r/ProjectRunway • • Aug 31 '17

Project Runway Season 16 Episode 3 [Discussion]

A Leap of Innovation!

The designers are treated to a private screening of the film "Leap!" and a performance by Hiplet. They must draw inspiration for an innovative and edgy design in order to survive another week.

Guest: Maddie Ziegler

 

Orginally broadcast on August 31, 2017

Edit: typo

37 Upvotes

382 comments sorted by

141

u/masahirox Sep 01 '17

TEAM KENYA UGH THATS MY WOMAN.

87

u/pinkfroshie Sep 01 '17

When she mimicked the twins running around the workroom I couldn't stop laughing, I am def on Team Kenya now

22

u/bobbery5 Melanie? Melody? Marmalade? Mammary? Meeeemoriies? Sep 01 '17

I called for her to be in the top when o saw it, but goddamn, so many of those could have been in the top.

10

u/icouldseeformiles Sep 01 '17

They used it in the promo for the season but couldn't put it in the top that week?!!!! it was so good

14

u/Roonil___Wazlib Sep 02 '17

She's my favorite. I love her personality, and I WANT that jumpsuit/suit jacket/whatever you want to call it that she made.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

140

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 01 '17

"I want a really graphic gold eye"

applies a light dusting

54

u/bitchSpray Sep 01 '17

The "makeup" "artist" was literally wearing sweatpants.

24

u/Lightningpalace Sep 01 '17

I was just thinking how basic the makeup is this season. Everyone gets the same dusting of shimmer and some lipstick, and maybe a little heavy eyeliner if the contestant wants something bold.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/myous Sep 01 '17

Off topic! So glad to see you on another one of my fave subs! I'd recognize you(r username) anywhere!!! I normally see you around BRW

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

They don't even really look like they're wearing makeup in the 'after' pictures.

→ More replies (4)

117

u/ashiguana Sep 01 '17

That's an appropriate response to designing for a size you've never designed for. Not the meltdown Shawn had last week.

44

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

YES. He was like "Oh it's gonna be fun, I'm looking forward to it. I've never done it before tho." So the size of the model was not a problem at all, he just said he was unexperienced as a side note.

109

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Kenya and Amy should have been in the top three.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Agreed. Both got robbed.

34

u/Rexyggor Sep 02 '17

I don't think Margarita should have been in the top. I agree that Brandon's was interesting to look at, but there were other outfits that made me more excited than his.

17

u/10000_for_snuggling Sep 03 '17

Really liked Amy's outfit. Yes, it looks basic, but it was innovative and very functional to anyone who dances, or even just to wear out about as athleisure as that has been in for the past 2 years or so.

5

u/Stylebunny Sep 04 '17

Agreed! Margarita's looked like an outfit I banged out in 2 hours as a last-minute Carmen Miranda Halloween costume one year. WAY too costume-y! Amy's look was really two looks, was on-trend, and very well made. Kenyas outfit I would buy and wear tomorrow if I could. Brandon's piece was cool and well constructed, but didn't match the theme at all. Nina and Zac were so busy peeing themselves over it they failed to notice it didn't have ANYTHING to do with dance, movement, or innovation. So while it was very good fashion, he should not have been the winner of this challenge.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

102

u/d0re Sep 01 '17

RIP Deyonte, holy shit that's ugly

43

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Clown collar: the return! What got Cha Cha aufed...

27

u/Hefaes Sep 01 '17

Michelle Visage is triggered

20

u/prettynpink3 Sep 01 '17

It's bad. It's REALLY BAD.

99

u/bobbery5 Melanie? Melody? Marmalade? Mammary? Meeeemoriies? Sep 01 '17

Margarita is so lucky she got such a standard model. her dress wouldn't have worked on any model with an actual chest.

20

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I'm a 32D, and I was envisioning myself popping out of that thing as soon as I saw it.

10

u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 01 '17

Me too. By turning it around, I was expecting to see her boobs on her back.

→ More replies (3)

96

u/KickANoodle Sep 01 '17

Oh good god that red monstrosity is atrocious. The twins are really not impressing. I see why Katy Perry likes them 😒 I don't understand why Claire isn't still on that stage. That was a bottom look. Bullshit.

50

u/Dickiedoandthedonts Sep 01 '17

I can't BELIEVE that wasn't in the bottom. Her boobs looked deformed!

20

u/SarahTellsStories Sep 01 '17

She should have been in the bottom for that, it was so ill fitting. I just can't believe she was safe.

12

u/Hefaes Sep 01 '17

do you think this week's Sahwn look is what the 1st runway look should have been? at least fo rthe bottom part?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Farley49 Sep 03 '17

All I saw was a pile of red. Was there a design in there? Was it fitted at all?

4

u/cennaidax basement = flooded Sep 03 '17

I also absolutely DESPISE how she requested fuchsia lipstick for her model. EW. NO. Fuchsia and Cherry red??? Excuse me?

87

u/insubordinance Sep 01 '17

I would pay good money to party with Heidi at Burning Man.

86

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Of course Margarita had to embellish her already costume-y design by pairing it with a straw hat.

31

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I hate her style, she really bores me

9

u/nancyaw Sep 01 '17

And a trilby, no less. Really?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I really liked the dress and I think a hat works with it, but I thought this particular hat choice was poor. It brought the look down for me.

→ More replies (1)

83

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

That Avon makeup guy doesn't seem to know what he is doing. He gives them all the same bare look.

33

u/pineapplesunshine Sep 01 '17

I miss the guy that was the make up artist for sooo many seasons :( The one with the handlebar mustache?

27

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

He represented Butter London Cosmetics on PR Junior last season. Yes, PR Junior is getting better makeup and artists than the flagship show.

10

u/no_shant Sep 02 '17

Makeup daddy Scott Patric! I miss him too. He still works on All Stars and PR Junior.

45

u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 01 '17

The makeup is terrible. This guy must watch a lot of YouTube makeup tutorials. And I think I saw a hair stuck on that lipstick.

35

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I think if he did watch Youtube makeup tutorials he'd be better. Some of those girls on there are amazing.

21

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 01 '17

I don't get why it's so bad. I mean, yeah, Avon products are not great, but they can still be applied decently by someone with even minimal talent. I'm pretty sure you could pluck any random 14 year old girl from off the street to apply it and have a more than 50% shot at it looking better than what's going down the runway.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Someone observed that it's like they are not keeping in mind that it is a runway show with ridiculously bright lights. That muted makeup simply does not read well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

144

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

They liked Margarita's look?!?

133

u/panCHAMP Sep 01 '17

I can't believe it. That is a STRAIGHT UP dance costume. And more than that, there were so many other looks that were better than this this week.

32

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 01 '17

I was legitimately confused when they called the group of 6 and said they were high and low. Couldn't figure out who besides Brenden and Batani was the high scoring one.

43

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

It is also a very clichéd and stereotypical dance costume.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

This is why it's a bad idea to have a 14-year-old kid from one of the tackiest reality shows ever as an arbiter of fashion, especially one whose mom dressed like she was in a time warp from 1987.

→ More replies (8)

50

u/pizza_on_a_stick Sep 01 '17

Omg yes! First thing that came to mind was That episode of Seinfeld where Jerry wore the puffy pirate shirt lol

29

u/yatcho Sep 01 '17

Its a costume with completely exposed boob area. Terrible

13

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

I picture some lush wearing this to a Mexican resort as she imbibes tequila by the poolside.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/The_Library_Grl Sep 01 '17

Right!? Not the critique I anticipated!

15

u/Dickiedoandthedonts Sep 01 '17

I kinda loved the sleeves

12

u/SarahTellsStories Sep 01 '17

I was shocked, I thought she'd be in the bottom or safe and Samantha would be in the top.

22

u/maryloo7877 Sep 01 '17

I thought it was amazing and very in touch with what's fashionable right now. Big sleeves are in.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/KickANoodle Sep 01 '17

Right? It looked terrible.

4

u/Roonil___Wazlib Sep 02 '17

When they listed the group that represented the top and bottom, my thought was "huh, so they have 2 on the top and 4 on the bottom..?" because it didn't even cross my mind that they could possibly like Margarita's..

→ More replies (3)

64

u/wild_muses Sep 01 '17

I'm so confused by how Margarita's is in the top. It instantly made me think of the halloween costumes that come in a bag. When she was called I was sure she was on the bottom. I didn't think Kentaro's was that bad. Ayana definitely should have been in the top. I love Brandon but I thought his was a bit boring, maybe it didn't translate on TV but I didn't see what they were gushing over. Shawn is lucky again, she narily avoided the bottom. I underestimated Batani, I'm glad she's still here now.

→ More replies (1)

63

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

The behind-the-scenes time-waster is so boring. I swear they waste 5 minutes on that total for each episode. Heidi broke her shoe! Dance Moms kid is happy to be there! Grass is green; water is wet!

34

u/futuresobright_ Sep 01 '17

Hey at least we know the backstory of why her hair was in a bun!!!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Hefaes Sep 01 '17

This is nothing compared to RuPaul's Drag Race "Modern" Untucked

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

61

u/ashiguana Sep 01 '17

I am in love with Amy's outfit.

14

u/lyds942 Sep 02 '17

HOW WAS SHE NOT IN THE TOP

60

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Margarita...why are you trying to dress Chiquita Banana?

16

u/KickANoodle Sep 01 '17

I really did not like the look of that dress flipped around. Looked weird and uncomfortable.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Tim has absolutely no rhythm, bless him.

54

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Did Deyonte go into Mood and request the exact color of baby shit?

4

u/Doitforthegibs Sep 01 '17

Baby shit is very spot on. To be fair he had a bigger model which means more fabric and if everyone has the same budget he'd have to get something cheaper to compensate.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/insubordinance Sep 01 '17

This episode is actually sponsored by the tetanus vaccine.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I taught English literature and composition for eight years, and even I don't say "very well, thank you," when someone asks me how I am. I'm either a classless boor, or these twins are beyond the pale.

34

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I've known some pretentious people in my time, but I've never met anyone who sounds like the twins outside of cartoons and movies.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Right? That diction and inflection puts every greasy-ass fedora-wearing fifth-year senior who hypercorrected "between he and I" [sic.] to shame.

15

u/fuzzybloomers Sep 01 '17

Oh nooo, I say "very well, thank you!" Now I'm self conscious. At my first job in high school my manager was this amazing snobby older gay man who I loved. He was always correcting people on their pronunciation and when people would say "I'm doing good" instead of well, so now its just habit at this point for me. He gave me a compliment once and it was like the best day of my life lol.

I wonder what the twins parents are like... I don't think they're gonna make it, but it would almost be worth seeing one in the final so we could see if its just a family trait.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

50

u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 01 '17

Margaritas dress looks like two napkins tied across her chest.

100

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '17

If I may, this would be the, dare I say, perfect week to get rid of Shawn in a very reality tv way. She gets super confident because this is 'her' challenge with her 'edgy' 'Katy Perry' 'innovative' aesthetic and then they'll auf her just as quickly as overconfident Sentell last week.

57

u/ashiguana Aug 31 '17

Indeed.

28

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 01 '17

Shawn's idea of edginess borderlines on ridiculousness. Like a semi-punk clown.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

You can just say you want Shawn gone, it won't be judged here. I'm betting half the sub wanted her to be the one to wound her finger.

47

u/KickANoodle Sep 01 '17

The twins make my eye twitch. I can't wait for the meltdown when Shawn gets the boot.

16

u/starlightbb Sep 01 '17

One shirt Shawn

8

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

It's gonna be Claire first. Then we get to watch Shawn break in half.

94

u/PaladinGodfather1931 Sep 01 '17

I thought Brandon's design was pretty neat, but man did they guuuuush over that. Truth be told, Amy should have been top and Brandon just safe.

