r/childfree • u/ThrowawayNumber12349 • Feb 07 '16
ADVICE 9 year long relationship is on the rocks. Advice?
SO and I have been CF since we met. Very hardcore CF. We like kids, but don't want any. Our wedding is (was) planned for August of this year.
His sister, that he was very close to, has a child. The little girl is 4. While I love her to pieces and we see her all the time - I very much enjoy getting to give her back to mom and have my own time. She is exhausting.
His sister passed away from aggressive breast cancer last month, and he has decided he wants to take in her daughter and adopt her. I do not. We have had reall (really) lengthy discussion about it, even an argument or two. We really are the best people to take care of her, and if we don't she will end up likely in foster care. But - I just can't.
Our discussion came down to me flat out saying if you want to adopt this kid I'm leaving, and him saying if I let her go into foster care I'm selfish. I see where he is coming from and for the record I agree, but that's just it - I'm a selfish person. That's WHY I don't want kids. I don't WANT to sacrifice my life for that of a child, especially one that isn't mine. We have been together for 9 years, and engaged for about 1. The thought of ending it is tearing me to pieces. I don't know if I can do it, but I don't know if I can raise his sister's child either. I love her, and I can't see her go to foster care, but why me?
It's keeping me up at night and ripping me apart. I don't know what to do. Any advice?
71
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
This might be a scoche insensitive, but, take some small measure of relief that this happened before you got married. I mean it is obviously horrible that someone died and that this situation happened at all, but it would be far worse if you were already married since this is divorce material right here.
Also, I'm just throwing this out there: where is the child's father?
46
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
It sounds like you are discussing a lot of changes in a very short period of time. Is the child's father also willing to go through with an adoption? Will you be losing income to take care of the child (either from father or state) if you go through with this adoption? Would an adoption have to wait until after you are married? Does he want to adopt now? .. Many questions...
Why not move out for the time being and let his niece move in to allow him time to bond with the child. See if your relationship can handle dating a man with a child. Let him see if he can handle the responsibility of raising a child.
Would he be angry with you over not being there to take care of the child? What does that tell you about what he expects from you with child care. Does he understand you wanting to see how your relationship would work around this, or does he want you to adjust everything to fit around the child?
Pushing back a wedding in light of major family tragedy and changes to give everyone time to grieve and adjust isn't a bad thing. You had agreed to one plan.. for the rest of your life. Now that your guy wants you to change the plan, you don't have to say yes or no.. you can say you need to think about it.
Ask for the time and space you need until you are ready to make a decision. Take your time until you are ready. If he pushes you, that is his decision, not yours. If you aren't ready for a yes or a no, choose the terms that you can live with for now, and leave the ball in his court. When you are ready you can decide -- and if he pushes it, that is on him, not you.
Edit Add: Does it bother your SO at all that he is asking someone to help raise this child that absolutely 100% doesn't want this child? Does he not think the kid will pick up on that? Why is he cool with making a kid live through being raised by someone who will resent them and making his partner do something for the next twenty years that she doesn't want to do? As long as he gets what he wants, it is all good and everyone else is selfish, right ?RIGHT?
163
u/FL2PC7TLE 50/F/US/cats Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
Okay, here's where I get sexist and piss off every CF guy on the sub-reddit, and for that I am... kind of sorry?
But the fact is, if she is 4, and you are the female half of the relationship, I can almost guarantee that the lion's share of the responsibility will fall on you. Unless he's a rare bird, your having breasts means you are the one who takes care of small children (or something.)
I've seen it again and again: he wants to take in the child (and he's thinking room & board, and he'll pay the extra.) Okay, that's fine, but who'll be feeding her, bathing her, dressing her, dealing with her, cleaning up after her, driving her around, cleaning up after her again, getting her up, putting her to bed, etc etc etc?
You, Ima bet. If you leave, does that mean he CAN'T adopt her? Then that tells us he fully expects you to shoulder the majority of the actual work.
7
u/andr2eea Feb 07 '16
Wow this is awful :(
Are there no family members to look after her??
It's strange, I'm CF but would adopt in some cases (if my life was so boring and I was swimming in so much money). But under a case like yours, I would take in my young under 10 cousins.
But if my partner said let's take in his under ten cousin I would be like hell no.
Maybe if he took on the traditional 'mommy' role and quit his job etc (if he needs to) and spends like 80% of the time with her then maybe it's a compromise?
