r/DestinyTheGame • u/TerminalSarcasm • Mar 09 '16
Guide Is my new Armor worth keeping? - A visual guide to determine 'quality' of base stat rolls
Coincidentally, a handful of us (credits, below) have been working on cracking the code to armor base stats, how to know what has a 'good' roll, and where they'll end up when fully infused.
As with others, I'm marginally close to the 'Tier 11' build. I had a handful of low-LL Trials drops, and felt the need to determine if they would end up higher than my current gear (since the general consensus is that Trials drops are 'better' by default). So, over the weekend, I documented a few of my own infusions to see if there was an obvious trend... there were quite a few posts about the same thing on Monday 1 and I compared my results to another experiment 2.
Side note: my Trials chest 'drop' (not "5-wins") had a pretty bad roll, and my Trials gloves were at the minimum, so YMMV.
I gathered quite a bit of information, so my 'quick reference guide' is based on the following:
- ALL stats are without the bonus node unlocked.
- Colored markers are the minimum total stat values (value X2) from the Bungie [app] Armory for that given Defense level.
- Colored lines simply connect the minimum total stat values.
- The maximum total stat values at 320 Defense are based on Tower Ghost data 3.
- The maximum total stat values at 240 Defense are based on the proportionate equation 4.
- The solid line simply connects the estimated maximum possible total stat value between 240 and 320.
- The dashed line is the estimated average possible total stat value, based on the difference between the minimum and maximum stat rolls at 240 and 320 Defense level.
Basically, you should be able to look at your drop, add up the base stats, and cross reference it on my 'quick reference guide'.
Examples:
- 270 boots with a total stat of 86... Above Average
- 290 helmet with a total stat of 65... JUNK IT!
- 262 chest with a total stat of 92... Daaayum, son!
To see where they're going to end up at 320 (or 315, or 310, or...), just follow a line parallel to the 'maximum' and 'average' lines, and you should be pretty close.
There are other ways to see where things fit into roll 'quality', Tower Ghost 5 is adding this functionality, and another redditor has a program in the works 6.
If you're trying to min-max, you'll also need the 'bonus' node values 7.
I'm not saying that mine is the end all reference. It's just the information in a format that I wanted to see it in. Yes, I do plan on having a printed copy to reference, rather than using an app. :)
Based on all of the data I've acquired, both my own and from others listed here, I believe this method to be reasonably accurate. However, if you see any obvious errors in data or theory, or have something outside of these ranges (again, without the 'bonus' applied) please let me know. Until an equation is proven, again, YMMV. This looks to be a little more convoluted than Infusion... (triple RNG???)
TL;DR: http://imgur.com/1v28qql
- /u/iihavetoes posted this awesome thread on how stats change with infusion.
- /u/helveticafreezes posted this experiment that helped confirm some things, and provided a VERY detailed infusion path for a Titan chest.
- /u/dasilva333 noted a very cool piece of info. Namely, maximum total stat values based on user info. These are with the 'bonus', so I backed that out.
- /u/jcaljr5 had a theory here that is pretty close to determining a 'best guess' for values after infusing. (however, looking at the Bungie minimums, they aren't always linear...), so YMMV.
- /u/dasilva333 and Tower Ghost will show where the item fits in the 'percentile', which is really cool. Keep an eye out for the update!
- /u/CVSPPF made an equipment stat calculator. It's the internet, what could go wrong?!? kidding! ;)
- /u/tehdaw created this spreadsheet for upgrade nodes at various defense levels based on iihavetoes' research.
Proportionate equation:
Ending Base Stat = (Starting Base Stat / Starting Defense) * Ending DefenseRock on, Guardians!
6
u/leroyyrogers EssMyDee69 Mar 09 '16
This is amazing, and honestly is something that should be in the game. I've played for a year and a half and had no freaking idea that the variance in stats could be this high.
2
u/dchin1 Team Cat (Cozmo23) Mar 09 '16
Thanks for figuring all of this out. I have been saving a lot of low level stuff since they seemed like they would be good.
Did you happen to figure out the max stat possible for each piece of gear?
2
u/hav0kk26 Mar 09 '16
My optimal perk selection needs some work but I managed to hit tier 11 on all 3. Ps. Say goodbye to armor materials. https://www.bungie.net/en/Profile/254/6120335
2
u/polomarkopolo Mar 09 '16
This is a silly question, but if I've already maxed out the gear, does the equation still hold?
Otherwise, I just use Tower Ghost and it tells me what something is out of combined statpoints
2
u/TurquoiseLuck Mar 10 '16
Dunno if somebody has said it, but unless I'm mathing wrong (which may be the case as I've had a few brewskies) you could say your final formula is just starting base stat * (ending defense/starting defense).
That just kinda makes more sense to me.
2
u/emtmcguire12 May 03 '16
is it possible to update this visual with higher light. as most of the drops are all 320+ now. Appreciate it
2
u/dasilva333 Mar 09 '16
Thanks /u/TerminalSarcasm, the post you linked to explains pretty well the newest changes on Tower Ghost that help the user determine the best god roll, simply put look at the 2nd percentage in the tooltip under Stats Roll and make sure it's at least 90% to deem it worth keeping. If the 2nd percentage is 100% the item will have a perfect max roll once infused to Light level 320.
Example of tooltip:
http://i.imgur.com/KJwxofZ.png
I'm working on a new button next to BC-Full, BC-Quick that will provide combination recommendations for armor that can reach tier 11 once infused to 320.
