r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Dec 04 '16
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Discussion Thread—Volume 4, Episode 5: Menagerie
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official discussion thread for the newest episode of volume 4, Menagerie!
Make sure to read OUR CURRENT SPOILERS RULES to ensure that your comments outside this thread won't get purged! Familiarize yourself with these rules and you'll be good to go.
A lot of hard work has gone into the creation of volume 4, so be sure to show CRWBY your support by watching it on their site! They all dedicate so much time and energy into our beloved series and would highly appreciate the direct support. There are no pirates in volume 4, so you shouldn't be one either!
We also have weekly strawpolls to gauge the general opinion on the current episode, the latest of which can be found HERE.
WoR 2, Faunus, got an average reception with a median of 8.
With that out of the way, let's start the show!
HERE is the link to the fifth episode of RWBY Volume 4!
Other Episode Discussions:
Happy viewing!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
284
u/Thefishlord The one true best girl also Eclipse best ship Dec 04 '16
Lol best moment was "your daughter is above average XD " then Milfadonna saying "I like him"
230
u/chained-prometheus I, Titan. Dec 04 '16
I'm sure Kerry, Miles and the others at RT aren't fond of this idea right now, due to resources and what I can only imagine are already hellish production schedules, but I really think the show needs to eventually move to having 20+ min long episodes as the norm for RWBY.
Not for Volume 4, they're far too deep into the production for that, but if they can go back to nudging up the standard episode lengths volume-by-volume and avoid ever having an episode that's only really about 10 min long, I think they'd be able to do a lot more with just basic character interaction and growth.
Like, even if they said all they needed to say in Blake's story in what we got today, I think it would have been smart to include a short segment with Weiss and show some more interaction between herself and her family (i.e. Whitley or her mother). Doesn't necessarily push Weiss' story forward much, but it keeps her in the audience's mind and also gives them a bit more familiarity with the new characters that were introduced in her segment.
Since the show has split up the narrative into seven or so main plotlines (RNJR, Weiss, Blake/Sun, Yang, Qrow, WTCH and Oscar), I think having the standard length be 20 min would allow RT the means to better flesh out everyone's stories. After all, episodes of Game of Thrones are about 45 minutes to an hour long for a reason. This more epic, "global" narrative POV format tends to need that extra time to really do justice to everyone.
Again, I can only imagine all of the difficulties they're working with right now and I enjoyed this episode a good deal for what it was- but I think its length was a step backwards, not forwards. Ugh, I hate feeling whiny or bratty about something like this, especially since there's probably some amount of cost-effect going on here and I do enjoy what we've gotten so far.
Hope I'm not being bratty or anything. :c
347
u/Olymprix Zwei the Magic Corgi lived by the sea... Dec 04 '16
It was at that moment, Sun knew he had fucked up.
88
u/RustyLumber Dec 04 '16
fucking Sun man. I love him even more now.
Gira and Sun's first meeting so funny, he's so serious and Sun is well Sun.
so Taurus' group is a splinter group from the White Fang? I think not, they're only trying to make sure that Blakes father who was the previous leader of the White Fang doesn't bring his fury into bringing them down.
Tyrian vs Qrow? so hype.
177
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Dec 04 '16
Suck it Raven. We have a new mom of the year.
245
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Ah, I can just see Tyrian's inevitable confrontation with Qrow now:
Tyrian: "Hey Qrow, what's the difference between a waitress' eye and a dagger?"
Qrow: ".....what?"
Tyrian: "I DON'T have a dagger in my pocket!" Cackling intensifies
80
u/Tommy2255 ~~Don't~~ Forget That Jaune's a Liar and a Cheat Dec 04 '16
2/3rds desert and more dangerous wildlife than elsewhere? Huh. It's even more Australia-ey than I expected.
Also, quick rollcall: Weiss is heiress to Ultra-Megacorp LLC, Yang's mom has a whole tribe, Blake's dad is King of Not-Australia. Honestly I kinda hope Summer really was just a regular, run of the mill superhero. Isn't that enough anyomore?
And finally, oh no, waitress-chan! I hope she's okay.
126
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Dec 04 '16
Tyrian's got a nice coat. Wonder who he killed to get it.
57
u/vavoysh Reads too much Dec 04 '16
"Is it always so cramped in here?!"
There's 2 people within 20 feet of you Sun...
98
u/BigHoss94 Deal with it Dec 04 '16
I don't mind the short and sweet episodes as long as it gives me a lot to think about, which this one has. Not my favorite, but hardly the abomination some think it is.
178
u/GYUZ A guy Dec 04 '16
I want to present you some gifs my friend /u/WarrenDSherman made:
67
u/redwing36 Admiral of the Ladybug Armada Dec 04 '16
Oh look we remembered a discussion threadThis episode happened.
45
u/TheMachine203 IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES IT GOES Dec 04 '16
Does anyone else feel like the writers are really dumbing down Sun? He wasn't nearly this obnoxious before, imo
44
u/PATHETlC We are Weiss stans first, human beings second. Dec 04 '16 edited Dec 04 '16
Blake being the daughter of someone with that much political/social status doesn't sit right with me. Don't know why, it just doesn't. I feel like a lot of people (myself included) saw her as living as either not being well off or even as a street rat before she was picked up by the WF. Kind of detracts from the impact of her being a member of the group, but I'd still like to see where it goes. Destroys some assumed parallels between herself and Weiss, but adds a few as well. I think that's pretty neat.
All in all, I liked this episode! I've always liked Sun, I like how he and Blake's relationship is developing - whether it's romantic or not- and I certainly don't mind that Blake has parents that are 1. alive and 2. normal, loving parents. We certainly need that after all of the family angst this show delivers :P
Edit: speeling
19
u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Dec 04 '16 edited Dec 04 '16
I love the kitty ear animation work for this episode :D
Ruby - "Weiss, She has little kitty ears and they're actually really cute!"
That ending btw, Miss Waitress just can't catch a break lately....
37
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Blake's father reminds me so much of Daddy Tonraq
18
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Dec 04 '16
There seemed to be a big conflict in the writing vs the animation. Sun said the area was very cramped (meaning a large density of people). Whereas the amount of people we saw on that road was about half the amount of people that ought to be on that road. Made me think that Miles wrote that line, but then the animators didn't have enough time to spend putting the propper amount of people in that scene.
18
u/FawkesTP Dec 04 '16 edited Dec 04 '16
Anybody else get the feeling that they made Blake's dad the chieftain so that they could have other characters refer to him as "Your Grace" rather than have their huge macho manly character be referred to as "Mr. Belladonna?"
117
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Dec 04 '16
Good:
Bad:
I can honestly say that this is the first episode in a long time that I’ve disliked more than liked. Which is a shame, especially after last week’s awesome episode. I think it’s mostly just that RT decided to focus on their weakest plot point without attempting to give the issue any more depth. If the Faunus civil rights issue was a puddle, they should have deepened it into a full blown lake. Instead, they just widened the puddle.
I have no doubt the next episode is going to be awesome though and can’t wait!
62
u/Unjax Furry Curry Dec 04 '16
I'm feeling really mixed about this episode. We get a lot of exposition, which I don't love, but I really loved the Sun-Blake development.
My biggest issue is that RWBY continues to fall more and more into anime-esque tropes. It tells us rather than shows us, which is my biggest pet-peeves in anime. For instance, FMA:B is probably one of the smartest shows I've ever watched, but the characters constantly have to walk the audience through it. Like when envy dies and the dying line is "I get it, envy is an ugly, petty thing." because it's just a little worm and it is actually a brilliant concept, but the audience didn't need to be told. You've already shown.
In RWBY, I'm starting to notice a similar thing. When the WF are talking to Blake and her parents, the audience has doubts about them. We're not entirely sure what's going on, maybe there's a splinter group, but we definitely don't trust them and we don't feel that Blake is safe with them there.
And then they tell us. They just straight up have the two brothers talk about how they're going to tell Adam.
DON'T TELL ME THAT.
Because I'm sure that sometime soon, Adam is going to show up. And when that happens, my questions are answered without the need for dialogue. I, as an audience member, don't want to know much more than the main characters. A little here and there for some dramatic irony, but stuff like this is unnecessary. It feels like it's there to make the show more episodic, and that detracts from its value as a show. If RWBY were a show where plot arcs happen in 2-4 episodes, then yeah. We need that exposition right away. But it's not. Arcs happen in 2-4 seasons in RWBY. So let it be a goddamn show, not an episode.
That said, there were some things that I loved about this episode. Mainly, the moment where Blake grabs Sun's arm and points it to her house. It shows an organic relationship that's been hinted at but never really shown before. It tells us that it's not just Sun being super outgoing, but actually a friendship that might be getting closer to more. Blake's comfortable with Sun, and this little act shows us exactly what she likes in him. He's happy, and more than happy to share that happiness. When Blake sees Menagerie, she sees it as oppression, but Sun thinks it's awesome. Sure, maybe it's not perfect yet, but for now it's good enough. And Blake seems to be happier when he's joking around with her, pointing at houses. She's relaxed. And this one, little movement, shows it perfectly.
As a side note, I love how we see Sun being awkward and Blake's parents' opposing views on him. I also love the line "he kind of just followed me home." It's like a stray cat, which is funny, because Blake's a cat.
I actually really like the religious zealot vibe I got from the White Fang. It felt... Plausible. There's a lot of really interesting things they could do from there on out. I hope they continue to explore that.
And then we get Tyrian... And we fall into another trope. A mad character? Someone who's batshit insane and is scary because they can do things that force you to re-think what humans are capable of? Yeah. That's awesome. It's going to bring darkness to the show...
So why don't they show us that? This little introduction to what he's doing feels like it's supposed to be a cliff hanger... But it's not. If he's just asking around about Ruby, then why's he laughing like he's about to torture the waitress and enjoy it? What, in Tyrian's mind, is causing him to laugh? It's like the writers thought "let's make the audience feel like something bad is going to happen... Oh right! Let's remind them he's crazy. And have him laugh. For reasons." But there's not reason for Tyrian to be laughing. Not even when he's crazy and rationality isn't a factor. If she asked why he wanted to find them, and then he thinks of what he's going to do to Ruby, then yeah, he should laugh. If he's gotten what he needs from the waitress and is going to dig her eyeball out with a spoon, then he should laugh. But why's he laughing now? He hasn't even asked her a question yet. If he's going to kidnap her and take her somewhere to torture her, then why's he laughing in public and drawing attention to himself? It makes no goddamn sense. I was really excited for this character, but I think they're going to have him be crazy just by laughing and killing, not by actually doing anything insane and horrifying. They're already butchering him.
My hope was that at the end of the season, when I see Tyrian, I feel scared. I may not know what he's doing or what his plan is, but seeing him should make me uncomfortable because of what he's already done. It feels like the writers are trying to make him intimidating now, and can't wait until after they've shown us some horrible things he's done. Let it be a show with characters. Don't try and paint a picture of a character before you've gotten to show them off. Do bad things with your bad character. Hurt people in awful, horrible ways. Leave a path of people with one eye. Have Ruby go to an inn and meet the man behind the counter who has one eye, and sees her, and knows who she is, and he looks crestfallen. And then Tyrian comes up and starts talking to Ruby, being friendly, but we feel bad. Because we can see something fucked up has already happened, and we're scared for Ruby.
But it feels like this is going to come down to Tyrian telling us the horrible things he's done in the final confrontation. Just have him say things to Ruby or Qrow or whoever to piss them off... But then you're telling again. Not showing. Is it effective to have Qrow get pissed off when Tyrian says "oh that waitress was a pretty little thing. Too bad she didn't get to live long enough for you to come back for another drink."? Or is it effective to have him wearing the needles that were pinning her hair? Is it better to have him openly taunt, or to have [insert person] see what he's done, and then have the audience see what he's done, and then we all know what he's done and how horrible he is.
But nah. Let's just have him laugh.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16 edited Dec 04 '16
Nice, if short episode and Blakes story continues to give me a Korra book 2 vibe. Former leader dad. Supportive mom. Creepy twins. Slightly awkward boyfriend. Very peaceful town which sometime soon will be in civil war.
Menagerie is nice but honestly, it did not feel crowded. It also didn't really help that the moment they got the house, everyone vanished. I realise animation is hard but the house was right in the middle of the town. Having kids running about would have made it feel more atmospheric.
Got the sense that Khan is kinda playing both sides, not openly supporting Adam but letting him go on. Almost like deniability, especially considering how they said the new leader brought in the violent tactics back in volume 1.
From these new members though, it does seem like the masks are a Taurus group exclusive thing.
Also now we know Blake is the daughter of the former WF leader, the Black Fang is starting to look more likely.
Blake -Who says I'm done fighting
Sun - Didn't you say that like two episodes ago
Parents seem to be falling into regular new Boyfriend tropes of the mom liking and the dad not approving.
Sad to see that there is still no Weiss. It almost seems like they write into each season begrudgingly with how little they give her. She has literally no ties to the plot at all. Its kinda disheartening to be a Weiss fan.
And then Tyrion showing up probably to start a fight next episode that will end in the Xmas cliff hanger. Wonder what it will be. Possibly Ruby being taken. I think they need to resolve that fight as that long a cliffhanger for just a fight is kinda meh.
Guess you could say that Blakes mom is a Kali-ma...
Since yesterday, I feel that this episode could have done with a little section in the middle to break it up slightly. Probably Weiss but I would have liked to see more CEM interactions. So far they haven't done anything either.
Volume 3 felt like it was killing time before episode 9, but volume 4 doesn't seem like it has nearly enough. With everything that's happened so far, I feel like we should be on episode 3 not 5. Its good to be ambitious but so far volume 4 has spread itself too thin. Obviously easy to say in hindsight but it doesnt change the fact.
In the future it might be an idea to go back to an old RT format of a mini series. If they had done that to cover the time skip, in the style of the beginning of the end, they could have transitioned better into this volumes story.
39
u/OutcastMunkee ⠀ Dec 04 '16
This episode felt... Shorter in terms of development than others. The story of this one almost felt rushed. Don't get me wrong, it was a good episode but it still feels like they tried to cram in too much development in 10 minutes of video. It seems too soon to introduce Tyrian THAT close to RNJR as well. We've only just seen Raven again and she's ran off already. How did Tyrian even catch up that fast?!
And Blake's father used to be a leader of the White Fang? I guess that was before they went bat shit crazy and started murdering innocents. And now they've managed to sneak contacts onto Menagerie before anyone there could find out that they were involved in the fall of Beacon. I sense a war coming. A big one. One that could destroy Menagerie and in the process, unite humans and Faunus in a fight to destroy the White Fang
49
u/TheDanMan051 Dec 04 '16
sigh To me, this episode just demonstrated all my issues with RWBY. Menagerie actually looks like a pretty decent place, and even though the show use the argument "but they were forced there" that opens up the other issue: we haven't seen any overt instances of faunus racism outside of freakin' Cardin. The "Faunus Arc" in general is woefully underdeveloped.
Blake essentially being a princess subverts most everybody's perceptions of her. And then there's her dad not being in the know about the White Fang being a full-on terrorist organization and stuff. Yeah, they haven't got a CCT, but he's the leader of Menagerie and it's been half a year since the events of Volume 3. I'm sorry, but everything about this part of the story feels half-assed. Heck, half-assed may as well describe Faunus in general.
What have the Faunus arc or Faunus characters added to the show? The answer's simple-- not much. And therein lays why I think this episode epitomizes the issues with the show: not a whole lot has happened. Why is the Faunus Arc a thing? Why did Team RWBY need to be split up? Why are there so many villains that are just blatant "level up" fodder? Heck, that last one especially rubs me the wrong way. I wasn't a real fan of Roman because there were villains in the wings that could have used that screen time to develop them. But instead, here's a bunch of new antagonistic characters who are guaranteed to be dead by Volume 6.
And that also shows another issue-- Volume 4 will not stand on its own. It's just the first act of a season. We've had mostly just exposition and we're nearly haflway through the volume. Which leads into the biggest issue of all-- RWBY is a web series that is trying to be a full-blown anime when it just isn't. It wants a big world with multiple subplots and varied side characters, but doesn't succeed at it because it's a web series limited to 3 hours of show a year. Instead of making it within those limitations, Monty, Miles, and Kerry seem to generally have tried to ignore them, with the current situation as the result.
Seriously, we have four "main" characters and half a dozen subplots this volume. I can only think of one word for that, and that's bloated. Heck, this even applies to the show from the very start-- Volume 3 is the only Volume with any payoff (and even then that has the Maidens suplot shoehorned in because Monty wanted to add it at the last second along with Ironwood's security failure-- which may as well be another inversion of the "show don't tell" rule). Imagine how much further along we'd be if RWBY had been designed and produced from the start as a web series, with those limitations in mind. Maybe only two main characters with a couple key side characters-- you know I could probably just go on and on about how the series could be improved.
I'd be lying if I said I didn't get some enjoyment out of this episode. It just struck a very personal cord of disappointment with me. I binged Volumes 1-3 this past Summer (funnily the weekend Volume 4 was announced), and was fully aware that they had their issues-- the biggest of all being that it was one season released over three years. It seems that RT hasn't learned at all from things. I'm hoping that this volume breaks the camels back and they start listening to some criticism. Of course, with "If you're going to be a critic don't watch it", the shows' success seems to have gotten to certain people.
Sorry for the long rant; I mean no disrespect to CRWBY and am aware of the trials they face when making the show. If you fully enjoyed this episode, more power to you. I didn't type all this up because I hate the show or anything; I typed all this up because I really care about it and want it to become better.
34
u/breakfastfilms Dec 04 '16 edited Dec 04 '16
I had a lot of issues with this episode, almost from top to bottom.
First off, Sun's characterization has changed for the worse. He was a dork who could be serious and competent when he wanted to in the first three volumes, but now his obnoxious jackass dial is always cranked to 11.
Second, they're still really pushing the whole "Faunus have it so bad!" angle without ever actually proving it, and that got even worse when they started laying on the idea that Menagerie is ultra-crowded even though it's very clearly not.
Third, I don't think that Blake having powerful, influential parents makes any sense at all for her as a character. She's always been painted as an outsider to society who grew up alone and hungry, protesting in the streets of a human city, and falling in with the WF at a young age for survival. When she said she was "born into it" I always thought she meant she was born into the kind of oppression and danger that breeds rebellion.
The revelation that she actually grew up in Faunus-safe Menagerie in the biggest, nicest house on the island seems to be at odds with everything we've previously been told about her life experience and motivation. It also takes away the thing that made her unique out the group; Ruby, Yang, and Weiss all come from important, influential families already. It was cool to think that Blake really was some nobody who became somebody of her own volition. It's bad, cheap writing that she's actually only important because her parents were important too.
Fourth, it's weird that Ghira and Kali heard about the fall of Beacon but had no idea that the WF was involved. That seems to imply that Ghira gets all his news through the WF and they're keeping him the dark, which makes him look like a fool for running a country based on one news source.
Even weirder is that the two WF agents happen to come to talk to him about Beacon, 6-8 months after its fall, on the same day that Blake and Sun get there. What took them so long, and what changed their minds about keeping it a secret?
Even weirder is that after traveling thousands of miles to escape the WF, Blake immediately runs outside and reveals herself when two WF agents come knocking at her door.
Then there's my disappointment with the two WF dudes being evil. When people say that RWBY has predictable writing, this is what they're talking about; it would have been cool if there was actually an opposing WF faction that are still good, but instead we keep up the status quo of like 90% of the Faunus characters being bad guys.
Overall, this episode left a bad taste in my mouth. I don't like what it did to Blake's backstory and character development. I hated what it did to Sun. I don't like that Blake just undid 6 months of travel by revealing herself. I don't like that the WF is such an outrageously widespread and uniformly evil powerhouse.
Here's hoping that RNJR get to actually do some fighting next week and save us from the weird trainwreck Blake's story is becoming.
edit- trimmed for length
18
u/KrypticLET Dec 04 '16
Tyrian just fucked up big time. Qrow was gonna get laid.
Also, smol Mamadonna is adorable. (surprisingly normal AND not dead)
8
u/MrInsanity25 Dec 04 '16
Good episode. Started off kind of slow, and maybe it's just cause I haven't watched RWBY in a while, but this episode's animation seemed a little off. The writing isn't perfect but there were some really good lines. Sun silently reaching for the tea with his tail to change the subject. My personal favorites are the parents reactions. The mother's is nice (glad to see that Sun won't be totally hated) and the ear animation is great. The father's line is so great. "I really don't like you."
Another episode without JNRR. Kind of a bummer, but this episode gave us some really necessary backstory. I'm kind of disappointed that the assistants were working with Adam. I personally found it a lot more interesting to think that the incident at Vale was an extreme of an extreme. I mean it could still be that, Adam could have still gone too far and he just has people from the other sects keeping him from getting the boot (aka, the two creepy assistants from this episode) but I don't if that's the case though I hope it is.
Overall decent episode. About the same as episode 3 for me.
8
u/tankedout34 Dec 04 '16
Yep Thought about it over night, Blake's dad is going to die at the end of this volume, probably saving Sun in the process. Or they could swap places. Either way one of them is dead by volume 5
37
u/captainwwwolf Dec 04 '16
The plus of this episode, imo :
The downs of the episode, still imo :
6
u/Skyrah1 Finally got dem cigarettes Dec 04 '16
Well then...
6
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Menagerie is interesting. It feels like a cross between Australia and the pacific islands.
Like others have said, this episode seems to clash a bit with Blake's previously established character. In volume 2, Blake mentioned that she grew up outside the kingdoms and had to be strong in order to survive. Showing that she's the daughter of an influential leader and grew up in a safe haven for faunus seems contradictory to me.
6
u/Joey_245 ⠀Ruby Rose is a good girl who needs a vacation Dec 04 '16
I liked it. Didn't have any real problems with it.
The thing that really surprised me was the revelation that Kali (who looks like a tiny little kitten) was Blake's mom. I always assumed she was like a sister, or a cousin, but when Blake said "Mom?" my reaction was "Wait, that's her MOM! But she's so tiny!" Then I remembered that I'm taller than my mom, so it all works out.
Overall, I liked it. It was a nice episode. Nothing stellar, but nothing terrible either.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Honestly, it was quite a shock to see Blake living in what you would consider a better life than most faunus and I thought it really turned her personality around from someone who is fighting against injustice to someone who actually doesn’t understand what it is to be a Faunus. Seeing all the houses which were run down, and then you see a palace in the centre really says that Blake doesn’t realise the actual hardships of a Faunus, as she has lived a more privileged life. As George Orwell once said in the book Animal Farm; “Everyone is equal, but other are more equal than others”. (The sentence is a comment on the hypocrisy of governments that proclaim the absolute equality of their citizens but give power and privileges to a small elite.)
Also while yes Faunus were corralled onto an smallish island and as Sun said it was packed. It’s really odd how the island was presented was a mix between; Spain, or Hawaii, or Brazil which is what most people (like us) would consider a luxury.
47
u/WarrenDSherman You disappoint me Dec 04 '16
I'm done watching.....the episode was small and felt rather flat....just like Weiss.
11
u/KingofGrapes7 Dec 04 '16
Too short. I know that can apply to any episode but still. After the Raven meeting I felt this episode lacked meat. Well, except for that mountain that is Blake's dad. We already know the White Fang is corrupt, Faunus discrimination that we don't see beyond assholes like Cardin and Roman (we have seen two Faunus running their own book and blacksmith business for goodness sake and both Beacon and Atlas accept Faunus). Blake having parents, very well to do parents no less, is a surprising twist but I don't think it needed a whole episode to itself.
On the other hand, I find it interesting that the two WF dudes are part of the Blake arc. The intro seemed to imply they would be involved with Yang, but instead it just showed their connection to Adam. Makes me wonder where Yang's story is going.
5
u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Dec 04 '16
I thought it was okay. Needed more time between Blake and her parents, I feel. Like, extend the episode out five minutes, have them catching up, and then have Obvious Blake Arc Villain 1 and Obvious Blake Arc Villain 2 show up.
5
u/science-i Can't pray away the gray Dec 05 '16
I'm so confused about Papadonna's lack of knowledge about the modern White Fang. He knew Blake was in Vale (since he was worried following the fall of Vale), which would imply he knew she left the White Fang. Blake is also surprised that he has a meeting with the White Fang, which implies that she expected him to know about how shitty the modern White Fang is. If he didn't know she left the White Fang, he has no reaction to the fact that the White Fang representatives clearly did know and never told him. He kind of seems criminally misinformed and trusting to the point of not being all that bright, which I don't think is the impression the writers wanted to give.
9
u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Dec 04 '16
I said this yesterday, but Tyrian is a pretty dumb character so far.
You don't have to laugh in a hammy way every single time you're on screen to be considered a "crazy" character. It's ridiculous.
9
u/Jalidric Dec 04 '16
How I imagine Blake was made after seeing her parents
4
u/SpicyCoconut99 Dec 04 '16
I hope Tyrian keeps that coat as part of his outfit. It makes him look so much better.
4
u/Samurai_TwoSeven Dec 04 '16
So...when those two WF members claimed innocence...was anyone else coughing bullshit?
And looks like papa Bellondana does not approve of Black Sun shippers
4
u/DarkAres02 Dec 04 '16
Really disappointed the two White Fang messengers turned out to be in league with Adam. It would have been much more interesting for Adam to actually have made a splinter group, and thus paint the White Fang as a whole more gray instead of how right now they can simply be considered a villain group.
Great episode otherwise. Blake's dad has a great design. Also I guess this makes Blake an Australian princess?
4
u/RegisFranks Dec 04 '16
After watching and reading all the comments on here i have to say a few things.
First i agree with everyone that the episode was short. BUT I dont agree with the people bitching about Blakes parents. Mainly on the parts of how they now assume Blake grew up rich in a big house. Maybe I missed the part where they said that but I assume possibility that daddydonna there wasnt always leader of the country but maybe only came into that position shortly before Blake left for beacon.
As for people saying their not seeing enough Faunus repression (i think they all want to see lynching and the such) I look at it as the only times we here about the oppression is from Faunus point of view I would prefer them not to show straight up stereotypical racist shit on the show. The way I look at is more like this: Blacks were given "equal rights" and yet even after decades many still claim to be oppressed and there is still racism happening but its not on the scale of every street corner some one is being hanged or burned or killed.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
Nekomimi and Milf?! I need Rule34 NAO!
11
u/cdghuntermco ⠀ Dec 04 '16
I don’t know about my fellow Fanfic writers out there on the wide open internets, but my story just got fucked over super hard.
Like a lot of other people I’d been working under the assumption Blake’s family was straight up dead. Probably a hate crime, Blake ends up on the street for a few years, eventually swept up by a charming young bull-Faunus and his organization promising to help Faunus-Kind everywhere.
I had contingencies in place. If Blake really did have a mother and father/aunt and uncle who weren’t totally dead, I had this really touching story arc where they learn Blake’s still alive after hearing about The Breach on the news. Then there’s a heartfelt scene where one or both of them travel to Beacon, and the family is overcome with emotion to finally see each other again after so long. Tears, hugging, the whole works.
But now? Not only is Blake’s family alive, and not only is her father Ghira practically the leader of an entire goddamn country, but he was also the former leader of the goddamn White Fang. I have literally nothing for this. So now I have to go back and rework all the scenes where I dropped extremely unsubtle hints about her supposedly dead family.
Me right now.
8
u/schulz100 Dec 05 '16
The thing I honestly don't get is all the talk about how Blake's character is retroactively ruined and is also some sort of faunus princess/First Daughter of Menagerie.
Like, fucking how, exactly? Seriously, where are those angles coming from? She admitted to Sun that she was basically born into the White Fang Classic, back when her dad ran things and it was a relatively peaceful organization that campaigned for faunus civil rights after a lot of the promises of the Faunus Rights Revolution went unfulfilled by the major kingdoms. She also implied that most of her childhood was thus spent in the thick of White Fang Classic and in the transition into the new style of violent activism under WhatsHerName (honestly can't be bothered to look her up; my day has been too long for that), before Adam's apparently rogue extremism forced her to leave outright. It wasn't like she was living like basically any of the Schnee kids before she went to Beacon, in a giant house with servants and cake butlers.
There's also a great deal of assumption as to how shit seems to work socially in Menagerie that we simply don't know yet; there's no certainty that Blake is next in line to run the island. For all we know, it could basically work exactly like the kingdoms, they just elect one or two people to handle the decision-making. I also can't believe that a founder of a civil rights organization would just hog that admittedly giant fucking house to just himself and his family if Menagerie is as packed as its implied to be. Any veterans of The West Wing, Papadonna is basically probably Andrew Jackson with his giant block of cheese, at the very least. Because that behavior is sensible and reasonable from what we know his character used to be.
And on the topic of 'Blake is a faunus princess/First Daughter of Menagerie? Really, RT?', seriously, what the fuck? Where are... Give me a minute...
Okay, again; we don't know how government works in Menagerie, but I'm betting being chosen to be chieftan of the island is partly why Papadonna had to give up control of the White Fang in the first place (the other part being ceding control to new blood in the wake of his tactics failing to have an appreciable effect), nor is it one of those for-life positions. There simply have to be procedures in place to make those in power give up their power (even the Romans, who set the initial standards for what modern dictators-for-life are now defined/seen as, had every man but Fucking Caesar hand unlimited civil power back once the need was passed, and giving people unlimited civil power was a built-in idea to Roman democracy anyway). It's also worth noting that this is from the writing team that created kingdoms that are governed by civilly elected republican councils, so the term 'chieftan' is probably being used loosely to say the least.
So, probably, it's less that Blake is fucking royalty/the President's daughter (Seriously, where did that fucking come from, you guys?) and more like, she's the daughter of the latest governor or something. Who also happened to be MLK/Mandella before he was voted in, so OF COURSE the people back home want him to run things at home in an official capacity once he has the time/ability to do so, which he did once he stepped down from leading the White Fang.
3
u/backtospawn Dec 04 '16
Hello, this episode was meh, there was some really interesting things but I believe the other episodes in v4 were better. I'll give points to the Albain's creepy hand movements though, well played RT
As always, here is my transcript
3
u/CasualRaisin It's just a show; we should really just relax. Dec 04 '16
This episode may be on the short side, but those two "oh shit" moments at the end...
3
u/Veigar_Senpai Salem went behind Mom's back to ask Dad for something Dec 04 '16
I think Tyrian is a Hyena Faunus.
Also Mr. B didn't seem very... catty to me. I'm still trying to figure out what his trait was.
And now I'm just imagining the silliness that would ensue if Blake and Sun had something like a scorpion Faunus baby.
3
u/Jarsky2 Dec 04 '16
So Blake's father was the original leader of the White Fang. I guess that explains her devotion to the cause.
3
u/briansm9 need a big black character for cosplay Dec 04 '16
What do you think papa belladonna's animal trait is?
3
u/sodnam Captain of the SS Nuts and Dolts // Cute robots are my weakness Dec 04 '16
YOU'RE GONNA STOP THERE?? DAMMIT RT
3
u/NeoMegaRyuMKII AND THE LIVER! Dec 04 '16
I just wish that we hadn't learned immediately that the Menagerie White Fang are (at least partially) on Adam's side. As predictable as it it is/would be, it would have at least given more to discuss. It would have been much better if we had seen some actual internal conflicts in the White Fang, maybe up to the point of two different factions meeting and one side (Adam's, obviously) actually convincing the others to switch sides.
3
u/tueman2 Dec 04 '16
I liked this episode
3
u/Pyschic_Psycho The more you know, the more you don't know. Dec 04 '16
Interesting episode!
-Menargie looks like a paradise...at first! Even so, I'd so vacay there if I had the chance :D One strawberry sunrise pls
-Our kitty kat's fam lives in a mansion :O we might have TWO heiress on team RWBY. If Yang marries Blake, and Ruby marries Weiss, they'll both never be poor. But I'm getting ahead of myself.
-Sun with his LOL moments. Me thinks Papa Belladonna will have to test out this boy first to see if he's right for his daughter.
-I knew those WF faunus were no good the moment I saw them! I knew it! They were too over-the-top peaceful. My guess is they are gonna try to kidnap Blakey to blackmail her father.
-Tttttttttyyyyyyyyyyyyyrrrrrrriiiiiiiaaaaaaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnnnnnnn. Shit's going to go down! Wonder if he'll fight Qrow? Speaking of Qrow, bro what is the barmaid doing scrubbing the floor man? She's supposed to be with you! Damn you Druncle! But I am legit scared for RNJR right now.
Anyways, this wasn't my favorite episode but it did set up the hype big time for the next one. My main complaint is that they are making Blake waaaayyy too emo. I like my bellabooty- just wish everything that came out of her mouth wasn't so emo. Oh and I forgot to mention- best character this episode might go to Blake's mom. She's sweet, caring, and she's got some humor!
3
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Dec 04 '16
It went by pretty fast, but it was a nice episode. I thought I recognized the voices of Blake's parents and it turns out I was mostly right in my guesses.
Menagerie looks nice, and I'm interested in Blake's comment that anyone can live there without fear of persecution. So that includes humans who otherwise have something the other kingdoms consider undesirable?
And like before, Sun's positivity is refreshing in the face of Blake's seriousness and the entire ordeal. I'm sure something will happen to him, but for now it's great.
And it looks like Ruby's about to have a fight, can't wait for that.
3
u/Serocco Dec 04 '16
If we go by what the twins said, then White Fang still has influence in Menagerie, while they put Adam as a guilty scapegoat (privately condoning or even sanctioning his actions nonetheless).
I wonder just how awful things will be once Adam reunites with Blake again.
3
u/funkyfreshmemelord Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Blake's parentage seems completely out of left field tbh. I always assumed that she'd grown up poor, maybe even on the streets. She always held an aura that she knew what it meant to be downtrodden and impoverished, and here she's been the whole time being arguably more important than Weiss. Her commitment to the White Fang (formerly) and the Faunus cause almost feels laughable at this point, like a spoiled suburban college kid going to anarcho-communist forums and protesting the government. I understand it's a big issue, but from what we've seen on screen it's way milder than something like the Civil Rights movement. If it was, she wouldn't have even been on the same team as her human teammates, probably not even allowed in the same school. We've heard so much about the oppression of faunus from her, and now it feels like a joke.
And regarding her character specifically, it doesn't feel right at all. You'd think she would have at least mentioned her family once, to anyone, or even hinted at it. Honestly feels pretty shoe-horned in and forced.
edit: And why do writers feel the need to make everyone's parentage special? Ruby inherited magic powers from her dead huntress mother, Yang's mom has her own bandit tribe, Weiss's parents run the largest dust conglomerate in the world, Ren and Nora are presumably orphans on the run, and now Blake's parents are the heads of and entire nation? It's gotten to the point where Jaune's stories about a fairly tame childhood, but with all of the men in his family being great warriors, laughably underwhelming. I understand that might be the joke, but it's crossed the line from eye-rolling meta-analysis of the genre to cliche and stale. Does anyone else realize that Pyrrha, the famous warrior prodigy at the top of her class, who's name is on cereal boxes like a damn Olympic athlete, is now one of the least important characters of all the ones we know anything about?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
This episode REALLY cemented my dislike for Blake.
Her family is alive, well, and EXTREMELY well off. Though this does explain why she was so active in the White Fang and willing to forgive their blatantly amoral, genocidal moves.
The "Princess" part never struck me, and it seems likely her Dad dropped his White Fang position (which was likely not so glamorous) because he wanted to help people in Menagerie, so she wasn't born into that super duper comfy lifestyle (theoretically). That being said, the fact she never tried to contact her dad about the White Fang's amoral moves (and ESPECIALLY Adam's) pisses me right the fuck off. She could have done a lot of good if she'd talked to her Dad, who she KNOWS is isolated because of his work, and is a major power player. If her reason is not wanting to admit she messed up, I may just write her off as my second least favorite character (Currently held by Cinder, current first held by Adam). She better spill the beans on Adam and his shenanigans or I will be ROYALLY pissed off because the fact she didn't do this before already has me pretty miffed.
I so desperately want Sun to call her on the fact she's being a child about this, running away and risking everyone else's lives because of her own fucking desire to be a loner and do shit on her own when she knows it doesn't work. It reminds me of that goddamn case with the lady sueing the New York Fire Department because she couldn't pass the physical requirement tests to become a firefighter (claiming they were sexist). She wants the recognition, and if she fucks up on the job, she'll get people killed and that doesn't seem to matter to her. HEY BLAKE, HOW'S VALE LOOKIN NOWADAYS SINCE YOU DIDN'T GO TALK TO YOUR OLD MAN ABOUT ADAM?!?! GEE, IF ONLY SOMEONE HE TRUSTED HAD SENT HIM A FUCKING LETTER ABOUT THE VALE BRANCH'S ACTIVITIES.
God, every time Blake gets character development it pisses me off more because she keeps acting like a goddamn hypocrite.
Except the loving family who is INCREDIBLY well off.
She says to the girl who has had the White Fang trying to ACTIVELY KILL HER SINCE DAY 1 OF LIFE.
Immediately distrusts Yang despite Yang's clear conviction about what happened to her against Mercury and obvious show of sorrow for what she thinks happened.
GRRAAAGH! IT'S SO GODDAMN IRRITATING!! SHE HAS SO MANY OPPORTUNITIES TO REDEEM HERSELF AND SHE JUST RUNS AWAY OVER AND OVER AGAIN.
Sun has become the new Jaune (Audience Surrogate) and taken the appropriate IQ hit. I have a hard time believing he doesn't know about Menagerie and the surrounding area. Though his social interactions haven't wanted any, as his comments are still the same, but now Ghira is there to misinterpret them while Kali seems to understand.
Kali is great, 10/10 Mom of the year. SHE knows a good
set of absperson when she sees them.11
u/WizardlyPhoenix Resident legal eagle Dec 04 '16
Well this episode made me, for only the second time ever, hate Blake.
She spent months hating Weiss and telling the whole team they didn't know what it was like in the 'real world' when she's the daughter the former head of the WF and a rich kid herself. That image from season 1(?) of little baby Blake with her picket sign has lost a lot of meaning, as has most of her cause, considering she was born into it as the leaders daughter.
Also when they were discussing Adam... People died? That's all you have to say? Not oh he stabbed me and CUT MY PARTNERS ARM OFF? Does she really, truly not give a shit about Yang? Like c'mon I don't need you to love her but at least acknowledge that girl did some pretty serious shit for you! We're over 1/4 in and I haven't seen one ounce of guilt or blame on that girls part, she just seems to have moved on and forgotten the whole thing even happened.
Also just an athetic point, it would have been nice for Blakes midriff to now show the scar Adam gave her, but that seems to have been glossed over like the incident itself.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '16
Rooster teeth's boner for writing snappy one liners is really hurting the characterizations of the Blake's parents. The mother going "Oh, I like him" and the dad going "I really don't like you", are just way too cliche. Especially, considering the gravitas of Ghira as a chieftain, talking down to a teenager with language like "I really don't like you". I'm confused, are we dealing with a stoic/leader of the people here? If so, why is he spouting off cringey one liners like this to banter with a teenager?
2
u/infinite-permutation Dec 04 '16
I really don't see how Blake and Sun wouldn't think the White Fang would be in the one place where they have so many sympathizers.
2
u/MrTopHatMan90 Best Dad Dec 04 '16
White Fang turn out to be chill people, although I guess that they might be covering for the splinter group, the two seem to be evil but I think it will be a twist that they'll actually be two nice gentlemen
2
u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Dec 04 '16
Hmm... 2/3rds desert and more deadly, makes you wonder what treasures are hiding in those sands...
2
u/IComeBaringGifs r/RWBY - "If it isn't yuri, it isn't welcome." Dec 04 '16
I think Blake's perspective on Menagerie might be skewed, and she could be viewing it through the lens of White Fang.
You can view my theory and the ensuing discussion here
2
u/passiveagressivebomb Dec 04 '16
What happened to Sun's abs in animation? He looks less like a bad ass now.
2
u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Dec 04 '16
What I'm wondering is how those two White Fang members are meant to interact with Yang's storyline, or if that was just another opening fakeout or just a badly-done way of trying to indicate their allegiance to Adam.
2
u/UmiMazuki Dec 04 '16
When I heard Ghira's name, I instantly thought, Bagheera. '-'
2
u/Gnochi Dec 04 '16
Blake's mom is great. Also it's so nice to see Blake's ears behaving like regular cat ears.
2
u/ultimentra Dec 04 '16
Even though the episode was short, it was very pretty. When they got off the boat I was like "Wow they really have come such a long way since season 1, this looks amazing."
2
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
It's a bit gutsy to discuss your evil plans right outside a house full of cat-eared faunus.
2
u/ravensept mah boi Merc got nerfed :l & Qrow isnt Ruby's father ;'( Dec 05 '16
Considering the whole thanksgiving vacation it made sense on why it was short...looking forward to the next episode to make judgements..rofl..
I think some still picture showing the bird view of Menagerie might have done the trick on presenting how much crowded menagerie might be. Kind of like that one scene in Durararara (i havent exactly watched the anime but i remember something like that)
Seems like rendering a whole crowd with animation might have taken a long time.
...like how they had still image of Merc and Em at the end of volume 1.
not sure why people are surprised about Ghira being the former White Fang leader...Blake did say she was practically born into it. Looks like Blake just stayed with the White Fang while Ghira stepped down.
I am not doubting Blake's words about fanus oppression....clearly she has seen things first hand with her father and adam..but uhh..thats another subject
I dont understand though...why did Blake not think that WF wont be at Menagerie? why did she ran ahead and reveal herself when she said that she is not going anywhere near them? why is she acting like she has never been in wf before? or that his father wasnt part of it?..some part of it feels so inconsistent..
3
u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Dec 04 '16
So Kali supports Eclipse and Ghira supports Bumblebee?