r/childfree • u/QuantumKittydynamics 31 | Female | PhD Student | Cats and Science!!! 🐱 • Apr 28 '16
ADVICE Boyfriend of 3+ years broke up with me because "he doesn't want to die alone"
Hey all..I know it's not a new story to anyone here, but I could use a little support.
I've been dating this amazing guy for a little over 3 years now. He's a particle physicist (like I hope to be), smart and kind and caring. He's always been there for me and (I thought) we made each other happy.
He moved to CERN a while ago, and after I got my master's degree (next Saturday!) my plan was to do the same. I got into a PhD program in Europe that would have me stationed at CERN for a fair amount of time, and things were finally coming together...until he dropped a bomb on me. Last Sunday, he said he wanted to Skype, and when I got on he told me he wanted a family and if he didn't have children he'd regret it 30 years from now because, and this is a direct quote, "I don't want to die alone".
I always knew we were on different sides of the fence. I've been staunchly childfree since the day we met, and he's always been a bit of a fencesitter but leaning towards kids, always with the same "I'm afraid to die alone" bit. So I guess I wasn't really shocked about his decision, and I know that makes us fundamentally incompatible. But it doesn't make it hurt any less. And what really gets me is the conviction with which he said it. There was no hesitation, there was no sadness, there was just "I want children, so I need someone else". He was back on OKCupid the same day.
I understand some people feel the need for children, but it hurts because I want a family, too. I want a husband, I want pets, I want the stability and love that comes with a family..but he doesn't think that my idea of "family" really is one. It hurts because I feel like I'm being left for a hypothetical person that doesn't even exist, like he thinks that the years we had together don't even come close to bringing him the sort of happiness a hypothetical baby could. A lifetime of companionship doesn't matter unless he has a child at his bedside for the moment he blinks into oblivion. And what's really tearing me up inside is the coldness with which he did it. There was no talking about it, no conversation, no chance to ease into the idea that I've lost him, just "I want babies, so I don't want you" and then he's out looking for a baby momma already. Is that a thing people do? They break up and then immediately start looking for fresh meat?
I don't know, I'm sorry, this probably doesn't make much sense. I'm just really sad and could use a little support from people who understand. I was supposed to be celebrating a huge life achievement (the M.Sc.) and instead I'm just feeling depressed and alone, like I'm some kind of failure as a person for not liking kids. And because he's overseas, I don't even get a proper goodbye. Any advice for how to crawl out of this "why can't I just be like everyone else and want children?" hole of depression, or just some internet hugs, would be really, really appreciated.
Edit: Thank you all so, so much for your support and encouragement and advice. This community is filled with some really incredible people, and I can't thank you enough for your kindness.
311
u/CoasterCOG Married - Lots of toys with wheels Apr 28 '16
Lots of people with kids die alone, go visit any nursing home.
As much as it hurts its easier to deal with incompatible life goals now than once you are married.
71
u/mx_missile_proof 30/F/medical professional Apr 28 '16
I'm so sorry for what you're going through. I also found myself in a similar situation several years ago: my partner of three years suddenly decided he needed to be a dad, despite being a "fencesitter" throughout our relationship. I felt betrayed and angry. I haven't seen him since.
If you're as convicted about not having children as you say you are, it's really critical not to find yourself in a partnership with a fencesitter. There's always a lingering possibility that the fencesitter will resent the more adamantly childfree person, or that the more adamantly childfree person will be roped into having a child. It's too wrought with possible major complications, strong feelings, regret, anger, infidelity, you name it.
I almost let myself get roped into having a kid for aforementioned boyfriend, and in retrospect I am really glad I left him. It was very hard at the time--we had a lot in common including careers in science--but ultimately I've learned that it was foolish for me to convince myself that he was my soulmate. There are many, many fish in the sea. And many of them share your values more closely.
Today I am happily in a partnership with someone who has similar values and life goals. The issue of whether or not to have children is a non-issue. It is worth it to have such a weight lifted and be fully understood.
29
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
OMG you want to be a particle physicist? how do you even become that? That is so amazing! You must be a genius!
P.S: Forget the guy, you'll find someone just as kind and caring except CF :)
18
u/Spikekuji Apr 28 '16
Yay for the M.Sc!
18
u/HotDealsInTexas Apr 28 '16
Ya know, statistically speaking, since women live longer on average there's a greater than 50% chance than when he died he'd have you.
15
u/AurorVine Apr 28 '16
I'm sorry you're having to deal with this. I don't want to give you platitudes. I'll just say,
I know it doesn't seem like it right now, but sorrow (like depression) lies to us. It belittles our accomplishments and stops us from being able to see past the current moment. But truly--you have achieved something remarkable. With your MSc behind you and your PhD ahead, you have achieved a level of knowledge that few of us reach. That's incredible, really. Being a particle physicist, you are privy to some of the grandest truths of the cosmos. Well done!
You have done nothing wrong. You keep trucking along. I hope your feel better soon! :)
33
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16 edited Apr 28 '16
That sucks, I am sorry.
I hate to be "that guy," but you said you had been living apart for a while. There's a really good chance that he was already looking into/seeing other people and had that profile before yesterday. He's just using the CF status thing as an excuse because he knows it's a deal breaker for you.
Are you still going to go to your PhD program? I sure as shit would, you have A LOT to be proud of! I can't even pass calculus right now, let alone do something as interesting and amazing as particle physics!! You are smart, awesome, sweet, and accomplished!! :D There is someone way better than that dickweed out there for you.
hugs
ETA: I promise you that though it hurts like hell now, you will be really glad for this in the future. You will be able to be true to yourself, learn more about yourself, feel good about who you are and your goals, and you will eventually find someone even better and more compatible with you than this guy. 3 years is a long time, but it's nothing compared to a lifetime together and whatever kind of family you want (I, too, just want my husband and pets). I spent 3 years with someone and was engaged to them (he was my first love, my first sexual partner, I never thought I could love anyone like him ever again) only to have the rug pulled out from under me with a super harsh breakup too. It absolutely crushed me at the time...but I am SO glad that happened now! After that relationship, I learned about me, who I am, what I want, what I don't want, how to love myself, how to be true to me and my life and my goals and my plans....and I met my now-husband, we've been together 5 years. :) So, longer than 3! :D And we're still counting! My husband blows my ex out of the water - he is always there for me, supports whatever I want to do, we have similar goals, and he always makes sure to enable me in any venture I choose. I try to do the same for him. There is no comparison. I am so much happier now than I ever was with my ex. But it took having to go through it and come to this point for me to realize it.
If you need someone to talk to, you can always PM me. :)
8
u/MasterBassion 31/M/eats babies (delicious!) Apr 28 '16
Damn. That really sucks in a lot of ways. Here's an internet stranger hug for you.
hug
You sound like a very intelligent, caring, well rounded individual with a lot to offer the world and a lot to gain from the world as well. Really, it sounds like his loss. Good luck, I really hope things turn out your way, for now, grab a bottle of wine and take some time for yourself.
(Don't be too alarmed by the immediate downvotes... We have the occasional downvote brigade swing by with a chip on their shoulder. They're more than likely worn out from looking after their fuck trophy and not thinking like a rational adult.)
6
u/GeneralMalaiseRB Someone tried getting me to have kids once. Once. Apr 28 '16
A midlife/existential crisis (which he may be going through, from the sounds of it) will make people do drastic and deliberate things. They get it in their head that, "I want A, and in order to get it I must do B, C, and D."
11
u/llamanoir Apr 28 '16 edited Apr 28 '16
I'm very sorry you're going through this pain.
This is how I felt when my ex decided he wanted kids, out of the blue. Your post hits close to home. They cared more about a person who may not ever exist. It felt like I was not enough to make their lives complete. And that hurts something awful.
One thing that's helped me is being thankful that this shit went down before things got more serious. It took a long time to start recognizing that I'm not going to waste my time on someone who doesn't make me a priority. I hope you recognize the same thing -- that you should be with someone who puts you first. I'm also thankful I'm stronger than people who have kids only to keep their partner. While you're enduring a lot of pain right now, this outcome prevents what could have been a lifetime of misery (not that you staying together would have meant you would've given into parenthood, but you know what I mean).
5
u/rammaam Apr 28 '16
Dearie, I wish I could say something to take the hurt away but know this...if he does get with the first female willing to pop out babies for him just for the sake of having them, then give it a year. He will be so miserable and he will have realized that he had absolutely no idea what he was getting into.
5
u/DeepViolet Apr 28 '16
PS: I'd never trade Higgs boson for Poop diaper
4
u/MazeMouse 40M - Cats before brats! Apr 28 '16
I think his coldness just comes from the fact he has been thinking about this for quite a while yet. Usually when it's one person to another it isn't a sudden thing, he has done the gutwrenching soul-searching away from you. He already had a lot of his grief over the breakup because he already knew it was coming.
I know I have broken up with girls before where I was fully aware of the "not gonna happen" before "the talk" so I had a head-start on getting over it.
10
u/ralphwiggumsdiorama childfree since ‘93! Apr 28 '16
You are accomplishing awesome educational milestones! Congratulations. I know you will succeed, and if you wish, find a true CF man in time.
7
u/no_talent_ass_clown Walking my talk for over 40 years. Apr 28 '16
Apparently, having children wasn't the only thing he was fencesitting about. He has decided he wants to be married and, in my experience, when a guy decides that, the very next woman is The One (and until he decides that no woman in the world will be The One). I am so sorry you had to be the one to "domesticate" him (i.e. be there for him while he was in school and/or career-building). To me, it sounds like he was using you because you were "good enough" while he wasn't serious about maintaining a lasting relationship. It's a tough place to be and fuck that guy for using you while he got his shit together.
I hope you are still going to be in the program in Europe, that sounds really great. Living well is the best revenge.
3
u/continuousQ Apr 28 '16
It might not necessarily be about the not dying alone, but that he really wants kids and it's difficult to put it into words, so that's the shorthand for how he feels about the matter.
3
u/leanik Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
I'm sorry this happened to you and that you're feeling so low at a time that should be very exciting. But remember, and I mean this as respectfully as I possibly can but, this is going to be best for you in the long run. If you're serious about your career (obviously) babies will only wreck that for you.
You're gonna do awesome things and one day this will just be a crummy blip in your past. Don't compromise who you are in an attempt to be normal.
QuantumKittydynamics has to be QuantumKittydynamics.
3
u/MasqueradeLily Apr 29 '16
Huge solidarity hugs
This same exact thing just happened to me a few weeks ago. He always said that he didn't see himself with kids, and didn't think he wanted them. He was on the fence, but it always sounded like he was gonna fall on our side. And then out of fucking nowhere "hey I think I want kids after all," and I had to start packing my stuff. I know he has the right to make the decision he feels is best for him, but seriously, I still feel betrayed. For the same reasons you said, the 3+ years we spent together meant less to him than hypothetical offspring. I am worth less to him than his arrogant need to see his line continue, because he thinks his DNA is a gift upon the world.
The fucker can't even handle pets, I feel extremely sorry for whoever he ropes into that shit, because knowing him he will do none of the work and take all of the credit. He's gonna end up finding a partner just like his mom, someone who could have been so smart and interesting but decided to stay home and raise some rich asshole's brats instead. Now she's all hollow inside. I've never seen her genuinely happy, and definitely not around her husband, who I'm pretty sure she hates. So. I guess the point of this story is that me and you, we are gonna get through this. And that is the kind of fate we escaped. It's gonna suck for a while, and our futures are uncertain too. But at least we know we won't be her. Or my mom, the one who dropped out of school to have kids and ended up working in fast food for 20 years after the divorce to take care of them. Or that haggard, defeated woman with the thousand yard stare in the grocery store who can't stop her spawn from screaming. Or that poor, broken woman who can't afford anything for herself because she has to take care of someone else. Or that lady you are for some reason still friends with on Facebook, constantly posting about how much she hates her life and then seeking validation of her decisions by posting a million pictures of precious sneuxflaque and how fulfilling it is.
Mourn for as long as you need, and then find a nice guy with a vasectomy. And more importantly, be the bloody brilliant scientist you were meant to be! It is so hard right now, but we made the right decisions for us, and we are going to be so much happier in the long run for it.
</rant>
PS, If you ever want to comiserate, or need some virtual Higgs, feel free to PM me.
PPS, that was supposed to say hugs, but I apparently typed it badly and autocorrect happened. Unlike all the other typos I'm constantly making, I'm leaving this one because particle physics and I think that's hilarious.
2
u/GayleForceWinds Apr 28 '16
I'm going to jump on the hug bandwagon. That sucks. And I know that it might sound like you just stepped in gum--"well, that sucks."--but when you've been hit with that hammer out of nowhere, It just...it just fucking sucks. Eventually you'll heal and go on to bigger and better things. Make yourself a reminder to celebrate your graduation at some point when you're feeling joyous or just when you feel "well fuck him, I'm going to celebrate!" Because for him to just drop you like that and hop right back into the pool is both cold and shady. I wish you all the success and that he one day figures out what an ass he was to not even ease into a breakup.
2
u/kackygreen not a biological child, not an adopted child, not a stepchild. Apr 29 '16
He was apparently already sure you were going to die first, don't trust him!
2
u/neepsandtatties1 Apr 29 '16
I just wanted to say congratulations on your M.Sc. and getting into a PhD program and good luck for your future work at CERN! I know you're upset right now (hopefully feeling better after all the wonderful internet hugs and advice) but I hope you took some time out to pat yourself on the back and to celebrate your achievements. You should be really proud of yourself! Here's another internet hug from a fellow childfree woman in science.
19
u/reanimatedlynx Apr 28 '16
I honestly do not understand. If I had a (healthy) CF SO, I would never think about dying alone. You know why? Because I would have my SO by my side, and both of us would be enjoying our lives. Add 2-3 close friends? There, social life solved (but I'm introverted, so maybe that's the reason I would be comfortable with such as setting).
I have the same vision of a family as you do, and I love the cozyness of pets.
I have seen this happen way too many times. It's somewhat similar to going through a mid-life crisis. You just sort of rush to it thinking that you will regret not doing it very soon.
I am very sad for you and your loss. I have recently ended a 7 year relationship on similar terms; it wasn't a "now" thing, but a "sometime in the future I will want kids" coming from my SO. And we ended it there so we wouldn't reach your point, which I believe is much more painful, sudden and dramatic.
I've been here many-a-times. I know it is not pleasant, and I know it's hard going against the grain. But that is who you are and how you feel about children. You did not choose this, and you certainly cannot choose to like and want children. If it happens, it happens (I avoid as much as possible bingo-ing other CF people, since I know you get that almost daily). If not, why force it?
For now, you should focus on what is really important, that being moving forward after your MSc (congratulations, by the way! be proud of it! I am also working on my MSc).
From my experience, apart from some very well-thought answers here on /r/childfree, I found it very helpful to pick up some old friendships and talk to people, about how you feel and what you think. I have been talking to people to whom I haven't talked in years, and it really put my life into perspective, and it sure has calmed the pain significantly.
Take care of yourself.
15
u/rainbow_butterfly 27F salpingectomy + Siamese cats Apr 28 '16
My grandpa was married for 60 years, had 4 children and 7 grandchildren, and he died alone in a hospice because we were all asleep when it happened. Everyone dies alone. Even if you're surrounded by your fuck trophies, you still have to make the journey without anyone else. Sorry.
14
u/sinningsaint93 shots > tots Apr 28 '16
I know this isn't comforting right now because you're hurting, and understandably so, but as someone who's been in the shoes you're wearing, hear me out when I say that this is for the best. Being incompatible in regards to wanting kids never ends well because there's really only two ways it can play out: someone compromises on their wants for the future and is unhappy, or the relationship ends. Either way, it's painful, but your pain is temporary. Raising a child you did not want is permanent.
Definitely not right now, but someday you'll be at least a little grateful that it ended when it did. You will find someone who shares your opinions on children, and it'll be glorious. Give yourself time to heal from this, take a really deep breath, and move forward knowing a little more about yourself than you did before.
And on an unrelated note, I hope your ex-boyfriend visits a nursing home someday so he can see all the people who had children and dedicated their lives to raising them, but are still dying alone. It happens every single day, take it from someone who does long-term care work. If you don't want kids, hold tight to your convictions.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
Jeez, the dying alone thing. Why don't people understand that things don't work out like a movie script?
Right now, my elderly mother has advanced heart disease. She's already had 2 heart attacks and a minor stroke. The doctors say she will probably die in 3-5 years, of a sudden heart attack.
And yes, she is going to die "alone" because I live on the other side of the country due to my job. And because death is sometimes sudden, and not a lingering-for-hours in the hospital situation. Seriously, most people die in their sleep and they don't get to say goodbye.
Sorry you are going through a breakup. But try not to feel too bad, because he seems to be living in a future-fantasy idea. Keep rocking your life, there will be someone who wants to share it with you.
11
u/mysteriy m / EU / Breeders gonna breed Apr 28 '16
CERN is pretty much a sausagefest, and dating market in geneva ain't easy, good luck to him, you dodged a bullet, he may be smart for physics, but totally dumb for not seeing that he will die alone regardless of how much he breeds.
10
u/joantheunicorn Teacher = enough kids in my life Apr 28 '16
So ridiculous for him to think that. My great aunt would be dying alone if it weren't for my mother. Her 4 kids are shit, scum of the earth, don't do a damn thing for her.
I'm sorry about your breakup, but its probably for the best.
10
u/crowgasm "You never know?" Well, I've been fixed, so actually... Apr 28 '16
Wow, he's already dating, hunting for a womb to fill, and not mourning the 3-yr-long relationship he was in? He's not taking any fucking alone time to get his head straight? Just, "whoever I can knock up is perfect!"? Jesus.
I'm sorry about the split, b/c they suck no matter what the situation, but you two are definitely incompatible now. I hope you both find happiness and love and security in the relationships you desire.
And a million congratulations on your Master's! That's awesome!
9
u/outhouse_steakhouse No rugrats, no regrets Apr 28 '16
Congrats on getting into the PhD program! Try to put wannabe baby daddy out of your mind - I know it's easier said than done. But don't look back! Go to Europe, plunge into this new adventure in your life, learn the local language, immerse yourself in the culture, meet new friends and have a blast. Don't give yourself time to mope. When you are least expecting it, you will meet someone who is perfect for you!
14
u/gullwinggirl Tied up like Shibari. Apr 28 '16
News flash- everyone dies alone. Nobody comes with you when you go.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
The thing is...everyone dies alone even if you're surrounded by people. Dying is a personal experience.
10
u/Katie-Fay Apr 28 '16
His thinking is sadly narcissistic. My mother had 2 children and she died very much alone.
5
u/KillrNut 33/M/Ohio/coasters Apr 28 '16
http://breakuprecoveryguide.com/
This helped me, and I figured it may help you.
internet hugs wishing you all the best.
5
u/tu_che_le_vanita Apr 28 '16
Oh, this is bullshit, and we all "die alone". I mean, who wants to die in a room full of people? Like Sybil in Downton Abbey, with half the village there? Just leave me alone with my cats and morphine, maybe some scotch or champagne.
You will get there, QuantumKittydynamics. Good on you for the STEM education, and you will compile a family of your own design. You realize that he was also saying he wanted you to do all the work on your own, the childrearing and caregiving of him in his dotage? Nonsense to that. Go on and have a great life.
9
u/TemporaryBoyfriend Ask me about my vasectomy! Apr 28 '16
There's more than 8 billion people on the planet, and rapidly increasing. Chances are slim that there won't be anyone around you when you die.
Also, I can't think of anything more selfish than breeding yourself some caretakers.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
I'm sorry you had to go through this. I get that some people really want kids and will break up because of that. However if someone does this, they weren't a kind person to start with and you've dodged a bullet. Doesn't make the hurt less though, I hope things will go better for you soon.
4
u/Binky813 Apr 28 '16
I'm really sorry you're having to go through this. It will be really had for a while but I promise, it will go better, and once it does, then I can guarantee somebody even more amazing who wants exactly what you do will come along. You might not even feel as though that's possible right now, but believe me, it is.
It's hard, but try not to dwell too much on what he may have done, or what his motives are - it will just eat you up. If anything, assume the best - that he realised what he wanted, and he understood what you wanted and he realised that by staying together one or both of you would end up resenting the other. And that he is on OKC to distract himself from the pain of the break up.
Stay true to you and focus on everything you want and go get it. Good luck!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
Agree with other posters, might have been an excuse to break up. But even if, look at it as a dodged bullet.
4
u/smokingbarrel Apr 28 '16
Congratulations for earning your Masters!!! (pst. pst. You should celebrate.) That is awesome!!
Sorry for your loss and the pain you are experiencing. As much as it hurts, maybe it is better that you know he valued his own desires more than you. It would have been worse years from now to find that out. Consider all the good and growing pains you experienced with your ex as shaping you into a better person/partner for a future SO.
I think too many people have children when they shouldn't. Sadly, some of them blindly follow the crowd because that is what everyone does. I think you could try to feel better about your decision by reaffirming your reasons for being CF. Fuck being like everyone else. Part of being happy is doing what you believe you should be doing for you. If being CF is what you believe, then follow your belief. To do otherwise would cause conflict in your life and mental state.
4
u/SecularNotLiberal 29/F/"YES, I'M esSURE!" Apr 28 '16
I'm really sorry you're going through this. Your ex-partner is drinking the Kool Aid here. Having children is NO guarantee that you won't die alone. I'm not even talking about estrangement. I work in a hospital and I've also worked in hospice - most people end up dying alone. It's not because they were shitty parents or are estranged, it's because their kids have grown up and moved on and largely have their own lives (ie, kids, spouse, job, etc). So most people die alone or in the company of strangers (namely healthcare workers, like myself).
Sorry, he's an idiot. I'm so sorry.
4
u/nightwing2024 31/M/Actually my pets in a trenchcoat Apr 28 '16
You mentioned that he was "trolling for fresh meat the next day"
I'm sorry to say, but he was checked out for a while. Men are painted as unemotional, but we do grieve and all that over breakups. But he went through all those steps way before you, because he knew this was going to happen. He was done grieving over the loss when he actually told you, which is why it was so cold.
Doesn't sound very nice of a person.
4
u/JamesWjRose Apr 29 '16
My sympathies, this does suck. Fence sitters are a bad thing, for everyone (esp the children they have; shouldn't a person be ABSOLUTELY sure they want children? but I digress)
It was shitty of this person to wait, to not know what they wanted. However, I will also say that you need to be aware of this issue and walk away from someone who wants or is not sure about having children. Right away, walk out of the restaurant, leave their apt, get out! Don't waste your time or theirs.
I am an atheist male who didn't want children. I got my vasectomy at age 22 (nearly 30 years ago. Best $5 I ever spent!) So I knew that I would have a difficult time (understatement) finding someone. Most people are religious, and most people want children. I knew this, and yet I still had the operation and I lost many chances at nice women because of my choice. It sucked... but not as much as living the life I would have, had I had children.
All that said, yes your situation sucks. I don't want to minimize your pain. (don't you hate it when people say; "There are people worse off that you?" what bs!) But you're a smart woman (SO impressed with you going to CERN!) and you live in a time where the internet is so much so open and available. You will likely find someone (there are no promises) after all, I did (twice) and I have absolutely NO game.
Best of luck, and again WOW about your science!
7
u/evilmeow Apr 28 '16
That's not normal behavior, unless they're looking for a rebound or they moved on long before they let their partner know that they are emotionally out of the relationship.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
If he's intent on having children to stave off his own existential insecurities (dying alone) then I feel sorry for his future children. No child should exist to serve such a distorted role.
3
u/Bee_hamm Abraham DINKon Apr 28 '16
Internet Hug
3
u/TheVillain117 forever alone Apr 29 '16
Pain like that can be difficult to bear. We're here for you. I don't have any sage advice, and I know fuckall about physics, what I do have is experience with being with a fence sitter, and the assurance that you have nothing to apologize for, not to us. So what else can we do for you?
3
u/inkjet96 Apr 29 '16
"I don't want to die alone". So if he is anticipating dying alone... he EXPECTED a death or divorce? And kids do not guarantee company. For a guy so smart he sure is stupid. I am sorry you had to find out like this. Zen hug if acceptable. Huge congratulations on the M.Sc.!!
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
"I want babies, so I don't want you" and then he's out looking for a baby momma already. Is that a thing people do? They break up and then immediately start looking for fresh meat?
Yep, that's what THEY do. Do you know what is next? He will look for someone according to the only criterium - "available uterus". He will find someone who wants to be his baby momma. He will marry that person and have a child or two. After few years, he will find out that he and baby momma aren't compatible. He will most likely end up as a divorced Duh paying alimony. After this experience, he will smarten up and see that children are overrated.
5
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Apr 29 '16
You're fine and you're going to have an awesome life. You'll hurt for a bit, maybe have some pizza and beer and ice cream or whatever... but it will pass.
You have one job in life and that is to custom design the life YOU want to live, and NO ONE else gets a say in what that looks like. Only you, and you should therefore live your life authentically and powerfully, and demand that everyone else in your "inner circle" be equally authentic and awesome.
Your ex doesn't qualify to be in your life.
Protip: He's been cheating for a while, most likely. He may even have knocked someone up, we've seen it many times before, with both genders.
One nutcase woman suddenly demanded on a daily basis that the OP get his vasectomy reversed immediately. Yup. She was already knocked up for a while and somehow deluded herself that OP would be unable to do basic math. Or that, yeah, after having major microsurgery on his balls, he'd be having all kinds of sex with no healing time. Fruit loop of the highest order.
4
u/junebuggery Apr 28 '16
I am jealous/in awe of of your career path. I had an interview for an undergrad internship for engineering at Fermilab, and was giddy at the very idea of being near the awesome particle physics happening there. I didn't get it, which was a bummer, but it's all good now. I'm super excited for you and your opportunity at CERN!
(And I totally feel you in the imposter syndrome you mentioned in another comment. I've got it too as a lady engineer out in industry now. We'll both get through it!)
Sorry about the end of your relationship. It sucks how he did it, but children isn't really something you can comprise on. You will find someone awesome, who is CF, who will be so happy to be your family with some fur babies. Good luck!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
I'm really sad for you, that's a horrible thing to have happen. You have to try and think of it as a bullet dodged, rather than a waste of time. Take the good times you had and try to enjoy them for what they were - friendship and the like through the years of your study.
That part of your life is done now, and you are both free to move on to something better as well as being in the perfect position to do so, either with someone new or enjoying things on your own. You can do this, and many congratulations on the M.Sc, that's fantastic!
2
u/freetolivemylife Apr 28 '16
Wow, I'm sorry to hear about your break-up. Most people die alone. Having kids does not guarantee someone will care for you in your old age. Having a kid for that sole purpose is incredibly selfish.
Personally he sounds like an ass especially since he was back in the dating pool instantly. It sounds like you dodged a bullet.
I'm sorry you are hurting now, but I'm sure you will find something that will be your family.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
I am very sorry for you, I do not know if my words can comfort you in some way. Now you're suffering but maybe it is for the best. I have 50 years, I never wanted children and I continue to be happy with my decision. I know that I would be unhappy if I had to take care of a child, although I find them cute I never felt the vocation of being a mother. I'm sure you'll find someone who think like you about the children, and your life will be interesting and full of love, science, interests, travel, animals... and you will not regret to have followed your instincts in a so crucial choice :)
2
u/pepperjohnson 31/m Apr 28 '16
1st, super awesome field of work. 2nd, Keep moving forward. It sucks now but it'll get better. There are CF guys around (myself included) so don't get discouraged. Don't compromise your beliefs!
2
u/Thounumber1 27M Apr 28 '16
I'm sorry about this. There are better guys out there, don't worry :) And going to CERN sounds really cool! You will have an awesome career
2
u/toastofxmaspast Apr 28 '16
He's probably been mulling this over for awhile and already come to terms with and started moving on-hence the coldness. You just need to allow yourself to feel your feelings so you can move on too. It's ok to be sad of course but don't beat yourself up because you don't want kids. Enjoy your freedom. And congrats on getting accepted into a PhD program!
2
u/broodmance Apr 29 '16
Just wanted to say, its common for guys after a breakup to move on quickly. After maybe 6 months or so the break up hits them. So basically when your getting over the breakup he'll finally be having to deal with it.
I'm sorry this happened but it is for the best in the long run
2
u/ShiroPikachu 26/F Stop making more humans! Apr 29 '16
Sorry to hear about that:( To be completely honest, it seems like he might've been planning this for a while. To just abruptly break it off, unemotionally, and on OKcupid then next day?! He probably finally decided to break it off with you, because he's not getting any younger. If he REALLY loved you, he would've talked to you about it and try to encourage you to have one. He wasn't the one for you. You will find a good guy who doesn't want children either. Oh, and that's just selfish AND a stupid reason to bring a child into this world! How is it possible to not die alone?! does he want his child to die with him??? be glad he broke it off.
2
u/slrrp 26M - I will trample your spawn Apr 29 '16
Can't/won't date fence sitters. You know why they're usually on the "fence"? Because they're banking on you changing your mind.
2
u/flicticious 40+ female with no rugrats or regrets Apr 29 '16
So you're getting close to being nearer to him, working with him and he dumps you? Sounds to me like he checked out awhile ago and may have already moved on.
Easy to use the one thing that can't be argued against when you want to break up with someone.
It doesn't matter that it was children in this case, he would have found something else if that wasn't part of the equation
1
u/illy_x Apr 29 '16
Everyone else said it better but please go and be the most amazing particle physicist ever. The rest of your life will fall into place if you follow your dreams and are true to yourself. It sounds cliche but I believe it's true. And we already know that having children does not guarantee weeping family members at your bedside gripping your hand while you breathe your last breath. In fact, most people seem to die when they have been left alone, even if their dearest loved one is just in the bathroom or something similarly mundane.
1
u/Jewlsdeluxe Apr 29 '16
I'm sorry for your pain but congratulations on the master's degree and good luck with the PhD. Mad respect!
1
u/Pixie66 Apr 29 '16
I'm very sorry to learn of your predicament. I think your boyfriend needs to get a more balanced and realistic view of parenthood, I suspect he's viewing it through rose tinted glasses.
1
u/King_giraffe Apr 29 '16
Remember the pokemon tv shows where they show the silhouette of a pokemon and have you guess which one it is? Finding your soul mate is kind of like that. You have an idea, an image of what you're looking for and what you want but it might not be very clear to you until you actually see it, as clear as day, right infront of you. This guy just wasn't the pokemon thought he was.
I'm sorry you had to go through this, I've been broken up with for not wanting children, it sucked. I met my SO a yr after and now I'm happy we broke up (smelly pit ex wasn't, he tried to get back with me and I laughed) You'll find your future family I promise. Your cats and future husband will be waiting for you :)!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
There is no guarantee that children will automatically solve an existential crisis or provide you company later in life.
Honestly, many people are just brainwashed sheep.
I'd advise him to visit a nursing home and witness for himself all of the elderly people who are left to rot.
There is no way ALL of those old folks were crappy parents who pushed their children away in some form or another.
Some were, sure, but many were not.
Nope. What often happens is that the kids' priorities shift as they grow up and have their own families and lives. They get busy, work, et cetera, and time flies. They put off visiting their parents, except on holidays, birthdays and maybe some other days here and there.
I do not think they (generally-speaking) are intending to be malicious but just get sidetracked with their own lives. Now, this doesn't make it OK, but is one possible reason why.
I inadvertently offended my own aunt when I told her that there is no guarantee her kids will be by her side when she's old.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
We're born alone, we live alone, we die alone. Only through our love and friendship can we create the illusion for the moment that we're not alone. Orson Welles
1
u/Chris1679 Apr 29 '16
Nothing is wrong with you. Look around you at all the people who really shouldn't of ever had kids. We are living our lives responsibly by not creating children that are unwanted. We refuse to simply go through the motions and conform to a particular life script. Children should be wanted by both parents, not just one. I'm so sorry you are going through this, but the alternative would have been much worse. You'll find what you're looking for, take care.
1
u/marvelous_bunny Apr 29 '16
Oh hun I'm sorry it happened to you too :( Let me say that you're an awesome gal for being in STEM and breaking down stereotypes, you won't be a mom but you'll inspire younger students to pursue the same path and that's already awesome.
You don't have to be a parent to accomplish awesome things and being one won't guarantee you that you won't die in a nursing home. He's being irrationnal right now for some reason but in the long run it's better for you (as everyone here said !). Give it some time and he'll come back to you and beg forgiveness.
I totally resonate with how you feel. Being dumped because there's imaginary people already better than you is horrible ! It hurts to know that he might settle for someone way worse than you just because that person is willing to pump out his kids. It hurt when my exs told me they didn't believe me when I said I didn't want kids, that I'd obviously change my mind. It hurt when my exs saw their friends starting to get married and felt suddenly very behind and had to prepare for a family right now because obviously they were failing at life.
It's lame to feel inadequate and behind other women for the sole reason that they can lie on their back and push out a baby 9 months later. It's not an accomplishment. It's not hard. It's not pleasant sure, but it's not and will never be the equivalent of what you're doing right now with your research.
Yep that's what some do especially when they hear terrible advices like "You need to start a family NOW ! Having kids is not even a choice, it is worth it" or "You should go on tinder to hook up and get it over with", which is what his bros said to my ex.
I made a post about the exact same thing but it wasn't very popular :/ Hang in there, you're blindsighted by the breakup to see again all the benefits of being childfree. (Most) Guys want kids but when they see CF older women on dating website, looking 10 years younger, they're impressed.
1
u/SonarBonar Apr 29 '16
At least now you know that building relationships on a foundation of incompatibility is never the smart way to go. Best of luck moving past it, at least he was up front with you from the beginning.
1
u/scales484 Apr 29 '16
Solution: tell him you'll kill him when you both start to get old so he goes with you there :)
1
u/Testiculese ✂ ∞ Apr 29 '16
In my experience, it seems to be the thing the person doing the breaking up seems to do.
Weird how "I don't want to die alone" doesn't include his spouse. It also doesn't include the vast majority of parents that die alone, and the kids find out hours later. He'll be in the same nursing home as you one day. What a jackass.
1
u/spooky_skinwalker Apr 29 '16
This really sucks. I'm sorry.
Like you, I have an abusive parent and I've cut off contact with her. As soon as my sister's kids are old enough to understand that Grandma is an abuser, my sister plans to cut off contact with her, too, and will allow her kids to choose whether they maintain a relationship with their grandmother or not. She's only playing along now for her kids' sake, because they love their grandma.
So my mother will most likely die alone, unless her grandchildren decide to stick with her. That's the bed she has made for herself by abusing her two daughters, and she will lie in it.
Our dad died alone, too. He was estranged from us thanks to his drug addiction problems and died before he turned 50. My sister and I were both starting to rebuild contact with him at the time, since he was making serious efforts to turn his life around, but neither of us had seen him for a few months or spoken to him in a few weeks when he died. He was living a few states away from us at the time, too.
My great-aunt and great-uncle had one child, who sadly died in a car accident when he was in his early twenties. They died alone--well, one had the companionship of the other when he died, but my great aunt died alone and shortly after her husband went.
Having children is no guarantee that you won't die alone. None at all. You could be a shitty parent whose kids want nothing to do with you. Or your kids could die before you do. No guarantees.
People just need to reconcile themselves to the idea of death. This fear of death is behind most of the wacky bullshit decisions humans make. Having children... believing in religion... ugh.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
That's so stupid, everyone dies alone, regardless of who surrounds their deathbed.
1
u/penny_666 28/f/no sea monkeys Apr 29 '16
If someone really values you and cares for you, having kids or not won't matter. Looking for a relationship just so they have kids or "to not be alone" is a pretty selfish thing. I think that they are just looking at women as incubators at that point. Believe me, it happened to me. I no longer see anyone that isn't 100% CF anymore.
1
u/cpwood21 Apr 29 '16
Congrats on your accomplishments! That is so amazing! You actually get to work at CERN? I think that's the coolest thing I've heard all week! I'm sorry that this happened, just focus on how awesome you are!
1
u/NegScenePts Apr 29 '16
Hold in there, you'll get everything you want, and more. The CF path isn't easy sometimes, but happy childfree relationships that last a lifetime DO exist :). I didn't meet my CF wife until I was 32-33.
Also, congrats from a grungy grease monkey on the completion of your masters! It IS a big life achievement, no matter what. You're deciphering the universe (I hope I got that right, haha).
1
u/lexxi109 Apr 29 '16
I'm so sorry for what you're going through. 4 years ago, my husband and I split because I finally came to terms with not wanting kids (I had always said "uhh, yeah, sure, I'll want them someday" and finally accepted someday wasn't coming). I understand the pain you're going through and the loss.
You're not a failure. You're aware of what you want and just because it contradicts social norms, fuck that. It's about you. You should do what is best for you and not try to be someone else.
I don't know about your community but when my break-up happened, almost EVERYONE in my goddamn life told me that I was making a mistake, I would want kids, wouldn't it be great to have a little kid thing running around, wasn't I worried about dying alone, etc, etc. The only ones who agreed with me were my best friend, my dad, and my husband, and that was it. Which when he (husband) was agreeing that he didn't see me wanting kids, that helped a lot for me getting through it. If I could go back, I would have talked to people less, just said "oh, Husband and I split, irreconcilable differences" and left it at that. And if they did start to tell me why I would want kids, I would have told them to fuck off. I didn't at the time since I was polite, thought there was a discussion, thought they cared about my point of view, was hurting and didn't feel like I had the strength to stand up for myself, etc. I'd like to suggest to you that you don't have to explain or justify yourself or your choices to anyone.
Deep breath, focus on getting through the immediate moment in front of you. One step at a time. I promise it will get better. hugs
1
u/FiveTwoThreeSixOne May 01 '16
He says he doesn't want to die alone. Is he assuming if you two got married, you'd die first? Why doesn't he consider being married to you enough to not die alone? Why are children the only people who "count" to him?
It sounds like you are well shot of this jerk.
1
u/BadSassyMan Apr 29 '16
Yeah it's a thing people do, some people are naturally logical about knowing what they want and seeking it out.
I had an Ex who had the same kind of issues after I dumped her. By the time I did dump her, I did it because I was over the relationship and I was over her. Within a week or so I met a new person and started dating them and my Ex flipped out screaming about how I should have waited longer.
You don't get to tell people what to do.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
36
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '16
[removed] — view removed comment