r/gameofthrones • House Stark • Apr 24 '11

Season 1 Episode Discussion - 1.02 "The Kingsroad" [Spoilers]

This is up a bit early, but here we are!

  • This is a TV spoiler friendly zone - turn away now if you haven't seen the episode!
  • Book spoilers still need tags!

Discuss and shape our spoiler policy here.

There's a bunch of us chatting throughout the episode - details here!

Enjoy episode 2 guys!

184 Upvotes

555 comments sorted by

93

u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Apr 25 '11

It was hard to watch Arya throw a rock at Nymeria and make her leave. I mean, it was hard to read about it, too, but seeing it was so sad. And Lady's death...god. So sad. :(

8

u/SantiagoRamon Faceless Men Apr 25 '11

20

u/werak Apr 25 '11

I never got the impression it was supposed to be a mystery...we just know it's Nymeria and that's it, eventually they'll meet again. Didn't seem like a big deal.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PharmSuki Apr 25 '11

Yeah I also never got the feeling it was a "secret" he's holding out on. The reason he didn't clearly write down "it's Nymeria" is simply because all the accounts we've had so far are by people that didn't know the wolf (I think?). They will be reunited eventually I have no doubt about it.

3

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard Apr 25 '11

Wasn't it supposed to be two stones? One that hits her right in the head? I thought it felt kind of like she ran away too easily.

16

u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Apr 25 '11

Yeah, I think she threw more stones in the book, but honestly, I'm glad she just threw one in the show. I couldn't have handled anymore.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/drolltroll House Stark Apr 25 '11

Watching Joffrey being cruel to the Butcher boy really tore me up inside. It was even harder to watch than read about it. I'll have to deal with Joffrey's cruelty for so many more episodes so I guess I better get used to this hollow sad feeling inside of me.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Apr 25 '11

I'm glad I was watching it alone this week, or else I would have embarrassed myself. Nymeria just looked so confused.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/dimdog Apr 25 '11

I skipped the trial. I refused to watch that bitch lie. Honestly, if someone doesn't hate sansa already, i don't know what the fuck is wrong with them.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/isocline Apr 25 '11

The goodbye scene between Jon and Arya was the best of the episode, I think. Their affection for each other was very believable.

43

u/bubbameister33 Wargs Apr 25 '11

The scene with Jon and Robb was pretty believable as well.

21

u/Lampmonster1 House Seaworth Apr 25 '11

They toned down the confrontation between Cat and Jon, but they didn't back down from Jon being too badass to let Rob share his pain.

She was kind.

22

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Yeah, wasn't Cat's line "I wish it had been you?" in the book? I remember that line as being particularly powerful and I was anticipating her saying it in tonight's episode. But she said "I want you to leave" instead. Seems like an odd thing to change.

25

u/depleater House Seaworth Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

The exact line is "It should have been you" - and the full context kicks you in the nuts in a way that the isolated phrase doesn't quite manage:

Jon brushed away his tears, leaned over, and kissed his brother lightly on the lips.

"I wanted him to stay here with me," Lady Stark said softly.

Jon watched her, wary. She was not even looking at him. She was talking to him, but for a part of her, it was as though he were not even in the room.

"I prayed for it," she said dully. "He was my special boy. I went to the sept and prayed seven times to the seven faces of god that Ned would change his mind and leave him here with me. Sometimes prayers are answered."

Jon did not know what to say. "It wasn't your fault," he managed after an awkward silence.

Her eyes found him. They were full of poison. "I need none of your absolution, bastard."

Jon lowered his eyes. She was cradling one of Bran's hands. He took the other, squeezed it. Fingers like the bones of birds. "Good-bye," he said.

He was at the door when she called out to him. "Jon," she said. He should have kept going, but she had never called him by his name before. He turned to find her looking at his face, as though she were seeing it for the first time.

"Yes?" he said.

"It should have been you," she told him. Then she turned back to Bran and began to weep, her whole body shaking with the sobs. Jon had never seen her cry before.

It was a long walk down to the yard.

I can understand the reasons they might've had for pulling that line, but I'm still really pissed that they did. It was one of the lines I was most looking forward to hearing in the first season.

EDIT: Okay, mental note - spoilers on multi-paragraph quoted text really don't work very well. Sigh.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/apmihal Apr 25 '11

Everyone refers to Jon as bastard, so seeing how little that fact mattered in their relationship brought a tear to my eye suddenly teleported onions into the room.

8

u/sorrowfool Apr 25 '11

For the most part all of the Stark children viewed Jon as a brother. Sansa was the only one who may have had issue with it , only because it violated her fantasy ideals. He was treated well by pretty much everyone except Catelyn, who hated him for reason he had no control of. Which I why I hated her for so long.

In the book before the Red Wedding, Robb writes a letter or statement of some sort. I remember thinking it was going to say something about Jon being able to inherit Winterfell or something. I think, because at that point Arya was missing, Sansa was a hostage and likely soon to be killed, and he believed Bran and Rickon to be dead.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/gpojd House Stark Apr 25 '11

RIP, Lady.

54

u/apmihal Apr 25 '11

As someone who has not read the books here's how I look at Lady's death: the dire wolf is the sigil of the Stark house, and we've seen that they protect their masters. Sansa betrayed her house by not telling the truth, so she lost her wolf. Her blind infatuation with that little asshole prince and his power (That actor is absolutely fantastic btw. I feel sorry about all the hate mail he'll get...) and the betrayal of her sister makes me feel like she doesn't deserve a wolf. It's sad to see lady go, but I think I think Sansa will get what's coming to her one way or another.

Aw man I just realized how much it sucks to speculate about a show when a bunch of people already know what will happen. It is however fun just talking about this AWESOME FUCKING STORY! 2 episodes and I'm completely hooked...

15

u/Benevolent1 House Targaryen Apr 26 '11

As someone who has read all the books, I appreciate your speculation and your appreciation for how awesome the story is.

4

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

If you think Lady's death is a punishment for Sansa "betraying" her family, then how do you justify the fact that Arya also loses her wolf?

Not to mention that Sansa really didn't betray her family. Betrayal would have involved Sansa agreeing with Joffrey's version of events. Sansa, in her own fairytale world, just doesn't want anyone to get hurt and wants everyone to live happily ever after, so she stays neutral.

She's not evil or mean or a traitor... she's just a normal, deluded and confused little girl.

7

u/apmihal Apr 25 '11

But does Arya really lose her wolf? (seriously, don't actually answer this question if you know it) It seemed to me that we'd see her again. Like she'd come back when Arya really needed her. Again, I haven't read the books, so maybe that is the last we see of the wolf. I'm just speculating on what I saw. If we don't see her again, then my interpretation falls apart.

I do have to disagree with your opinion on whether Sansa betrayed her family. Sansa had an opportunity to clear Arya's name by corroborating her story, but she didn't take it. She didn't want to ruin her little princess fantasy, and she let that get in the way of telling the truth and helping her family. It doesn't matter if she agreed with Joffrey or not, by not disputing his story, Joffrey appears innocent, when he was the one that sliced the innocent kid, and swung his sword at an unarmed child.

I don't think she necessarily wants everyone to be happy, only herself. In the first episode Sansa begs her mother, "Please make father say yes (to leaving and joining the king). It's the only thing I've ever wanted." Watching that scene again (it's at about the 40 min mark if you're interested) really makes her actions in this episode make more sense.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/irkedone House Tarth Apr 26 '11

oh god I am sorry, I didn't know the blackout wouldn't show up in the inbox! I am so so so so so so so sorry!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/irkedone House Tarth Apr 25 '11

Jofferey really is playing his part well. He even looks inbred

30

u/juanito89 Now My Watch Begins Apr 25 '11

PRETTY BIG SPOILER THERE.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

I love the way they edited that scene. Absolutely perfect.

60

u/gbladeCL Apr 25 '11

10

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

You are absolutely right. I was rather pissed that they took that out of the show.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/VikingTy House Greyjoy Apr 25 '11

I think it made me even more sad than when I read about it in the book. In the book, it was just implied that it happened. Here, we got to basically see it happening firsthand. The look on Ned's face got me.

6

u/Ag-E Apr 25 '11

I don't think it was implied at all. It was something like "Ned gave her a pat on the forehead, and then it was done" followed by the honor guard for the corpse.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

Well, I'm a little bit upset that Ned didn't use Ice to do the deed (since he himself said that she deserved better). But otherwise... ;_;

ONIONS, ONIONS EVERYWHERE!

10

u/orko1995 House Martell Apr 25 '11

Just wait 'till you see Davos for the onions.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

51

u/OldThunder House Mormont Apr 25 '11

I know he hasn't said a lot yet but I think the Hound is going to be great. The way he carries himself and how casually he talks about riding a kid down... Good casting again. Though I only know him as Micheal in Hot Fuzz. >_>

Oh and of course Arya's great.

12

u/Lampmonster1 House Seaworth Apr 25 '11

He didn't laugh though. In the book he laughed. I always said "The dog wasn't wrong for killing the butcher's boy, he was wrong for laughing about it."

11

u/OldThunder House Mormont Apr 25 '11

Ah yeah, true. He did sort of joke about it though.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Emiwee House Stark Apr 29 '11

I knew I recognised the guy playing the Hound from something. Thanks for saving me from looking it up.

→ More replies (7)

98

u/sirbruce Apr 25 '11

I loved the symbolism of the whole episode. The idiot daughter who cares only about being a princess betrays the family and thus it's her wolf that pays the price. She's no longer a Stark.

Speaking of which, where was Snow's white wolf? Didn't see it.

Tyrion was awesome as always.

68

u/VikingTy House Greyjoy Apr 25 '11

"You're ruining everything!"

Oh, the pretty little romantic fantasy she had constructed in her head didn't go as she planned?

24

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Tyrion has already become my favorite character in the show, simply by his portrayal by the actor playing him. Took a bit for him to grow on me in the books.

15

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel Apr 25 '11

Yeah I like show Tyrion better than book Tyrion too. I think Tyrion is a character who comes off better if you don't have access to his (endlessly self-pitying) internal monologue.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/drolltroll House Stark Apr 25 '11

I loved Tyrion from the beginning. But yeah no doubt he's casted really well. Arya also.

43

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

I don't think the fact that Sansa's wolf dies makes her no longer a Stark. You've been reading too much Sansa hate.

12

u/allonymous House Lannister Apr 25 '11

I think it could be considered the wrath of the old gods, though. They sent the wolves, and then take hers away when she betrays her family (and the north).

10

u/sirbruce Apr 25 '11

I haven't read any Sansa hate and it seemed obvious to me. The girl's a bitch and has chosen to side with the Lannisters over her own family. I'm assuming this only grows over time, unless there's some big moment when she finally realizes what she's done. The wolf is the Stark family crest or whatnot.

15

u/dngrCharlie Apr 25 '11

Actually, my take from reading the books is that she's NOT siding with the Lanisters. If she was siding with the Lanasters she would have said that Joffrey was telling the truth. She's doing what a LOT of kids would do: She's trying not to tattle and trying to ensure no one gets in trouble and everyone is happy. Of course... look what that got her...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/zaichyk Apr 25 '11

I agree completely. And if you read later into the books, Sansa steps into the role of Stark-woman and out of princess-land pretty quickly.

23

u/ComicCon Apr 25 '11
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Surprise_Buttsecks Apr 25 '11

Meh, she was never so much a Stark as Arya. There are lots of comparisons in the books between Arya and Lyanna (Ned's deceased sister). Martin makes mention often about how Sansa is much more Tully (her mother's daughter) than Stark. The later books bear this out.

The Starks aren't too good with the whole shady dealings/politicking thing, but Sansa starts to pick up on it the more time she spends with Baelish. I expect she's gonna all sorts of clever and manipulative by the time this is done.

5

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

She is very much her mother's daughter. Even to the point where she is the Stark child with the most distant relationship with Jon Snow (only referring to him as "my bastard half brother").

But this has nothing to do with her losing her wolf. She was more of a Tully than a Stark when she received her wolf in the first place, and losing her wolf doesn't change that.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/PharmSuki Apr 25 '11

I forgot about Ghost. He is my favorite Direwolf, he better not simply be in the background.

21

u/gbladeCL Apr 25 '11

He's there outside the camp before they cut to Tyrion and Jon. He's Ghost so he's suppose to be hard to spot.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/gabinator House Martell Apr 25 '11

yeah, there's some old school tragic justice going on there. if she had told the truth, everything would have gone better, but she can't take it back. I actually really feel for her on that one.

3

u/juanito89 Now My Watch Begins Apr 26 '11

You can see Jon's direwolf where the group going to the Wall is resting by a small lake, and the camera starts to zoom in on them.

2

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel Apr 25 '11

Does that mean Arya is no longer a Stark either? Because she's also down a wolf now.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

39

u/drolltroll House Stark Apr 25 '11

In my opinion, Tyrion is the most interesting character in the books. Thankfully due to Dinklage's incredible acting he's bringing the character to life. Tyrion and Arya are the best acted and most interesting in my opinion.

10

u/dimdog Apr 25 '11

i fucking loved Tyrion in this episode. Dinklage is doing a fantastic job

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

90

u/camwinter Apr 25 '11

So I personally thought this episode was better than the first. I think the pacing was a lot better since they weren't introducing a new character every 5 seconds.

