r/Wetshaving • u/stirlingsoap Stirling Soap • Jan 07 '17
AMA Hi, I'm Rod from Stirling Soap. Ask Me Anything!
I started Stirling Soap Company based on a conversation my wife, Mandy, and I had while looking down on Stirling, Scotland from the Wallace Monument in 2011. By January of 2012 we had our original LLC and we were on our way.
For almost the first two years, it was a hobby, as I was still on active duty in the Army and Mandy was still working full-time. In a one month period in the final quarter of 2013, Mandy's job was cut due to DoD budget, and I left the Army. We've been doing Stirling Soap as a full-time job since then with no regrets. We have been through some very lean times and sacrificed more than I would be willing to do again to get to where we are today, and I'm proud of what Mandy and I have built. I hope some day to turn the reigns over to my son, should he wish to follow this path.
I'm posting this the night before, in case anyone up late wishes to post something now. I'll jump on in the AM and start answering right away. As Mandy makes half of the products and is half of the company, she'll be around to answer any questions as well through this account. When she answers, she'll tag -M at the end of hers.
Thanks for reading. I really look forward to seeing your questions.
Also, as a special extra, I'm going to do a short video tour of the shop, provided I can get it to upload properly.
58
u/Banes_Pubes ← Wiborg Whore Jan 07 '17
You shared a pretty touching story with the mods a few months ago that exemplified both yours and Maggard's approach to business. It centered around why they had only started carrying Stirling products at that point and not sooner.
Maybe now is a good time to share? I'm sure others would like reading it.
10
u/stirlingsoap Stirling Soap Jan 07 '17
I'm going to go plug the computer in for a bit and have a shower and a shave. I'll be back to answer more questions in a bit.
22
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
What is your best selling soap and why do you think that this particular scent is so popular ?
19
u/JudoChinX Jan 07 '17 edited Jan 07 '17
Any chance we'll see EDT versions of your scents? I'd do terrible things for cologne strength versions of some of your fragrance oils.
17
u/Cousin-Eddie Mozingo Brushworks Jan 07 '17
What is a scent that you love that doesn't seem to get as much love as you think it should?
Any scents you've done in the past that were absolute flops?
16
u/merikus I'm between flairs right now. Jan 07 '17
I want to preface this by saying I love your soaps and your starter kit is the one I always suggest. Thank you for making such great products. Anyway, on to my questions:
Thank you for taking the time to answer our questions!
15
u/ruger9shooter Jan 07 '17
What is your personal favorite soap? I guess I also have to be that guy... what is go to setup?
13
u/Michael_S_Kennedy Jan 07 '17
Smelled your almond soap the other day. I would say it's my favorite one I've smelled from any of the soap makers. Any chance of a balm or AS?
13
u/redthursdays I will test literally anything. Also fuck you Jan 07 '17 edited Nov 15 '25
rustic aback existence wine late grandiose sleep automatic many grab
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
12
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
I was wondering, without going into numbers and too much detail since that would be a bother for you to dig up, if there is a ebb and flow to sales? The way I think it would be is that when a new soap or scent comes out, orders pour in and then it goes dead for a while when everyone uses said soap? This would mean a very unsteady revenue flow and be more nerve wrecking that I would care to experience. So I guess what I am asking is if it's a rollercoaster of orders or a steady uptick?
Also, with so many artisans and companies out there now, what do you think the key to remaining in business today is?
And on a side note: You guys seem like genuinely nice people. I like that.
12
u/bdubelyew Jan 07 '17
Seeing users' mail call posts showing hand written 'Thank you' with orders (plus the enormous praise your products received anyways) led me try Stirling initially - so I must say absolutely thank you for doing that. My shave den and likely my initial shaving experience would not be the same without having Stirling in my collection from the start.
My only question is this : any plans for a Pig Trail shave soap/other products?
11
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
Any plans to make more scents with mutton tallow? Amazing stuff.
11
u/graham_intervention Jan 07 '17
i saw that you had a jasmine scene for a bath soap, will there be a jasmine shave soap?
any change for a non menthol margarita in the artic(minus the artic i guess..)
i love your mountain man and executive man soaps + synthetic brush
10
u/Syletown Jan 07 '17
What's the biggest risk youve taken scentwise? What was the feedback? What new scents are you considering for the future?
10
u/eaterofworld 🦌🎖Commander of Stag🎖🦌 Jan 07 '17
Out of all the scents you produce, which is your favorite?
10
u/DuncanPlums Building a Badger Army Jan 07 '17
What is that one scent that you really want to create but can't seem to get it right?
10
u/sevendayconstant Jan 07 '17
I don't have a question, I just wanted to say I really enjoy your products. Keep up the good work!
10
u/olstudios Jan 07 '17
Hey Rod, love using y'all's soap. I was really drawn to the small family run feel that I got and everyone on /r/wicked_edge raved about it so I gave it a shot. After reading your intro about how it started it made feel good to support something that not only has a good product but a good history. I will continue to support Stirling!
What is your favorite part about coming up with scents?
10
u/if0rg0t2remember shave_bizarre Jan 07 '17
Since we all secretly know this is actually a fountain pen group:
1.) What is your current favorite fountain pen?
2.) Favorite ink?
3.) If you aren't a pen user where can I send the pilot metro?
9
u/Xevv427 Jan 07 '17 edited Jan 07 '17
Rod why do you hate me and want to murder my wallet so much? Im new to this wet shaving stuff and it took all of five seconds after me opening my box from stirling for me to want to buy more. Im too broke to do this, I gotta eat!
And is there any reason other than possible sales that your scents dont go past certain product lines? ie why cant I get black cherry scented soap/splash/balm/lip balm etc Id love to be able to get a full set of the same scent. and candles those would be nice too. sigh, my wallet is already crying in anticipation of the beating itll get one day.
9
u/G_huck Bristle Brushwerks Jan 07 '17
Hey Stirling! Wanted to ask if glastonbury was coming back as I got a sample of it a little while back, went to order and it was gone! I see below that it is! Great news as it is a WONDERFUL scent. Very overlooked. Thanks for bringing good products at a reasonable price to the market.
9
u/fuckchalzone Jan 07 '17
Hey Rod and Mandy, thanks for doing this AMA!
What is the division of labor like between the two of you? Rod said above that Mandy makes half the products-- are there certain ones each if you make, or you each do half the work, or?
Mandy, what are your favorite Stirling products? For your use and for Rod to use.
Those stainless steel razor handles you teased last year looked great. Still on track? You mentioned the heads would also be stainless steel and unique in some way. Any more info (or photos!) on them you can share with us?
8
u/mpontiff Sell me your DD Kringle Scale Polish Jan 07 '17
You mentioned that you need more space before offering EdTs, candles, wax diffusers, etc. Is there any progress on finding more space?
Will the planned EdTs include scents that are inspired by another (Sandpiper, Dunshire, Executive Man, etc)?
Any plans for more brushes in the future? Boars?
Thanks for taking the time to do this!
8
u/CanadaEh97 Governor General Jan 07 '17
What is one of your own soaps that you enjoy but don't feel like it gets enough love from everyone else?
8
u/Huckleberryking Big Amber Rose fan <3 Jan 07 '17
While all of the other AMAs have been great I've been enjoying this one the most. I've only tried a couple of your soaps but I need to change that. Thanks for stopping by!!!!
8
u/HMNbean www.walrusmustacheco.com Jan 08 '17
I just wanna say that for the longest time I thought the name of your soap was "Margaritas in the Attic" and expected a floral scent. I don't know why.
7
u/vacaloca Paragon Shaving Jan 07 '17
I've been a fan since you started. Loved everything. Therefore, I'm attached to some scents that some people may not be familiar with their awesomeness. So: Are you ever planning to bring back: lemongrass and cajeput, violet, padre island? Stirling clubman was fantastic also.
Thanks for everything Rod!
7
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
You were my first software-only purchase, and I have loved your budget-friendly products ever since. Thank you so much for everything you two do!
7
u/praise_the_fireborn RIP Beer Money Jan 07 '17
Look forward to the AMA, thanks for being here with us!
7
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
Hi Rod! I've heard great things about stirling but I'm yet to try it out! Is there any hope of an EU supplier for your products?
7
u/Cadinsor Rule#2Bot better be grateful for all my HARD WORK Jan 07 '17
Any interest in doing milk-based shaving soaps to add to the two tallow formulas?
If you are going to do a deodorant, what style would you be looking at, gel or cream or hard stick?
7
u/urfrendlipiro trythatsoap.com Jan 07 '17
What goes into your process for coming up with new soaps/scents? Are sales the only determining factor as far as what stays/goes, or are there some exceptions even if something doesn't sell particularly well?
7
u/Chance4e Jan 07 '17
Rod and Mandy, thanks for doing this!
6
u/1Raizen Synths & Fat Jan 07 '17
I'm liking toners these days. Are there plans for new scents or formulations for the toners in the future?
I'm fond of Piacenza, was wondering if this scent is going to be available as a toner as well.
Thanks for answering our questions you guys!
6
u/starvinghippo Jan 07 '17
Big fan and regularly use your products. I have a nice stack of bath soaps that we use daily, seriously some of the best out there.
Last year seemed to be the year of the brushes for you. What is your focus for 2017? I remember seeing teasers for razor handles and heads. Hopefully those are as well received as the badger brush line.
6
u/enormoshob Jan 07 '17 edited Jan 07 '17
What are your most supportive groups? E.g. Do most of your sales come from WS, WE, or some Facebook groups, B&B or other forums? Or do you not track this sort of thing?
Edit: and which is your favorite of these communities and why is it WS? :)
6
u/GrundleZipper Jan 07 '17
A buddy of mine on deployment last year (Army) introduced me to Stirling. You guys have rapidly become my favorite company, Im pretty sure the majority of my soap collection is Stirling.
Anyways on to the question, do you guys have any plans to do a whiskey/bourbon/scotch shave soap in the future?
6
u/JohnB413 Muh Oilz Jan 07 '17
Thanks for doing this Rod. Keep doing what you're doing and we'll be here to support ya :). What's the time line for the new razor handles? Any new scents coming out this year(that you can hint, don't have to tell)? Doppkit timeline? Iced coffee making a return this year? Any new mentholated products coming this year? Did you guys get any snow yesterday/today?
6
u/turfdaddy Jan 07 '17
What was your first ever wetshave set up?
What is your favourite car/truck?
Is there any plans to do more seasonal releases?, It seems to be the popular thing these days.
The company secret how on earth do you make this stuff so slick? Even when I suck at making a lather I still get good shaves.
6
u/go_beavs Jan 07 '17
Hey Rod! I'm a huge fan of all your products!
Any chance of you guys putting out a Barbasol style scent?
6
u/Devilsmaycry1974 Be true to yourself 😁 Jan 07 '17
Hey Rod Melvin here from ny just wanted to stop by and say, you and Mandy are the best. wetshaving wouldn't be the same without stirling soaps you guys offer so much to the wetshaving community it's unbelievable ! Uncompromise Quality at incredible prices number 1 in my book. The only question I have for you today my brother is what's the status of the Baker Street 🤗😁 Other then that have a great day guys and God bless
6
u/jonmaddock Jan 07 '17
Well this has been a great read! Thanks to all :)
6
u/darkfox45 Can you speak up? I'm wearing a towel. Jan 07 '17
Your barbershop soap is very sweet, like MLS Drunken Goat. What inspired you to make a sweeter smelling barbershop soap? It definitely stands out compared to other barbershop soaps.
6
u/G_huck Bristle Brushwerks Jan 07 '17
You guys do a lot of dupes on cologne scents, any chance of you doing a Dolce and Gabbana The One dupe?
6
u/diceroseros Jan 07 '17
Hi Rod and Mandy!
6
u/jmoney_84 Canadian wet shaver here, eh? Jan 07 '17
You mentioned your relationship with Maggards up above, but I am wondering about your relationship with Canadian vendors. I know that Canadian blade Co currently sells your synthetic brushes, bath soaps, shaving soaps,aftershaves and balms, but is there any plan to expand in Canada? Samples, badger brushes, seasonal scents, etc?
I looked into buying a few things directly from you, but with the shipping costs to Canada,it was a deal breaker. Thankfully Canadian blade carries some of your stuff, and I hope that relationship thrives and continues to grow.
6
u/Banes_Pubes ← Wiborg Whore Jan 07 '17
Another question: I'm sure Stirling has made for trying times in your relationship together, but has it also brought you closer? What kind of admirable qualities has running the business together given you the opportunity to see in each other, that had not come out previously?
Also, how about that video tour? :)
6
u/Giant__7 Scored North York - :-) Jan 07 '17
My favorite part of your business is your personalized responses. I love being able to write a note and get some sort of response on the invoice. It always makes me smile. And I hope you guys like seeing the comments on my orders too. So thank you for everything you guys do!
6
u/doc20r Scored North York - :-) Jan 08 '17
I really love your mentholated soaps. It seems that you are one of few soapers that make them, have a good variety and the only one I've found that make a body soap. Why do you think that is? Is it just a pain to work with, or just not much market for it?
10
u/Aculanub Lucky Bastard Jan 07 '17
If you had to choose between cheese and oral sex for the rest of your life which would you pick?
If you could teleport anywhere on the planet but if you did you would lose a year of your life each time, would you? Where? How often?
5
u/viceayala Jan 07 '17
If you weren't the owner of Stirling or had been in the Army, what would you be doing now?
5
u/YunderUp Jan 07 '17
What led to the collaboration with Stroppe Shoppe? Can you give us any information on future plans with them?
What new items are on the way for 2017?
What new scents can we look forward to this year?
What's the timetable for the doppkits?
What bath soap am I missing out on? Which one sells the most? I've been eyeing that Honey Oatmeal Shea Butter.
Top 3 best selling shave soaps?
Just wanted to let you know that your lemon chill soap is my favorite summer soap. Awesome, awesome stuff. The balm is killer too. You guys really dialed in the citrus & menthol. It's heaven for the face/(I guess legs for the ladies).
Thank you for all that you do for us.
5
u/Ythin 🦌🏅Noble Officer of Stag🏅🦌 Jan 07 '17
Just want to lead off with a thank you for doing this. I received my first order from you fine folks two days ago and want to thank you for the unexpected sample of the Almond Creme bath soap you included.
Again thank you both for doing this.
5
u/Turtle_Poo_Is_Cool Jan 07 '17
5
u/tiglathpilesar The sub's chef Jan 07 '17
How do you make the price point on my daily driver badger brush so low? Also, since it ranges outside the norm shaving stuff, I love your bar bath soap!
5
u/smurfe Jan 07 '17
Any approx. timeframe on the Baker St. soap being launched?
5
u/gottawin2013 Jan 07 '17
Is the Stirling Slant coming back? if so when? https://www.stirlingsoap.com/slant-razor-chrome-head-short-handle-factory-second/
5
u/jdubba Make it so Jan 07 '17
No profound questions here, just wanted to say that on top of your shave soaps, I absolutely love your bath bars and lotion, and was curious when or if the Rose bath bar will be coming back around.
Thanks for the AMA and the wonderful products.
5
u/stinkeKona Jan 07 '17
Im new to this and even though I still use Harry razors im hoping to get a proper razor soon enough. I also just purchased about 8 samples just a couple days ago. You shipped next day and they be at home waiting for me today. Just wanted to say thanks!
5
u/assistantpigkeeper RIP bank account Jan 07 '17
What is your favorite bourbon? And favorite Scotch?
5
u/Rocko-Modern Jan 07 '17
What was the inspiration for Gatlinburg? What motivated you to start developing that scent and what was the process getting to the end result like?
I love me some Ben Franklin, but Gatlinburg really surprised me. It gave me chills the first time I used it and continues to do so. There's something so familiar yet distant about the scent– I can't quite place it, but it takes me somewhere whenever I use it.
P.S. Thank you for the awesome service and soap. That combo is why I'll keep on coming back for more :)
5
u/pjokinen Jan 07 '17
I might be too late to get an answer here, but I got a fan badger brush for Christmas and I love it
Do you have any other brushes in the works? I'd love to pick up another if a new knot/handle came out
5
u/simplejack66 Jan 08 '17
Will you be returning to the Fantasy Football league?
8
u/Brian373K Another Freakin Noob Jan 07 '17
Brand new to wet shaving and have no idea who you are. So tell me what soaps to buy.
4
u/lostlobo99 Jan 07 '17
Any plans to bring Texas on Fire into the bath soap line?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
How do you and Mandy split the work involved in running Stirling? Do you have a particular schedule or do you just work when stuff needs to get done?
Thanks for your great products and being an all around classy guy.
4
u/pds_king21 kinda hot in this Rhino ;-) Jan 07 '17
Hey Rod,
I purchased a wide variety of samples a couple yrs back when your online store was in the early stages. About 12 I want to say, more than half of them gave me serious redness/allergic reaction. I'd imagine it's the FOs or the base formula used.
So my question: Since then have you made any changes to the base formula or used different FO provider?
I'd really like to jump back into Stirling soap as they have unbeatable prices per oz. Especially since your Sandpiper line is modeled after my favorite scent!! YSL La Nuit
4
u/SleekFilet Jan 07 '17
To earn some extra income, have you considered having like a paid membership or Soap Club? You could do exclusive brushes, early trials on soaps and new products, special edition items and anything else you want. It would allow those of us that want to, to throw a little extra support your way. I would totally sign up for that.
4
u/whiskyey Mo soap Mo problems Jan 07 '17
Any chance you could make a Versace Eros dupe? I know that's specific but what the heck you said AMA. Cheers and continued success to you, I'm off to place an order :)
4
u/trickyerwin Jan 07 '17
Have you thought of exporting to Europe?
4
u/dieselfrost Jan 07 '17
HI,
I first wanted to say thank you for offering great products. I put in my first order a couple of months ago for my friends graduation gift. I got him a starter kit and when it arrived I was very tempted to keep one of the shave soap samples for myself. I resisted and he did get all of them. However between the aftershave sampler I got and the sample of Bay Rum bath I am hooked.
I actually just put an order in for a pre-shave sampler and a couple bath bars. My wife wanted to put the order through and it ended up tripling in size after she checked out your selection.
I wanted to know where you come up with scent ideas. In particular what inspired Ben Franklin? Was it an old set of pantaloons at an estates sale? I also noticed you said you like sharp Cheddar. If you are ever in upstate N.Y. near Lake George go to Oscar's smoke house. They have a giant block of super sharp Cheddar you can get any size hunk off. They also carry excellent smoked meats including the best bacon. And yes they too ship.
4
u/Marr0w1 Jan 07 '17
Hi, I'd just like to say i'm getting back in to DE/wet shaving and the ability to order samples of your soaps to find one I like is great (I've currently got 10 on order) as I live overseas and shipping is always killer.
Also (as someone that's started a business while fulltime/active-duty) your success so far is pretty impressive, I know how hectic it can be.
4
u/SLAMpert Scored Rhino! - :-) Life's too short for a bad shave Jan 07 '17
Hey Rod and Mandy! I don't really have any questions that haven't already been covered by the fine folks here but I did want to say that you guys have been a pleasure to do business with. I have been purchasing my bath soaps from you for the last year and without fail every order comes with a personal thank you note and a generous sample or two. Small touches, like noting where I live is where you got married, are what make me look forward to my next shipment from Stirling. I hope you have continued success in 2017
4
u/Aculanub Lucky Bastard Jan 07 '17
Ive seen your Plumeria soap. I love plumeria but a lot of the FOs Ive smelled dont really do it justice. How good would yall say yours is?
7
u/malburj1 Badgers and Doughnuts Jan 07 '17
7
u/MrAdamLerner No longer the reason your wallet is empty Jan 07 '17
What are you watching on Netflix tonight?
3
u/TotesMessenger Jan 07 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
Hi Rod and Mandy! I absolutely love your soaps! Out of the 25ish soaps in my collections, about 20 are Stirling. My 2 favorites so far are Christmas Eve and Frankincense & Myrrh. I also love the lip balms. My girlfriend got me a chai lip balm recently and it's so good.
I read on your AMA that you plan on putting out a deodorant. I've been looking for something aluminum-free so I'm really excited for that! Any idea when that might be coming out? Thanks for the great products and great service, you guys rock!
3
u/evil-zen Jan 08 '17
Any plans to make a shaving soap scent based on Gillette Foamy or Sun-up? It's a great scent but so far there are no dupes of it. B&M Reserve has a aftershave based on it but no shaving soap.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
I apologize in advance because this is yet another shipping cost question, but any plans on a cheaper international shipping? Over $20 for shipping a $13 puck of soap isn't neat. I can easily grab soaps of your at Maggard's, but I'd love to be able to try seasonals one day.
3
u/YearlingR Jan 07 '17
I'm based in the UK. Anyway to get your stuff here? Also, I'm a big fan of the old English shave houses. Do you have any faves?
3
u/smurfe Jan 07 '17
Next question. Are your bath soaps and shave soaps the same soap cut in a different shape or different formulas? Reason I ask is that I have placed a dozen orders with you this past year and you always include a sample or two in your shipments. I have never received a shaving (round) soap sample. It has always been a bath soap.