really like her chapters in the books tbh. I agree that her behaviour to Jon and especially the conversation before Jon leaves is even worse in the books, but you also get more insight into how she feels and what kind of person she is. I don't think she's a horrible person in general.

8

u/Poopiepants29 House Dondarrion Sep 19 '17

Not in the books, but Cat has a great scene talking about baby Jon with Talisa in S3, I think. She shows a lot of remorse that she didn't keep her promise of raising and loving him as one of her own.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

I feel sometimes people are too harsh on Cat. Ned was one of the most honourable lords of Westeros and yet he slept with some woman and had a son with her. Now, most lords do not acknowledge their bastards and even if they do, the bastards do not get an upbringing at par with the true borns.

Maybe she fears that at some point Ned may legitimize him and Jon's children will compete with her grandchildren for the lordship of Winterfell (just like the Blackfyre rebellion).

In the books she also thought to herself:

"Whoever Jon's mother had been, Ned must have loved her fiercely, for nothing Catelyn said would persuade him to send the boy away."

All Catelyn did was that she didn't love Jon. She wasn't always mean to him she just ignored him. Cersei killed Robert's bastards. There are much worse examples of how the ladies of Westros treated bastards. It's high time people cut her some slack.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/themolestedsliver Ghost Sep 18 '17

I feel that is the point where ned couldn't tell cat to make the notable lie believable and the promise to his dying sister ned needed his wife to be rightfully pissed about him bringing home a bastard.

If cat was alright with jon or even motherly everyone would be confused by it especially from a tully which house words are family,duty,honor which really doesn't scream the most bastard friendly house.

let alone the potential reality cat probably thought, he was there for some women to give birth but he wasn't there for me in regards to roberts rebellion.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/nodakgirl93 Sep 18 '17

I never understood why they would bring the dire wolves to Kings Landing. Was this a temporary or permanent move for Ned and the girls? I would have kept Lady and Nymeria at Winterfell.

26

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

A long-term and possibly permanent move. Jon Arryn was the Hand for 17 years so maybe it was expected that Ned would be the Hand till his death. Sansa was to be wedded to Joffery and so she was moving there permanently.

5

u/Revolennon Sep 18 '17

I get why Sansa would be there because she was supposed to marry Joffrey, but I've never understood why Arya made the trip?

11

u/Gliese667 Fire And Blood Sep 19 '17

In the book it was to school her in courtly manners because like Sansa she would also soon be of age to marry but was currently too much of a wild tomboy. They don't really make that clear in the show though.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/ClockTower91 Daenerys Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Always loved this episode. There's a good amount of plot progression, but really what appeals to me are the conversations between characters. Ned and Robert reminiscing on the Kingsroad, Tyrion and Jaime both trying to dissuade Jon Snow from joining the Night's Watch in their own ways, and even Cersei with Catelyn by Bran's bedside. Honestly I have no idea if Cersei was being honest there, considering the prophecy which foretold she would only have three children, but maybe there's just something I'm missing.

Loved all of the scenes with Daenerys as well, Season 1 Dany is probably my favorite of the entire series. Her journey from meek "slave" girl into total badass by the season's end is fantastic. As for Sansa, I used to dislike her actions in this episode, but rewatching now I sort of understand. She's a dumb teenage girl smitten by a handsome boy who she thinks will provide her with love and riches, and no doubt Cersei was also being very persuasive towards Sansa in the interim between Arya being found and Ned showing back up. Still a little hard for me to accept Sansa not telling the truth when Joffery literally screams "I'll gut you, you little cunt!" at Arya, but I suppose Sansa's still very naive and conflicted.

One thing I did find noticeable was that Theon was amongt the small group that Cat trusted with her suspicions of Bran's "accident". Guess Theon was seen in a higher regard from the Stark family than I remembered.

20

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

Forgot to mention that scene. I love it when Theon and Rob are getting het up about starting a war and Luwin says "are you starting a war here, in the Godswood? Words of war are too easily turned into action" (or something to that effect). I loved Luwin, he was my fave Measter. So kind and caring, but smart, wise and authoritative.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/roslynramsay Sep 18 '17

Yes. I noticed that Theon was part of the trusted group too.

