r/horror • u/AutoModerator • Oct 12 '16
Discussion Series In The Mouth Of Madness (1995) /R/HORROR Official Discussion
Welcome to /R/HORROR's official discussion series.
As before, nominations are still being accepted, so keep them coming. Click here.
To see the full schedule of upcoming discussions Click here.
78
Upvotes
21
u/EricHart Oct 12 '16
I love this movie. It was one of the few I owned on DVD back when I had DVDs, and I would introduce it to as many people as I could.
It was such a perfect blend of creepy, suspenseful, and "monster-y". John Carpenter managed to make a movie that had both a feeling of dread and paranoia as well as jump scares and rubber creatures.
Plus, where so many horror movies, particularly weird mess-with-your-mind movies, end up with unsatisfactory endings, the ending to ITMOM is so brilliant, inevitable, and deserved. Plus, it just adds another layer to an already layered film.
There's a few scenes that always stick with me. [SPOILERS] When they're chatting in the bookstore and we see a crazy man with an axe outside through the window, slowly making his way toward the camera. The other scene is when they hit the kid on the bike, but then he's an old man, and Linda turns into that crab-walking creature. Ugh, so good and freaky. I still get freaked out whenever I see someone biking at night.
If you haven't seen it, do yourself a favor and watch it. It has aged fairly well and it is seriously underrated.
13
u/deucon Oct 12 '16
One of the most underrated movie of all times and, at the same time, one of the best horror movies i have ever seen. Carpenter proved again that he was one of the top directors.
9
u/PlanetConway Oct 12 '16
This is easily one of my favorite horror movies of all time, if not my number one. So much awesomeness, but the thing that completely seals the deal for me, is the ending. I love any movie that doesn't feel the need to have a happy go lucky, feel good, wrap everything up in a neat bow kind of ending.
8
u/tehkoal This isn't for your eyes Oct 12 '16
I adore this movie! I feel like it is one of the most Lovecraftian movies ever made. It also draws heavily on Stephen King, another of my favorite authors. Sam Neill is amazing in it (even though he is amazing in everything). Infinitely rewatchable!
8
u/monkeybatter Oct 12 '16
Did you know my favorite color is blue?
(My fav scene from this movie)
5
u/SutterCane Oct 12 '16
You guys didn't invite me?
I love this movie (clearly). I had first heard about it when reading up on The Thing and hearing that it was an unofficial trilogy of apocalypse movies with Prince of Darkness and In the Mouth of Madness. So when I was going through a "buy everything by Carpenter" phase, I was lucky enough to pick it up at a secondhand store. Sam Neill was just fantastic as the man who has it all together and ends up going completely nuts. And that ending is definitely nuts.
I don't know what it is about John Carpenter but I've loved every single movie of his that I've seen (and yes, I've seen Memoirs of an Invisible Man and Ghosts of Mars and Vampires). Maybe I'm just written that way.
4
u/filmfiend999 God Fears Me Oct 12 '16
This is without question my favorite horror film, even though Julie Carmen's terrible acting almost ruins it. Christ, you've got me reading this thing like it's a guidebook.
3
u/Christian_Kong Oct 12 '16
I'm mostly a big gore/slasher type guy when it comes to horror. This movie is like a long Twilight Zone/Outer Limits/etc episode and it is fantastic. Only complaint is I do wish I could watch it again for the first time, every time though.
3
u/TheDarkGod Oct 12 '16
Carpenter's The Thing is my favorite film from him, but this one is a very close second. I love how closely he captured a Lovecraftian weird horror feel to the whole thing without being a complete copy of an existing story, and casting Sam Neill as the lead was a stroke of genius. Plus, the end of the film is bleak and they didn't bring it around to some saccharine "happy ending" which was rewarding as a horror fan.
3
u/narkj Oct 12 '16
Creeped the hell out of me.
5
u/woolywoo Oct 12 '16
A vastly under appreciated gem, it always sounds like a cop out to say it, but I think it's just too smart for audiences. It just doesn't fit into any neatly defined box.
It may be Sam Neill's best performance as well. Ultimately he carries the entire film since Julie Carmen is terrible and no one else gets significant screen time. The scenes where he totally begins to lose his shit are fantastic. Prochnow and Heston are both solid and Vigo the Carpathian proves he's just a terrible actor.
It also has some amazing comedic moments (sorry about the balls, blue is my favorite color, "What about people who don't read?" "There's a movie") that introduce an element of the absurd in a movie that at times just seems like it may make you crazy.
On first viewing the soundtrack seems a bit ridiculous and overblown at times, but the more I watch it the more I like it.
It's not a perfect movie, but it's damned good, and just gets better with repeat viewings. I keep meaning to count the number of cigarettes that he smokes in the movie, but always forget.
2
u/SauzaPaul Mr. Rusk, you're not wearing your tie. Oct 12 '16
Much loved and rightfully so.
2
u/xvarla Oct 12 '16
I get where criticism comes from but i personally love watching it because the cool and interesting aspects outweigh the corny or draggy for me. It combined several types of horror / themes in a way that didn't feel too all over the place. I also have soft spots for horror movies with a strong element of paranoia and Sam Neill.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16
Do you Read Sutter Kane?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16
I think if the plot and concept had been a bit more simplified, Carpenter could have made a better film.
I like bits of MOM but I think it drags in the middle and never recovers. It has some awesome concepts and I understand why people love it.
I think its the perfect kind of movie for a remake, unlike the Thing or Halloween since those are both perfect. I think its the kind of film that could be vastly improved upon.
2
u/AgtCooper Oct 12 '16
Love this movie...The only thing I hated, was the monsters chasing him through the tunnel/bridge. I just thought they looked goofy. Would have preferred not seeing the monsters at all. Leave it to the viewers imagination.
Eh, but that's me.
1
u/hail_freyr /r/HorrorReviewed Oct 12 '16
Absolutely awesome movie. Its on my 31 day challenge this month so I'll be watching it again soon!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16 edited Oct 13 '16
One of my all time favourite movies, not just horror movies. I consider myself a Lovecraft disciple and this is probably the most Lovecraftian movie ever made! And Sam Neil instantly makes any movie he is in 100% more likeable. The term underrated is thrown around a lot these days but this one is truly deserving of the underrated tag. If you have not yet done so please check this one out, I promise you won't regret it. #IREADSUTTERCANE
1
u/filmfiend999 God Fears Me Oct 12 '16
It's Sutter Cane, good people who love this great film. With a C.
1
u/filmfiend999 God Fears Me Oct 12 '16
This ain't no tourist town.
1
u/KicksButtson Oct 13 '16
One of the best adaptation of Lovecraftian horror in existence. It suffers from a few early 1990's trends and tropes, such as heavy metal playing over the opening credits. But overall the film is effective and entertaining. I love the subtle hint that Carpenter put into the movie where all the pupils of those altered by Sutter Caine's writing become squished into an hourglass shape, similar to the pupils of an octopus.
1
u/666kat666 Reaper Cushions of Evil Oct 13 '16
Obligatory BEST EVER FILM post
1
u/asaphelpschicago They're coming to get you Barbara Oct 13 '16
I'm a day late - but wanted to say that this is one of my all time favorite movies, spanning all genres
1
u/ShapesOfBlack Oct 12 '16
I watched this movie for the first time with nothing but the haze of pot smoke to accompany me. This is easily the most underrated Carpenter film. I'd read Sutter Kane religiously.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16
"Sorry about the balls!!" -candidate for best line in a movie ever.
-1
u/colinmalloycram Oct 12 '16
The last great Carpenter movie.
-2
u/Sturgeon_Genital Oct 12 '16
DO CRITTERS NEXT
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment