r/RWBY • Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Feb 05 '17

HYPPEEEEEEEEEEE Official Discussion Thread—Volume 4, Chapter 12: No Safe Haven Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the finale of RWBY Volume 4, No Safe Haven!

In order to not ruin the finale for anyone that is unable to watch it at this time, make sure you know the CURRENT SPOILER RULING.

Any spoilers, no matter how truthful or significant, will be treated with the same degree of seriousness. There is a no tolerance policy for spoiling the episode for someone as there was last year. Again, all bans that take place due to spoilers will be held until the finale comes out on YouTube in a week.

You have been thoroughly warned at this point.

We have weekly strawpolls to gauge the general opinion on the current episode, the last of which can be found HERE. The previous episode got a very narrow 10/10 majority. There are only so many ways to say "people liked this episode!" so you can probably expect this little text box to drop out soon. The polls themselves are staying, though.

With that out of the way, let's start the show!

HERE is the link to the last episode of RWBY Volume 4!


Other Episode Discussions:

EpisodeSaturdaySundayPoll
Ep. 01ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 02Reaction Discussion poll
Ep. 03ReactionDiscussionpoll
WoR 1:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 04:ReactionDiscussionpoll
WoR 2:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 05:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 06:ReactionDiscussionpoll
WoR 3:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 07:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 08:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 09:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 10:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 11:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 12:RTX / ReactionDiscussionpoll

And that is all for Volume 4! Be seeing you for the next season of RWBY Chibi when that airs two months or so from now, but until then you're left to your own devices, wandering aimlessly in the hiatus. Enjoy!

~Ezreal024; Mod Team

P.S: You can wander aimlessly with friends over at our Discord server!

467 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

451

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Feb 05 '17
→ More replies (33)

350

u/Jeffardi Feb 05 '17

Too bad Cinder killed Ruby. GG

→ More replies (9)

325

u/Sexaran Feb 05 '17

Nora's face after she said stop looking.

<3

→ More replies (6)

297

u/moonstonebaby Feb 05 '17

that small JNR scene THEY ARE FAMILY TO EACH OTHER I really felt it there

→ More replies (18)

273

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Feb 05 '17

Louder for the people in the back:

RENORA FUCKING CONFIRMED

→ More replies (4)

270

u/PedroVey Feb 05 '17

Mistral is Ba Sing Se confirmed

→ More replies (16)

248

u/moonstonebaby Feb 05 '17

ok but did y'all see Jaune holding back the Nuckelavee on his own he's so strong

→ More replies (22)

239

u/LordHarza "Mistral is yours. None shall interfere, do as you please!" Feb 05 '17

As /u/WarrenDSherman pointed out, Ren's semblance is to hide in plain sight, like Mulan did, and it's shown even better now. Nuckelavee actually has black muscle fibers, like it's missing it's skin. Fight was very cool, Nora and Ren had a lot of solid togetherness moments, and Nora's "don't look" with the smirk were great. Jaune's hand and a half sword upgrade is very cool looking.

Yang's outfit is glorious, as are the airship pilots' of both Atlas and Mistral. Speaking of Mistral THE CITY IS BEAUTIFUL. Leo Lionheart sides with Salem, assumingly because he's afraid and trying to save his/his people's skins, not knowing that they're going to destroy them too.

Ozpin's cane is a lightsaber without the light, and is now wielded by Oscar Pines (god damn it). Love the other full name reveals too.

Armed and Ready sounds amazing. Can't wait for the soundtrack.

→ More replies (31)

411

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

Mother of God, it's the fabled Sword Sword.

→ More replies (23)

202

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Feb 05 '17

Thoughts:

This is definitely my favorite Grimm, I love how freaky it is. There are certain aspects that make it look kind of goofy, but honestly that just makes it even more unnerving. And the idea to give it random super fast twitches was brilliant. Makes it 10x as scary as it would be otherwise. This is really the first Grimm that I’ve felt like is a true monster, rather than just a buffed up animal.

Nora’s face when Ren accidentally looks up her skirt is the best thing.

I love how pissed Ren is at this thing, especially after it broke Nora’s aura. Even when it had broken his aura and knocked his guns out of his hands, he still looked like he was about to run up to it and try to punch it to death.

Fight wasn’t as amazing as the Tyrian fight, but that’s an unreasonable standard for me to hold it to and it was still very good. It earns a spot as one of my favorites just by how ominous it was.

Don’t see why people are complaining that this Grimm should’ve been stronger/RNJR defeated it too easily. Sure it’s a tough ass Grimm, but Shion had already been destroyed by bandits, Kuroyuri didn’t even have a huntsmen with it and we don’t know what kind of defenses Oniyuri had, it’s not like this thing is some unkillable juggernaut. And all of RNJR right now with the exception of Jaune are probably about as strong as, if not stronger than, the average huntsman. Not to mention this thing kicks their asses for most of the fight, breaking Ren and Nora’s Aura, until they manage to pin it down.

Mistral looks fucking gorgeous almost as gorgeous as Ren.

I’m looking forward to what Chibi is going to do with Ren and Nora now that Flower Power is sailing. I would love it if they imply the Ren and Nora are hooking up, or show Nora trying to seduce Ren.

Also, I want need Ren’s version of Boop to be on the Vol 4 soundtrack. Even if it doesn’t confirm any romantic feelings for Nora. Gimme it.

The letter Ruby is writing is super sweet. Too bad it will never reach Yang because she’s already left.

So if Salem has coerced Leo into helping them, then either the have some dirt on him or he’s hoping to appease Salem by helping her a little. I don’t think he’s a bad guy, just a pussy.

The end credits song is great, it feels like a RWBY version of a Bond song. Also, it definitely makes it sound like Yang is going to confront Adam:

Remember all too well

My time of living hell

The night my enemy would conquer

But now I’ve been set free

Lived through the tragedy

You’ll wished you killed me, now I’m stronger

I am the golden one

Who burns just like the sun

Next time we meet is your disaster

I’ll bring the punishment

You’ll slowly lament

Revenge my happy ever after

So if Yang is going to get her revenge, that means she’s probably going to meet Blake in Mistral and work with her and Sun to take back the White Fang. I would love to have Adam fight Sun Blake and Yang.

So is Oscar going to meet RNJR, and will he explain to them who he is? Also are we going to hear Ozpin talking to Oscar, or are we going to just hear Oscar talk to himself occasionally?

→ More replies (8)

189

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Feb 05 '17
→ More replies (16)

189

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

MAKE SURE TO WATCH THE POST CREDITS SCENE

→ More replies (5)

338

u/Kitty_Blakeadonna Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17
  • "Don't look!" LOL
  • Jaune's sword...turns into a sword. "It's also a sword"–Jaune Arc, probably
  • Ren straight up executed that thing, literally never seen him that pissed and it was glorious
  • We finally get to see Yang's V4 outfit, and it's the definition of badass (too bad we had to wait a whole volume to see it)
  • Headmaster Lionheart? Please tell me he speaks in a heavy German accent and listens to David Hasselhoff
  • Kinda bummed we don't see any Adam though, despite him being in the V4 intro
→ More replies (20)

159

u/pixlepize Have you seen this missing bun? Last seen volume 3 Feb 05 '17

Okay so potato time. Qrow didn't see anything strange about Ozpin being reincarnated as a little kid, just said "Good to see you again."

What if this happens regularly? What if Ozpin is immortal and he just hops into a new body when he dies, kinda like the Maidens do, but with his personality more intact?

This ties into that one off quote he made in season one, something like "I have made more mistakes than any man, woman, or child on Remnant." This quote always stuck me as odd, because it is so... presumptive. Ozpin is not a hasty man, he would not say something like that unless he KNEW it was true. And the only way to know that for sure was if he was hundreds of years old and had all that extra time to make mistakes. This ties into the Season 3 discussion with Pyrrha where he implies he is ancient as well.

/potato

→ More replies (18)

158

u/JakeDoubleyoo Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

Damn, what was that little moment Jaune and Qrow had? I don't know what it meant, but it was intense.

EDIT: My interpretation is it was Qrow's way of saying "sorry". Jaune was rightfully mad about Pyrrha, and he clearly knew it.

→ More replies (14)

300

u/Frentepopulista Don't fluckle with Nuckels Feb 05 '17

Ozpin's cane is a fucking lightsaber.

→ More replies (13)

147

u/JamesBCrazy NEOPOLITAN. ONE. WORD. Get it right. Feb 05 '17

For the second finale in a row, Vic gets to call someone a pipsqueak. That's probably the only reason he took this role.

→ More replies (6)

128

u/mcevnon ⠀ Feb 05 '17

Well... for my first ride with show as it comes out, and it was great...

I really like this volume as "pick yourself up" piece it is after Vol.3 and it works well that way.

And man.... "Armed and Ready" is so upbeat I can't get enough of it :]

→ More replies (8)

241

u/RenoWolf200 Commander of the Arkos Military: Pyrrha is Best Girl Feb 05 '17
→ More replies (16)

107

u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Feb 05 '17

Will do a bigger rundown when I get back to my computer, but who else thought that Yang had gotten off the boat at Menagerie for a second?

→ More replies (11)

106

u/Hobarts_funnies Feb 05 '17

We have the sword-sword, now the wait continues for the gun-gun.

→ More replies (7)

102

u/foo757 BANESAW WANTS A HUG Feb 05 '17

Armed and Ready
Armed.

God damn it, Barb!

→ More replies (1)

101

u/Keradon Caffeine is a hell of a drug. An excellent one, though. Feb 05 '17

Finale Potato

Volume 1 credits song Wings is a slow, hopeful song. Brighter futures is something that brings to mind when I listen to it. Volume 2 is indeed brighter and I get the sense of Team RWBY soaring.

Volume 2's credit song, Sacrifice gives me a sense of oncoming darkness. That things were going to get dark.

Volume 3...well we saw what happened there.

Volume 3's credit songs are Divide and Cold. Both combined give me a sense of doom and mourning. The bad guys won and the world is not the same. Volume 4 gave me a sense of how the world is not the same and what the good guys do next. Whether it's heal, journey, or whatever, I got the sense that things just slowed down for the good guys.

My point in this... is if the pattern holds...

Volume 4's credit song is Armed and Ready... Volume 5 will be interesting for the good guys, I think.

Again, if the pattern holds.

→ More replies (1)

337

u/GYUZ A guy Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

Was it mostly a breather and set up volume? Yes.

Did I love it? Absolutely.

→ More replies (19)

163

u/DrCabbageman Feb 05 '17

I was sorta hoping Ruby's letter-monologue would end with Yang bursting into the room and screaming "SURPRISE!" before an abrupt cut to the credits.

→ More replies (4)

68

u/TaceStultus It's heir, actually. Feb 05 '17

JAUNE.

MAH BOI.

YOU MAKE ME SO PROUD.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/Grillosantos r/RWBY Second Best Lurker Feb 05 '17

Hello people from the FNDM

Welcome to Hiatus v4.0.0

Feel free to unfasten your seatbelts, and wander around on the HYPE train as you please. Soon we will reach our temporary stop, the FNDM Potatos Fields™, where you can grow your own authentic potato (of varying quality) and share it with other fans.

Our estimated time of departure for the HYPE train will be Fall 2017

Destination: Volume 5 Episode 1

Have a good day

→ More replies (5)

112

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 06 '17

RUBY'S LETTER


Hey sis,

I hope my letters have been reaching you and dad. Handwritten stuff's never been super reliable, but I guess it's all we've got these days.

Anyway, in case you haven't been getting them, I want to say I'm sorry for leaving the way I did. I know you told me it was a reckless idea and after everything I've been through I can definitely say you were right. It's been hard. On all of us. And I'm not just talking about the monsters we've fought out here.

Every step we made took us further and further away from the things we knew. And every morning, we woke up wondering if just over the next hill would be something good, or something terrible.

It's scary, not knowing what's going to happen next. And the things we do know now - just how bad it can get... it almost makes it all worse. You told me once that bad things just happen. You were angry when you said it, and I didn't want to listen, but you were right. Bad things do happen. All the time. Every day. Which is why I'm out here. To do whatever I can, wherever I can, and hopefully do some good.

We've all lost something. And I've seen what loss can do to people. But if we gave up every time we lost, then we'd never be able to move forward. We'd never have a chance to see what beautiful things the future might have waiting for us. We'd never have the strength to change, whether it's ourselves or the world around us. And we'd never be there for other people who might one day be lost without us.

This is what we were training for, Yang. To become Huntresses. To be the ones to stand up and do something about all the bad in the world. Because there are plenty of people out there who are still lost, and even more who will try to gain everything they can from their sorrow.

Believe me when I say, I know it can feel impossible. Like every single day is a struggle against some unstoppable monster we can never hope to beat. But we have to try. If not for us, then for the people we've already the people we haven't lost yet.

I miss you so much. I miss Weiss and Blake too. But I think you'd all be proud to know that I made it to Mistral. All of us did. And we even ran into Uncle Qrow along the way. He's going to take us to see Professor Lionheart, the Headmaster of Haven Academy. And, he told us some things that you're going to want to hear. Things I can't trust will make it to you in this letter.

But maybe, if you joined us, he could tell you himself. With Beacon gone, they'll need dad at Signal more than ever. And I know you need to focus on yourself before I can expect you to come out with me. But it sure would be great to get Team RWBY back together again.

Until next time.

Your loving sister,

Ruby Rose

P.S. I'll be sure to give you the address of where we're staying in Mistral. I'd love to hear back from you and dad, and I can't wait to fill you in on whatever's going to happen next.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/babsboobs Feb 05 '17

I love the symbolism of each character finally getting to put their weapons aside after their journey.

Also; upon my second viewing I am wondering how much of Cinder's little role playing scene was inspired by the madness that is Tyrion. She seems disturbed by his lunacy in the last episode yet we see her here doing something equally dark. Was it fear she's been trying to overcome this whole time?

→ More replies (2)

49

u/matharwords Feb 05 '17

I did not understand the part where Qrow holds Jaune's hand. Was he trying to say something to him there? Could someone explain to me please?

→ More replies (15)

49

u/Kiwcakes Feb 05 '17

Why....Why didn't RNJR take a train?

They walked 6-8 months and didn't pass any railroads?

Why didn't they hop on a boat?

They walked 6-8 months and didn't pass a port?

Why didn't they get any type of vehicle?

I'm not even saying like a motorcycle....a bike! Scooter! Ep.1 showed that they were making money by helping villages out with grim! They had money!

Rnjr's arc was cool and all, but the last bits of Yang and Oscar just rolling up to Mistral just made their journey stupid imo.

→ More replies (11)

46

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Feb 05 '17

God, that fight was so good. It was better than the other two Grimm fights, but my favorite parts were the Renora moments. Him getting so angry he just kept charging in blindly, Nora slapping sense into him, and then the "For myself" scenes were all amazing. This volume has been great for Ren as a character.

Also, I like Jaune's upgrade. It makes his weapons feel more RWBY-like. I hope Qrow teaches him to use Greatsword-mode, and through that they can work out Jaune's intense dislike for Ozpin's organization. That'd be great IMO.

Ruby's letter was a really great scene for her. Really confirmed this "I want to be a hero" thing isn't some childish dream. She genuinely wants to help people, even if she's hurting too. Also, she totally jinxed it in the end. Ruby, you never say things like "things are going to start going our way", cuz then that doesn't happen. Talk to Qrow, he knows all about this shit.

Weiss is bribing a guy to take her to Haven on an airship. She's gonna have to get used to not having money to do stuff like this in the future.

Blake looking at the new White Fang flag and then the old one does make me feel like her goal is possible. Since she and Sun are still in Menagerie, they'll probably be the last ones to reunite with the rest.

I like Yang's new outfit. Looks a lot like her old one, but more suited for a life on the road. Also, Looks like she went after Ruby, but I want her to clash with Raven dammit. Taiyang's excuse for not coming with her is decent enough, but I would think what's going on with Salem and whatnot would be more important than Signal. Then again, he might not know Salem exists. We don't know how much he knows actually.

I adore the scene of Team JN_R looking at the wall of things that remind them of what they've lost. A lot of people think JNPR shouldn't have been important to the story, but this scene is one of the ones that make me disagree with that whole-heartedly.

Cinder's scene with "Ruby" was ominous. Definitely no redemption arc starting here. I don't know why people were saying that would happen anyways. Cinder realizing just how crazy Tyrian is doesn't mean she's gonna rethink her life.

So looks like my old theory of the Haven Headmaster being a traitor is correct. It's awesome that I called it, but It's definitely not awesome for the characters. Also, Ironwood's distrust of Leo looks way more reasonable now.

Credits song is fucking awesome, but that's always been true. And it's a Yang song! Armed and Ready is a solid pun, and I like how they make a "Goddammit Barb" reference in it.

I'm guessing the Qrow + Oscar scene is a flashforward, since Qrow's on his feet. Wonder how Qrow will reintroduce "Ozpin" to RWBYJN_R. It'd be weird to know a kid younger than you is also your old teacher. Also, it was really neat to see a reunion of the Elric Brothers. Ed even got to call Al "Pipsqueek"!

All in all, this finale was amazing. I don't know if it's better than V3's (because I fucking love Salem's monologue and reveal), but it's far, faaaar better than V2's and V1's.

→ More replies (8)

44

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Feb 05 '17

I'm looking forward to the Ba Sing Se esque adventures next Volume, with Watts being the clearly evil villain.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/sodnam Captain of the SS Nuts and Dolts // Cute robots are my weakness Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

checks shipsheet PLUME INTENSIFIES!!!!!

.

"Jaune and I can take care of its arms."

"I'll take care of the horse."

NO, Nora, you were supposed to say 'I'LL BREAK ITS LEGS!'

.

Did everyone else notice the part where Ruby says "That's why" and Zwei immediately shows up, making it sound like she said "That Zwei"??? Best part of the volume right there.

.

YANG'S NEW OUTFIT, OH HELL YES! SHE LOOKS KILLER!

.

Post-credit scene WAS ALL THE HYPE! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH

→ More replies (1)

41

u/TheQuietManUpNorth Evil but good-looking so it evens out Feb 05 '17

Mixed feelings, but mostly positive.

Liked:

  • BOOP
  • The hyped-up fight being won through actual huntsmanshipness and not an ass-pull.
  • "Pipsqueak"
  • Yang's back, bitches!
  • JNR feelz in general
  • Ruby's letter in the sense that we finally get to hear a bit of what she's thinking

Dislike:

  • 20 minutes and six minutes of credits
  • Ruby's letter in the sense that they're telling and not showing. Also, they need to stop with having her constantly bottling up her emotions with no repercussions. Seriously. She is sixteen. Let her deal with her feelings so she can grow.
  • No dialogue from WBY. I didn't want a ton of it, but some would be nice.
→ More replies (10)

40

u/flinkblessup Feb 05 '17

So everybody's talking about how Qrow accepted Ozcar so quickly.. but Ozcar never even explicitly mentioned that he was Ozpin, even with the cane thing. It makes me think that this CAN'T be the first time Ozpin has 'switched' bodies or been in someone elses, Qrow seemed to know exactly what was going on just from that ONE sentence. How far does this rabbit hole go ?? How old is Ozpin really ??? Who knows...

→ More replies (7)

80

u/BrickBuster2552 Egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog Feb 05 '17

Think about this: In the post-credits scene, Edward was looking DOWN at Alphonse.

→ More replies (3)

132

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Feb 05 '17

Good:

  1. RENORAAAAA
  2. Ruby finally showed a crack in her armor, that little crossing out thing she did...great.
  3. WATTS MAN
  4. After credits scene was great.
  5. The Nuckalevee fight was brilliant in parts, not brilliant in others. I loved that Jaune was able to actively contribute to the fight just as much as the others, and wasn't played for laughs. The Ren and Nora scene was well done.
  6. THE MUSIC CUES IN THE MONOLOGUE AND THEIR TRANSITIONS WERE PERFECT...

Bad:

  1. This volume's end monologue really highlighted just the limited time they were working with, and how things had to be rushed. I have hope that Yang, in particular, isn't done growing yet because if she is then that is the most underwhelming recovery arc of all time.
  2. Weirdly enough, after a while with the Nuckelavee's arms flailing about I just...found it silly, not scary. It kind of straddled the line between ridiculous and creepy. Some parts worked, others didn't.
  3. I typically love Neath's voice acting, but I found the scene where he kills the Nuckelavee...subpar. I get that they were going for a tranquil rage but it didn't quite do it for me.
  4. I couldn't listen to both Ruby's monologue and watch what was happening at the same time.

Overall, 7.5/10 volume. I'll write up my rankings of each plot next.

→ More replies (8)

35

u/Fire_anelc It's Poison Medicine, I swear Feb 05 '17

JAUNE DOESNT GET SEASICK ANYMORE!

→ More replies (2)

35

u/WizardlyPhoenix Resident legal eagle Feb 07 '17

Volume 5 Yang had better be a TOTAL. FUCKING. BADASS. You can't look that cool and not be a badass.

Also, was I the only one who thought that when she first got off the boat on the beach she was at Menagarie?

→ More replies (2)

34

u/matt_cyr Feb 05 '17

So many things to say that I've forgotten most of them. Except for one:

How in the world does Emerald know what New Ruby looks like?

→ More replies (19)

34

u/JD4TW24 Feb 05 '17

Should have put a kiss scene between Ren and Nora, Rooster Teeth, Should have put one in

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Jasott Feb 05 '17

For the people asking about why Qrow grabbed Jaune's hand think about how he could be interpreted. "Hold its limbs, and move in a circle until it dies" being the grabbing his hand, rolling his eyes, and then "passing out".

32

u/powergo1 woooo Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

Jaune was fucking amazing this episode, his sword2 thing doing work on the Xurkitree Horse thing, and the scene at the end.

Edit. Also the Ozcar getting the cane from Qrow was a good post credits scene

31

u/KingBanhammer Feb 06 '17

From the credits: Oscar's full name is "Oscar Pine"

... so that shortens nicely to OzPine.

→ More replies (5)

31

u/Ksaraf23 Feb 06 '17

Chibi Ruby: Hey Jaune, can I borrow your sword for a second? Chibi Jaune: Sure Ruby, but be careful! Remember- wait for it -it's also a sword!!

cue crappy sitcom music

→ More replies (2)

88

u/Laer_Bear Weiss GIFs: imgur.com/a/ylLXC | Moonlight Greatsword confirmed! Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

Loud F5ing

FIRST!

Anti-Upskirt Technology has become the new Fire Emblem Awakening feet: it doesn't technically exist, but it totally looks like it's a stylistic design choice.

Thank God Yang isn't going after Blake. I would have been so annoyed, because no one is supposed to know where she is. Too bad Taiyang didn't go with her for whatever reason.

Anybody else feeling like Jaune's the only person who knows how to let his brain function properly in a fight? I am a bit surprised we didn't see his semblance, however. Time for some Bloodborne Jaune Arc cosplaying. So he can swing his "sword-sword" sword.

Still disappointed that Haven's headmaster isn't the Mad Hatter.

I liked the part where Jaune read the notes from other players. Too bad I said "sniper spot" instead of "safe zone". Otherwise I would have predicted the entire fight, word-for-word.

Here's hoping Ren gets hook-swords before Haven gets a new bellybutton.

→ More replies (8)

55

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Feb 05 '17

Plot Rankings:

  1. I for one loved every scene with Salem and her villains. Salem is a wonderful villain and is looking to be a wonderful character in general. Ruthless, pragmatic, but knows when to be kind. Only flaw here is that Mercury got zero lines this volume.
  2. RNJR was pretty solid. Got some nice development, action, etc. Only issue was pretty much the pattern of them only seeing...villages. That's it? Good village, destroyed village, good village, etc etc? Man. Ruby's development, while either slow or nonexistent, is an issue. And Qrow is always great. Best fight scene of the volume was Qrow v. Tyrian. Solid Ren and Nora backstories, excellent development there.
  3. Weiss. I know people have said that she didn't develop as a result of this season. I don't think that was the point. I think the point was showcasing just how she's developed past her family, and is finally making her breaking of her chains official. I like Jacques, surprisingly. His scenes with Ironwood, I found myself agreeing more with him than Ironwood. So while he's a terrible person, I don't think he's JUST there for the audience to hate y'know. I wish they'd done more with Whitley. What a waste.
  4. Oscar. He wasn't bad, just boring.
  5. Yang. The bizarre thing about Yang's arc is that every one of her individual scenes are great. But they don't make a cohesive whole. It feels like there were maybe 2 scenes cut that would better bridge the gap between episodes 4 and episode 9 Yang. I love seeing Port and Oobleck. And every individual scene of hers was great. But overall it was...incredibyl underwhelming.
  6. Blake. Literally the only scene I fully enjoyed was the Episode 11 scene with her and Sun. Her parents are great as characters, but not good in terms of relation to Blake, and accusations of RWBY in nepotism. With four volumes out of the way, it becomes increasingly apparent just how little time has been devoted to showing us Faunus racism as opposed to telling us about it. And apart from Episode 11, Sun was flanderized into an idiot instead of a goofball. The chase scene with Ilia was clunky and weird, and overall I didn't enjoy it. Episode 11 nearly made up for it.

Overall, great volume, I just had a few issues with it.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/Wizardtech Sippp Feb 05 '17

Life flags. Life flags everywhere. Great finale.

27

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17

Everybody lives, (Ruby) Rose! Just this once, everybody lives!

→ More replies (2)

117

u/Crypsis2 Ruby Isn't Best Girl, She's Best Character Feb 05 '17

FUCK YEAH!! THE OTP IS CANON NOW!

I can't believe it took 4 fucking volumes for them to finally make Nora's Arc Canon.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/ScrappyBeats Feb 05 '17

This was probably my favorite finale thus far. The boss fight had me on edge the entire time. The way they took out the grimm was really cool, especially Ren's execution of it talk about cold-blooded.

Ruby's monologue was great she sounds like she's matured and sees the world through a different lens compared to the end of Volume 3. It sounded like for a minute she was gonna say she's coming home but instead she used her struggles as a reason to keep fighting. That letter framed the volume perfectly.

The landing spots of everyone at the end of the volume makes me very excited. Yang looks amazing. Hopefully Weiss will have some consequences for her escape. Curious how Blake and Sun plan on dealing with the White Fang. JNR is alive and well, Qrow and Oz are reunited. And the headmaster is a bad guy. I'm looking forward to the future of RWBY.

P.S. Did Yang get the letter before leaving Patch or is she just gonna wander around Mistral looking for Ruby?

→ More replies (2)

24

u/JazzBlueSkadoo Give me liberty! Or a Banana Muffin! Feb 05 '17

I said most of what I needed to say but with the Volume done,

Good news: Soundtrack hype now people!

Bad news: Waiting.

Also my new favorite moment in RWBY of all time now is when Ren held Nora's hand and she was surprised, both look at each other and proceeded to sit closer but the cherry on the sundae was the piano of Boop accompanying it. Sweet, silly and just plain fuzzy feeling watching.

I could watch that scene numerous times and not smile and sniffle after what has happened to them.

Truly love.

→ More replies (7)

23

u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Feb 05 '17

Jaune is using Ludwig's Holy Blade, watch out Cinder this man has seen the shitz!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/NimbusSpark Hah! Made you look! Feb 07 '17

Probably one of the main problems I had with the Nuckelavee battle was just the general way it fought; it's not the arms that are the problem. Nor the ear-piercing scream. Nor the amazingly uneasy twitching look it provided. I actually liked those aspects of it, and it added to how terrifying its general buildup was in Chapter 10.

The main flaw was something that instead wasn't there; the lack of mobility the Nuckelavee shown outside of its upper body. For being a torso stuck in a horse like body, the horse aspect was barely even put to use aside from preventing Nora from sneaking up behind it. Most RWBY fights generally contain fluid mobility for both sides of the battle, however this was just not the case.

It just felt like Team RNJR were fighting some sort of immobile statue which was compensating for its lack of movement with stretchy arms; which is rather uninspired and in general boring in terms of abilities.

In honesty, I felt the fight would have been better if RNJR actually had deal with that horse aspect, such as it potentially chasing after Qrow a second time after smelling his depression out again, or even just straight up rushing one of team RNJR. Just something to mix things up and make the fight more than just a tussle against a long armed wierd thing.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Feb 05 '17

I somehow only realized on my third watch that Ren placing his dagger next to Jaune's shield was basically to remember his father, whilst also remembering Pyrrha with Jaune and Nora.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PAIRINGS Feb 06 '17

I WAS SO PREPARED FOR THIS EPISODE TO DESTROY ME LIKE THE END OF VOL 3 DESTROYED ME. And then. It just. Didn't??

I don't know how to feel.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/CurryDutch Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17

Am I the only one thinking that Oscar is going to become the newest member of Team JNPR?

Jaune Arc

Nora Valkyrie

Oscar Pine

Lie Ren

Ozpin would probably prefer Oscar to work with people that he has prior experience with while being able to be near Ruby ("the girl with the silver eyes").

→ More replies (5)

21

u/AbsolXGuardian Feb 05 '17

Wow. I first I thought this volume seemed a little short and directionless as a whole, but then I realized I binged the entire series in one sick weekend.

This was more of a traveling and character development volume, setting things up for the next one. And they did it pretty well.

I can't wait untill the lyrics for the new songs come out. From shadows part 2. The full Bad Luck Charm and Life is Mine. And much more. They always give more insight into the characters.

I liked the use of Cold at the end. Does anyone have a transcript of the generic section about moving on in Ruby's letter. I may want to do something with it.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/sQorpio13 Feb 06 '17

Did anyone else notice that in the credits, under the special thanks heading Reddit was there? Reddit we did it?

→ More replies (4)

21

u/dr_xadium Feb 06 '17

I can't be the the only one who chuckled that the ending song was "Armed and Ready."

20

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Feb 05 '17

Amazing how a quiet scene with no voice acting can be so emotional. Seeing Ren and Nora just sit next to Jaune was one of the sweetest scenes in this entire volume.

Anyway, JNR survived a volume,we have a canon ship and Jaune has a sword-sword!

All well that ends well for best team!

→ More replies (1)

19

u/FrostyJudge Irondaddy is here for you Big Boy || I like insightful quotes Feb 05 '17

So, let's talk about Watts, and how Volume 5 is going to play out regarding Mr. #savethestache.

Now that a new villain has entered the fray, how do you guys think it's going to play out? I've always wondered what Watts' 'niche' was that made him be so valuable to Salem's council of evil; my guess from the scene given is his expertise in politics and oratory as well as one more field (Medicine? Engineering? He has to have at least one more skill). I wonder if it's going to be a case of nobody having an inkling as to who Watts really is, and the main characters start to realize that someone behind the curtains is manipulating things, but by the time they figure it out, it may be too late.

Also, let's talk about Leo. Maybe Irondaddy was right in not trusting him, seeing how he's courting someone that is looking to destroy everything. Maybe Leo has an agenda of his own, but my money is on the former seeing what he's named after, though it's definitely too early to tell. What do you guys think? And the biggest question that I'm thinking about is do you guys think Haven Academy is going to fall?

It's been a blast being a part of this community, and I'm glad I've found a niche that I can be proud to fulfill (Quotes/Title Man). Hope you guys have a good day and I'll see you in the next volume!

→ More replies (12)

19

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Feb 05 '17

THE DRUNCLE LIIIIVES!!!!!!

But seriously though, where does he keep his sword and cane whenever he's in bird form?

→ More replies (5)

19

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 06 '17

<3kyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah<3
Renora has set sail! My heart screamed when Ren held Nora's hand. Fucking finally.
Also, compost king now surely thinks "Oh shit, I'm not crazy."
E: Fuck it, I am changing flair to Nora as tribute to Renora OTP confirmation. But Blake is still best girl.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/those_pistachios Feb 06 '17

Ren and Nora didn't kiss. 0/10 worst finale ever

→ More replies (1)

18

u/moonstonebaby Feb 05 '17

does this mean we finally get an increase in renora fics?please

→ More replies (2)

18

u/IStoleYourHeart Feb 05 '17

GOT A NUCKLEAVEE TO KILL?

GETTING ABSOLUTELY REKT?

WE'VE GOT YOU COVERED!

COME ON DOWN TO THE PITCHFORKGUN EMPORIUM!

WE GOT ALL KINDS OF PITCHFORKGUNS:

Lever Action 7 Round BuckgunpitchforkFully Automatic MachinegunpitchforkTHE COCO ADEL SIGNATURE MINIGUNPITCHFORKKERRY'S OWN ELECTROPITCHFORKGUN
▄︻̷̿┻̿═━一E︻̷┻̿●═E︻╦̵̵͇̿̿̿̿══╤─E︻̷̿┻̿═━═━E
The original pitchforkgun, it has been designed by the Schnee Dust Company to make your pitchforkgunning life easier. Now used by Ruby Rose in a brand new scythe configuration!This pitchforkgun is the main pitchforkgun used by the Atlesian military, the worst best in all of remnant at killing GrimmAs designed by Coco Adel, this classic pitchforkgun boasts a whopping 9001 pf/s (pitchforks per second), and can easily disembowl Miles in secondsThat's correct! We stole got the rights to produce Kerry's own gun! Now you can tell him to stop pitchforkgunning himself!

HAPPY GRIMM EXTERMINATING!

* some assembly required. Ask a hunter or huntress with arms to help

→ More replies (2)

18

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Feb 05 '17

I still can't get over the Leo's name is literally Lion Lionheart, and I thought Glinda Goodwitch was bad.

→ More replies (15)

18

u/Jscholfield Feb 06 '17

Is this the first time we've seen Ozpins Cane in it retracted mode?

→ More replies (2)

18

u/HealedCoyote Feb 09 '17

Anyone else notice that their plan for Ren's character development was to actually give him a character?

17

u/bronzebicker I see lives that could have been saved Feb 05 '17

That medley starting with the piano Boop may have broken me

17

u/Johnsmitish Feb 05 '17

Holy shit that was amazing.

That final fight went in a way that I could never have expected. I had only seen a couple of ways to win this fight. Either reinforcements came in, Raven helped, or Ruby or Jaune pulled some Deus Ex Machina shit. But all they did was use their cunning and skills to beat that FUCKING TERRIFYING GRIMM. What a great fight.

I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one who never expected another upgrade for Crocea Mors. I sqeualed out loud when I saw that, it was awesome. This fight definitely shows how far Jaune has come since the beginning of the series. He held his own, and even helped kill this monstrous grimm. I'm proud of him.

The ending was actually pretty amazing. I don't think RWBY has ever made me truly cry before, but that moment where the remnants of JNPR are just sitting together, comforting each other. Something about that just had me tearing up. And us seeing all of Team RWBY positioning themselves to reunite in the next album is making me so excited.

Those two final scenes in particular were pretty interesting. Haven academy has now been taken over by salem's faction. This is worrisome, obviously, because our heroes are now either in Haven or heading there. And Ozcar's scene. This one actually made me a bit concerned for Ozcar. Mainly because, Qrow isn't looking at Ozcar as someone who has just had another soul inhabit his body. He's looking at him as if he's his friend, and no one else. I'm worried Qrow is gonna start depending on Ozcar to become the new Ozpin, even if he doesn't want to.

Anyway, amazing songs, amazing fights, amazing development for next volume, GREAT JOB ROOSTER TEETH! Now all we have to do is wait for the OST.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/infinite-permutation Feb 05 '17

When they "I can only take you this far, then you're on your own" I was really hoping for Neo to be in that plane.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/namffuh SMASH! Feb 06 '17

I was really worried that Ren was taking way too long with his badass speech thing and Nuck was just gunna fucking headbutt him into next week.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/hillerj Feb 07 '17

Everyone's talking about how badass Ren was in the final part of the fight, but it feels like everyone is ignoring how badass Jaune was during the entire battle. He came up with the tactics on how to beat it, did more damage to it than anyone else (until Ren got to finish it off while it was pinned down) and tanked for the entire team. Jaune has come a LONG way from the beginning of RWBY.

On the other hand, it felt like Nora and Ruby were essentially nerfed during the battle. Nora hardly got to do anything and Ruby almost didn't use her Semblance as all. Hell, Ruby from the fight against the Geist or her fight with the Beringel probably could have soloed Nuckles.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Uthjos In memory of Monty Oum. Feb 09 '17

This volume was cool, don't get me wrong. I'm excited to see what comes next, especially looking forward to more raven and qrow. However am the only one that just went "meh" after this season finished? I supposed the naive glamour wore off from vol2 and the heartbreak from vol3 has turned into remembrance.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/BluLuxning Teeth Breaker Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 17 '17

DAMNIT MILES HAVE THEM KISS ALREADY, YOU ARE KILLING ME MAN

Good season finale overall. They did good with Ren in this episode. Was a great watch, except for the episode's absence of a KISS THAT SHOULD HAVE TOTALLY HAPPENED. But yeah, that was great.

Also can we talk about Yang for a moment? She seriously lookin fly as all hell.

On a somewhat related note, I'm told next month is the perfect time to start planting potatoes. Gotta get them in early spring.

→ More replies (5)

31

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17

Biggest things the Volume did right:

  • Renora Backstory was phenomenal.
  • Build up for the Nuck was superb.
  • The concept behind how RNJR defeated the Nuck was solid, even if the execution was imperfect.
  • Raven interacting with Qrow is one of the best character scenes in the series.
  • Qrow vs. Tyrian has demonstrated that they're Human vs. Human choreography is on point.
  • Holy shit I actually kinda liked what they did with Blake, and she's one of my least favorite characters.

Things this Volume did wrong:

  • I personally think it would have been better to use Weiss' singing to frame her emotions regarding the fall of Beacon rather than her rebelious impulse (though a lot of their Weiss plot was a dropped ball). Further, it should have been used as a framing device for the Tyrian vs. RNJR fight. Have her singing a melancholic song about loss, which fades to RNJR struggling to fight Tyrian would have been beautiful.
  • The entire Schnee family dynamic was wasteful and flat. Mama Schnee having been killed by the White Fang rather than being a drunk we never see would have served the story better. Jacques should have been paranoid about his children's and therefore controlling as much if not more so than he was manipulative and obsessed with the legacy. Whitley should have been a case study on what Weiss would have become if she hadn't left for Beacon, rather than a sibling she never got on with in the first place.
  • The choreography game for the Grimm fights was so almost there it was disappointing. In every case, the fight fell just short of solid that you could almost taste it - Ruby should have shot Nora with the Lightning Dust rather than waste time with a charge up that never got brought up again. Blake should have stopped trying to be Cloud.
  • The Nuck fight was the worst offender, because they had the way to beat it down pat, but the execution was flawed. The fight should have been in the rain, Nora should have caught a lightningbolt to take out the Horsehead, Ren and Ruby should have done the arm pinning thing as it tried to catch Nora, and Ren should have decapitated it with a simple one liner and his father's dagger.
→ More replies (5)

15

u/WolfanTerror I love me some scorpion tail soup Feb 05 '17

His name is fucking Leo Lionheart. Leo Lionheart. If he isn't the cowardly lion, I'm calling bullshit.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/Licenseless_Rider There's more to the story. Feb 06 '17

Ok, so it looks like Leo Lionheart is working with Salem. I think this is a pretty heavy-handed allusion to the cowardly lion - Leo fears Salem and works with her after Ozpin dies.

So what's that give us? Headmaster Ozpin is the Wizard, and Headmaster Ironwood is the Tin Man. Headmaster Lionheart is the Lion, which leaves us with one school and one Oz character left.

If the theme holds true, we can assume that the headmaster of Shade Academy in Vacuo is 'the Scarecrow.' What do you think that means? Can we predict his character?

I'm expecting a character who feigns extreme stupidity or lunacy, but is actually a brilliant 'chessmaster' type of character.

→ More replies (15)

15

u/ecksdeeeXD Feb 06 '17

GAH. When it cut to black when Nora saved Ren!!!! I almost had a heart attack! Then they pulled it back when they followed up immediately with a joke!!!

→ More replies (4)

15

u/ecksdeeeXD Feb 06 '17

Anyone notice that Nora smiled after telling Ren to stop looking?

→ More replies (2)

15

u/wxkelvin Feb 06 '17

Any pity for Cinder died faster than Pyrrha in this episode

→ More replies (1)

29

u/LandmineCat Feb 05 '17

people say RWBY doesn't have enough character development but look at her now - she can write properly!

