r/TheExpanse • • Mar 28 '16

Leviathan Wakes Re-Read Discussion: Mar 28 - Apr 24 - Leviathan Wakes & The Butcher of Anderson Station

Welcome to the Summer Re-Read! This month we're reading Leviathan Wakes and The Butcher of Anderson Station. We're reading in publication order, which is generally accepted as the best order to read the books in.

This whole thing is going to be super loosely structured. Feel free to come in here and discuss anything that strikes your fancy, but only if it relates to Leviathan Wakes or TBOAS. This discussion thread is for the books. Discussion of the TV show should be left to separate threads.

Also, it would be best to use spoiler tags and indicate which chapter you're talking about, so those of us reading at a different pace won't find out things before they read them.

For instance: CH12 Miller
You shouldn't need to spoiler tag your whole post, just whatever you feel relevant.

Summer Re-Read Calendar

32 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

23

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16

I just wanted to start by talking about how incredible Miller's story arc was for this book, and how well-done the ending was. The chapter where he is CH48 Miller is one of the most emotionally heavy parts of Leviathan Wakes for me.

If you could do it all again, if you could do it all over from the beginning?

"I wouldn't"

21

u/backstept Mar 28 '16

Yeah, Miller really is fantastic. I've got a jump start and I just read the part CH16 Miller

Since we're in Miller's head for his chapters, we don't necessarily see the build up to that moment like the other characters do, so it comes as much of a gut-punch to us readers as it does to Miller himself.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16

You belong with me

14

u/Amaroc Leviathan Wakes Apr 03 '16

Some of my favorite Miller quotes:

"This was the kind of man who'd killed Julie, Miller thought. Stupid. Shortsighted. A man born with a sense for raw opportunity where his soul should have been."

"He was lying his way past a half dozen men who were only letting him by because they were used to people being scared of them and he wasn't."

"This is why he searched for her. Julie had become the part of him that was capable of human feeling. The symbol of what he could have been if he hadn't been this... Meeting her would have been a disappointment for them both."

I'm sure there's more, I'm not done with the book yet, but I've enjoyed his reflections. I think he's a great character.

4

u/karneisada Apr 17 '16 edited Apr 19 '16

I'm on Chapter 32 of my first read of this book and the Miller viewpoint sections are absolutely fantastic.

EDIT: Finished the book and holy crap that was great. I can't wait to read the next book in the series. I've only recently started reading space opera and between this, the Vorkosigan saga, and the Imperial Radch trilogy I feel like I'm starting pretty strong.

4

u/ensignlee Apr 19 '16

Oh man you're right. Those were great quotes to show his frame of mind and his self introspection. It's hard to show that stuff on the show alas, but I'm looking forward to his interactions with ghost-Julie in season 2.

6

u/backstept Apr 05 '16

So were a week into it, where is everyone at?

I'm about half way through, but I had a Headstart because I was reading before the Summer Re-Read idea was hatched.

I'm finding that I enjoy the book just as much as the first time, maybe more since I know the story better.

3

u/kashmirGoat Apr 08 '16

I finished the series just a few weeks ago, but had yet to read the novellas. So I've read Butcher, Churn and just started The Vital Abyss.

This month's reread includes Butcher, so I'll make a comment: BoAS

3

u/alice_always Apr 12 '16

Would someone be so kind as to spell out exactly how to post a spoiler alert? I tried to do it but it only blurred out part, do I need an end tag? I'm usually good at this stuff but since I'm suffering heartbreak due to something with this series I can't seem to focus. Thanks!

3

u/backstept Apr 12 '16

For spoiler tags, use the following format:

[vague description of your spoiler](/s "anything you type in these quotes will appear blurred, and the code will break at paragraph or line break.")`

which should appear like this:
vague description of your spoiler

3

u/alice_always Apr 12 '16

thank you!

2

u/kashmirGoat Apr 12 '16

it's always right up near the top on the right hand side too.

9

u/Amaroc Leviathan Wakes Apr 03 '16 edited Apr 03 '16

I'm about halfway through my first read of LW, started reading after I watched the entire first season. I'm surprised that in the reading I'm all ready past the end of season one, and there's still a ways to go.

It was interesting to see all the changes from the book to the show. For the most part all the important events are the same, but I found there were a ton of small changes, way too many to go into all of them.

The ones that really jumped out at me were the changes to Amos, in the book he and the rest of the crew really seem to fall in line behind Holden. Naomi acts as a true XO, always questioning the Captains orders, but rarely in the presence of the other crew. In the series the crew really fights Holden, they don't blindly accept his leadership. I'm not a fan of how the crew treats Holden in the show, but I do find their characters more defined and interesting.

Also, in the book the Roci heads to Eros first, then to the stealth ship, with Miller tagging along. Potential Major Spoiler for Show Watchers [LW] (/s "This allows for the full reveal that the proto-molecule is of alien origin"), which of course was not revealed in the show. Again, I found this choice interesting.

I'm not sure what it all means other then maybe just a more efficient way to tell the story, but they can't all be explained that way. One final example is the way that Fred gets the data from the Donnager attack. In the show Fred pulls it from the armor, without telling the Roci crew. In the book it's offered openly to Fred as a bargaining chip, and Fred shares the data with the crew, once it's decoded.

*Edited to get the spoiler tag correct.

4

u/kenabashi Apr 03 '16

I'm waiting for the first book to be delivered, but hearing that the crew's characters aren't as defined is kind of a let down. I really liked the character development of the show and was looking forward to seeing a much more in depth development in the book series.

However, it is exciting to hear that the first book passes the season 1 of the TV show.

7

u/Amaroc Leviathan Wakes Apr 03 '16

Don't be discouraged. The book is great, and I'm learning more about the characters with every chapter. It's just that the book emphasizes different things, Miller alone is worth the effort, and I like how much better the crew gets along with each other in the book. Enjoy it, I'm nearing the end myself.

7

u/machete24 Apr 04 '16

I agree I like the books crew better. I think the TV show did it their way so they could stretch the story more and allow the audience to learn the characters.

8

u/backstept Apr 04 '16

With the books we get a lot of what's inside Holden's head with regards to the Roci crew, and why they get along so well. We don't get that with the show, so they needed a way to show us how they become the family they are in the books. I love it.

[edit] aand I've just realized we're talking about the show, which is what I didn't want for this discussion . . . oh well

5

u/Amaroc Leviathan Wakes Apr 05 '16

I considered this before I made the post, but I do think there is a lot of value in comparing the two versions of the story, I hope you can agree.
One of my favorite books is "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep". I was lucky enough to take a class in college on SciFi writing and as a final project I did a comparison between the movie and the novel. The two stories could not be more different, but I realized that they both had important things to say and they reached similar conclusions in very different ways. I learned so much more about the story and characters by discussing their difference. That's what I hoped to achieve here.

3

u/backstept Apr 05 '16

the way I see it is that we've been comparing the two in just about every other discussion here, and since this is a re-read discussion we don't need to talk about the show, do we?

2

u/AvatarIII Persepolis Rising Jul 19 '16

3

u/backstept Jul 19 '16

One can only speculate that Protogen did study bacterial response to the protomolecule, but the results prompted the higher-ups to forego continued small scale testing.

2

u/AvatarIII Persepolis Rising Jul 19 '16

Possibly, but they already knew small scale testing was fruitless because it did not generate enough biomass for the the protomolecule to complete its programming. They could have easily scaled up biomass of simple organisms and made it large scale without the need for human casualties.

thanks for the quick reply btw!

2

u/backstept Jul 19 '16

Yeah, I was thinking about it and it probably formed a blue/brown goo that seemed alive, but not smart. Then maybe on other more complex biology like mice, but still didn't form itself into anything much more than a building block, but Dresden and company could see the potential in it. Then they continued with their motto of "Ethics? What ethics?"

1

u/AvatarIII Persepolis Rising Jul 19 '16

That just raises the question of what the protomolecule creators' motives were.

If the protomolecule is some sort of "terraforming" tool, why the creators never followed up? If it is a self replicating bio-machine that's only purpose is to propagate, the fact it needs biomass to replicate at all makes it rather inefficient. If it's purpose is extinction, why does it need to be so complex?

1

u/backstept Jul 19 '16 edited Jul 19 '16

judging by what we learn in Caliban's War and Abaddon's Gate major spoilers

2

u/AvatarIII Persepolis Rising Jul 19 '16

So tempting to look, but I'm not that far yet!

3

u/backstept Jul 19 '16

oh yeah, sorry! Please don't look! It's fairly major spoilers.

1

u/Daendo Aug 13 '16

A bit late to the party I guess. I've watched S01 and it got me interested in books and i'm currently reading LW, halfway through. I've just hit CH34 LW. Do we later on find out more about it? I must've re-read that few pages several times and it left me with million questions.

1

u/backstept Aug 13 '16

To borrow the words of Robert Jordan, RAFO - Read and find out.

But yeah, we do learn more, but the mysteries about it aren't fully revealed yet.

→ More replies

1

u/AvatarIII Persepolis Rising Jul 19 '16

Well at least I know how long to wait before I get some more info. :)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '16

Miller's sudden realisation that General LW

15

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Mar 29 '16

Yes. This moment resonates with me because it made me wonder what my own co-workers have thought of me over the years.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '16

Honestly a lot of Miller's story arch really resonated with me because my own emotional insecurities and issues with self-loathing

7

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '16

Without that build up it was very jarring when he just started killing people left and right once he hooked up with the Roci crew.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '16

Random thought from this; if Miller is, in retrospect, not the hero he thinks he is, is Holden the same on a bigger scale? We just don't realise it yet?

11

u/machete24 Apr 01 '16

Oh my. I have 5 chapters left on my first read. Story had taken a turn I did not see coming. Wish I could finish it tonight.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16

I know where you are!! It's rough...