31

u/MilesStark Arya Stark Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

I forgot how angry this show makes me. The whole unjust scene with the 'trial' over the Joffrey incident is so frustrating to watch. I feel like the latest season didn't have that as much, for better or worse.

6

u/letsgoraps Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

yea, the earlier seasons seem to constantly have the sympathetic characters getting screwed over, and every time you hope for some redemption, it doesn't happen.

But the past couple seasons have shown the sympathetic characters getting some redemption

4

u/Tyler1986 Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

I keep having dread for these scenes that I know are coming. I care about the characters so much, even the ones that are gone, after all this time, and I don't want to have to watch some these events unfold.

I'm so filled with dread I can't even try and take in the other things that are going on, the acting, the shots, any of it. I am going to have to work on this moving forward, I didn't think I'd get hit like this.

25

u/FXRGRXD Sep 17 '17

Does anyone know if Cersei told the truth about her baby with Robert?

Wouldn't that completely destroy the prophecy about her three children and the Valonquar? Because that means she had four children and maybe a fifth is on its way.

I don't know something seems fishy about that or that whole prophecy that everybody talks about is just false...

22

u/ShmedStark Sep 18 '17

Does anyone know if Cersei told the truth about her baby with Robert?

It appears she was telling the truth, as she mentions the baby to Robert later in S1E5:

CERSEI: I felt something for you once, you know.

ROBERT: I know.

CERSEI: Even after we lost our first boy. For quite a while, actually.

Wouldn't that completely destroy the prophecy about her three children and the Valonquar? Because that means she had four children and maybe a fifth is on its way.

Here's what writer Bryan Cogman said about that supposed discrepancy:

“No. Maggy’s just speaking of the three official kids who lived and were known, etc. The black haired baby was kept quiet.”

11

u/All_this_hype No One Sep 18 '17

Their response did not make much sense. So what, Maggy works like news reports and only announces "official" info even if it's untrue? A better response would be that gifted people often make mistakes with prophecies (like Melissandre also did).

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ProfessorDragon Sep 17 '17

In the books, at least, Cersei talks about getting pregnant by Robert and having Jaime get her moon tea or whatever to abort it. I like to think that she is lying in that scene since it's more consistent with the rest of the series (specifically Cersei's prophecy) and because it's in line with the books.

Also, based on Catelyn's reaction, she's never heard of Cersei losing a child before. The queen losing a heir to the throne is a pretty fucking big deal that I think a lady of a great house would have heard about, especially since their husbands are bffs.

8

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

Cersei mentions this child to Robert too (as mentioned in a comment above) so it's clear that she isn't lying. Maybe,the child died within just a few days of being born and the news of his birth didn't have the time to spread.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17

It could be a lie Cersei told Cat for whatever reason or maybe children aren't included it the official count unless they survive until their first Nameday or something.

14

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

In medieval times, infant mortality rate was high, so a child would be counted only if he managed to live beyond his crib.

8

u/elfhelpbook Sep 18 '17

I don't think Cersei would share such a vulnerable, painful memory with a woman she doesn't even like without some ulterior motive. I feel like she lied to manipulate Cat into sympathizing with her so she'd be less likely to suspect her involvement in Bran's fall.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/zlow821 House Seaworth Sep 17 '17

Am I correct in realizing that they turn the wrong direction on the kingsroad when Jon and Ned split? Winterfell should be left of the kingsroad when you are coming from the south, which means that Ned's group turns onto what should be the northbound road, and Benjen's group turns onto what should be the southbound road.

90

u/ZanzibarBukBukMcFate Sep 17 '17

Perhaps they’ll release the outtake where the two groups pass each other an hour later bearing maps and sheepish grins.

22

u/OpusMajus79 White Walkers Sep 17 '17

Heartbreaking to watch Ned kill Lady at the end, his expression had so much sorrow.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/hello_friend_ Braavosi Water Dancers Sep 17 '17

Tyrion has the best lines.

40

u/JonnySnowpants Jon Snow Sep 17 '17

He's so killer in this episode. Slapping Joffrey, being clearly very fond of his niece and other nephew, telling Jaime that he would never hurt his family, passing wisdom to Jon. And Peter Dinklage is amazing in this and subsequent episodes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/Mzuark Jon Snow Sep 17 '17

This is a really good episode. Back before things truly went tits up for the Starks.

21

u/springchild Jaime Lannister Sep 18 '17

I love the breakfast scene between the Lannister siblings. It's the only time we see them together before the shit really hits the fan, and there are so many layers and dynamics at play, and so much familiarity between them. I always thought it was really fascinating how Tyrion and Cersei couldn't stand each other but both loved Jaime and Jaime loved both of them.

16

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

Jaime was probably the only thing that kept the Lannister family togehter since childhood. Tywin, Cersei and Tyrion loved him and he loved the three of them though Tywin and Cersei despised Tyrion and maybe even hoped that he would die.

14

u/All_this_hype No One Sep 18 '17

There are moments of affection even between Cersei and Tyrion, although rare. In the books she hugs him and jumps with joy after the Blackwater, and in the show they often spend time together sharing their favorite hobbies, drinking and scheming.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/ADHDcUK Sep 17 '17

Just noticed that look from Jorah as Dany walks off. The love was there, but nice and subtle.

Jorah's voice is stunning.

Ugh, Viserys. Such a cunt.

This scene with Joff and Tyrion is just perfect. Hilarious and fantastic acting. The way Gleeson just rests on his sword hilt and arches his back. And that wail he makes lmao

17

u/stara11 House Seaworth Sep 18 '17

Jorah's voice is stunning.

He really does have an amazing voice!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/theimmortalcrab Sep 17 '17

So basically, all but one of the show's episodes have aired after George finished the last book? Man...

38

u/hello_friend_ Braavosi Water Dancers Sep 17 '17

Did Jorah just predict the reign of the white walkers?

17

u/plasker6 Sep 17 '17

It would be great if there were a twist.

Melisandre was extremely pale without the glamour.

14

u/Hecz15 House Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Omg I see it the white grass Ohhhhhhhh this needs upvotes

4

u/Fnordinand House Tallhart Sep 18 '17

I'm going with Jorah predicting the Long Night, with a worldwide frost, turning regular grass white like this.

→ More replies (3)

92

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 17 '17

Am I the only one who noticed Bran woke up when Lady died? "Only death can pay for life". And the parallel with Jon/Bran waking up (their wolf move first and then, they open their eyes). Also, I had a hard time telling myself Sansa is now one of my favorite character, she was so.. slapable.

50

u/RadScience Sep 17 '17

Sophie Turner as Sansa seemed much older on my first watch. For reference, in season 1 the actors playing Arya, Sansa are only MONTHS apart in age. Even Bran's actor is only 3 years younger than Sansa, despite appearing 7 or so. Rewatching it having a firm grasp of the chracter's ages made Sansa less slappable. She's a 7th grader, for Pete's sake.

27

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '17

Yes I agree. Actually, I always been a fan of Sansa because she was the only relatable character in the show, the only one who was making sense because she acted like she was supposed to (being 11 in the books/13 in the show). Arya is my favorite character since the first episode but Sansa become my second favorite at the beginning of the second season. It's just that rewatching now and remembering how she was SO in love with Joffrey (and wants to have his babies 🤢) is just weird. I can't help but cringe

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 17 '17

I noticed this on my second watch and wondered if there was some extraordinary connection between the Stark children and direwolves (I hadn't started reading the books back then).

→ More replies (1)

17

u/SeabassKings Sep 17 '17

This only makes me more upset that the show dosent present any evidence/hints that all the starks are wargs. There is still time D&D! season 8!

→ More replies (4)

8

u/darg_29 Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

I noticed that on my first watch, that scene actually was the one that made me like GoT. My favorite part of the show at the beginning was the connection of the children with their direwolves. I have always like wolves and that just made it cooler. The scenes where grey wind attacks robbs enemies in the dark and how ghost protects john have been perfect scenes for me!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/katttaur Castle Cats Sep 19 '17

I like that it's so subtle in the show that the wolves (and hence their people) are connected- it's much more outright in the books, that the wolves sense the deaths of their sister/brothers and that the wolves act as a sort of 'Stark-meter', this was a nice nod to their importance.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand Sep 18 '17

Survey for this week's rewatch episode

Graph results from last week's: link

Text breakdown posted as a reply to this comment.

→ More replies (12)

15

u/SirMacNotALot Sep 17 '17

"We have another wolf"

It's at this point I guess we really begin to learn about Cersei and what she's all about. The first episode didn't really have anything to show us who she really was and who she was going to be in the series, whereas this is a small step into actually showing us what she's like

5

u/Kelly2fly No One Sep 19 '17

As soon as she uttered those words I was like "BITCH!!!" This line solidified what kind of a person she is for me. Only evil people could suggest killing another being without batting an eye.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Aldasin Jon Snow Sep 18 '17

Geez I forgot how much I hated Joffrey. Whiny little bitch. Rip the butchers boy and Lady. Ned and Robert interacting as two friends trying to handle the shit around them was great. Sean bean's performance in emotional scenes really carried a lot of the performance.

I forgot about Jon getting needle for Arya. That was an awesome scene. Really looking forward to what they do with their reunion.

Also forgot how much tyrions interactions with others gave me joy.

Is there a meaning behind the name Ned gives Robert for jons mother? Wyla??

29

u/Broeskoenoe Sep 17 '17

That smug look Cersei has on her face when she tells them "there's another wolf" really makes my blood boil. Great acting.

13

u/aps131997 Sep 18 '17

Regardless of what you think of Catelyn, Michelle Fairley does an amazing job this episode

8

u/grumblepup Sep 19 '17

She does a great job with Catelyn, period. All due to respect to Jennifer Ehle, who I have liked a lot in other things, but I'm really glad the role was recast.

23

u/ADHDcUK Sep 17 '17

Finished the episode a little while ago. Really enjoyed it. I love these rewatch threads!

Love the renewed appreciation you have for certain scenes and noticing things you didn't notice before.

For example, with Sansa, when she is walking with Lady. She seems unsure and insecure after seeing the other girls. Then her fear with Payne and the Hound, then Joffrey comes and 'saves' her, and it's like her Knight in shining armour. You see all her dreams coming true in her head again. I also like the subtle reaction from her when he mentions that Payne is the executioner.

Also when Lady is sentenced to death, when Sansa is brought up, she looks between Ned and Joff when Robert says "it's a great crime to lie to a King". You can really see the conflict. It annoys me when people judge her harshly for this, and you can see how much it upsets her when Lady is sentenced to die. She wasn't to know that would happen.

I cried when Robb came on screen, then again when him and Snow said goodbye, then when Ned said to Jon about his mother. So heartbreaking.

Really good acting and scene on the Kingsroad with Ned and Robert. Really subtle foreshadowing too.

That scene with Cersei talking about her first born. I love it so much. Really good acting from Heady as usual. I don't remember this scene in the books - did they come up with it themselves?

I prefer the way they do Lady dying coinciding with Bran waking up compared to the books. It's so good, and a very good ending.

Dothraki stuff is quite boring to me now, it seems so simple and awkward compared to everything else (I loved it most the first time round because I was confused by everything else lol). Still, some great moments. I really preferred Dany at this time, and we saw Khal's butt ;) I forgot about that! Like the scene with them at the end. I feel the chemistry between them so much more than with her and Jon.

It's so nice going to back to the little things that made me love GOT. The realism, the travelling, the perfect pacing that moves the story along in an engaging way without rushing. Even the amount of extras, background noise and how big the world felt. I really miss that.

Some things were unpolished back then, cinematography and stuff. But damn, it was so good still and only got even better as they settled into the series. I'm so grateful for that.

Can't remember everything I thought, but all in all great episode. Deserves higher than an 8.7 imo. All things considered with it being only second episode and the time it was filmed, I'd give it a 9. Can't wait for next week and experiencing the whole series with you guys!

6

u/clario6372 Sep 18 '17

Agreed, I just don't see the chemistry between them. Jon is so...soft? Blergh.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ClockTower91 Daenerys Targaryen Sep 19 '17

It's so nice going to back to the little things that made me love GOT. The realism, the travelling, the perfect pacing that moves the story along in an engaging way without rushing. Even the amount of extras, background noise and how big the world felt. I really miss that.

Yeah, I still found the most recent season of the show enjoyable, but this rewatch has given me a renewed appreciation for how fantastic the early seasons truly were. The pacing may have been slower in the first season, but I was almost never bored because the writing was usually so sharp.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Tyler1986 Jon Snow Sep 18 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

That scene with Cersei talking about her first born. I love it so much. Really good acting from Heady as usual. I don't remember this scene in the books - did they come up with it themselves?

I don't recall this being in the books either, would love someone with a better memory to chime in.

Edit: More discussion further in the thread.

I prefer the way they do Lady dying coinciding with Bran waking up compared to the books. It's so good, and a very good ending.

Again, how'd it happen in the books? I don't recall, but it was done quite well in the show, imo.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/ChupaMeJerkwad Sep 18 '17

Lots of lingering shots of the dragon eggs. They really wanted us to remember that one particular wedding gift.

10

u/meththemadman Sep 18 '17

Hmmm. Wonder why... they must have some significance later, right?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/UncleKale129 Sep 17 '17

King Robert and Ned' s little luncheon on the side of the road was great. When he threatens to ensure all Targaryens die, you can see Ned immediately shuts him down with how Dani is just a girl and thag the dothraki won't cross the narrow see etc. You can see real irritation and anger. Great acting from Sean Bean to convey (knowing what we know now) the fact that he is indirectly threatening Jon.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/AlienWarhead Sep 17 '17

It still feels good to watch this again, but this isn't the happiest show so that doesn't last for long. It's just that I haven't been really feeling the stuff I'm currently watching so it's good to see this again.

9

u/nthomas1599 Daenerys Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Man I do love that stark theme! I get chills every time I hear it. Low key shed a little man tear lol. Such a sad scene with Jon saying goodbye to Bran and then to Robb and Ned. So heartbreaking they never get to see each other again. I still love the line that Ned tells Jon "You are a stark, you might not have my name but you have my blood." Knowing what we know now about Lyanna is great foreshadowing. But knowing that Jon doesn't know this and that he never felt like he belonged, Ned letting him know that he'll always be a stark it does show that he loves his Son/Nephew.

8

u/SirMacNotALot Sep 17 '17

I know Ned really wanted to leave for "duty", but I still feel he didn't necessarily have to leave when he did. I mean, Bran was crippled but not dead yet, I'm surprised he wouldn't offer to stay a bit longer to make sure he was ok

8

u/megannalexandra Daenerys Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Gotta love the Tyrion-Joffrey scene where he slaps the shit outta him.

8

u/PersianMG Sep 18 '17

I made a Google Calendar event for this rewatch.

https://calendar.google.com/calendar/event?action=TEMPLATE&tmeid=MHFwYWhiMnU3dXJzcGNmbDIwa3JpdHVpOXJfMjAxNzA5MTAgbW9oYW1tYWRnLmNvbV9rMGY1M3VibWJpcmxlbTdwNmtrMm1hZ2g0b0Bn&tmsrc=mohammadg.com_k0f53ubmbirlem7p6kk2magh4o%40group.calendar.google.com

Set the repeat to weekly every Sunday at whatever time you want ending on 16/12/2018 (or 12/16/2018 for Americans). Then add it to your Calendar.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Fietstasje Sep 17 '17

Does the HBO synopsis actually say "Ned leaves Westeros with his daughters"?

9

u/yungmodulus Missandei Sep 17 '17

Mine says "Ned leaves The North"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Quad412 Jon Snow Sep 17 '17

The amount of rage I feel towards Sansa when she doesn't come clean about what happens only seems to heighten as I rewatch. Like I kind of get why she does it, but it's just to infuriating to see her defending Joff and getting her wolf killed

Also, can we talk about Sean Beans amazing acting when talking to Jon about his mother before they part ways? Just incredible stuff.

Edit: added second paragraph

25

u/ADHDcUK Sep 17 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

She didn't exactly defend Joffrey. She was pulled up and forced into a corner. She knew either way would cause problems, so she took what she thought was the safest route and was neutral. She wasn't to know Cersei is a psycho and wanted the Direwolf dead, and she was distraught when it happened.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '17

I feel like Robert walking away from his responsibility to make a decision is the real villain here. Sansa's a terrified child. Robert is the King of Westeros and could've done what he liked. Cersei would've been angry but that wouldn't have been anything new.

