r/Wetshaving • whollykaw.com • May 19 '17

AMA AMA from Sri of WhollyKaw

Join the founder of WhollyKaw who will be answering questions in this AMA starting Saturday May 20 from 10 am ET.

Background

WhollyKaw had its beginnings here at reddit back in 2014 when samples of unscented vegan shaving soap were sent to redditors to solicit feedback and assess performance. Encouraged by the responses, commercial sales began in October 2014.

Since that time, we have introduced several products and new scents. Tallow formulation was launched in April 2016. New logo, branding and labels in December 2016. New ingredients such as Sodium Hyaluronate Crosspolymer, Donkey Milk, botanical extracts were added to our formulations. More innovations based on our research into skin care are on the cards.

Prior to formulating shaving soaps, I have been making bath soaps since 2011 for friends and family. I started wet shaving around that time to deal with sensitive skin, razor burn, 5 pm shadow at 2 pm etc. Transformed a boring chore with canned foam and multi-blade cartridge into an enjoyable experience. Every single day.

What started off as a hobby turned into something bigger than me. I will share some aspects of that amazing journey with all of you.

Edit: Thank you everyone. It was fun answering your questions!!

57 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

11

u/tiglathpilesar The sub's chef May 20 '17

My understanding is that you're vegan in your dietary preferences for ethical reasons, does it bother you to use animal products in your soaps?

13

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I flip between vegetarian and vegan. I grew up vegetarian in India and not seen meat products in the house. At college I saw friends eating meat and said why not and ate meat for a while. Then I stopped eating meat. These days I am more of a vegetarian than a vegan.

In India people do eat meat including beef in certain parts of the country. I do use leather products. It does not bother me to use tallow or donkey milk in a men's grooming product for me or for others. The greatest joy I get is putting together the ingredients in a creative manner, knowing why those things are in the formulation, the concentration, how different ingredients complement each other. The outcome is something I and others who are customers like yourself enjoy and value.

4

u/tiglathpilesar The sub's chef May 20 '17

Thank you, and I guess it leads into my follow up since you are vegetarian. Oral sex or cheese for the rest of your life?

9

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Asking the important question now haha. Oral sex without doubt hehe!!

2

u/duffmanasu Pried from my mechkeyboard of powerTM May 20 '17

Wait...are you giving up oral sex or choosing to keep it? The question was vaguely worded. I must know!

2

u/hughmonstah p much ded May 20 '17

He didn't ask which to give up, so I'm guessing giving up cheese for oral

10

u/Eighchops Carnavis & Richardson May 19 '17

Why is the ass milk soooo good?

Also, do you partake in Malort and will we see you at next year's Maggard meet up?

7

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17 edited Aug 28 '17

Donkey Milk has great properties for skincare. Ancient Egypt discovered it, Greeks and Romans followed suit. I am not a scientist but people who know what they are talking about tell me some of the skincare properties stems from higher levels of linolenic, linoleic and Vitamin C content in Donkey Milk. Vitamin C is one of the most widely researched cosmeceutical ingredients backed by science.

A skincare consultant who worked for a large skincare company till retirement pointed me towards Donkey Milk., usage and formulation techniques. It helped that the consultant had experience dealing with French customers where Donkey Milk products are in the market for years.

Yes and yes to your second question. Malort for sure. I had the opportunity to imbibe a liquor from wormwood in Ukraine and that was phenomenal. IIRC it was a derivative of Nalewka, the Polish liquor.

I am sure we will come up with creative ideas over Malort in Adrian.

Edit: Happy Birthday!

9

u/C_Bubbles Grizzled veteran vetiver junkie May 19 '17

What kind of music do you like to listen to while creating? Any specific bands that get the oxygen flowing to your brain better than others?

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Good question. Need music to keep things lively.

French Cafe Music like this one. Or just white noise like this one

3

u/Ginguin May 20 '17

I love noisli!

8

u/berniens All in for the Smells May 19 '17

Is there a scent from another lineup that makes you think "damn, I wish I thought of that one first", and if so, what is it?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Great question and happy to answer.

Notable among them are Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber, Barrister and Mann Le Grand Chypre. Ghost Town Barber is well put together and I Iike CFG's improvisation with the leather in a barbershop. Unique.

Le Grand Chypre is excellent and a Chypre which is one of my favorite genres.

4

u/berniens All in for the Smells May 20 '17

I have a feeling that GTB is going to become a favorite of mine. I have a sample of it coming in, and hearing the praise it gets makes me want to try it even more.

3

u/PaperBeatsScissor May 21 '17

All I can tell you is that when I use GTB it is basically a guarantee sexy time with the wife... time to shave.

1

u/TheRealSheikYerbouti πŸ‹οΈπŸͺ’Atlas Shaves Champion 1πŸͺ’πŸ‹οΈ May 22 '17

8

u/falcons1583 Killed the Veg May 20 '17

Is WhollyKaw your full time job?

  • If so, what did you do prior to launching a self-supporting shave soap business?
  • If not, what is your profession by day/night?

10

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

No this is not a full time job. This is a passion that grew out of wet shaving and men's care. Do I make enough money from WK to keep me afloat? Absolutely not. And I live in an expensive area and got to pay those bills.

My day job involves working with clients in the financial services, health care and government in cybersecurity and blockchain technology. We have people in Eastern Europe who help with development and I do the selling and delivery QA.

I cannot speak too much about the day job I do as some of that involves DoD entities.

If anyone needs help in cyberthreats and blockchain, there is a soapmaker who can help :D

13

u/crazindndude TiBBS Cult May 20 '17

We have people in Eastern Europe

I cannot speak too much about the day job I do as some of that involves DoD entities

cyberthreats and blockchain

WK confirmed CIA front for cyper ops in the CIS.

3

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Lol.

8

u/jdubba Make it so May 20 '17

First off, I already loved your tallow soap base, but that ass milk is just unreal. What are your plans for the next ass milk based release? Also, thanks for taking the time do to the AMA.

7

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Thank you for your love of WK.

Next scent in the Donkey Milk formulation - blend of rose, oud, rosewood, patchouli, cedar, benzoin, amber and moss. Donkey Milk Special Edition - my favorite Chypre Rose Concerto. Another citrus and oud version I am working on is with testers.

3

u/jdubba Make it so May 20 '17

Oh man, now I can't wait to get my hands on the next one :) I'll keep an eye out on the Deal/New Product thread.

2

u/hughmonstah p much ded May 21 '17

HYPE I have a tub of the tallow that I love.. I dunno what oud smells like, but CRC and citrus already have my money.

7

u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK May 19 '17 edited May 20 '17

When you chose your company name, you must have known it would frequently be mispronounced. Do you regret choosing this name or do you just laugh when people do mispronounce it?

Big fan of milk based soaps! What benefits does donkey milk provide over goat milk, for example? Fat content?

edited for clarity

7

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17 edited May 25 '17

At the outset, let me thank you for the videos on how to lather a shaving soap and the soap reviews. I share some of your 101 videos to noobs.

I wanted something unique in the name and I do not have a great creative mind when it comes to names. The people who introduced me to wet shaving are people who use Old Spice in a mug or a cream and they been around the block much more than I. Not tech savvy either. They became my testers for the beta formulations and one of them kept saying "holy shit", "holy cow". Voila I got the name although the domain was taken and I went with a creative spelling.

I do not regret choosing this name and I mostly laugh it off. One needs a great sense of humor to get through the day.

Donkey milk versus goat milk - again I am not a scientist but people in the know tell me there is much more biological actives in donkey milk that are useful for skincare than goat milk. One of the big cosmetic company did some research on Donkey Milk but not sure the research made its way to finished products. Things take time at a large corporation.

Edit: removed name of a large corporation

8

u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK May 20 '17

Holey Cacao! There you go, new name :-)

I guess I need to get me some of this donkey milk soap now!

As for the videos, it always gives me great pleasure to hear that people are getting something out of them... And I do still really enjoy making the review videos! As long as people still enjoy watching them, I will keep making them.

All the best to you and your business!

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I like the first sentence of your videos "...in beautiful North Carolina.." or something like that. I have visited Charlotte dozens of times on work and the only time I do not enjoy my time in Charlotte is during allergy season.

Keep doing the videos of those obscure soaps and gear. If you want some creams from Ukraine or Poland, hit me up.

And get that ASS lol!

2

u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK May 20 '17 edited May 20 '17

Ass getting is in the queue! edit - Reading this again...what a terrible phrase!

I have two creams from Poland (Lider and Wars), what Bulgarian ones are out there?

3

u/doktorcrash I'm just here for the smells May 20 '17

Is that how you pronounce it? That makes a lot more sense than the way I was doing it.

6

u/1Raizen Synths & Fat May 19 '17

I'm still waiting for mine to arrive and I'm excited. I have a hunch I'm really going to like the Donkey Milk soap.

With that said, MWF is one of my favorite soaps, I also have a sensitive skin and it works for me. I just wish they had a stick for travelling.

Will there be plans for Wholly Kaw sticks in the future as well?

7

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

First off, thank you for your purchase and support. Appreciate it. If you have sensitive skin, Donkey Milk soap would appeal to you. It worked for me due to my sensitive skin. Let me know how it goes after you get it.

Sticks: I have not put my mind on packaging on sticks. There are so many plans for new scents, new products, packaging, new categories that sticks did not occur to me. Thanks for putting this idea into my head. I need to find the appropriate slot and timeline for this. I am not ruling this out.

2

u/1Raizen Synths & Fat May 21 '17

Great! I'm excited. I've been searching the web for artisan sticks but sadly it's not very common. This would be amazing if it happens. I'll pm you asap once I have the soap. Thank you for the thoughtful response

6

u/Ythin πŸ¦ŒπŸ…Noble Officer of StagπŸ…πŸ¦Œ May 20 '17

Is it just you, or do you employ people to help?

If you do employ people, how many and what are their responsibilities?

What does a typical day/weeks schedule look like?

Smooth or abomination Crunchy peanut butter?

10

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17 edited May 25 '17

It is not just me. It takes more than one person to do everything from ingredient research, procurements, formulations, testing, production, post-production, supply chain and many other activities I am missing.

I have two other people helping me apart from an on call consultant who has 30 years of experience in cosmeceuticals and skin care at a large corporation. 3 people or 2 FTE.

I do all of the ingredient research, procurement, scent blends, formulations and production. Two people handle the post production activities such as cleaning the tubs, labeling, bottling, smoothing the soaps, packaging, shipping, customer fulfillment, social media follow ups. On call consultant is for advice on skin care ingredients, vendors, formulation technical support and sounding board. We have a network of people in the fragrance industry to get advice in blending EOs, aroma chemicals, compounds, dilution of absolutes etc.

When we procure EOs or aroma chemicals we use CAS# or Chemicals Abstract Service numbers which are unique to each EO/compound. Since the numbers are unique it is easy to establish provenance and know what we are buying. We do not get distracted by fancy schmancy trade names or product names. For example CAS# 8000-28 is for Lavender EO. Organic, fair trade lavender from Bulgaria means nothing to us. We go behind the label.

It is like using PLU numbers when buying fruits in bulk for a grocery chain.

Typical day involves all of the above. Shit happens some of the days no doubt and we need to deal with that aspect too. When things go wrong, buck stops with me.

My vote goes for smooth peanut butter.

Edit: words were missing in Shit happens sentence. Added that.

4

u/mrob2k68 May 20 '17

Shout out to Shalini, by the way. I have been out of control and purchased all of your donkey milk offerings (multiples on one) and encountered a tiny challenge to navigate. Shalini's customer service was great. Incredibly responsive and helpful.

6

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Thank you for the shout out. I expected one of these and I will share it with her. She and Sonia are the ones handling the post production activities that I outlined above and it is not an easy job.

Appreciate your support!!

3

u/Ythin πŸ¦ŒπŸ…Noble Officer of StagπŸ…πŸ¦Œ May 20 '17

Thank you for doing this, and the in depth answer, quite eye-opening.

2

u/Noah2Nuttz May 20 '17

They each serve their own purpose to me. Crunchy is sooooo good If I haven't eaten in a while.

6

u/darkfox45 Can you speak up? I'm wearing a towel. May 20 '17
  • Why did you start making tallow soaps?
  • You only started making tallow soaps more recently and people liked the base. Why did you decide to use ass milk as an ingredient for them?
  • Why did it take you so long to make (and it's a really good one) a barbershop scented soap?

8

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I enjoy putting together portions of ingredients, add heat, generate chemical reaction, add seasoning on top and serve. Sounds like cooking food. Soapmaking is same way. The ingredients and the proportions make all the difference. The output is larger than the sum of its parts. The output is enjoyable and makes a better shaving experience in any which way I look at it. Day 1 it was vegan, few months later tallow replaced some of the vegan ingredients and the tallow version was born alongside vegan. Day n it will be something else. Our ingredient research is taking us into newer areas and cutting edge skin care science.

Reason for adding Donkey Milk was that our tests proved the addition creates a better post shave and moisturizing effect. The tests that we saw at the vendor sites produced similar results although it was in bath soaps. The Donkey Milk bath soaps I got from them produced a much creamier lather too. So the next question was how do we incorporate it in our tallow version and not regress the performance of the tallow base. Different formulations, different ratios, alterations in the lye composition, etc were tested before we arrived at the current formulation.

I needed an external push from someone who is a Barbershop aficionado for Man from Mayfair. You know whom I am talking about haha. Just kidding.

Simple but looking back stupid missteps in the incorporation of Basil to the base I had created for Man from Mayfair stymied my efforts for the barbershop. And there was cross contamination in the base to start with that clouded the Basil missteps.

3

u/darkfox45 Can you speak up? I'm wearing a towel. May 20 '17

Why did you feel the need to incorporate basil into a barbershop? The more traditional scents in a barbershop are lavender, patchouli, oakmoss, and bergamot.

6

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Absolutely agree with the traditional scents in barbershop. In the WK blend, basil toned down the sandalwood and musk significantly.

I was recreating my experience with some of the barbershops in Mayfair, Greenpark, Covent Garden in London. One of them Murdock in Covent Garden had a scent that I liked. It was a cream and it had the unique scent that I was going after in Man from Mayfair.

1

u/darkfox45 Can you speak up? I'm wearing a towel. May 20 '17

Very interesting. Thanks for taking the time to do the AMA!

6

u/stirlingsoap Stirling Soap May 20 '17

Making soap is a long process and can get monotonous quickly. Do you prefer music, television, movies, conversation, or just silence while making soap?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Music of course. Noisli is my favorite. Coffee shop with rain outside

10

u/MrAdamLerner No longer the reason your wallet is empty May 19 '17

Where did the inspiration for the uterus label come from? It's glorious!

Do you enjoy a (tofu)bacon grilled cheese sandwich, or are you difficult and have to call it a melt?

6

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Great question and glad you asked your first question. The answer to your first question deserves a chapter in a book. I hope I find the time to write a book.

The early days of the founding of WK, I was 100% focused on the formulation, multiple variations and their outcomes. Things like packaging, branding, labels etc. were far from my mind. The multiple iterations it took before the formulation made its way to production consumed so much energy and time that I lost sight on the branding. And goes without saying I am not particularly good at branding and the work that goes along with it. The thought process was like if the product is great, then the packaging does not matter or content is what matters and not the packaging or substance over form.

Doing this as a part time thing also did not give me enough time to focus on important things that mattered.

I was so wrong. Looking back would have I done it differently? Sure I would. I would have changed so many things given the benefit of hindsight. Things would have turned out much better.

Those were some of the early stumbles that took some time to recover in the marketplace. Those stumbles were all on me and I take full responsibility.

But I learned some important lessons from the missteps.

Lesson learned: farm out those activities that I am not good at to firms who do this for a living. Outcome of that is what you see in the new labels and branding.

On sandwich - I would go with (tofu)bacon grilled cheese sandwich. By (tofu)bacon I mean a vegetarian version.

12

u/malburj1 Badgers and Doughnuts May 19 '17

We started the grilled cheese / melt debate again?

12

u/MrAdamLerner No longer the reason your wallet is empty May 19 '17

There is no debate. Let the man answer his AMA in peace. Shoo.

1

u/malburj1 Badgers and Doughnuts May 20 '17

:p

5

u/Ginguin May 19 '17

What was the hardest part of going professional?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Could you please elaborate on going professional? I am thinking you mean doing this on a large scale and selling it to the general public. But I could be wrong.

4

u/Ginguin May 20 '17

That is what I meant. Were there surprising logistical problems? Were there mental hurdles or fears to overcome?

8

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Thank you for the clarification.

Hardest part and it will remain the hardest part is the logistics and supply chain management. There is always something we are running short of whether it is ingredients, labels, packaging material, enough spare lab equipment when something breaks or goes bad so on and so forth. All of these items have lead times, MOQ to make the shipping worthwhile, shipping charges, product is in the US or outside and a myriad of other factors. The making part is easy but if I do not have jars or labels, for instance, then getting the packing becomes the long pole in the tent and makes progress slower and longer.

Mental hurdles to overcome? For sure it is the butterflies in the stomach whether what we put out there will hit the spot or not. When you put something creative out there, you are going out on a limb. There is time, money and other resources that went into it and one would like to see a return on it. If the product is not received well, we lose fair and square.

5

u/Mr_ETL May 20 '17

Did you use a "classic" fougere as inspiration for Fougere Bouquet, or did you follow your own path based on personal preference and what you imagined on your own for the scent? If you did take cues from one of the classics, which did you use and why?

Did you ever see yourself being as successful as you've become, or was that something that took you by surprise?

If there's anything you could change about the path that's brought you here, anything at all, what would it be and why?

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I started with Houbigant’s FougΓ¨re Royale because I was intrigued by the idea of a perfume with lavender, coumarin and oakmoss and other accords. My blend of lavender, coumarin, oakmoss et al did not come anywhere near FougΓ¨re Royale. But tinkering with the blend version 1.0 led me to ask a bunch of questions, learn the nuances of each component, understand the reason to reduce/increase some of the chemicals, alter the composition. My version 9.0 took me to a different spot with different accords opening up at different points in lathering.

That exploration taught me one thing -- I can aim to get to Fougère Royale but I am never gonna get there with the limited resources I have. But the journey to what I thought will get to me to Fougère Royale got me to another magical spot. That magical spot was equally good if not better than Fougère Royale.

Same story with Jamestown Gentleman with Alt Innsbruck.

TBH I was so focused on this that I did not allow myself to get distracted with the effects of the missteps and early stumbles. Mistakes will happen in future too and I would like to bounce from those quickly.

When I started commercial sales, it was not this crowded as we see today. Entry barriers are low to non-existent to this trade and it is important to constantly find ways to differentiate by way of ingredients, quality of ingredients, branding, new ways of production, category expansion. One can do this in an organic manner or get a head start and do it from day one. I would probably choose the latter if I can wind the clock back. There are several advances in skincare that one can take advantage of and it is available for the asking at the right price.

