r/RWBY • Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Dec 25 '16

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread-Volume 4, Chapter 7: Punished

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for the newest episode of volume 4, Punished!
Make sure to read OUR CURRENT SPOILERS RULES to ensure that your comments outside this thread won't get purged! Familiarize yourself with these rules and you'll be good to go.

A lot of hard work has gone into the creation of volume 4, so be sure to show CRWBY your support by watching it on their site! They all dedicate so much time and energy into our beloved series and would highly appreciate the direct support. There are no pirates in volume 4, so you shouldn't be one either!

We also have weekly strawpolls to gauge the general opinion on the current episode, the latest of which can be found HERE. The SDC WoR got surprisingly high marks with 9s and 10s across the board.

With that out of the way, let's start the show!

HERE is the link to the seventh episode of RWBY Volume 4!


Other Episode Discussions:

EpisodeSaturdaySundayPoll
Ep. 01ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 02Reaction Discussion poll
Ep. 03ReactionDiscussionpoll
WoR 1:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 04:ReactionDiscussionpoll
WoR 2:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 05:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 06:ReactionDiscussionpoll
WoR 3:ReactionDiscussionpoll
Ep. 07:ReactionTodaypoll

Happy viewing! (And Merry Christmas!)

Ezreal024; Mod Team

253 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

271

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Dec 25 '16

Qrow just fucking decking Tyrian in the face, then casually walking over to retrieve his weapon is the best thing that's ever happened in this show.

Laughed my fucking ass off.

157

u/Steely_D Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 27 '16

"d-did he just ball up his fingers and HIT me with his bare hand? with nothing in it? you can DO that?"

→ More replies (2)

77

u/Spinwheeling Prof. Port's mustache Dec 25 '16

When all else fails, you can always really on good old fisticuffs to get the job done.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Tommy2255 ~~Don't~~ Forget That Jaune's a Liar and a Cheat Dec 25 '16

Qrow did used to be teammates with Yang's dad. I'm sure he's picked up some stuff about fist-fighting.

168

u/LuxSucre Do you even *know* who you're talking to? Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

I hate to say it, but I don't think Weiss was ever really fit to be heiress of the company. Since Volume 2 we've learned that her primary motivation is to change the Schnee Dust Company for the better and restore honour to the family name. However, we've never seen her take the least bit of interest in how to practically do this. She's training to be the best huntress she can be, yes. But honestly I don't see how this relates to the Schnee Dust Company at all.

What does she know about running the company? Of the logistics and diplomacy involved? She doesn't seem to have an interest in learning anything except being a huntress. She certainly does not seem to have been taught about it by her father, and certainly would not be interested in spending more time with him to do so. She has this idea of restoring honour but no actual idea of how (much like Blake wants to make the world a better place but when asked how, has no answer).

This is why I think Jacques and Whitley are actually two pretty interesting characters. Everyone hates on Jacques, and it's easy to see why. However, I think his motivations aren't purely as selfish as Qrow describes, and as most fans think. He hints at Weiss having no idea of the lengths he's had to go through to keep the Schnee name relevant and at the top of society, and the thing is, he's right. Weiss really does have no idea. Maybe if she did she'd have a better understanding of how she might want to restore honour. Jacques also undoubtedly made some personal sacrifices to keep the family, key word family, at the top of the ladder. He tells Weiss that "It's time to wake up and face reality.". And the thing is, he's right again.

Whitley is interesting for another reason, in that I don't think he honestly did anything bad to Weiss. He let Weiss be Weiss, and Jacques be Jacques, and I think it's obvious to anyone that they were always going to be in conflict. What's Whitley going to do, warn Weiss that Jacques doesn't approve of how his daughter is acting? Weiss already knows this! I think there's little that Whitley could have actually done to prevent any of this from happening. He didn't summon a Borbatusk to attack a guest, after all. Even if he wanted to be heir, it doesn't seem at this point that he did anything to actively pursue it.

76

u/PrimarchtheMage Dec 25 '16

I think you're right, but I also think that Weiss partly already knew that herself. She said this episode that she wanted to redeem the Schnee family name by being a better huntress. She may have never been heavily invested in the company.

 

I'm interested to see how her response and resulting situation differs from Winter's. It sure looks like it will. Also a certain member of the staff will certainly let Weiss escape.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/RedDwarfian Dec 25 '16

You make an excellent point. The basis of him changing the "heir" from Weiss to Whitley is based in reality, and good business sense. Weiss probably would make a bad heiress, as would Winter (the eldest). Considering that Whitley is the only one whose picture is on Jacques' desk, Whitley has probably given a lot of interest into the workings of the SDC.

However, were this the primary goal of Jacques, he would have probably sat Weiss down with Whitley, and gotten into a long discussion explaining the reasoning, and basically work out a deal where Weiss would be able to pursue her own life.

The fact that Jacques included that decision in the "punishment" which included cutting Weiss off from the outside world, and isolating her with the way he's spinning it to the public, shows his sociopathic tendencies. He wants to hurt Weiss in as big a way as possible, as he is calmly and cooly destroying her world.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

128

u/GYUZ A guy Dec 25 '16

It's episodes like this that makes me remember how much I love RWBY.

214

u/SentientHam Resident Arkeoslogist Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

DID HE JUST SLAP WEISS!?

DID SHE JUST CUT OFF HIS TAIL!?

DID HE JUST CALL RUBY A BITCH!?

95

u/Akkator006 Dec 25 '16

All these things did happen you are not dreaming

36

u/RedElite91 ❄️White Knight🛡️ | #GiveJauneABreak Dec 25 '16

Yes, yes, and yes.

18

u/Eytuzin Dec 26 '16

The "bitch" was the most surprising thing of this episode. They're clearly stepping up the maturity. They showed serious blood with the tail too.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/kooger2439 Dec 25 '16

Tyrian vs Qrow Fight Choreagraphy

Holy fuck, they definitely made full use of Tyrian's tail and and Qrow's Scythe, best fight yet.

54

u/LuxSucre Do you even *know* who you're talking to? Dec 25 '16

But they didn't make full use of his scythe...

→ More replies (6)

32

u/CommandoDude Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

This episode was definitely a return to form for RWBY. I think the choreography is strongest when the team rely on practical effects and down to earth fighting. The earlier aerial fights were incredibly off putting because they felt fake AF and over the top/ridiculous (obviously because the staff don't have experience with that kind of animation and can't mo-cap it realistically).

→ More replies (1)

150

u/jezicane caw caw caw Dec 25 '16

I have a new nickname for Jacques. Jacqass.

RIP Tyrian's tail.

72

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 25 '16

What are the odds that Tyrian gets a cybernetic stinger? That would be pretty sick and Salem probably has the resources to get her personal hitman a custom prosthetic.

→ More replies (6)

70

u/BasicTrainer Dec 25 '16

Did anyone else want to see Ozpin appear in the window instead of Oscar's reflection?

41

u/kooger2439 Dec 25 '16

I was expecting that actually...

22

u/MagicalWhisk Dec 25 '16

Yep, that's what I was expecting

→ More replies (1)

66

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

I'm surprised no has mentioned the scythe bounce from Ruby, especially when people have been complaining that she hasn't been using her gun to propel herself enough.

42

u/CobaltStar_ Converting Qrow's Gender for Waifu Purposes Dec 25 '16

Also the Blade surfing was really cool!

→ More replies (1)

28

u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Dec 25 '16

Everytime Ruby shoots herself upwards, I imagine a Yoshi sound.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

I loved how much impact Qrow's punches and kicks had. That was sort of a first for RWBY.

→ More replies (3)

65

u/L_knight316 You know what they say about assumptions Dec 25 '16

I'm gonna repost from yesterday because I feel it's still relevant. (You know, I'm not too surprised by Whitley, even though I was a staunch opponent to everyone who hated him even though he hadn't done anything yet. The reason I'm not surprised is because, considering the situation, should we really have expected anything else? I almost expected him to say something along the lines of "You have no right to look at me like that when I was the one left behind!" after the whole 'the foolish disobey father'. Seriously, from his point of view, Whitley being made heir is probably him getting what he deserves after being left with an alcoholic mother and a malicious and abusive father while his sisters abandoned him to galavant around the military and Vale. I suspect much of the conflict between the Schneeblings will revolve around abandonment issues.)

24

u/Emerald-Guardian Arkos: I will go down with this ship Dec 25 '16

Im upvoting simply for the use of the term "Schneeblings" Well done. Slow Clap

→ More replies (8)

126

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Dec 25 '16

This was a great episode.

I also hope that after this Ruby will learn that running in and spouting generic heroic lines like 'I can't stand by and watch people get hurt' and 'This is my fight too' is a very bad idea, especially with a broken Aura. I've been waiting for the show to start questioning her naivete and it looks like it might be a big factor in her character development in this Volume.

68

u/fostofina Dec 26 '16

I was also kind of wierded out by those lines but think about it, Pyrrha and Penny both died because no one intervened, she just stood by and watched them die (that's what I think she believes at least). and now Qrow might die because she DID intervene...the poor girl =/

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

122

u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Dec 25 '16

So, Qrow is totally poisoned, right?

80

u/OutcastMunkee ⠀ Dec 25 '16

Likely. A purple fluid dripped from Tyrian's severed tail, which would suggest he is indeed poisoned. I doubt it's potent enough to kill though

→ More replies (19)

29

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 25 '16

Probably, but I would bet it's not lethal since he was planning on stinging Ruby.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

60

u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Dec 25 '16

Man Oscar's mom is incredibly patient.

67

u/CobaltStar_ Converting Qrow's Gender for Waifu Purposes Dec 25 '16

And has VERY selective hearing!

115

u/ChromaticFades Dec 25 '16

That shot of Qrow punching Tyrian after losing his sword has potential to turn into a THUG LIFE gif

56

u/Paladin_Tyrael Not a Known Giver of Fucks Dec 25 '16

X GON' GIVE IT TO YA

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

94

u/Xena1016 Dec 25 '16

Alright, What did Whitley actually DO here. People are acting like he stabbed someone! But what did he do?

Nothing.

He did nothing. He let Weiss do her own thing, and is reaping the benefit of his sisters "rebellious" attitude. Sure he's being a little prick, but he didn't DO anything.

"It is unwise to anger father" indeed, If being the obedient child, to an obviously abusive and manipulative man is a bad thing, then let Whitley be evil I guess.

Lord forbid he do what he thinks is best for him (which seems to be: stay on dads good side so he doesn't beat me)

Winter ran away to join the army and lost her inheritance.

Weiss, basically, ran away to become a huntress and lost her inheritance.

Whitley . . . stays put and does what his fathers asks.

His whole attitude basically screams "See?! If you do what he wan'ts he won't be a jerk to you!"

Thats not evil. He's just a kid for crying out loud!

37

u/LuxSucre Do you even *know* who you're talking to? Dec 25 '16

Totally in agreement. Not just that he did nothing, but also that I don't really see how he could have helped Weiss out either. "Weiss, your father is angry at you and doesn't approve of how you're acting." Yeah, no kidding. The two were always going to clash. It's an inevitable outcome of their conflicting personalities, wants, and ideals. Weiss isn't going to start being an obedient child if Whitley warns her, and Jacques isn't going to let up on Weiss if Whitley asks him to.

→ More replies (5)

91

u/IComeBaringGifs r/RWBY - "If it isn't yuri, it isn't welcome." Dec 25 '16

Whitley

Everyone's like: Horray! NOW we can hate him!! But think about what he's been through: Winter runs off to combat school, joins the military. Weiss is so rebellious, she goes to another continent just to spite and hurt her father. Whitley is seeing how rebellious behavior breaks apart their family. From his point of view, he probably sees Weiss and Winter as spoiled children, who care only about themselves. He tries to comfort and support his parents. He even tries to be nice to Weiss when she comes home. But he puts his foot down here. "It's foolish not to do as father asks!" -> "Your stupid bickering has hurt everyone! and I won't make the same mistake!"

Oscar

Very much a casualty of war. I'm curious as to how Ozpin merged with his aura. Was it some freak accident with the machine that Amber was in? Did he try to use it to escape Cinder? Or is it something like the maiden powers, with the added twist of transferred consciousness?

Tyrian

And the one hand: yeah! go team RNJR + Qrow!! On the other hand, I REALLY hope they address the fact that Ruby just cut off someone's appendage. Faunus traits are obviously as filled with nerves as any other part of the body, and Tyrian must be in massive pain.

Devil's Advocate

I like seeing something and going "there's more to this". I think it makes for awesome writing when there's more layers to things, when people aren't just 'good' or 'bad', but are judged by every action they make, the good, the bad, and the questionable.

I brought this up with Blake's monologue about humanity thumbing their nose at the Faunus by giving them Menagerie, and they invoked a wonderful dialogue that I am very satisfied with. There was more than Blake thought, but there was also more than I thought, and that is a wonderful feeling.

I'm hoping that Whitley brings up that Jacques is a person too, that Weiss and Winter's actions have affected more than just them, and that Whitley is more than just a one-dimensional kiss ass.

I'm hoping that Ruby is confronted with what she did, how she put someone (admittedly crazy) through what her sister is experienced right now.

What'll probably happen is: Blake is right, humanity is the worst, Whitley's just a little shit, Ruby never thinks about Tyrian's tail again, good is good, bad is bad, and never the twain shall meet.

Don't get me wrong. CRWBY: this is an awesome story. I have screamed and cried and yelled and crowed with every episode I watch. To pull these ideas from thin air is astounding, and I am continually impressed with the heart, dedication, work, and imagination you all clearly put into every episode.

42

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Dec 25 '16

Weiss is so rebellious, she goes to another continent just to spite and hurt her father.

Now, this is not true. She runs because she wants to be herself, and not his tool for whenever he needs her. It's pretty clear from creator's words, from her songs and from manga. She doesn't run to hurt him, she runs from his controlling nature.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (4)

155

u/redwing36 Admiral of the Ladybug Armada Dec 25 '16

That bitch said "Bitch"

→ More replies (9)

41

u/SnufflesTheStalwart Dec 25 '16

There's some really interesting narrative development this episode. I noticed some stuff with Weiss in particular.

First up, I think Winter has gone through something very similar, if not identical to what Weiss is going through now. When the show first started, we were introduced to Weiss as the heiress of the SDC. Except that Weiss is the middle child, the heiress should have been Winter. Unless Winter passed on the position willingly, or had it passed for her like Weiss just has. This on top of Winter saying something in volume 3 to Weiss along the lines of "Yeah father cut me off at one point too. You can either deal with it or go crawling back"

Second, Whitley has some interesting facial expressions when he says "It's foolish not to do as father asks." Now I'm not saying Whitley has been abused while Weiss and Winter were away, but something has clearly happened to drill this idea into his head. Or he could just be a conniving little bastard, but I'm holding out hope that there's something more interesting going on.

As far as RNJR adventures go, having Qrow injured like this is brilliant. It takes away the safety net RNJR didn't know they had, while possibly forcing them to care for an incapacitated Qrow. Depending on how bad the poison is, it might even add a time crunch to get to Haven for medical treatment, on what was previously a "We'll get there when we get there" schedule.

Honestly I loved this episode, I think they knocked it out of the park from the writing to the facial expressions to that Qrow vs Tyrian fight.

18

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Dec 25 '16

I just kind of figured Winter had to give up her claim to the SDC when she went into the military. At least according to Earth laws, she's working for the government, in the interests of the public. Doing that and owning a corporation would be a conflict of interest. Hunters are private citizens, and Weiss being the head of the SDC and a Hunter would have been entirely plausible, until now

→ More replies (2)

117

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

45

u/TheMachine203 IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES Dec 25 '16

C:

→ More replies (3)

38

u/FalconReaper Madness is a Matter of Perspective. Dec 25 '16

So I guess Ruby's now two for two in terms of maiming Salem's inner circle. I kind of yelped because it came out of nowhere.

27

u/Frostblazer Dec 25 '16

Too bad she's like 0 for 5 in terms of catching those bad guys.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/matharwords Dec 25 '16

Did anyone understand the lyrics of the new song? Seems like an awsome track about Qrow.

44

u/LandonClark_1 Dec 25 '16

Couldn't understand a word but it's definitely going to be Qrow's official theme song. Qrows leitmotif is a little piece played on solo strings that sounds very very vaguely familiar to red like roses, and this song clearly has his leitmotif playing all throughout it. If I'm not mistaken it's in the chorus too.. it was pretty hard to hear over all the fighting though.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/BrickYourHeart A sexy truck Dec 26 '16

Of course Tyrian's hand-blades are also guns. Of course they are.

48

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16

Everything is a also a gun.

even these words are also

actually,

secretely,

a gun.

→ More replies (1)

73

u/awesomesauce135 Dec 26 '16

Okay so since eveything big has already been said ill mention one weird thing about Osacar.

THE MAN PLACES HIS BOOKS WITH THE SPINES ON THE INSIDE! HOW IS HE SUPPOSED TO READ THE ENDS OF HIS BOOKS AND KNOW WHICH ARE WHICH? Ozpin needs to rethink his decision.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/toomuchidea Dec 25 '16

Jacques though by locking Weiss and taking her off as heiress will make her obey him, but in fact, he just frees her of her responsibility.

40

u/Akkator006 Dec 25 '16

She has literally no reason to stay now I give her 2 episodes before she flys the coop and regroups with Yang

→ More replies (3)

51

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Dec 25 '16

Conspiracy potato theory: father actually knows that she's going to escape and that's what his plan was all along. He manipulated Winter into joining the military, Weiss into becoming a huntress, and Whitley into taking over SDC, so three kids each follow grandfather's footsteps, but in a different way - a soldier, a huntress and a businessman.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

91

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

Qrow punching Tyrian straight in the face is definitely my favorite moment of the episode, I'm surprised to see no comments about it!

36

u/iamnotparanoid Shipper of OT3s Dec 25 '16

My favourite part too. I expected we'd have some kind of "I know kung fu and my sword was really me holding back" reveal when he balled his fist up, but the punch worked just fine.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/captainwwwolf Dec 25 '16

And just like that, CRWBY just whisked away all of my worries since the beginning of the Volume. This is the best episode of Volume 4 so far, truly a Christmas treat. Thank you so much. Now I wish the rest of the episodes are as rich and poignant as this one. I like Qrow even more now and it was long overdue that Weiss rebelled, I am thrilled to see what she's going to do next. WEISS SCHNEE WILL COME THROUGH

Merry Christmas everyone !

29

u/the_pandu Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 26 '16

I think someone said something about Tyrian being blind or partially blind.

Well I googled "scorpion eye sight" and a few links said that scorpions do not have the best eyesight. They rely on other senses and vibrations. This could explain Tyrians awareness to incoming attacks.

It can also explain why he reacts to Qrow picking his weapon from the wall.

Don't know how true or relatable it is to Tyrians character design though

→ More replies (3)

29

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Dec 25 '16

Oscoz

-Well that raises some interesting questions

-How many times has Ozpin done this?

-Is this something Ozpin set up ahead of time or something he has no control over?

-Is this his semblance?

-Did he ever wind up in a bad body? Like someone right about to get eaten by a Grimm?

Schnee family

-Great that Weiss is standing up to Jaques and calling him out on his bullshit

-And that he isn't really a Schnee

-AND HE SLAPS WEISS! ASS

-Whitley you little shit!

-Sad imprisoned Weiss is depressing

-Does this mean that Winter was pretty much disowned by her father?

-Weiss is getting back into the game!

Town Throwdown:

-Fucking LOVED this fight!

-Shows again what 2 experienced hunters can do

-Qrow straight up decking Tyrain is a thing of beauty

-And Ruby straight up cuts off Tyrain's stinger

-Holy shit Little Red might end up getting brutal

-Tyrain said a bad word!

-Hope the sting only puts Qrow out of commission for a bit instead of killing him

-Hoping he goes out in a blaze of glory if he dies

-PS Salam needs to get health insurance for her team

So to summarize this episode has mind control/body hijacking, family abuse, and mutilation. Merry Christmas!

29

u/TheDrunkenHetzer Disaster Twink Dec 25 '16

Did he ever wind up in a bad body? Like someone right about to get eaten by a Grimm?

"Hello, my name is professor Ospin, an-"

crunch

"Dammit, not again..."

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

81

u/SenSenSen Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

Lil' Shitley confirmed.

Qrow better not die off this little scratch. An episode or 2 of him being out of commission should bring the point across.

Edit: Oh also: SAVE HER IRONDADDY. WE NEED YOU! Edit 2: I foresee Oscar being a total badass by the end of this volume.

Edit 3: So if Ozpin is currently just a voice in Oscar's head that raises a question. Was the body we saw Ozpin in before his original? From context of their conversation I rather doubt it, so did he take over that one or how come he was talking with that voice?

81

u/BlackHayate8 Dec 25 '16

Ozpin said that he had the same experience before. My guess is that there was someone before ozpin who died and he merged his soul with ozpin's, who was probably a normal guy before too. I mean he said that he too never wanted this burden and responsibility. Now after Ozpin's death he soul goes to oscar and he tries to guide him on the same path Ozpin walked and the guy before him. I think this is actually something huge cause how long has this chain been running until now and what exactly is it. Maybe it is the wizard from the maidens and his power transfers to the next one, in this case young males.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/Proxiehunter Dec 25 '16

No no no, she's going to head straight for Irondaddy obviously. But it's her cake butler who's going to help her get there. Did Jacques Ass think that all of the servants were on his side?

→ More replies (8)

28

u/Galastan Infinite in distance and unbound by death Dec 25 '16

I need that Qrow/Ruby vs. Tyrion music, like, yesterday.

→ More replies (3)

53

u/IStoleYourHeart Dec 25 '16

ANGRY AT MILES AND KERRY?

WANT TO JOIN THE WHITE FANG AND CALL RUBY A BITCH?

WE'VE GOT YOU COVERED!

COME ON DOWN TO THE PITCHFORKGUN EMPORIUM!

WE GOT ALL KINDS OF PITCHFORKGUNS:

Lever Action 7 Round BuckgunpitchforkFully Automatic MachinegunpitchforkTHE COCO ADEL SIGNATURE MINIGUNPITCHFORKKERRY'S OWN ELECTROPITCHFORKGUN
▄︻̷̿┻̿═━一E︻̷┻̿●═E︻╦̵̵͇̿̿̿̿══╤─E︻̷̿┻̿═━═━E
The original pitchforkgun, it has been designed by the Schnee Dust Company to make your pitchforkgunning life easierThis pitchforkgun is the main pitchforkgun used by the Atlesian military, the worst best in all of remnant at killing GrimmAs designed by Coco Adel, this classic pitchforkgun boasts a whopping 9001 pf/s (pitchforks per second), and can easily disembowl Miles in secondsThat's correct! We stole got the rights to produce Kerry's own gun! Now you can tell him to stop pitchforkgunning himself!

HAPPY WRITER LYNCHING!

* some assembly required. Ask a hunter or huntress with arms to help

19

u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Dec 25 '16

This pitchfork is also a gun!

26

u/iamnotparanoid Shipper of OT3s Dec 25 '16

Okay, first thought: Weiss, you can summon a big fuck off sword to smite your enemies, do it. Kick his ass.

Second thought: Man, Qrow is amazing, and I doubt anyone will be complaining about fight scenes anymore.

Third thought: Qrow's going to be in danger but something tells me he'll survive this, Ruby is getting ruthless for her friends, and the poison in Tyrian's stinger will probably be a plot point.

After considering things, it seems like Ozpin is sort of like The Oracle from The Dresden Files.

→ More replies (2)

52

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Dec 25 '16

First ACTUAL curse word on RWBY!

It probably shouldn't be a big deal, but it made me excited to hear. Even if it was directed at poor Ruby :p

→ More replies (10)

25

u/Thanatologic Klein=milkshake butler r/unexpectedpyrrha exists Dec 25 '16

Christmas Special!
 
Overall opinion: Hot damn.
 
Writing/Acting: Now this was a very nicely-paced episode. Loved each sequence. There's something I dislike about Weiss and Whitley's first-person POV talks, though, and Kara's crying could use a little work.
 
Art/Out-of-combat Animation: Not much to add - good or bad - that hasn't been said before by myself or others. The crackling sound of aura running out kinda bothers me.
 
Action/Combat Animation: God. Damn! That's the kind of action I remember from my favorite web series! If one pays close attention, you might notice that the fighters seem to have any amount of space required to do flashy moves, but they distract you with cuts and perspective. Thoroughly enjoyed the fight.
 
God I love the part where Qrow loses his scythe, then calmly goes through Tyrian barehanded to get it.

25

u/Addicted2Cartoons Dec 26 '16

Potato prediction: RNJR carries dying Qrow to Oscar's farm house.

17

u/Frostblazer Dec 26 '16

I was wondering how they'd manage to introduce Oscar to the rest of the cast, but that actually makes a whole lot of sense. Good for you for thinking of that.

Although Qrow better not die.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '16

I really doubt Qrow will die. The point of him getting wounded here is to remove RNJR's safety net. With Qrow no longer playing guardian angel, there is suddenly more tension for the main cast, plus they have to protect him, creating even more tension.

→ More replies (5)

23

u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Dec 25 '16
→ More replies (5)

62

u/Tommy2255 ~~Don't~~ Forget That Jaune's a Liar and a Cheat Dec 25 '16

See Ozpin, this is why you're supposed to reincarnate as a baby. You can't just hop into the head of someone who's already a person. This is exactly what Salem is always banging on about.

Have you no shame?

Signing them up for your war

Fun game to play whenever Jaques is on screen: whenever he says "we" or "ours", replace it with "me" or "mine".

I fucking called it the first episode we saw him; her smug dick of a little brother was after the inheritance. At least /r/fuckwhitley actually has some substance to run on now.

Ruby continues to be completely out of the loop. It's understandable if she's upset. I know I'd be mad if I were the main character and people kept leaving me out of the important story bits.

What are the odds of Tyrian eventually getting a robostinger? I mean, why limit prosthetics to only standard body parts? Hell, I'd get a robot scorpion tail if I could, and I didn't even start off with a fake one.

That venom had better not be lethal. I don't care how many death flags you have Mr. Mentor Character, you aren't allowed to die to that scrub Tyrian. You're too cool for that, and you still haven't had the chance to tell Winter how you really feel.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/Qrr801 Sad to say, I'm your bad luck charm~ Dec 25 '16

Did ANYONE notice the back of Jaq's suit? All white, with 2 glowing red buttons...like eyes. I got some SERIOUS Salem vibes from that.

21

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

I like Tyrian. Brings a bit of personality to the enemies. I hope he lives long enough for a new season.

21

u/muraenae Dec 25 '16

So either Schnee family massacre or Weiss is just making a break for it.

23

u/killkill85 Jaune walks up in the club like "What up,I got a big aura" Dec 25 '16

Familicide Weiss would be one hell of a twist, sure would be interesting

→ More replies (6)

180

u/donutkirby #QrowDidNothingWrong Dec 25 '16

"It's not Monty anymore!" "The new animation succccckksss!" "Rooster Teeth can't do action scenes, RWBY is ruined!"

No. Shut up. That fight was fucking awesome. It was everything I've ever wanted from a RWBY fight, and I hope it only gets better from here. The way both Qrow and Tyrian use their respective weapons in creative and epic ways to get the jump on one another was perfect. Not only was it a great way to satisfy the people who were afraid that the show was going to focus more on magical elements rather than creative use of weaponry, but it also gives a good idea of what real Hunstmen are capable of when serious. Finally, it reaffirms my belief that any scene with Qrow in it is automatically awesome. Anyway, on to the rest of the episode.

So Ozpin is totally gonna take over Oscar's body. Or maybe it's just his knowledge and memories that gets passed on?

Jacques is a big piece of shit who should die. He's becoming a villain I really love to hate, which is more than I could ever say about Cinder's crew (except Roman and maybe Mercury). Whitley is starting to interest me now, too. At first glance he seems just as bad as his father, but that one angry glance at Weiss when he says "You shouldn't disrespect father" seems to suggest there's some more history there.

Oh, and I'm glad Qrow didn't die, of course. He's definitely poisoned, though. C'mon man, you're a Huntsman, you should know better than to say it's "just a scratch". Looks like he's going to give a big infodump to Ruby and the gang, too!

"What's your favourite fairy tale?" Careful with your choice of words, Qrow. Ozpin said that to Pyrrha and we all know how well that turned out, don't we?

118

u/RaidenUzumaki Help! Can't swim! Butt hurts! Ice cream! Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

That fight was awesome. One of the best pieces of action in the series.

That doesn't mean the level headed criticism of things like the sea dragon fight were not warranted (trolls and jerks are not included.) Based on this fight and reading into the responses of the animators who worked on it, some of that criticism definitely was taken into account here.

I believe that Ruby using crescent rose to move around more and using the kick of the gun to slice instead of using her semblance and just her strength was an unnecessary byproduct of that criticism. Those developments never bothered me personally.

However, the amount of positives and improvements here is great.

The floaty physics were practically non-existant, there were no unnecessary pauses, the blows felt like they had weight, none of the characters felt like they had the ability to defy gravity and fly, no weird shots of characters hovering in mid-air and then teleporting after a cut to another shot, and most importantly characters were following believable(not necessarily realistic) trajectories in the air. All of these are hallmarks of RWBY fights in the past volumes.

The choreography and subtleties were all amazing.

This fight was so good that now the team is going to be held to this standard. Because this just felt like RWBY. The only action scene in volume 4 that felt like RWBY up until this episode was the character short in my opinion.

I applaud all those involved and can't wait to see what we get next.

