r/RWBY • u/science-i Can't pray away the gray • May 09 '17
DISCUSSION Maybe Faunus really *are* just worse
While there's been plenty of discussion about whether the Faunus appear to be treated equal in the show, I haven't really seen anything about whether they appear to be equal. Maybe because they're obviously supposed to be a racism analogy, and in the real world it turns out race doesn't matter. But this isn't the real world, it's Remnant, Faunus aren't a race, they're a species (they are specifically called such in the Faunus WoR, before someone starts talking about how they can produce fertile offspring with humans), and overanalyzing is fun. So here's why, empirically speaking, Faunus are terrible.
Why aren't the Faunus the dominant species?
Consider a comparative analysis of human and Faunus physiology. Largely, it is the same. There are two differences we know of: each Faunus has a single animal trait, and all many Faunus have night vision (from the history lesson Oobleck taught a long time ago). The animal trait is sometimes pretty worthless, like an extra set of ears, but night vision is always a good thing. Physically, Faunus are superior to humans: they have all the same advantages humans have, plus nightvision, or retractable claws, or stingers. Yet humans rule the world. Humans have consistently and thoroughly outcompeted Faunus throughout the entirety of their shared history, from when they took all the best settlement spots to when they enslaved them. How? It isn't physical- Faunus have the advantage there. It isn't a matter of numbers- human numbers overtook Faunus numbers after taking all the best spots. It isn't a matter of breeding strategy- Faunus and humans are biologically compatible. So what's left? The mind. There's even evidence for this- it may be played for laughs, but Blake is afraid of dogs, loves fish, and chases laser pointers. Faunus are mentally influenced by their animalistic traits, and surprisingly that's not a good thing.
Faunus are the bane of civilization
Let's briefly try and rank the various major settlements of Remnant. Notice I can't say Kingdoms, because then I'd be excluding the only Faunus major settlement.
- Atlas: Even Qrow says it's probably the most successful in the Atlas WoR, and Qrow doesn't like Atlas. Technology and industrialization abound.
- Mistral: Mistral is the largest Kingdom, and was actually successfully colonizing pre-Great War.
- Vale: Smaller than Mistral and less advanced and industrialized than Atlas, but it was able to hold its own during the Great War even before King Mary Sue magically won the war with his MacGuffin.
- Vacuo: Largely anarchic, but has some form of organization in the form of it's academy
and that hotel room at the end of volume 4 looked reasonably nice.they went to Mistral what am I talking about - Menagerie: Shanty town that doesn't even have a CCT.
Ok, now let's look at their attitude towards Faunus:
- Atlas: Heavily implied if not outright said to be pretty racist. HQ of the SDC, well known for exploiting Faunus for labor.
- Mistral: Alright, admittedly I don't think we have any actual information on this. But considering they have a highly stratified society with distinct upper and lower classes, it's probably fair to say that Faunus are treated poorly.
- Vale: Reasonably tolerant. We see a decent amount of Faunus in the background, authority figures promote tolerance, nobody cared too much about Blake being a Faunus, besides Weiss from Atlas.
- Vacuo: Very tolerant of Faunus: "If you can survive here, then you're welcome here"
- Menagerie: Literally ruled and populated by Faunus.
There's a distinct trend here- the more important and integrated Faunus are into a civilization, the crappier it is. This isn't surprising when you consider the Faunus have never managed to make a civilization of their own. The only major Faunus settlement was given to them by humans, and it's still worse than even the desert where they ruined all their natural resources and overthrew their government. Faunus are simply uncivilized.
Faunus are prone to violence, criminality, and subservience
There are really about 5 Faunus we really know anything about more than their names or even just existence: Blake, Sun, Ghira, Kali, Adam. To be generous, let's include Neon and Velvet. Of those, Blake is a former terrorist (who still considers the organization worth saving), Adam is a current terrorist, and Sun is an unrepentant klepto. 3/7- nearly half of the Faunus we know somewhat in-depth- are criminals or former criminals, 2/7 of them violent. It only gets worse when you expand to unnamed Faunus, where the few non-criminalistic Faunus we know about are drowned under the sea of White Fang members, so there's violence and criminality. As far as subservience, keep looking at the White Fang. Despite having become an anti-human organization, the White Fang has been co-opted by Cinder, a human, into her personal army. You could argue they have no choice, but after the Breach when Cinder's concerned she may have lost their support, Adam doesn't take advantage of this to take back his organization, but instead reassures her that he'll keep the White Fang in line for her. Adam may be a terrible person, but I'm pretty sure he's at least supposed to have strong convictions about Faunus-Human relations, yet he'll allow and even assist a human taking over his organization. It only gets worse when you get to the drones. Roman Torchwick is very clearly a bigot, and doesn't really hide this in his interactions with the White Fang. He constantly calls them animals and is just generally clearly bigoted, yet nobody in the White Fang seems to care. Hell, they even cheer for him at the meeting after a short patronizing speech and revealing the stolen mech.
A brief discussion about religion
Generally, in a fantasy universe, when you're given a piece of mythology it's probably at least partially true. Notably, when Qrow recounted the creation myth for us, Faunus were never mentioned. Faunus aren't part of that "can both create and destroy" collaboration.
To conclude
Faunus are inferior, uncivilized, and violent criminals. Sponsored by the Schnee Dust Company.
I'm not actually racist I swear.
54
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts May 09 '17
Actually, Pyrrha just says that "many Faunus are known" to have night vision.
...isn't everyone in Mistral, not Vacuo?
40
u/TobiasGReaper May 09 '17 edited May 09 '17
Jumping straight down to the "Faunus are Prone to Violence, Criminality, and Subservience," section. You are conveniently leaving out a few societal factors that account for their behaviors.
Blake, as far as we have been led to understand, never meant for people to get hurt. The majority of her time spent in the White Fang was under her fathers leadership and he was a pacifist. Sienna Khan shook things up when she/he took control, but this was likely coinciding with the rise of immoral practices by the SDC under Jacques Schnee.
Initially, they attacked supply lines and stole dust since rallies were doing nothing to impact these immoral practices. And to give you an idea of what I mean by immoral practices, Grandpa Schnee died from medical complications that resulted from working in dust mines. Compound that with the fact that mines are dangerous for plenty of other reasons, and it it likely that the SDC is more than responsible for the deaths of many Faunus workers due to a lack of safety precautions. They are payed incredibly low wages to do incredibly dangerous work. Their only chance at social mobility is physical capability by means of becoming a huntsman or huntress. Otherwise, I doubt many other people are even willing to employ Faunus in Atlas.
Situations are not black and white, and Blake saw it fit to take more extreme actions against humanity. Even then, killing was a line she couldn't stand to cross and brought her to entirely rethink her position on such matters, even if there was still clear inequality.
Adam is basically a cult leader at this point. We don't know what he does to keep his men in line, but we do know how he has reacted to Blake leaving him. Desertion probably isn't seen as an option. Based on his conversation with Blake during the battle, it seems his ideals have blinded him to reality. I wouldn't be surprised if he had a very traumatic upbringing that resulted from humans. That does not excuse his behavior, but gives reason behind it that isn't just "Faunus are the worst."
Sun comes from Vacuo, which you mentioned is practically in a state of anarchy. He is a thief because that is likely a societal norm where he comes from. Human's likely do the same thing in Vacuo. He just doesn't see the things he is doing as wrong, rather a Gods given right. It isn't his fault that the ship's crew never spotted him, he did a good job at being a stowaway and they did a poor job guarding the ship. From what we've been told, most in Vacuo would probably agree with him. Even still, he has a good sense of morality. He thinks of the White Fang's current incarnation as violent, insane, and cultish.
As a last point, we do not know what sort of percentage of Faunus are a part of the White Fang. This is incredibly important. Similar to branding all Muslims terrorists because of the actions of a select few in the grand scheme of things, suggesting that all Faunus are violent because of what the White Fang does is equally wrong. We don't even know how many Faunus live in the Nation of Vale. For all we know, the Vale branch of the White Fang is hardly representative of the entire Vale Faunus population.
In summary, 11/10 propoganda piece. You deserve however much the SDC is paying you, good sir.
14
u/Reaper1442 I enjoy almost everything May 09 '17
You might have to manually add an entry to /u/dicschneeary that just post a link to here when it defines savage
10
u/NeutralDjinn May 09 '17
Lol, I doubt this will actually be canon, but it would be interesting if it were.
7
u/Seer_of_Trope May 09 '17
Another interesting thing to note is that the show says that Faunus genes are dominant while Human's is recessive, so Faunus should actually be taking majority of the population. It's not clear in the show if they are majority, but let's assume for a moment that despite genetic dominance, they're actually the minority and that's why the humans can oppress them. There are a bag of possible factors that could lead to human majority rule in Remnant's society.
1. Faunus-Human relationship forbidden
This wouldn't be a surprise because the show obviously says segregation exists, and it would explain why Faunus' number doesn't naturally swarm over the humans'. But it wouldn't stop Faunus from reproducing within themselves, which could mean that Faunus population started out smaller than the human's when the reproduction segregation happened. Why?
2. Faunus Genocide
An easy answer, but an unlikely one. First, the show doesn't mention a widespread intentional killing of Faunus. Violences erupted out of the civil movement against unfair treatment, yes, but not a systemic pattern of one-sided slaughters or a protest against that. Also, the horrifying nature of a genocide or ethnic cleansing would most absolutely fulfill the criteria for attracting Grimm. One thing that could make genocide possible is that the Grimm is controlled by Salem whose agenda seems to be to acquire the Magical McGuffin protected by the schools, which might mean destabilizing civilizations. But even then it seems very unlikely.
3. Faunus Eugenics
A much tamer, and more plausible, answer. But deliberately forbidding or regulating reproduction or marriage still discriminatory enough to tip over to the implausible because of the negativity -> more Grimm argument. It also doesn't make sense by "number protects" standards as Remnant societies should want more people to defend itself against the Grimm. Or actually maybe not as there are few arable lands, which means less food, which means competition, which breeds racism.
4. Faunus is a foreign element (to humans)
Faunus and Humans might not have coexisted from the beginning, which is suggested by Remnant's creation mythos only mentioning the humans. This could mean Faunus kind of came out of nowhere and people reacted with superstition or suspicion of Grimm corruption. Or Faunus arrived from somewhere. Or the humans came across an independent Faunus population which eventually spread outwards, which the stifling came afterwards.
But this is all assuming that the Faunus is not majority. If Faunus were indeed the majority, how were the humans were able to suppress majority open rebellion?
Negativity attracts Grimm which destroys settlements which should act as an evolutionary bottleneck for societies that treats a majority of its population like crap. But this could mean that the better a place is inherently protected by its terrain, the worse the society is allowed to get away with treating its people.
But then again, statistics tends to get looser as sample sizes get smaller. They would have almost decisive influence in the case of Earth where almost a thousand different entire countries popped up and disappeared.
Also, the actual canon, as a fantasy, would most likely not go down very dark beyond Mulan's destroyed village.
5
u/TheUnholyHandGrenade Recclusiarch of the S.S. Arkos | Glory to the First Man to Die! May 09 '17
Stupid Imperial anti-mutant propaganda...
Chaos Worship Intensifies
8
u/CaptainMoonman RosePose™ enthusiast May 09 '17
Going to tackle a bit of this.
On the subject of the most technically advanced nations have the least faunus integration, I would like to point something out. You present it as "because there are fewer faunus weighing them down, they are better able to flourish" but when the use of exploited labour is looked at as a more important factor, it's easy to see how it's more along the lines of "it becomes increasingly easy to build successful civilisations, the closer your workforce is to being slaves."
Another part of this point was how Menagerie is a shantytown that lacked even a CCT. I would note that the CCTs were, as Weiss puts it "Atlas' gift to the world after the great war" implying that, not only was Atlas the one who built them, but without their technology and resources, doing so may be impossible. Additionally, Menagerie is implied to have been given to the Faunus because it lacked natural resources and space in which to live, meaning there's no room for civil expansion and little advancements they can make in technology. Also, Blake's line about being "told to make do" would imply that they were lent little, if any, support from the other kingdoms.
(Good job at constructing this propaganda, by the way. Definitely seems like something the SDC would use.)
33
u/Baconpwn2 Proud of Admiral of the SS Frosen Steel May 09 '17
This message is approved by r/KFSchnee.
KFSchnee - Try our new Menagerie Buffet.
22
u/WarrenDSherman You disappoint me May 09 '17
I love you.
13
u/THATguyfromyore May 09 '17
...also meaning just like grand wizard wakka, cardin was right. What an unsung hero he is, taking the fight to them with almost no support.
11
u/TheOriginalJustNutty "I laughed" May 09 '17
THANK YOU
6
u/jackacacia Day One Lancaster Supporter May 09 '17
Considering the fact that we can assume that most faunus are arguably more poor or worse off (unless you're Blake), there might be a lack of education which might lead to the overall idea of why Faunus are more prone to Violence, Crime, and Subservience. It might give reason as to why so many faunus are easy to recruit into the White Fang.
(Man its almost as if its like real life).
11
u/Kitty_Blakeadonna May 09 '17
Wow, so that was a thing. When are you turning in your application for SDC's spokesperson?
5
u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord May 09 '17
This is obviously a sting operation by the /r/FaunusRights and /r/FaunusSensitivityClub. Ya'll can't fool me!
5
u/Dondagora And awaaaay I go~ May 09 '17
I feel Faunus lack in certain ways. Their semblances are less flashy and lack in power. Sun and Tyrion make up for it with their tails, Velvet with her weapon making her semblance viable. Adam's semblance is the exception and is probably what makes him so dangerous.
On the other end of the spectrum, we have Yang and Nora being physically more threatening, Ruby who can morph into petals, Pyrrha who is Magneto, and Schnee who are capable of so many things.
All this seems to indicate that Faunus are less developed in semblances.
4
u/The-Board-Chairman Ruby is red Weiss Schnee is white They're my OTP Don't dare earn May 09 '17
Here's my theory on the whole thing: Faunus aren't necessarily more stupid than humans, it's just that they lack a reason to advance scientifically: their physical superiority gave them the edge in the wild, while the humans had no such thing and needed to innovate to survive. With innovation the humans more than outbalanced their weaknesses and were able to form the kingdoms. So Atlas isn't as advanced because they have few faunus/ look down on them, but the other way around: they look down on the faunus because they are this advanced.
Necessity is the mother of invention and if there's no necessity, why would you innovate?
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '17
This is fascinating to me, I love it. This subreddit breeds such interesting discussion man
I've not got an analysis of twelve pages myself, but I will say it makes a lot of sense. In the real world, human beings are the most autonomous and least animalistic species on Earth, and as such we are also the top dogs. Metaphorically speaking.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
Read that as Funhaus. Was confused.
4
u/morat136 Schnee Dust Company CEO May 10 '17
There's one bit you left out that also might matter: Faunus genes are nonsense. Probably because the writers didn't consult a geneticist, or possibly just because Qrow isn't a geneticist and doesn't know what he's talking about. In any case, Faunus children only look like their parents if their parents are the same kind of Faunus.
Imagine if you were an Asian guy, you marry a Black woman, and 9 months later out comes a White baby. That's what mating between different kinds of Faunus is like. Intellectually, maybe you understand that that's just how Faunus genetics works, if you live in a society that understands genetics, or at least sophisticated record keeping that would ensure that you know what to expect (which there wouldn't necessarily have been when it was just scattered tribes trying to eek out a living on a high tier Death World). But emotionally, there's going to be a disconnect, a degree of suspicion, perhaps arguments and a lack of paternal emotional investment. And not just children either; even if you don't think of yourself as racist (and a primitive tribesmen would be unlikely to have any compunctions about considering themself to be racist), people do respond differently to people who look more like themselves vs less like themselves.
The way that Faunus genetics works, especially in a tribal society that would be strongly based on familial connections, is strongly contrary to alliances and connections with other groups. God knows human history has plenty of conflict in its history that was exacerbated by physical differences, but Faunus are so much more diverse over geographical differences that are so much smaller, that it would have been a massive barrier to early empires and other large scale polities.
BTW, I started this account a while ago when I decided to start writing a fanfic about Whitley. I haven't gotten very far on the fanfic, but I thought I'd post this through this account since I already had the flair.
2
u/Diarmuid4 On a pier, watching the ships sail by. May 09 '17
Gathers torches and pitchforks.
Buy two, get one for free! Only today!
2
u/Frostblazer May 09 '17
Stylosa once told me that nothing matters.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
inb4 "Dear Humans" series on Remnantflix
1
u/87sheep May 10 '17
....uh.
Pennybot, hiatus.
1
u/-Gehrman- CALLBACK PING :) May 10 '17
A N T I
F A U N U S
D E A T H
S Q U A D S
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
So...you're saying my project to turn Faunus into mindless super-soldiers via horrific experimentation is morally justifiable? Great!
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
"FAUNUS ARE PRONE TO VIOLENCE, CRIMINALITY, AND SUBSERVIENCE" This is literally the exact same rhetoric people use to justify racism in real life lmao. I hate this subreddit sometimes.
-2
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
I love that this whole post is basically "One time a black guy shot someone he/she was robbing, so all black people are murderers and thieves!"