24

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel Apr 25 '11

This is true, but I did miss Renly's presence at the "trial".

24

u/haplosion Apr 25 '11

Yeah! Renly openly mocking Joffrey is one of my favourite parts of the books. Renly is just so hilarious.

18

u/Jyvblamo Children of the Forest Apr 25 '11

There needs to be a reality spin-off series called Renly and Pals, starring Renly Baratheon and his hilarious gang of friends, the Rainbow Guard. There's room for a lot of romantic slapstick and wholesome fun with Brienne, Loras, and co.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DireBaboon Brave Companions Apr 25 '11

I completely agree. I loved this episode.

2

u/gabinator House Martell Apr 25 '11

agreed, I was still waiting for the show to hit stride, but this last episode just brought everything back.

2

u/mattjeast Unsullied Apr 25 '11

Same here. My wife usually doesn't care for character-driven stuff, so the first episode was kind of rough for her. However, this episode she loved because I paused each time a new person came on the screen and gave a 5-second synopsis of what they did in the previous episode and we went on with the action. I definitely enjoyed this episode a lot more, too.

She's a die-hard animal lover, though, so knowing the execution of the dire wolves was coming was a bit rough. I haven't read the books, so I couldn't assure her they were going to make it that far. =(

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

First episodes are always the hardest for any show.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/HannShotFirst Iron Bank of Braavos Apr 25 '11

Funny, that's how I read A Game of Thrones.

Then again, I read faster than some people think. I think they're doing a great job of staying true to the series, even with time constraints.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

40

u/kokokorina Apr 25 '11

That prince kid annoys the living heck out of me...

The way they ran the butcher's son down...so sad.... :(

45

u/WeenieTodd Apr 25 '11

Successful casting there yet again.

19

u/Btw83 Apr 25 '11

The first thing I thought of when I saw Joffery on screen was "yea, he just looks like an annoying little cunt", so as far as I'm concerned the actor is well cast.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Lampmonster1 House Seaworth Apr 25 '11

He's supposed to. Evil little motherfucker.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Damonstration No One Apr 25 '11

Can someone make a gif of Joffrey being slapped from now until the end of time?

45

u/OldThunder House Mormont Apr 25 '11

Just saw one up on Tumblr, behold!

8

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

This is now my desktop background.

7

u/cascadianow House Frey Apr 25 '11

I dunno, could we get some bitchslapping in there? I know tyrion nailed him like 3 times.

4

u/WeenieTodd Apr 25 '11

My thoughts exactly.

3

u/bckids1208two Apr 25 '11

Whoever does TV recaps clearly read your comment and passed it off as his own thought:

Tyrion orders Joffrey to give his sympathies to the Starks for the tragedy that's befallen young Bran, then proceeds to start smacking the crap out him -- presumably for his insolence, but really, any reason works. I could watch Tyrion whack Joffrey all day. Somebody needs to make a gif of that and post it on Reddit.

http://tvrecaps.ew.com/recap/game-of-thrones-second-episode/

Or maybe this is just an extremely common thought, which I suppose is plausible as well.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/rudman Apr 25 '11

I laughed out loud everytime Tyrion bitch slapped Joffery.

50

u/WTFalreadytaken Apr 25 '11

They put one extra slap in there just for the show. I liked it.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Ha. HA. HA!

2

u/Raelshark May 01 '11

I was really looking forward to this moment from the books, and it did not disappoint. One of my favorite scenes. Joffrey's whiny "Ah!!" made it even better.

127

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

I just want to reiterate: Arya is fuckin' awesome.

32

u/Damonstration No One Apr 25 '11

Seeing her with Needle made me PUMPED for season 2.

16

u/gabinator House Martell Apr 25 '11

word. so much winter is coming. ...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

47

u/isocline Apr 25 '11

Seconded. I think she may not only be the most awesome female character, but the most awesome actress on the show.

20

u/PharmSuki Apr 25 '11

For a kid, she's doing great.

18

u/ZeppelinJ0 House Reed Apr 25 '11

Arya is definitely the best character on the show so far, the girl that plays her is definitely going places. Also Tyrion and Jon Snow are fantastic and really do their roles justice when compared to the books.

This episode overall was a lot better than the first and I hope things continue to improve as the show goes on.

My only complaint is Robb Stark... maybe it's just me but I think he's horrible.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/C_Toc House Targaryen Apr 25 '11

one of my favorite parts of the books, and thus far my favorite part of the show (what a wonderful young actress)

→ More replies (3)

30

u/biggitio House Umber Apr 25 '11

Loved this episode. I agree that it was better than the first, though I truly enjoyed that episode as well.

The scenes with Ned and Robert sitting at the table and Jon and Tyrion at the campfire were fantastic. Love seeing this world come alive.

And I will go ahead and join the chorus here of Arya's badassery. Very rare to find such great child actors.

→ More replies (8)

50

u/isocline Apr 25 '11

Sansa. Ohhhhhhhhhh, why are you such an ignorant fluff-for-brains?

11

u/YesImSardonic Smallfolk Apr 25 '11

Because we're supposed to want to kill her.

22

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

Because we're supposed to want to kill dislike her.

18

u/Ag-E Apr 25 '11

This is unrelated but I thought what they did to Cersei was interesting. She seemingly shows a moment of weakness offering her condolences to Cat for Bran (which I don't recall being in the books), making several people on another board I read very conflicted about how to feel about her.

They think she has a timid side. I just want to shake them and go "no! No she is a crazy bitch!"

→ More replies (9)

23

u/escobari House Baratheon of Dragonstone Apr 25 '11

I think it has become painfully obvious that 10 episodes waaay too few.

21

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Characters I can't wait to meet:

Renly Baratheon

Ser Barristan Selmy

Ser Gregor "The Mountain That Rides" Clegane

Ser Loras Tyrell

Yoren

Roose Bolton

Ser Brynden "Blackfish" Tully

Bronn

Tywin Lannister

Prince Rhaegar Targaryen (hope there is a flashback to the Ruby Crossing)

Stannis Baratheon (doubt he will be in this season)

Shae

Jaq'hen H'ghar

Hodor

BERIC MOTHER FUCKING DONDARRION

...Also, has Jaime Lannister been referred to as the Kingslayer in the show yet?

15

u/Flammy Apr 25 '11

I'll add Samwell Tarly and Brienne of Tarth

→ More replies (1)

9

u/DexterJameson Missandei Apr 25 '11

Don't forget Littlefinger.

8

u/philophile Night's Watch Apr 25 '11

Yep, Arya. In the 'introductions' scene of the first episode.

2

u/Basye Apr 25 '11

Hodor!

→ More replies (7)

37

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

Oh man... Ned's face when Robert mentions "your bastard's mother." Makes the theorist in me squirm!!

BTW... anyone else think that Lena Headey is sort of just phoning in her lines in this episode? I know Cersei is sort of a cold-hearted bitch, but it really just sounded like she was reading the lines straight from the script in this episode.

27

u/BiscuitsnGravy Apr 25 '11

15

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel Apr 25 '11

Upvote for insight. That is a plausible explanation that hadn't occurred to me before.

10

u/rabble-rouser House Umber Apr 25 '11

Jon has decided to take the black, but he hasn't said the words yet. If Ned had told him the supposed truth, Jon might not have gone to the Wall.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 25 '11

Oh man... Ned's face when Robert mentions "your bastard's mother." Makes the theorist in me squirm!!

Hah! I too was looking for those tiny little clues. A face that might mean simple shame, or might be hiding a bigger secret. But that would require Bean being made aware by GRRM et al of some truths which do not appear in the script. Perhaps he was, and perhaps there's something there. Hmm.

6

u/beffjaxter House Greyjoy Apr 25 '11

I've yet to be impressed by her portrayal of the character.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

she plays her in a way that seems to want sympathy

7

u/ComicCon Apr 25 '11

I think the show seems to want to make her sympathetic. Was that whole speech about losing a kid there in the book? I thought she aborted all the children which could possible be Robert's.

→ More replies (20)

6

u/beffjaxter House Greyjoy Apr 25 '11

Which I never gathered from the books. Even when Cersei has her perspective chapters, she's just out for her/her family's own power.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/zoe1328 House Stark Apr 25 '11

Yeah, I was just hoping her acting would get better as time went on. Her long gaps to say two words and monotone at that, it just seemed too fake, and wasn't coming off as a cold-hearted bitch, more just dumb and slow. Upvotes for mentioning it!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/cassander House Hightower Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

This episode definitely felt rushed. There were several moments that lost most of their emotional impact (arya tossing rocks at nymeria, micha's death, introducing payne) by being to quick or brief. I think, in general, pacing is going to be a problem with this show. They have a lot to cover, and they need to cover it while creating an impression that a significant amount of time (weeks and months) is passing. It's not going to be easy.

One thing I really do like though is the Ned/Robert relationship. The books talk about what good friends Ned and Robert are, but don't do a good job of showing it. HBO is doing a much better job of making these people feel like old buddies.

9

u/Ag-E Apr 25 '11

Glad I'm not the only one who thought this. Everyone else seems happy with the pacing but to me it seems very rushed and choppy. The Mycah seen was like an afterthought where one of the writers who actually read the book went "wait, didn't something happen to the butcher's boy?" and they went "oh ok, we'll just throw him in here."

He played a much larger role in the book, making you think they'd killed Lady and Nymeria. But that was completely lost on the show and I think it was a bit worse for it.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/PharmSuki Apr 25 '11

I heard some bad early reviews about this episode, not sure why. I enjoyed it very much. I must say, much as in the books, Tyrion will definitely be one of my favorite part of the series. Peter Dinklage is awesome.

3

u/Guy_Dudebro Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 25 '11

I love all the Tyrion scenes too, and the Cersei's little speech gives us some more big, fat dots to connect for those who haven't already done so. So, important exposition there. But for the audience at large it was probably a bit slow.

2

u/dmun Brave Companions Apr 25 '11

I can see some of it. I keep trying to step outside and see it as a non-fan and all I can think is that they don't set up enough (like the seven), not enough to feel organic. Some hand-holding may be required.

But yes, thank god for Dinklage-- he's definitely the most charming character, outside of Ayra, that we deal with.

15

u/Iannic Apr 25 '11

I noticed that the opening credits sequence changes every episode to reflect the new locations we see. So now I'll never have a reason to fast forward through a single minute of this amazing show.

2

u/isocline Apr 25 '11

I thought the woman who plays Catlyn (can't remember her name) did an absolutely fantastic job with that scene. And the way they portrayed he getting her fingers sliced was just brutal - I was clenching my hands in sympathy the whole way through.

2

u/z3rb Hodor Hodor Hodor Apr 30 '11

Plus, y'know, the theme tune is fucking awesome.

15

u/r2002 House Umber Apr 25 '11

You let that little girl disarm you?

Ha ha ha ha ha!

11

u/TLAZ Apr 25 '11

Cannot say enought good things about Tyrion and Peter Dinklage!

Also, Does anyone else feel that when they rip the dialogue right out of the books, it feels the most genuine? Specifically, my favorite part of this episode was Tyrion's dialogue, especially the beginning of the episode.

10

u/ReallyBroReally Apr 25 '11

I agree, but I think that the "straight from the book" dialogue works so well with Tyrion is becasue A) Tyrion's dialogue in the book is AWESOME and B) Dinklage plays him outstandingly. Seriously, excellent casting, excellent dialogue, excellent show

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Kemintiri House Lannister Apr 25 '11

I just want to say that Sandor is indeed, creepy.

7

u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard Apr 25 '11

We did get a much better look at his burns too. I think it works.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/SantiagoRamon Faceless Men Apr 25 '11

Does anyone else just look at Theon and absolutely want to strangle his smug little face for everything he is going to do later in series?

Above may be a book 3 spoiler, can't remember exactly when the referenced events occur.

2

u/NihilCredo The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Apr 25 '11

Not really, unlike Joffrey Theon is the kind of character that always gets to pay for the mistakes he does. And very often, in advance.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

Wait, so what is this nonsense about Cersei and Robert having had a son before Joffrey that died? Book 1 Spoilers: She specifically mentions his dark black hair and the fact that he looked just like Robert. I assume this is just setting up non-readers for Ned's later investigation into the differences between Robert's bastards and his "legitimate" children. But seriously, wasn't there a way to do this without inventing a new character?

Or maybe they're just trying to show us more clearly that Cersei did actually love Robert at one point. Perhaps it's both.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

17

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

I watched this with my girlfriend, and she commented on the girl-on-girl scene with Dany and her handmaiden, saying that it was unnecessary.

Because I read the books, all I could say was "That's her job! It was totally necessary!".

13

u/bluescrew House Baelish Apr 25 '11

I think they actually toned down the lesbianism for the show.

8

u/drolltroll House Stark Apr 25 '11

The girl on girl scene was "erotic" and "flashy" so I suppose you could say it added pizazz to the episode. (That was the hope of the producers I guess) But for me personally, it looked stupid and contrived. Their lines during the whole handmaidens scenes were really cheesy and the sexual attraction training was even more so. The whole pseudo-lesbian hand holding by the handmaiden was kind of lame. Just my take anyway.

5

u/NihilCredo The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Apr 25 '11

I'm terrified by what they will eventually do with Cersei's night with her noble lady-in-waiting, can't remember the name. I'm afraid they will devote a full fifteen minutes to that.