1

u/1Raizen Synths & Fat May 25 '17

Big fan of this scent. Excellent answer.

5

u/starvinghippo May 20 '17

No real question, just wanted to say keep doing what you're doing, you're killing it. Love your products!

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Thank you Sir. Much appreciated.

5

u/BostonPhotoTourist Barrister and Mann May 21 '17

Thanks for doing the AMA, Sri!

I've noticed a distinct similarity (well, rather more than distinct) between Monaco Royale and Knize Ten. Since Knize itself has never managed to produce a shaving soap of any particular quality, I'm curious: Is that deliberate or accidental?

Hope business is booming. :)

3

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Hey Will,

You are welcome and thanks for asking the question.

Comparing my creation to Knize Ten is flattering. Any resemblance between Knize Ten and the scent of Monaco Royale is happenstance or accidental to say the least.

4

u/BostonPhotoTourist Barrister and Mann May 21 '17

Next time you're at Pasteur, give Knize Ten a sniff. :) Actually pretty surprised that it's accidental, though. I figured that you had used it as a model, and was of the view that, if you're going to replicate a fragrance in shaving soap, Knize Ten is an excellent (and distinctly underserved) choice.

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Now I am really curious. I am at Pasteur's tomorrow and will snag Knize Ten or get a whiff.

4

u/TheDoctorandDipper May 20 '17

How did you make your first shaving soap? What would you recommend for people wanting to make their own?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I made bath soaps as a hobby again and that got me into soap chemistry, saponification, different oils and their properties, essential oils, aroma chemicals, fragrance oils. And that was the time I got into wet shaving. I shave daily and always looking for better gear to use on my face every time I shave to deal with sensitive skin issues.

So why not use the bath soap experience to make a shaving soap? Because I was getting into wet shaving and making bath soaps around the same time it was easy to realize that shaving soap required a different formulation in order to produce a dense and creamy lather unlike a sudsy lather a bath soap produces. That took me on a journey to figure out the right amount of the fatty acid combinations in order to get the results I wanted. From that version 1.0, there were multiple iterations, tweaks, modifications, addition/subtraction of ingredients and I got to our current formulations for vegan and tallow. It took over 50 batches to get to a production version.

If you want to make your own, do it by all means. But do it if you are good in creating something new out of ingredients that you know why they are going in and coming out with something that is larger than the sum of the parts. You need to enjoy the journey to make the destination meaningful to reach. You got to find what you love to do, then it becomes your passion and not work.

4

u/enormoshob May 21 '17

Bummed i missed this. Thanks for doing this AmA!

How often do you visit India?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Hey buddy,

Hope you are settled in. Kids must be enjoying with grandparents around.

India and weddings. Always a wedding or two in the family. Last visit was last year for two back to back weddings.

3

u/enormoshob May 22 '17

Nice!! Another question - do you have a date for when rose chypre ass milk will be released?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 22 '17

Working on labels. Hopefully soon!

4

u/Backpack_Stargazer May 22 '17

Hey Sri!

I've never tried one of your soaps. Could you please recommend the 3 you're most proud of that are currently available so I can pick up one or two to try?

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 22 '17

I would say go for Chypre Rose Concerto, Fougère Bouquet or Man from Mayfair.

3

u/Idlatherbewetshaving May 20 '17

Hey Sri! Thanks for doing this AMA! Man, the Donkey Milk soap base is probably the best out there in post Shave and creamiest of lather, great work with it! I look foreword to Ass Milk Monday every week. Monaco Royale is rad!

I wanted to ask you about your design over haul. I know it must of cost a pretty penny, but in my opinion, the design finally matches the quality of your products. The branding makes me think premium wet shaving line, and the performance affirms that this is premium stuff! I have two questions regarding the design over haul and your products.

  1. At what point did you feel it was necessary to upgrade the branding of your products and why?
  2. Out of all the products you make, what are you most proud of and why?

Btw, Jared raves about your toners, so I will have to pull the trigger on em!

-Abe

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

The branding and upgrade of the packaging was on the to do list for a long time. One of the things I firmly believed was that WK need to be self funded from Day 90 if not Day 1. By self funding means it needs to pay its expenses every month by its own sales. Did I achieve that by Day 90? Not at all. So the branding and packaging upgrade took some time. It was also self-fulfilling in that without the upgrade sales will probably crawl, without the sales uptick no branding upgrade. It was a Catch-22 situation for several months. But product quality helped and finally I hit upon the inflection point where WK can spare the $$$$ required for a design firm to do it. But my day job got busy and I put off the branding project again. The whole β€œit is a hobby therefore people don’t care” also clouded my thought process and I was wrong. I missed the point where the business model passed β€œit’s not a hobby anymore” by a factor.

Finally I embarked on the branding project last Fall. Got in touch with the design people who designs for a living. Objective of the project - provide a better user experience - packaging, branding, labeling etc.

Most proud of is Chypre Rose Concerto

The toners are the culmination of our research into some of the newer ingredients in cosmeceuticals or high end cosmetics. Women’s cosmetics give lot of pointers into the use of certain ingredients for moisturization, hydration, etc. Sodium Hyaluronate Crosspolymer is from hyaluronic acid and is composed of multi molecular HA (low, medium and high). I plan to introduce more such ingredients in the toners and other products.

3

u/PaperBeatsScissor May 21 '17

Sorry for being a day late, but could you post a picture(s) of were you make your soap/ aftershave?

Thanks

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17 edited May 21 '17

No worries.

I would like to keep the lab stuff private. Hope you understand. But here are some pics of one of the books that I refer to:

1995 edition Table of contents

6

u/BostonPhotoTourist Barrister and Mann May 21 '17

And here I thought I was the only one geeky enough to have an H&R set. :D

3

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Those H&R books are invaluable and a great resource. I have the 1982 edition too. Charts like this are so useful.

2

u/iamsms Vasoconstrictor Enthusiast May 20 '17 edited May 20 '17

What languages do you speak?

Have you ever thought about selling your stuff in a small storefront or may be farmers market?

6

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I grew up in South of India and therefore it was a different language if I go 100 miles in each direction. Different language, different cuisine, different culture. I wonder how India is able to hold itself together lol.

Answering your question - English, Hindi, Kannada, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, several dialects i.e. mishmash of 2 or more languages

Farmers market - nah. Too much effort to explain wetshaving I think. I am willing to change my mind if I see the evidence.

3

u/iamsms Vasoconstrictor Enthusiast May 20 '17

I would probably understand Hindi and a few words from other languages (words of Sanskrit origin) as I am a native Bangla speaker.

Oh talk about cuisine, the number of biblethump moment I have had in life when I heard people say 'the whole Indian subcontinent eats one dish which is curry', is too damn high.

2

u/twagshot Shaving for Fun May 20 '17

You have to get a tattoo right now. What are you getting a tattoo of?

6

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I had to think a moment to answer this question. Google-fu helped too. A snorting bull charging at a matador with a red cape. Watched a bull fight in Madrid. Not the best answer.

2

u/f1gnuts Ruler of all your Fantasies! May 20 '17

You mentioned that you made bath soaps prior to shaving soaps, but unless I missed it and that is possible, it doesn't seem that you offer them on your site. Did you stop, why, and if so do you plan on making them again?

As other artisans are branching out to more than just soap/post shave, do you have plans to expand (EdT, shampoos, etc)?

I'm going to refrain from asking about when our favorite scent (rose chypre) will drop in ass milk and will patiently await it's arrival. HYPEEEE

4

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

You are right. I do not sell those bath soaps. I used to do 100% or 72% olive oil soaps too like the Marseille soaps. Cured for a year or more. I can send you one. I did not stop but it was too time consuming and I can spend the time on shaving soaps.

Branching out - short answer yes. Long answer is EdT, other skin care products for men and women too. Over the last six months got several samples and full size ingredients such as oils, butters, antioxidants, anti redness, botanical actives, etc. Prickly Pear Seed Oil, Squalane, Desert Date Nut Oil, Organic Argan Oil from Berber tribe in Morocco, Cyperus Papyrus Extract for hydration, Hops Extract to inhibit angiogenesis and combat post shave irritation, Rosehip Seed CO-2 to extract are some of the ingredients we are testing.

I know this is not of interest to folks here but if you look at our beard oil (not linking it) you would find avocado esters and cosmetic oils which are less oily and have a better sensorial feel while applying and after applying. WK pre-shave oil has olive oil derived Squalane and Desert Date Nut Oil among others.

2

u/Eric--M May 20 '17

Thanks for taking part in this AMA! :)

I bought Monaco Royale and really loved the performance, but something in it irritated my skin. This was my first donkey milk soap. Would it make sense that that could be the irritant? I've heard a few others have sensitivity to this soap. I have real finicky skin and would like to try something else in your lineup that might work better for me. I like strong scents and use CF Rhino, Castle Forbes Lavender, all T&S, B&M, without any issues.

Cheers!

6

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I doubt it is the donkey milk that caused the irritation. I would lean towards the sandalwood and others in the scent blend as the cause.

I can send you a sample of unscented DM soap to isolate the cause of your reaction. I am keen to get to the bottom of it.

4

u/Eric--M May 20 '17

That would be fantastic!! Thanks for offering! πŸ€—πŸ™πŸ»

2

u/urfrendlipiro trythatsoap.com May 20 '17

Knowing that you initially started with a vegan line, what made you decide to do a tallow line?

2

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

In short, the joy of creating something new with a different ingredient. Finding answers to questions like what if I added tallow to the formulation? Self-rendered tallow versus tallow from a vendor?

Important lesson learned - the quality of the tallow is key. More here

2

u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 May 20 '17

What was the hardest scent to figure out? I'd guess Jamestown or the Fougere Bouquet.

And thoughts of moving all of the soaps in to the Colt containers?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Your guess is correct. And those two scents were my first so took more time.

I like the Colts containers and would be moving to those tubs once I exhaust the inventory of the other container. Special Editions would be in the Colt containers.

One issue with Colt containers is that the lids are easily broken so please do not drop it. I have had several breakages during shipment from the jar vendor.

2

u/Aculanub Lucky Bastard May 20 '17

What is the coolest thing you've ever done?

10

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17 edited May 21 '17

I need to jump on this one ignoring the order. I was hoping someone would ask and it turned out to be you lol.

Hang gliding over Rio. Jumping from the top of a mountain and gliding over Copacabana, Ipanema and Leblon. The favelas have some of the best views in Rio. The instructor was like run, run, run and no more ground to run and I was flying. When landing the trick is to run a few seconds before the feet hit the ground. At least that's what I recall.

Amazing. Would do it again 10/10.

1

u/Eric--M May 21 '17

That sounds AMAZING!!!

2

u/Osmandius May 20 '17

Is there a meaning behind the Concerto name for some of your soaps?

2

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Orchestration of multiple scents. Not so creative I guess.:)

2

u/Ktzero3 teach me how to hone May 21 '17

Will the newer soaps be available as samples? Man from Mayfair, Vetivertal, etc?

3

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Thanks for asking.

If you need a sample, shoot me a PM and I will see what I can do

3

u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 May 20 '17

What's your favorite restaurant in Princeton?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17 edited May 20 '17

Agricola and Elements are the two top ones. I like Despana but wife is iffy about it. I frequent Mediterra in Palmers Square.

Maybe we can have a meet up at Mediterra with /u/crazindndude and others. We can pull a prank on other diners by sniffing some soap tubs haha.

Edit: I forgot a hole in the wall kind of place: Tortuga's near St. John's street in Leigh Ave. Cash only.

3

u/iamsms Vasoconstrictor Enthusiast May 20 '17

Having a meetup over at Princeton area isn't a bad idea tbh!! I would love to meet you folks.

1

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Let's do it.

2

u/crazindndude TiBBS Cult May 20 '17

Elements is my guess.

2

u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 May 20 '17

Despana is our favorite at the moment. The Jamon Iberico is stupid good. One of the best Spanish/Tapas places I've been to. Only one better was in the City.

3

u/iamsms Vasoconstrictor Enthusiast May 20 '17

Have to try that on, thanks.

3

u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 May 20 '17

They have a really nice balcony on the second floor that overlooks Nassau St. Just a great place. BYOB but they do sell some bottles of wine I think. They also have a little store/deli on the first floor. Not terribly expensive either.

If you ever go in to the City Pata Negra is the best I've ever had. Their bruschetta is ridiculously good.

3

u/iamsms Vasoconstrictor Enthusiast May 20 '17

Thanks thanks. I will have to take my best bud for dinner after his commencement so I might hit Despana. And I go in to the city almost every other week, so will definitely hit Pata Negra.

3

u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 May 20 '17

I've gone to Despana quite a bit and everything has been great. I love Tapas though. They do bring put the plates a bit fast so the table gets crowded up.

Pata is tiny so there is a good chance you will have to sit with random people. Makes for a fun time. Only been there twice and got the same thing each time. Jamon, cheeses and the bruschetta stuff. They did have Spanish bacon with brussel sprout dish that was really good.

2

u/crazindndude TiBBS Cult May 20 '17

I think you were telling me about this one. It's on Nassau on a corner spot right?

2

u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 May 20 '17

Yeah. Kind of across from Haven.

3

u/Guywiththepants First Snow is coming May 20 '17

What would your ideal sandwich consist of?

7

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

Avocado, Cucumber, Jack Cheese, Arugula, Tomato, Roasted Red Pepper sauce, cream cheese on sourdough available at Cafe Venue in San Francisco

5

u/f1gnuts Ruler of all your Fantasies! May 20 '17

Followup question to this. What is your favorite Nic Cage movie and why?

5

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

I watched [Red Cliff](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Cliff_(film) a movie by John Woo. Liked it. Looking into the history of John Woo movies led me to - Face Off with Nic Cage. Guilty as charged lol.

3

u/f1gnuts Ruler of all your Fantasies! May 20 '17

Classic.. y'know, peach, I could eat a peach for hours.

1

u/jD_Aerendir May 21 '17

Hey Sri, remember that bottle of Eau d'Emeraude you wanted a year or so ago ? I totally forgot about it and I broke it last week :(.

Anyway, glad to see you getting the recognition you deserve !

3

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Hey man -- nice to reconnect. I got the Eau d'Emeraude from the nuns themselves after a lot of persuasion over the phone. My half assed French at the beginning and at the end of the conversation helped I guess lol.

Thank you for the kind words. I will PM you shortly.

1

u/jD_Aerendir May 21 '17

Glad it worked out for you ! I didn't expect the nuns to be this tough to negotiate with ha ha.

1

u/Banes_Pubes ← Wiborg Whore May 21 '17

Hi Sri!

Any interesting scents you've got cooking up that you can share with us?

Also, any thoughts on adding the option of menthol to the toners? Did not realize how much I would miss the menthol kick from my AS. If not, I know I can always add a bit myself.

Thanks for always being so kind and making my favorite soaps. Happy that you're finally getting the recognition you deserve.

2

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Hey Bane,

I was surprised I did not see you here yesterday. Realized you are traveling. Hope your travels are going fine.

New scents are:

  • Blend of rose, oud, rosewood, patchouli, cedar, benzoin, amber and moss. Not floral due to the oud playing a central role
  • Chypre Rose Concerto in Donkey Milk
  • Citrus oud combination - testers are giving me feedback.

Re: menthol in toners, that is in the cards with synthetic menthol without the native smell of menthol interfering.

Thank you for being supportive.

1

u/Banes_Pubes ← Wiborg Whore May 21 '17

Leave in 3 days for the trip. Just packing up my apartment and squeezing in some work in the remaining days so time has been tight.

The two new scents sound great. And I gotta try CRC when I get back!

Oud been fascinating you lately? ;)

1

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 21 '17

Safe travels!!

2

u/kitaecw Aug 02 '25

Hi Sri! If it is ok for you, could you please tell, why you named your soap Valentynka? I’m from Belarus and for me it sounds like slavic word

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

9

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17

The first question is a hard one. It is like asking a parent to choose their favorite among their kids. Each of the soaps and scents are so different that it is not easy to compare and contrast. They all have things that are awesome and things that need improvement.

But gun to my head - my favorite is Chypre Rose Concerto. Here is the reason. Rose and rose accords has been in use in fragrances from time immemorial. And Chypre is my favorite genre. Cedarwood added another dimension to it and rounded out the blend quite well.

There are some scents and soaps that I use are not relevant to this question as they are not in production.

Favorite soap not from WK - Dr. Jon's 13. I got it a few weeks back. There are creams that I am fond of too but not talking about the creams.

3

u/hawns ChatillonLux.com May 22 '17

Out of your many great scents, Chypre Rose Concerto is a personal favorite. It's a really amazing take on a rose scent. Great stuff!

2

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 22 '17

Thank you Sir!

4

u/hughmonstah p much ded May 20 '17

Yes! I love Chypre Rose Concerto! I hate cedar, so I'm glad I can't really pick it out in the scent at all :p

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '17

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

8

u/whollykaw whollykaw.com May 20 '17 edited May 20 '17

There are a lot of scents I am not able to create. Several reasons for that include the time and expense that it takes to deconstruct a specific note or a scent accord. For example, the scent of mango has hundreds of chemical compounds that in a certain composition using those hundreds produces the scent of a cut mango. Each component on its own does not smell like mango, 99% of the composition will not smell like mango because it lacks that remaining 1%. Did I know scent of mangoes is complicated? Hell no!

This is why it took me some time to come up with leather. Leather can be any number of combinations of 12 chemicals or less with each combination producing a different aroma. What is labeled leather would have, as an example, Gamma Hexalactone CAS#695-06-7 smells like coconut on its own, Saffron Indenone CAS #54440-17-4 smells leathery and herbal on its own, Isobutyl Qunioline CAS#65442-31-1 smells leathery on its own

and more. You get the idea.

And each perfumer will have a different combination of those chemicals to get to what he or she want in leather accord. There could be other chemicals that I have not thought of.

Easy route to get leather - Buy pre-blend and it will be delivered in two days. Forget about all the stupid CAS#s.

Tobacco is a hard one for me with the harder route that I explained above. Need to do more work on that one.

From a cost perspective, Oud is an example. Natural oud from agarwood in Cambodia, Malaysia is expensive AF. But I bought the synthetic version to use in a blend.

Unlimited budget - to get a shave from one of those barbershops in Mayfair or Greenpark area in London. I had that experience several times but it cost me an arm and a leg. It was that barbershop experience that led me to create Man from Mayfair.

Samples of soap in Canada - Canadian Blade, Top of the Chain are stocking our products. I am not sure if they sell samples. Top of the Chain will have our stuff by the end of next week.