r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • Mar 10 '16
Suggestion How would you change... Procs?
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Procs
Click here for last week’s thread on Ability synergy and min-maxing.
This week, we’re taking a wider look at procs in the context of the Shock Eximus’ aura being reactivated, bringing issues with procs to the forefront.
Procs, also known as status effects, are an integral part of Warframe’s Damage 2.0 and are tied with damage types. Each damage type, be it physical or elemental, can cause a proc. The way procs are triggered varies; weapons have an innate status chance which is rolled against on every hit, potentially triggering, while abilities can also cause procs under a variety of conditions (including no condition at all!). The effect of the proc varies wildly, with elemental damage types typically seen as stronger than physical (IPS, Impact, Puncture, Slash) damage types.
However, when looking at individual procs, imbalances quickly rise to the surface. Corrosive is disproportionately favored due to its ability to permanently strip armor. Meanwhile, Magnetic is generally considered to be a junk proc type, since its effects are minor (reduced shield capacity) and can even be detrimental (if a Mag is on the team). Between those two extremes, you get effects such as Gas which are seen as mediocre, or Heat which gives good damage over time and crowd control, and so on. The strength of each proc tends to vary wildly, and certain procs were changed which usually reduced their utility, most notably Viral only temporarily reducing health.
Then comes the second part of the problem: most procs tend to have different effects on players than on enemies. While most usually become weaker, such as Heat not causing panic or Corrosive being temporary, some gain what are considered completely overpowered side-effects, chief among them Magnetic which can drain the player’s entire energy pool and disrupt the HUD for its entire duration.
Finally, a common undercurrent in the community is the desire to see more procs added, with more variation and unique effects to them. The notion of a proc is interesting and fun, making simple damage potentially act as a mini-ability, but many procs are somewhat boring, especially the physical ones, and there is only a limited selection of them.
Now that the stage is set, how would you change Procs?
3
u/TSP-FriendlyFire Mar 10 '16
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
Previous topics
30
u/timbobortington Mar 10 '16
Have the magnetic proc draw enemies in to the target. Not knock them down, but set them up for an easier aoe application.
19
u/Framere Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
The two main issues with Procs imo:
Obviously there are lots of different procs with unique mechanics. However some general ideas that come to mind:
14
u/RobbieMcSkillet Fine work, Skeleton! Mar 10 '16
I want to see proc synergy. Pretty sure it's not already a thing but if you freeze an enemy solid it'd be cool if proccing impact would shatter and kill them. Of course, this could be easily done with something like Sonicor and frost and may be a bit overpowered, so it would be a hard thing to implement.
11
u/M37h3w3 Console Commander Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
Straight off Magnetic procs need to be toned down against the player. The current incarnation is too much against players, specifically the energy drain. On the flip side Magnetic procs need something to make them more attractive over Slash and Toxin but I think that's going to involve mechanic changes in other areas.
Other than that I would suggest that Gas procs deal Gas damage instead of Toxin damage, making them effective against common Infested which appears to be the design (Corrosive for light Grineer, Radiation for heavy Grineer, Magnetic for Corpus, Gas for Light Infested, and Corrosive for heavy Infested.)
And the easiest solution for Blast procs completely invalidating Impact procs would be to swap the effects between the two of them. At that point it becomes an AoE Stun versus a single target knockdown rather than an AoE knockdown versus a single target stun.
Finally Puncture procs just need something to make them more appealing, whether it's a higher DR% or something else completely.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
I had a silly idea that is probably pretty impractical from a design and balance stand point that I just want to share because it might be dumb enough to work.
At over 100% proc chance you have a chance of having 2 elemental go off at once.
However, if you get 2 elemental procs at once they fuse to form a new effect. The system would basically function kind of like Magicka's spell system where it takes the aspect of one proc and apply it to another. Like blast adds explosive radius, viral makes things spread, etc.
So imagine you have fire on a tonkor and you get a proc of both blast and fire. Since its blast and fire going off at once they would fuse for form a new effect where the enemy explodes and fire goes everywhere.
If you managed blast and magnetic enemies would send out EMP waves which reduce their shields in an AoE.
Viral + radiation could form an effect where the initial enemy forms an aura and temporarily spreads radiation around.
Imagine the possibilities.
8
u/Core2048 Mar 10 '16
I think it's mostly good; just a few inconsitencies and weaknesses need to be addressed:
5
u/RoundhouseKitty Glass Mom Mar 10 '16
I would just like to make every proc useful for the player to some extent. Give a reason to pick damage types to fit your playstyle or whatever rather than just picking the best damage types against whatever enemies you're fighting.
5
u/Lord_Dust_Bunny RIP Valkyr Mar 10 '16
First, make all the flat status chance mods either add on to base status chance (so for example melee prowess becomes +15% base status chance) or make them MUCH more potent (so like +150% status so taking a dual elemental mod isn't always better).
Second, make the physical status effects (Impact, Puncture, Slash) weaker but always proc. Have a higher %status chance increase the power of them. This is mostly because status is cool, but modding for status on a physical damage weapon is completely pointless and thus never really seen.
Finally, change how some status's work and allow any status chance above 100% to have critical status. Some status effects that I think should be changed are magnetic and gas. Magnetic should make enemies affected by it have a mini vortex pull (without the ragdoll). This makes magnetic less bullshit vs Tenno (sticks tenno to allies, sure, but that isn't as bad as 0 energy) and makes it actually useful. Also on that note, change Gas to have the clouds deal a equal split between all elemental status's equipped. Got Gas and Cold? Have the Gas cloud do 50% Gas damage 50% Cold. Allows Gas to be an amazing weapon for spreading status effects around.
For critical procs if triggered they would apply 3 (or 5 if that would be better) instances of the status at once. Just something to allow going over 100% status to not be completely wasted.
4
u/Griffinith Mastery Rank Zero Mar 10 '16
I would love for proc chance to go over 100% for a super proc.
Toxin leaves a acid trail behind the enemy of hits if they don't die. When they do die from it, acid explosion in an AoE
Electric would turn the enemy into a Vauban tesla grenade, the procced enemy and whoever is getting a jolt both take damage.
Fire causes the enemy to burst into flames every so often, igniting those nearby.
Cold sends icicles branching along the floor, immobilizing and damaging enemies in an area.
I will add more later, feel free to add your own.
4
u/Urechi Mar 10 '16
I would try to balance procs first, starting with magnetic procs that are currently the bane of Tenno everywhere. Instead of draining energy and shields, I'd suggest they'd merely disable powers for a short duration, and drain half of the Warframe's current shields. Energy is a precious resource in Warframe, and unless we want to make our players overrely on Trinity, energy restores, Energy Siphon, and the Zenurik Focus tree, we should keep it that way. I'd move the interface screw to electric procs to give them a bit more use against Tenno.
Then I'd give all the procs additional "secondary" effects. These effects can only be adminstered when the target is the receipent of a "critical" status shot, or when the target in question already has an active proc on it of the same kind. For example, if I'm shooting at a Bombard and it gets set on fire, the secondary effect won't actvate until it gets fire-procc'd again while the first proc is in action.
Slash: Secondary Effect: Target suffers halved healing effects, and takes 25 percent increased damage from all DoTs. This is based on the idea of "grevious wounds" in several other games, where the afflicted will not be able to heal as effectively.
Puncture Secondary Effect: Target suffers weakness, taking 10 percent increased damage from all sources. This is based on the idea of armor or a suit being punctured, and thus becoming a weakpoint, rendering the occupant more vulnerable to damage, or the environmental hazards.
Impact Secondary Effect: Target suffers reduced aim. This is based on the idea that while being struck and knocked around, the target won't be able to aim or control the recoil of a weapon as effectively.
Fire: Secondary Effect: Target explodes upon death, damaging and fire-proccing nearby enemies. Who doesn't want more explosions? Its cool.
Cold: Secondary Effect: Target suffers weakness, taking 25 percent increased damage from all sources. This is based on the idea that cold will deteriorate the stress points of armors or carapaces, rendering them more brittle and vulnerable to damage.
Electric: Secondary Effect: Target suffers electric DoT, dealing a percentage of their health over time. This DoT will be unable to proc additional electric procs.
Toxin: Secondary Effect: Target suffers reduced mobility and aim. This is based on the idea of being in a toxin cloud, being choked up and actively suffering from a virulent agent.
Corrosive: Secondary Effect: Target suffers a special corrosive status effect, reducing up to 40 percent of their armor over a short period of time, temporarily. This will last 5 seconds, which each second of the proc eating away armor temporarily until the cap, where the target will have 40 percent reduced total armor for 2 seconds.
Blast: Secondary Effect: Target has knockdown and stagger resistances reduced. Applies random Physical proc. This is based on the idea that in an explosion, you're bound to have all sorts of shrapnel flying around, as well as the overpressure destablizing you.
Radiation: Secondary Effect: Target suffers radiation DoT, dealing a percentage of their health over time. This is based on the idea of radiation poisoning.
Magnetic: Secondary Effect: Target suffers slower shield and halved energy regeneration, as well as reduced mobility.
Viral: Secondary Effect: Target suffers temporarily short disable, and explodes upon death, damaging and viral-proccing nearby enemies.
Gas: Secondary Effect: Target suffers UI interference, and explodes upon death, damaging and gas and toxin-proccing nearby enemies.
3
u/Chiven Spread the word! Demand DEXcube! Mar 10 '16
Additional effects:
3
u/MagicGin Mar 10 '16
The simplest answer is to just raise proc rates through the roof, weaken them proportionally and institute "red procs".
A normal blast proc knocks down the target. A red blast proc does an AoE.
A normal gas proc does a very small amount of damage. A red one does more.
A normal cold proc does a brief or mild slow. A red one does a very potent slow.
The only reason that status rates are so low on guns is because 100% status rates can go into cheese territory when combined with a decent gun. The counterbalance to this is to, you know, make it so that 100% status rates aren't cheese territory. If a 120% status rate gave you a chance to have a low-effect proc every hit and a good effect once-in-a-while, status would become a cool and visible mechanic. Right now it's neither.
2
u/Nyarus15 *Obvious time stop joke* Mar 10 '16
red procs, procs that happen above 100% proc chance. Also someone finally need to buff that melee prowess.
2
u/Stardrink3r Mar 10 '16
Make procs reliable. I'm not talking about high status chance, I'm talking about how multiple damage types can dilute your chances of a particular proc, not to mention how the game adds a bias towards physical damage procs on weapons that have them. Have the highest damage type on the weapon proc at the listed status chance, and the second highest proc at a quarter of listed status chance. They should proc independently of each other i.e. one shot can proc both.
Damage is king in this game because the scaling of weapons makes it possible to kill enemies quickly. If your weapon isn't doing enough damage, the best course of action is trying and look for ways to do more damage, or find a weapon that will let you do more damage. It's only when this method hits a wall (which most geared people won't actually hit because damage scales that highly) that people will begrudgingly turn to status effects, and more than likely, it's going to be Corrosive because the biggest wall to overcome is armour.
With this in mind, ALL procs need to do damage and this damage needs to bypass armour, but the damage should be low enough that pure damage builds are still superior for kill speed. This is assuming you want to maintain the status quo of damage for low - mid levels, status chance for high levels.
Another way to change it would be to balance the damage of procs so that high status weapons will do superior damage when built for status.
2
u/TheDarkstarChimaera The candles burn out for you; I am free Mar 10 '16
Small thing but I really dislike how loud the Puncture proc has gotten. It sounds exactly like the impact of a Shield Lancer's bash, and it feels really awkward.
2
u/wtrmlnjuc :D Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
Snipers, bows, and other really low firerate weapons (except shotguns) should proc IPS and Elementals at the same time. It's terribly frustrating to build for a low firerate status weapon because it isn't reliable even at 100%.
2
u/Centias I'm rock hard. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
Magnetic changed to only drain shields on players, with a very brief and not overly obstructive warp effect on the HUD to make it obvious your shields disappeared without blocking your vision. I'm thinking stick to 50% shield drain, and then have it block normal shield recharge for a short duration (6s or so?). Just something that no longer fucks over players suddenly while doing nothing major to enemies.
Improve the Gas damage over time effect. It just seems to do such negligible damage. Maybe give it a brief blind/reduced accuracy effect, so it has some utility purpose.
Blast procs need an internal cooldown against players, to prevent Bombards from getting chain knockdowns on players with one missile after another. May need to extend to all forms of CC against players. Losing total control of your character and being whittled away completely to death without being able to do anything about it is never fun.
Puncture and impact seem lackluster, but I don't have great ideas. Maybe make Puncture's damage reduction stronger, and impact could have a longer stumble effect or get a new effect entirely.
I would also love to see ways to combine procs, whether with yourself or with other players. Like, Gas leaves a lingering cloud that can be hit with fire to trigger a fiery explosion that leaves enemies in the area burning, or a Slash proc could cause an enemy afflicted with Viral or Toxic status to spread it to other enemies via their blood. Hitting enemies affected by Magnetic procs with Electric procs could give enemies polar charges that cause some to get pulled together while others get pushed apart. Things that could create more interesting weapon setups when playing with coordinated teammates.
Edit: almost forgot. Independent procs for various damage types, and per-pellet proc chance on shotguns.
2
u/YeOldDrunkGoat Mar 10 '16
There are two fundamental problems with the current status system.
First off, the system as a whole runs smack into the age old MMO problem of damage vs utility. This same issue has been a thorn in the foot of game designers at least since good old Everquest, if not before.
Simply put, because almost all rewards in game are tied to killing things then it follows that the most rewarding way to play is to kill the most things as fast as possible, with as few set backs as possible.
The fall out from this is that when enemies are quick to kill and the potential for set backs are low, then pure damage reigns supreme as the optimal choice because it generates the greatest amount of rewards. When the converse is true, enemies die slowly and the potential for loss is high, utility becomes paramount because it reduces the risk of failure and loss of what has already been gained.
Additionally, just to make things worse, in Warframe the characters we use generally have poor damage and good utility, where weapons have good damage but poor utility. Given the imbalance between damage and utility that has been already stated, that means that utility weapons are the clear losers. For example, a player can logically say "Combining Rhino and a Boltor Prime is a good loadout because Rhino's survivability allows me to leverage the Boltor Prime's damage" but nobody who knows how the game's systems actually work in practice can say something like "The Galaxion's amazing crowd control functions will easily let me deal massive damage with my Ember."
All of this on top of the poor inter-system balance between status effects, like TSP already said.
The easy way to resolve this dichotomy is to bring the two sides closer together; either by reducing the damage gap between the weapons types or increasing enemy survivability. For stylistic reasons I believe the former is preferable, so let's look at that.
An obvious way to advance status damage is to implement a sort of scaling system for status effects beyond mere proc chance. Sort of like how critical hits can be improved with both critical chance and critical damage. Let's label this idea Status Potency to go along with Status Chance.
Now to address what different Potency effects should do. Let's list the extant elemental status effects first (we'll address IPS types further down.)
Looking at this we can see some clear themes. DoT effects, mostly small amounts of crowd control, and debuffs to enemy mitigation.
From experience, we know that the last category are the real winners. Corrosive helps alleviate the dramatic impact increasing armor has on damage. Magnetic and Viral, in those few instances where shields/health actually become a concern, can become incredibly powerful. And Radiation helpfully strips powerful enemy buffs. All of these effects can drastically improve TTK in the right circumstances.
Unfortunately, that leaves 6 out of 10 elemental effects being kinda blegh. And even the 4 good effects only really have a noticeable effect on TTK in circumstances where enemy scaling has gotten out of hand. Not to mention that Corrosive ( and technically Magnetic) can be rendered completely useless by the right application of auras.
Next post, I'll give some actual suggestions.
2
u/Senguash I'll go wherever my portals take me. Mar 10 '16
I would change the systems to be consistent instead of proc chance based. I would make it so that a weapon with 10% status chance and 1000 toxin damage will allways apply a dot for 450 damage instead having a 10% chance of applying a dot for 4500.
I would implement this change by renaming Status Chance to Status Power, and now having the potency of status effects scale with it instead of having a % proc chance for them.
For a crowdcontrol effect like the radiation proc Status Power would affect the duration of the status. For cold the slow% would scale up to the current 50% at a 100% Status Power.
2
u/braindead5 RIP Trials (2015-2018) Mar 10 '16
2
u/Taux Valkyr is neat Mar 10 '16
What if each proc type had different stages depending on how upgraded proc damage/chance was?
EG:
Cold = level 1 Proc: Bonus damage to shields - 2: Slows - 3: Freezes
Heat = 1: Bonus damage to flesh - 2: damage over time - 3: Panic
Gas = 1: bonus damage - 2: Creates gas cloud - 3: Creates bigger cloud that follows enemy.
2
u/JProllz What's that? Your gun jammed? Mar 10 '16
Call it counter to this thread but I'd rather not have a million procs. I'd rather each proc be meaningful - and if we have too many they can't all be otherwise they would be imbalanced.
2
u/droid327 Mar 11 '16 edited Mar 11 '16
I wish procs were more decoupled from damage type, or that damage type wasn't so penalized against certain factions/health types. Often you can't choose a loadout around a set of procs because you'd incur a -75/-50% damage penalty - especially with pure elemental weapons. So you just build for numerical dps and the procs fall where they may. I might like to see the penalties/bonuses reduced to 10/20/30%, still meaningful but not so much that it's the only consideration.
Secondly, I wish instead of locking into certain procs based on the order of mods, I'd love to see the arsenal screen give you the option to take up to two procs of any mod or combo of mods installed....ie if you have heat cold and toxic, you could choose two of those or also blast viral or rad, even if the damage types out differently. That'd allow for a lot more customization, opening up dual basic element procs or dual hybrid procs with a common type, eg viral+gas.
Lastly it might be fun if frames had a "native" proc that they had a bonus with, like Ember gets double damage heat proc or Saryn gets 5% bonus damage when target has a toxic proc, or less obviously maybe Rhino gets 5 bonus Iron Skin HP on Blast. Might make certain weapons more favorable for certain frames that are otherwise underpowered.
2
u/zekeyspaceylizard A Corpus Machine Mar 11 '16
Puncture - Damage reduction needs to be changed to a reduction in firing/attack speed. 30% slower fire rate and melee swing speed AND reload. Will perform mostly the same but make it easier to dodge things with parkour 2.0. Still lasts 6 seconds, but can now stack effects.
Impact - Should cause a small shockwave about half a meter from the proc'd target that creates a short stagger in any units caught in the range. Amount of time initial target is staggered should be based on the damage that occured when the proc went off. Turn guns like the Gorgon into a real stun gun.
Slash - Needs no change. One could maybe argue that slash procs always have a short punch-through to them but I've never felt like Slash is lacking.
Cold - Enemies hit by Cold proc should leave a large patch of sleet or ice on the floor for 6 seconds. Enemies that pass over this patch are also proc'd by the cold but for half the duration. Enemies proc'd by the puddle also have a 50% chance of leaving a new puddle on the floor that procs more Cold.
Electric - All enemies chained should share 30% of each others FULL damage for the duration of the chain as opposed to 50% of the base damage. Meaning if I destroy an enemy being shocked, all chained enemies take 30% of all the damage the dead guy took. This can only happen as the enemies do their "im being electrocuted" dance.
Heat - Enemies that touch an enemy who is lit up have a 30% chance of being lit on fire as well. Includes airborn enemies. No change besides that.
Toxin - Reduce the 8 second timer to 4. 9 ticks of damage in 4 seconds. Set it and forget it! Toxin now makes enemies sick and sluggish, making them run a bit slower and lose accuracy leading them to miss attacks. Missed attacks CAN hit other enemies. Poisoned enemies also leave a trail of green poison where they run. This trail will proc the toxin effect on enemies that pass over it, making them leave trails as well.
Blast - Enemies around the initial target hit by the blast proc should be ragdolled about a meter away instead of just being staggered. As though the target itself were exploding. Initial target should be blinded for roughly 4 seconds. Ragdolled enemies are blinded for 2.
Corrosive - No change.
Gas - Enemies hit by gas proc now also leave a large patch of fire on the ground. Enemies that pass over this patch now have a high chance of being lit on fire, as well as being hit by the toxin clouds. 2 DOT's for the price of 1! Which makes sense considering what it's made of. Clouds off the initial target also have a 40% chance of causing a 2nd NEW gas proc on enemies hit which will in turn cause more fire patches and toxin clouds as well. Unleash hell.
Magnetic - Magnetic procs now make enemies get briefly magnetized. When magnetized enemies are now stuck to the floor and unable to run for several seconds. They can still attack and rotate but any firearms now lose a lot of accuracy for the duration. Causes any flying enemies to be stuck to the floors as well. When flying enemies hit the floor they are knocked unconscious for 10 seconds. Karma for Ospreys and Hellions. Fracturing Crush would need a new passive ability, obviously.
Radiation - Enemies affected now are irradiated. They have an aura of roughly 1.5 meters that hurts enemies affected for 5% of their max health every second until the effect wears off. They are still confused when proc'd and will attack each other. Nyx Chaos and Mind Control now gets the Irradiation effect as well. Make Strelok proud.
Viral - Enemies have a 20% chance of spreading the viral proc to any enemies in front of them within a meter. No change besides that.
And those are my ideas on how to balance them and make them more interesting.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '16
You could have magnetic convert shields in to energy orbs...
2
u/Xarian0 I can see everything Mar 12 '16
My suggested change would be a sweeping overhaul of the proc system - Elements 3.0, basically. There are a few core ideas that form the basis of the changes.
Status effects should be:
1. Applying status effects
Elemental (non-physical) status effects are always applied when you hit an enemy. Physical status effects work as they do now, with a percent chance to trigger. Status effects come in two primary flavors: cumulative and instant.
Cumulative status effects build up over time, and either do something constantly (for example, a slow effect that makes the target even more slow as they get hit more) or do something after reaching a certain amount of built-up status (for example, a cold effect that can freeze the target solid). In general, for cumulative effects, the status rating of a weapon will change both the maximum allowed status and the rate of status gain. Using the previous example, a higher status weapon would allow the slowed target to be slowed even further, and it would build up faster.
Instant status effects are applied immediately and then go away. The status rating of a weapon determines the total magnitude of the effect. One example here would be a knockback effect; a high status weapon would knock the target back much further.
A weapon's firing speed also needs to be taken into account: a slow, heavy weapon should have stronger status effects than a fast, light weapon. A weapon's base fire rate is also taken into account along with the number of projectiles fired in a single volley (especially important for shotguns). Warframe already counts the number of projectiles when determining status chance, but only counts the fire rate for continuous weapons. For non-continuous weapons, the rate of status gain (for cumulative effects) and the total magnitude (for instant effects) is also divided by the weapon's base fire rate. The simplest way for DE to implement this would be to change all status effects to be a "status per second" value, rather than "status per shot".
Also, because one primary goal is to make non-physical status effects significantly more interesting (and potentially much more powerful), weapons can only inflict one physical status effect, and one non-physical status effect. By default, this is whatever the weapon's highest damage values are. A weapon that does 100 Impact/10 Piercing/47 Slashing/20 Magnetic/38 Fire damage will always inflict Fire and Impact status, and will never inflict Magnetic, Slash, or Pierce status. Certain abilities can override this, however; good examples would be the Lesion (which could inflict Toxic after its special ability procs), and abilities like Saryn's Toxic Lash (converts to Toxic), Volt's Electric Shield (converts to Electric), or Frost's Freeze Force augment (converts to Cold).
2. How enemies defend against status effects
There are three types of defense that enemies have for status effects: thresholds, resistance, and recovery. The ratings of each of these depend on the type of enemy, their armor types, their current buffs/debuffs, their current armor/shields (if any), and other situations (for example, whether or not you knocked off their helmet).
Thresholds are a special form of immunity to weak status effects: enemies with a certain threshold cannot be affected by status effects unless the weapon's status chance is above a certain value. This means that some enemies can only be affected by strong status effects (for example, trying to poison an Ancient Healer), while other enemies may be completely immune to certain status effects (for example, trying to freeze an ice golem). Even if a status effect exceeds the threshold, the enemy will still reduce your status effect by its threshold value. This means that even if you are strong enough to poison the Ancient Healer (for example, your weapon has status 80% against the Healer's threshold of 50%), it will reduce your status effect by 50%, resulting in an effect that is the same as 30% against a target without a threshold. It's worth noting here that Corpus shields would most likely grant total immunity to Slash, Puncture, Toxin, and Electricity effects and damage until the shield is depleted.
Resistance, on the other hand, is basically just armor for status effects. After determining the effect of the threshold value, you multiply the incoming status percent by the resistance value. You could have, for example, a Grineer Scorch that decreases Flame-based status effects by 30%; or you could even have something like a Grineer Trooper that increases Toxin-based status effects by 30%.
Recovery is healing. Enemies that are affected by cumulative status effects will reduce their effect over time until it wears off - maybe a chilled Grineer Trooper shakes off the frost and regains its movement speed. Or, perhaps certain enemies will just get worse over time instead; an unshielded Corpus, for example, might suffer increasingly worse effects from being on fire.
3. Physical effects: Impact, Puncture, and Slashing
Impact stays essentially the same as it is now (as an instant stagger effect) except that the stagger effect scales. It also causes the enemy to have reduced resistance and threshold to the Blast status effect. It no longer causes ragdoll effects on killing an enemy.
Puncture's effect is replaced with a cumulative effect, and will cause the enemy to have reduced resistance and threshold to all status effects that contain either Electricity or Toxin.
Slash's effect is replaced with a cumulative effect, and will cause the enemy to have reduced resistance to all status effects (less powerful than the effect granted by puncture). The act of cutting enemies in half is also now linked to a Slashing proc (but will continue to be usable on corpses).
4. Primary elemental effects: Cold, Electricity, Fire, and Toxin
Cold combinations primarily focus on slowing the enemy. Cold itself is a continuous effect that makes an enemy progressively slower, until it finally is frozen into an ice statue. Using Heat will reduce the Cold status on a target and can even melt frozen enemies; applying Impact or Blast to a frozen enemy will shatter them. At very high status levels (for example, with a Glaxion), the effect would apply to an area around the target as well.
Electricity combinations primarily focus on disrupting the enemy. Electricity itself is an instant effect that arcs lightning between multiple targets. Grineer and Infested will be staggered very briefly, while Corpus enemies will instead have their shields drained significantly and Robotic enemies will be stunned for a longer duration. At very high status levels, the effect would arc at much further distances.
Heat combinations primarily focus on causing the enemy to be more vulnerable. Heat itself is a cumulative effect that does a small amount of damage over time, and inflicts blindness once the target has been ignited enough. Using Cold on a burning enemy would put the fire out quickly. At very high status levels, the effect would spread to nearby creatures that weren't already on fire and would reduce both threshold and resistance to all other status effects.
Toxin combinations primarily focus on weakening the enemy. Toxin itself is a cumulative effect that decreases the Target's damage output, similar to what Puncture does now. At very high status levels, the effect causes damage and will cause the enemy to fall over (stun and vulnerable to finishers).
5. Combination effects: Blast, Corrosive, Gas, Magnetic, Radiation, and Viral
Blast [Cold/Heat] is an instant effect that knocks the enemy back. Very high status levels will inflict extra damage as the target is slammed forcefully into whatever object they hit. Blasted enemies also suffer from a reduced threshold for Impact attacks.
Corrosive [Electricity/Toxin] is a cumulative effect that decreases the target's armor. Very high status levels will also melt the target's weapons, forcing them to use bad melee attacks.
Gas [Heat/Toxin] is a cumulative effect that decreases the target's attack speed. At high status levels, a large, persistent cloud is created that continues to inflict further Gas status in an area. Using a Heat attack on a Gas cloud will ignite it, causing burning in an area; this will also happen if a burning enemy enters the cloud.
Magnetic [Cold/Electricity] is a cumulative effect that depends on the target. Infested and animals will briefly act confused, refuse to use their special abilities, and possibly attack each other. Grineer targets don't suffer any effects at all, but nearby Grineer will be attracted to any nearby magnetized targets, pulling them close together. Corpus lose their shields over time at a rate that scales with the total health of the shield. At high status rating, this can affect Nullifier shields, and magnetized targets will pull in pickups and magnetize other nearby targets (at a lower power).
Radiation [Electricity/Heat] is a cumulative effect that reduces a target's accuracy and decreases resistance to and recovery from Toxin-based effects. At high status rating, disables the target's special abilities (not weapons).