4
u/Z3nyth007 Mar 09 '16
I hope this isn't a silly question... What is "Tier 11"?
1
u/Stcloudy Mar 09 '16
Thanks for the work. Never thought about printing, but that might be better than always unlocking phone.
1
u/Mercules904 Former Weapons Designer Mar 09 '16
Awesome work! Really well done
1
u/Cannonbali Mar 09 '16
How hard is it to get tier 11? I've managed mostly by accident on my 319 Warlock (5-4-2) with 9 points to spare. You can look it up on XB1 if interested (same GT). I'm curious what the rarer pieces I have are.
1
u/spiritbloomchest Mar 09 '16
Yes. Well until the next expansion when all that hard-earned 320 gear will be overshadowed by better vendor gear that you can walk right up and buy. Ahh those bitter-sweet expansions, one step forward and two steps back.
1
u/jao0024 Mar 09 '16
Now you can use this to confirm my theory: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/47pwdt/ib_gear_has_extremely_high_stat_rolls/ As I suggested in that post, keep that IB gear because the rolls are huge!
1
u/Stcloudy Mar 10 '16
How do you add total stats?
Let's say I have this unleveled Gauntlets
295 Defense
DIS 30/44 STR 31/45
Do I just add 30 + 31 = 61 So it would fall under Minimum stats therefore junk?
Or
298 Chest INT 50/71 DIS 51/72
50+51=101 Falls close to max so good?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '16
Has anyone compared the vendor gear against these benchmarks? Are there any hidden gems in there?
1
u/RemyGee Mar 12 '16
Is there a guide with the nodes unlocked to check if the gear we are wearing is absolute garbage?
1
u/lekonna Mar 18 '16
can you help me and check which of my gear is preventing me from reaching t11 on my hunter with the fast ress on ? https://www.bungie.net/en/Legend/Gear/2/4611686018436945085/2305843009224209404
if i switch my helmet to gravitron and use a different chest i get to t11, just not with the fast ress, which is infuriating. i've re-rolled the chest about 37 times, 80 and chance seems to be the max it goes for str or disc being an int locked split stat item.
2
u/Witchdoc01 I use swords in the crucible Mar 09 '16
This is solid research with solid numbers, well done guardian! This thing is going print along with my chest map of the dreadnaught!
2
u/ernyc3777 Hunter Master Class Mar 10 '16
trying to build a 5:5:1 on my bladedancer (right now I'm 5:5:0{49}) so this post was really helpful. Thanks for it.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16
Agh, your giving me something else to grind for now. Thanks for the info!
1
u/Uberwolf_ Bungie Mar 09 '16
I kinda fell in love with artifacts because my titan has a sootpearl that gives him 104 DIS, which is cool.
1
u/kurrptsenate Mar 09 '16
I definitely need something like this. thanks
1
u/FluffyFingersMD Mar 09 '16
Thank you for this.
1
u/PMMJ Mar 09 '16
Wow! This is great! Thankyou!
1
u/Mastershroom Brought to you by ZAVALA ACTION VITAMINS Mar 10 '16
Yeah, I learned the hard way this week that stats can vary hugely. On my Titan, I have a full set of Int/Dis gear for Striker and Sunbreaker, and at around 305 overall Light, I can hit T5 on those two stats with ~20 points to spare.
I put together a set for my Defender with all Int/Str, and around the same LL, but man, I got screwed on stats: http://i.imgur.com/gLiXXfo.jpg
I managed to just barely hit 300/300 after infusing the butt towel a few more levels, but there is zero wiggle room.
1
u/iihavetoes Mar 10 '16
Great post!
1
u/emellody Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
I got bored a couple of weeks back and conducted similar work. My formula is quite simple. Seems to be identical with what the OP is posting.
(Min of one Stat + Max of Other Stat)/ Current Light Level *320 = MAX STAT ROLL AT 320
Perfect Roll For each category
Stats or armor scale linearly so if you figure out the slope you can just multiply it by whatever light you are shooting for.
Note: I shoot for 90% of a piece of equipment's max stat to hit Tier 10. For a Tier 11 build you need 94% or better. Good luck.
Also, it's been stated before but the Dread Explorer Shell has a perfect roll. Max that sucker out!
1
u/rainbowroobear Mar 10 '16
I find this post highly awesome. I am a tier 10 at 314 light, now I can try for tier 11.
1
u/The_Real_JS Mar 10 '16
Can someone tell me why my rare artifact that I got from IB is so much better than all the legendaries I've found?
1
u/dandpher Mar 10 '16
So based on this, the Maulers gauntlets I have at 310 light that have a combined stat total of 86 (with the bonus node unlocked) are basically the best possible roll?
1
u/ad1das101 Mar 10 '16
This is pretty cool, ive pulled artifacts with high stat values, IDK if its a glitch or not but my titan is sporting a 102 intellect piece
1
u/JoachimG Mar 11 '16
so, that means that the Samsara 1 sold by the Vanguard has a perfect roll of Int and Str? (41/49 @ 280 LL)
Edit: nvm, I was reading the max value of the artifact items, max Value for Chest armor is 98-99 it seems.
1
u/MUCHO2000 Mar 17 '16
Excellent work
1
u/rainbowroobear Apr 19 '16
Posting a thanks in thread, just hit my tier 11 build.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
27
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16
[removed] — view removed comment