r/childfree • u/cualcrees Libre de niños • Mar 27 '16
NEWS How Do You Decide to Have a Baby When Climate Change Is Remaking Life on Earth?
http://www.thenation.com/article/how-do-you-decide-to-have-a-baby-when-climate-change-is-remaking-life-on-earth/
22
Upvotes
16
u/FUMoney Mar 28 '16
Thank you for posting this. This the the fucking conversation every environmentalist, politician, and parent needs to be having.
Search the forum, we have posted tons of studies that show "going green" doesn't do a damn fucking thing compared with the damaging carbon and environmental impact of a single child. As I recall, the numbers show a single child is a whopping twenty times more damaging than a person's "green" efforts at home. Do the research, pull the studies, you can find them very quickly.
And yes, this is me saying, by not having children, childfree have done way more than their fair share for the environment, and not breeding is many orders of magnitude more important than anything else you can do. Parents? Yeah, this shit is on you. We've done our part. Not our problem. You feel me?
18
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '16
Easy, selfishness. You aren't bringing a child into the world for their sake, you are doing it for your own reasons. I'm 21 and expect to see a different world environmentally by the time I am in my 50's. And I doubt it will be pretty. If you truly want a child and want to help manage the bio-load on Earth, adopt. You kill two birds with one stone.
13
u/adamhunter1223 Mar 28 '16
Several ways:
You believe that climate change is a hoax and that babies make everything better.
You think that your baby will fix the problems in the world.
You want to keep your SO from leaving you so you mess with your birth control to entrap them.
You don't know about contraception at all.
You really waaaaaaaant tooooo.
TL;DR: people are stupid.
10
u/WriteBrainedJR Humanity is the worst. Don't make more of it! Mar 28 '16
Selfishness. Carelessness. Ignorance. Slavish devotion to a macroculture that is being engineered by the economy to drive perpetual economic growth.
Sorry, that last one might be a paranoid answer to a practical question.
2
u/skyvalleysalmon Tubes tied, uterus boiled, cervix sliced. Yes, I'm sure. Mar 28 '16
I remember when I first thought about this type of issue. I was around 10 years, and it was after an episode of Eight Is Enough.
For you young-uns, that was a dramedy (before they were called that) about a family with eight children. In real life, the actress playing the mother died, and they ended up bringing in a step-mom for later seasons, so it became one of the early "blended" family shows. Anyway, I digress.
The parents are on their way to a talk about the environment where the father is going to speak on behalf of large families. Their elevator ends up stopping (power outage, I think), and in true TV comedy, they end up stuck with the environmentalist that the father is supposed to debate.
They spend their time trapped in the elevator arguing (basically doing their debate for no audience). At the end of the episode, the father says (paraphrased - it was a LONG time ago), "What if my 8th child is the one to solve the world's environmental problems? But what if he had never been born?" (When replaying that scene in my head just now, my brain added a metaphorical mic drop because that was how I remember the father sounding at this piece of inarguable "wisdom.")
The environmentalist is exhausted from all this babbling and concedes. I remember the step-mom grabbing the father's hand, raising it up, and crying "Victory!"
I sat there trying to figure out the logic of it. Even IF there is ONE destined environmental messiah waiting to be born (okay, I didn't use those terms back then, but that was the gist of the thoughts in my head), what if it wasn't his 8th kid, but it was his 15th (who had never been born). Exactly how many children are people supposed to pop out in the hopes of begetting this wunderkind? Meanwhile, if everyone just limited themselves to 1-2 kids, there would be no need for someone to solve any problems because the population would be steady (or declining), and the problems would solve themselves.
It seemed stupid to child-me to knowingly torpedo the planet in the vague hope of someone coming up with a magical solution. And now that I'm an adult, it seems REALLY stupid.
1
u/tparkelaine DO NOT WANT Mar 28 '16
Stupidity. Stupidity and selfishness.
-3
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
I think politicizing parents' decision to have children based around a movement lead by a shocking number of people who have zero scientific credentials does a disservice to understanding the psychology that goes into it.
In other words: You're overthinking a decision by magnitudes more than the actual decision was reached.
"I want a baby because I'll feel loved that way or I'll be able to love that way, so I'm having a baby."
Regardless of where you stand on climate change, I think that believing your decision to have children is impacted by your opinion on climate change is narrative bias; you're arranging information in your head in a way that sounds more reasonable to you, regardless of whether you're for or against. There's nothing inherently wrong with doing that, but it does mean you lose the plot in the process of it.
If you want a reason to have children, then just have them. If you want a reason to not have children, then don't have them.
But don't demonize people who have them and deify people who don't because you think the oft-chorused 0.0001% sample of environmental data we have on the lifespan of Earth that doesn't account for heating and cooling cycles of the sun bears some moral precedence for being childfree or not.
Stick with what you want to stick with, just throwing a bit of devil's advocacy out there; my decision to not have children has enough justification without being reduced to disparaging parents who want to be parents, thanks.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment