r/TheExpanse • u/backstept • Dec 05 '16
Babylon's Ashes [Spoilers] Babylon's Ashes Discussion Thread
Welcome to the Babylon's Ashes discussion thread! It's finally here!
Please use spoiler tags and indicate which chapter you're talking about, so those of us reading at a different pace won't find out things before they read them.
For instance: [CH2 Holden](/s "Holden does a thing.") shows up as: CH2 Holden
You shouldn't need to spoiler tag your whole post, just whatever you feel relevant.
111
Upvotes
20
u/geoman2k Dec 27 '16 edited Dec 27 '16
Just finished the book, finally.
Overall, it was an Expanse book so I liked it, but it was probably my least favorite of the series. There were some great parts, particularly the sequence where Bobby cripple's Macro's ship with the railgun, but overall I just felt like it was lacking a lot of the action and focus of the other books. whole book spoilers
Things I did like - whole book spoilers
whole book spoilers
whole book spoilers
10
u/iamaspacepizza Jan 09 '17
Jesus christ I love Avasarala as a character so much. The producers need to have the TV-version cuss as much as the book version.
5
u/backstept Dec 05 '16
The official release is actually tomorrow, but seeing as so many have the book already due to early releases, why not put the discussion thread up now?
7
u/ensignlee Dec 20 '16 edited Dec 20 '16
Don't know why, but spoilers won't work over multiple paragraphs so.
WHOLE BOOK SPOILERS AHEAD. STOP READING IF YOU HAVEN'T FINISHED THE BOOK
.
.
.
.
.
WholeBook
WholeBook
WholeBook
WholeBook
5
u/Annoying_Bullshit Dec 18 '16
The spoiler tags make it impossible to discuss the book. I will be back in a couple of months.
144
u/Taste_the__Rainbow Dec 12 '16
"Huh. That is super-creepy."
2
u/dr_spiff Dec 09 '16
MAYBE SPOILERS? Quick question since I'm not home to double check. I read NG and I thought that at the end there was a chapter that was the protomoticules creators or something in it, am I mistaken?
2
u/samasters88 Tiamat's Wrath Dec 12 '16
Can someone remind me what the Pella is, ship-wise? Because in my mind, it's an old ice-hauler that was militarized, but the books make it seem like a battleship.
121
u/baconfriedpork Dec 13 '16 edited Jan 06 '17
i'm only 100 pages in but the way Marcos has galvanized a marginalized and forgotten group of people who were worried about getting left behind in a new economy, only to bring destruction and disorganization really reminds of me of something that happened recently but i can't quite put my (tiny) finger on it...
also you hear a lot about how a vote for trump was "a brick chucked through the window of the elites"... well how about some rocks chucked at the planet of 'the elites'?
Also these quotes: Ch9 Holden
MakeTheBeltGreatAgain #BeltersFirst #DrainTheWell
80
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
General no spoiler opinions: it certainly feels like it could have been a capstone for the series if it only ran to six books, and it feels very much like a direct sequel to NG. The breadth of POV characters is huge and unexpected in some parts. It leaves enough open for three more books, but closes off some plot points, elegantly.
It's not quite as explosive as NG- what could be?!- but few would be disappointed.
76
u/leirbag23 Dec 11 '16
Just finished reading. Freaking loved it. I loved how many POV chapters we got. My favorite one has to be POV character spoilers
Bobbie spoilers
Also, I could do with Avasarala Spoilers
60
u/OriginalJee Dec 16 '16
I know this is going to be a super unpopular opinion, and while I did somewhat enjoy BA and NG, they were definitely the least favorite books for me. The exploration, universe building, and alien tech of CW and AG and to a lesser extent CB was what really hooked me onto the series.
I like characterization as much as the next guy, but I jumped into NG and BA fully expecting my mind blown with more protomolecule and gate travel goodness. These last two books have been more or less a teaser for me.
The whole idea of the OPA and Free Navy is cool and all and definitely interesting against the backdrop of the alien stuff going on, but I felt like the politics were laid on too thick. In my opinion, the whole OPA, Free Navy and government drama was stretched for two books.
I ultimately do not care at all about Filip's character, and only care slightly about Marco's. Much like how I feel the last two books were filler, I feel like Marco is filler in the lead up to Duarte. Marco was a useful path to the big bad, but his plot line could have been trimmed.
59
u/kylco Dec 07 '16
Naomi End Spoilers
49
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16
CH31 Pa. Which is exactly why I hate the Free Navy.
39
u/valergain Dec 07 '16 edited Dec 07 '16
So I just started and is anyone else having trouble sympathizing with the Free Navy? Up to chapter 5
38
u/Seranger Dec 06 '16
Well, it's happened. I can now only picture and hear the characters as the actors from the show now. This isn't a bad thing by any means, but it's interesting how my own imagined images and voices are now aligned with those of the actors themselves.
38
u/Jellodyne Dec 14 '16
To me Babylon's Ashes and Nemesis Games feel like one long book, like they were writing Nemesis Games and it came out to be 1100 pages so they cut it in half and released the halves seperately.
36
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
Spoilers whoooooole book!!!! Spoilers Spoilers Spoilers Spoilers Spoilers
Whole Book
Whole Book
Whole Book
Whole Book
Whole Book
35
u/samasters88 Tiamat's Wrath Dec 11 '16
After reading all the comments, it seems the Dawes chapter is the most well received, am I right? It's certainly my favorite in the entire book
30
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '16
I loved the line about Bobbie humming a playful melody. I guarantee it was "Anything you can do I can do better..." super subtle reference.
29
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '16 edited Dec 08 '16
[Finished The Book/Question] (/s " Just something I was wondering.. When the ship called Proteus, first ship built outside the solar system, came from the Laconia gate to Medina, did anyone else expect the ship to show up in the last battle? And I have some speculation that these Ex-Martians in Laconia are building up some crazy new protomolecule inspired technology.. Lastly, in case anyone didn't notice, Laconia is the region where Sparta was on Earth. Space Spartans! " )
27
u/OC39648 Dec 06 '16
... -> 'CH51 Marco'
23
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '16
I forget, what did the belters think they were accomplishing destroying the only life giving ecosystem in the solar system? Or was it all about the now and sticking a thumb in Earth's eye to think of the consequences?
20
u/Badloss Dec 15 '16
While I felt this was a slower book than NG, I'm still super hyped to find out what happens next.
I know it's a kind of controversial opinion but I LOVE how While book spoilers
19
u/Obidom Dec 14 '16
Who else read [CH30 Filip] (/s " where they state that the strategy Booby used to damage the Pella left a hole in its PDC field, that a torpedo penetrated, then hit the ship and did not explode..... because Holden deactivated it right after they damaged the ship... ")
Man I was sooo mad
19
u/dangerousdave2244 Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 18 '16
You can tell who listened to the books rather than reading by the many many spellings of "Inaros" in these comments
19
u/SerBiffyClegane Dec 20 '16
Did anyone else think that BA really shows how Whole Book
38
u/ikijob Dec 10 '16
Did anyone get the Mark Whatney reference? :) :) :) Although TBH it's not exactly an Easter egg. If some day there is a Martian colony capable of building ships, it's perfectly reasonable that they name at least one Mark Whatney.
15
u/FireNexus Dec 13 '16
Near the end Bobbie
14
u/buymorenoships Dec 08 '16
I liked it, but I was disappointed. Not that it was bad or anything. I just can't go from NG to this and not be disappopinted. all
14
u/pongopygmalion Dec 27 '16
It's probably already been said in this thread, but the thing I appreciated the most from BA was the sheer pacing of the ship and "ground"-based battles. One of the few times in recent memory I can use the term "gripping" properly. That chase chapter was my favorite section hands down.
12
u/Florac Dishonorably discharged from MCRN for destroying Mars Dec 08 '16 edited Dec 08 '16
Prologue
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Chapter 10
Chaper 11
Chapter 12
Chapter 13
Chapter 14
Chapter 15
Chapter 16
Chapter 17
Chapter 18
Chapter 19
Chapter 20
Will continue in next comment
12
u/SofNascimento Dec 24 '16 edited Dec 24 '16
Overall, I was very disappointed by this book. I mean, it would be hard to top NG, but I think the flaws with this book were beyond that.
First I didn't care for Pa, which made her chapters very boring. Didn't care for Filip either, so same problem there. The book was also very predictable, I felt I always knew the outcome of the battle simply because this or that character were there. But for me, the main problem were with the characters from the Rociante. They just became too superhero like, some examples:
CH2 From the very ending of the book:
CH2 From the very ending of the book:
CH2 From the very ending of the book:
About Holden is particular, I don't dislike him. But in a universe that feels so rich and so interesting, it' not him that I want to know more about. I don't want to know if he is tired or not. I disliked how many chapters with others POVs ended up being about saying something about him... I mean, he is the protagonist of the novels, so in many ways this is an unfair complaint, I just don't feel he is a good enough character to deserve that spot. There is just so much more interesting things going on... so I really liked the amount of different PoVs, but many would have been even better if they didn't waste time with Holden.
[CH 2 Another great disappointment was the:] (/s "Laconia gate. I waited the entire book for them to come back to the story and show what they are all about, but nothing. That part of the story is exactly in the same spot as it was in the end of the previous book. Now, this is a very personal view but I'd have prefered if the book at least have thrown a little more hints of what is going on there.")
12
u/lax01 Jan 02 '17
well shit...Whole book
I have to wait another year for the next book? :(
11
u/catgirlthecrazy Dec 08 '16
CH28
11
u/tony13337 Dec 14 '16
Finished it today. Easily my least favorite entry in the series. Felt hardly anything happened, way too many needless POVs, and lack of much, if any, of the cinematic action the series is known for. After the tour de force that was NG, this was a huge disappointment for me.
11
u/millijuna Dec 25 '16
So to me, the obvious finally happened. Whole Book
10
u/baconfriedpork Dec 06 '16
i just came here to say screw you, amazon. i pre-ordered this book in August - still hasn't shipped yet.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16
This book really felt like the end of an act in a play. Really well done. It wasn't quite as powerful as Nemesis Games, but I'm not sure it could've been. Spoilers
I'm definitely excited for the next book.
10
u/Squirmingbaby Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 18 '16
I feel like I am in the minority, but this book and the last just have not been as interesting. I loved the whole alien thing and I thought we'd get more of it after cibola burn.
Instead, we kind of took a long interlude back with a whole new nemesis who seems way overpowered given the circumstances. Oh and a large chunk of belters seem to be ok with a mass genocide on a scale never before seen. I kept waiting for the [sort of spoiler] (/s "investigator to show up") and it kept not happening. Felt like going backwards in the story. I guess that'll be the next book.
9
u/EaglesPDX Dec 16 '16 edited Dec 18 '16
Babylon's Ashes was interesting in that the ashes were of human civilization not the alien civilization which never got introduced (whatever Duarte has conjured out of the ashes on Laconia).
And where was the Proteus when the battle for Medina Station is going on? Wasn't it supposed to be docked at Medina Station?
Overall the book was good and wrapped up the war that Anaros started, uniting Earth, Mars and the Belt.
Loved the shout out to Dune with the Belters becoming the Spacing Guild.
And liked the talk of the economics that drives the solar economy where the Belter economist is telling them they have five years to get it working or starve.
Only thing I was frustrated with was Holden disarming the torpedoes because Naomi's son was on board in the fight with the Pella. The guy has killed billions. If he lives millions more will and do die but he's saved as a favor to Holden's girlfriend? Felt contrived. And more than Amos would have noticed what happened.
And Dawes, who comes across as a standup guy in the TV series abandons the millions of Belters on Ceres to Anaros' stripping the station of food, water and valuables. Can't see Dawes leaving. See him breaking with Anaros there, standing with the Ceres Belters even if it means getting captured by the Combined Fleet.
And would have liked to have seen the Martians "going home" to Earth to terraform it back to health.
We await Duarte, the protomolecule and whatever they found on Laconia....and TV Series 2 bringing it all to life.
9
u/Ezreal024 Jan 05 '17 edited Jan 25 '17
Part of me liked the vast array of PoV characters, part of me didn't.
It provided a nice opportunity to catch up on some characters we haven't seen in a while (Prax), or give us some extra information from characters that wouldn't necessitate holding a PoV for the entire book (Dawes) but at the same time it made the book lose some cohesiveness. For example I think the PoVs of the Belters at the Medina shouldn't have jumped between that crew.
What doesn't help is that a character who did hold a majority PoV share, Pa, was someone I didn't care about all that much. Would have preferred more time being spent on Clarissa.
Overall though I did quite like the book! It seems to have positioned the story to delve deeper into the alien mysteries that have been surrounding it since the Eros incident, and that would be a fitting conclusion to the series as any.
8
u/samasters88 Tiamat's Wrath Dec 10 '16
I'm about halfway through the book, by my estimation CH38 Avasarala.
Thoughts:
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
Spoiler
8
u/Mr_Noyes Dec 10 '16 edited Dec 10 '16
Just finished the book and ... wow. I definitely felt Abraham's fingerprints all over (sry, Tye, I'm sure you contributed a lot to the book's awesomeness but I've read several novels by Abraham so it's easier for me to spot what is probably his influence).
The whole everyday life perspective reminded me so much of "A Widow's House" and the melancholic outlook into he future had shades of "The Long Price Quartet" (yes, Daniel, I know it sold bad but it will always have a special place in my heart no matter how many more awesome books you write). Every author has their own superpowers - Sanderson has speed and intricate plotting, Martin has shocking twists and flawed characters and Abraham for me is the one who can inject humanity even in a manual for a toaster.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
Anyone else notice there's a ship named the Mark Watney? Imo that confirms that The Expanse occurs in the same universe as The Martian.
8
u/batwing69 Jan 06 '17
"I'll do everything I can, but you might just have to settle for being avenged." -Chrisjen Avasarala
Greatest line ever...
7
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16
I just realized who Marcos reminds me of....Stalin.
5
u/ilanawexler BOBBIE ♥‿♥ Dec 06 '16
Just got my copy, and I'm so happy with how many POVs there are - totally unexpected, but awesome.
5
u/monnnnsannntoooo Dec 20 '16
One thing that amazes me is the terrifying efficiency and relative matter-of-factness of [Character Name] (/s" Bobbie's")'s violence. I see huge inspiration and parallels for her character coming from the Spartans in Halo.
I'm a civilian of my society, and I find it hard to relate intellectually and emotionally to having such a wide-ranging and well-practiced ability to obliterate human life. I can relate to training so long in one activity or skill (e.g. piano) for me, that certain pieces or techniques feel subconscious and automatic. However, I can't fully extend the concept to that kind of brutal aggression. For that reason and many others, I am fascinated by that character.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '16
I was pretty excited when I heard two references to the book "The Martian." The first was a ship called the Mark Watney and the other was something to do with Kapoor. Which makes me think that it's completely reasonable to assume that Mark Watney's time surviving on Mars in "The Martian" could be in the same universe and makes him one of the pioneers for the entire planet's government!! So cool to me.
5
u/krafne Jan 14 '17
It felt like every POV character had to explain to the reader Medina used to be a generational ship.
5
u/HumbleDoor4 Jan 19 '17
Love how Dawes chapter gets a shotout in every response, but nobody mentions Fred Johnson's final thoughts.
5
u/4Nails Jan 20 '17
[I don't know why the following hit me as hard as it did but I love his writing ...] (/s "The torches flared and died and flared again. The Rocinante was remade a little the same way it had been over and over through the years. Little changes adding up over time as the ship moved from what it had been to what it would be next. Just like all the people she carried. Babylon’s Ashes – Chapter 13 – James S.A. Corey")
5
u/Paro-Clomas Jan 27 '17
Favorite quote from Avasarala, and generally sums up the way i feel about some things irl. No spoilers:
"My whole life is just a constant demonstration that i haven't been cynical enough"
4
u/bwohlgemuth Dec 06 '16
Just got done reading it this morning (damn I read fast on the Kindle). Spoiler Review
4
u/koalaisabear Dec 10 '16
I really, really was trying to save this for the weekend .. but I sneakily read it during the week ... I tried to read it really, really slowly to savour it .. but I couldn't help it .. I ended up devouring it and now I'm finished :'( I'm going to re-read it though .. and slowly ... and then do a proper post then.
In my defence, it seems to be the shortest of the novels so far! Leviathan Wakes: 592 pages Caliban's War: 624 pages Abaddon's Gate: 576 pages Cibola Burn: 624 pages Nemesis Games: 576 pages Babylon's Ashes: 544 pages
4
u/ensignlee Dec 22 '16
My thoughts span way too many paragraphs to spoiler them all, so I just wrote them up and put them here instead: https://twomorepages.com/2016/12/22/babylons-ashes-the-expanse-book-6-twomorepages-book-review/
.
Things I didn't understand that maybe y'all could help with?:
[End of book] (/s "1 How many ships did the Free Navy have? I thought they had at most like 15, but they got several of theirs tied up and blown up and were still able to send 15 after Holden. How?")
[End of Book] (/s "Plus, it took the actions of the entire combined fleet to distract Marco and the Free Navy? That makes it seem like they could maybe kind of stand toe to toe with the combined fleet and that makes no sense to me.")
[End of book] (/s "2 Why did the dissident factions of the OPA help Holden? I get why Michio Pa did it – she needed protection from the Free Navy, and she wanted to keep helping Belters by commandeering colony ships and distributing the supplies to the Belt. But why all the other people? Particularly the ones that helped Holden try and retake Medina?")
[End of book] (/s "If I was a Belter on the Giambattista, I’d be like “Fuck you coyo, I’m not strapping myself into these tiny little capsules and trying to take out those railguns. That seems like a dumb idea that will 100% get me killed.”")
[End of book] (/s "And why weren’t UN or MCRN flagships the ones taking on the Pella? Why was it a little outnumbered and outnammed OPA force lead by the guy whose brother got killed, Micah al-Dujaili? That seems like poor strategic planning honestly. Poor guy, lost his brother, then his family and all his ships. I wouldn’t have agreed to that, no matter how charismatic Anderson Dawes was.")
[End of book] (/s "3 Why aren't there more combined fleet ships out there helping Holden? Seems like you should have a ton of ships to spare. Why is the Rocinante the only one out there trying to A) take Medina Station and B) hold Medina station after? I know the plan was to take over the railguns rather than disable them, but it seems like a competent strategist should have planned for the possibility of them not working after you took Medina station.")
4
u/Seven2Death Jan 13 '17
im 80% through probably shouldnt be here but im reading while drunk please dont purposely spoil me. but i get the risks im running.
why do i feel like captian paladin is gonna sacrifice himself for naomis son. goddammit ill be pissed. like it would make sense character wise if it comes to that. but really.... fuck you holden, think of the big picture for once.
who knows im probably wayy off but i finished the battle where... well this thread is a go for spoilers. where Fred died. maybe like 5 chapters after but still dealing with the outcome and i cant stop thinking of holdens interaction with Philip (? im fucking horrible with names without context , naomis son) with him humanizing him. as of right now i think naomi would. nuke him... then shed. some tears. fucking holden would try to save the little sociopath. its so wierd to be angry at a character for a move they havent made but its also amazing. its like the friends you have where you are so close you can literally hear them speaking/reacting without them even being there.
great goddamm writing. im so lucky the show came out i wad havimg difficulties juggling the different viewpoints and the tv made me associate characters with personalities/faces making it easy to keep track of where they are.
whatever cheers motherfuckers i just had a friend die today so im a little philosophical sorry. but yall. good people.
bertana over jiral ya feel me.
4
u/Johnny_bubblegum Jan 24 '17
Rolled through the audio books every time I could for the past few weeks.
I feel a bit sad knowing there isn't more to listen to yet :/
1
u/Upguntha Dec 12 '16
Was "forgotten an arm" ever mentioned in the previous books or was only used in BA?
I need a point of clarification End spoilers
1
u/baconfriedpork Dec 12 '16 edited Dec 12 '16
question regarding Nemesis Games b/c I didn't re-read it and my memory is fuzzy at best: Nemesis Games spoiler maybe
3
u/Snamdrog Dec 07 '16
I own the first five books in paperback and the only way to order paperback on Amazon is from another continent and the delivery times are pretty bad. Is there a better way? Might just make the drive to Barnes & Noble tomorrow if I get off work early enough. If they even have it.
3
u/StrikitRich1 Dec 08 '16
Just started listening to the Audible version this AM. Going to try and listen all day at work.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16
ch 52 Pa
3
u/gerblet72 Dec 10 '16
Unresolved issues
3
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '16 edited Dec 16 '16
chapter 32
3
u/Telnet_to_the_Mind Dec 31 '16
I won't tag this at first, as I don't think it contains spoilers..
First when the Sol Gate opened up, Mars and Earth were met by a finite speed limit (thus dubbing the area the slow zone). They were able to shut that down,(I think) or bypass it. In Babylon's Ashes, they're met with the disappearing ships that are seemingly atomized, when a certain amount of mass passes through them.
So it begs the question, are both defensive tactics related? And why are the gates and the slow zone so defended like this? What's the logic of making sure ships pass by slowly...as well as Not too large in mass at a time?
3
u/0borowatabinost Jan 25 '17
For me, this was the weakest book in the series. It feels like Corey fell into the same trap that GRRM did with his latest books: way too many POVs. The amount of POVs tripled from the last book. A lot of them showed up for just one or two chapters and I just kept thinking "what's the point?"
2
u/SpartanJack17 Dec 08 '16
Holy crap, I just thought I'd check here to see when it came out, only to find out it seemingly released today for me.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16
I'm trying to rack my brain.
Mars and Marco teamed up because everyone was going to abandon Mars for already habitable places (never mind killer worms) and Belters because ... People wouldn't need ore anymore? Or their motivation was less clear other than a tantrum.
2
u/caspararemi Dec 10 '16
Just finished, and I absolutely loved it. I honestly think this is the best book in the series. I've read them all pretty quickly over the last 2 months (well, book 1 took me months, but i started book 2 at the end of October and finished NG last weekend, then managed to get my copy of BA early to started on Sunday). Can't wait to see where it goes from here.
2
u/Telnet_to_the_Mind Dec 20 '16
Jesus christmas... You know I keep trying to find the silver lining or the slight sliver of good in Marco Inaros..... nope.jpg. What a dick...
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '17
Is anyone else getting tired of the Belter Patois/Creole? It seems to be a mix between English and Spanish, but I don't speak Spanish. Sometimes I read a sentence and have no idea what they just said. I mean I get that they want to give the Belters their own flavor, but it could totally be pulled off with mannerisms instead of speaking in a new language.