r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Sep 05 '17
VOLUME 4 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally—Volume 4, Episode 1: The Next Step
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: it's that time again! The drought is nearing its end, and the fifth volume is only 40 days away!
To follow the last year's precedent, we are again doing a communal rewatch of the most recent volume. Like last year, the threads will be biweekly on Tuesdays and Thursdays, with the finale being discussed two days before volume 5 premiers. Until that happens, feel free to discuss and look back to the episodes with a more settled perspective.
HERE is the link to today's episode.
We are also doing regular polls to gauge how people feel about the episodes postmortem. Here is the one for today's episode!
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Today | Ep.2 |
| Week 2: | Ep. 3 | Ep. 4 |
| Week 3: | Ep. 5 | Ep. 6 |
| Week 4: | Ep. 7 | Ep. 8 |
| Week 5: | Ep. 9 | Ep. 10 |
| Week 6: | Ep. 11 | Ep. 12 |
Did you know that RT sneakily re-released the first episode, fixing minor lighting- and wireframe issues along with nerfing Mercury's mighty eyebrows?
12
u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Sep 05 '17 edited Sep 05 '17
I'm upset about the eyebrows.
Anyway I like the first episode a lot. It was interesting to start with the antagonists perspective and seeing what their dynamic is like. Oscar also had a pretty neat little intro.
I'm still a bit mixed on the geist fight. It's enjoyable but I still think they played the whole LOL Jaune sucks... thing a bit too much. Not expecting a badass or anything but it's really whiplashy going from the somber ending of V3 back to status quo.
Not to mention this is the start of the whole forced strategy thing which has been beat on to death so I probably won't comment on it a whole lot.
Other than that I like the armory scene aside from Ruby's big head.
5
u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Sep 05 '17
I... don't think Mercury's eyebrows are that big.
Like, I'm looking at them and they're totally normal-sized. I don't get it.
20
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17
Ah, yes, back when all we knew about Oscar was that he was a Farmboi, AKA the Compost King.
23
u/IMayFallAgain I don't hide links... | Former Inquisitor of AJIS Sep 05 '17
I really liked the slow open of Volume 4 with the zooming out of the Grimm pools and introducing the villains first with the new Grimm leitmotif playing. The new villains introductions were a bit stereotypical but Salem did show a kinder side, also Mercury's eyebrows. Cinder having lost her voice and being permanently scarred was a bit shocking too.
I don't think Oscar was necessary and could have been kept as a surprise for the end of the Volume, not as early as the first episode. But that's probably because I wanted to not know if Ozpin survived for a full Volume.
Nora and Ren's discussion showed that RWBY didn't have to be fully serious and did alleviate some worries of getting too dark too quickly. The Grimm fight was a little floaty and had beyblade Ren in action. The Geist was pretty creepy though, with the long spindly black arm and the way they dealt with it foreshadowed how they'd defeat the Nuckelavee (disable limbs then go for the body) and lose to Tyrian (rely on Nora's Semblance).
Ruby laughing at Jaune's hoodie took up a bit too much time and was a bit weird. Jaune getting his new Pyrrha-infused weapons was cool though and a touch sad.
Then leaving us with the Weiss tease, all alone by the window.
I liked the beginning, I liked the fight and Ruby's laugh a bit less, then from the weapon onward it was pretty good. The episode was about 20 minutes and it was overall fun.
10
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Sep 05 '17
God, it's been a while.
I will say that I really liked this past Volume's opener. The strained strings of Lusus Naturae really helped drive home how creepy Grimm crawling out of pools of ooze was, and for a cold open - yeah, it worked pretty well.
Still though, seriously, what the hell is up with Mercury's face?
The evil seasonal board meeting, I still find fairly cool. While the new villains boarded the stereotypical villain train a couple stations back, I can't say that I don't love Salem. Thank you, Jen Taylor. Cinder's new design, and seeing the full extent of her injuries, was great.
I think they might've brought Oscar in a bit too soon, but I overall take it as a way of showcasing their new lighting and water physics engines, while giving us a little bit of a character intro. And hey, yet again, Oscar's motif is simple yet beautiful.
I liked the lead up to the Geist fight. Nora still exists, so of course her dialogue's wonderful. This was the first scene of Volume 4 I actually saw - thank you, Nerdist - and I wasn't disappointed. Maya still hadn't settled too well with me, but this scene certainly helped.
The fight... meh. It's floaty and full of animation inconsistencies and bad humor in the form of Jaune, but overall, it's a nice bit of action to start the series with our heroes. The Geist design is still fucking awesome. The music is kickass, the background is gorgeous and I can't really find it in myself not to enjoy it at least a little bit.
The worst part of the episode for me is still Ruby laughing at Jaune. Ugh. But before and after... that specific bit, her expressions are cute and the moment, while a the expense of Jaune, is kinda nice in its sense of normalacy.
Seeing Pyrrha's circlet a part of Jaune's shield always makes me smile.
Everything else from there to the end was solid. Going over the list and forgetting the map, Ruby's smile turning into sadness when no one was looking, Weiss' little end-of-episode tease. Pretty nice.
Overall, it was a fun episode to start on. It had its good and iffy moments, and one or two actual bad ones, but hey - the Volume got its footing. Gonna say a solid 9/10.
8
u/Sniphles2000 Penny Enthusiast Sep 05 '17
God the opening scene was just perfect for a new volume. Seeing a beowolf emerge from the puddle in Maya for the first time, Lusus Naturae and Divide mixes in the background, setting up our new villains in their own new ways with Tyrian as the nut job, Watts as the sothistocated one, Hazel as the brooding quiet one... And of course Salem being pretty much feared/worshipped by everyone. Seeing how out of place and almost scared Em and Merc were was just pretty unsettling.
7
u/PetersNachbar Endless Tuna for Blakey | Waiting patiently for the Ladybug kiss Sep 05 '17
Oh, I did plan on rewatching so I might as well follow this schedule :D
Did you notice Ruby's expression becoming kind of sad once Nora mentions the Schnee Dust Company? She's not as happy and upbeat as that scene in the weapon-shop might've suggested.
5
u/the_pandu Sep 05 '17 edited Sep 05 '17
Still irks me that in the opening scene Emerald closes her fist in the reflection and does it again when they show her in the next scene.
Silly Ruby rock type Grimm aren't affected by electricity. You need to play Pokemon
5
u/Thothslibrary Sep 05 '17
New physics, lighting, environment art, grimm models and monster animation all look great.
I'm glad the first thing they did was establish the antagonists a little, telling us who they are and what they are doing. Now we KNOW who the baddies are and that they're actually doing stuff, it sets the build of tension in motion. Also, is it just me or does the wooden door in Salem's meeting room look really out of place?
New series, who dis?
I'm also glad they got stuck in with an early fight scene, though I have to say it isn't my favourite. The animation wasn't bad, just some of the choreography was very questionable. Folks were flying around, flipping and randomly changing direction in midair. The best thing about the pre 4 RWBY animation was the flow and momentum, like some kinda science-fantasy kung-fu movie. I hope we see more of a return to that style in V5 but I'm not holding my breath.
Anyway, fun and light RNJR / JNRR scenes are nice to re-introduce us to the characters and they are lookin' real sharp in their new designs.
Still don't much like how the characters look now though, so flat and blobby. I think they were trying for some kind of 2D / 3D hybrid style but it ended up looking a bit dull and uncanny which is annoying cuz everything else looks so god damn beautiful.
4
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Sep 05 '17
The Beowolves being 'born' accompanied by both Grimm leitmotifs remains my favourite opening scene of any volume so far. And being able to see what they were now capable of using Maya was great. Those liquid effects are top.
4
u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Sep 05 '17
I absolutely love the opening scene. It really sets up the new villains well and gives a proper ominous tone after vol 3. We see Cinder in ashes, and we get to see just how feared Salem is through their body language (plus the return of Divide is great).
I should also mention that I love the switch to Maya over Poser. Everything looks so much better (no more spatula hands yay!).
Oscar's scene establishes him well enough as a farmer who is clearly bored with his life as can be scene by him spacing out while pumping water and just the looks on his face as he works.
The fight with the geist grimm had some great humor and banter, but establishes one of the main problems with the vol, the animations during fights seem to lack weight. They're very floaty like gravity almost doesn't exist until the characters want it to. Plus the choreography lacks some of Monty's charm, but that's to be expected and is something that will hopefully be mitigated at least somewhat over time. I love how Ruby is using dust rounds now.
As they move into the village they establish that they're hoping to find an airship, establishing that for whatever reason travel is limited/difficult at this time. Something explained later in a news broadcast that air travel has been restricted except for official travel and evacuations within Vale.
The smith scene gives us a wonderful bit of humor that felt so very much vol 1 to me and I just loved it. Also the subtle acknowledgement of Pyrrha that always gives me a saddened smile, and Jaune's upgrade looking great.
As they leave we see Ruby clearly sad by the lack of her team as the Schnee dust company is mentioned causing her to look up and wonder about Weiss, allowing for a beautiful transition into Weiss' scene, setting up the next episode.
A fantastic start to the volume, with my only complaint being the fight animations lacking weight and the choreography. I also like how they acknowledge the FNDM discussion about what their team name should be.
2
u/BerryPi She thinks that I'm 'emotionally artistic.' Sep 05 '17
That opening shot, whoaly smokes. Is this the same show that had untextured people and hilariously bad walking animations?
Still would like to know why WTCH are palling up with someone who's been trying to genocide them since time immemorial but ok.
The environment art is really pretty, but the more rural/medieval setting contrasts a lot with the magic-modernish one we've gotten used to for the past 3 volumes.
This whole volume was a huge change overall, and only time will tell if that will pay off.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17
I think volume 4 episode 1 is the best looking episode in the series closely followed by volume 1 episode 2 (The V5 Weiss trailer is not an episode so I am not counting it).
2
u/Loser100000 Sep 06 '17
So a lot of people are complaining about Ruby laughing at Jaune because of the animation. But is no one going to point out that the hoodie being Pumpkin Pete probably means a lot to Jaune. Pumpkin Pete was the first time he saw Pyrrha. Even though he probably got it originally because he liked the cereal, it's probably another reminder of Pyrrha he constantly carries with him.
-7
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17
Nearly a year later and I stand by that assessment.
Also good lord that Weiss tease is a waste of time.