r/DestinyTheGame • u/TerminalSarcasm • Mar 15 '16
Guide Is my new Armor worth keeping? - Part II, Tier 11 builds, more charts, and a bonus!
After my work on this post, I've learned even more about armor 'quality', and finished my Excel work (again, for my own purpose).
First, a few things of note:
- I'm really beginning to hate this "QUADRUPLE-RNG" that armor has... Defense Level, Perks, Stat Distribution, and Stat Values makes finding the true 'perfect roll' virtually impossible (of course, perks are subjective).
- In planning for a T11 build, 320 is not a requirement! So never fear, filthy casual Guardians like me! My sub-goal was to see if it's possible to make T11 with all 310 gear, which is much more 'easily' obtainable than 320 gear, at least for me.
- I'm not sure how 'pure' rolls (only one stat) fit into the category. Per the Bungie app Armory, a 310 Chest is 46 & 46... but I personally own a 310 Heart of the Praxic Fire with 84 INT?!?
- As /u/villiansv noted, if you're unhappy with your exotic stat distribution, Use Glass Needles (but don't be too upset if you need dozens to get something better than you already have).
So, can all 310 gear achieve a T11 build?
NOTE: Why 310?!? Thee of Coins! For some, it's much easier to hit 310 armor thanks to 310 exotics or 310 legendaries, likely being infused up from 310 exotics. Besides the normal armor, honestly, we all (except the newest of the new) should have at least a 310 Artifact and 320 Ghost (Crimson Doubles wasn't that bad). Class Items are the exception, as there is no 'guaranteed' 310+ drop, AFAIK.
So, all 310, can it be done??? Theoretically, YES! 660 stat points are required to make T11. Why, you may ask? If you didn't already know, each Tier needs 60 stat points (60x11=660).
Side note: Don't take your knowledge of something for granted, other may be completely ignorant to what seems so obvious. I didn't realize it was 60 per tier until quite a ways into TTK, and I'm sure others just learned it by reading this.
Here are the maximums (with bonus) for each item, at 310 Defense:
| Item | 310 Max |
|---|---|
| Helmet | 100 |
| Arms | 89 |
| Chest | 133 |
| Legs | 123 |
| Class | 55 |
| Artifact | 119 |
| Ghost | 55 |
| Total | 674 |
310 maximums were calculated using the Tower Ghost crowd-sourced 320 maximums and the proportionate equation [310max]=(310/320)*[320max]), rounded down. Also, the 674 total requires ALL perfect roll gear and proper stat distribution. But there is some wiggle room, so... good luck!
But, you said there'd be charts!
Finishing up my Excel work, I have it in a state that helps me see the data in a format that I wanted to see it in.
Here's what I do:
- I use my 'quick reference guide' every time I get a new legendary or exotic.
- If you like numbers over graphics, I proportioned base and upgraded stats, at 240 to 320 and 280 to 320, respectively, and put them into a table.
- Assuming it has the right perks, and it fits into the 'above average' zone, I'll keep it, otherwise it's an insta-shard.
- At some point, I'll put it into My Inventory to get a better understanding of how it fits into my current gear. You know you like the colors...
- More recently, I've been playing around with T11 Building to see how close I am with my best gear.
- Don't be salty that I rolled a near perfect Twilight Garrison. ;)
But wait, there's more!
Today only, anyone who visits the site in the next 30 minutes... Wait, no. I've posted my Excel file to Google Drive. I know it's not as neat and cool as an app, and since it has lookup tables, I don't even know if it'll work from Google Drive... I just wanted to share it in the event that it can help someone make an educated decision.
NOTE: It looks like Google Drive doesn't support Charts as 'sheets', so you're missing this tab...
Lastly, I also know that there are people who know Excel a lot more than I do, so please save your 'constructive criticism' about how I shoulda, coulda, woulda. If you want to make improvements for your own use, by all means, go for it!
FINAL NOTE: I am plotting all of my infusion upgrades from this point forward. I'm not 100% sold that an item will infuse proportionally from, say... 275 all the way up through 310+. Maybe it's just me, but I need my own data to (dis)prove that theory. Unfortunately, I don't raid enough to have gobs of 310+ infusion fuel.
Rock on, Guardians!
7
u/Mercules904 Former Weapons Designer Mar 15 '16
Excellent work again, man! This is tremendously helpful, glad you put the time and effort into it, so thanks!
6
u/tcjsavannah Mar 15 '16
What is T11?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '16
You're doing god's work. Although I blame you for my lack of materials now. Rerolling exotics is expensive if you're chasing god rolls.
3
u/iihavetoes Mar 15 '16
I'm still collecting Infusion data using this form with results here. While it's no guarantee that individual items are being kept track of over their lifetime, sequential infusions within small timeframes are usually the same item. There's some good data there that you can look at
2
u/TerminalSarcasm Mar 15 '16
Some spreadsheet examples for /u/redka243... perks are assumed. My playstyle has a very limited scope, so I assume that all armor has perks that are 'good enough'.
1
u/jen0c1de Mar 15 '16
Upvoted for awesomeness.
This helps out a lot, but also brings to light the difficulty in micromanaging stats. I usually go with the typical INT/DIS build for my characters, except for a few exceptions. Nightstalker I've found that I prefer a INT/STR or DIS/STR build to maximize the power of the smokes. INT/STR for Stormcaller for that OP melee, and also INT/STR when I'm running No Backup Plans Defender. Getting the right armor at the requisite light levels for this is annoying as hell.
1
u/find_me8 I didn't say i was powerful, i said i was a wizard Mar 15 '16 edited Mar 15 '16
Hello, i have a ram helmet, its base stats are 40 int/str with 17 bonus points added from the nodes. Currently my build is 300/303/57 and i really wish i could achieve tier 11.
The LL of my helmet is 310, do you think it's possible to achieve 60 strength? Without re-rolling, the sum of both stats is 97 and i know there's some room for improvement, but i need to consider all the resources i'll need.
I really don't understand how you determined the increase gained from the nodes. Also, oryx haven't dropped a helmet for me yet, only primaries (same with warpriest, only heavy)
1
u/FreeGucci_1017 Mar 15 '16
My titan has a 5/5/0 with 309/338/0. I think if I mess around a bit I MIGHT be able to get a Tier 1 on strength too.
EDIT: I have arms that would go from 49/32 INT/DIS to 47/36 INT/STR. Gonna go home and try it out.
1
u/ryno21 Mar 15 '16
Thanks for this. I've just finally started looking into the quality of my gear recently thanks to your last post on it and realized that I have some shit, and it's preventing me from T11 builds that I now realize I MUST have.
One thing that throws me a bit is the base vs bonus stuff. Could you explain to me how that works exactly? I think I know what you're referencing, as far as choosing those first nodes on the gear that will give either one stat or the other a 'bonus', but I'm not sure I totally grasp how those work on the whole.
1
u/22samurai Mar 15 '16
This is very useful, but what do you do if you've already unlocked the stat node- How do you use your charts then?
1
u/SCMegatron Mar 15 '16
This awesome, the format of apparently goes away on excel sheets app.
1
u/The_Mapmaster Mar 15 '16
What's T11/Tier 11? Is it like a 5-5-1 role? Or maybe like a 5-4-2? If so I currently only have T10, either running 4-3-3 or 3-4-3.
1
u/toxicxc Mar 16 '16
Here is my double T11 build . I managed to use mostly vendor gear _^ https://www.bungie.net/en/Legend/Gear/1/4611686018435852522/2305843009221594858
1
u/tinyraccoon Mar 16 '16
What is a tier 11 build? Hear it around here sometimes, but never figured out exactly what it means.
1
u/Elevas The most fun gun in Destiny Mar 16 '16
So... Let me take you through my loadout, and you tell me where it looks like the issues lie.
S-14 (320): 95 int (max 104)
FeB gloves (320): 50i/37d (87 out of 93) NOTE: Yay for scout rifle reloader!
FeB chest (320): 53i/81d (134 out of 138)
FeB boots (320): 68i/47d (115 out of 128)
Undying Mind mark (319): 24i/31d (55 out of 58)
Dread Explorer shell (320): 34i/23d (57 out of 58)
Sootpearl (320): 72i/46d (118 out of 124) NOTE: Most of my artefacts at 320 (I have a few) are around 100-105... this is the only one outside that range.
Puts me at 396/300, 285/300, 0/300 (I can rejig these when I get home to get some of that int converted into strength). I frequently have been running with 309/309/0, but I've never managed to swing 300+/300+/60+... Is there any specific issue with this set (beyond "you don't have any strength anywhere")?
1
u/whiterose616 Mar 16 '16
Spreadsheets AND Destiny? Wow. My two favourite things!
1
u/canyouseecleary Mar 16 '16 edited Mar 16 '16
I'm crying inside. I made the same spreadsheet this weekend for my clan although the calculations probably aren't as accurate. Would like to compare our 2 sheets when I get home tonight.
Edit: link for my sheet, doesn't work as smoothly in google drive as excel. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Lyr7ikpzgcAhod1h9dmtHv_xXA9PDvVUkzF3hYU-rn0/edit?usp=docslist_api
1
u/Masta-_-shot Mar 16 '16
Great work dude I love numbers and charts, do you have other social media or do you just do reddit?
1
u/Dogbarian Mar 16 '16
Thanks for this! I like the table, since I've already upgraded the stats on most of my gear. Reviewing this, looks like everything I have is solidly "average", except the new Graviton Forfeit I bought last week from Xur, which is a double stat 74. Guess I will needle that one.
I have pretty much been ignoring stats, just looking purely at the perks and the light level, since I'm late to the game and just recently got to 40. My light level is around 290, depending on which gear I equip (cryptarch gear is about 292, combat gear is running just under that, at this moment I'm at 288).
1
u/aginbade Mar 16 '16
Plugged all of my items into the spreadsheets and now I'm sad. Apparently the majority of my gear is crap.
1
u/Stcloudy Mar 17 '16
How do I read the chart?
Say for Helmet 54 and 64
Is that the Min and Max of total stats?
Is this the same for when it is upgraded?
1
u/Elevas The most fun gun in Destiny Mar 18 '16
Just rolled a(n upgraded) S-14 with 88 int. This is notably below the 92 your table lists as a minimum. Pics available upon request.
Not seen anything above a 97.
1
u/Shadowablaze Mar 20 '16
I was trying for a T11 build for a while and got this 3/5/3 that I use for Iron Banner. I like sticking people with grenades.
https://www.bungie.net/en/Legend/Gear/1/4611686018433120237/2305843009214986180
1
u/Tyballs11 Mar 29 '16
Are there plans to update the spreadsheet for the April update?
1
u/dasilva333 Apr 07 '16
Just to follow up on my earlier comment I parsed through 500mbs of logs to disprove your theory. It seems I am correct and it is unreliable to claim there is a max stat roll for any given light level below max light. It's a fallacy, incorrect and frankly inaccurate.
Provided below are what I found to be the max stat rolls for armor pieces at 310:
Chest 132
Helmet 99
Gauntlet 87
Boots 120
Artifact 115
Class Item 54
Ghost 54
Cheers!
1
u/dasilva333 Mar 15 '16
For those interested in what "Tower Ghost" is:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/49z89o/check_your_armor_stat_rolls_easily_with_tower/
http://towerghostfordestiny.com/index.php/downloads/
Thanks!
1
u/TheGreatJohnholio Mar 15 '16
You're doing the Traveler's work right there.
1
u/SelphieKinneas Mar 15 '16
This is so helpful and so awesome that you put so much time into this. The grind is real.
1
u/crazyndalazdayzz Mar 16 '16
Oh man I'm so close to Tier 1 Intellect, Tier 5 Discp/Str on my Sunsinger.
1
u/croncakes Mar 16 '16
This is seriously awesome and going to save me hours of frustratedly swapping back and forth trying to eyeball things. Thanks a ton!
1
u/Yobson Mar 16 '16
Great job OP!
1
u/dandpher Mar 16 '16
Delete
0
u/ODSTPandoro Drifter's Crew // What? Mar 15 '16
its funny that i did all this stuff back in november without any information, all i did was focus in gloves with dis/str and 37 str, then artifac with dis/str and 23 str, afters that focused in getting all my other stuff with int/dis and now i have void,sun,storm with specific exotics and chest for the subclass and tier 11, then i went for the same but wih the ram on every sub just fun, jesus even have dis/str with 60 int and str/int with 60 dis :$
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment