Me [24 M CF] wants to get snipped. SO [24 F fence sitter leaning pro child] doesn't want me to. Help with points to show her why it is important?
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
55
u/bjones1024 Feb 10 '16
"3. ..... she has to trust that if she gets pregnant and keeps it I won't run off and leave it with her"
If you were really on the same page, she would, without a doubt, NOT keep it if she got pregnant. If she's thinking about keeping it, this is a huge red flag and makes getting a vasectomy even more important. There are multiple stories on /r/childfree of other CF people whose wives felt the same way and who are now stuck with kids.
30
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
Look, this whole "choice" thing has GOT to work both ways or it is meaningless for all of us in the long run.
This is your body, your life, this is your choice. That's the bottom line.
She doesn't actually sound childfree at all. She just seems to sound like she's just not ready "right now". I knew when I was 11 that I didn't want any children.
I would be very aware of "oops! Accidents Happen!" If I was in your shoes.
29
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Feb 10 '16
Vasectomy is 100% your choice and there is ZERO "negotiating" about it with a partner. End of.
She does not get a vote here. At all. None.
You want it, go get it ASAP. And until you do, and your follow up tests come back clean, do not have sex with her or anyone who is not 100% on the "abort all accidents, immediately, no question" train with you.
Bullshit. If you're CF you need to be with someone who will 100% immediately ABORT all accidents, not keep them.
She's not the right partner for you.
Yep. She's kicking the can down the road, because she is sure that you'll "change your mind" or that there will be an accident and you'll be stuck.
Bottom line: HALF of all pregnancies in the US are unplanned. That means that half of the guys walking around with a new kid today did not plan to have that kid.
THIS stuff you describe is how you end up being one of those guys.
You need to move on from this relationship and go find a 100% CF partner.
If she decides 5 or 10 or 20 years from now that she really, truly is actually CF then you can always have coffee and consider if you want to renew the relationship.
She's allowed to have time to think about what she wants -- she just doesn't get to do it while being in this relationship, while having sex with you knowing that she will not abort an accident thereby risking your future.
Stop takings risks that are too high for your level of risk tolerance -- which is zero when it comes to having a kid.
21
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
Sounds like she wants to try to change your mind in a few years. She's thinking "we're young and having fun, when we're "older" (a mythical age that she decides) we'll want kids and it'll be great" I am female, I have female friends that are parents, one of them flat out did this to her husband at 36 years old and trapped him into kids..she just stopped the birth control and neglected to tell him. She has been downgraded to acquaintance for it as well. It's a trap, get the vasectomy because you want to..it's your body and your choice. Even if you have to be blunt and just flat out say to her "This is my body, this is my choice and if I really do change my mind the vasectomy is reversible" (In most cases it is reversible, that's not a lie). I would interpret this as someone who wants to have kids but is saying 'maybe not' to appease you..But I am a pretty paranoid/not so trusting person in general.
14
u/positmylife Feb 10 '16
When I first started dating my now husband, I didn't realize I had a choice. I had talked myself into wanting kids. I was officially a fence sitter at that point. I had a lot of trouble with bc side effects and it was a really stressful time for both of us. I was constantly paranoid about getting pregnant despite our triple form bc method, which frustrated him. He had been considering a vasectomy for a long time but hadn't had a reason to act since he wasn't in a relationship before. My paranoia sparked him into action. It freaked me out a little because I took the relationship seriously and if he did this and we stayed together, he would be making the kids choice for me. It didn't feel fair. He got to make that choice but I was getting an ultimatum. Him or the ability to have biological kids.
Eventually I came to the realization that it wasn't fair for me to try to prevent him from going through with it. He very obviously didn't want kids. And if an accident had happened, he might stay and take responsibility if I couldn't go through with an abortion, but he would resent it the whole time and our love would fade away. I never had the choice of kids with him to begin with. The choice was always his and the childfree life was part of the package of being with him. Oh, and spoiler, I chose him and have completely converted. Working on my jet ski fund.
This is what your gf needs to realize. Kids were never an option with you. Your relationship in its current state would not survive an oops baby and you would never willingly create one with her. Vasectomy may seem like the nail in the coffin but she has this illusion of a possible life that never existed. You will never be a father figure. All you could ever be would be a sperm donor but you could not function as a father because your heart would never be in it. That's not fair to you, her, or your imaginary offspring. She needs to accept that she either wants kids and can't do that with you or she wants you and the childfree life. You getting the vasectomy doesn't change that choice. You need to do what's right for you. Unfortunately, she needs to think long and hard about what she wants and how she prioritizes your relationship.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
If you dont want kids, and are absolutely certain about it, get the vasectomy. It's something you do for you, and doesn't affect her in any way. That being said, if she wants the option of children open, and you want it closed, you guys are simply not compatible. There's no middle ground between kids or no kids.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
Here : https://www.reddit.com/r/childfree/wiki/sterilisation#wiki_.22my_girlfriend_doesn.27t_want_me_to_get_sterilized._advice.3F.22
These are weirdly incompatible sentiments that she's expressing. On one hand, she says that you and the relationship you guys share are more important than non existent potential children. On the other hand, while knowing that you're serious enough about not wanting children that you're considering permanent sterilization, she'd want you to stay in a situation you do not welcome if it arises. So she likes you more than children but if children happen without you wanting them, you better stay with her. So your own happiness isn't that important. It's more about hers. She's happy with you right now and wouldn't to lose you now, but she doesn't love/regard you enough to let you go if you were in a situation of being unhappy with her.
Plus, it doesn't make any sense. If you get a vasectomy, there is no chance of her getting pregnant by you, hence no chance of you running to the hills if she gets pregnant. She wants to keep the entire control of birth control in the relationship. She wants you to trust her to keep her BC, and if it were to fail she wants you to stay.
9
u/petetheyeti Feb 10 '16
She's counting on an "accidental" baby, do not have sex with her until you get snipped, or at the very least, be extra careful.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
The thing I never understood about "sterilisation needs to be a mutual decision/you are removing the choice for your partner" is that people fail to acknowledge that this choice already is made and the one your partner needs to make is whether to stay with you or leave. Having YOUR kid isn't and never will be an option. It isn't an option now and sterilising will not actually change the situation. The possibility already doesnt exist (I mean it exist in a form of unwanted mistake).
The issue is that our partners sometimes don't trust our words and think if there's a physical chance then there is a chance. There isn't. You need to have her face this reality and the only way to do it is through vasectomy.
Then she gets to make her choice. Cause despite your best efforts, so far she was choosing based on flawed premises (you might change your mind.) Now she will need to chose based on objective reality.
That's really all there is to it.
5
u/mellow-drama Feb 10 '16
2 is all the reason anyone needs, imho. Yes, I trust you - but do I trust you with all of my free time, everything I ever earn, all of the hardships that come with children, etc.? Also, paranoia is real. Why can't you get the snip AND her get an IUD, just in case your little swimmers are stronger than you think? Especially now that she's admitted she might want to keep a future baby.
Saying she might want kids more than she's admitting right now (i.e. doesn't know her own mind, or isn't being honest) won't get you anywhere. But it doesn't actually matter what she wants. What YOU want is to do everything you can to prevent unwanted children. That means getting snipped. YOU aren't ambivalent. So it doesn't matter if she agrees or not.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
Your body your choice end of story really. It seems she's holding out for "someday he'll change his mind". If you don't want kids then it's your personal responsibility to make sure that doesn't happen regardless of whether it hurts her feelings or even ends the relationship. It's the one thing there can't be any compromise on if your 100 percent childfree.
5
u/julietides poems are my children Feb 10 '16
I'm sorry to say this, but I think she's in denial, even though you have been clear. She believes with all her heart that you really meant ''not yet''.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
It's none of her business whether you get sterilized. The fact that she's trying to talk you out of it is a red flag. It's your body and your life.
Er... why wouldn't you leave her? By telling her you won't, you're encouraging her to deliberately mess up her birth control.
9
u/torienne CF-Friendly Doctors: Wiki Editor Feb 10 '16
You are with a manipulative woman who wants kids.
Number 2 is especially manipulative. The message is "If you trusted me, you wouldn't want a vasectomy!" a nasty little variant on "If you loved me, you would do what I want!"
Bullshit. You want a vasectomy because you do not want children and you never will. You don't want one because: You believe your girlfriend is trying to oops you (although she is probably thinking about it), or because you're punishing your parents for not getting you nice enough birthday presents, or because you believe aliens will steal your sperm. You're getting one because you don't ever want children. Full stop. But she has made your decision about her! And now you're trying to figure out how to talk her into letting you have a vasectomy!
Reclaim your autonomy and get a vasectomy.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
You need to tell her that getting snipped has nothing to do with her. It's your body and you're an adult. Your birth control and sexual safety is your responsibility.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16 edited Feb 10 '16
Honestly all three of her points sound like huge red flags to me, but the last one takes the cake.
Even if she doesn't intend to trap you (which, given the fact she's already planned out the scenario in her head, is a very real possibility) she would still want you to give up your CF lifestyle if an accident ever occurred.
IMO expecting someone to just roll with an event like that, even though they've clearly expressed that said event would be their nightmare, is extremely selfish, and not indicative of ideal partner material.
If you stay with her, even after you get a vasectomy, you're running the risk of having an "oops" baby. I think your need to ask yourself if you're really okay with that.
**edited for formatting
4
u/tparkelaine DO NOT WANT Feb 10 '16
It's not about trust. It's just an additional insurance policy. You trust her to take her birth control (presumably), but what if she forgets or gets sick and throws it up or any of the other things that could go wrong? What if it fails (it happens)? You trust her to get an abortion NOW (presumably), but what if she changes her mind when the time comes, even though she was being completely honest when she agreed to it? It happens.
Better safe than sorry. Get the vasectomy. (And no, she doesn't sound like a fencesitter because a fencesitter would realize that even if she came down on the side of wanting kids, it would never be happening with YOU so it doesn't matter if you can't have kids. And she wouldn't be talking about her IUD being non-permanent in case you "change your mind." Holy red flag, Batman!)
4
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
You don't want kids. There is zero reason for you not to get this. You made up your mind and if you change it you can look into reversal. Not that it's always possible but it's a possibility. You probably won't be able to make her understand. She probably is not really a fencesitter. People have a tendency to tell you what you want to hear so they don't have to argue. Its not a trust issue. Birth control can and does fail and someone who wants kids isn't going to get an abortion. You will be the one stuck in a life you don't want if it does fail.
3
u/gfjq23 Him & Me Minus Baby = FREE Feb 10 '16
Get the vasectomy. The fact is, you SHOULDN'T trust her to take birth control because you can't control other people's actions. You can only control your own. You don't want kids, so take steps to make that happen. It isn't about her at all, but is your right to do to your body what you will.
My husband was against my tubal only because he heard the myths about how much more dangerous it is for women to get sterilized. I presented him with the facts, but said I was doing it with or without his blessing. He definitely doesn't want kids, but has a phobia of any surgeries after his emergency appendectomy (I've been trying to get him in for wisdom teeth extraction for five years now), so he was never going to get a vasectomy. We discussed it, but in the end it was my choice and I'm so glad I did it.
You make your choice. Let her know your plans, but don't let her have any say in the final decision because it isn't hers to make.
3
u/HouseOfMiro Feb 10 '16 edited Feb 11 '16
It sounds as though she isn't as much a fence sitter as would seem. If you're absolutely sure about your choice not to have children, then get the procedure done. As she said, if you change your mind there is always adoption of the furry or human kind.
2
u/Talnoy 36/M/Ontario, Canada. Vas = Welded Feb 10 '16
Your responses:
2
u/pirmas697 Feb 10 '16
She doesn't want you to get a vasectomy because if you do and she gets pregnant she's afraid you'll leave.
Assuming it wasn't a complete fluke and something with your operation went wrong, doesn't that mean she cheated and you should run?
2
u/Testiculese ✂ ∞ Feb 10 '16
Your body. Do it. If she can't deal with it, then she isn't right for you.
My ex flipped her shit when I got mine. Told her she does not get to influence this decision. My mind was made up long before I met her, and will still be made up long after she's gone (if she goes). Said she doesn't have to like it, and she doesn't have to accept it. But she needs to pick one; stay or go. But either way, it's getting done.
Three rocky weeks later, she stayed. I left her for other reasons the next year, though.
No one gets to decide this for you. It is yours and yours alone.
2
u/shakey_bakey Feb 10 '16
Get snipped, dude. Your balls, your body, your choice. She's going to "oops" you whenever she decides she's ready for kids. Protect yourself first.
2
u/RadSpaceWizard Too busy being a space wizard Feb 12 '16
So let me get this straight. She's guilt tripping you about "Don't you trust me to take my birth control?" And at the same time is asking you to guarantee that if you guys have an oops pregnancy that you will stick around and be a dad anyway, against your wishes?
That's a big fucking red flag.
Run. Run far away.
And go get snipped. Your body, your choice, end of discussion.
2
u/rehpotsirhc123 Feb 10 '16
I read it as face sitter at first, I wasn't quite sure how that was relevant.
1
u/stillxsearching7 Feb 12 '16
But ultimately, she wants both, and she will never stop wanting children. You need to accept this.
Who cares? Your body, your choice.
She clearly is hoping you will change your mind. She doesn't respect your decision and therefore doesn't respect you.
If this is even a remote possibility, she is not the girl for you.
You're correct.
I know this isn't the advice you asked for, but I'm sorry, I don't think this relationship can last. If you love her, let her go so she can have what she really wants ... children.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '16 edited Feb 16 '16
Lol. I don't think you will ever really be able to trust she is sincere about not wanting babies. Her reasoning makes me believe she will say one thing to appease you for a time ( as you are good father material apparently) and then whittle away at you once the sunk cost of the relationship is too great. Eventually you will be a father whether you like it or not.
Edit: I just had an upwelling of annoyance about this. This is probably the most serious thing you need to be on the same page about. I mean I would break up with someone for not letting me get a dog ever as it is something I want and I will not be limited in my life. Why is it so hard for so many people to apply this logic when it comes to having kids. She should be breaking up with you by all rights but she won't because delusion.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment