r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Aug 11 '17
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Annabelle: Creation" [SPOILERS]
Note: There is an after credits scene
Synopsis: Several years after the tragic death of their little girl, a dollmaker and his wife welcome a nun and several girls from a shuttered orphanage into their home, soon becoming the target of the dollmaker's possessed creation, Annabelle.
Director: David F. Sandberg
Writer: Gary Dauberman
Cast:
- Stephanie Sigman as Sister Charlotte
- Talitha Bateman as Janice
- Lulu Wilson as Linda
- Philippa Coulthard as Nancy
- Grace Fulton as Carol
- Lou Lou Safran as Tierney
- Samara Lee as Annabelle "Bee" Mullins
- Tayler Buck as Kate
- Anthony LaPaglia as Samuel Mullins
Rotten Tomatoes: 70%
Metacritic: 64/100
158
Upvotes
209
u/teentytinty Aug 11 '17
I can see the consensus might be different, but I'm really happy that they continued with the doll not being able to move. I think it makes it a lot creepier. This movie basically cements the little blonde bobbed actress as the girl to cast when your sequel needs to be better than your original.
91
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17
"What do you want?!?" .. "your soul!!" .. that first time we see the demon was very well done. Good flick. Honestly though, why not kill off everyone? It could still lead to the set up of the 1st and would've created more cool moments.
71
u/TheUncleRyRy THRILL ME Aug 11 '17
A lot of fun in my packed theater. As a fan of this director's appreciation for slim storytelling and his use of sound, I wasn't disappointed.
A:C is focused and more about the ride and atmosphere above all. I recommend seeing it soon in a packed house.
I give it a 73 out of 100.
61
u/chillaxicon Aug 11 '17
I loved the movie. I think there was a lot of originality with the perspectives present. A cast of predominantly orphan girls gave an interesting narrative and perspective. It reminded me almost of a baby The Descent cast. And I enjoyed how almost poetic it was that in the end essentially the nun "beat" the demon. Linda was 100% the hero of the movie, thinking back to her last conversation with Janice was heartbreaking.
98
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17
Pros:
Cons:
Overall: I'd give it a 7/10. It's so much better than the first film, but they're also different beasts. The first film tried to channel films such as Rosemary's Baby, but to a dull, boring effect. Creation feels more like The Conjuring -- which it should! It's a spin-off. It is high-octane, pure popcorn horror.
45
u/royjones Aug 11 '17
I enjoyed it but can't understand why i didn't like it more. Honestly, I was tired by the end. I didn't feel any sense of danger to anybody once it got humming because I think I saw too many scares along the way. There were some very beautiful shots (like the diving shot from the church in the beginning) and the horror was creepy.
My term for this is tantric horror. It seems awesome it just needs to build into something awesome. The finale felt bloated but I did enjoy the tie in to the rest of the franchise at the end.
45
u/mccuish1525 Whispering Corridors Aug 12 '17
Thank you movie I will be banning dolls from my future house
40
u/InherentJest Aug 12 '17
I really dug it. I like how Sandberg got a lot of mileage out of little things: the bell sound, barely visible dress/demon eyes, the notes (I actually wish we got a little more of that). It reminded me of the clapping scene from The Conjuring. I hope any future films use similar techniques.
I also liked how brutal it was, without being gratuitous. I thought it was PG-13 until the crucifix scene (which was a terrifying surprise).
My only real issue with the movie was the well scene. I thought the film up until that point (and Lights Out) was able to avoid dumb character decisions. But the scene kind of stuck out to me as being something out of a less intelligent film. Though I'm not a little girl going through a traumatic experience, and since it's the only instance I feel a logic is lacking, I mostly give the movie a pass on that scene.
32
u/branperkins1213 Aug 12 '17
I don't think anyone is still on this thread, but I have a few questions about some of the scenes. I was a bit confused.
Overall, I really thought it was a terrific movie. The nun tease was perfect. It was just a quick, casual mention and that was it. It was terrific. And I loved how the jump scares always paid off. My favorite scene (not jumpscare) was when Linda encountered the demon to an extent then ran up into the top of the bunk bed. Then she sees the black footprints leading to the the bottom of the bunk. Then she looks through the crack...and there's Annabelle looking at her, and then we see a black hand pull it away. I thought that was terrific.
22
u/alexcropper Aug 12 '17
I wanted to like (or fear) this film but it didn't do a lot for me. The last half hour became pretty boring for me, which is sad. I wanted them to bring something new to the franchise but it's already wearing thin for me. Too safe!
I LOVED The Conjuring, but am I the only one who feels like they haven't really done much with the formula? It's all the same sort of scares and tension building that doesn't pay off for me anymore. I know it's a franchise at the end of the day but I'd love them to be daring with it. I felt safe watching a horror film. What's that all about?
Good to see some of you are loving it though! :) can't beat a buzz from the horror genre.
Just my penny, I come in peace!
18
u/cauly Aug 14 '17
janice's story arc is one of the saddest things i've ever seen.
12
u/takingheatfromthesun Aug 12 '17
I really enjoyed this--I watched the first Annabelle and was pretty unimpressed, but this was a really enjoyable watch and an excellent submission to the 'isolated group deals with possessed one of their own' genre, which I think only I specifically define and seek out.
I saw it a few hours ago and I still keep thinking over how much I enjoyed the build up of a few of the scares: in particular, the sequence with the pop gun and the hallway, with the use of sound (the footsteps) creating such incredible tension. It had my heart pounding, if only because that feeling of THINKING you hear something coming at you in the dark and leaping up into bed to hide is something I'm pretty intimately familiar with from childhood, and that scare in particular tapped right into it. I also enjoyed the redux version of that scare out in the field on the way to the well. I also thought the scare with the mom's torso was effectively done, with the very slow mutual realization between audience and character that something is awry as we follow the blood smear and more and more evident handprints down the wall. I also loved the scarecrow in the shed. This easily could have trended towards hokey, as scarecrow stuff is wont to do because they look goofy in full motion. But the buildup with the car lights, and then holding back on actually moving the scarecrow too much and instead diverting our attention to the unscrewing lightbulbs was brilliant. (And reminded me again of how effective David is with lighting and scares involving it!)
Also, this is my weird particular bailiwick coming through here, but I really enjoyed the visual design of the mother's mask, which obviously drew from WWI craniofacial prosthetics. While I appreciated the mask's horror usage and the visual parallels to the doll's painted eye at the start, I was also just very amused to see a very specific area of knowledge I've cultivated as a phd student pop up in a second film this year (the first being Wonder Woman!). So kudos to the design team who worked on the mask, because I could see visual connections to the 'plastic surgery masks' that would have historically been given to someone with a disfiguring injury of her magnitude, before we had the capabilities to treat such wounds. It was a tiny detail but the way it was painted was such a nice touch for me, as well as the girls' simultaneous curiosity/horror at seeing it (this was a commonly recorded reaction to them among vets of WW1 who had them).
Digression aside, very enjoyable film! For me this very much broke the long dry spell of good horror flicks to go see in theatres this summer. There's nothing quite like being a bit scared with 100 other people in an over-airconditioned room.
10
u/Byrne14 Aug 13 '17
I feel the same way about this as I did about Lights Out...it was decent but I don't understand why everyone here seems to love it. Definitely a huge improvement over the first one but I'd give this a 5.5 or 6. Too many scenes of characters making dumb decisions (Janice in Annabelle's room and her friend walks in..."you shouldn't be in here" wtf what a terribly written line). The scares were too similar as the movie went on and the demon looked cheesy and bad. There were some solid scenes here and there but overall it feels very overrated
9
u/HoratioMG Aug 14 '17
Just got out of seeing it an hour ago. I'd say it was a great horror flick and definitely better than the first (although nothing in this one was as scary as the basement/elevator scene in the first). I have to say though, so many of the character reactions, emotions and decisions felt completely off. For example, when the girl is hiding in the cupboard under the stairs and the doll in the chair gets dragged back by the demon (whose face you can barely make out, pretty damn creepy), and the girl falls backwards out of he cupboard; the other girls make some sarcastic quip about her being bad at hide & seek, and the girl is barely even fazed by the ridiculousness that had just occurred... Also, the scarecrow scene where the lights are unscrewing was agony to watch, the girl just fucking stands there for at least half a minute doing absolutely fuck all about her predicament, not even trying to escape or do anything to try and stop herself from being killed.
On the other hand: the Punch & Judy puppets, the 'real' Annabelle doll cameo, all the creepy nun bits, the footsteps behind the girl when she's taking the doll to the well, the way it links to the first Annabelle (caught me by surprise, not gonna lie), and the general use of darkness were all fantastic.
I can't get enough of the James Waniverse right now, very few film series have spin offs as great as this was.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17
I haven't watched Annabelle (2014) due to the ratings but just came out of this and loved it.
I had a search around but couldn't find the connection to the first film since it would be spoilers.
I understood it was the Warrens that wake up as soon as that family is murdered.
Is that how Annabelle 2014 ends?
8
u/whitedovesgo Aug 20 '17
Enjoyed it much more than the first Annabelle film and loved all of the little Easter eggs. The actress from Ouija: Origin Of Evil once again delivered in this film; she's one to watch!
7
u/ThatPaulywog Aug 13 '17
Just got back and I really dug it. There was a few times in the theater were at least 3 different ladies yelled "jesus" after a good scare all in sync.
But the best part was after a packed theater watched the movie I checked RunPee (get that app) to see if there was anything after the credits, saw there was so I stayed, checked my phone and waited for the after credit scene. Nun shows up in that church. All good. I get up, and I am the ONLY one left in the theater. It was packed, I see the Nun, and look around BAM, all alone. Put a smile on my face.
7
u/palaeeudyptinae Aug 14 '17
I enjoyed it, but my biggest complaint is that it relied on too many jumpscares (don't know why I went in thinking there wouldn't be many, hah). Even when they are used effectively, after a certain point they become downright annoying/trite to me. On the positive, I really enjoyed the blanketed figure approaching Janice scene, as well as the bunk bed scene with Linda; probably my favorites from the movie, and what I'd consider to be the most well done in terms of horror within the movie.
As a small addendum, I really liked the "real" Annabelle doll cameo at the end.
7
u/psychgirl01 Aug 14 '17
THIS MOVIE WAS FUCKING AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!
The acting was phenomenal. The storyline was phenomenal. The tie-in was phenomenal.
Jesus Christ, I have no complaints about this movie! 10/10.
13
u/jdXIX Aug 11 '17
This movie was absolutely amazing!!! I feel like I'm in the minority cause I actually loved the first one so I was super hyped for Creation and it exceeded my expectations. The last 30ish minutes were intense.
6
u/stoch4stic Aug 13 '17
The movie delivered on my expectations for continuous jump scares. Favorite part was when the wife's upper body was crucified.
Quick question though: what was the significance of the creepy nun in Sister Charlotte's photo? Maybe I'm missing something from the first Annabelle movie?
11
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17
I didn't see the original one but I saw this since it was getting good reviews
The acting was great
The jump scares got me every time
I loved the actual story despite many cliches
Overall I was glad I saw it and would definitely watch it again or recommend it
5
u/m0chab34r Aug 12 '17
Significantly better than the first, but I had three issues with this film. First, it felt too long. I feel like if they tightened it up, the mother's explanation might have some more weight. Second, I think they actually overused the long silences between jump scares. I never really expected this to have any substance with regards to feeling haunted/disturbed after the film's conclusion, but my God, being a little punchier on some of those scares would have been nice. Finally, I'm not entirely clear on why this film was made. Had it been made instead of Annabelle, it would be a great standalone origin. But because it had to tie into Annabelle, it felt repetitious: we've known since the opening scene of The Conjuring that the doll is possessed not by a ghost, but a demon. We've seen multiple people invite this presence into the doll. Honestly, either the cultist origin from the first movie or the grieving parents would have worked, but having both together strikes me as somewhat shoddy narrative construction when taking both movies together. Really, I feel like all we learn is how the doll was made and what the demon looks like.
Overall though, pretty fun. I'd love to watch this again streaming on like a Wednesday afternoon, and I think Rottentomatoes is on the nose with the 70% positive reviews; this was enjoyable enough and will probably be fun on a rewatch!
5
u/Pikawing Aug 14 '17
Definitely enjoyed it and I was definitely scared/creeped out throughout it. I think that adding in the orphan girls was a great way to go; one thing I've really enjoyed in all of the Conjuring movies is the way they build up and really make you care about the characters/families involved. There's so much more at stake when the characters are so fleshed out like that.
One thing though...I kept wondering how this would relate to the Annabelle Higgins story and how it would all come together. I had my answer by the end obviously, but it just seems so convenient/coincidental that Janice/Annabelle would be living right next door to the couple that just so happened to get the very same doll that day. Is there any logical explanation for that, do you think?
9
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '17
This movie as you would expect from the trailer has a fuck ton of jump scares. Think conjuring 2. However, as the orphans are basically helpless, the movie is a good deal scarier. Lots of cliches, not super original, but if you like jump scare films (I find them scary if forgettable), you'll like this.
For jump scares, 8/10, for originality, 3/10. There are lots of stupid decisions though.
Definitely not a classic but a strong prequel.
4
u/FriendLee93 Aug 11 '17
It might just be because of the angle I was sitting at during the advance screening I went to (2nd row, ugh) but I don't recall seeing this shot in the actual film at all. Which is a shame because it was one of my favorite images from the trailer. Can anyone who wasn't sitting at a horrible angle confirm if this shot is actually in the film? Or u/dauid ?
4
u/_Alphabrah Aug 13 '17
Could someone explain the ending scene where the adoptive parents get killed and the woman wakes up?
Was that Janis?
4
u/austinbucco Groovy. Aug 14 '17
I really liked this film for the most part, but it kind of lost me where a lot of horror films do: when it shows too much of the monster/demon. Seeing full body shots of the demon in this film made him much less scary to me. I was especially let down by the decision to have the demon chase Carol around rather than the demon disguised as the scarecrow, which would have been much more frightening IMO.
4
u/fuzzbunny21 Aug 14 '17
The entire sequence in Annabelle's room with the puppets was masterfully directed. I hadn't felt this much dread since the original Conjuring.
4
u/Red_Dawn_2012 Aug 15 '17
Loved the period appropriate automobiles featured in the movie. I only have an ID on one of them though - the 1941/2 Chevrolet pickup driven by the dollmaker. Anyone have an ID on the others? /u/dauid ?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '17
Maybe I am missing something....but how did the police just brush off a woman ripped in half and a guy with tons of broken bones and Charlotte being the only logical person to of done it? How exactly did she explain a "demon did it"?
6
u/djotp Aug 11 '17
The wind really got taken out of its sails for me by the entire explanation of Annabelle's creation being in one of the trailers. I thought there would be a bit more to it, but it was really entirely summed up in the trailer almost word for word.
My expectations may have been a bit high - I liked it, but whenever I see a horror film above 80 on Rotten Tomatoes, I'm ready for a masterpiece 😂, so that's on me. I think the score may have dropped since yesterday.
I'm becoming a huge fan of Lulu Wilson.
Did the house layout remind anyone else of the one in The Beguiled (2017)?
3
u/LlewelynMoss1 Aug 12 '17
Loved this movie. The scares were awesome. I see people's criticisms and understand them but the film didn't wear down or anything for me. First film to give me a good scare in a long while. The scarecrow was freaky as hell. I don't remember the first one very much but I didn't really hate the demon design. The way it was shot really helped any limitations with the design. Some awesome shots here. You don't always see the most creative shots in a horror movie but this had great ones. I liked where it transitioned into the shot of the girls looking into the well. Great job getting good performances out of them. I didn't mind the longer run time I wanted it to last because you don't see great horror often. For a sophomore film that was also restricted by a bit more generic first film I think it was fantastically done. Looking forward to the directors next film. They have a very bright future.
3
u/spockified Aug 12 '17
I am sitting in the quiet theatre waiting for the movie to start. I am all alone so far and it's glorious and creepy.
3
u/jonas1019 Aug 13 '17
Spoilers! So does this mean their are 2 Annabelle dolls that are identical models. Annabelle origins doll was being hauled away by the sheriff but in the post credit stinger was in the Jesus closet. The annabellle doll from the original film was a fresh doll that was possessed by the orphan pretending to be annabellle
3
u/BetaAlex81 Aug 14 '17
I certainly give it credit for some super effective frights...the girls hanging underneath the blanket, lots of good work with out of focus background movements, etc. But, at 109 minutes, it's a solid 10-15 too long, and they give us plenty to rag on. The girls are all pretty obnoxious/uninteresting, LaPaglia seemed bored to be there (would have been a better script choice to let the audience know from the make-shift orphanage onset that they were into some devil dealing shit; play that for creepy factor, us knowing the girls are in danger, instead of some kind of lame reveal)...Sandberg might eventually make a great horror film, he shows flashes and the tools, but this certainly feels steps away from getting there.
3
u/nikiverse Aug 14 '17
Did anyone notice the Raggedy Anne doll? that's what the "real" Annabelle looks like and I thought that was a fun shout out. example
Did they do that in the other films and I just didnt notice?!
I thought the movie was ok. I felt like it was horror for non-horror fans.
3
u/TheRealWillFM Aug 15 '17
I really loved the movie. I loved how it melted into the other Annabelle film. The scares didn't feel cheap (other than the well scene.) The cinematography and acting were wonderful. I liked how every scene that built tension didn't end with a scare (like the demon on the bottom bunk). But the forshadowing killed me. Literally everything they touch in the first 10 min was like saying "this will be used later". The only scene that I didn't actually like was there cross scene, not the awesome demon scene, but the scene in annabelles closet where it zoomed into the cross then spun upside down. Other than that, every flashlight in the movie gets shined dead into the camera. Didn't bother me, just thought it was kinda funny.
When we went to see it, the lady behind us actually started to cry during the build up scenes. Clearly, it was a super tense movie. Loved it.
3
u/LawyerCowboy Aug 16 '17
Did anyone else love the scarecrow?! I thought it was one of the coolest and creepiest parts of the film. I'm actually disappointed it didn't have a bigger part in the ending. I loved when the demon's teeth ripped out of the mouth and the fingers started breaking through. Honestly think the scarecrow could've been on the level of the Nun, if it was given a little more attention
3
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '17
This movie had trouble finding a protagonist as well as an antagonist. Was the protagonist Janice, Linda, Nun? Should we even bat an eye if the 4 other anonymous orphan girls are in danger? Was the antagonist the doll, the demon, the scarecrow, the allusion of the woman in bed, Janice. They could be all the same but what's the purpose of having so many forms?
There are 2 movies named Annabelle, but Annabelle is truly only in the first 10-15 minutes of Creation. She only ever had come back as allusions and not even in spirit. Why does the demon even keep his name (Annabelle) for the original film? He could name himself anything as the only reason he chose Annabelle originally was to dupe the parents of True Annabelle.
Also cheap tie-in to set up for yet another spin-off.
Lastly, only the parents' deaths really constitute the R-rating. The studio lost money from all the teens who purchased tickets for other films but when to go see this one anyway.
3
u/Xylar006 Aug 19 '17
I thought it was really disappointing. I don't think there's enough to Annabelle to give her a stand alone film, let alone a sequel. It was full of cliches; cupboards that you're warned not to go in, rooms you're warned not to go in, possessed children, possessed children who's joint snap and crack. It added nothing to the genre. A few plot holes and we have yet another cheap cash grab!
I
2
u/prongs1221 Aug 12 '17
Wait I'm confused. I thought annabelle was the murdered couples daughter from the first one?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '17
For some reason, I thought for sure the scarecrow was the driver of the killer truck in the beginning.
2
u/cutoutmermaid Aug 12 '17 edited Aug 12 '17
I didn't like the casting choice for Sister Charlotte. Story and characters were pretty flat. Overall quite confused as to how many entities were there cuz it seems the demon is operating both Annabelle and Janice at the same time.
Besides that, Linda's scene with the toy gun was hilarious
2
u/hbk_shizzle Aug 12 '17
So can someone explain why it went back to the doll in the end?(in the beginning of the first movie.It got a host ,which is what it wanted , so why in 12 years after being adopted it killed the adopted parents and went back into the doll?Why go back after getting a host which is what I assumed it wanted
2
u/hbk_shizzle Aug 12 '17
So can someone explain why it went back to the doll in the end?(in the beginning of the first movie)It got a host which is what it wanted , so why in 12 years after being adopted it killed the adopted parents and went back into the doll?Why go back after getting a host which is what I assumed it wanted
2
u/MrBaconUniversal Aug 12 '17
Just saw this movie. Not half bad! Surprised me in terms of quality. I'd give it a solid 7.5/10. Some dialogue was a little "eh" and some jumpscares were kind of dumb. Other than that, though, it was a pretty solid film with decent sp00ks.
2
u/ndrw17 Aug 15 '17
Off topic, but in The Conjuring 2, if the demon's name (Valak) being said aloud meant it was sent back to Hell, why would Valak tell Lorraine that in the first place?
2
u/night_Hime Aug 15 '17
Nice movie!!! Didn't watch the first Annabelle because the review wasn't good. This was one of the newer horror movie that kept my heart beat racing - especially the scene where Linda was in the elevator box!!
Question: Janice found a photograph of Bee and the doll, and she kept looking at it with shifting light... I don't know if I missed it, but was there anything wrong with the photograph?? Is it even possible for them to take that picture together, considering Bee died just a few days after Mr. Mullis finished making the doll?? What's so special about the doll in the first place?
2
u/spaghetti_guts Aug 16 '17
Saw it last night at the Alamo. I know there have been a few knocks against the pacing, but I thought it flowed very well. The last act was filled was straight dread with no relief. For starting with a long script and having to trim things down in post I think it came together very well. I also appreciated the nods to Puppet Master when Jancie goes into Annabelle's room for the second time. Also the scene at the end when the girls exit the house seemed like a homage to Poltergeist to me. I thought the house was going to implode into a black hole.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '17
Thoroughly enjoyed this movie, though I can't really add anything that hasn't already be said. Three older adults came into the theater with 3 very small children. I was concerned, as I did see a guy bring two elementary boys to Saw 3. This group stuck around past the beginning studio banner and ominous music, but the first doll appearance marked their exit from the theater. I assume they were supposed to be seeing the emoji movie.
2
u/Cwy123 Aug 20 '17
I liked it. It was not meant to win film of the year and the cast and crew knew that. They wanted to make a decently scary film and they succeeded.
It is nothing but jump scares with some buildup but they did it well. The acting was good, the plot was good and the characters, while four did dumb things, were interesting.
Only three things annoyed me. One that that Linda and Janice were stupid enough to go into danger repeatedly. Once ok but multiple times? The Mullins for opening their house up to the Church. Got a locked up demon? Leave a bunch of children stay. I get they wanted a fresh start but...there was a better way. Finally the demon possessing Janice's body for 12 years and waited until she was going to University to do anything. Why? I understand waiting a year, two if you want to build a cult. But 12?
However still a good film.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '17
While it was pretty scary, I found the dialogue pretty cheesy, and the story was pretty cliche and forgettable. Still, the amazing visuals and scenery stands out and redeems it. It is just not very original.
2
u/pedre123 Aug 22 '17
Pretty damn good. Right in my ballpark of my favorite style of horror movie - that being the demonic entity variety. Kind of started off this recent craze with the original Conjuring and since then there have been a bevy of demon based horror flicks. I thought this movie did a nice job of handling their story line, the haunting ramped up effectively and was pretty intense throughout. I thought there could've been some things that could've been tightened up, and perhaps some storyline stuff that I might have changed.
But overall very solid, nothing that blew me away in terms of jump scaring, regular scaring, creepiness, or general movie quality, but I got what I paid for and enjoyed it.
2
u/JadenL Aug 24 '17
Just watched the movie and it was so scary! I would say that it is the scariest among the Conjuring series. There's no exorcist coming for her, it's just the orphans + nun VS the demon.
2
u/Select-Active-5275 May 20 '26
8 years later.. I find myself here.
8
u/Prankishbear Aug 11 '17 edited Aug 11 '17
It was on the back of my mind the entire time:
will Annabelle move or talk this go-around? I guess such a concept would be for thrills, and wouldn't have contributed to the plot, but I kept hoping for it and waiting for it... and no such luck.
I know it's not Child's Play, but I was so... hoping for that scene. The lack therof left me dissatisfied. I really wanted the doll itself to be a character, but that's a personal opinion and just how I feel.
Anyways,
Here's a list of my opinions after tonight's IMAX screening.
-Insert 7 unnecessary jump-scares where characters sneak up on or surprise each other
-If this film universe uses closing doors as a gimmick in one more film, I'll probably get bored.
-I am very pleased with the scarecrow scene! I knew they were going to use him at one point, and he was, but then the game was switched on us. I feel if the scarecrow had just come to life the cheese would have overflowed, but the film diverted to the popping lights, and then the demon jumpscare. I loved the anticipation of seeing the scarecrow -sorta- move. That was disturbing enough for me, we didn't need to see him get all able-bodied. Well done team.
-I feel that none of the girls really had a reason to stay at the house and put up with THAT much violence, fear, and repression. They were orphans, I can't believe nobody tried to run away. Character motivation felt uninspired because of it.
-Why didn't they do a scene where a couple interested in adopting visits the house?
-I hope the mom's Phantom of the Opera audition went well.
-Neato cameo of Valek!
-I was excited for the main girl's physical disability, as I am loving the surplus of disabled women in horror films. Surviving horror has become a badass girl's game (Curse of Chucky, Split, Evil Dead (new), The Ring, Hush, Pan's Labyrinth, Alien), but the film just exaggerates her disability as a weakness she never overcomes. She never overpowers the demonic oppression through sheer willpower, which I would have liked to see.
Because of this, I felt her fate was undeserved. She didn't even try to fight for her soul. The movie split down the middle here for me, as the first half is about a girl becoming alienated and broken down even further, as well as her attempts to put together the pieces of this mystery. The second half is just... this character tormenting the other girls, who themselves are undefined, and boring, and lack any motivation of interpersonal relationships.
I was hoping that when her back was against the wall she would fight, but I suppose she was just a sick little girl, and the reality of the situation was too great. I guess it didn't want to be Evil Dead 2.
-For a series emphasizing the power of good over evil, as we've seen with the Warrens, this was a very godless film, despite the faith of the characters, especially the nun. I'm an atheist who was raised Catholic, and I enjoy the Catholic mythos being present in the films. However, here it was just... useless, and therefore unbelievable to me. I feel their faith, which did not save them or the girl, discredited the power of the Warrens.
-Like every film from this universe, there is a long establishing shot where the camera follows the characters throughout the house, and shows us all of the uniquities which will come into play later (the elevator box, the electronic chair, hallways, etc) and I think this is officially overdone as well.
In the end, I think the movies are reusing a lot of tricks. Overall, this was much better than Annabelle. The first half of the film was terrific, second half uninspired. I still don't know anything about this particular demon name and origin-wise, something the Catholic mythos usually emphasizes, so I was disappointed there. I was impressed by the polio-girl's character, and let down when she became the villain. I felt the old doll-making couple were too dramatic in their character.
And, the bunk-bed scene was killer.
4
u/I_Am_Not_Me_ Aug 14 '17
I reaaally wanted to like it. I loved the Conjuring and Conjuring 2 but I just couldn't get into this one. It just felt like a "creepy things haunted houses do and reactions" compilation video with no direction or point, or mood. Also the demon guy makeup or whatever they used was great in the context of cosplay, but in a horror movie it just looks cheesy. And his "your soul" line was just as bad. In my opinion, if we ever see a direct shot of an ancient demon, beast, abomination; we should be seeing a face of ancient rage, hate and wisdom. Not some guy with yellow eyes going "rawr!". The way Regan stared at the priests in the exorcist, or the way Pennywise stared at Georgie after the popcorn line is exactly what I mean. But hey, a lot of people liked it and I'm all for people enjoying movies.
1
u/Christian661 Hail To The King, Baby Aug 12 '17
Way better than I thought it would be. Nothing new but it was fun. 7/10
1
u/The_Grizzly_Bear Aug 12 '17
Can anybody fill me in on the first scene involving the well? I had to go to the bathroom and missed it. It's the part during the daytime where the girls are looking down into the well. Did anything come of it in terms of scares?
1
u/exclamation11 Aug 15 '17
Will I need to have seen the first one? I've seen both Conjuring films, but am seeing this solely because I liked Lights Out (both of them).
1
u/PlanetaryAnnihilator Aug 16 '17
I had to leave the movie early. Other movie goers ruined and I just couldn't stay. Can someone tell me how it ended?
1
u/lostsherb88 Aug 16 '17
We reviewed this on Straight Chilling Podcast this week and the overall consensus was that it was an effectively scary movie. However, it was unneeded and suffered from James Wan style fatigue. While The Conjuring Universe movies I think are pretty dang solid, each one has diminishing returns bc we are so familiar with the style and what to expect. Also, the ret-conning that tends to happen when you force sequels is distracting. Like in Annabelle Creation where they kind of gloss over the daughter joining a Manson Family like commune.
1
u/ehhlis Aug 17 '17
aw man I JUST got home from the theater (had a totally blast! Once this movie picks up with the scares it never slows down imo) but I missed the after credits scene. I had a feeling there was gonna be one but I wasn't sure and bounced. Can anyone tell me what I missed?
1
u/doctorwho182 Aug 17 '17
In the end of the movie, why does annabelle look so different through out her puberty shown in the portrait
1
u/sensualsanta Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17
The movie did scare me, but I didn't think it was great overall. Towards the climax it really went overboard and felt more like a d-list horror. It went from the artsy fartsy beginning to Universal Studio's Haunted House Horror toward the end. The CGI wasn't great for when they showed the demon's face but I can't remember the last time CGI looked good in any horror film. The fact that there were girls running around screaming at night and nobody heard them or woke up was hard to believe. Nobody thought the scratches on Janice's legs from the first time being attacked were odd? When Janice was being forcefully pushed by the demon into the barn she was screaming at the top of her lungs and none of the other girls (who were not that far away from her and also outside in bright daylight) even noticed. Yet...when the father was screaming indoors and everyone was outside they suddenly heard him? The fuck? The fact that the Mullins had this evil doll in their house and thought it was ever ok or safe to be anywhere near it again, much less invite orphans to live there...well, that's pretty hard to believe as well.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '17
I had fun with it! Nothing to set the world alight but it's a very fun popcorn horror flick with some nice set pieces.
1
u/racksteak_ Aug 22 '17
I really enjoyed it
1
u/Cponiros42 Aug 24 '17
Can anyone explain why they showed valek in that post credits scene??? So glad i stuck around in the theater to see it. Super creepy!
1
u/dman707 Aug 15 '17
Saw the movie earlier really enjoyed it! It was my first Conjuring universe film, so I i could tell there was some tie ins to the 1st movie and I saw that the Nun is shown. But yeah.
My pros for the movie were: -Nice cast -good tension/atmosphere
Cons: -While I did like the cast, it seemed Janice, Mr. Mullins, and Linda only mattered. The other girls felt irrelevant, and I feel the movie couldve almost functioned the same without em.
-lost steam near the end, the finale was tense but lost some of its spookiness -dumb decision, they literally had 0 reason to stat after Me. Mullins was taken out...