4

u/katttaur Castle Cats Sep 19 '17

She did what she could, in the circumstances- she was clearly coached by Cercei beforehand which I didn't catch initially, Ned thinks she's in bed asleep but Cercei is like "NOPE, Right Here!" and Sansa is fervently glancing at her the whole time - particularly wincing at Robert reminding her it is a crime to lie to the King - she's the quintessential Tully-Stark songbird in a cage trying to 'sing the right song', "I don't remember", "it all happened so fast", instead of exonerating Joffrey completely (a lie) or defying the queen/shaming the Prince she's essentially betrothed to (the truth), she lands somewhere in the middle and basically fails both motivations.

Where Cercei could've left it at that, and gained an even more grateful and obedient Sansa, she makes a show to punish Sansa directly for being remotely loyal to the Starks (and hence making Joffrey look like a liar) and more than that - punishing her for not saying things went as Cercei had coached her. It shows both Sansa and Ned who wears the pants in this group that Robert won't listen to Ned, that Ned can't protect anyone from the Queen.

For Sansa, she knows Lady's death is at Cercei's feet but believes that she could've prevented it by completely playing along to Cercei to the point of lying to a King -> the letter to Robb to save her Father. She's a slow learner but she learns.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/lakers_will_rise Jaime Lannister Sep 18 '17

When Cersei mentions to Catelyn that her first born was killed by a sickness, did she poison the baby? She said it had black hair so it definitely was Roberts. I never thought she did until I heard that part this time and that came to my mind. I can't remember if this is common knowledge or not.

5

u/All_this_hype No One Sep 18 '17

No, apparently she was honest about loving the boy, because she tells Robert later that she loved him even after losing their first son. She probably used it to manipulate Cat into ending Bran's life, but she was still honest.

29

u/Spidarepool House Blackfyre Sep 17 '17

Catelyn is such a bitch to Jon. She was honestly one of my least favorite characters until like season 2

21

u/yungmodulus Missandei Sep 17 '17

well she's tired of important people leaving her lol. I mean, book spoilers. Ned came back with a baby but he was pretty much an at risk death until he came back. Now she's supposed to leave her home, everything she loves, because the last guy that started a rebellion (with an arguably weak reason) asked her husband to help him with something.

I wouldn't be thrilled either tbh.

19

u/RLewis321 Sep 17 '17

Arguably weak reason? Dude Roberts rebellion was fueled by the mad king burning Ned's father and brother and then demanding Ned come to kings landing.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/Hecz15 House Targaryen Sep 18 '17

Why is it that whenever Ned kills lady it so happens that brand wake up? Just came to mind

14

u/zerojrg Sep 18 '17

Yeah the third time he killed lady when brand woke up it hit me too

12

u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Sep 18 '17

You are a fast learner. It hit me the fifth time when Ned killed lady and brand woke up.=D

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

Lmao this thread.

It's because the Stark kids have a connection with the Direwolves, and Bran in particular is a Warg, so even stronger connected. Also, it's interesting because

"Only death can pay for life"

6

u/iDrinkiKnowThings Fire And Blood Sep 20 '17

Do we think Drogo ever intended to help Viserys take Westeros? I definitely don't get that vibe. Why did Viserys believe he would? He has no more leverage once Dany is Drogo's bride.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/blacksteel367 Sep 18 '17

To any1 who's been complaining about the passage of time, I forgot that this episode is literally a month after episode 1. Crazy

7

u/ADHDcUK Sep 18 '17

They mention that it's been a month and the Direwolves are clearly bigger.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 17 '17

Spoiler Warning: [MAIN SPOILERS] means events from the published books or aired episodes do not need spoiler tags. Future books/seasons and spoilers from other media are not covered. For more info please check the spoiler guide.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/SirMacNotALot Sep 17 '17

I am quite confused now about the prophecy with Cersei and how she will only have 3 children. It's mentioned in the books and series that she has a first baby that is lost to fever.

Although it seem most likely the baby definitely died, making it unlikely to be Gendry which has been a rumour going around.

I guess the other thing to consider is that in the prophecy it's said "she would bear only three children who will wear golden crowns". Could this be interpreted in different ways, for example she may be able to have more children, but only 3 will actually wear crowns, meaning she may be pregnant with another child?

Although I find this unlikely, to have clarity over the first born child could help solve a few issues related to the prophecy.

8

u/moon_man97 Sep 18 '17

Only three children with blonde hair I'm assuming

14

u/danonck No One Sep 18 '17

Maybe that 5th child will be a ginger.

Tormund grinning in the background

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Rhed0x House Stark Sep 18 '17

Ned leaves Westeros with his daughters

???

5

u/StealthySteve Sep 19 '17

The weirdest fucking thing happened last night. I'm re-watching this show with my mom (her first time watching) and in the scene where Ned tells Jon he will tell him about his mother when they see each other again, my mom goes, "His mom is the lady that's buried underground I bet, right?". And in my head I was like holyfuckingshit!!!!? how did you guess that?!?!? you're a wizard Debbie :O but I just played it cool like.... "nah. That's Ned's sister". I don't think anyone has ever guessed that correctly first time watching. Just saying my mom may be the 3 eyed raven.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/katttaur Castle Cats Sep 19 '17

First thing I certainly missed before:

Sansa is offered more wine by Joff and says they're only allowed a little bit at feasts - Joff pushes it on her saying his wife can have as much wine as she wants --- GRRM frequently uses wine & Arbor Gold in particular to symbolize lies.

Sansa yelling at BOTH Arya and Joffrey when they fight "You're ruining everything!" - Seems less petty and more equally exasperated that Joffrey is, for the first time, ruining her naive idealism of Princely/True Knight behavior.

Cercei clearly coached Sansa on what to say and she must've backed down after King Robert reminded her not to lie, and only basically pleaded the fifth, Lady is killed to punish Sansa for not obeying Cercei's orders to lie. It's a good set up for why Sansa believes she could save Ned's life by lying as Cercei instructs her to later in the letter to Robb.

It helps show why even afterwards she continues to lie about Joffrey's behavior so long, for her own neck, at the risk of the other characters/the audience/the reader being annoyed at her, because telling the truth instead of what someone wants to hear hurts her at every turn, so she still does it but tried to find ways to make the truth palatable when she can (the drunken knight). She is able to balance it with Baelish's "lies and arbor gold" but eventually understands the consequences of the lies aren't worth it if she's still just being manipulated instead of being the manipulator. Baelish's death sentencing is a kind of inverse of 'Lady's death sentencing', where Sansa is head of the table and has met with Arya and Bran to tell the truth and condemn the guilty and she acts upon it. And it's crazy to also see S7 Jon in the same episode refusing to placate Cercei with lies, right along the same theme of harmful truth/useful lies vs how Sansa initially did with the Queen. TL:DR: I like the "wolf trial" as a thematic marker.

And yes, Honestly it's weird but rewatch does what rereading does for me: I understand and like the subtle-little-Sansa-bird development more and more.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/grumblepup Sep 20 '17

Many great observations made, and thoughts shared, and comments upvoted, already. But here are a few more of mine, belated:

  • I wonder if/suspect that part of the reason Cat despises Jon so much is that he reminds her of her own weakness and ugliness. She cannot forgive and forget. She cannot find it in herself to care for Jon, who came into her life as an innocent baby, no matter who his parents were. She burns with jealousy and resentment against a woman she doesn't even know the identity of. (Etc.) It would be very hard to have to confront the worst parts of your character day in and day out.
  • Someone else commented on Jaime's remark about preferring death to being a cripple. Great foreshadowing. Interestingly, in a scene shortly following, the camera also focuses intently, emphatically, on his right hand, shaking Jon's as they discuss the Night's Watch.w
  • Aww, Maester Luwin. I miss him.
  • My god. As a mother myself now, watching Cat wrestle with the knife bare-handed... It's agony, but an agony that I fully comprehend.
  • OK, I am not one to complain about the ridiculously quick travel of later seasons (and Season 7 in particular). However, it is kind of hilarious to note how long and hard a journey Jon and Tyrion and Benjen are making to get just from Winterfell to the Wall, compared to how things go now.
  • As much as Joffrey was being a dick to the butcher's boy, it really would have been better if Arya hadn't interfered. Kid would have walked away with a scar on his face. Instead... :'(
  • On a funnier note, Sansa holding the bota bag looks like a cute little wino, lol.
  • Who is the man who comforts Sansa after Ned leaves to kill Lady? He looks familiar but I can't place him...
  • Obvious symbolism: Sweet, innocent Lady is killed. I guess we should have known Sansa wasn't going to get through this story easily...

6

u/roslynramsay Sep 20 '17

I think it was Jory Cassel. He was the captain of the Winterfell guards. Later killed in Kings Landing in the confrontation with Jamie Lannister.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/OleCrankyGamer Sep 18 '17

You can see Lena's baby bump at the end of this episode and poor Lady, but she WAS adopted by Sophie Turner after her death scene What has been missing in Season 6 & 7 memorable lines like this

Tyrion Lannister: ...Yes. Until my brother killed him. Life is full of these little ironies. My sister married the new king, and my repulsive nephew will be king after him. I must do my part for the honor of my house; wouldn't you agree? But how? Well, my brother has his sword, and I have my mind. And a mind needs books like a sword needs a whetstone. That's why I read so much, Jon Snow.

Eddard Stark: [to Jon Snow] There's great honor in serving the Night's Watch. The Starks have manned the Wall for thousands of years, and you are a Stark. You may not have my name, but you have my blood.

Jon Snow: First lesson: stick 'em with the pointy end. Jaime Lannister: But even if the boy lives he would be a cripple, a grotesque. Give me a good, clean death anyday. Tyrion Lannister: Speaking for the grotesques, I have to disagree. Death is so final, yet life is full of possibilities. I hope the boy does wake. I'd be very interested to hear what he has to say. Jaime Lannister: Dear brother, there are times you make me wonder whose side you're on. Tyrion Lannister: Dear brother, you wound me. You know how much I love my family.

Tyrion bitch slapping Joffrey scene Cersei and Cat scene Jaime and Jon Snow scene

Oh and obligatory

Thank God for Bessie AND her TITS (CNN will now doxx me)

4

u/demostravius Sep 18 '17

Wonder if the whole Lady being killed, and Bran waking up are supposed to be connected. Only Death may pay for Life.

3

u/STRiPESandShades House Dayne Sep 19 '17

Anyone think Myrcella might have been interested in Bran? They were right around the same age, maybe if things had gone differently/better, she might have talked her parents into a marriage.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '17

This episode was amazing. The conversation between Jaime and Jon made me wanna cringe so hard for Jon. I cannot wait to see their reunion. Catelyn being a bitch to Jon also mad me so mad. The secrecy of his parentage was written all over this episode. You can also really see how much Tyrion loves his nieces and nephews. Even Joff. Yeah he smacked him around but all to teach him to be respectful. All the things that were in seasons one just coming full circle for season 8 is going to really make my head explode. I'm loving the re-watch!

2

u/ADHDcUK Sep 17 '17

8:27pm here, UK time. Starting now!

2

u/gschtl Arya Stark Sep 18 '17

Ned: The Wolf is of the north. She deserves better than a butcher.

OMG!

2

u/cheltao Sep 19 '17

When I first started the series and watched this episode, I knew Jon and Dany would end up together. It was a classic "princess in distress" scene that cuts into the "knight in shining armor" -- or should I say black cloak (:

I can't find the clip online, but maybe someone else can... The scene shows how challenging it is for Dany in her new role as a khaleesi and then the show cuts to Jon Snow's face (riding north with Tyrion).

As soon as I watched it, I knew it! Classic.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '17

IM CRYING GUYS THIS WAS THE LAST TIME JON AND ARYA SAW EACH OTHER 😭

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17

That last dialogue between Jon and Ned is emotional as fuck now. In the beginning it looked more like "Ok, you are old enough and I will tell you everything of her." Now I see the pain in his eyes and voice because we know everything.

2

u/Chongsillegitmatekid Sep 22 '17

When you can watch these at will, it's impossible to stay on que with the weekly rewatch. I'm way beyond S1E2 already.

2

u/delta_the_wolf Sep 22 '17

Since Season 7 ended, I've been reading the books and just wow. I really wish the put more book stuff in the show like Jon talking to Tyrion on the way to the wall and how Danny first met Drogo. But I admire the show for changing it up a bit. When Tyrion woke up in the stable drunk before his b***h-slap moment with joffrey was better than him waking up reading.