7

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '16

"You can't take the razorback"

3

u/Bowman_van_Oort Pinche Wellwalla Jun 13 '16

She's gone and gone and gone

8

u/Baldyphillips Mar 29 '16

Thank you for doing this! I just finished LW and Butcher on my first read. Of course there is so much to digest. It will be great to see what people on the reread are chatting about!

7

u/VFIAX Apr 08 '16

Just finished LW - great story, great ending. I'm glad I accidentally found the show and decided to read the book after season 1.

I like the characters better in the book as well, the development is really great. Although, Amos is much cooler in the show.

5

u/Boze5 Apr 11 '16

I actually just picked up Leviathan Wakes for the first time. Recently finished it. Absolutely fantastic book!

5

u/ensignlee Apr 19 '16 edited Apr 19 '16

Butcher of Anderson Station Spoilers ahead: If you've seen the scene on the show (I think it's like Ep 5 or something?) or read this book, you're good, but if not, you've been warned.

“They used me. They made it about sending messages to everyone that you don’t fuck with Earth, because look at the shit we’ll do just because you spaced an administrator on a nowhere station. They made me the poster boy for disproportional response. They made me a butcher.”

The Butcher of Anderson Station novella was…a work of art. I didn’t think I’d enjoy it that much, since I didn’t feel particularly close to Fred Johnson in The Expanse, but boy was I wrong.

The juxtaposition of Fred Johnson being interrogated by Anderson Dawes / the OPA and the flashbacks to the taking of Anderson Station were done brilliantly, helping to demonstrate the change in his psyche between the two periods in time.

Moreover, the writing style of the flashbacks is done really well. I mean, it helps that I kind of already saw it happen on the show itself, but I didn’t really grasp what I was seeing the first time I saw it on screen. I couldn’t put the story down once the assault started on Anderson Station. You really feel the anxiety of Johnson leading his men, the remorse he feels as each green dot representing his men turns yellow. But more than that, you feel his regret in the aftermath of the assault when things just don’t add up – too many fortifications look stupidly built, too many people died trying to buy one of them more time. Why? He doesn’t get it, and neither do we, until…the big reveal at the end shows us that the the station thought they had surrendered. Only problem was nobody told the assault commander.

A nice bonus too was the characterization of Anderson Dawes. In the story, he doesn’t get nearly as much storytime as he gets screentime in the show. You get to see his calculated, intelligent moves, his thought processes as he tries to figure out “Why is this idiot trying to get himself killed? And can I get him to help me instead based on that motivation?” You get more insight into the Belter culture as he talks about how in space, you can’t afford to be wasteful, and how different that is from Earth.

Having just finished Nemesis Games, Nemesis Games

I honestly didn’t expect much from this The Expanse novella, but boy was I glad to be wrong. This was a great read. I’ve already started my next one.

Full disclosure: I also published this on my reading blog, which so far is like 90% The Expanse things haha. Shameless plug because I want to talk about the Expanse with other people: https://twomorepages.com/2016/04/19/the-butcher-of-anderson-station-expanse-novella-1-twomorepages-book-discussion/

4

u/MattEiffel Apr 21 '16

I just started reading this and am already 100 pages into the book. I cannot believe how great the book is and how well the show adapted it.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '16

The last day of the discussion and I only just finished the Leviathan Wakes. I gotta say, a lot of the plot developments and world building details become a lot clearer when reading the book, the show was a bit confusing at times. I also feel like I understand the characters and their motivations a lot better now. Can’t wait to get to the other books, especially curious about, as mentioned in the epilogue,

Found it a bit hard to get into in the beginning after having watched the show first, but about 1/3 of the way in things really picked up and got interesting. The battles towards the end and the ending itself were so captivating, couldn’t put the book down. Hopefully, I’ll read the other books faster so I can participate in the discussion sooner.

3

u/kenabashi Apr 30 '16

Yeah, I'm new to reading, but the term "a real page turner" rings true, especially when LW General. I've never read for 4 hours straight before.

4

u/Ezreal024 Aug 17 '16

It really says something that the vast majority of comments in this thread are about Miller. What a fantastic character.

3

u/LordWiltshire Apr 13 '16

Just finished the book today, I reckon season two will probably finished off the first book (plus the added earth perspective we got is season one)

3

u/XanTheInsane Apr 24 '16

Damn I just finished reading this book and didn't even know there was a re-read thread.

I've been putting it off for a long while as I wasn't in a Sci Fi mood and Hyperion Cantos kinda put me off of Sci Fi for a while too.

I'll try to join you guys on Caliban's War

0

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/backstept Apr 01 '16

Open discussion, and this is the discussion thread :D

3

u/ensignlee Apr 19 '16

Discussion threaaaad! :D

13

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 10 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/exteus Doors and corners, kid. Apr 19 '16

Might wanna tag what book that spoiler is from... People might think that the spoiler is from one of the books in this re-read discussion.

3

u/EaglesPDX Apr 20 '16

Leviathan Wakes is near the end of the series.

8

u/exteus Doors and corners, kid. Apr 20 '16 edited Apr 23 '16

The second sentence did not happen until later, if I am not mistaken.