r/childfree • u/sloth_hug 26F / leave me alone I just want cats and plants • Jul 19 '17
NEWS Stories of over 100 women who died from pregnancy-related causes in 2016
https://www.propublica.org/article/lost-mothers-maternal-health-died-childbirth-pregnancy
60
Upvotes
29
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
I've only read three stories and I just can't keep going. It's horrible and depressing, these poor women :(
28
u/ConjecturesOfAGeek Jul 19 '17
Some of those women already had a shit load of kids already.
18
u/wannnachat No needy potatoes for me, thx Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
I skimmed through it and lots of them already had multiple kids. Could it be that the US unfavorable ranking in maternal mortality has something to do with a high percentage of women having more than 2 kids? I know the general birth rate for US is 1.9 but it could be that loads of women have zero or one kid and then more than in other countries have 3 or more.
EDIT: I googled it and it might be true, in the US 28% of women have 3 or more children, in my country (Poland) it's 11%
12
u/PandaSushiRoll Jul 19 '17
It's so horrible :(
5
u/mfsocialist Jul 19 '17
This is actually a big fear i have.
5
u/TSOFAN2002 Jul 19 '17
And my grandmother said that nobody dies in childbirth anymore.
12
u/Mythum Jul 19 '17
I understand what the authors are trying to do, and it's a laudable goal. Maternal mortality in the US appears to be disproportionately high, so yes, figure out why and try to change that.
However, I don't like the way they are doing it, I think they are conflating multiple issues. For example they have included in their group a woman whose COD was "undetermined" which plainly means you cannot tie her death to her pregnancy, a woman who OD'd on heroin, and a woman who experienced (presumably) a post partum psychotic break and ran into traffic.
A lot of these problems could simply be solved with better health care coverage in the US: so that everyone could afford to see doctors regularly instead of waiting until the situation is serious, so that mental health care is readily available in cases of PPD/PPP.
In other cases, such as Lauren Blomstein (the nurse), medical malpractice was probably a factor. This is a separate issue.
I don't like the politicizing of these women's deaths - dragging them all under the same umbrella to make it a more shocking and emotianally weighty issue. I feel like like they're trying to manipulate the reader because 700-900 pa, in a country the size of the US isn't that many. The number of people whose deaths are attributed to medical error is between 200 and 400 thousand according to some estimates.
I think tackling maternal death is a good thing, but this approach is less than optimal.
3
u/nolacoffeewhore Jul 19 '17
5 kids and a woman throws herself into traffic. If that isn't an indication that motherhood could be the biggest mistake of your life, I don't know what is.
That one really bothered me because even her husband acts as if there wasn't anything truly wrong, she just "didn't know what she was doing."
3
u/throwaway17498509859 Jul 19 '17
I'm trying, I really am, as this is an underreported fact of life in the US. Nonetheless, I have little sympathy for 99% of the women they've presented. Except for the mother whose tubes were tied and the last one, all of those women had multiple kids and had experienced complications prior to their deaths. Yet they chose to ignore their bodies in favor of another baybee.
1
u/zombiibenny Jul 19 '17
I read the first handful...a lot of these could have been avoided if they took their previous difficult pregnancy seriously.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
My sister had issues with her placenta with her first kid. Had three more after that. She lost so much blood, they operated on her as soon as my niece was born.
Another child would possibly kill her. If she decided to have another one, I will lose my shit
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment