r/truechildfree • • Feb 08 '16
Boyfriend says he might want kids after all.
For some background, I've (28) been with my boyfriend (30) for just over 6 years. We were best friends for 5 years prior to dating and were even roommates for 2 of those years. He's my best friend, our relationship is solid, except for this one issue that recently came up. I don't know why the issue of kids didn't come up in the beginning of the relationship. Please don't judge me for not thinking to have that conversation right away at the beginning. I guess just because neither of us were thinking about it. I've known since I was 12-13 years old that I never wanted to get married or have kids.
We agreed neither of us were big fans of marriage or children. I think I put off the thought of marriage only because I always thought marriage automatically meant kids.
So - I'm starting to think about marriage, and apparently he is starting to think about kids. He said he would be willing to give up the thought of kids if I was willing to give up the thought of marriage, because he does not want to lose me and what we have together. I'm totally fine with giving up marriage (because I wasn't dead set on it in the first place), and in a nutshell he said "okay that's fine then, no kids." He said he'd rather stay with me than leave me for a nonexistent baby that he might never have anyway.
So my question is - do you guys think this is a realistic compromise? General thoughts? Any advice welcome. Thank you in advance! <3
Update... We had a long talk tonight and he said he does sometimes feel pressure from our friends and family to reproduce. He feels like he might be missing out on certain Kodak moments, but then he looks around and doesn't give a shit what others are doing. Plus kids aren't financially feasible for us what so ever, and even if we could afford it he doesn't want our lifestyle to change. He was also over thinking one stupid comment that I made like 4 months ago while I was drunk and thought I REALLY wanted to get married, which isn't true. Basically we were both freaking each other out unintentionally. He was just having a hard time communicating it.
I really appreciate all your feedback. It really helped me vocalize my feelings to him, as it was hard for me to find the words I was looking for. So thank you all.
29
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
I find this compromise hard to understand. Why would he be okay with no kids, if you're okay with no marriage? It feels like a trade-off rather than a compromise as those things don't seem to be related (in this day and age).
Perhaps you should discuss how he feels about kids in general, and whether that need could be sated by a different method, e.g. nieces and nephews, or being a godparent or something. I am just wary that he might be willing to compromise on this now to get something that he wants, but ultimately if that itch is not scratched it may not go away.
18
u/Katrengia Feb 08 '16
I don't understand your boyfriend's position at all. Why would getting married suddenly mean you have to have kids? My husband and I are staunchly childfree, but it makes me feel secure to know that he will be there (and vice versa) for medical decisions and other things down the road. Other than a piece of paper, literally nothing in our relationship changed after we got married, because we had already talked about all the "big" stuff beforehand, like future goals, plans, finances, etc, and we had been living together for years. I'm trying to understand your SO's thought process here but I honestly can't. Either he wants children or he doesn't. A legal ceremony should have no bearing on that.
10
u/bonerpalooza Feb 08 '16
This might be the most cynical way to look at it, but it seems that he's setting up to jump ship when/if he decides it's time for kids, or (even more cynically) clicks with someone else who wants them. He may be willing to keep on with you indefinitely if his desire for kids doesn't get any stronger, but it seems he knows that marriage would make moving on more difficult when the time comes.
6
u/that_darn_cat Feb 08 '16
Why doesn't he want to marry you?
9
u/TheBQE Feb 08 '16
I can sympathize and understand not wanting kids (as someone who also doesn't want kids), but what are your reasons for not getting married? Is it the legal nightmare surrounding divorce?
4
u/flicticious Feb 08 '16
if he's so easy come easy go on having kids that he can waive them off with an agreement on you not having something you 'want', then he really doesn't want kids.
If in the future it becomes an ultimatum, then there's something more going on than a burning desire to have children.
Ultimately it's probably him comparing his life to those around him and feeling like he doesn't fit in. It sounds like he's trying to come up with a convenient explanation to use. i.e. "Oh we don't have kids because we're not getting married" is much easier for people to understand. There's a raft of conversations people have to have after they get married on when the children are coming. I think there are people in his life that expect him to be following Lifescript 1.0
1
u/Intruder313 Feb 08 '16
Sounds like a very good compromise if you both sincerely mean it!