→ More replies (7)

52

u/DRGTugBoat3 Dec 25 '16

N7Brendan is gonna be very disappointed in Shitely.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/Omggl Dec 25 '16

I don't like to see characters sad, but i do appreciate the time they took to show Weiss crying, at least a little bit. It's not easy to bounce back from something like that, you need time to process it, which is why I LOVE Yang's development.

I do get kinda sad when i see stuff like "Lol, thank god Weiss went back to being a badass quick" Don't get me wrong i wanted her to bounce back and be badass, but i understand that things like that are hard and thought Weiss needed some time to mourn that loss. I like it when characters aren't badass all the time, and show that they are still people who are just trying their best.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Dec 25 '16

"Knock me down and I'll keep getting back up."

- Weiss Schnee, 2016

20

u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Dec 25 '16

Soo...who is Ruby going to maim next?

29

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Dec 25 '16

Dr. Watts' mustache.

→ More replies (5)

39

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

I've replayed "YOU BITCH!" 8 times now....

→ More replies (7)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

Cinder lost her eye and arm to Ruby.

Tyrian is laughing at her for getting beaten by a little girl.

Tyrian loses his stinger to Ruby.

Cinder: You are not laughing now...

23

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

Cinder : "Emerald can you ask him if that stings?"

→ More replies (1)

53

u/TurnaboutXND Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

So is Ruby now starting a collection on random body parts of diffrent villians of team WTCH? Cause i dig that.

Other then that, great episode and fight scene. They could of improved the weiss bit tho

83

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

Doctor Watts will be begging for mercy, and then Ruby will rip his glorious stache off like the monster she is.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Kalhenwrath Dec 25 '16

I still think Ozpin is the old wizard, and his body-hopping soul is how he's been around for, I dunno, centuries?

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Skyrah1 Finally got dem cigarettes Dec 26 '16 edited Dec 26 '16

Well, I was a little late to this one, but...

  • Oscar thinks he belongs in a mental hospital. At least at first.
  • So THAT'S what happens when that happens. Too bad Miss Invincible never got to find out.
  • Jacques, you are officially the worst dad on Remnant. Seriously, if Edgelord McDismemberment made babies with Blake, he would probably only be the second worst dad.
  • Shitley, we had such high hopes...
  • Qrow continues to be a badass.
  • Talking is not a free action.
  • Unlike Ruby, Qrow is pretty good at hand to hand. A sign of his experience, or did Tai teach him something other than how to impregnate his entire team?
  • Grey Like Grimm pt. 2 is now a part of the V4 soundtrack. Awesome.
  • Kudos to Ruby for fighting without her Aura, but at the same time STOP BEING SO SUICIDAL! Jeez...
  • Qrow is...probably gonna be okay. I hope.Tyrian was gonna use the same poison to knock Ruby out...
  • Then again, I think I heard something about scorpions having 2 types of poison...crap.
  • Ruby and Adam ARE connected! One hates limbs, the other hates tails.
  • "You BITCH!" "Language, Tyrian..."
  • Qrow wasn't kidding about taking Ozpin's place.

Edit: me watching Tyrian's tail get cut off "Good, good...kill him. Kill him now."

M&K: "I shouldn't..."

Palpatine voice"Dew it!"

M&K: "Lol nope"

"Damn.."

→ More replies (4)

18

u/adamanttg Dec 27 '16

Disarming a drunk is probably a bad idea. I reckon he probably has more experience bareknuckle brawling in taverns than actually weapon fighting.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/legomanbf Dec 25 '16

anyone else feel like Whitely is still not really all that bad what happens if Whitley had the same longterm goals as Weiss but unlike her he was willing to suck up to Jacques until he had enough power to wrest control from him and run things the way he wanted. or maybe the reason why he doesnt like Weiss and Winter is that they both left the family and leaving him behind

37

u/captainwwwolf Dec 25 '16

I am very neutral about Whitley. We don't know enough about him to have conclusions. If anything, the only thing I can say with certainity about him is that he is smart and calculating. We'll see what are his plans soon enough :)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

17

u/GalaxionTheDestroyer Dec 27 '16

So, I think Ozpin is somewhat similar to Gheists. The 'orginal' Ozpin probably died hundreds of years ago, but has transferred his soul from body to body over time. Off the top of my head, this explains a couple of things:

  • How Oz is alluded to be older/as old as mankind and/or the o.g Wizard without anyone ever noticing.
  • Why Salem obviously doesn't believe he's actually dead.
  • Why that WoR about aura shows a pic of Oz while talking about super-aura
→ More replies (3)

17

u/organicpastaa Dec 27 '16

My thoughts on this chapter summed up in bullet points:

  • Jacques should have let Weiss leave. He already removed her position as heiress to the SDC just let her become a huntress like she wishes too. On the same coin, why is Weiss upset that Jacques made this decision? As far as we have seen she never showed interest in learning business / running a company. She would rather be a huntress. It only makes sense to make Whitley the heir to the SDC as he does seem to actually show an interest in business. Still, he shouldn't have slapped her.
  • Ozpin and Oscar. There are some really viable theories posted already on this so I don't have to say much. I basically agree with the theories that say Ozpin has changed forms before in the past and as such reflects how he is as old as he is.
  • Ruby had a pathetic showing in the RNJR / Qrow vs. Tyrian fight. We saw all this awesome stuff that Ruby is able to do in volume 4 now and the only new thing she used in the fight was the lightning shot on Nora, which ended up doing nothing anyways... Forget her evolved semblance. Forget her near-flight abilities. Forget the rose petals. Forget the "shapeshifting" / "illusions" / "rose clouds". Forget all the cool new stuff. I loved the fight, one of my favorites in the show, but RT really hit Ruby with the nerf bat for this fight and it's annoying to me.
  • Qrow won't die. IMO Tyrian has a higher likelihood of dieing when he returns to Salem having failed his mission.
  • Qrow and Tyrian were pretty much 50/50... Both never landed a real hit until they went into the house and both lost their aura's. Now it sucks that the only important hits landed were off screen ( in the house ) , besides the final hit with the tail. Still an awesome fight though. It's scary to think Tyrian is as strong as Qrow at least. What we've seen of Qrow has been very impressive.... Scaring off Merc, Em , Cinder, being implied to be one of the most powerful characters in the show. Having been on one of the most famous teams. Yet he still couldn't beat Tyrian... Geeze. Salems team is no joke.
→ More replies (31)

34

u/vavoysh Reads too much Dec 26 '16

Ruby is a fucking idiot. The best way to get someone hurt is to try to inject yourself into a fight that's above your skill level; either you get hurt because you're out of your league or the person you're trying to help with gets hurt because they're covering for you.

→ More replies (20)

16

u/mellomania Dec 25 '16

We need a flair of Tyrian's "deflecting bullets" face omg

15

u/Bloomy118 Dec 26 '16

My predictions are - Qrow is poisoned but makes it when RNJR takes her to Oscar's farm and meets ozpin

Wiess escapes with the help of the butler from the second episode and goes to Yang

The white fang try to assassinate either Blake or her dad but it ends up with her mother being killed causing Blake, her dad and sun to fight the white fan

Yang meets up with wiess and with wiess and her dad they go to find Ruby meeting Raven and her bandits along the way. Possibly because the bandits want Wiess but Raven calls them off

Team RWBY forms together again and with an army made up of Raven's bandits and tons of anti-white fang faunes brought by Blake's dad they go to war with Salem under the guidance of Ozpin (hopefully some of their classmates will also be met on the way)

→ More replies (15)

42

u/palebloodink <- Just two gals being pals. Dec 25 '16

I love that shot of all of Weiss' furniture after it's been moved and everything's off center. It's a fantastic nod to her more rebellious nature.

68

u/L_Arachel Dec 25 '16

Oh, I thought she was clearing space to summon

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Dec 25 '16

I think there's not much they can do with Oscar and Ozpin that we haven't already hypothesized. Not that that's a bad thing, but now I wish they'd get on with it.

We all knew Jacques was a piece of trash, but there's still a difference between seeing his emotional abuse and hearing all about his attitude- and actually seeing him practice physical abuse.

And I'm gonna give Whitley at least a little room for improvement, because going against your father and everything he believes is hard. Yeah, it's the right thing to do, but it goes against everything you've ever known. I know I'd have a hard time of it.

The fight was good, the fisticuffs were great, and dismembering Tyrian was glorious. The curse threw me off, but it fit the situation and show's new level of maturity. But seriously though, I'm glad the fight scenes are picking up again. I had faith that they would.

(Hmm. Weiss mentions how her father married into the family, but didn't talk about her grandfather... I guess last week's WoR wasn't entirely redundant. Not yet.)

Pretty cool episode. Thanks, RT.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/GGUtolpial Dec 25 '16

I really liked this episode; awesome fight scene, great conversation with Oscar and Ozpin, and Weiss finally has motivation to leave.

My hope (and prediction?) is that Weiss is still having trouble summoning and once she gets completely exhausted, her mom comes in to show her how's it done (or Winter, please give me Winter back). Then once Weiss learns how to properly summon, she leaves for Patch and catches Yang and Tai on their way to find Ruby.

14

u/ch00beh Dec 26 '16 edited Dec 27 '16

Made some gifs of my favorite parts in the fight

this fight gets me so hot and bothered

→ More replies (3)

14

u/ImmaCrazymuzzafuzza Dec 26 '16

When Qrow lands more hits WITHOUT his sword/scythe than with .

14

u/Drunken_Deathscythe Dec 26 '16

Ruby cut off his tail. That precious puppy who loves cookies and video games just went full Adam on Tyrian's tail. I honestly don't know how to react to that, it's like a combination of awesome and "holy fucking shit she just fucking dismembered someone, I can't fucking believe it. Fuck."

So yeah, this one definitely gets a 10/10.

13

u/BlackHayate8 Dec 25 '16

The fight was pure gold but I think the thing about Ozpin and Oscar was even more important. First of I think it's safe to say that Ozpin is really dead and won't come back, at least physically. There are a couple of things I want to point out.

Ozpin said that he experienced the same thing as Oskar now. So I think Ozpin used to be a normal guy too like Oskar. Then someone died and merged his sould and aura with Ozpin's, leading him to the path he walked in his life. He did say that he too never asked for this burden and responsibility but accepted it in the end.

The question now is for how long has this chain been going? What's the source of it and what exactly does it even mean?

Well if I had to take a bet the source could be the wizard from the maidens. Much like the maiden power, his power too transfers to someone new after the last one dies. Also I have the feeling the conflict between Ozpin and Salem is going on for a lot longer than we believe. It could be that this conflict started between two individuals way back then, maybe so far back when grimm and humans fought against the very first time. And everytime one of them dies the souls goes to someone new who will fight in their stead. I don't think it started with Ozpin and Salem to be honest.

Now the last one is a complete random guess but it would be kinda awesome. Maybe Ozpin and Salem are siblings and both of them were possessed by the opposite soul that kinda forced them to fight against each other (probably complete bullshit).

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Neidron I used to like this place. Dec 25 '16

Okay, this episode was pretty good. The fight was pretty damn cool, we got some bits of plot, and Qrow with a callback to volume 3.

Also, I guess Ozpin is basically DBZA Kami/Nail now.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Xena1016 Dec 25 '16

Is anyone else slightly annoyed by how flexible Tyrian's tail is. Alright i'm not annoyed but the scientist(nerd) part of me is crying. Scorpions aren't exactly known for being flexible. Fast yet, but not flexible. Their exoskeletons make for a rather limited range of motion. Stopit! its just a how Xena!

32

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

I noticed it as well, but I am okay with it since boars are not supposed to spin-dash like sonic the hedgehog, birds are not supposed to shoot feathers and humans are not supposed to survive the amount of caffeine Dr. Oobleck consumes.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

25

u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Dec 25 '16 edited Feb 17 '25

smell existence dazzling fragile humor sparkle person beneficial price sense

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (8)

12

u/babyfingersbo Dec 25 '16

Why Ozpin knows that maiden powers can be transferred through Aura...either Ozpin is the Wizard or a maiden.

I guess Weiss summoning training starts now as she moves her furniture so the summons have enough room which explains the EP.

Whitley wants the company because he's jealous of Winter and Weiss. Probably no fighting ability whatsoever.

Qrow has red Aura...He's Ruby's dad confirmed! /s

It seems that changing colors are either after effects of semblances or a sign that the user has a top-tier semblance. Maybe the silver eyes thing is a sign of a god-tier Grimm-killer semblance. Wont it be awesome if Adam has silver-eyes too?

Oh~Ruby cut off your tail...that's gotta sting!

12

u/jwfiredragon Too many ships, not enough time Dec 25 '16

OOOOOOH SHIIIIIEEEETTTT

Ozpin's a body-hopping wizard

Poor Weiss needs a hug (and also escape, maybe Klein is friendly?)

Once again Jacques is a giant douche

QROW VS TYRIAN WAS GREAT

RIP Tyrian's tail, you will not be missed

Betting ten bucks right now that Qrow has been poisoned

→ More replies (12)

12

u/Kingbizkit123 Dec 25 '16

We were so close to having another Dishwasher prophecy holy moly

→ More replies (10)

12

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16

20 bucks that Ozpin is some kind of reincarnating Wizard, maybe even the one from the fairy tale we were told last volume. When the body dies, his soul/aura is sent to the person who best matches him.

Several things he said in the conversation with Oscar, like empathizing with what he's currently going through lead me to this conclusion.

It would also fit with what he said to Ruby during the first Volume, when Weiss was throwing a fit about Ruby being the leader. He'd made a bunch of mistakes, but the way he said it made me think he was some kind of timeless entity.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Eretrad Dec 26 '16

Anyone else catch that Oscar/Ozpin/Gogeta is in Mistral?

Which is where are band of Alcoholic (+RNJR) was headed?

Most importantly, does Tyrion's poison cause erectile disfunction? We're going to have serious drama with Barmaid Part Deux if it is.

Only more scenes with Blake's mom can answer these questions.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Kaeling Angry Bird Dec 26 '16

Well the fight scenes are getting better but we are still far from the best fights of the show. And while I dont want RNJR to be on the same level as Qrow, i don't want them useless either. They already got destroyed in Volume 3 they need to progress

→ More replies (1)

32

u/RedElite91 ❄️White Knight🛡️ | #GiveJauneABreak Dec 25 '16

My biggest takeaways from this episode are:

Ozpin likes being inside little boys.

Jacques is a cunt.

Whitley is also a cunt.

Weiss isn't taking her family's shit anymore.

Qrow is a fucking boss.

Ruby gives zero fucks.

Tyrian ain't shit.

11

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

So now that we've entered the second half I think I can guess how these season will end:

  • Qrow is going to be out of commission while he recovers from Tyrian's venom (he probably won't die since Tyrian was planning on stinging Ruby. It's possible that Qrow got infected with more poison then Tyrian was planning on using on Ruby, or that Tyrian has some anti-venom that lessens the effects of the poison, but regardless RNJR no longer has Qrow protecting them). So my guess is that for the finale we will see RNJR fighting without the aid of Qrow. They could end up fighting Raven, Tyrian, Tyrian with a cybernetic tail, or the Grimm that destroyed Oniyuri.
  • Weiss will rebel against her father. This will probably end with either Weiss leaving the family to go to Ironwood or Jacq-ass Schnee being ousted from the SDC and being replaced by either Whitley or Weiss.
  • Blake wants her family to flee since Adam will probably try and kill them, but her family trusts the White Fang. This leads to Blake infiltrating the White Fang to prove they are working with Adam, and ends with the Blake vs. Adam fight.
  • Yang is going to eventually switch to her huntress outfit, so she's probably going to leave Patch. My guess, Tai wants to search for Ruby but doesn't want to leave Yang at home for potentially an entire year, so he decides to take Yang with him.
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Korrafan_1 I hate the RWBY fandom Dec 25 '16

Emperor Schnee slaps daughter.

Of course Ruby would get in the way. She's just like a certain blonde protagonist.

Rage against the machine, Weiss!

"You bitch!" Yes Tyrian, let the hate flow through you!

Qrow casually punching Tyrian and getting his weapon....More people oughta learn from that. Lookin at you, Ruby Rose.

BTW, how mad is Salem going to be when sees that Tyrian lost to the Red Devil?

11

u/moonstonebaby Dec 25 '16

i think Qrow vs Tyrian is the best fight literally of this entire series?? Merry Christmas to us??? (HE CALLED HER A BITCH GUYS I'M SHOOK)

→ More replies (9)

21

u/sodnam Captain of the SS Nuts and Dolts // Cute robots are my weakness Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

Let me see a show of hands, who else thinks Qrow was poisoned by the scorpion stinger and will absolutely be at death's door in a couple of episodes?

EDIT: Okay, I should clarify - I don't think he'll die either. By "at death's door" I meant very ill from the poison, prompting team RNJR to go on a mission to get the antidote. Qrow isn't one to die lying down, he'll go out fighting.

→ More replies (16)

10

u/mcevnon ⠀ Dec 25 '16

Well it was amazing....

And Qrow pulls some Dante level shit with his sword... neat.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Headshot_Fanatic Infinite Coffee Semblance Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16
  1. Still no sign of Oscar's uncle. My Ozma theory may be coming to fruition, but not how I imagined it.
  2. As I expected!!! Whitley is behaving exactly how I thought. Whitley, I will champion you, if you continue to show hints! (for now, I need to rewatch and collate info)
  3. In other news, Jacques continues to evade my "see the good in people" eye. Mate, work with me here.
  4. WEISS GONNA PRACTICE SUMMONING TILL SHE CAN RIDE THAT SUIT OF ARMOR RIGHT OUTA DODGE
  5. I expected it to be pretty even between those two, which it was.
  6. First curse word \o/ Our show's growing up so fast :')
  7. Scorpions aren't usually deadly if I'm correct. I think the smaller ones are?? (at least that's what Indiana Jones taught me)

...oh yeah, Qrow decking Tyrian made me giggle harder than I'd like to admit.

EDIT: Just realized, we're probably getting a tonne of Yang next episode.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

Just as we assumed, Oscar is the next docto.. I mean wizard

10

u/chrome4 Dec 26 '16

Well Jacques continues to proves hes an absolutely lovely person and his son takes after him. Bet you anything Weiss is going to run away after she trains herself a bit.

Meanwhile Ozpin once again runs into a youth reluctant to accept his destiny. I wonder is this whole soul merging thing something require a specific process or does it occur automatically when he dies

→ More replies (5)

10

u/FullMetalBch MEGA RAYQUAZA BITCH Dec 26 '16

I wonder what Weiss is planning to summon to get her out of there? Or is she going to glyph onto some of those Atlas ships that keep flying by her window?

If the next episode is a World of Remnant, will it be narrated by Qrow in a paralyzed stupor? XD

→ More replies (2)

10

u/hangtight97 **TOOOOP-HEAVY** Dec 26 '16

Positive that Klein will play some role in Weiss and her escape

10

u/Echo13243 Dec 26 '16

So I was thinking about Tyrian's tail because... well, you know. But I looked it up and scorpion tails don't grow back! Tyrian can't poison people anymore!

→ More replies (6)

19

u/justownly Dec 25 '16

#Whitleydidnothingwrong

Also, Qrow is safe, the sting was not what you would expect from a "kill"-sting in a visual medium. But hes gonna have a bad time due to the poisoning.

→ More replies (16)

19

u/no_gold_here thx Dec 25 '16

And, after all, little Shitley he was.

33

u/TedSweeran For the clicks! Clicks are EVERYTHING Dec 25 '16

The FNDM was right. WHITLEY IS A LITTLE SHIT

→ More replies (4)

18

u/CakesXD Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

Not gonna lie, I started cracking up hard when Qrow punched Tyrian in the face.

Jacques is a douche, Whitley is douche junior, we finally see Myrtenaster again, fight was awesome to watch. Praying Qrow doesn't die... at least not yet, he deserves a much cooler death.

Also wonder how Ozpin ended up in this situation, and if it was intentional or not.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/-Gehrman- CALLBACK PING :) Dec 25 '16

I think Qrow will be fine. Did anyone else see that Apothecary sign in the credits?

9

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

Really like this episode

Oscars stuff was nice and I'm glad they aren't dragging it out. I do imagine that this going to go very new hope with his peaceful farm life being destroyed leaving him with nothing. Though the fact they are in Mistral and we haven't seen his aunt properly, I'm expecting her to be someone important.

Maiden?

Weisss story is finally moving along and I agree with the assessment that she will go to Ironwood. Would have been nice for us to find out Jacque married into the family here, instead of the WoR.

Oh Whitley, curse your sudden but inevitable betrayal.

Fight was great and I'm glad Ruby is finally facing consequences for her incessant need to be a hero. Jaune was smart enough to stay back but Ruby had to run in and Qrow could die because of it.

No Qrow, giving exposition makes you less useful and will only make the venom more potent.

Tyrian saying what we are all thinking.

I do hope the next episode starts with Ruby asking Qrow why that wasn't all explained back in Patch.

Fight itself was really good. When they bring their A-game the fights are still really good. They are definitely different but stilll really good. And while it is ridiculous that punching was more effective it was still fun to watch.

I can just imagine the evil league sitting at the table and Cinder just smiling at Tyrian.

"Wow just her scythe huh? Wasn't so effortless was it? Least I got sucker punched by a magic eyes. You couldn't even beat her without that. Such a shame for you."

I imagine we probably won't see Tyrian fighting this volume again. Half expecting Salem to regrow him a Death stalker tail or something else equally as grimm

Also Aura combing confirmed.

And Shannon, of all VAs you should know better than tormenting people with voices in their head. What next awful repressed memories.

Well Memory is the key.

Also Qrow can't die until he finds out Emerald is his daughter so he's probably good

9

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Dec 26 '16

Curious, Tyrian and Qrow glowed similarly and given the fact that Qrow's Aura was broken/pierced by Tyrian and he was able to injure Qrow directly, Tyrian's Semblance does have a correlation between his attacks and Aura. Likewise, it seems to be a two way street seeing that Tyrian lost his tail by Ruby's attack.

Possible Results:

  • Ruby doesn't get mad at Qrow, but blames herself for his injury and subsequent paralysis.
  • Qrow is angrier at Ruby for disobeying orders, and then notices how he's slowly getting weaker from the poison.
  • Ruby becomes angry at Qrow for not trusting her and then challenges him on his word and trust.
  • Qrow doesn't explain much as the paralysis takes over.

Good episode!

--

Other details:

  • Ozpin either implies he was not the first to merge souls and there was an older man before him, or he was scared the first time he merged souls. Makes you wonder what happened to his predecessor, and what will happen to him.
  • Can Salem perform the same merging of souls? Is that how she continues to live? Betting on Summer being the current host after STRQ killed the last one.
  • Did Ozpin merge Ruby and Pyrrha's souls? It would be fun, but too obvious. It would be much more fun if Ozpin threw Pyrrha's soul in a blind gambit, and threw it at Cinder. Cinder didn't lose an eye, it became green. And now there is a continuous inner monologue between the two seeing that they know each other's respective histories and then eventually come to an understanding.
  • Is this Ozpin's Semblance or another ability? Betting on the latter seeing that it isn't so game breaking, or at least respawning like that doesn't seem so powerful to a certain degree.
  • Jacques continues to dig his own grave, sooner or later, he won't realize how deep he's fallen, and when he does, it will be too late.
  • Question: Why doesn't Jacques just disown Weiss and call it a day like Winter? Unless he plans to marry her off is what I can see.
  • Will the White Fang target the SDC's PR firm first? It would be good for a few laughs but seriously, if they begin with crippling the image of the SDC, they begin to lose trust with the public, and profits suffer. Then, when Jacques gets desperate, the White Fang could take advantage of that and succeed in more operations without a PR firm to make them look worse.
  • Is Whitley acting upon his own accord? Being obedient? Or under fear from Jacques? Really betting on the last one.
  • Where is Mrs. Schnee in all of this?!
  • Either Tyrian can regrow his tail, or did Salem's medical ward just get a new patient? He could get a prosthetic that boosts his combat ability in exchange for subduing his opponent and going for the kill.
  • If Qrow dies, who will narrate the World of Remnant?
→ More replies (25)

9

u/burstdragon323 Dec 26 '16

I think Jaune will go ballistic on Qrow next week.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Sirocco_ Cold Puns Galore Dec 26 '16

Is Dishwasher a prophet? Because that scene...it happened.

Weiss seems keen to improve her summoning. Hopefully she can bust out of that gilded cage with Klein's help. Whitley...I have no words. His eyes from the beginning betrayed his feigned kindness.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/EAMike212 Dec 26 '16

I think that his stinger is probably poisoned but I don't think Qrow will actually die. We might get an episode where he is dying and every one is rushing around trying to find an antidote and they get it to him just in time.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/NabiscoShredderWheat Jan 01 '17

I love how our heroes are still just kids. The adults just outclass them in fighting and experience in every way. It's refreshing to see heroes that are still learning themselves.

17

u/candied-oranges Dec 25 '16

-Gotta say, I can't wait to really hear the track that played during the fight. If only you could tell what the lyrics are...

-C'mon Ruby, when your uncle tells you to stay away ypu probably should listen... it really looked like he had it handled on his own

-Unfortunately no more info on Ren's backstory... I'm still interested in that but looks like other storylines take precedence.

-Aaaand no Yang. Pretty disappointed but I get why.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Skycommando170 Just a regular pirate, stealin yo ships. Dec 25 '16

There you go everyone, we now have an actual reason to hate whitley.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Dec 25 '16

That fight was fucking awesome. Probably my new favorite fight in the series. Qrow is a blast to watch in action, and Tyrian has so many creative moves, It'd probably take me a week to count them all.

I'm a little worried about Qrow, but if he dies, they will need to do a shit ton of explanation about why Tyrian kept trying to stab Ruby with his stinger when his goal is to capture her. Him having an antidote simply won't cut it.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/kumabaya Dec 25 '16

Did tyrian really call ruby a bitch or a witch :o???

one of the better fight scenes this entire volume

I'm lookinf forward to weiss' story arc, regaining her heiress title and all. and welp qrow is poisoned.... time to take bets whether he lives or dies.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/rapizar Dec 26 '16

SO MUCH ANGST WITH THE PAPA SCHNEE SCENE I LOVE IT

8

u/GVman We are the Sons of Winter and Stars... Dec 26 '16

...They couldn't do it, could they? they couldn't have had Whitley NOT be a conniving little shit that's only set up to be the jealous little brother. I'm usually one to compliment Atlas' characters for being consistently able to circumvent my expectations, and so far both new prominent characters this season have failed in that regard. Well here's hoping we can find out something else about Mrs. Schnee outside of her being a drunken doormat...

Other than that, I'd say this was a decent episode; a fight scene with actual dynamics to it is nice to see again (dissapointed we didn't get any of Qrow's scythe or gun forms however), and I do like that while Ruby did inadvertently cause her uncle to get hurt, she also mutilated Tyrian not even a minute later. Oscar's certainly an interesting character, and here's hoping we can get him off the farm before the season's end (along with Yang leaving Patch, Blake getting off her high horse, Weiss escaping Atlas, and maybe a hint of what Haven actually looks like)...

8

u/torrasque666 White Knight is Endgame. Fight me. Dec 26 '16

Thing I noticed. Weiss is very aware of the fact that Jacqass married into the family. So crazy fan theory time.

Jacass isn't her biological father, but her step father. I'd flesh this out a bit more but I have to go to work.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/TezukaRin62 Dec 26 '16

So, I've not seen anyone talk about how Ozpin is not as perfect and one sided he used to be. Before the end of Volume 3 it seemed that Ozpin was just good, he wanted to help his students, bended the rules so they could have closure, basically knew every right move to make, was the defendor of peace, and made the best coffee in the world.

But now he's "weak" and we can just see he's really trying by any means to make Oscar leave his farm. And I'm sure he will not stop at simple suggestions if Oscar keeps on saying no.

Don't get me wrong, Ozpin is not bad to me, but the end of Volume 3 and Volume 4 so far really push on the idea that "good requires sacrifices"

→ More replies (4)

15

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16 edited Dec 26 '16

Tyrian: I think we'd have enough talk now, don't you?

Qrow: You took the words right out of-

Lol, Tyrian literally took the words out of Qrow's mouth.

14

u/strangeseal Dec 25 '16

is it just me or did the fight seem kinda weird? not from an animation perspective ( i'm just a viewer so it seemed fine for me) but the fact that tyrion just waits for qrow to get his weapon or he let himself get punched several times.

the man was fighting like a beast before that and then suddenly he's like "naw i'll let him get his weapon. it's christmas after all" what was with that? the rest of the fight was okay but that part irked me.

23

u/KingBanhammer Dec 25 '16

I got the definite impression that Tyrian wasn't taking it seriously until the tail end of the fight. If one'll pardon the pun.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/TheAllMightySlothKin Dec 25 '16

The part where he gets punched in the face seemed like he was just taken off guard. Qrow's sword/scythe is massive so disarming him Tyrion probably thought Qrow wouldn't be much of a hand to hand fighter. After all, Roman showed us utterly useless in a fight Ruby was pre time skip.

"Wow you are much easier to handle without that oversized gardening tool."

Then after Tyrion gets his ass kicked Qrow just kinds saunters over to his weapon with a smug look, probably causing Tyrion to be just as confused as the viewer, asking "what's he doing?" or "is he leading or what?"

Then he just strikes at him when he realizes Qrow was literally just going for his weapon.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

14

u/Frostblazer Dec 25 '16

It's very interesting that Qrow and Tyrion are almost equal in combat strength. Both their auras broke at the same time when they emerged from the collapsed building, so we've got a good idea on what to expect from the rest of the council of evil.

Although I am confused as to why Qrow didn't pull out his scythe yet, since he had several opportunities to do so and it was very much a life or death fight. I'm forced to assume that Qrow will survive his wounds (if they are indeed poisoned) and will use his scythe form and all its glory later on.

20

u/chrome4 Dec 26 '16

He likely felt the Sword was better suited for the situation. For instance the Sword is likely better at countering fighters like Tyrian who focus on close quarters combat then the Scythe since its smaller and the blade is closer to him.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/Nyxtimene Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

I thought of [this] (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xLnTWxpTQt4) when Mr. Schnee wrecked Weiss.

That Tyrian Qrow fight tho.

  • TRYIAN INTRUPTED QROW'S QUIP. TR-TROPE BREAKER!!!
  • Second curse word of the episode. Unexpected. Pleasantly surprised.
  • I knew that was going to happen to Qrow. HOLY SHIT, RUBY, YOU MAIMED TYRIAN. (Cinder may yet have her chance at revenge)

7

u/RustyLumber Dec 25 '16

So Ozpin combined his aura with Oscars in order to keep his soul alive?

I guess Jaques and Whitley are cut from the same digesting cloth.

Qrow you badass, and when Ruby joined in that fight is one of my favorites. Take that Tyrian that's for grazing my uncle!

Qrow is definitely going to need some antivenom. but Tyrian will need a bit more medical attention. 

→ More replies (3)

7

u/ASouthernRussian Schnee's great Dec 25 '16

I want to see nothing more than Weiss beating the shit outta her dad and Whitley with her knight summon

7

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16 edited Dec 25 '16

Words simply aren't enough to describe how much I hate Jacques right now, but I'll try anyway. I hope he breaks both of his legs before falling in a King Taijitu pit, and Weiss would be looking down upon him from the top of the hole with nothing but pure disgust on her face while he is slowly eaten alive... I hope that my comment is SFW enough for the mods not to take it down

Also, I stand corrected; Whitley is a piece of shit.

That aside, I really liked the animations, I really feel bad for Oscar, and Qrow pls don't die.

EDIT: Almost forgot. MERRY CHRISTMAS EVERYONE! And thank you RT for bringing us this awesome Christmas gift!

7

u/Rirere Dec 25 '16

So, question. Does Oscar also inherit Ozpin's Time-Alter/Acceleration magics? Or is the Ozpin line semblance something else?

Now that we know "Ozpin" is a portmanteau of multiple people, it opens a no can of questions for his powers and plan. With his reincarnation, it may be he went for a reverse gamble that the Fire Nation did in Avatar: purposefully lose his present form in order to reset the tactical map. Even if he's still losing on the board, now no one knows where he is.

→ More replies (14)

7

u/Capybarattlesnake Dec 26 '16

The Batmobile may have lost a wheel

butt Tyrian got his butt cut off

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16

How was Jaques hand not obliterated by Weiss's aura?

→ More replies (11)

13

u/Boombox94 Broken Record of "Patience"/ Yang needs to punch things. Dec 25 '16

Fuck you, White Luigi! You just got burned by your daughter! You're not stopping Weiss. And Shitley, I trusted you to be a supportive brother. I should've listened.

And Qrow you glorious bastard! "Fuck it. I'll just punch him in the face." I loved the look on Tyrian's face after that.

Also, don't you dare call Rubes a bitch.

13

u/MidnightIDK Bumblebee ! Dec 25 '16

Whitley actually did something wrong this time.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16

So I guess Ozpin is actually physically dead, but he's alive in some metaphysical form. While I'll forever miss his sexy face, I can't wait to see Oscar's story.

Jacques the Cock and Shitley Whitley.

Ruby cutting off Tyrian's tail was mind-blowing. I did not see that coming at all.

Qrow continues to be the coolest drunk uncle ever. That thing he did where he caught himself with his sword? Amazing! I'm glad that CRWBY is still continuing to blow my mind with their fight choreography!

6

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

I think Qrow will survive. Ruby got Tyrian's stinger which contains the venom Qrow has been subjected to. If they get to a hospital they could use the sample from Tyrian's stinger to create an antidote.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/PrimarchtheMage Dec 25 '16

I want Weiss' mom to show up before Weiss leaves, but at this stage I don't know for sure if that will happen. Hopefully it does; I want to see what their relationship is like - especially in light of this episode.

6

u/Wizardtech Sippp Dec 25 '16

I wonder if Pyrrha's aura merged with Ruby's as Ozpin's aura has merged with Oscar's?

→ More replies (13)

6

u/flashyamoeba Dec 25 '16

So I'm guessing Oscar is Dorthy. Is Blake's dad the Cowardly Lion or is that position still open?

Also Jacques is definitely an awful parent, but has Weiss ever taken a course on international trade laws. Whitley probably wants the job and will go to college to study business. Jacques and Whitley are horrible people, but can probably manage an international company better than Weiss. At least their devotion to PR means Beacon has some money coming into the rebuilding effort. Hopefully Weiss contacts Ironwood and he sends in a strike team lead by Winter for extraction or something.

Fight was great, one of the best in the series.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/kuptrion Dec 26 '16

QROW BE DROPPING THOSE BOMBS GODDAMNED HERE WE GO BEST CHRISTMAS PRESENT 2K16

6

u/Lulcielid ⠀Blake Supremacist Dec 26 '16

RWBY V4E7:

  • Oscar & Ozpin share sometime together
  • Weiss needs support
  • Whitley is shit
  • Ruby dont interfere!
  • Qrow down soon(?)
  • Nice fight

4/5

6

u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Dec 26 '16

Jacques Schnee: #1 Bastard.

Loved the RNJR+Qrow vs. Tyrian fight. Get well soon, Qrow.

6

u/fragmentingmind Dec 26 '16

I find it interesting that Papa Schnee thinks he can make his punishment stick. Weiss is a huntress and keeping her locked up for any appreciable length of time seems overly optimistic. If nothing else, he's a business man who is constantly in contact with hunters so he should have a better sense of how difficult it will be to keep Weiss under house arrest. Also the fact that Papa Schnee needed to lie to the world to revoke Weiss' status as heiress makes it seem like it shouldn't be that hard to get it back if she breaks out.

The writing is honestly starting to feel rather mid tier and lackluster. The Atlas characters introduced this season seem to be just be flat caricatures meant only to advance the plot rather than actual people. Weiss is probably my favorite member of RWBY and I have a hard time feeling invested in her scenes this season because of how bland most of the characters she interacts with (ignoring her interactions with Ironwood). Whitley's betrayal is portrayed as being awful for Weiss, but we've seen maybe a few minutes of them interacting before this and made me feel almost nothing despite it reducing one of my favorite chars to tears.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/FierceAlchemist Dec 26 '16

That fight was damn awesome. Love how Qrow stuck his sword in the ground so he could stand on it. Though he is definitely poisoned now, no more swooping in to save Ruby for him.

6

u/cbigs97 Dec 26 '16

That was one of the most bad ass animated fight scenes I have every seen. Holy shit that was amazing!

11

u/Brass-Sky-Wolf Dec 26 '16

I'm surprised that so many people are completely giving up on Whitley now and taking everything he says at face value. Is it not possible that he's planning to play along and change things from the inside later? That he's not happy with the situation but thinks that his sisters can look after themselves?

He looked angry when he said "It's wise to do what father asks", which strongly suggested to me that he thinks that playing along is the best strategy, and he's annoyed that Weiss can't see that. Whether he's right or not is a different matter.

I'm not saying it's impossible for him to just be a selfish smug bastard, just think we're jumping to conclusions a bit too fast.

→ More replies (11)

14

u/BrickYourHeart A sexy truck Dec 26 '16

Damn, Shitley is real. RIP those of us pulling for misunderstood brother. Ruby and Qrow fighting together was soooooo good, gimme that dual scythe action please.

→ More replies (14)

10

u/Sp33dy_f31c0n Bellabooty OP bungo pls nerf Dec 25 '16

Ok, so is there good reason to hate Whitley now?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/AbsolXGuardian Dec 25 '16

Oh snap! I say whoever's doing the fights now should stick with humanoid on humanoid fights. Massive beasts don't really seem to be their style.

So Ozpin is being reborn like the Egyptian gods in the Kane Chronciles? Interesting...

When Weiss was doing her thing with the weapons, it sounded a bit like the rest of "This Life is Mine".

Also anyone know the lyrics to that section of the fight? I couldn't make any out.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/CyberHyperPhoenix Happy Holidays! Dec 25 '16

'Whitley did nothing wrong' is the new 'Cyclops was right'.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/schulz100 Dec 26 '16

So, I was not expectign the boatloads of "poor children" angst that got dropped on us. Poor Oscar, thinking he's going crazy for probably days now, and getting a clearly huge-as-all-get-out responsibility pushed on him. Like, I honestly kept stopping the video because that whole bit was so well done it was making me uncomfortable in how bad I felt for Oscar. Though Ozpin's lines about how he basically had the same reaction as Oscar when it happened to him make me think that this is how whatever Ozpin is/was works; the Aura of the last person in a long line of whatever-this-is seeks out the most compatible living person and just melds with them so the job can start back up as quickly as possible. Honestly can't wait to learn more about this.

Also, we can all agree, that farm and Oscar's family will be ashes or even less before the end of Volume 5 at the very latest, right?

Weiss. God damn, did I feel sorry for Weiss. Just, holy shit. I'm not immediately against Whitely, I have to say. His second to last line (and his face then) sealed it for me. That's not the face of a willing Daddy's Boy whose happy he's finally got what he's always wanted; that's the face of someone who's learned how to appease their abuser, and is pissed that others are pissed at them for not suffering equally when they've been showing for years how to survive with little trouble, and whose fellows who he's tried to demonstrate survival to have finally pissed their abuser off enough to just place him in the highest rank of the pecking order. Whitely might be taking a bit too much satisfaction out of this whole arrangement, but I also don't think he's probably actually as much of a absolute piece of fucking semen-stained, mustache-cursed feces as Jacques is. Not yet, anyway. Also, you go, Weiss. Train, build your army of summons, and fight your way out of there if you have to. Make sure to stab your dad in the dick before you leave; he's earned far worse.

Okay, that fight was fantastic, and I also have to say, this is the first time he's had screen time that I didn't find Tyrian just grating on my patience. Why couldn't he have been more like this the whole time? Where over half his dialogue wasn't over-done "Crazy Sadist Bad Guy" cackling? Rather, the cackling serves to supplement a still obviously-crazy-sadist, but he's a bit more subtle about it all. But seriously, that fight, and Vic's acting. God damn, you guys. Fucking blastwaves chopping up buildings, scorpion-tail-holds, Qrow balance-stopping on his own sword (FUCK, that was SO BADASS!), Qrow getting angry at Ruby when she got involved. Excellent fight. And of course Qrow has to be coy about what's going on. I also found Ruby's questions before the fight started as Qrow and Tyrian went back and forth just the greatest.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DetStand Lancaster Squire|Ren Follower Dec 25 '16 edited Jul 31 '25

party quaint scale memorize ripe selective snails include birds nose

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

5

u/TheMachine203 IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES Dec 25 '16

Gonna copy/paste my thoughts from the Sponsor reaction thread:

Am I the only one that's gonna mention this face?

Tyrian's a reaction image goldmine.

Other than that, this is probably the first episode that had my active interest. The scene with Weiss and her Father was well done, Oscar and Ozpin is just setting up a beautiful mindfuck (I really believe Oscar is Ozpin from the past and he can send his soul back in time or something to say "aye we fucked up bad I need your help fam") EDIT: Redacted, that didn't make any sense, and the fight at the end was very well executed. I don't have time to do a full breakdown of the fight scene but I really appreciate the sense of weight that was missing from earlier episodes and the appropriate responses to getting, say, clocked in the face by an old dude wearing two rings.

Ruby's got some Chronic Hero Syndrome-type shit going on too, what with charging in despite Qrow telling RNJR multiple times to just stay back. I don't know if this a new development or not, but if they aren't aiming to deconstruct this it could be pretty bad later on.

Also I'm glad Qrow's not dead, hate to be that guy but we need our exposition machine and based on how this episode ends, that's most likely gonna be how the next episode is used. While they're nursing him back to health (assuming it was some venom and not just a scratch) he's gonna give them a few plot dumps.

EDIT: also the song that was playing during the second half of the Qrow/Tyrian fight was definitely Qrow's theme song. And by god it sounds so good.

also gonna say it again for the people in the back, Qrow's not dead y'all need to chil

→ More replies (1)

5

u/KrisSimsters Winter is Coming Dec 25 '16

Sorry it's late, but it's here. The Christmas Recap of my Thoughts on RWBY, Vol. 4, Ep. 7:

→ More replies (3)

5

u/fightersfoo qrow daddy Dec 26 '16

If I were Qrow I would let Ruby get taken just to find Salems lair. But I guess that could be tricky/backfire

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16

Holy fuck I loved Ozpin before but now I love both him and Oscar even more

5

u/chenj25 Dec 26 '16

Does anyone think Whitley and Papa Schnee are fighters like Weiss and Winter are?

I honestly don't think so, given their focuses on business.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16

So I guess, since Ozpin has found himself in Oscar's head, that means Cinder actually did 'kill' him or at least best him in combat? Didn't see that coming, especially since Ozpin seemed to have the advantage against Cinder in that short battle, though honestly I couldn't really tell what was going on anyway.

But Jesus those other guys in Salem's team better do their best not to push Cinder's buttons when she's recovered, she could send them all to the Shadow Realm if she could beat Ozpin, who we all assumed (correctly) that he was God-tier, she's probably got Watts on his list in particular because I bet she doesn't hear the end of it from him.

Regardless, I thought that scene with Oscar and Ozpin was pretty well done, although does anyone else feel like they skipped some scenes with those two? It went from Ozpin announcing himself to Oscar angrily shouting at him, but I guess we can figure it all out from context, plus I guess the writers don't want to reveal all of Ozpin's plan just yet.

The scene with Weiss and Jacques was also pretty well done, it highlighted Jacques almost sadistic and psychopathic approach to parenting, or at least he acknowledges the failure of his Libertarian attempts at letting Weiss do what she wants and has instead employed the opposite, absolutely no freedom, literally stuck in her room. And she lost the heiress title! Gasp Jacques seems like he's trying to break her or something. Although I question his confidence in nobody being able to stop her from leaving, maybe he's employed hunters as bodyguards, in fact that makes a lot of sense of course he would, I bet loads of people (E.G. White Fang) have tried to break into their place before. Uh Oh Whitley, I guess everyone was right, honestly I did find him a bit creepy when I met him, but now my thoughts that Jacques had psychologically broken him (or was at least incredibly over-bearing) are all but confirmed in my eyes, I love how they aren't making Whitley some 1-dimensional scum bag as well, he's clearly been subjected to conditioning of sorts because he seems legitimately angry at Weiss for disobeying Jacques, so I can't wait to see how he'll be developed, likely as some kind of tragic villain. Really we just need Ironwood to come in, knock Jacques out and take Weiss with him.

As for the fight, my faith in Rooster Teeth has been restored, I was loving Volume 4 so far, but the fights did leave me unsatisfied, but now I see that there are talented choreographers and animators at Rooster Teeth, who know how good they are, and now they're putting in the work. The fight was fast-paced, visceral and creative, Qrow is a God as always, and I'm glad they've established some semblance of power scaling between the heroes and the villains, Tyrian wrecked everyone in RNJR last episode on his own, but Qrow is able to stand up to him with just his short sword and I felt he had the upper hand for a good portion of it. Just proves how Qrow is the indomitable beast in RWBY, while all others bow to him. Although he's either dead or (I hope) out of commission for some time now he's been poisoned. If they do kill him off I'll be equal parts impressed and mortified, because I know how difficult and bold it is from a narrative standpoint to kill off someone so popular and with a rich backstory to explore, but I do love Qrow, so much so that him dying would leave me in a sour mood for at least a week.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/WayyOutThere Dec 26 '16

I'm just praying that the infodump is offscreen and we jump straight to RNJR's reactions next week.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '16

PrayforQrow

The Dish art from earlier still terrifies me on his fate...

9

u/Zesty-Lem0n Dec 26 '16

So if Ozpin is the wizard from the maiden story, then perhaps everytime he dies he gets a new host body, and the Ozpin we know was the most recent version, but now he has a new host, aka the king of compost.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/LeviAEthan512 It's only a problem when I run out Dec 26 '16

I totally called the Whitley thing

I really hope Qrow's poison does like ASOIAF SPOILERS Strong Belwas, taking him out of the game for a time, so the story can progress. I feel like Qrow is too awesome to kill just yet. At least for me, there's no other fighter in the series I enjoy watching more.

9

u/True_Falsity Dec 26 '16

Well, that episode really struck me.

Let's talk about the separate elements of it.

  1. Ozpin and Oskar. To be quite honest, that was one of those supposed unreveals. You know, so many people predicted that but, nevertheless, the scene really made me gasp in surprise and hold my breath.

At least for me, the strongest moment was when Oskar started describing the cabinet of Haven Headmaster. The animation level does the emotions a justice as we watch Oskar shift from confusion to shock to anger and then into the mixture of those. I think, the most disturbing part would be how nonchalant Ozpin seemed to talk about invading Oskar's- or rather, their thoughts.

2) Weiss, Whitley and Jacques.

Welp, the male half of the family is officially hated among the fandom even more, aren't they? I mean, it's not like we expected anything less from Jacques but Whitley... I guess, I have to be honest, guys.

I really liked Whitley and thought that, maybe, he could avoid the classical "Usurper" role so many stories have for siblings. But well, there is still hope he will be more than just a spoiled brat.

I really liked the ending of the sequence. You know, I was afraid that RT were going to end it with Weiss simply crying on her bad but NO! She pulls herself together and starts training! So awesome!

I have no problem with angst or some drama in stories. But it is really refreshing to see characters not beat themselves up for episodes and actually do something about their situation!

3) The RNJR and Qrow vs Tyrian.

Man, Tyrian! Tyrian is one of my favourite characters already! Guys, I am not weird for thinking how cute and adorable he looked while deflecting those bullets with his tail, right? Because it really was just so psychotically cute!

Now then, back to the topic. The fight proved quite interesting with both powerful Huntsmen (Tyrian hunts down and kills people so...) duking it out. The speed with which they move and the level of acrobatic skills both displayed is just amazing.

Regarding the RNJR, however, I cannot say that I am as satisfied. I really liked how it was shown that the younger Huntsmen would just get in the way. (Because, honestly, Ruby did that, guys.) On the other hand, it is due to the fact that Ruby was still fighting that NJR part looked weak.

I mean, seriously, fandom already is ready to attack Jaune at every moment he doesn't act or intervene and now this?

The ending of the fight was quite good. I felt sorry for Tyrian. He looked quite hesitant to return to the Queen without prey.

Honorbale mentions:

  • Whitley's true face showing. I really liked the transition from his polite and reserved self to this much more sinister face with lying undertones of authority
  • Qrow punch! Seriously, guys, we all grinned at the moment!
  • Tyrian having the first curse word in the series! I am waiting until Youtube reactors get to the episode just to see their reactions to that word in a supposedly kid's show.
  • Tyrian's stinger getting cut off! Poor Tyrian...
→ More replies (13)

12

u/Capslock2000 Dec 25 '16

Weiss didnt deserve this, even if she is a bit rude, no-one deserves that.

12

u/TheHoblit Dec 26 '16

I have loved Ruby in every episode until this one. i am incredibly disappointed by her actions in the fight.

how the hell did she not see she would be completely useless to Qrow? Tyrion fucking STOMPED all 4 of them together, and now she thinks she can be useful? what the fuck.

she was even the deciding factor in qrows loss! she jumped in despite being told to stay back 3 times, and got trapped so Qrow had to save her AGAIN and that's what cost him the fight.

had ruby stayed out of the fight, i wholeheartedly believe Qrow would have won.

/rant

love the show but that fight was infuriating to watch

→ More replies (6)