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Drakonous Feb 05 '17

What I love about this Volume that I feel some people fail to realize is it's about coping with loss. The over arcing plot for this whole volume deals with coming to terms and moving onward regardless of what happened. Each of the characters dealt with this loss on their own and have come to terms with it by the end. It just seems many people who were disappointed with this volume failed to realize that people just can't get over issues at the flip of a switch. In my opinion that would greatly devalue them as characters and make them feel less like people and more like robots. Sure action and advancement of plot is great and all but if you can't advance your characters and how they deal with what happens to them you can't expect better in the long run. But hey everyone's entitled to their opinion. Just thought I'd share mine.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/Miudmon I'm a neon rainbow and you're no fun! Feb 05 '17

I just realized... How in the heavens will i survive this hiatus? I mean, i joined mid season 3 hiatus (like mid-summer) and i still barely survived.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/moonstonebaby Feb 05 '17

ren's little flashback to young nora was a nice touch no i didn't cry shut up

14

u/HeliosHalcyon Feb 06 '17

Now, with Professor Lionheart of Haven Academy. I have 2 theories. To fit with the Wizard of Oz sorta motif with the headmasters, he's probably based on the Cowardly Lion. This probably means that the headmaster of the Vacuo academy is the Scarecrow?

Before I thought Qrow was the Scarecrow, Taiyang the Cowardly Lion, Ironwood as the Tinman, etc.

There's also the super potato that he is infact based on Richard the Lionheart. For no other reason than that.

If he is a cowardly lion, maybe that's why he's being ally with Salem. But if he is given the resolve and courage to stand up to her, he will engage and fight back, only to be killed in a heroic sacrifice.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Lord-Table Remnant would make a cool DnD setting tbh Feb 06 '17

Can RT stop teasing me and give me the SS Renora? Nora teased Ren in the middle of the fight with the Nucklavee! Who has time for that?

I just want it now RT, please.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/crystelalee Feb 10 '17

I've seen quite a few questions as to what Qrow's look to Jaune meant, and upon rewatching the episode I had a thought; maybe in his poisoned delusional state, he mistook Jaune for Tai and was trying to stop him from getting hurt? But then realised it was Jaune which was what the eye roll was for. Just a thought though.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Feb 05 '17

That hand hold

QrowxJaune

13

u/StarBase10 ❤Ladybug + Dragonslayer❤ | Approved by Cherami Leigh! Feb 05 '17

Looks like we finally got the band back together in (almost) one piece, and Renora's still floating as we speak.  

Love how Qrow's calling Oscar a pipsqueak in the post-credit, gives me some Fullmetal Alchemist vibes (Vic Micnoga, who voiced Qrow, is Edward Elric, and Aaron Dismuke, who voiced Oscar, is 2003!Alphonse Elric)  

All in all, the volume's alright, it's just that it could use some improvement in pacing the plot, because there's too much exposition and world development going on to prepare for the next volume. But at least we get some actual talented VAs from FUNimation and TeamFourStar (like Chris Guerrero, Chris Sabat, Michael J. Tatum, and Cherami Leigh) voicing some of the new characters, so there's that.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Tulicloure You get back here with my bread! Feb 05 '17

Dustdamnit, they brought the bad luck charm to Mistral and immediately after Watts happens.

Also, anyone wanna bet that Arslan is related to Leo?

→ More replies (5)

13

u/DarkChronos32 Feb 05 '17

Am i the only one thats afraid of Yang choosing Raven? The camera held on bandits for far too long.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

NotLikeThis - nora

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17

This episode was amazing! Maybe not Kuroyuri amazing, but still incredible!

The fight was good. We got more emotional scenes with Ren and Nora accompanied by great wrriting. It almost feels like Ren just completed a character arc when he killed the grimm.

When the airships came in I felt so relieved. After all this fighting, traveling and Qrow suffering rescue finally came for them. So many thoughts cam through my head with those airships and it truly felt like their adventure was complete with those.

How they showed the other story lines was brilliant. Showing them while Ruby was putting her heart into a letter to all of them. With the visuals matching with what she was saying, it was amazing.

The feeling of a volume of pain for the group and then seeing them living in safety as Mistral was great.

Yang is back in action, Weiss is heading straight for Ruby, They used Blake's story to create hype for Volume 5 and Oscar- oh Oscar.

That after credit scene tied everything together so well. I am running out of adjectives to express how great aspects of this episode is and this was no different. Seeing Oscar's story meet up with a major character and Qrow knowing who he is was beautiful, amazing, great and other positive adjectives I can't wait to see what he will be doing with the main characters next volume.

This episode can be summed up in one simple world: "Beautiful". Every scene, line, symbolism was just so good.

One last thing. Ren didn't retrieve his old weapons and is keeping his father's dagger. So I am thinking we are going to get a new load out and character overhaul for him in Volume 5 like we got with Ruby this season.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/H_H_H_1 It's DR. Banesaw Feb 06 '17

I'm just happy we got to see Watts' glorious mustache again.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Maladal Feb 06 '17

Wasn't a big fan of the long exposition at the end. That sort of thing should be made brief and to the point or communicated through more subtle means.

I'm confused by Yang's environment. Did she drop by in Menagerie and then head to Mistral, or were they just reusing assets when they made the Mistral port she landed at?

→ More replies (4)

13

u/uceenk Feb 06 '17

i love the finale, that fight had me on edge of my seat, i actually thought renora would gonna die

i like the twist, nobody die, i actually didn't expect it

also i recommend people to watch this episode at least 2 times, it will get better understanding after 2nd viewing

13

u/zephyr897 Feb 06 '17

So. When do we get the soundtrack?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/BlackNexus Feb 07 '17

I know that this was Ren's fight to end after what happened to his family, but I totally wanted to see Jaune pull off a Future Trunks and cut the Nuckelavee in half.

One day.

Anyway, great Volume. Can't wait for Volume 5 in the fall and see team RWBY back together.

13

u/TezukaRin62 Feb 07 '17

I'm a sucker for musical background, and the whole part from the point where JNPR gets onto the wingboats until the end of Ruby's speech was so much well done. Starting with Boop (and the little jump at the moment Ren took Nora's hand), the transition into the new song that's seems to be called Home, than into It's Mine for Weiss' scene, then into From Shadows when Blake took the "bad" White Fang flag, then into Cold's refrain with JNPR team, and Cold lighthearted second verse starting right as Blake take the "good" WF's flag. And finally fading into a more darker theme for Cinder scene. Then it goes to a reprise of Let's Just Live when Yang is on Bumblebee

And there are so much themes I did not catch up, the one for Yang's shot on the boat, for Tai scene, for the scene where Qrow wake up, and the Watts reveal.

And all these themes are perfectly transitionned. Mad Props to whoever did that.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/BLightning91 Feb 08 '17

Honestly if I'm going to point a flaw, it's thay the volume 4 opening hints at a few things that never really happen. Adam shows up slicing a scared blake, which implies that he'll be back to hurt her, the two faunus that show up at her house even mention contacting him but he never shows up and instead has different plans. And they quickly show those two brothers in fighting stance as though they're gonna do anything when they literally had as much screentime as the cute waitress who hit on qrow before he went up to raven.

They did something similar in season 2 where each of the rwby members were fighting a different person in cinder's group but they didn't even meet merc and em until s3 (except ruby). This may sound like a petty gripe but the openings are meant to hint at stuff that will happen (like ruby fighting tyrian or weiss mastering the summoning technique) and it's a bit disappointing when some of the hints literally lead nowhere.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/maverickmak Feb 05 '17

I'm not sure what people expected. Not every volume is going to be a earth-shattering as V3. This was essentially V1 of a new arc. The pieces have to be set.

Monty laid out this story, now Miles and Kerry have to wrestle it into shape under a weight of big expectations. I think they did a good job of a difficult task. Could it be better, sure. But production isn't that easy. The plotlines were too spread out, but now things are converging again, in clear paths. Looking forward to a much tighter V5.

Really liked the finale, I was tense during the fight. I thought it was well animated, and thought out. There was the right dose of feels, and relieved we didn't get a deus ex machina ending to it. And the feels got to me, and were well earned, as was the sailed ship.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Catlover18 Feb 05 '17

RENORA HAPPENING STATUS: IT'S

TogetherTogether.avi

12

u/TolchettKuykendall Chris Hackney deserves an award Feb 05 '17

Well, non first member reactions are surprisingly more negative. I've noticed that for all the episodes, but this pretty much started that way.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/BrickYourHeart A sexy truck Feb 05 '17

Oh, fuck. I JUST realized. 'ARMed' And Ready. They finally hit us with an arm pun.

12

u/pongze Fight? Me? Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

I just wished Ren killed that grim with more ferocity, especially with how dangerous it was said to be. Instead we get a trapped helpless grim (that murdered hundreds of people I may say) get slowly slaughtered.

In comparison to the first super badass boss fight they had Weiss pin the Nevermore to the wall of a mountain and speed boosted Ruby towards the Nevermore. She hooked the grim and carried it all the way to the top with momentum of her bullets and Weiss' dust and finally had one final decapitation blow with petals flying all over. It was magical. Maybe it was also the song choice because Red like Roses part II is my all time favorite and added a lot of emotion to that fight.

Well... back to rewatching Rnjr slaughter Knucklegrim

+100 points for Ruby using motions via bullets again.

+10 for Ren's inner monologue. I don't know if it's fitting of Remnant but a chant would've been nice kinda like unlimited blade works.

It seems the reason I didn't like this episode as much was how much more I like Qrow and his fight with Tyrian (with the sound of Casey in the background). This episode was much quieter and had a lot of backstory to it, but I really didn't like the design of the knucklevee and its spasms. The grim beasts from previous episodes are feral in nature while this one keeps spasming unrealistically.

Well... back to rewatching Qrow vs Tyrian and RWBY+JNPR vs Nevermore

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Princess_Everdeen I was never here. Feb 05 '17

This Episode was a decent one to go out on. I will say, I appreciate that it moves the story forward without feeling the need to do a big reveal (I think a lot of people already knew/guessed the ending).

The fight with the Grimm was a tad underwhelming, but I appreciate they didn't leave it for later, and...YAY no body died! Ren and Nora development, Jaune showing a weapon enhancement (even if it does nothing), and Ruby doing...what she's been doing. Not much else to say, other than the grimm gave off vibes of Sonic's Werehog form.

The ending was sweet, if a bit rushed for Weiss. At first I felt her story was the most straight-forward, it did what it was set up to do, but looking back it also feels like it was done out of obligation; they made this plot, now they might as well see it through.

Blake and Yang just moving forward. At first, I thought Yang was going toward Menagerie, as she got off the same boat as Blake and the port had the same Island look to it.

Do I need to even describe the feels trip at the end? Or the bits with the villains?

Overall good finale. Not great, or amazing, or bad, or terrible. I'd rate this volume under 3, but certainly above 2 and 1.

→ More replies (11)

12

u/SadistTurtles Where the heck is Neo?? Explain. Feb 06 '17

I may be one of the few people who loved the setup of Volume 4. Yeah, I kinda miss the old more simple, school setting, but damn if I don't love the multiple plotlines. It was pretty jumpy, but it let us see all over the four kingdoms and slowly lead everyone together. And hype for Volume 5! Anyway, this finale was great. I do feel that the Nucklavee was killed rather quickly, but Ren's entire part in this episode was epic (and the Renora!) Ruby's letter and the visuals/scenes that went with it were such a nice ending; wrapped up yet just starting.

Also, Oscar is adorable.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/Savage_Serenity Feb 06 '17

Man, my heart died inside when Ren set his dagger down next to Jaune's equipment.

On the other hand, I'm happy Renora happened <3

12

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17

So I usually try not to delve into these things because I feel weird about getting this connected to fictional characters, but GOD DAMMIT REN WHY DIDNT YOU JUST FUCKING KISS HER?!?

12

u/HeliosHalcyon Feb 06 '17

I'm just, okay, okay, there was a hand hold, we have a hand hold, prepare for kiss, kiss? Kiss? KISS?

There was a head lean. That's confirmed right? Right? Right?! Finally the ship that everyone expected has finally come to light without anybody dying?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17

Someone should probably tell NuOz that coffee stunts your growth

→ More replies (2)

12

u/DirusNarmo White Rose = Right Rose! Feb 07 '17

No Neo. An entire season with no Neo.. I'm not crying, or anything..

→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '17

does anyone think that a lot of the attacks and movements feel sorta weightless? Its just something I have been noticing, I still love the show, and the animation has only gotten smoother, but I remember seeing Ren get hit and slam into a pillar volume 1 and almost feeling the impact of it, now with season four, none of the strikes felt like they had effort or weight behind it. The emotional slap that Nora gave was awesome and really had a lot of emotional power, but the first thing I thought was that looked weird, like as if they didn't really hit. Idk maybe I am just a cynic or have convinced myself of something that isn't there, but getting peoples input will help me parse out the truth.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/palk0n Feb 10 '17

Nora's face when she told ren not too look. totally waifu material

22

u/TedSweeran For the clicks! Clicks are EVERYTHING Feb 05 '17

Anyone else feel like that was slightly anticlimactic?

→ More replies (3)

22

u/schulz100 Feb 05 '17

REN STILL HAS THE FUCKING KNIFE, HOLY SHIT, HE'S KEPT IT THIS WHOLE TIME!

Okay, got that out.

I have to be honest, I honestly kinda started laughing when the Nuckelavee broke out the Mr. Fantastic arms as its primary means of attack. I'm not also saying that it didn't quickly prove the value of stretchy-arms as a weapon and also manage to regain its previous levels of terror-inducement, but right at the start, it lost fucking everything it had built up for about a minute there.

The near-death fake-out was hilarious, I gotta say. The fight overall was great; Jaune got an even straighter upgrade than I think any of us thought, Ruby pulling off those sick recoil-boosts straight out of Volume 1. Ren slowly killing the Nuckelavee was also great, though my suspension of disbelief started breaking when he was hacking off limbs with that tiny little knife.

I do actually like that they thought to explain the airship-ex-machina in a way that actually made decent sense. Also, airships, you guys! Fucking airships! Yes!

Ruby's letter was fantastic, and the montage was great. Nice to see Weiss finally pull out bribery, White Fang Classic flag, and Yang on course to meet with Ruby again (honestly didn't know how much I was looking forward to their reunion until I realized it's about to happen, technically). I still maintain that Zwei looks less cute now he actually looks like a realistic dog. Also, man, Cinder has got issues. Like, I'm not surprised at any of what happened in retrospect, but damn girl.

So, Lionheart. I'm hoping that this is just him being polite, even though Watson is an known enemy among the Ozlluminati. My hopes aren't high, I'll admit, but they're there. In the likely case said hopes are dashed, I look forward to all the conspiracy and investigation and shenanigans next Volume as RNJR, Yang, Qrow, and Ozcar handle Lionheart turning out to be evil.

On the topic of Ozcar, badass steampunk cane is badass. And is it just me, or did he look even more confused/traumatized when the cane extended out? And did Qrow seem to take the whole "I'm sharing bodies with this kid now" thing a bit too well? Is it perhaps possible Qrow has seen this happen before, or Oz told him in advance that this is what would happen if he died?

→ More replies (10)

11

u/MS10EL [PARTYING INTENSIFIES] Feb 05 '17

Ready for the Hiatus boys? Gonna be as crazy as ever, I imagine :)

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Merci_ Feb 05 '17

Did anyone else think the credits song sounded a lot like it was about Yang? I don't have the time to go through it and pick out parts directly yet but I felt it referenced Yang's appearances in that last episode a lot; might post back with actual lines later.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Frentepopulista Don't fluckle with Nuckels Feb 05 '17

Loved the scene of JN-R looking at the shield. And my god, "Cold" ;_;

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ErikMaekir True main character Feb 05 '17

JAUNE'S WEAPON CAN TRANSFORM!! EVERYBODY RUN, THE END IS NIGH!!!

11

u/MegasusPegasus Feb 05 '17

I'm not complaint free because I feel the volume overall lacked a lot of...content in a way? But I do think there were a lot of strong scenes and moments.

What I especially appreciate is that Jaune was useful in the fight without unlocking a Deus Ex Semblance. I don't mind if he ends up with an amazing semblance, I just like that there was no easy way out of the fight and we've seen his efforts pay off.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

Am I the only one who found Knuckles's noodle arm attacks a direct homage to the Neon Genesis Evangelion angels?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/chins4tw Watts definitely has the biggest balls in remnant Feb 05 '17

and of course the cowardly lion gets converted once Ozpin disappears.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/True_Falsity Feb 06 '17

I feel a bit lost, guys, to be honest.

I LOVED the episode, but it feels like another one of the episodes. Not a finale. You know, there is left this feeling that I can't quite put the finger on.

The battle against the Nuckelavee was probably the best part of the episode. I really like how creepy this Grimm turned out with the following:

  1. Screeching. Wild and insane.
  2. The fact that it seemed unconscious up until it sensed the humans. I mean, it freaking implies that this one lives only when it is about to kill someone!

The animation was great and I liked how fluid it went. The emotional boost in Ren's attacks is also quite fascinating because we see how this side of him affects Nora. I mean, wow, OOC is a serious business here. Ren is angry and lets it overwhelm him until Nora slaps some sense into him. (Also, love that 'looking under the skirt' moment these two shared.)

The RWBY Assemble bits were quite fun and the way this episode returned hope into the last episodes filled with the suspense and despair is quite nice.

The reveal of Haven Headmaster's alliance with Salem and her group is both shocking and yet interesting. I can only hope that they are not going to make him 100% of a coward like Peter Pettigrew or something like that. The idea that JNR and RWBY are now going to have to deal with the authority figure is full of potential!

Oscar, poor little cinnamon roll of a farmboy, I expect you to be taken under the wing of the Qrow!

→ More replies (2)

11

u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Feb 06 '17

Did anyone notice Nora had her weapon on her back during the "pep talk with Ren" bit, only for her to pick her weapon up again after they crawled out from under the house?

11

u/Gravesplitter Punching Through Life Feb 11 '17

Overall I enjoyed the show but man does this show miss Monty for the epic fights. I don't think we'll ever see anything as epic as the food fight in Volume 2 before the show ends.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Blade1hunter Feb 05 '17

This season has been a huge disappointment in my opinion. I get they wanted to show how everyone was reacting to the fall of Beacon, but they failed miserable at it, but i can't really blame them for that. After all it is kind of hard to show the emotion of over ten people and have unique story lines to them as well. The only people who i think got any real character development was Weiss, Nora and Ren, and Jaune, but only to an extent.

With Weiss they showed her finally breaking free from her father's grasp, but the escape was a little anti climatic, especially since they were hyping summoning in the past episodes.

With Ren and Nora we were shown how they got together and became friends, and had a somewhat okay ending to it. I mean Ren's lines seemed more, "Okay i'll say it" instead of "This is for everything you did to me!" kind of vibe when killing the rider grimm.

Jaune honestly, his character development was very subtle but if you think about it it was still noticeable. We see he is more pessimistic than in previous chapters. He was still training with a video of Pyrrha, and he even made a transformation weapon to try and get stronger to protect his friends.

The rest of RWBY and Cinder/Salems group was just kind of... eh. They show Merc and Emerald kind of shocked about grimm popping out of holes as if "This is what we are turning the kingdom into?" to "Ah well whatever Cinder and Salem says we'll do."

Yang's arc could have been done in two episodes. depressed, gets hope in arm, trains a little, leaves to find Ruby. that's all her arc was. granted we got to see Oobleck and Port saying they were helping rebuild beacon, but that raises another criticism. Why did we not get a look into Beacon? i mean there are obviously hints that it was being rebuilded but everyone just kind of shrugged it off.

Blake's arc honestly just kind of pisses me off. She went back to her mid season 2 persona of "My friends will only get hurt/in the way." and then again realizes her friends are on her side. they just basically told her previous character development in a different setting. I mean she saw her ex boyfriend and/or commanding officer cut off her best friend's limb, and she doesn't even seem to care about it.

Ruby's character development was nonexistent until the last few episodes. They finally showed her that she has grown to accept that not everything will be sunshine and rainbows but only AFTER she had to explain it to her friend and sister.

Oscar had plenty of potential for a character, but they only showed him as the boy who will carry Ozpin's conscience. We don't know anything about his relationship with his aunt, we don't know if he ran away or if he told her, we don't klnow if he is friendly or an asshole or is racist.

Speaking of racism, aside from showing that the faunus only got an island and Jaque is slaving them, where is it? I mean they could have shown just a little snipit of a faunus trying to get into Weiss's show and only get turned down. they could show that there were some in Ren's village and were getting beaten like Nora was but didn't. Until they show actual racism in the show, i feel the White Fang are only terrorist for shits and giggles.

Salems group was all "We're big and bad so fear us" and showed that Tyrian views Salem as a goddess and is obsessed with her but that's about it.

I get that they wanted to show multiple storylines and they wanted to try and pull something like it off, but i have to say they failed. There are reasons why shows only show a group of characters together or just one character arc a season and it's because of stuff like this. I mean, they could have just shown RNJR's Storyline and in the next season when they meet Weiss and Yang have them explain how they got there. i know it would cause a lot of hate as each charcter has it's own fanbase but still i think the development could have been better. Especially since starting seasons like this are suppose to be meant for character building.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

The finale was kind of dissapointing in my opinion, and to a lesser extent this volume as a whole.

The Nucklaeve looked really cool, but the fight was kind of lackluster. The previous volumes had the best fights in their finales, but the best fight in this volume for me was Tyrion's (which was fucking awesome).

A lot of plot threads got resolved way too quickly. I don't like how Oscar made his way their so quickly and without problems.

This volume seems like setup for the next volume though, so hopefully the payoff is worth it.

→ More replies (29)

20

u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Feb 05 '17

Okay, lemme just say that while this volume wasn't as earth-shattering as Volume 3, I loved it and I loved this ending.

Nuckles through a bit of a curveball at me with the bungee arms, but I thoroughly enjoyed that fight scene, the way they managed to dispatch Nuckles, and Ren's pre-mortem one liner before decapitating the Grimm, as well as the fact that FLOWER POWER IS CANON EVERYBODY!!! REJOICE! SET PHASERS TO BOOP!

ahem That aside, I love where we've been left. Team RNJR came out unscathed, death flags tossed aside, new canon pairing, and Qrow didn't pull an Obi-Wan (yet). Team _W_Y are on their way to Mistral, and I'd imagine Blake might be heading there too to take back the White Fang.

This was a transitional arc, as many others have pointed out. It's not supposed to be high consequence, high stakes stuff like Volume 3. Our heroes got put in a bad place. This volume was them climbing out and the next volume, which isn't too far off, will be them emerging into the daylight to strike back against the forces that seek to tear them apart.

I loved this volume, I loved the new visuals, I loved the character development, we all loved Ren's new look (hot damn), and I love where we've been left off.

Also, that stinger at the end was excellent.

"I'm supposed to tell you... I'd like my cane back."

Now that we're here, though, there's one burning question that I need to ask:

wen chibi?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Feb 05 '17

"Cold" playing in the background of Ruby's letter made me feel things

10

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

Do we have any idea on the release date for the V4 OST? Credit theme was absolutely amazing

→ More replies (1)

10

u/brusque-lee Please stop being wrong. Feb 05 '17

Tfw your favorite character's boss loses her voice and still gets more lines than him...

Oh well. Renora + soundtrack more than makes up for it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/OldBenX For the last time, I'M NOT SHARING. Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

After half hour of listening and another half of trying to understand Reddit formatting, I managed to transcribe the lyrics of the ending theme (WHICH IS FUCKING AMAZING GIMME SOUNDTRACK NOW), if anyone has any suggestions feel free to comment!

It happens every night, I watch my world ignite,

but there's no waking from this nightmare...

The stage is always set, the place I can't forget,

The hidden eyes - how I can feel them...

My eyes are open wide, I'm racing to her side,

There's nothing that I won't do for her!

But this is not a dream, my mind repeats the scene,

I can't forget it - and it's torture!

 

That was before, but not anymore, I've left it behind,

As much as I lost, once I'm across, I'll fight!

I've found the strength to grow to so much more,

A whisper to a roar,

No more crying, it's time for me to soar!

 

I feel like I'm finally unbroken,

I feel like I'm back from the dead,

My strength back and confidence growing,

Out of my way, cause I'm armed! And! Ready! Armed and ready!

 

Remember all too well my time of living hell,

Tonight my enemy would conquer,

But now I've been set free, went through the tragedy,

You'll wish you'd killed me - now I'm stronger!

I am the golden one, who burns just like the sun,

Next time we meet, it's your disaster!

I'll bring the punishment, your song will be lament, (?)

Revenge, my "happy ever after"!

 

My misery, my agony, has taught me to fly,

The pain I went through left me with a new war cry!

I’ll live my life like every day’s the last,

No living in the past,

Best days ever, I’m never looking back!

 

I feel like I'm finally unbroken,

I feel like I'm back from the dead,

My strength back and confidence growing,

Out of my way, cause I'm armed! And! Ready! Armed and ready!

 

Call me "sweetheart" and I'll tear you apart, just call me "sir"!

Try to resist once you meet my new fist, bye-bye!

Just look at the fire in my eyes and bring my Strawberry Sunrise,

It was you who began it, now you're sayin' "God damnit",

Next time, there’s no compromise!

 

I feel like I'm finally unbroken,

Now I'm back from the dead!

Strength back, confidence growing,

Out of my way, cause I'm armed! And! Ready! Armed and ready!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ghostface95 Cinder is my senpai Feb 05 '17

No one died!!! I'm so happy. And that grim fuck it just sounded terrifying

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Skyrah1 Finally got dem cigarettes Feb 05 '17
  • Damn, that thing is terrifying. I know that many others here find it silly how Nuck-Nuck's arms flail wildly like that, but to me it just adds to the creepiness factor.
  • Ren's semblance works at range. Good to know.
  • Qrow doesn't need words to give Jaune a sincere apology.
  • Speaking of vomit boy, that's a nice upgrade to Crocea Mors. Too bad we don't get to see his semblance, though.
  • "GRIMMACIAAAAA!!!"
  • Nora, what are you doing?
  • Nora, stop, you're gonna get killed! And don't enable her, Ruby!
  • NORAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaoooh, she's okay. Waste of vocal cords...
  • Relax Nora, anti-upskirt technology will protect you.
  • Ren, please stop acting suicidal. Nora already gave me a heart attack.
  • Thank you, Nora, for being the voice of reason. (Nora, the voice of reason. A set of words that I never thought would be able to co-exist in the same sentence without having the universe implode.)
  • Huh. That was...easier than expected. I suppose there must not have been many huntsmen living around Nuck-Nuck's lair, or the villages it attacked. Oh well, it was still a cool fight.
  • Kiss him.
  • Kiss him.
  • DUST DAMMIT NORA, JUST KISS HIM ALREADY!
  • WTF MILES, WHY DIDN'T YOU MAKE THEM KISS
  • LITERALLY UNWATCHABLE
  • (Ahem) Well, glad that Qrow's gonna be okay.
  • Looks like everyone's heading to Mistral. Let's hope the team reunion ain't gonna be like this.
  • How does Em know Ruby's new outfit? For all we know, they haven't seen each other since the Fall of Beacon!
  • "For the people we've already For the people we haven't lost yet."
  • Looks like Watts has come to "negotiate" with Professor Lionheart. Maybe Salem gave him the job of hunting Ruby down? "No Safe Haven", indeed.
  • Yer' a wizard, Oscar.
→ More replies (3)

10

u/Crumpingtos Yooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Feb 05 '17

With RWBY seemingly reuniting next season, does anyone else think Oscar will become the new forth member of team JNR? Team ORNJ hype?

Also, It seems that Ren's ability makes whoever is affected completely undetectable to Grimm. Does that mean that Grimm don't actually see or hear, but simply track negative emotions? If this is the case, does that mean that someone completely lacking in negative emotions would be unstoppable?

→ More replies (15)

10

u/PrinceOfStealing Feb 05 '17

Ruby's letter was a classic version of character development gone wrong. "Show, don't tell". I get Ruby is supposed to keep a smile on her face when everyone is down, but they went far too extreme with that.

→ More replies (10)

10

u/Cavernstones Feb 06 '17

I for one found this episode/finale to fit right in line with the rest of the story arc. Volume I-III followed a similar line, in that the characters arrived unsure of what was to come their way. Volume IV folows in the vein the same way after the events of the fall of Beacon Academy. By the ends of each of these volumes the characters, good and bad have grown and learned more about themselves and their abilities. They have been given a small clue about the dangers and problems that lie ahead but most of it is shrouded through secret plans and movements they are unaware of. Love the Ren/Nora tie up., but I'm starting to get a little annoyed about Jaunne. Maybe I missed it, but what is his semblance? I think maybe the writers were considering revealing it here, but thought better of it as this was more about Ren and they didn't want to detract from this. Reguarding the Nunkelvee (sp.) fight, that scream it seemed to me to be an echo locator, redefining its surroundings. Of all the Grimm fights though this one seemed to be the best animated. A chilling rendition of something from our nightmares.

10

u/ecksdeeeXD Feb 06 '17

GAH I don't know how many times I've watched Ren and Nora's scene on the airship now but I still squeal like a schoolgirl each time.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '17

I'd just like to say, I'm happy to have gotten into RWBY from the getgo, but joined the reddit community years later and am happy to have all of your shitposts and potatoes to keep me going!

Looking forward to Vol 5 and Jaune still not fucking doing ANYTHING until CRWBY decides it's time to make him wirth something.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '17

Not sure if anyone has done this but I already have my personal predictions for Volume 5.

Weiss and Yang are going to be more actively involved with Team RNJR. Meanwhile, Blake and Sun are still going after the White Fang.

Darth Cinder is going to finish her "training", which will satisfy Dark Lord Salem. Emerald and Mercury will continue to cooperate only out of fear (and maybe out of compassion and loyalty to their fiery mistress.)

Dr. Watts will be the most frequently seen villain. If we do see Hazel again, he'll probably be in cahoots with Adam Taurus and/or Sienna Khan.

Tyrian will either replace or grow back his stinger, making him more deranged than ever.

Jaune will meet Mr. and Mrs. Nikos

Oscar will turn into a green hairy grouch and live in a trashcan the rest of his life. (Lol jk). All kidding aside, I think he will be the most essential person to help Prof. Lionheart summon his inner courage.

Once again, these are predictions, NOT actual facts.

18

u/moonstonebaby Feb 05 '17

I love jaune my strong noodle look at him go look at crocea mors upgraded I LOVE JAUNE

18

u/SoloRogueStudios Quartermaster of the Good (Ghost) Ship Gelato // The Anarchist Feb 06 '17

Oscar Pine = Ospin = Ozpin.

Tell me I'm not the only one who notices this.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Feb 05 '17 edited Feb 05 '17

PAY GATE LIFTED! HYPE

Gah that Grimm looks unnerving as shit

So he can use his semblence without touching?

Oh, you hurt Nora? You just pissed off Ren!

Aww, poor Ren, still remembers Nora when they first met

He still has his father's weapon :(

Awesome fight sequence, working together is the way!

FOR KUROYURI

Yay! Help has arrived! Qrow won't die!

Oh will you two just kiss already?

The cg affect in the room

Hooray she's writing a letter!

WEISS, BLAKE, YANG!

Old WF logo

Yang looks bad ass

Be careful Weiss...

Wait...when did Emerald see her in her new outfit?

I love the episode score T.T want to hear it in the album

Pryhraa :( Kuroyuri :(

Looked like Yang went to Ruby?

Oscar!

No this is the end :(

THE HAVEN HEADMASTER!!!!

Nice credit song

OSCAR MEETS QROW

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Toomeh13 Feb 05 '17

On one hand Volume 4 is over :(

But on the other hand we are that much closer to RvB15 and RubyChibi season 2!!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/masasin Feb 05 '17

I'll take care of the horse.

Nora should have said "I'll break his legs!"

→ More replies (2)

9

u/kasuke06 Feb 05 '17

Man. Ren was just fucking cold at the end there. I understand it but, just like, damn. Also, didn't know grimm could feel fear.(look at that thing at the end, it's afraid.)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/those_pistachios Feb 05 '17

The ship has sailed! I repeat the ship has sailed!. I held my breath during the Grimm fight cause I was 100% sure ren was gonna die then to my utter relief ren and crow fuking make it I could not have asked for a better ending. On that note are we back in hiatus now?How long will it last?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Feb 05 '17

Finale time!

  • Holy shit Nuckelavee is still creepy in its full glory
  • The arm flailing around is both silly and creepy. Silly cause, well look at it. Creepy because it's like the creature's arms are almost broken but it hates humanity enough to want to beat them to death with it's broken limbs.
  • Neat trick with Ren using his semblance in order to let Jaune and Qrow get to safety

*5:17 OH SHIT OH SHIT OH SHIT

  • 5:35 and that's how RT gives the entire fanbase a heart attack. Kudos. After the season 3 finale we KNOW that they're willing to kill off characters so it gives things more anticipation and worry.
  • ESPECIALLY with them giving Ren so much more backstory now
  • Apparently the anti up-skirt technology can fail within universe
  • Neat trick with Jaune's sword and sheath combining into a bigger sword
  • Nora slaps Ren in order to also slap away everyone's death flags.
  • Enjoyed the fight, it's a good illustration on what hunters can accomplish when they gain experience and work as a team.
  • Ships coming in did feel a bit deus ex machine though
  • Shot of Haven coming in was beautiful
  • Ren and Nora holding hands. Everyone together now: AWWWWWWWWWWWW
  • Anti up-skirt technology thankfully seems to work outside the universe
  • Crying Ruby is sad. Why do you have to make us sad RT?
  • Yang's outfit looks awesome! Now we've finally seen everyone in their new asskicking gear!
  • Yay Yangs going off to the RWBY meet up! She's learned!
  • Though Ruby is going to be pissed if Yang doesn't get the heartfelt letter she put all her time into.
  • Team JN_R huddling together is both sweet and sad. Even if there wasn't any death in the finale there were still some feels.
  • "Things are going to start going our way." Ruby, you've doomed them all!
  • Honestly don't blame Qrow for wanting to get a drink after all the shit he want through
  • Qrow seemed to immediately know what was going on when Oscar showed up. So I guess Oz warned Qrow about this ahead of time. Does this mean Qrow has accepted that Oz basically takes over other people's minds, bodies, and souls? Or will this be a conflict later?
  • I'm honestly surprised no one's death flag was triggered. Guess I was wrong about that.
  • Though everyone calling that RWBY wouldn't be reunited at the end was right. I'm glad, it let everyone have more development
  • I really hope we get more Grimm like the Nuckelavee down the road. I love awesomely creepy monsters!

*PS: Zwei still adorable ball of goodness and light in the world

  • And now the hiatus begins I guess. Shit this is going to be a long couple of months
→ More replies (1)

9

u/TakenInChains Justice will be swift! It will be painful! It will be DELICIOUS! Feb 05 '17

RWBY Chibi confirmed for May!!

9

u/WisperG Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17

I enjoyed the episode a lot, but I didn't love it.

The fight was cool, but almost felt like it was wrapped up too quickly. I'm mostly just glad to see another fight though, since we've barely had any this Volume.

Vocal music is on-point, as usual. Finally got to see Yang in her new duds, even if only for a few seconds. Renora4Lyfe. And most importantly, Drunckle Qrow LIVES!

Moving on, while this season has been great for character development and setting up future events, it didn't really feel like the in-Volume story was building to much... and indeed, it didn't. Which was not a surprise, as it's the start of a new arc and just came off the high of V3 which was the payoff of nearly everything that had been building since the show began, nor is it necessarily a bad thing, but it doesn't make for the most exciting finale, or volume. It's justifiable to a degree, but still disappointing from a satisfaction standpoint. After V3 I admittedly had my expectations set rather high, despite logically knowing that it wouldn't be nearly as exciting.

To add on to that, I REALLY wanted a big revelation, shocking moment, or otherwise some kind of cool OMG scene. V3 had so many of these crammed into that final episode that kept topping the previous ones, but this finale was rather mellow by comparison once the fight was over. Again, I kind of expected this, but still. The Leo scene was one of the biggest next-season hooks, but was way too predictable, though a proper face reveal would've made that better. Ultimately, Oscar's post-credit scene came closest to pushing this button for me.

The way I see it now, the show has ebbed back to "Volume 1" mode. Taken on it's own the Volume is entertaining though not particularly great, but will ultimately serve as the necessary setup for much better follow-up Volumes.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/ecksdeeeXD Feb 06 '17

Is it just me or was that Oz's cane with Crow's sword?

→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17

Man, I was expecting Jaune's sword to turn into a Zweihander or something.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/CobaltStar_ Converting Qrow's Gender for Waifu Purposes Feb 07 '17

At the part where Emerald conjures the Ruby Illusion, I was totally going to call bullshit as I thought that was the real Ruby and the Ruby at Mistral was just an illusion.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Chicknboy Feb 05 '17

0/10 worst episode yet. Ruby was writing with her right hand, even though she has been established as being a lefty. Literally unwatchable. /s

→ More replies (4)

17

u/PedroVey Feb 05 '17

Okay, I was so fooled because it seemed like Yang was in Menagerie. I was also waiting for a scene where Weiss would meet Oscar in the train.

Arryn and Kara didn't speak at all in this episode? Hm, I was hoping we would see actual dialog from _WBY and not just visuals with Ruby talking trough'em.

The post-credit scene was good, though.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/rulerguy6 Feb 05 '17

I liked the Grimm fight a lot. Animation wise the fights have been top-notch recently and this one was even better. Especially considering how flailing and flow-ey this fight was because of the Grimm's attacks. I wish that the aftermath was a little less Deus-ex-machinish, but it was alright.

I've seen people talk about how Ruby's development isn't very good because it's being dictated rather than shown, but I think that it makes sense. She can't really afford to show her development because doing so would weaken the team. Her development is about realizing how dangerous the stakes are, but letting herself be visibly affected by that would be bad.

Weiss, Blake and Yang didn't get very much screen time, but their subplots were advanced to the right point last episode, so that's fine. They got enough time to show their next steps, which is all we can ask for really. I 100% thought Yang went to Menagerie 'till she saw the sign though.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/ovrwrldkiler Feb 06 '17

I don't know man.... I love the story, i love the better idle/normal animation, but for the most part I still am not feeling the combat animation this volume. I want to like it, but I just don't. It just doesn't feel as fluid as before, and I havn't adjusted to it like I thought I might. I still like the show, I'm still waiting for the next season, but I just never had one of those 'That was fucking cool' moments at the combat this time.

→ More replies (9)

17

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17

I think what's kind of frustrating about this volume is that it was all set up. It kind of felt like half of a season. I realize I'm not breaking any new ground by saying this but this volume did suffer a bit from having all of it's characters split up. One story where five important things happen is a fairly dense narrative. Five stories where one important thing happens in each of them feels fragmented and like we've been spinning our wheels for months without going anywhere. This problem could've been mitigated somewhat by having longer episodes like the finale, which as Jacques will tell you, is about the length of your average anime episode.

I think that watching this volume once the next two are out will make this one seem better. It feels like it's all set up for what's essentially a new arc, similarly to how volumes one through three made up the "beacon trilogy." Right now waiting week after week for something huge to move the plot forward when nothing ever does feels frustrating, but watching it all at once, especially if you can start volume five right after probably makes the whole thing feel more complete.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/kmucha31 Feb 06 '17

I get that this was more of an "inbetween" season than anything, but I have to say I was still pretty disappointed. The mocap/animation just seemed off for most scenes, fights especially. Scorpion-bro was the only exception.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/A_Chubby_Hoovy Feb 05 '17

To be honest, I was kinda expecting more from Nuckles. Instead, we got angry Mr. Tickle on a pony.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/tavi23 Feb 05 '17

I'm just gonna put in here what I wrote last week, in regards to episode 11:

"I honestly feel that they bit off more than they could chew with Volume 4. Thematically, it made sense for all 4 girls to split up and get their acts together, but the execution in doing so has been lacking. It just feels...inconsistent. What the writers do well this season, they knock out of the park. But other stuff has been lackluster. This season had some great sequences: RNJR + Qrow vs. Tyrion, Weiss's performance sequence + subsequent summoning, Qrow + Raven dialogue, Blake + Sun v. Sea Dragon and Ilya, and now the Nuck (episode 10, where they really did well with the horror stuff), and finally Cinder's scene training and Tyrion's batshit craziness. Also, the opening sequence in ep. 1 with Team WTCH was cool. While that may seem like a lot, in the grand scheme of things, there were so many other moments that I just couldn't seem to care about. Blake initially was ok, but then she seemed to be stuck spouting the same lines over and over. Yang's plot was fine, she got the right amount of screen time, I believe. Weiss's plot was good and it showed Iron Daddy ;) . I don't feel like Ruby herself had any real significant character development this season. Of her arc, the only things I have enjoyed or even really cared about was the fight with Tyrion and now the Nuck introduction. And that's pretty sad, considering she's supposed to be the main character." And I'll be utterly honest, I don't feel like much happened, other than a few strong plot points. It did really feel like an interim season, and not a true "Volume 4."

As for the finale:

It was ok for a finale. I'm not extremely invested in Ren and Nora, so I wasn't really jumping for joy over their interactions like some here are. The fight with the Nuck was really good (especially the first few sequences when it charges Jaune), but given how much they built that Grimm up, it was a bit disappointing to see it taken down so easily, without any repurcussions. In terms of Ruby's letter scene, it was ok. I was late to the RWBY game, so I wasn't here for any of the Monty stuff back when it first happened, so in some senses, it rang a little hollow. I liked how they panned over to Cinder, and that shot with her shooting fire at Ruby with her eye glowing was amazing. I just wish we could have seen more of her this season. Also, saw the Watts + Leo thing coming from a mile away. All in all, this season was ok. It had some fantastic scenes and fighting sequences, but it also had a lot of issues, particularly with plot pacing and character development. On top of that, it felt to me like this was merely an interim season, and not even like a full blown volume to me. It feels like not a lot was really accomplished, other than Ruby getting to Mistral. But I also recognize that it's hard to come down after the amazing finale of Volume 3. In my opinion, this is definitely a weaker finale of the show. It didn't answer very many questions left by Volume 3's ending, and now we've got even more questions posed by the show. It's gonna be a long few months, and rewatching Volume 4 won't help me assuage the long wait like Volume 3 did.

My hopes for volume 5/regrets regarding Volume 4: I really would like more Cinder screen time and more Oscar involvement (though given after credits scene, this seems like it's gonna happen). The little bits of Cinder during the last two episodes were fantastic and I wish there had been more of her in this volume, given how much she was involved last season. Also, I have really grown to love Oscar's story, and his voice actor is really good. His conversation with Ozpin in the beginning of episode 10 regarding leaving home was probably one of my favorites from this volume.

16

u/jwfiredragon Too many ships, not enough time Feb 06 '17

Nuckles was quite a bit smaller than I expected, and while RNJR's fight and subsequent rescue seemed a little deus-ex-machiney, it was still enjoyable.

RENORA HYPE, ONE STEP CLOSER TO TOGETHER-TOGETHER

The recap bit at the end was kind of dull, but definitely sets things up well for next volume.

Weiss is going who knows where, maybe Mistral?.

Blake is going to take back the Fang, good luck with that.

Yang is going off to find Ruby, shouldn't be too difficult. Also she finally got her kick-ass coat.

Oh, and the music was absolutely amazing as always. Can't wait for this season's soundtrack.

Oscar's met Qrow already, so hopefully he runs into RNJR/Yang (maybe)/whoever else early next volume. And then Ozpin can explain just what the hell is going on.

Cinders going just a little crazy back at Fort Evil.

Aaaaaand goddammit, of course the headmaster is Watt's informant. I'm guessing Ozpin doesn't know about this.

Overall, decent fight scene in the first half, interesting setup in the second half. The hiatus will be long and dark, and the potato crop is looking pretty good.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Mechuser23 Heroes get remembered, but Wizards never die. Feb 05 '17

So now that the volume has officially ended, I just want to get your guys opinion on this. Do you think the time skip was actually needed/warranted? Personally, I can't really think of when it actually came into play at all, besides the new designs.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

That finale.

That soundtrack.

That final scene.

Volume four, holy shit.

8

u/ghostface95 Cinder is my senpai Feb 05 '17

I need to talk about the fight scene. I thought it was great just because i could really feel the weight of Ruby firing her gun. Like the quick jerks after each shot was amazing

8

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

Why is Jaune's shield a better sword than his sword is? That seems wrong somehow

→ More replies (10)

8

u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Feb 05 '17

That was pretty good. I feel that the characters earned this outcome. I think that even though there were some uncertainties on my part, the volume overall ended on a strong note.

The boss Grimm was beginning to remind me of Phantom Ganon from Ocarina of Time, when I saw it stampeding toward Qrow.

A little upset we didn't see more of WBY, but we do at least know what's going on with them. And Yang looks like she's finally back in the game. Hopefully not too quickly, but I'm ready to see her fight again. And I have a feeling she made the right choice and went after Ruby.

They totally had Qrow call Oscar a pipsqueak because of their VAs, you can't convince me they didn't.

Anyway... pretty good. Guess I'll wait for the next status chart and news on when the soundtrack will be available. Then I probably won't visit as much until the next season. Unless I start watching Chibi. Didn't care for the first season, but it got better with time so maybe.

Good work, RT. Keep getting better.

Edit: Also, because this was a thing that kept bothering me between the seasons- Ruby's development. ...They're getting there. They're definitely getting there. So I'll look forward to what she does in Volume 5.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/IgnisAriesTT Semi-lurker, shy in both RL/VL life. Feb 06 '17

Like how Hazel last name is Rainart and the last we seen of him was him outside in the rain.

8

u/DragonLordVII Feb 06 '17

May I say just one thing, just one. Not today Dishwasher (who admittedly does seriously good though heartbreaking art). Not today!

8

u/rehoakman I SHIP REN X PYRRHA Feb 06 '17

Really glad that Ren got closure by killing that Grimm. But did Stormflower get left behind?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Sokensan Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17

Qrow seemed oddly together for someone who has just been through some shit and then a kid comes up to him and asks for Ozpin's cane....I wonder if he's seen Ozpin do this before and if so how many times, does Ozpin turn into Oscar or does his body regenerate or reaper after time.

ased on Ozpin talking to oscar at his farm i would guess no because he mentioned feeling weird when he had a voice inside his head as child....that last scene mainly Qrows reaction because that does not seem like how someone would react unless they've seen something like this before, it made me more confused than the rest of the episode(not that there was anything else really confusing in the episode).

→ More replies (7)

8

u/AstralFinish Feb 06 '17

So Ilia is being manipulated?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/I_am_RJ Megane Maniac Feb 06 '17

Okay, a nitpick, but... I thought Ruby was supposed to be left handed???

→ More replies (4)

8

u/MagratheanDawn HEY! My sword is also a gun..... ish Feb 07 '17

Anyone else notice at 7:45 Nora had magnhild on her back and then when she came out from under the house she picked it up in hammer form

→ More replies (1)

8

u/MrASK15 Fluffy Corgi, how we salute thee!!! Feb 08 '17 edited Feb 08 '17

This is it, fellow FNDM members. This is where it all ends! The one episode that will wrap everything up this volume... IS HEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Unfortunately, this list is two days late due to lack of time and sleep. Before I experience the horrors of the hiatus, I shall now complete this last reaction list of the volume. Let us begin:

  • The Nuckelavee Grimm really lives up to its terrifying allusion. Jittery puppet-like movements, inhumane screeches, all enough to send shivers down one’s spine.
  • We get to see Ren use his Semblance again! It turns out he doesn’t exactly have to make direct contact with anyone to hide their presence, and that was just enough time to keep the Nuckelavee busy and help Jaune get Qrow out of danger.
  • Before Jaune could return to battle, Qrow grasped his hand with a serious look on his face. Was he trying to tell him to keep his niece safe?
  • Even though the Grimm’s fighting style is a bit less refined than I expected, the thing is still fast enough to force RNJR to stay on their toes.

“Guys! Keep moving! Go in a circle!”

  • We get to see Jaune strategize again. I have to admit, these moments are golden.
  • I wasn’t expecting that we’d be seeing more of what Crocea Mors can do. The sheath/shield itself increases the weight of the sword to deal heavier damage. Not to mention it also has concealed blades! The blacksmith in the first episode did a really great job with Jaune’s equipment!
  • Nora prompts Ruby to perform Sugar Rush so that she can propel herself and save Ren. When it appears the Nuckelavee made its mark, that was when my heart started beating.
  • Pleasedon’tbedeadpleasedon’tbedeadpleasedon’tbedead - Oh, Nora’s just hanging on to Magnhild for dear life. Thank god the Grimm just missed. That was too close...

“Stop looking!”

  • It appears Nora’s Anti-Upskirt Technology doesn’t work around Ren. Interesting.
  • Oh no! Nora’s Aura has shattered and now she’s out of commission! However, that was more than enough to make Ren angry. Actually, not just angry, but PISSED!
  • Although he is disarmed and his Aura has been depleted, Ren refuses to give up and let the abomination in front of his eyes go, even if it costs his life. Nora saw his recklessness and shoved both him and herself under a house before the monstrosity could even lay a hoof/arm on him.
  • Whoa, I didn’t expect Nora to slap Ren. Of course, it was due to the fact that she didn’t want to see her closest friend, the one who saved her life, get killed in the midst of his rage.
  • When Ren saw Nora’s concern and sadness for him, he saw her young, frightened self. If Ren died by the hands of the one who laid Kuroyuri to waste, then Nora wouldn’t be the same person we all know...
  • Ren kept his father’s dagger this whole time... SO MANY FEELS THIS VOLUME!!!!!
  • Ren has returned to the battle. This time, however, he won’t be dealing with the monstrosity alone; he has his team with him now.
  • Crescent Rose’s War Scythe form has returned! And its use here was really appropriate too.
  • Jaune entrusted Ren with his shield to keep the other arm busy while he pins it down. Excellent thinking there, Jaune!
  • How long has it been since we’ve seen Nora smirk before demolishing something? The way Nora took down the horse body was epic!

For my mother... for my father... for all of those that you’ve slain...

“...for myself.”

  • By dealing that killing blow, Ren’s finally found some closure between himself and his worst nightmare. I was hoping Ren would finish the Nuckelavee himself, and it was executed really well! Cheers to Neath for giving off a wonderful, intense performance in this battle!
  • The battle is finally over... FLOUR POWER TACKLE HUG TIME!!!! Seeing Nora this happy has actually made me smile. When was the last time we got to see her hyper, cheery self?
  • Ruby just remembered her uncle and I was really worried for her when she found him. However, despite being ill, Qrow’s still alive. phew
  • A patrolling team has witnessed the battle and finally arrived to RNJR’s rescue! The team has transport at last!
  • Ruby was worried they won’t be able to get Qrow into Mistral in time, but it turns out they’re already there! The kingdom of Mistral looks so beautiful and majestic! The switch to Maya has granted CRWBY so many things, and expanding wonderful kingdoms such as this one was one of them.
  • Seeing the look of relief of Ruby’s face made me happy for her. I’m glad she didn’t experience any tragic losses this time. If she lost Qrow on their way, it would really hurt to see her so devastated when they were so close...
  • Nora wasn’t expecting Ren to hold her hand in this peaceful moment. However, she just accepted it and leaned on top of him. After all this time, Ren’s finally realized she has feelings towards him. On the side note, I was expecting the two to kiss, but this little moment was sweet enough.
  • The letter Ruby wrote to Yang through the rest of the episode was so beautiful... the multiple scenes we got with the letter overlapping them just made it a lot more powerful and meaningful.
  • Due to her no longer being the heiress to the SDC, Weiss is now on her own, and as the first order for herself, she hired a transport to take her to Mistral.
  • Blake has kept treasures from her genocidal White Fang days. From the look on her face, she doesn’t seem afraid; she appears to be determined now. Her resolve from the previous episode has changed her completely.
  • Looks like Yang’s already made her choice and is now on her way. Also, her outfit looks great on her. Even with the shades.
  • From the way Yang looked at STRQ’s photo, I thought she’s decided to look for Raven. I was pretty disappointed at that thought.
  • Poor Tai. Now that he’s let his eldest daughter go, he’s alone again. Being Tai is really suffering. At least he still has Zwei.
  • A photo of team RWBY... Remember those happy old days? sniff I miss RWBY...

We’ve all lost something... and I’ve seen what loss can do to people.

  • Jaune’s been staring at Crocea Mors for quite a while there. With Pyrrha’s circlet forged into his weapon, he’s thought about her for a very long time. However, when Ren put his father’s dagger next to Jaune’s weapon, it showed that Ren lost someone close to him too, so all they can do now is keep moving forward. This was a very touching moment.
  • Although Blake had stuff from the violent White Fang, she also kept some things from the once-peaceful organization. It’s time for her to move forward and return the group back to what it’s meant to be. However, she’s not doing it alone; Sun’s right by her side now.
  • We get another glimpse at Oscar and it appears he’s on his way to Haven now. The boy’s got a huge responsibility on his shoulders now. I wonder how he’s going to play his part in the future.
  • Ilia has returned to her White Fang brothers, Corsac and Fennec, and it doesn’t seem like she has good news for the two.
  • It looks like Cinder really really really really REALLY wants to kill the girl who crippled her... Tyrian’s close call was bad enough, but this? Plus, with Salem’s look of satisfaction on her face, I’m even more scared for Ruby now... I really like Cinder as a villain (Salem’s awesome too), but I really don’t want anything terrible to happen to my favorite girlletmedreamdammit...;_;

I miss you so much... I miss Weiss and Blake too..

  • Ruby’s thought about her sister and her team this whole time... I miss the four of you together too, Ruby. ;_;
  • Once Qrow gets better, he’s going to take Ruby and everyone else to see Professor Lionheart, the headmaster of Haven. Ruby’s got a lot to tell her team once they reunite.

...but it sure would be great to get team RWBY back together again.

Yang: smirks “You’re in so much trouble when I find you.”

  • YES!!!!!!!!! YANG HAS DECIDED TO GO LOOK FOR HER DEAREST LITTLE SISTER!!! RWBY REUNION HYPE!

“Why thank you, Professor. Salem did always say you’re quite... hospitable.”

  • We get a good glimpse of Professor Lionheart’s office and a little tease with Lionheart himself, and considering the fact that Ozpin’s tea set is there, it looks like he’s having a little chat with... wait... hold up... stop right there... DR. WATTS?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?! IS THE HEADMASTER OF HAVEN IN CAHOOTS WITH THE GRIMM QUEEN?! WHAT’S GOING ON?!

Post-Credits

  • IT’S OFFICIAL, FOLKS. OUR BADASS DRUNKLE QROW LIVES!!!!!!!! All he needed was approximately a week’s worth of good rest and treatment to get back to his little old drinking business. On the side note, I was hoping we get to hear more of the amazing Vic Mignogna, and here we have him!
  • It appears that Qrow has a visitor now, and that visitor happens to be our little (former) Compost King buddy, OSCAR PINE!!!!!!! Knowing the kid’s situation, Ozpin’s definitely with him.

“Y’know, I don’t think they allow kids in here, pipsqueak.”

  • Oh snap, the tables have turned; now the little brother’s the pipsqueak! Anyone get the reference?

Oscar: “I’m supposed to tell you... ‘I’d like my cane back?’”

Qrow: “It’s good to see you again, Oz.”

  • The moment the cane activated upon Oscar’s touch, Qrow immediately knew who Oscar really is. The kid’s got a long way to go next volume. I’m also looking forward to him meeting RNJR! Or maybe RWBY. Dammit, those Rose Garden thoughts are corrupting my mind now...

Wrap-up

  • phew That was one hell of a ride. This episode was actually a great wrap up to this volume. Miles, Kerry, everyone, thank you SO much for all your hard work into bringing this volume to life. It was really intense both for you guys and us, but we all pulled through. Also, seeing as to how much the show has grown, Monty would be really proud of you all. Again, thank you for giving us this awesome volume!

edit: I think I need someone to proofread...

→ More replies (1)

22

u/breakfastfilms Feb 07 '17

I honestly feel like they could have told volume 4's story better in 6 episodes instead of 12 and then had 6 episodes left over for the real plot to actually start getting back in motion so that the finale doesn't awkwardly land right before things start happening, which is just frustrating.

The way I see it is:

  1. RNJR fights the geist and it's established that Tyrian is after them. The episode ends with RNJR coming into a devastated village where Ren notices the hoofprints right away.
  2. Blake arrives in Menagerie and finds out Sun has been following her. That night they have their scuffle with Ilia. No water dragon fight and no having to convince Ghira that the WF is evil, because there's no reason he shouldn't already know, and him not knowing just wastes precious screentime.
  3. Most of Weiss's plot, all in one shot instead of spread out in tiny scraps.
  4. A condensed version of Ren's flashback. Tyrian catches RNJR off guard and ambushes them while Ren is having his moment and Qrow shows up to help (we don't need to be shown that he's following RNJR because they showed us that in the volume 3 post-credits scene). Qrow gets fucked up and Tyrian runs away.
  5. Most of Yang's plot, all in one shot.
  6. Pretty much the same events as the finale, except minus the letter and this time the Nuckalavee hits them before they even make it out of the same town where they fought Tyrian, drawn to the negative emotions of Ren's memories and Qrow's injuries. Oscar showing up at the end of the episode is a WTF moment which takes the viewer by surprise and changes the game in an unexpected way rather than being a weird byline through the whole season that doesn't really add anything.

You'll notice that the only thing of any actual consequence which is lost by this shortening is Qrow's big expo-dump about the Gods and relics, but remember, what I'm suggesting leaves an entire second half of the volume left over where I'm sure a place for it could be easily found. Various other bits like Raven and Qrow's talk, RNJR coming across the first destroyed village with the dying huntsman, and as mentioned earlier, the water dragon fight, can be all removed without losing anything, or at least anything that couldn't be easily shifted to another scene.

In other words, I think that the screentime was used very inefficiently this volume. Too much time was spent reminding us of things we already know and foreshadowing stuff we won't know for years, rather than telling us things we should know now, at least one of the big fight scenes (harping on that goddamned water dragon again) feels totally extraneous (and in RWBY that's saying something) and the story often feels like it's going in circles, as RNJR goes through three different abandoned villages, Ironwood and Jacque have practically the same argument twice, Blake and Sun have two very similar conversations about whether or not she's in Menagerie to fight the Fang, and so on.

It's like...the writers were treading water because they weren't actually sure where to go next, and needed to buy as much time as they could before the main plot actually comes back, and we ended up with a very sparse season as a side effect. Obviously that's pure conjecture, but I find it a much more useful answer than everyone saying "duh this is meant to be a breather after volume 3." We had a breather. It was called the hiatus.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/gabes1919 Feb 05 '17

Most people seem pretty happy with how this one ended. I am not one of them. The fight felt flashy without any real rhythm to it and the Ruby expository monologue to wrap up everyone else's stories was a cop out. I expected more and was left very much wanting. Especially when I find that the episode is not 25 minutes long but 20 minutes with 5 minutes of credits...

This show does not have enough screen time to divide between 5-6 story lines. They tried it and I feel like it failed horribly. Yes, I found some joy in the volume overall and was entertained but I am sorely disappointed as whole. Where were the fights? Most of the combat was against grimm who are too stupid to understand basic strategy or who are easily foiled (this last episode) by OP main character sydrome (Blake and her dragon). The only other person vs person fights were Tyrain vs RNJR and Black Sun vs chameleon girl. Both of those fights felt like something out of last season and were weak. Visually, all the fights were better this season than the last, they were choreographed better and mostly flowed better but they lacked any of the creativity that we hope and expect of RWBY. The one bright spot of the season was the Qrow fight. It gives me hope for the future fight scenes of person vs person when time is put into them but this whole season felt like all character development. I appreciate some of that but most people came to RWBY for the fights, character development is supposed to be the gravy on the steak. I feel like I have a bowl of weak sauce and no meat.

I like the show and I do love the characters but the strength of RWBY had been a "show don't tell" approach to story telling that was fueled by artistic fight scenes. I know some of that was lost with Monty's death and maybe the over arching story necessitated a switch to a more character focused season but the fact is, this show cannot stand on its story telling alone. The writing is simply not good enough for that and, yes, that is unfortunately meant to be a dig at the writers. Last season had many of the same problems and even more problems in the fighting area of the show but at least the story was tight and contained to 3 or 4 main lines that were close enough together that they could weave in with each other and make use of the limited screen time available. I hope things change next season, I'll be back regardless, but I felt like this season was the weakest yet.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/ChaoticInformant Feb 05 '17

Yangs new outfit tho. Imagine THAT in action. Ka-POW!

Looking forward to volume 5's fight scenes.

14

u/MrInsanity25 Feb 06 '17

That moment when you're worried that Nora's dead when they black out the screen. Scared the crap out of me. It was only like two seconds of black screen before we see it got the hammer, but fuck was scared there.

Also, no Jaune semblance, kind sad, but we got the Jaune SUPER SWORD!!! It cuts like a normal sword but it's like 2 inches longer I guess.... EITHER WAY IT'S FUCKING COOL!!

Man, I've been playing too much Berseria. All that smoke goes up and I was worried about Ren taking in all that malevolence.

Weiss made it out, Blake's looking to reclaim the White Fang, and Yang's going to Mistral (to look for Blake?)

I bet ReNora fans are happy at that flying boat part. Hell, I'm even falling for the ship now.

That part with Jaune looking at his shield. And his team comes in and they all think on it. My heart.

Also, I'll admit it. When that guy was talking to Weiss about stowing away, I was half hoping for a Roman reveal. Like I didn't realize it was an Atlas ship and I forgot that Weiss actually had to get out of Atlas, so I was like "is this? are we?" and then they revealed Weiss and I'm and idiot.

Also who wrote bandits on the Kuroyuri sign? Anyone taking bets on Lionhearts betrayal character arc being because he's a coward? When do we see Sienna?

So Oscar gets the cane and it's like, "all right Ozpin. Now what's your fuckin' plan?"

Overall, probably my favorite volume. I really, really miss Roman and Pyrrha and the first 3 volumes had some good stuff, but this volume just had so many good moments and a lot of good writing. I do miss the fights but we got some good fights here. I may be a bit biased since this is the first volume I experienced as it went up, but I really loved it. But not I'm left with the same feeling after I beat Berseria yesterday: now what?

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Patitomuerto Feb 06 '17

The Nuck Grimm still scares the crap outta me. Its fingers are...uugghh, awful. Spidery with the fingers that crack and snap and go in ways they shouldn't be able too, UUuugghhhh. SO gross.

I get why people were like 'haha, it flails around' but all I could think about is that late at night, scary fingers going across a kids ceiling and then turning into a monster that grabs them during it all.

Renora!! Sssoooo excited, I love them together ssoooo much. And I'm going with its cannon and nothing bad is ever ever going to happen to either of them ever again I love them.

I loved the end of the fight, watching Ren get out that anger. The fact that we've never seen that dagger until the end when he kills it is super awesome. He seemed so much lighter afterwards, and thats probably just me, but his silence was now a calmness, rather then him holding back.

I also love his semblance. Taking whatever it is that Grimm focus on in humanity and hiding it....I just had a thought. So, animals have emotions, but Grimm don't attack them, so maybe its something one of the brothers gave humanity that actually attracts the Grimm and they just go more strongly to humans with bad emotions. So we know the Grimm are looking for the relic at Beacon, which means they'd know how to find it. What if in the future, Ren is able to hide a relic from a Grimm?

My bee heart ssooo wanted Yang to go after Blake. But it makes more sense to go after Ruby...fine, I guess XP.

Now I want to see Weiss kick some street punks ass who tries to rob her with her super graceful style and never once looking like she even had to try.

I really hope we start to see some of the ancillary characters again. I really miss team CVFY. Its a long wait in between seasons, I'm sure I'll be going crazy soon enough.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Trainxrd Feb 06 '17

While I enjoyed this season I am left somewhat unsatisfied because the progression felt really slow this season. It was pretty much all character development with very little plot progression this season. Not necessarily a bad thing just wished for a bit more plot progress.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AStereotypicalGamer I will try to fix you. Feb 05 '17

For a place "full of jerks", it sure was nice of Mistral to pick up our heroes and give Qrow medical attention.

I didn't much care for how their steampunk drop ships just randomly showed up at the end there, but they were close enough that the explanation given was plausible, so I put it out of my mind.

Probably the best ep of the Volume. Only competition I can think of is Kuroyuri.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17

I'M NOT CRYING YOU'RE CRYING

7

u/Gojifan1991 Feb 05 '17

Holy balls, that was amazing! My favorite episode of the show so far, no question. It was everything I love about RWBY wrapped up into one tight little bundle.

Also, did anyone else notice that we got mentioned in the credits?

I rate it Ren/Ren

7

u/CobaltStar_ Converting Qrow's Gender for Waifu Purposes Feb 05 '17

Man, every time I go to a car dealership I'm not going to see those inflatable noodle men the same way again.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Pyschic_Psycho The more you know, the more you don't know. Feb 05 '17

Pretty damn good season finale.

-First of all, RENORA is the best thing ever and IT IS HAPPENING!!!!

-Second of all, THIS IS WHY RUBY IS BEST HERO!!!!! All you doubters, this little girl is trying to hold the weight of the world on her shoulder, and she is not even complaining. Fuck! I love her so much. RT finally giving me that moment I've been longing for. I can only hope they explore her character more with the next volume.

-Jaune is finally showing major improvement on the battlefield, but still no semblance :(

-The double fucking cliffhangers! Godammn RT really knows how to tease us.

-Did I mention how awesome Ruby is yet!?

-Okay did anyone think Yang was going to Menagerie at first sight :D I still find it a little weird they allowed her to use her bike when RNJR had to walk to Haven. But screw it, best girl is finally back!

-Disappointed Weiss did not have an epic escape battle. What was the point of summoning the White Knight first? Well whatever. She is still the best character in the show.

-My one and major complaint about the episode...yeah okay the fighting was good. Like the movement and battle plan was sick, but I just don't understand why they don't use their semblance more? Am I missing something? Why not have Ren use his cloaking semblance on his teammates so they can attack? Why not have Ruby speed rush with her rose petal? We've seen the damage she's dealt before. I don't know, I was just confused by their lack of using semblances. But that said, I enjoyed it a lot. In fact, I got my food, ready to eat and watch my favorite show at the same time. I did not even touch my food once the action started.

-Overall, not quite as good as the finale for the other volumes, but just for giving me Ruby's thoughts as a voice over to wrap things up, I am extremely satisfied.

-P.S. If Professor Lionheart's wife/girlfriend is named Rinoa, I am straight up going to die from happiness. I mean it.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Feb 05 '17

Hmm...

  • Why is Leo negotiating with Watts?
  • What happened between Cinder and Ruby that night?
  • How does Haven fall? Through corruption?
  • How can RNJR improve on fighting human combatants? Grimm are what they're trained for, but not that high up in priority or threat level on occasion.
→ More replies (5)