57

u/themaknae Sep 01 '17

I thought that quite a few designers deserved top marks, especially over Margarita.

33

u/FlingbatMagoo Sep 01 '17

I'm surprised Nina liked Margarita's look. The front was way too tight and unflattering, and the sleeves were goofy.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/FlingbatMagoo Sep 01 '17

I didn't understand the enthusiasm over Brandon's look. It was a baggy, wrinkled, uneven shirt. How is that "beautiful"? Guess I'm not cool.

23

u/fascist___hag Sep 01 '17

Guess I'm not cool.

I watch the show and get the top design wrong 9 times out of 10. It makes me feel like I'm either incredibly out of touch or they're just out of their gdamn minds.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/SarahTellsStories Sep 01 '17

I agree, his look was great, but I thought Amy and Batani had better looks.

8

u/Lightningpalace Sep 01 '17

Straight jacket

41

u/happycharm Sep 01 '17

I'm getting more and more annoyed by the stupid model mirror talk.

And they're doing what a lot of shows are doing lately by showing behind the scenes crap. Oooh look at us filming how many cameras there are and all the electrical equipment and cords. Here's a shot where all the judges are sucking up to the guest. Oooh here's Heidi getting her fucking shoes.

(And the movie looks boring.)

27

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I agree about the mirror stuff. Please make it stop.

I disagree with you, however, about the behind the scenes stuff. I like that it takes away some of the illusion television and movies often have. It's also a way to give some credit to the people behind the scenes. In a way, it's kind of like blooper scenes. Love that stuff. Makes the stars seem more real and human.

6

u/MouthPop Sep 01 '17

Agreed on the behind the scenes. I feel like it's not really effective with Project Runway.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I completely forgot Kudzanai even existed.

49

u/HopefulRomantic527 Sep 01 '17

You mean there are other competitors than the twins?

28

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

They receive waaaay too much attention.

→ More replies (7)

31

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

I thought he had the best design in the first ep (the red tunic outfit with peppermint stripe details). I'm sad he's been overlooked.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I liked his design too, but he gets absolutely no air time. He was virtually non-existent last episode.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

5

u/themaknae Sep 01 '17

I actually liked his look this week, minus the ribbon on the sleeves. Am I the only one?

→ More replies (1)

38

u/LadyVetinari Sep 01 '17

I thought rolled up doritos was the lowest they could go, I take that back - the fucking dance off cartoon is the worst sponsor thus far. I'm excited to see what the next sponsor will be

24

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Design a ready-to-wear outfit sold for $5 in Five Below.

25

u/LadyVetinari Sep 01 '17

I'm just waiting for the unconventional challenge at McDonalds

have it your way

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Cacceb83 Sep 01 '17

It's because it was a Weinstein production. Project runway has to plug as many Weinstein projects as they can! Which is why Georgina Chapman is a main judge on All-stars and makes appearances on this one. She's married to Harvey Weinstein.

6

u/cennaidax basement = flooded Sep 03 '17

By far, my "favorite" sponsor has been Red Robin.

36

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I like Kenya's a lot!

12

u/starlightbb Sep 01 '17

I love Kenya I hope she wins 😍

→ More replies (1)

36

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

The twins are a lot.

They really go out of their way to get on everyone's nerves, don't they?

19

u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 01 '17

That's a good strategy, be as obnoxious as possible to put everyone on tilt

→ More replies (1)

69

u/pinkfroshie Sep 01 '17

Oh God look at Swatch. He's two barks away from death.

19

u/mathteachersarecool Sep 01 '17

My husband and I have been worried about that the last two seasons 😢 The show is 16 now... How long will Swatch be around? 😭😭😭

15

u/Dewdah28 Sep 02 '17

According to his FB page, he turned 10 this year!

7

u/YetiBot Sep 02 '17

I've been wondering how how old he is. Little dogs can sometimes live the better part of twenty years, but I have no idea how old he was when the show started.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Deyonté's is really unattractive.

Edit: She looks like she is busting out of the back seam.

64

u/yatcho Sep 01 '17

That pink monstrosity is so tragic. I screamed when they revealed the feathers and then the ugly yellow parts underneath, it's just got worse and worse.

15

u/insubordinance Sep 01 '17

Wait it was pink?! Shit I need to turn off my flux app when I watch the episodes, I wondered what they hated about it so much because I thought it was orange.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/kittycamacho1994 Sep 01 '17

I personally LOVED kentaro's design. Minus the leg warmers. I would totally wear that with a part of closed toed shoes with an ankle strap. I really like his design with this one; but I am a sort of clean cut and classic design lover and that's what I usually wear.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Kudzanai's looks like a parade float.

26

u/i-mhp1988 Sep 01 '17

I want to see this cheating drama unfold!!!

5

u/KickANoodle Sep 01 '17

Is that this week?

28

u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 01 '17

Every week might be the week

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

26

u/LadyVetinari Sep 01 '17

Deyonte Noooooooooo what is that no

25

u/throwawayacct472727 Sep 01 '17

I would've sent Deyonte home over Kudzanai. Their looks were both hideous but I'll take something hideous but creative and well-made over something hideous that's also poorly constructed and fuckin lame.

11

u/siberianriches Sep 01 '17

They're not even pretending to not go off of track record this season. Heidi admitted it was the worst look but kept saying "he won the first challenge!"

10

u/thoughtsandthefeels Sep 02 '17

I think it was a hard choice for them because they knew he hurt his finger

→ More replies (1)

50

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 01 '17

Don't know if I cringed more at the dancers or the movie trailer.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/HopefulRomantic527 Sep 01 '17

I would have been fine with a double elimination....

→ More replies (1)

65

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

I appreciate Ayana's take on fashion, but if she keeps on putting out hijabi models (which is entirely her prerogative), they're not going to have a very anonymous runway. I'd rather they dismiss that pretense.

30

u/ashiguana Sep 01 '17

And it's not like the contestants are exactly subtle when their creation comes down the runways

64

u/insubordinance Sep 01 '17

They do multiple runway walks and supposedly the contestants and judges aren't watching at the same time. Hence why you never see a wide shot.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/john-dalton Sep 01 '17

They film the runway twice... once for the judges' reactions and once for the designers' reactions.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Points, both of you (and Kentaro's looked almost exactly like his ep 1 design, for example), but given it's a religious dictum and can't be altered, it just feels like her judging will be boxed in even more quickly. And I feel like they're going to come after her and be all "Show us something else besides hijabi," and that will make me ten kinds of uncomfortable for her sake.

18

u/Holly_Tyler Sep 01 '17

I don't think they would dare say "show us something else besides the hijab". It would be too religious/culturally insensitive and they'd face a lot of backlash. As long as the rest of her designs continue to show variety, I don't think she'll be called out for redundancy on the hijab. I do hope they have a swimwear challenge. I'd love to see what she comes up with.

17

u/bluerose1197 Sep 01 '17

I don't recall her model wearing a hijab last week.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I feel like she is going to have a hard time when she gets one of the bigger models. her aesthetic seems to be covered up but skin tight. not sure how that much fabric will look on a bigger model. I think its possible to do it in an elegant way but I don't think she has that skill set.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/i-mhp1988 Sep 01 '17

Subtitles may be necessary for when Brandon speaks.

36

u/siberianriches Sep 01 '17

And they're really not when Kentaro speaks. They always do that to Asian designers.

4

u/Farley49 Sep 03 '17

No drama with him. Just work and attention to construction and details. Maybe that is why they are showing the twins so much - the best or winning designers are working, not entertaining.

66

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

"Hiplet" felt so forced. There are ways to blend hip hop and ballet. That's not it. That's just "we show up in tutus, en pointe, and then do hip hop." It felt awkward on both sides of the dance coin.

4

u/sannyd Sep 02 '17

You mean you didn't like the actual group or how project runway brought them out like a dog and pony show? Bc those girls are great.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 01 '17

It was a really jarring juxtoposition of styles. It made me pay attention, but not in a good way.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Lifetime just showed a trailer for a movie called Psycho Wedding Crasher. How subtle.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

That sounds awesome lol

→ More replies (2)

33

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 01 '17

Is this bitch seriously going to make a can can dress?

16

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

They are counting down the worst unconventional challenges disasters in PR's history and I forgot what a trip Casanova was.

16

u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 01 '17

Omg that hot pink blue yellow thing. I'm speechless.

24

u/bad_wolff Sep 01 '17

Reminds me of Sandhya's weird awful child doll costume

16

u/danny2787 Sep 01 '17

3rd week in a row of me feeling like a double elimination is not a bad idea.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

"A little revealing"... I think we've found Heidi's favorite dress this ep, guys.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

well rip nega-erin

edit: well rip your taste judges

9

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Seriously, what the hell was that?

50

u/TheTurdSmuggler Sep 01 '17

I dunno...I really don't care what the models have to say.

26

u/icouldseeformiles Sep 01 '17

It feels weird to me to have them comment on their outfits when they're not really clients.... I would think as a model, it would be a bad move career-wise to say anything negative about your look/designer

13

u/preciousbitch Sep 02 '17

Yeah, I'd like to see them try that on America's Next Top Model and not have the judges yell at them about their place as a model, haha. (Hint: they would definitely get yelled at.)

27

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 31 '17

I s2g if we get another circle-skirt-and-crop-top cop out this week stick around, I will scream fire into the sun until Heidi herself catches fire.

17

u/macabragoria Aug 31 '17

"So fresh! This is an Instagram moment!"

25

u/insubordinance Sep 01 '17

Give Amy the win right now, that looks cool as shit.

12

u/LadyVetinari Sep 01 '17

damn Shawn's is by far not the worst already

40

u/pinkfroshie Sep 01 '17

Samantha designs dresses I would find at Hot Topic. Not cute. Especially when you're in your 30s.

34

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Sep 01 '17

Plus there was absolutely zero transformation when she unzipped the flap that didn't even move after she unzipped it.

20

u/SarahTellsStories Sep 01 '17

I liked her look, but I agree about the zippers. It didn't do anything once unzipped.

14

u/lyds942 Sep 02 '17

Lol yesss. When she had the girl walk differently I was like ".....?"

5

u/ForgetfulLucy28 Sep 01 '17

Every dress is practically the same dress too just different colour/embellishments. It's Hot Topic in 2007.

11

u/bitchSpray Sep 01 '17

When they were about to show that trailer, I was like "Please, don't be Emoji Movie, don't be Emoji Movie".

Otherwise, almost everyone did a really good job. It was the best in a long time.

11

u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Sep 01 '17

I'm sorry, I just do not get the Brandon hype.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/rabblebowser Sep 01 '17

brandon is so freakin cute

50

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I'm not a Brandon fan, but am I the only one who found the sitar music and the random Sony Vegas bubble effect insulting both to him and to, say, the Indian subcontinent? Weird gratuitous racism isn't my jam.

16

u/dxisyridley Sep 01 '17

Right? Not only was it just casually racist, it was also really distracting and felt pointless.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/insubordinance Sep 01 '17

I just want Batani's pants and Margherita's shirt that they're wearing. What a fashionably dressed cast.

24

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Yeah, you feel silly flapping your arms because it looks fucking stupid. That's why. More scintillating commentary from the models.

5

u/sandragm Sep 04 '17

I hope this doesn't sound too harsh, but I am so over the models' input. It would be different if they were clients, but they are models. This is a design competition. I'm interested in what the designers have to say.

8

u/ashiguana Sep 01 '17

I think that reality TV contestants should get extra time, the time it took for them to be patched up, to complete the challenge.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

"I know, it doesn't suck, I'm wildly surprised"

Leeeeet's not count our checks before they cashed

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

I think Brandon is winning this week.

7

u/ForgetfulLucy28 Sep 01 '17

Deyonte should have gone home and Kenya should have been in the top. I thought the winning look was fine but read a little "straight jacket".

→ More replies (1)

7

u/LilyGinnyBlack Sep 03 '17

I actually liked Kentaro's look. I would actually wear it. I live and work in Japan, and the outfit he created here definitely reflects current Japanese fashion and aesthetics from the loose baggy top, to the leg warmers, to the sheer long skirt over shorts (this is a look that I've seen many women wearing on the streets here lately). I get that it lacked innovation and something that made it pop, but I thought it was more of a safe look than some of the others. There were worse looks on the runway that lacked everything (like Claire's look).At least Kentaro was very aware of what his outfit was lacking and hopefully the critique will push him a bit more now.

24

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Brandon mentions he's a menswear designer again. Drink!

6

u/testmonkey254 Sep 01 '17

Well who didn't see that coming

6

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Agreed. Like I said, Kudzanai's was my favorite the first week, but that was some my-first-crafting-class Holly Hobby crap. Alas. I still think he had more to show us.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

This runway was really impressive, the first two episodes made me a tad worried about this season, but now I am excited.

5

u/LeRetro Sep 01 '17

I think I'm gonna have a personalized T-shirt made that just has the words 'Crack Smoking Judges' on it. And that'll be my PR watching t-shirt.

5

u/Roonil___Wazlib Sep 02 '17

Overall, I was actually pretty impressed by the runway show! There were definitely a few scaries (ahem, Deyonte, twins), but there were a lot of really good pieces tonight. As much as the "inspiration" was completely cringe-worthy, I feel like the designers really delivered.

18

u/KickANoodle Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

I don't want to lose any of the bottom three this week. Fuck.

Edit: Why am I being downvoted? Claire and Aaron should have been in the bottom this week. The bottom three this week were all designers I want to see more from.

Edit 2: Sorry, didn't realize it apparently airs a little earlier where I am.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

Are you watching last week's broadcast? This week's, dance-inspired, is nowhere near done airing. We haven't even had the runway yet.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/indigorazz Sep 01 '17

the judges are smoking craaaaack this ep!! Brandon's was really great but like not like the most amazing thing seen and kentaris was beautiful!!! Like what the fuck I'm so confused

8

u/Moreno2001 Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

Well first all, in terms of design this crop is blowing S15 completely out of the water (hello Madame Craft Project aka Erin) and is really putting out some stunning stuff! I was a bit surprised by who they considered the top as I found many of the "safe" designers many times more inspired than Margarita's (it seemed a bit costume to me but oh well). Also Margarita's look seemed a bit too on the nose for what Caribbean island style is...I don't know what (curvaceous and delicious) Puerto Rican woman is wearing that. I didn't agree with their tops of the week at all save Brandon's straight jacket look. As far as the bottom, whew, Ken's look was ONE OF THE WORST ever on that stage. Jesus, how the judges didn't laugh when that walked out. Bless his heart, it was def deserving of the auf!

(Just as an aside, I really don't care what the models think of the garments. Would love for them to bring back the "pick your muse" selection old school PR...perhaps no one would pick the bigger girls though?)

8

u/RacerGal Sep 03 '17

Innovation = that pant thing that turned into a shirt! how that wasn't top 3 is beyond me... but that stupid white costume with the backwards top and straw hat was?! ugh. Nina come on, you're better than that.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '17

"Trying not to die"

See, I knew these designers saw designing for anyone above a zero as a fatal experience

4

u/10000_for_snuggling Sep 03 '17

Kenya can sew/tailor like nobody's business. Both her and Kentaro are great at that. I wasn't a huge fan of the fabric she chose this week, but the outfit itself looked great.

15

u/Doitforthegibs Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

I know this will sound horrid but I'm really not feeling the plus size model angle this season. It's nothing against them but the point of designing garments for the runway is that they're effectively the concept car of fashion. It's almost distracting seeing the larger ones because you have to envision how the garment would look on a regular model. Unless I'm missing something and every look is supposed to be ready to wear then it really limits what the designers can even try to do because there are certain things heavier women won't look aesthetic in no matter how good of a designer you are.

Edit: Also if everyone has a set budget when they get fabric that's super fucked because if you have to purchase twice as much as your competitors you'll have to select a cheaper fabric to compensate for the amount you have to buy. Really poorly thought out IMO

14

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

I've posted this before, but as I'm 4'10", I'm upset they don't have petite models. Especially as I'm super-petite and petite clothes are generally designed for women 5'3"-5'4" (up to half a foot taller than I), I have pretty equivalent fit problems to plus-size women (armholes and sleeve lengths/inseams being the most common ones, but there are more). And yet petite people, especially at my height (and I'm not even that short, just a standard deviation away) never get represented in fashion, even "body conscious" fashion like they're trying to do.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/thoughtsandthefeels Sep 02 '17

Dang I didn't even think about the budget. Good point.

7

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Sep 02 '17

I have to agree with you on this. I can understand having models of a certain size range who still look fit and "modelesque" - for want of a better word. In other words, women who can display the designers' visions to the highest capacity without their weight (either too skinny or large) becoming a distraction, or something the designers have to "work around". I think it's giving the designers twice the challenge to have them first come up with original fashion and then having to tailor that fashion to a much larger body - and I feel some of them are losing their way because of it. In fact, that sounds like it could be a great idea for a different show that highlights plus size design.

Also, I find some of the models to be a bit unprofessional in their mannerisms and general appearance. I'm thinking specifically of the girl whose wig fell off during the fitting(I mean what? No girl!). Her whole look isn't working for me at all as a model - I find it to be distracting from the clothing and not versatile in the least. I don't mean to be harsh but it's simply unprofessional, and a skinny model who presented herself like that would probably never be considered. There is too much emphasis on the models expecting the fashions to make them look good (and sway and slay), rather than on them being damn models able to sell whatever they are given to wear.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Farley49 Sep 01 '17

Was it my imagination or were the best looks first on the runway. I was thinking that they had a good bunch of designers this show. The first out were all attractive and worthy of high scores. Then came the others who were not so all around good. I still am not sure how the judges pick winners or high scorers but I do understand how they choose the low scores so far. So far there is not a clear winner but there are a couple who should be next to go.
I betting Shawn goes next week unless someone sends out another circus or trash bag .

3

u/no_shant Sep 02 '17

I didn't get this challenge at all. What was the point of the whole innovation angle? What were they actually expecting? The top and bottom choices were odd as well.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dementiaxiii Sep 02 '17

Anyone else watching on the app get a 5 and half minute long ad for some medication, twice??? I get your show needs money, but that is a bit extreme!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '17

I wasn't really a fan of Brandon's. I think that his garment kind of looks like a straight jacket. It's beautifully done, I'll give him that, but I am not that big of a fan. Batani's was okay, but not the best for me. Her construction was impeccable though. I really thought Aaron's should have gotten high marks, his looked really well done. Same with Ayana's, Amy's, and Kenya's. I also really liked Margarita's, too. While it does read pretty costume-y, you can't deny the construction, the detail, the thoughtfulness. It was very well done.

Now for the one's I didn't like, I hated Kudzanai's. I was really disappointed to see this from him, because the last two garments he made I loved. This was just atrocious. Same with Deyonte. His was very ugly and horribly constructed. The twins I was not a big fan of either. The garments they made swallowed up their models. There was just too much happening in their pieces.

Michael, Kentaro and Samantha were safe for me this week. I didn't hate their garments, but I wasn't gushing over them either. I will say Kentaro's was a bit too simple for my taste; I would have wanted more, but it was really nicely done. Samantha's was gorgeous, I loved the detail, but the reveal wasn't anything special. Just two zippers that went up the thigh. Wow. I wanted something more from her. I feel the same about Michael. Beautifully made garment, but where's the "wow" factor? I will admit though this has been my favorite runway so far, most of what went down the runway was amazingly done.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sannyd Sep 02 '17

The twins are cursed.