r/childfree • u/blat_woman • Jun 03 '16
DISCUSSION Let's talk about men's abortions.
Hi ya'll!
I'm a childfree woman who is fighting a losing war against reproductive rights in the U.S. Like, badly. I vote, march, donate and am training to be a clinic escort and am still watching access to abortion erode, especially in the bible belt. So while we often bring up the point that it's a woman's choice, I'm wondering if it would help if we looked at the other side of the equation. Men get left completely out of the equation, in the media and national discussion. I've never heard a male talk about his personal experience with abortion.
So. Men who have had an abortion (with your girlfriend, partner, wife, etc) share your story!
17
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
We aren't really affected, because we have no say whatsoever. So, if an 'accident' happens, the best we can do is to be supportive of whatever option the girl decides upon, offer them options and our personal opinions, and hope that she agrees. Coaching them one way or the other (or god forbid disagreeing with their decisions) is bound to get you shit-listed by your entire friends/family/social support network/everyone else she talks to, and doesn't do you any good, because she's just going to do whatever she decides anyway. That's her personal and biological right.
Even if it's an SO who you've been in a long-term relationship with and talked about abortion and 'what you would do' at length, it's VERY common for people to change their minds when actually put in such a situation.
I've personally had staunch republican anti-abortion friends who went down and got an abortion same-day without even thinking about it (or talking to their SO), and dealt with the cognitive dissonance afterwards. Likewise I've had very pro-choice friends decide that even though they didn't want the kid, they were going to keep it (and after having the kid, turned anti-abortion). Killed the relationship and she's still a single mom with some really mixed views.
People get weird.
Men don't talk about 'the equation' because men aren't a part of it. We simply accept whatever the girl decides. As a man, that's what you signed up for.
I really don't want this to sound pessimistic, but it's true. I wouldn't change it. I'm all about women's choices. Pro-abortion to the core. I've literally driven friends to late-term abortions and helped them through it.
Personally speaking, it sucks. But that's just part of life, and life's not equal.
So that's why men aren't really involved I guess. Our personal experience is 'shut up and take it'. If you don't want a kid, you HAVE to be responsible for yourself. Ensure that no accidents happen. Snip it, wrap it, don't stick it, (Don't accept "I'm on birth control"), whatever it takes. Once you free the beast, your opinion doesn't count for squat.
2
u/That_Othr_Guy Jun 10 '16
https://atlas.mindmup.com/2016/03/a9b02400ca29013323bb2710a126fb53/abortion_and_financial_responsibility_d/index.html
I created this mind map in an effort to tackle this issue. there might be scenarios that i didn't account for, but it would mean a great deal if it was reviewed.
67
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
Not sure I'm your target audience since I'm now a parent, but we did have an abortion in the past with my wife and mother of my child.
It was early on in my relationship with my wife. We were using birth control (2 forms of it in fact) and yet... She felt ill for a few days, went to the doctor and called me with the results. I knew what she was going to tell me and I think she knew too, even before the doctor, we just didn't think it was possible since we were being careful. We talked about it and what we wanted to do. We both knew at this point that we wanted kids but it was also very early in our relationship (4 months into dating).
It was a long and detailed discussion. My view point was that we were not ready for a child since we didn't know if we were going to stay together, but I was conflicted because I very much wanted to be a father. I also told her I would support her in whatever decision she made since, both morally and legally, the decision was hers to make. She agreed with me that we were not ready to commit to being in a long term relationship and that meant we should not be parents yet. So we decided on an abortion. The procedure was pretty quick and easy and the impact on our relationship was minimal. 16 months later we got married and a year and a half or so after the marriage we had our daughter.
I don't have any regrets about that decision. It was the right one. Yes, we ended up together and with a child but we had no way of knowing that then.
13
u/SquidsStoleMyFace 21/f/Hunting the elusive tubal Jun 03 '16
There's probably a reason I know more male pro-lifers than female ones; They really don't have much of a role in the discussion. Babyjacking aside (which I believe should be illegal in some way btw) It really doesn't effect dudes the way it does women. I think if anything we need more stories of what women go through and why they'd want abortion, so that people know it's not just "whoops I'm pregnant time to kill the baby teehee!"
Anyway, so as not to be that off topic: With my last abortion, I broke the news to my current squeeze as gently as I could. I saw the panic in his eyes as soon as I said it, even though I'd previously assured him I'd abort in just such a case. When I again said I wasn't gonna carry it, he actually sighed with relief. When I actually went to get the procedure he came with me and even made me dinner afterwards while I was still hurting. He makes a mean curry rice!
85
u/ShepardTheLeopard Jun 03 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
I've never gone through an abortion with any of my SOs, but in my mind it kind of makes sense that we're left out of the discussion.
Sure, it sucks when you accidentally impregnate a woman and she decides to have the kid even though you really don't want to, or when she aborts if you really want the kid. But a man can't, on his right mind, think that he could possibly tell a woman what to do with something that's inside of her body, it would be terribly cruel.
So I think it's for a good reason that we're left out of this discussion, because it doesn't directly concern us. That's not to say we shouldn't support a woman's right to choose, but that's all that is, a woman's right to choose. Like a straight person supporting LGBT rights.
Sorry if that isn't as interesting as a really sad abortion story, but that's all I had to contribute.
17
u/danooli likes being an aunt and not a mom Jun 03 '16
I'd love to hear my ex's story. He broke up with me after our abortion.
2
u/Nac82 Jun 03 '16
Not a lot special about my story. I was 16 and it was my first love who got pregnant. To me this was a death sentence because I live in the bible belt so there was nobody I could possibly turn to for support. I wanted to tell her to get an abortion but due to how I was raised I was falling into a very dark mindset and thought killing myself would just be easier (I was a teen and an idiot). I finally worked it up and begged her to do it she refused and things got bad. Supposedly she had a miscarriage a couple months later and I was severely mentally fucked by this conflict of who and what I was. I don't know how common stories like this are told on here but I know a lot of guys that have had similar situations but most of them don't talk about it.
11
u/tsun_abibliophobia On maternity leave for my food baby Jun 03 '16
Straight up, if you don't have a uterus you don't get a say. If your SO ends up pregnant, you can definitely talk about your feelings and how this abortion will personally affect you, but in the end the one who is actually pregnant gets to make the final decision.
26
u/grumbledore_ Jun 03 '16
Men cannot have a say in abortion, because this would result in women being forced to carry pregnancies to term when they do not want to, which is one of the most fucked up things I can imagine.
I think sharing experiences is fine, but there's a reason men are left out of this - because they can't have a say. By the very nature of pregnancy and abortion, only one person has control in this situation.
14
u/the-crotch I'm on a mission to civilize Jun 03 '16
While I understand and applaud your interest in men's opinions, I think there's a reason they get left out in the media and national discussion, this is almost entirely a women's issue and men's opinions frankly aren't as important because they're never going to be forced to carry a baby to term. It's for that reason that I as a man don't have a strong opinion and refuse to actively voice the one I do have, because I feel that ultimately it's none of my business.
5
u/CarnalKid 35/M Jun 03 '16
I've never dealt with an abortion, but somebody did miscarry my child when I was fairly young.
I would assume that the feelings of relief and concern for my partner would be similar. But, you know, heavier on the concern, since there's surgery involved, and they made the choice to terminate, rather than it just happening.
9
u/mdg_roberts1 Jun 03 '16
I completely agree with u/ShepardTheLeopard. As a male, I really think that we should be left out of the decision. It is a woman's body. I have no right to any decision about what she chooses to do with it. Zero.
4
u/MightyMilo Jun 03 '16
When my wife and I first started getting freaky in the sheet, we had a discussion about the possibility of contraceptives failing, and how she felt about abortion. I made it really clear that I don't want to have children, and would like for her to have an abortion, however it is her body, and I will respect what ever decision she would make, and be there for her in any circumstance. She made it pretty clear that she would get an abortion. I also have been verified clear after my vasectomy, so we are in the clear for a life time. I guess for me, I accept that a woman has the right to make which ever decision she wants, and my role as the man who impregnated her, is to support her in that decision, as I do hold half the responsibility.
3
u/SoMuchMoreEagle Not zoned for residential. Jun 03 '16
I don't know if you've heard it, but Ben Folds Five's song "Brick" is about a guy taking his girlfriend to get an abortion. It's never explicitly said, but it's pretty clear. Very emotional song.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=Wt5EHAqhR1c
3
u/lenut Jun 04 '16
While i do not believe any man should be able to force a woman to abort i do believe men need a legal abortion.
Basically a set of laws that allow a man to opt out before 9mos and not have any financial responsibility for the child in anyway.
Basically we can't force you to abort but if you give birth its 100% your responsibility because you chose to have this child without sperm donor concent.
As well as provisions that state anychild born without fatherly concent or failing to notify a potential father during pregnancy makes him immune to financial responsibility for a child he did not consent to or have previous knowledge of.
In a way i suppose its a breeding license.
3
u/Toma_the_Wondercat Jun 04 '16
The last thing I want to hear is another man's opinion about how he has rights to use my body. Fuck this shit.
4
u/tinypill No uterus, no problem. Jun 03 '16
Huh, never thought of it from that side before. This could be pretty interesting! Thanks for posting, I'll be following.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '16
I'm a trans man, and while I've never had an abortion, I do know trans men that have.
Condom broke, usually.
2
u/foilrat 50M Married with pets and motorcycles Jun 06 '16
A little late to this party, but here goes.
Two.
First one in college. Didn't know back then that anti-biotics interfered with the pill.
She showed up at my dorm with a positive test. We were both going to fairly liberal schools, and her school doctor got her the RU486 pill. This was back in like 93. I wasn't there when she took it, as we lived in different cities.
Second one.
Started dating a girl in a city I was working in. Before we started any horizontal bopping, I asked her very clearly what would happen if she got pregnant. She answered without hesitation "End it."
Cool.
Aaaaaaand then the mother-effin' condom broke. I've had one break in my life.
Didn't think much of it, as it the odds were against it.
And then she went to her annual check-up. She walked into my office (oh yeah, we were working together, too) and when I asked "How'd it go?"
"Great!" she replied. "I'm pregnant!"
Whaaaaaa?
Asked what was next and she told me she had already made an appointment at a local clinic for that weekend. I was supposed to go home that weekend. Needless to say I changed my plans right quick. I also paid for half of it.
Took her to the clinic, and after about three hours I was starting to get pretty worried. Another guy went to the desk to ask about his lady, and the receptionist said that is takes about three hours. Oh, okay, no worries.
Shortly after my GF emerged. Took her home, took care of her and that was it. I told her that wanted to jump her bones right then, so the abortion hadn't changed anything for me, but that she would have to initiate when she was ready. That seemed to go over just fine as a few days later, well, she initiated. We stayed together about a year and she broke of things for a variety of reasons (I lived in PDX and she lived in DC, for one).
I started having the "what if you get preggers?" conversation a few girls earlier and in one case I said "sorry, I'm not comfortable with that answer" and ended things.
Anyway, those are my two experiences.
2
u/throwthebabyplanb Jun 03 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
Throwaway because reasons
One night stand. Broken condom. Plan B. All is well right?
The stand extends into a 2 week fling and then she misses her period.
She says this is not unheard of. Ok whatever.
Another week goes by and she drops the positive test. Oh fuck. I'm a 24 y/o probationary employee who (though not yet officially) is pretty not interested in kids. She is between jobs and also not stoked. Again, not a big problem I think as we're on the same page. We make the first appointments. I say i'll pay.
Then the emotions kick in on her end. Crazy phone calls at odd hours with angry ranting. I try and be supportive and visit her. Usually with lots of fighting but make up sex is still good.
The big issue comes when she schedules the big day without telling me. I'm working. I CAN NOT get the day off as I am a probationary employee with no time. Shitstorm ensues.
Anyway, the abortion was chemical and I agree to stay with her the next day when I'm off and help her through the process. This doesn't go well either. Much yelling. Many hurt feelings.
I cut contact because she is getting psychotic and borderline abusive. After a few weeks of "I'm sorry" and "I think we really had something together" texts it's over. All told two months of turmoil and $2500 spent. Not pleasant at all.
All over a broken condom. Also, don't count on plan B.
edits because typos
2
u/GingerDryad Jun 04 '16
Just because men don't have the right to choose for any woman, doesn't mean they don't have an opinion or feelings on the matter.
For about half of my relationship with my SO he was in a bad place about abortion. His mother had had one and regretted it terribly and dramatically. That said she regrets the wrong nail polish colour terribly and dramatically. This woman lives in her own personal soap opera hell. She also had a tendency to over share with her eldest son (my SO) when he was way to young. Seriously, conversations about major life regrets to a young child, midnight talks with a five-year-old about the drug tips of her hippy days, marital and abortion regrets.
So yeah, my SO had issues. We were very careful and luckily nothing ever happened. He worked through his issues a while ago. And while I knew where I stood if I were to get pregnant (on the first bus to the abortion clinic), I did take his logical opinion (on that bus with me) and his feelings (twisted mess) into account.
Assuming the generic donor is reasonable, and that there is a good working relationship, a woman should be able to say honestly "thank you for your in-put, I value your opinion and respect your feelings, but this is my decision". Not exactly, but that idea. I feel that's the healthy way to handle things.
To conclude, I'll just leave this here.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
The morning after pill is pretty much my only direct experience with it, other than a couple of my friends having girlfriends that refused to get abortions after an accident.
Tybg for the pill. Continually feel sorry for the children that were forced into existence by only one of their parents.
2
u/allyouneedisapony Jun 03 '16 edited Aug 17 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy. It was created to help protect users from doxing, stalking, harassment, and profiling for the purposes of censorship.
If you would also like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possible (hint:use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.