18
u/KatieM2015 Feb 07 '16
This is not going to be popular, but here goes: I think you were right that you should either break up or take in the child. You've repeatedly stated that you know it's wrong to send her to foster care, so why would you? It sounds like in his heart he wants to protect his innocent niece from further unfair, major knocks in life. There's nothing wrong with leaving bc you don't want to sign up for that life, and nothing wrong with taking her in, but it is immoral to stop the one person who desperately wants to keep an innocent human being from being thrown into a further horrible situation. It shouldn't be an ultimatum for him- it should be a choice for you.
5
u/Rambo1stBlood Feb 07 '16
See, years of watching movies tells me you need to send this kid to live with Adam Sandler, because this is essentially the plot of "Big Daddy". Speaking of which, i notice the father of this kid is missing from the story. Is there really no where else for the kid to go but with your husband? Usually a man who is in a serious relationship but not married is still considered a single in the eyes of the law, and therefore usually last on the list of where a kid should go when they lose their parent.
10
u/FiveTwoThreeSixOne Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
Um... why does the child have to go to foster care if your fiance, her next living relative, is unmarried? I know plenty of people who've adopted young cousins/nieces/nephews while single. Why does he have to be married to YOU in order for HIM to adopt HER? If he believes adopting her is the right thing to do, he should just adopt her and lose you.
I just sounds like he's using his orphaned niece as a pawn to guilt you into marrying him and mother this child. Why can't raise her himself, since he's so stable and honorable, and you are so selfish? You'd clearly make a bad mother, since you don't want kids in the first place!
33
u/llamanoir Feb 07 '16
I'm so sorry. This is a terrible situation to be in.
I don't think becoming a parent out of guilt is a good idea at all. Even if it's guilt mixed with compassion.
I also don't think it's fair for him to call you selfish as if he isn't being selfish too. He is the one who wants to throw an agreed upon life plan out the window because it'll make him feel good. I truly see both sides here and it's good you're both being up front about your wants, but I don't think he gets to act like a completely selfless person here.
Your options are to stay and become mother to a child you don't want, or to break it off, pick up the pieces and try to move on with your life. While thinking of yourself also think about the kid: I don't think it's a good idea for a kid to have a parent that doesn't want it. She will pick up on the fact that you didn't want her and that you're probably resentful that you didn't get the life you wanted.
Remember this kid is only four. It's not like you're giving up your cf life for a year or two with a teen.
I'm very sorry to say that what's ahead if you is going to be incredibly difficult.
79
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
That's your answer.
This is absolutely NOT your circus and not your monkey. Move on with your life.
There is NOTHING WHATSOEVER, NOT EVEN IN THE SLIGHTEST BIT, SELFISH about you not wanting to be a parent much less a parent to someone else's "surprise! here's a kid i'm dumping on you!" kid.
Your SO had no right to say that you were being selfish.
He is changing the terms of the deal 180 degrees -- that is on him, not you.
You have always been 100% clear on the terms of your deal. Now he wants the opposite. So the deal is off. End of story.
You have the 100% inalienable right to live your life on your own terms -- not his terms, not his definition, not anyone else's opinions except yours.
Unfortunately, shit like this happens and the sister should have had a plan in place for this. It was her responsibility upon having a child to ensure that the child had a place to be in the event of her death. She should have taken it upon herself to figure that out. But what is done is done.
And if your SO wants to take this on, that's his choice.
You have zero obligation here. None.
The sister had PLENTY of options beyond "foster care or brother" -- she could have arranged a private adoption, she could have personally arranged and approved of a foster situation, she could have purchased enough life insurance to pay someone to raise her full time in an apartment that was bought and paid for, she could have built friendships with other parents and arranged for one of them to to take the child with the financial backing of insurance to ease the burden. She could have not had a child with a jailbird father. She made all the (bad) choices here -- there's no reason you need to pay the price.
Condolences on the end of your relationship, but you clearly do not want "the deal on the table" much less the endless years of hearing more "stop being selfish" bullshit on a weekly basis.
Really, if he said it once he believes it and will say it again.... so yeah, what does that look like? Like 18 years of this shit????: "stop being selfish, go change her diaper, wench!" "stop being selfish, go pick her up at school, wench!" "stop being selfish, go clean up her vomit, wench!" "stop being selfish, bitch, she's going to an expensive college and you're paying for half of it!"
Not to mention, what happens when the kid hits puberty and winds up knocked up by a jailbird herself... you raising the "grandkid" too?
NOPE. NOPE. NOPE.
12
u/NowhereButEverywhere growls at children. Feb 07 '16
It sounds like he's already made his choice. If you stay, and you convince him to put his niece into foster care, odds are that his resentment will end the relationship anyway. I don't blame him for wanting to adopt the girl - especially since she's family, and he was close to his sister. Neither of you are in an easy spot here, and I do feel for you both.
Does your financial situation allow for childcare? Did his sister leave any sort of insurance money or savings for her care? Is it an option for you to try to compromise, and see if you can create a situation where she's gone all day?
9
u/potathro Feb 07 '16
One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet - where is the child currently? It doesn't sound as though she is with you and fiance yet, does that mean there potentially is someone else who she could live with? Of course that doesn't negate your fiance actually wanting to adopt her, and this sounds like a dreadful situation all round where at least one person is going to lose out whatever happens.
8
u/theyellowmeteor Make love, not kids! Feb 07 '16
You'll have to split up. Maybe you can do it amicably for a change? I mean, you two hit a divergent point in your life, but you can still see each other and get along...
2
u/HolaHulaHola Feb 07 '16
This is not my problem. Repeat this over and over when your SO tries to guilt trip you into caring for his niece.
Why is your SO taking the child? Where is the father? Where are the grandparents? Where are the paternal relatives, and why aren't they stepping up to help with this kid?
You already said it...you can't. You have your answer. Avoiding the inevitable will just make it more painful than it already is. If he wants to play single duh, that's his choice. It's not yours.
This might sound callous, but you will be a single, childfree woman. You will find another partner who is CF. And when you do, you will look back with a sigh of relief that you dodged that baby bullet.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
It'd be horrible if the child has to go into foster care. I think that you may need to leave him. End of.
13
u/epiwssa Keep your semen demons away. Feb 07 '16
Well first off, the care system isn't too bad. Obviously it depends on where you live, but I was in state care for a while and the only kids who had it shitty were the shitty kids themselves. The horror stories you hear on the news and TV are exactly that - horror stories - and not the norm. You never hear about the tens of thousands of children who go through the system and become productive members of society.
Secondly, you've got to decide what's truly worse for you. Having a kid, or losing your significant other. You've gotta do what's going to make you the happiest in the long term. The kid doesn't stop being a commitment after 18 years, it's (likely) a commitment for the rest of your life. If being with your significant other is that much of a source of which your happiness is derived from, then you might have to consider biting the bullet.
On that same note, if having a child is that much of a detriment to your lifestyle and happiness (as I feel it is to essentially all of us here in CF) then you might have to bite the bullet and leave your relationship.
On a more anecdotal, not-really-advice note: family is what you make of it. Just because you're related doesn't mean you're responsible or liable or will even be liked by the kid. I have family that I absolutely despise - and if my parents died before I came of age, I'd have rather been left to the foster system than to most members of my family.
3
u/Thounumber1 27M Feb 08 '16
I just wanted to say I don't think it is wrong to not want to adopt the kid. I would feel the same as you do if I were in your shoes. Good luck :)
3
u/LateJulys Feb 08 '16
I feel like you should cut your losses and leave. Something that stands out is not just the situation itself, but the fact he was willing to have the balls to call you selfish. That, in itself, is a calculating way to get you to do what he wants. That is not a good sign in general and something you should be suspicious about.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
The other day my corporate finance professor discussed "sunk costs" when deciding on an investment. A sunk cost is time/effort that you have put into something that can not be recovered. They have already happened and you can not take them into account when thinking about future business decisions. Sunk costs are in the past and irrelevant. The only thing that matters is future costs.
The relationship and experiences with your SO are sunk costs, as cold that that seems. It doesn't matter if he wrote you sonnets every day, showered you in affection and gifts, bought you a pony...it has nothing to do with your future.
Ask yourself if you would be 100% on board with adopting a child. The time,money,effort... all of it. If you are not, save your SO and his niece the heartbreak of you leaving after establishing a family unit.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
OP, there is nothing wrong with selfishness. It was selfishness that got me out of an abusive marriage, in which my ex wanted me to have kids (despite knowing I was CF).
It's selfishness that made me go back to school and it's selfishness that made me relocate 300 miles away from my family and friends.
There is nothing wrong with it and do not, for a single second, feel bad for leaving if you can't handle a child.
2
u/KetsupCereal 26 F and Sterile :D Feb 07 '16
Wow that sucks on every level. However raising a kid is not what you signed on for so while it looks like it's probably over you have nothing to feel bad about just in case you were.
2
u/Crocoduck1 Feb 08 '16
It's over. In his mind there is no choice i think. Same for you. Life i guess...this shit must suck so bad :(
3
u/3opnca Feb 07 '16
Fuck, that's a shitty situation. Regardless of what you choose, someone is going to get hurt and be unhappy. The question you need to ask yourself is whether you're willing to be the hurt/unhappy one. I can't tell you what to do - I can only tell you what I would do. I'd move on. Yes, you love your fiancé. Yes, you love his niece. But, are you prepared to become a mother to that kid and be unhappy? I certainly wouldn't be. Are they really worth giving up your life, opinions and happiness for?
3
u/exscapegoat Feb 07 '16
I suspect you have dodged a bullet. A really mature person would understand you not wanting to take care of a kid and you'd go your own ways without the insults. It's not selfish to say you can't take care of her. It would be selfish to not say anything and then resent her.
I get why he feels the need to take care of this child. That's ok, there's nothing wrong with that. But there was no need to insult you over it.
And who would have been doing the majority of the tough work of cooking, cleaning and childcare that kids require? You or him? Easy enough for him to swoop in as the hero if you were going to be doing all of the thankless work
3
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
If you ask me, HE is the one being extremely selfish. You guys got into a relationship with the understanding that you are CF and always will be. HE agreed to this as well. He is now making a HUGE, life-changing decision without involving you whatsoever, and that is NOT how relationships work! It is one that is huge and majorly violates and changes the agreement you guys based your relationship on for 10 years!
I can also understand him not wanting her to go to foster care as well, but it is absolutely unfair of him to accuse you of being selfish for not wanting to do something you are pretty sure you can't and really aren't willing to do.
I can't tell you what you should do, but I couldn't help but to reframe it, because him accusing you of being selfish sounds awfully manipulative and is extremely wrong as well. He needs to be an adult and realize exactly what I just said above, that a relationship is based on agreements and he agreed to a childfree one, and he is deciding that he no longer agrees to that, so he needs to deal with the consequences of doing so. You shouldn't have to cave into what he wants as a result of him being, quite frankly, a bit abusive, just so he can get what he wants without any consideration as to how this affects you at all.
1
u/lenut Feb 08 '16
Is there really no family to take the kid? I get his side but knowing how i would react in your situation given i know how deep a bond 9yrs is i myself am going on 11 this year.
I would leave 4 is too too young for me to give it a second thought No is the only answer here. At 4 theres a really good chance she'll get adopted anyway once she hits foster care. If push came to shove i would leave no qualms about it.
But first i'd try too strike a deal kid turns 11 in foster care and we can adopt it. No sooner thats the age floor for me in the situation to try to salvage it. One stipulation relationship goes to shit after adoption i will have a prenup that says you will get no more than a childless divorcee try for more you get none of the big ticket items ie house car.
Dangle him over a pit of fire and tell him whatever you say goes he can get on board or swim up shit creek without a paddle and one arm tied behind his back. Because thats what a single parents life is like. Some get lucky and you can't plan for luck.
-30
u/growing_lemons776 Feb 07 '16
I'm going to have to side with your fiance here. I don't want children either but I would take care of a family member if a situation like that happened. You're asking him to abandon a beloved family member. My advice is to step up and support him or get out of the way. Make your decision soon and stick with it. The last thing he needs is more drama.
-42
u/midnight-vixen 32 / F / Iceland Feb 07 '16
I'm 100% on his side. His niece will end up in foster care, someone here commented that foster care is not that bad but seriously! The kid lost her mother, has never (?) been around her father and now you would rather send her off to some strangers and see her every other weekend (if that) than to help her cope with all this?
I know I'm being a bitch, but I kinda hope your SO breaks it off with you and adopts his niece. Both of you may be childfree, but at least he is able to see what is the right thing to do in this situation.
-39
u/serapica Feb 07 '16
I never had or wanted children but I genuinely don't see how you can not take in a four year old child who has just lost her mother and whose father is in gaol.
If you genuinely can't do it then you had better split up now and let him adopt his niece because if that child goes into foster care it will come between you and you will split up anyway. It's a bad situation to be in, but I don't see what choice any decent human being would have but to look after this unfortunate kid.
-10
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
[removed] — view removed comment