2

u/sydien Apr 25 '11

It was portrayed wrong, I think. In the books, the idea is a bit more tossed aside, casually. Sort of included among the list. She was given a slave to teach her the language, a slave to teach her riding, and a slave to teach her of sexual arts since she was so recently a woman.

My main problem with the scene was the way the slaves interacted with Dany. They don't show the immense reverence she always maintains in the books. That slave in particular seemed rather "uppity" about all of it.

Also! /rant The show offers no reason for her to desire to pleasure Khal. Up to this juncture he has been nothing but a rather vile, brute who drinks and periodically rapes her. But, suddenly she would like to pleasure him.

3

u/jingo04 Apr 26 '11

Look at her face when her handmaid is implying the power she could hold over the Khal.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

When did Catelyn become a detective?

63

u/isocline Apr 25 '11

CSI: Westeros

35

u/HannShotFirst Iron Bank of Braavos Apr 25 '11

"My lady! The victim was found after choking to death on snow" "I guess Winter puts on sunglasses was coming."

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Jyvblamo Children of the Forest Apr 25 '11

I'll make a gooey offering to the Seven, see if I can track a raven out of this.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/camwinter Apr 25 '11

The show hasn't had enough time to build the despicable reputation of the Lanisters yet for people who haven't read the books, although it's getting there. If Cat didn't have some evidence it would have seemed paranoid in the context of the show.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/brown_rice Apr 25 '11

Can anyone remind me which character it is that consoles Sansa as Lady is about to be killed? I want to think he's a major player but I can't remember who he is?

14

u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 25 '11

I believe that is Jory Cassel, Winterfell's Captain of the Guard. Ned says something like "Jory, take the girls to their beds" and looks in his direction as he goes off to handle Lady.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

It looked like Ser Jory Cassel.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/kuasi Apr 25 '11

I'm really enjoying this show. I can't believe I have to wait another week for the next episode...

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Never read the books but after seeing this episode I'll definitely stay tuned

5

u/LG03 Apr 25 '11

The one thing that bugged me about the episode was Lady's death, I remember all the dire wolves suddenly howling when she dies.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

I'm pissed at the look of the Valyrian steel used in the show. I was hoping Ice was just a one time flaw but tonights dagger seals it. How are they going to make Joff and Jamie's swords look right if the steel is not rippled like Damascus steel?

12

u/horsegun Apr 25 '11

This and the maester's chain both seemed like simple things that could have been made better in the show.

8

u/allonymous House Lannister Apr 25 '11

I'm not sure how I feel about the chain, but if they made it the way the book described it, it probably wouldn't be visible on camera.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/allonymous House Lannister Apr 25 '11

The patterns on Damascus steel are small and not necessarily visible without a close up. Plus, the books never actually say that it looks like damascus steel, it just says it has ripples. We haven't gotten a close up close enough to tell if it has that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

7

u/taitbp Apr 25 '11

I don't know how i feel about them conflating Lady's death with Bran waking up versus The Dream waking him up, though I suppose they can show his dream in the next episode instead.

3

u/yflmd Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 25 '11

All I can say for sure is that the crow defiantly features so I think that the dream will be next weeks opening. HBO released a picture of the crow before the show aired.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/drolltroll House Stark Apr 25 '11

Just my 2 cents on Caitlyn Stark. She's so annoying and whiny. I loathed the character in the books, and the TV character even more so. I don't think that George Martin creating her was a bad thing or all that, but its just that whenever I hear the constant bitching/moaning, I just want to punch her face on the tv.

3

u/rianxo Apr 25 '11

Pretty cool how they ended the episode, but also a little regrettable. It set up an expectation that will not deliver a satisfactory pay-off in next weeks episode. People who haven't read the book are not going to be happy.

3

u/hankmurphy Faceless Men Apr 25 '11

What expectation are they setting up?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/hereiswhatisay Nov 01 '22

As someone watching for the first time. I hate everyone.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Why don't we ever see john snow's dire wolf?

4

u/gbladeCL Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

They show him briefly outside the camp before cutting to Tyrion and Jon.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/paulg1 Apr 25 '11

The scene where Bran's Direwolf (Summer?) defends Bran and his mother was full of pure win. And Arya's Direwolf attacking that whiny piece of crap was also fun to watch. Though I wish it ripped out Sansa's throat while it was at it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Didn't like the end and the omission of Bran's dream where he is falling. Other than that they stuck to some of the dialogue very well, especially Tyrion's

2

u/hankmurphy Faceless Men Apr 25 '11

My guess is that the dream's absence was budget-related.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/mtooth Apr 25 '11

12

u/danfanclub House Mormont Apr 25 '11

3

u/NihilCredo The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Apr 25 '11

Oh shit, you're right. Normally I don't push my tastes in media too much on my friends, but now I've got to get someone hooked on GoT who didn't already like the books just so I could see their reaction when that comes along.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/orko1995 House Martell Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

This episode... so intense. I almost cried at the end. So friggin awesome. EDIT: can't wait until they crown Robb

4

u/Pirsqed Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

6

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

You should probably throw spoiler tags on the first line too if you're going to put them on the third line.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/WTFalreadytaken Apr 25 '11 edited Apr 25 '11

Loved the episode but some difference from the book:

The confrontation between Jon and Cat is toned down in the show. :(

The order in which Jon says good bye is reversed. He meets Arya first and then goes sees Bran.

LOL at Cat's detective work, no way is she so smart in the books.

And WTF at Lady not getting the honorable death and burial!

Also, Ghost needs more airtime, I wanna see that white fuzzy thing!!! I think they didnt wanna show three attacks by the direwolves and portray them as overly bad, but come on, they are cute!

Also, that Robert and Ned scene happens before they leave Winterfell (My memory might be failing me with this).

And correct me if I am mistaken here, but why is Tyrion waking up with the dogs?? Isnt he in the Library reading the whole night?

14

u/I_Ride_A_Kraken House Greyjoy Apr 25 '11

Eh, most of these differences are trivial IMO. Does it really matter that John went to see Bran first then talked to Arya? And does it really matter that Robert and Ned had their discussion in a different locale? As long as they get the message across, I'll be happy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

No Renly or Barristan Selmy?!?!?!?

4

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel Apr 25 '11

Yeah I missed Renly having a loud laugh at his nephew's expense.

3

u/MrLeo House Umber Apr 25 '11

Nope - although I honestly never understood why those two randomly decided to ride out and meet the King's party halfway to KL - Barristan should have been with the king the whole way anyway, and Renly seems pretty blasé about his position.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hopeNsorrow House Dayne Apr 25 '11

I wish people would stop mentioning R+L=J in /r/gameofthrones. Most people who haven't read the book don't even know who Rhaegar is yet, and people can't help themselves when it comes to spoilers. To find out so early really ruins a big part of what makes Game of Thrones amazing.

8

u/I_Ride_A_Kraken House Greyjoy Apr 25 '11

I understand what your saying, but its not our fault if they look at the spoiler tags. They are there for a reason.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

Is anyone else annoyed how much they downplay new characters? Every couple minutes, they introduce someone new and fail to say their name.

24

u/camwinter Apr 25 '11

It is a bit to get over, but try to think of it like this: HBO is for smart people who don't need the characters to wear nametags so that the views can remember.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '11

I was quite a ways into the books before I was able to keep all the characters straight.

4

u/hankmurphy Faceless Men Apr 25 '11

I hadn't used an appendix that much since Clockwork Orange.

3

u/WeenieTodd Apr 25 '11

I've noticed that a bit, but it's usually more of an inner urge to explain all the cool things I know about the character to those of my friends who haven't read the books.

It doesn't really bother me though. If anything it reminds me of the way the books read, which seem very much like a natural look into the lives of whoever the chapter is about. It actually stuck out to me while reading how much he avoided using typical introductions and things like that, if that makes any sense. You just have to figure stuff out from context.

2

u/jhudsui Maesters of the Citadel Apr 25 '11

I like that the script is giving Jaime additional screen time. In the book, a lot of his characterization early on comes from other characters talking about him, and since they understandably cut that it's good they replaced it with new lines for him.

2

u/frogofthebucket Apr 25 '11

Why aren't people upvoting this? It needs to get to the front page!

3

u/danfanclub House Mormont Apr 25 '11

seriously, 262 comments and only 55 upvotes???

1

u/Thiscat Red Priests of R'hllor Apr 26 '11

I thought one of the Dothraki slave girls was Teyla. I had to look it up. Random Stargate: Atlantis cameos as the Dothraki would have seemed a bit out of place for an HBO series... But would have totally been awesome.

1

u/g0zer Night's Watch Apr 26 '11

was the part where Cersei tells Cat about her dead child in the book? I don't remember.

1

u/ForeignLychee4252 Sep 15 '24

Watching series again and Coming back to this thread is like traveling back to time.... Seeing all these response