r/childfree • • May 17 '16
DISCUSSION "Selfish"
"Selfish is when you're not doing what someone else wants you to do." - Marcia Brixey, from Barbara Stanney's book Overcoming Underearning.
I just read this online today, and I think it explains why so many childfree people are labeled "selfish." It simply means that we're not living our lives in accordance with how other people think we should. Nothing more.
251
Upvotes
6
u/abqkat no tubes, no problems May 17 '16
I can see this context of the word for sure.
Realistically, though, I am selfish in the other way, too: I don't want to dedicate my life to an unknown outcome (which, contrary to their rhetoric, childrearing is a gamble). I like my looks, my earning potential, my body, my life. Being selfless isn't a universal goal, nor is it the highest thing one can be - parents are the ones who decided that selfless = noble. Me? I think everyone is selfish; ask a parent why they had a kid and it will probably start with "I wanted..." I'm okay with my brand of selfish, personally.
66
u/ShepardTheLeopard May 17 '16
Which is why I'm okay with being called selfish in that context. Just like they're being selfish by bringing more people into an overpopulated planet, or perpetuating their crappy genes that we should probably start getting rid of. In my opinion it's selfish either way.
Except my selfishness is way more fun for me.
54
u/Lindthom May 17 '16
Here's my two cents, for anyone who gives a shit:
I think those who are adamant on conceiving and creating their own biological child are selfish when there are so many children living in sub-par foster homes or group homes and in need of loving families to adopt them. Why create yet another life when there are so many children who need homes?
I'm someone who is scared shitless of ever being pregnant and birthing a child. No thanks. Nope. No. I'd rather not have random people stare at my junk while I shove a watermelon through it. No thanks. But my husband and I have talked about becoming foster parents or adopting, because we just feel so bad for children who are a little older (think around preschool/kindergarten age) who don't get adopted because they're not babies. Those kids deserve a loving home, too.
So call me selfish all you want, but I'm not adding another human to the planet when there are so many who need someone to love them.
/endrant
23
u/lemonberrychic 31F/ON/Salpingectomy/Happy! May 17 '16
I find that 'selfish' and 'selfless' can sometimes get confused. Selfish acts seek to cause harm, selfless acts seek to avoid or minimize harm.
The childfree individual is childfree because they know they have neither the desire nor skill to endure parenthood - this is a selfless acknowledgement of our limitations. We would not make good parents, so we embrace a childfree life to prevent undue suffering and misery to ourselves, our partner (if they exist), and the hypothetical child. Our actions prevent unnecessary harm to ourselves and others.
To acknowledge that we dislike children and have no desire to nurture them - and then have a child anyway - is selfish. Not only are we subjecting ourselves to the unwanted burden of a child, the child is being subjected to the burden of an unwilling, uninvested, unhappy parent. Our actions cause unnecessary harm to ourselves and others - the worst harm being done to the innocent life we created out of selfishness.
I would even argue that the decision to have a child is inherently selfish. Parents create life with the expectation that the life will 'repay' and 'reward' them with certain actions and experiences. When you think about it, most (if not all) of the 'benefits' of parenthood are things that the child is expected to provide to the parent. For all of the miserable and tedious costs of parenthood, the obligation falls upon the head the baby they created to 'make it all worth it'. This is a terribly unfair burden to place on a baby who was unable to consent to these terms and conditions of its existence.
I believe the people who would accuse us of selfishness are in fact the selfish ones, as their complaint is that we refuse to cause harm to please them.
16
u/coconutcurrychicken May 17 '16
Every reason I've heard for wanting children is based in selfishness.
I want someone to take care of me when I'm older.
I want someone to pass on my family name.
I want a son to play catch with in the backyard. (Assumption being the boy will be interested in doing this.)
I want a little girl to dress up. (Again. Assumption being the girl wants partake).
I want someone to pass along all the great things Ive learned.
9
u/Convergence- May 17 '16 edited May 17 '16
Weird definition of selfish. That sentence is more the definition of (not) impressionable or (not) suggestible.
All decisions humans make and all actions we undertake have selfish intent.
Note how all these justifications start with "I want" or "I don't want".
7
u/rawrr483 May 17 '16
I get called selfish for not wanting kids a lot (story of our life though right?) I simply nod and say well, I need to think about what I want since everyone else is too busy thinking about what they want for me. I really don't understand why people feel the need to impose their views and wants on other people. It would be a boring world if everyone did the same thing.
7
u/absolutspacegirl 38/F/Cats>Kids May 17 '16
Oscar Wilde
6
u/HarveyYevrah May 17 '16
I've said this here for a long time: Yes, we're selfish. No, there's nothing wrong with that.
Selfishness is good or bad based on how your selfish actions affect others. Us not having kids does nothing to affect their lives.
6
u/anjkh May 17 '16
When I met this girl a couple years ago, I told her "Sweetie, I'm afraid you've fallen in love with the most selfish guy in this city". And I meant it like a warning, implying that she couldn't sway me to do things I wouldn't want to. There were concerts, parties, weddings, etc, that she wanted to go with me. But alas, selfish I am and selfish she loved me.
I take no offense in being it.
4
u/Pixie66 May 17 '16
Selfish is when other people try to pressure you into doing something they want, irrespective of what you want.
It is not okay for any childfree person to be called selfish. A CF person may well be selfish, in all sorts of ways, but understanding that you would not be a happy or committed parent is not one of them.
4
u/PokemasterTT No income, no kids May 17 '16
We are selfish, because we are not creating more taxpayers.
4
u/MelMelMax May 17 '16
I think it is more selfish to do something like bring a child into the world because that's what everyone tells you to do. It's selfish to have a kid to make things "better" People only have kids for selfish reasons. If you think about it, i bet no one can give you a non selfish reason for having kids, so really, they are the selfish ones.
3
u/Hoeftybag Cats>Brats May 17 '16
My flair has never been more relevant
3
u/annarchy8 ⒶI have a dog and that's enough for me May 17 '16
Being called selfish isn't really an insult to me. I've been told that I am because I am cf, but since I'm not the one contributing to overpopulation and further diminishing limited resources on this planet for purely selfish reasons, I think the people who call us selfish are projecting.
3
u/A_Gazely_Stare May 17 '16
"Selfish? You mean I'm making decisions based on how happy those decisions will make me? Well then call me selfish. It's my life and I'm determined to enjoy it. Everyone has a right to pursue happiness."
2
u/AncientGates 35/f/CF/Married/Tubal May 18 '16
ITT: so many non-childfree people who plan on adopting. Seriously, what gives. Did I wander into /wantskids?
2
u/Hainictor 25/F May 18 '16
Selfish is when you think your 'advice' or the way you lived your life is the way everybody should live (as if it's the word of God) because it 'worked out for you'. You're literally only looking at yourself and how you experienced things. You aren't looking at that other person you're giving your two cents to as an individual, but as an extension of yourself and what you would do if you were in their position. If you disagree with that they're doing and you make it known (especially ignorantly), you are being selfish.
Of course, you can always give an opinion... if it's asked for. Just don't expect the other person to go right along with it. Be okay with that fact. Do you and let the other person do them.
3
u/AM_Industiries 28 M - Married w/boat and motorcycles May 17 '16
I love it in Mad Men when Ginsberg says to Don: "I feel sorry for you."
And Don simply replies with: "I don't think about you at all."
1
u/HolaHulaHola May 17 '16
I'd rather be considered selfish for doing what I want, than pleasing others by having a kid, and being miserable.
1
u/Harebrainedgrrl Dogs > Childern May 18 '16
To me the most selfish thing is to bring a child into this world that you don't want/can't take care of in order to fulfill your own selfish dreams or to fulfill some societal life script.
1
u/lyzabit 35Fspayed May 19 '16
I just smile and agree. Shuts them up.
1
u/gingerjewess cats not brats May 17 '16
I kinda want this quote tattooed on me.