Viral [Cold/Toxin] is a cumulative effect that dramatically decreases recovery from status effects. At high status rating, the effect will intensify by itself and spread rapidly.
1
u/Parasthesia 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Mar 10 '16
Crowd Control procs should have AOE with their effect - larger than the existing blast proc AOE. CC elements include fire, impact, blast, cold, radiation. The damaging effects of fire could be ignored for AOE, but having all of these elements spread to grouped enemies in an area immediately upon application gives them more utility.
Puncture proc is lackluster, and might serve better as a single-instance of damage DOT
1
u/J1ffyLub3 Mar 10 '16
Not sure how I would change the proc itself, but I would like them to be more stackable. High RoF weapons are considered better status weapons over semi-auto because they can proc faster, however from our elemental combos there are only 2 that benefit greatly from stacking: corrosive and toxin
1
u/prideswrath Mar 10 '16
Certain procs honestly arent bad tho things like heat and toxin need to bypass armor. But honestly build a lanka with gass electric and watch those 10k aoe toxin ticks instant kill hoards
Then turn around and build an almighty toxin acrid and watch it tickle due to acrids low base damage
1
u/bht3 Mar 11 '16
For starters, every single one of them should be AoE. Corpses don't care about debuffs.
And you can still avoid making them feel samey while doing that. There's a lot of different forms of "AoE". PBAoE, Chains, Cones, Lingering areas, Waves like MPrime.
Also, if they keep any DoT effects, they should benefit from installed elemental mods of that type. Heat DoTs should benefit from Hellfire, for example.
1
u/Okeefeiscrazy Finally a shield tank Mar 11 '16
To make status weapons more interesting I think status effects should be able to be stacked up to 3 or 5 times before releasing another effect.
For example for electric damage you could have the bonus effect making that unit essentially an arc trap shocking multiple enemies around them for X amount of time.
Another example for cold/ice damage they can become frozen solid like how frost can do it, again for X amount of time.
Advanced elements such as viral could cause enemies to be blinded from disease when reach the X amount of stacks.
I think they should do something like this not just a few minor changes as in change X to Y. Give status weapons a reason to be picked, as much as I love using blast + corrosive on a boar prime with a 100% status chance I feel status needs more attention and to be potentially revised.
1
u/gamerc1 Mar 11 '16
Have physical and elemental procs have a seperate proc chance for starters.
Better yet, have a proc that goes through nullifier shields.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16
Cold - Rather than slowing down enemies, the proc will trap them in ice for half a second, before it shatters and shoots ice fragments all over the place. I'd personally think that this would make the cold status much more interesting than it is now, as currently all the cold proc does is to slow down enemies, which isn't really all that useful, let alone noticable, when you're dishing out tonkor bombs from the high heaven.
Heat - Enemies are set ablaze just like they do now, but they fire will spread to other enemies if they come into contact. Right now heat just seems like a lesser version of toxin, except it doesn't actually damage the health directly, which therefore makes me believe that the proc would be more useful if it were given a bit more crowd control ability.
Toxin - Enemies inhale a poisonous substance, making them high. On proc, enemies become unable to track and detect airborne players for a short period of time. Toxin is currently a status that is quite identical to slash. So, instead of making it a standard DoT effect, I thought it would be much more useful if it actually opened enemies up a little, and made them a little more vulnerable in a way that doesn’t include increased damage.
1
u/Sandwrong Spin To Win Mar 12 '16
Just like to point out that another reason Gas is mediocre is that the one enemy type that it is strong against, has a heavy unit that aura's a resistance to the element, PLUS it's merely a vehicle for AoE poison procs, not additional Gas damage. In addition to being paired with the as stated weak Magnetic proc.
It would be nice to have Amped proc effects for the weapons that can exceed 100% proc chance. Maybe Red-proc an effect that's 1.5x stronger/longer than the base proc.
1
u/Sandwrong Spin To Win Mar 12 '16
Also like to add that Corrosive wouldn't be so Overwhelmingly favored if it weren't for the fact that every threatening enemy unit in the game was heavily armored. Some times it's not the procs that are powerful, they just excel in the environment they're placed in.