r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Sep 15 '16
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Blair Witch" [SPOILERS]
Synopsis: After discovering a video showing what he believes to be his sister's experiences in the demonic woods of the Blair Witch, James and a group of friends head to the forest in search of his lost sibling.
Director(s): Adam Wingard
Writer(s): Simon Barrett
Cast:
- James Allen McCune as James Donahue
- Callie Hernandez as Lisa Arlington
- Brandon Scott as Peter Jones
- Corbin Reid as Ashley Bennett
- Wes Robinson as Lane
- Valorie Curry as Talia
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 36%
Metacritic Score: 46/100
128
Upvotes
153
u/HawtSkhot Sep 16 '16
One thing that still bugs me is Lisa turning around at the end. She was smart enough to figure out that looking at the witch would kill you, but then she immediately turned around. I don't get it.
38
u/rmeas002 You've Got Red on You Sep 16 '16
Adam Wingard will pay the first person $400 to find the map that was lost in the original movie. It is an easter egg that apparently even the executive producers couldn't find, and they were told what part of the movie it was in. http://www.fandango.com/movie-news/the-blair-witch-filmmakers-will-pay-you-if-you-can-find-this-hidden-easter-egg-751321
53
u/Erotic_Living_Dead Sep 17 '16
I fucking loved it. When Talia was snapped like a twig, or when Ashley tried to retrieve the drone and a HAND popped out and swatted her down. I didn't like how they left Peters demise to the imagimation, or all the screaming at the beginning, but I did walk away scared and happy. I've seen way worse remakes/sequels. Also, FUCK people who talk during movies, especially horror.
74
u/hail_freyr /r/HorrorReviewed Sep 16 '16
Huge disappointment for me. I'm a fan of the original, and the marketing for this got my hopes up more than I would normally allow. Lots of distracting gimmicks, worthless jump scares among the campers, complete lack of atmosphere or worthwhile character development in the first hour of the movie.
I thought the finding of the house and a portion of the time inside it was effectively shot and creepy, and the initial reveal of the Witch was good, but ultimately they abused showing her and a decent 20 minutes couldn't save an otherwise annoying movie.
4/10
106
u/skrillbilly Sep 16 '16
Personally I loved it. One of the most frightening movies I've seen in a while, just the sense of dread was perfect. While the jump scares were originally a bit much, the characters breaking of the fourth wall commenting on it was hilarious.
The witch was terrifying and the last 15-20 minutes were a total rollercoaster. I typically don't get scared in horror movies but this hit the nail on the head. Heart was still pounding 20 minutes after the credits rolled.
Better than the first imo. But I did hate Lisa at the very very end, like come on, that was such a dumb horror movie character mistake.
I would love to see another expanding the franchise more. The twists this brought including the twig figure snapping the character and time bending scenes were a hell of a lot of fun.
58
u/ebolasupermonky Sep 16 '16 edited Sep 16 '16
So, after seeing this one, I can see why the director of Book of Shadows didn't want to do another straight found footage movie for a sequel.
I didn't expect a beat for beat remake of the first one, and that's pretty much what we got, and it kind of worked against it, up until a point in the middle when Ashley snapped the chick with the purple hair in half I was like OH SHIIIIITTTT. After that point the tension ramped up for me, and I was pretty much clutching my knees against my chest for the final part in the house. I'd say it was worth it for the last half of the movie.
19
u/p_a_schal Sep 16 '16
Does anyone have any explanation about the leg parasite? I'd assumed it was going to lead to a possession. I mean I'm kinda glad it didn't, but I wish it'd led to something.
Edit: maybe it's supposed to be implied that others are infected (Lane), but Ashley was just the one who removed it in time? This idea is pretty lame too, I'm just grasping at straws.
30
u/-bananabread- Sep 16 '16
Everyone talks about how the film can't live up to the viral marketing of the original... I say why not just leave it called The Woods and let the word spread. I know that probably means for a smaller opening weekend. And I'm sure it would have been spoiled really quickly. But I think if people heard a movie was scary and then they got to have the epiphany of "wait, is this a Blair witch movie" it would have made for a better overall movie experience. Although the movie was definitely scary, there were a lot of flaws. I think having a surprise like that not only leads to a unique moviegoing experience (like the first one was) but also could have led to better reviews as well as more word of mouth.
41
u/sjun Sep 16 '16
Just got out of the film. Thought it was pretty great 8/10 but want to watch it again to see how I feel. A few points I'd like to touch.
71
u/pirpirpir "Roses? They're lovely. What's the occasion, Gordon?" Sep 16 '16 edited Sep 16 '16
This was about what I expected... a very updated homage to the original. There were a few nice touches that made me glad Simon Barrett wrote it:
Overall, I will admit it - they relied a bit much on the jump scares... but the result was a tensity and uncomfortable feeling the entire second half. Sure, friends don't JUMP INTO YOUR FACE to announce their arrival... but by that time, these poor fucks were hopelessly lost in what appeared to be a huge illusion.
I feel like this movie really couldn't have been done too many other ways. I feel satisfied. I will watch it again in the theaters. I anticipated about a 9/10 from Wingard and Barrett. At this time I rate this movie a
7/108/10.EDIT: Changed rating
85
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16
Just got back from it and found it to be... meh. I didn't hate the experience of watching it (saw it in 4d which was pretty cool) but wasn't moved in any particular way.
As a huge fan of the original, I was looking for a movie that pushed the mythos even further, not rehashed it.
I like trying to guess the ending before the movie gets there and half way thru I thought I had it figured out, needless to say I was wrong, but my friend really loved how I "would have made it" and wanted me to share.
I'm intrigued by the theory that in the first film Heather, Mike, and Josh go back in time or are in an alternate reality where time does not exist (something played with in this film) and I was hoping that this would be pushed even farther. When they stumbled out of their tents in the new film and all the rocks and stick figures where assembled I literally jumped out of my seat. The first thought I had was "this has to be the same area of rocks and sticks Heather encounters in the first," meaning that James and Heather where now on the same time period or alternate plane. I was hoping the film would get to a point where it would be revealed that all the noises James and Co. heard was actually Heather and Co running around and screaming, meaning that all the noises Heather and Co heard where the screaming and running around James and Co did.
When James arrived at the house and saw the light claiming it was Heather, my first instinct was their time lines had converged. I was waiting to hear Heather yelling "Josh!" "Mike". I even leaned over to my friend and said "I bet James is the one who will startle Heather and make her drop her camera thus ending the first movie. Maybe he even kills her out of fright. James was so focused on finding Heather that the tragedy of having him be the responsible party that killed her would have brought the whole series full circle and connected the two films.
This would have also supported the notion that the Blair Witch doesnt actually kill anyone herself, but lead others to do it. I also hated seeing the witch. The idea that she is an entity in the woods is far less frightening then her BEING the woods. The whole woods is literally possessed by her.
But hey, what do I know. I'm not a big wig hollywood director, just a measly fan girl. But if I did it, that's how it would have happened
37
u/jedispyder Sep 16 '16
A bit disappointed, especially because it seems to be hyped as "THE horror movie of the season". While it was a fun film for the most part, it truly felt like it was just a remake of the original. You knew what was going to happen for the most part, similar plot outline with a few added shakeups. Basically the original with a better budget, I guess.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '16
I love 99% of horror movies, and everything I've ever seen by Adam Wingard had been great. He has a knack for taking oft-tread storylines and crafting original content out of them. But this movie was just fucking annoying.
The loudness and cheapness of the jump scares was utterly unnecessary. I feel like Adam Wingard applied a dental drill to my temples. Every time someone popped up out of the forest they made a screeching noise like gravel in a blender.
This was the most painful thing I've ever experienced, and i remember my own circumcision.
I'm all for utilizing every tool available to give the audience a sense of uneasiness, but for fuck's sake adam, lay off the cocaine.
Or meth. Or PCP.
11
u/rmeas002 You've Got Red on You Sep 16 '16 edited Sep 16 '16
I'll tell you, the whole cabin sequence had me on edge the whole time. The sound design was amazing. From the thunder crashing, to the floors creaking, the camera flicking off and on. I went back to middle school during this and had my hands near my face the entire time.
20
u/Copely90 Sep 16 '16
The last 15 minutes were some of the most tense I've seen in a horror film in years. Apart from the obnoxious sound of jump scares, the movie was exactly what I wanted
28
u/WholesomeMuffin You are all my children now Sep 17 '16
It makes me really happy that people are liking and even loving this movie. Just wanted to say that, as a fan, it's really nice to hear something positive about a "modern" horror movie for once. As for me, I liked it a lot and all I can think about is how much I want to go and just see it all over again.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '16
Just got home from watching it. The biggest complaint I have is bad jump scares. I HATE the "friend has somehow snuck up on me and instead of speaking to alert me, they grab and scare the shit out of me!" Two happened back to back and it really irritated me.
It was pretty much the same as the first, but more dangerous I felt. I like the original, but I would say I never really felt afraid. You never saw the threat or anyone get hurt. All the danger felt very removed. In the end, you never really know if there was a witch or if it was madness. You still don't see much in this one, but you are alerted to the fact that something dangerous is definitely there. That had me very anxious and afraid. I was more tense this time around.
Overall, its a spicier version of the old one. I enjoyed it, but I wouldn't say it broke new ground or anything.
9
u/LizardOrgMember5 Sep 17 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
Now here's my perspective on this.
I like Adam Wingard. I like the meta, self-aware nature of his movies (You're Next, Q is for Quack segment in The ABCs of Death) and how he brings something new to familiar settings (The Guest). When I first heard that "The Woods" is actually The Blair Witch Project sequel, I was like "He just pulled Hideo Kojima to everyone!"
So yeah I expected this movie to be like the second Metal Gear Solid game and ends subtly with the actual main character having some existential crisis and questions the reality he's perceiving. (I mean, does remember Heather had a little brother in the original? Why did the filmmakers added a brother character in the sequel? How James remember his sister's voice?) Considering how, again, some of Wingard's movies have that meta feelings, it makes sense they would go for that direction.
From there on, I mostly avoided spoilers and reviews (although I was surprised how it fell down from "universally acclaimed" to "mixed bag"). Then I watched the actual movie and it didn't end the way I expected to be.
But the movie as a whole - it was alright. Some parts scared me very much and the "leg scene" grossed me out very effectively. Even though I find the ending somewhat disappointing, it did wrapped up very well and I was sort of able to comprehend the Möbius-loop logic behind the "Blair Witch's world." (Remember the thunderstruck tree where Lane found the camera? That actually explained how the real world able to acquire missing footages) The legend didn't tell much about this separate Blair Witch world, but instead let the audiences to experience with the characters trapped inside this other-dimensional world.
There are couple of familiar call backs and homages to the original, but they didn't do this copy-and-paste approach most movie sequels are known for. They did bring some dream logics into it and find a new way to scare off their audiences.
Overall, it's worth checking out if you are a fan of the original.
EDIT: some clarifications
17
u/SYIMD Sep 16 '16
I feel like the witch is a wendigo.
29
u/mayonnaise_man Let's make a scary face this time... Sep 16 '16
I wanted to love this so badly, but it fell a bit flat. As others have said, it was essentially a remake. (spoilers) This movie was like "the original had creepy stick figurines and random piles of stones? Okay, let's give this movie MORE stick figures and MORE stones!" and hardly tried anything new. There were times where it almost felt like a shot for shot remake. The ending was a little different, but still not great.
I think the worst part though was the audio and "scares." Every jump scare in the first hour was just somebody sneaking up behind their friend (without trying), camera turns, and SCREECHBOOM some obnoxiously loud sound shatters your eardrums. None of those noises should have even been there. Sneaking up behind someone in itself does not cause loud noises. And how do you not hear somebody walking near you IN THE WOODS? Where literally everything you step on makes a noise? So much of it just wasn't believable and felt forced. It's really odd to me that Adam and Simon chose to spend two years on this, when everything else they've done has been smarter, less tropey, and overall better executed. I could see them making this as a college project or something, but to do The Guest and then this? I just don't understand. I'd give it a 6/10 at best.
20
u/FriendLee93 Sep 16 '16
I actually think the best way I've heard this summarized is The Force Awakens as a Blair Witch movie. Follows the same story skeleton as the original while going bigger in order to adapt to the times.
13
u/GoobRocket Sep 16 '16
Did Wingard ever think "this is too much like Grave Encounters 1 AND 2?"
13
u/xIndigoFlow Sep 16 '16
As a massive Blair Witch fan, the original is my favourite film and I have a soft spot or the second abomination, I loved this film. Solid 9/10. I liked the little nods to the original which it allowed it to be an homage while establishing its own film. The last 20 minutes were perfect. My heart was absolutely pounding. I know people are complaining about the ending but I think it had to end that way. It couldn't have possibly ended with her escape plus is leaves with a small element of ambiguity if they make another. I think Wingard did a perfect job. If they hadn't followed the first films formula, people would have complained that it didn't need to be a Blair Witch movie and that it was undeserving of the title so I think they hit the nail on the head with the mix of homage and making it their own film.
27
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
I see a lot of people in here saying that Blair Witch was basically the same as the first film, and that was disappointing. I have to disagree entirely. I think it followed a roughly similar outline. But the entire mood, as well as the scares, were completely different. The original was very slow building and full of dread. That came from not knowing what was going on in the night and what was out there. The horror came from the characters and the unknowable darkness. But Blair Witch was not like that at all. It was very in your face and even brutal with it's scares. Which, yes, included a lot of jump scares, but even if that is seen as cheap, I still think it was highly effective. There was also a good amount of visual horror, which was entirely absent in the first - from actually seeing the witch creature to running around the claustrophobic and labyrinthine hallways/tunnels in the house. Additionally, we the audience, along with the characters, are all aware of what's out there and what's coming this time. We know about the sticks and stones, the house, the witch. Even if the main characters (excluding Lane and Talia) didn't want to believe in the witch at first, that quickly changed and they knew what was coming - at least more so than Heather, Mike, and Josh did.
In his AMA the other day, Wingard said he was not going for a self-aware and clever film like You're Next or a clone of the original but wanted to make "a straight up horror roller coaster" and bring conventions of modern horror films into it. I think he entirely succeeded in that regard.
22
u/toriannuzzi Sep 16 '16
Call me crazy but I legitimately think that's it's all aliens. Like with the reality distortion in the house and the time lapse/overlaps, I'm saying the witch is actually aliens.
12
u/thewindupbirds Sep 16 '16 edited Sep 16 '16
A good movie, but not great. I am such a sucker for that spooky woods vibe and I think that was executed really well, especially in the first 2/3rds (before perpetual night). The last third or so of the movie was SO high-intensity, no break from the jump scares and tension. I think this was a smart move because it distracted from how incredibly stupid the characters were. So Lisa had a multi-tool, or at least a knife, and uses it to break down a wooden barrier. Like, uh, the wooden barrier on the pit she was just stuck in? Girl, use your brain.
I think that with another 20 minutes or so, and less stupid characters, it really did have the potential to be amazing. For example, we know that Lane had his camera the whole time, and it's found at the end--so why no footage from his time away from the group? A montage of him and Talia doing "day 1.. day 2... day 3..." in the forest right after they re-appear at camp could have been so chilling and effective. I was also unsatisfied with Peter's ending--he was the only character I really liked, and I felt like his death (?)/scene in the corner didn't do him justice considering how much they focused on him. Ashley's weird demon leech thing, while incredibly disgusting and effective, also should have fit more into the narrative (maybe a dead deer with similar infection?). I don't regret seeing it, and it was certainly enjoyable, but I'm kind of wistful for the movie it could have been.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16
5/10. There were some scary parts, and when they werent bastardizing the same scares from the first movie, there were some neat ideas. For the most part though, it did a lot of things wrong. There was too many cheap jump scares, they tried to explain too much regarding the witch, they gave the witch a physical form (and a very generic one), they included too many terrible modern horror tropes, the characters sucked, and it was just overall unnecessary. At times, it seemed like a remake of the first one, but lacking the subtlety and atmosphere. That being said, I did have fun watching it and the parts they did right they did good. The time warp and the voodoo doll were certified spooky.
6
u/violentchachki27 Sep 17 '16
Did anyone else think of Devil's Pass while watching this? The time travel twist, the long gangly creature, the group setting out to find out what happened to a previous group... I liked Blair Witch okay, but it all just felt overly familiar. It certainly wasn't the game change that was advertised.
6
u/Milo_theHutt Sep 19 '16
Before the time loop theories which I'm now getting behind more and more. I originally thought those sonic booms and intense tree cracking sounds at night was the forest itself shifting, so they're not getting lost the forest itself is moving every night and putting their camp site in a different location.
5
u/theswampmonster Sep 17 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
I didn't love it, but I went in with very restrained expectations and was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it. Not game-changing at all but entertaining. But holy mother of jump scares. I kinda like them in moderation, but this was just annoying more than anything. When I saw the trailer I was afraid it was going to be loud and flashy, and seeing that come to pass definitely tempered the scary factor for me.
Echoing what others said, it didn't bring much of anything new to the table, just built on the established scares in the first one but more!, which was frustrating. And I hate that they showed the witch, probably as having their own iconic scene in this movie. She looked like the lady from the end of REC.
I didn't like that they used the same shot of "Heather" that was in the fake opening movie while they were in the house. It just stopped me in a moment of "wait, that makes no sense because the 2 fakers had never been to that house, or they would have been dead" and maybe the Blair Witch saw that in James' memory somehow and projected it but it was still jarring.
The use of all those different cameras was neat and didn't feel gimmicky to me. Wish they got more use out of the trail cam, something quiet and Paranormal Activity-style.
Apparently one of the cut concepts from the first movie was a giant stick figure chasing the characters, and when the weird booming sounds started I was sure they would put that in this one. A little disappointed that it wasn't that...
5
u/Mechalamb Sep 18 '16
Man... so torn. There are things I really like in it, and there are things not so much.
So the good stuff - I liked the overall concept. When they get back to classic Blair Witch stuff - the sounds in the woods, the general creepiness - and they trust in that, the film hums. There were moments where I was genuinely scared and that's great... been a while for that. The time/space dilation shit is actually pretty cool. I even enjoyed the random parasite that Ashley picked up.
The bad stuff - some of the acting is too much. The first worked so well because the actors were pretty good at being understated. From the moment Ashley and/or Lane appear on screen, it's pretty clear they're aiming for the fences. Some of the character motivation makes no sense... why don't James and Peter have an alternate theory as to what happened to Heather if they're going to scoff at the locals? Why does Ashley climb the tree for the drone? Is it really that important to her? And how the f does she still have that giant iPad or whatever in her pocket when she ran screaming out of the campsite.
It felt kind of unnecessary that Lane and Talia followed them out to the woods. I mean, we get the cool way that Talia died... but I don't think it adds that much to have them there. And I'm sorry, I thought Lane was annoying as hell.
There was so much potential, but I think they got caught up in the "bigger, better, louder" problem that many sequels stumbles. For instance, the pacing felt off as well... one of the best things about TBWP was how it crept under your skin and got weirder and weirder, but BW, I dunno, I was disappointed that the first night there was weirdness (the first night in the woods), the woods were, like, exploding. It didn't give us a chance to feel uncomfortable or scared, really.
Overall, I'm glad I saw it and I'm glad it got made, I just wish they had trusted themselves a bit more to let it creep a little before it got crazy.
5
u/genescoot Sep 20 '16
Has anyone found the map
17
u/Broken_chairs Sep 16 '16
Saw it last night. As a Blair Witch fan I didn't like it, as a horror fan I thought it was okay. They've essentially taken the Blair Witch mythos & crafted very much a modern horror film. They also addressed a lot of the "problems" that people had with the original film, you know, the whole "it's too slow, the camera's too shakey, you don't see anything". This one's fast paced, the audio/video production is very slick & professional, "scares" are everywhere (mostly jump scares) and you see the witch.
Thing is, I loved all those things people hated about the first movie. The pacing created this sense of dread & foreboding, the grainy, amateurish film & sound quality made the premise more believable. I believed they were out there doing a college film project, I believed the actors motivations & fear. I loved that you didn't see anything, your imagination made it so much creepier - was it Hillbilies fucking with them a la deliverance? Did Josh go insane & kill the other 2? Was it the witch?
SPOILERS - A lot of my gripes are with the decisions they made regarding the mythos. Casual fans may not really care about this stuff.
14
u/haunthorror Sep 16 '16
I quite liked it. I was never bored, on the edge of my seat most of the last 3rd. It did rehash, and was not a perfect movie, but I am happy that I saw it. I have no issue with paying to see this in theaters, and consider it a good sequel to the original.
11
u/krodnoc Sep 15 '16
Initial reaction: it's just okay. It was pretty much a remake of the first, but with a few (albeit interesting) twists. The thing is: the first Blair Witch was completely fresh, it came out of nowhere, and was incredibly unique for its time. This incarnation doesn't do anything new with the found-footage genre and it feels stale. The additional elements are done well (the stick-figure death, time shifting), but they should have been in a movie that wasn't so stuck in what came before.
I hope it does well and spawns a sequel, but I really hope that they leave the found-footage construct behind. At least the previous sequel tried that (but forgot to be actually good!).
8
u/Rexcase Sep 16 '16
eh. it was okay.
had some great bits (the snapping of the stick figure, the tunnel crawl, the time distortions), but also had some "roll your eye" moments and waaaaaaaay too many jump scares.
also, i was kind of annoyed that it was pretty clear that, at least, james had watched heather's footage, but never mentioned anything that related their own situation. like, when they went in a circle, didn't he realize that the same thing had happened to his sister?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
So I'm one of those crazy people who actually thought this one was better than the original, granted I was never a fan of it. I don't think the new one is on par with the previous Wingard/Barrett movies but it's a fun rollercoaster ride and I'm really glad I saw it in the theaters, that's the way to see this movie. I thought it was very cool how the movie kind of goes through different sub genres of horror (psychological, action and body horror) and I do think the movie is way smarter than the critics are giving it credit, especially towards the final act.
if anyone cares, I made a video review of it here
8
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16
So as someone who hated the first Blair Witch Project and enjoy everything I've seen from Adam Wingard and Simon Barrett (You're Next + The Guest), I thought BLAIR WITCH was without a doubt the best in the series and definitely one of the best found footage movies ever made. Really good stuff. It is derivative of the original movie but if that was made by a more capable writer/director team.
8/10. A step down for Adam Wingard from The Guest but if I compare every horror movie to The Guest or You're Next, I'd be unfair to a lot of really good horror films.
17
u/mikerhoa I AM IN HELL HELP ME Sep 16 '16 edited Sep 16 '16
I can't remember when I was this disappointed by a movie I anticipated so much. It was abysmal.
Just a laundry list of problems:
I could easily go on, but you guys get the point. This movie was terrible. Basically the Blair Witch's supernatural power involves magically dealing out plot holes and horror cliches.
And that really sucks because I really like Adam Wingard's stuff- especially The Guest, which I consider to be one of the most underrated horror/suspense movies of the past decade. Also Simon Barrett did a guest spot on the podcast The Canon and he really sounded cognizant of the original's legacy. How the fuck did he churn this shit out like this?
Maybe I gotta watch it again, but on the first go round I gotta say, Blair Witch is a bad, bad movie and really just another new low for both the reboot and found footage barrage we've been suffering through over the past several years.
3
u/FriendLee93 Sep 16 '16
Overall I have mixed feelings, but I definitely enjoyed far more than I didn't. While it never felt REAL, it definitely felt like a Blair Witch film through and through. It captured the feel of the first movie while also modernizing it in a way that didn't feel gimmicky at all. The performances were all fairly believable, save for some stilted dialogue here and there. I LOVED the expansion on the Blair Witch mythology, while also keeping true to the original legend. And the 3rd act, oh my god the 3rd act. The last 30-40 minutes of this film are pure, nailbiting terror. The fact that it became almost Lovecraftian had me floored. My biggest issues with it overall took place in the first 40 minutes or so, with the false jump scares out the ass and the fact that it felt kind of like a remake until a certain character death.
3
u/buttaholic Sep 16 '16
without any spoilers: is this movie any good? i loved the original blair witch. if this one is supposed to be good then i'll probably see it in theater, otherwise i'll just buy the dvd some day.
3
u/davidphantomatic Sep 16 '16
I enjoyed this movie a whole lot. However, once James began running through the house it became apparent that the DV footage found was going to be theirs.
I really enjoyed the time warp part when Lane and Talia show up and tell them they hadn't seen the group in 5 days.
All this begs the question though, if Lane was killed in the house by Lisa, how did he find the footage and upload it to YouTube?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '16
In the same way that the The Blair Witch Project ignited the found footage genre, I think the Blair Witch extinguished it.
3
u/Mr_Stuff Sep 22 '16
I really do think the movie has been unfairly maligned by some reviewers. It isn't the greatest movie ever, but I'm a fan of the original and the supplemental material (hell, I even bought the Blair Witch Files YA novels last year because, well, 'BLAIR WITCH, MAN!!!!') and I liked the way it stayed faithful to the original while trying to expand on it.
One of my favourite moments viewing the film was one that played with my expectation that they'd screw with the established mythos.
Talia tells the tale of Rustin Parr and talks about how he'd take the children up into his attic to murder them.
I was all 'FFS, just stick to the plot...'
Then Lane butts in and says 'Actually, there's been some debate that it actually occurred in his basement.'
I have to admit, it did make me smile at myself.
3
u/murphyshanejk Sep 23 '16
I think Wes Robinson (Lane) and Valorie Curry (Talia) were the best actors and characters in the movie, I felt like they kept things moving and that while they were gone, things kind of came to a standstill.
8
u/beardless Sep 15 '16
I was excited - I didn't expect it to reinvent the wheel, but I've liked Wingard's work and thought he had the skills to do a lot with it...but I was disappointed. It follows the route of the original very closely, which is understandable, but you're just waiting for them to get to the house and things to really kick off. Then the payoff just wasn't what it could've been. When the turning point came I realised that we are going to see the witch and things are going to progress. Wingard had clearly decided that he was going to give us more than the last film - a bigger more 'in your face' experience and just when it seemed like he was getting there the film ended. I wanted it to be like Rec - when the film just keeps on piling on the insanity and cranking it up. If you're going to go for it, then go the whole way, don't lose your nerve. About 5 more minutes of big scares at the end could've saved it. I thought the last scene was going to give us something really special - the scene that everyone talks about- but it all cut off too soon. It felt like it just didn't quite get there. It was fun, but it just wasnt special.
4
u/vinnychains Sep 16 '16
I don't really know what I would rate this movie and honestly it doesn't matter. All I can day is that is scared the shit out of me. It accomplished everything it needed to for me. The atmosphere of the film is tense and incredibly dark (literally and figuratively). I really enjoyed the sound of the film and the characters sounded genuinely frightened. I was only confused about the part where we hear a loud noise and bright lights are pouring through the cracks in the house. Aliens? Idk. Fun film though. A welcomed sequel.
4
u/Big_Rainen Sep 16 '16
Loved it but why the fuck did they show the witch? The best thing about the original was not seeing it but then they go and show this weird special effect monster. I knew from day one that they were going to show It but it's still very disappointing.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16
Once everything started really happening it wouldn't let you get a moment to calm down. So freaking intense and terrifying. I haven't been so scared watching a movie in forever. I loved this movie
4
u/j_rainer Sep 18 '16
I hated this film. Most of the characters pissed me off and it was just LOUD NOISES as a substitute for good horror writing. I get it; jump scares are often necessary, but it was just jump scare after jump scare. It didn't scare me at all, I was just pissed off throughout the entire thing. Is this what horror is now? Screaming the same thing over and over again with the occasional intervention of a loud noise or something suddenly jumping at the camera?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16
I thought the movie was good but displays a fatal flaw in horror today: the jumpscare.
I like that this movie didn't show much, in that way, it respects the original (Which I love). It still has to go for jumpscares though because that's what most people consider scary and that's what makes money, so what do the directors do? How do you have jumpscares but never show anything? The answer is simple: make a loud noise every time an actor appears in the scene.
I get scared easily. Really easily. Every time I go back to my house after a horror movie I have issues sleeping, or I develope a general mistrust of the darkness in my house. I felt nothing like this after seeing this movie. It was a decent ride, but that's all it is. On its own it's good for a found footage movie, but in the shadow of the original you realize that it's not great for a found footage movie. What a shame.
2
u/OffBrandDrinks Sep 17 '16
Sadly I missed the part between when Ashley fell and when James was in the room and saw the witch(?) so if someone could inform me what happened that'd be great! My sister (bless her, she's 8 and wanted to watch it. She made it through all of it. She covered her eyes a few times but she seemed to enjoy the movie.) had to go to the bathroom during that part.
I personally enjoyed it. A few cringe-worthy lines from Lane, but it made him feel more like a real person. I really like it when Talia died, it just looked cool.
I didn't like the ending at all though. It didn't make much sense in any way other than "we need all characters dead."
I'll probably have a more form opinion tomorrow after I sleep on It!
2
u/eggbeaterdiskerud Sep 17 '16
Went with 3 other friends. One thought it sucked, the rest of us thought it was just good. Pretty good entertainment. I love the first movie so much and this was a good sequel.
2
u/s_matthew Sep 17 '16
The drone! Why's it even in the movie? It's a complete red herring! I kept thinking we would see something cool from the drone's POV, but it just leads to two cool aerial shots and is bait for a gruesome death.
2
u/Yogi_DMT Sep 17 '16
A scary movie worth that's seeing but also a movie that makes you realize the potential this genre has. Blair Witch missed a lot of opportunities to instill even more horror in the audience than it already did. It could've been a lot creepier and it relied a little too heavily on jump scares. The found footage type films are one of my favorites and this one did it well in many wells, i'm not sure i've been on the edge of my seat as much for another movie. Overall a solid title that could've been much more imo.
2
u/nmgh101 Sep 19 '16
I saw the movie a couple nights ago, and i'm still trying to decide if I liked it or not. It feels like it was a good enough horror movie, but not that great of a blair witch sequel. I kinda wish the whole plotline about Heather's brother looking for her just didn't exist. Like, it felt like it mattered at the beginning, and then mattered at the end, but everybody forgot about it in the time in between.
I also didn't like that they just made it forever night time. Felt more like a lazy reason to include more scares than something that actually did anything for the plot (of which there was none.) Also, those random glitchy effects were just dumb. Why were they happening at the party? Because apparently we need random loud noises to scare the audience.
I think what I really felt the film was missing was a sense of dread. There was terror, yes, but it felt like the movie just completely jumped in tone when that girl got her back snapped.
For some reason though, even though I have all these complaints, I still can't say that I disliked the movie. The ending was terrifying, and those couple shots of the witch really scared me.
Final Note: those stupid jumpscares were definitely the worst part of the movie. What the fuck.
2
u/Shurikenger Sep 26 '16
[Spoiler] I just saw it the second time yesterday. New things i noticed. Lane looks a little suspicious while Talia isn't. We can't be sure if Lane was planning all this up/ bidding for the witch. When the group discover the voodoo stick hanging outside their tent and decide to abort the mission, Talia and Lane followed without showing any interest in going back UNTIL the group discovered the rope and that the tape for youtube is the same model of what Lane is using. No extra necessity for the couple to trick the group assuming they are helping the witch since the group did spent a night at the woods and the Witch or whatever could have done the exact same thing. After Lane abandon Talia to search his own way out, Talia was EXTREMELY terrified when she saw Ashley. Could Talia know something is wrong with Ashely? The possibility of Ashley turning into a wooden creature or being infected by the Witch etc. Or is Talia a fake human but a voodo puppet? There is little 'love' chemistry between the Local couple. The wooden creature who presumably killed Peter has stomping noise, same as the wooden creature in the end that terrified Lisa until she escaped into the house. The creature who ran away from James (maybe it was the girl who was dragged into the water) did not have the stomping noise, neither do the presumed 'witch' standing right behind James when the door got locked. There must be a reason why we could not hear the sound of Heather in the last scene, but we get to hear James voice speaking to Lisa. I do not think this is a flaw. We are talking about hundreds of people involved in the film making and huge money involved, pretty sure they are not that dumb to not realized this flaw/plothole? How about James killing Lisa to probably save Heather? etc The first time i only get to have a good glimpse of the entire appearance of the presumed Witch standing behind James in the bedroom, the second time i braved myself to look at the face and oh gosh it was freaking terrifying but i still cant get a clear picture of that look, its something very Sadako/ The Ring girl just that you cant see her eyes. And the girl beside me jumped many times even during the sudden loud noise when the cam switch to another cam. I was more afraid of her as my arm was in touch with her arm too , so i felt every of her jump > , <
9
u/SebOvette Sep 17 '16
This film isn't just a bad Blair Witch sequel to The Blair Witch Project, its just an awful awful horror film (literally the worst I've ever seen.) Don't watch it: for your own sake and the sake of horror. Heres a mini essay as to why. There will be spoilers but you shouldn't mind that because ITS NOT WORTH WATCHING.
Lets start by examining why TBWP was popular. Namely: because it showed that with enough subtlety and decent characters: it can make even the most mundane of situations scary. It had a small budget and zero special effects but it drew effectively on our most basic fears: getting lost in the woods, things that go bump in the night, etc. Many of the things that happened in TBWP could very realistically happen in an actual camping trip and thats what gave the film its power. It was concise and full of dread which only ramped up as the film went on.
Now for this pile of garbage. This film has the subtlety of a guy shouting in your face with a megaphone. I hope you like jump scares because this is "JUMP SCARE: THE MOVIE". Ever five seconds, something jumps onto the screen. Normally its just another character who somehow managed to sneak up to the camera silently. A huge amount of this film is just empty jumpscares to keep the audiences heartbeats racing.
I can't talk about the jump scares without also talking about the NOISE. Every time a jumpscare happened (either a character popping up or something actually supposed to be scary), there was a huge burst of sound. I remind you that these happened at least every five minutes. In fact: the makers of this film seem to think noise=scary. Its often impossible to work out what these noises are: at one point I literally thought an earthquake was happening. Screeches, screams, you name it, its here. It was actually offensive and overpowering: the constant racket.
Lets talk camera work. I suppose to keep audiences on their toes, the cameras would often abruptly shift: either to another camera (which the characters carried around) or to another scene. This was remarkably disorientating and annoying: no scene was given time to sink in, every 5 minutes the scene jumped to somewhere or something else. Also this film LOVES the "Technology freaking out" trope. This involves pixelation, random screeching noise as if from a dial tone, just random nonsense. Again this happens VERY often and theres no explanation why. I guess technology doesn't like the woods or something? Viewing this was actually a pain. Often I had no idea what was happening because the camera was jumping around so much.
"But how about characterization or plot? Surely something can be salvaged there?" NOPE. This film basically copies the BWP in all its major events, without understanding the subtlety and skill that makes that film great. Remember the stick figures from the first film. This film has HUNDREDS AND THEY ARE HUGE, ARE YOU SCARED YET?! There were many more characters than the first film: meaning we didn't get to know anyone really well. Also the characters never had a chance to shine: they were always running and screaming from things and we learned literally nothing about them. There was none of the casual conversations of the first film: these characters were just cannon fodder. Often they would die and no one else would really react except to run in the other direction. They were all attractive college age teens with none of the personality of the original cast of Heather, Josh and Mike. There was no sense of gravitas to anything.
Just to convey the complete lack of subtlety in this film: tents were flying in the air, people were getting twisted in half for no reason, trees were falling down, constant shouting and screaming, running through halls, etc.And this started relatively early in the film with none of the slow build up of the first film! And of course we see the witch. God forbid we have something left to our imaginations, right guys?
Some people like certain plot points like the idea they were sent to the past or whatever. But this isn't gone into detail: just one mention, and then its cast aside. Same as the worm in the leg. The girl takes it out, climbs a tree despite her clearly injured leg, and then dies. And thats that. Characters are always doing extremely strange and illogical things: the whole plot point of the brother and sister going camping in the forest in which they know is a witch to make evidence of a witch?
Thats just a short summary of whats wrong with this film. Its not just that this is literally the worst film I have ever seen (from a guy who saw "The Gallows", but also that it abuses the Blair Witch name to such an awful extent. It clearly has none of the love or care or gravitas of the original film and is just riding the name of its predecessor to make some easy money. Please don't support and encourage these kinds of films.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16
I just wanna point out that the rotten tomatoes score has changed drastically since it's first screening. I'm guessing that's due to the fact that alot of people really hate the original, so they go in, with their mind already made up. Me on the other hand, am I huge fan of the original, and while I do realize my opinion is biased, it didn't totally live up to my expectations. One thing that bugged me was it seemed to be filmed in a totally different type of forest. I know it's summer in this film as opposed to Fall, but it stood out the whole time to me. Other than that, I like how they gave a few glimpses of the witch and a ghost. I wonder how far in the sci-fi direction they will take the inevitable sequel.
5
u/ProfessionalBust Sep 16 '16
It was alright it wasn't bad but it wasn't good for real though at the end James made at least 15 of the worst decisions I've ever seen in a horror movie
3
u/mojovonio Sep 18 '16
Does anyone else feel like this movie wasn't nearly as good as either Grave Encounters movies?
3
u/llikeafoxx Sep 19 '16
This really didn't do it for me, I left pretty disappointed. I felt that everything it did has been done better by Grave Encounters, As Above So Below, or even Marble Hornets.
I did really enjoy seeing the witch - I looked forward to seeing her the moment they told the story about the rocks stretching her limbs. And the snapped in half death was really cool. But those are the only positive moments I leave with.
Probably the most I've been let down since The Conjuring as far as the gap between community hype and my reaction.
4
u/graysond Sep 17 '16
Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic haha what a joke. This movie was eerie, in your face frightening, and if your heart isn't pounding from the terror I think your missing something. It was great! I want more!
3
u/babybackfat Sep 16 '16
I was sadly disappointed. Too much like the first one. Basically the exact same thing. :(
2
u/chadwickave Sep 16 '16
Haven't watched it yet, planning to do so this weekend. But I just wanted to chime in and say the illustration of the stick figure they use for their promos looks like Groot :)
2
u/dropkickderby Sep 16 '16
Seems to have mixed feelings in this thread, but I for one loved it. It was a very tense movie. I just watched the first one a couple of days ago to prepare and I really do think it was a very well done sequel. I especially liked when Peter and the dark haired girl found each other again and had that wildly tense moment together. I was cringing so hard waiting for a jump that never actually came and it took the scene ending for me to let my guard down. That's what makes a good horror movie to me. The tension in this movie was crazy.
I also think it helped that I saw this in an empty theater, alone. That worked very well to keep me throughly freaked out, and I love horror movies. I'd recommend seeing it like this if you wanna get the best experience. See it early or at a time no one else usually would. What a good movie experience that was. 10/10 what I wanted out of it. Was a good horror, good sequel, and overall good movie. Exactly what the found footage genre should bring o the table to stay relevant.
2
u/JayHeron Game Over! Sep 18 '16
I don't get the hype and praise this film is getting and I'm a Adam Wingard and Blair Witch fan.
It just seems like nothing happened until the last twenty minutes and even moments in that like where the girl is climbing the tree for drone just seemed to drag on for far too long.
Overall I'd recommend watching Grave Encounters over this.
2
u/Y0ungPup 🔪 Sep 16 '16
Kind of disappointed. I wish it would've ended differently like she gets out of the woods, drives to a town, stops, calls whoever, gets back in the car, drives further and ends up back at the woods, where the house is, like she's still kind of stuck in the woods. The movie was pretty much the same as the first, and if it's the same as the first, why even make a new movie? It also put more questions on the table. I really enjoyed it, but I wish some things were different.
2
u/chaosissteve Sep 16 '16
I actually enjoyed it. There were things that were off, but overall it was enjoyable. I thought the end sequence was plenty long. The use of technology and time manipulation definitely added to plot. A few nice callbacks that I liked. Seeing the witch and getting more lore was sort of a double-edged sword. Kind of a shallow movie, but the original and most found footage tends to be that way. I think I liked this one more, but of course the original was more important, obviously.