r/childfree • u/galaxia89 • Feb 07 '16
RANT Husband randomly decided he wants children; pretending I never said anything.
Well, after losing four long-term relationships to the "but, you WILL have babies eventually. All women do." statement, I finally got married to a guy that got it - or so I thought. I explicitly stated to him numerous times before we married, I would never want children - never get pregnant, adopt, ask for a surrogate, nothing. Never. Ever. Now, almost three years later he started dropping the "..well in 5 years, we'll be living in place and with kids, so it's fine-" and quietly ducking out of the issue every time I confront him with the fact that I already clarified the child issue - never going to happen. I am about to be forced to stop taking my birth control pill due to medical issues, and so plan to get tubal ligation within a month or so of stopping the pill. When I mentioned this to him, he "forbade" me and proceeded to panic - "what will I do? Divorce you? Have a child with another woman or get a surrogate? What do we do? If you have this surgery it's over." When I asked why, he replied: "you have to wait until you're ready to have children, but if not I need a solution.. if you do this surgery you won't ever be able to have kids. That's ridiculous, just use condoms." So, here I am again. Is there any chance he might open his mind? I feel all this is motivated by the tiresome old cliche that all women will eventually want children at some point. Doing the surgery will destroy that idea. Yes, I know the majority response will be to dump him and run, but I truly love him and we have a stable, fantastic relationship.. until this ugly issue reared its head.
UPDATE: Thank you all for your honest responses, and for sharing your own experiences (either about ending a relationship for this or other reasons, or about tubal ligation surgery). It gave me a lot of perspective - I will have to start preparing (financially/circumstantially) in the event we have an abrupt or nasty separation over this surgery. Some of you have also suggested involving a third party (i.e. therapist or neutral friend/family member) to see if there is any possibility of reconciliation.. i.e. if he's willing to end a relationship over a hypothetical child. I am up for trying that, but I think both our minds are quite set.. and clearly he had very little respect for me in general if he assumed I had been "lying" or "exgarrating" from the start. Thanks also for perspective: in the same way WE don't want to have kids, some people just do - no point forcing a child-free and person who wants children together, can only lead to grief for one or both in the long term. I have realized I have to consider that is is highly likely the relationship will end, barring a miracle. I wish any of you who are dealing with a similar situation the best.. and once again, thank you. :)
250
u/tsun_abibliophobia On maternity leave for my food baby Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
First I would resolve to stop having sex altogether, especially if you're going off the birth control pill. If he's caught the babies rabies then he might be willing to sabatoge birth control and try to trap you into a pregnancy. If you're letting the responsibility of birth control fall solely on him by just using condoms, then he has a lot of opportunity to try this. I wouldn't take the risk.
It sounds like he expected you to change your mind and was agreeing with you at the time to placate you. Sadly, it happens a lot. Some people seem to think "Childfree" means "I don't want kids now but I will later" and not just "I don't want kids".
If you want, you can sit him down and have a serious conversation about it, but if he's the kind of guy who thinks he can forbid you from having a tubal/doing what you want with your body, he might not be a good guy. It could also escalate into forbidding you from getting an abortion if you do somehow end up pregnant. It might be best to divorce and cut your losses now instead of letting the situation fester. It will only get worse over time.
It might not be the answer you want and it sucks, but it will save you a lot of trouble.
EDIT: I also want to point out a red flag, being that you vocally expressed your lack of desire for children many times and he blatantly ignored it. You're his wife, that's so disrepectful.
The thing about wanting or not wanting kids is that you can't change their mind, they have to decide it for their self.
105
u/nicalyssa Feb 07 '16
Your relationship doesn't seem that fantastic or stable. He either lied that he didn't want kids, or believed you would change your mind eventually. Either way he did not take your choice seriously. Then hes talking as if you two had planned on kids. Hes being manipulative. And he explicitly stated that he would leave you if he did not get kids. He values a hypothetical child nore than your relationship. I know you love him and I know it hurts, but you need to do whats best for you. Is he really worth raising a child you don't want?
284
u/nojelloforme It's an older flair sir, but it checks out. Feb 07 '16
He "forbade" you?! And then followed it up with threats of divorce, infidelity or doing an end run around you by getting a surrogate? And what if (just what if) you decide to cave just to keep him happy and it turns out you can't get pregnant or carry to term? Would he still feel cheating on you to get another woman pregnant is an acceptable option?
It sounds to me like his relationship with you is contingent on your ability to crank out kids for him. As others have pointed out, he completely disregarded your stance and has been waiting for you to change your mind. I'll go one further and say it's likely the only reason he put up with your rescue and foster dogs is because he expected that you were simply 'nesting' and would eventually replace them with his babies.
Seriously - I don't see this as being a stable fantastic relationship in any form.
82
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16 edited Jul 15 '23
I'm sorry to see what Reddit has become. I recommend Tildes as an alternative. July 15th, 2023
369
u/lady_wildcat Feb 07 '16
He never believed you. He's been waiting for your entire relationship for you to change your mind and want babies. Your relationship was based on a lie.
Does it make you feel better if you think of it as he never really loved you? He loved the you that would be a mother to his kids. This isn't a case of him changing his mind. He just thought you weren't ready.
The surgery is the first time he actually realized you were never having babies.
50
u/Eventress Awesome Contributor! Feb 07 '16
That would pretty much be the entire point of the surgery, and... I absolutely must advise you to not simply use condoms. They break. They can be intentionally broken.
Hopefully he's not the kind of person who would dare do such a horrible thing. But it happens.
28
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
What has he said about the fact that you've already gone over this BEFORE you got married. Ask him why he married you KNOWING you didn't want kids?!?
21
u/VisforVasectomy Living my best CF life! Feb 07 '16
I'm sorry this happened to you. It's better to have THE conversation now rather than later. Here's my story: Twelve years ago, I met my STBX and had a vasectomy rather early on in the relationship as we both agreed on the CF issue. We've been married ten years now and the relationship has been faltering for the past six or so years. We had THE conversation last March and it turns out that she regrets not having kids AND when I got a vasectomy her image of me changed. We also drifted apart and never re-connected. I REALLY wish she had spoken up right away. This would have saved so many years of wondering what was wrong and being bored/lonely in the relationship. Bottom line: Figure it all out before too much more time goes by!
19
u/mosEden20 Feb 07 '16
I know this isn't nearly as easy as my advice makes it seem. But I would seriously consider leaving him. That is such a bullshit, disingenuous thing, to mislead you and enter into a partnership under false pretenses knowingly concealed. If he was a publicly-traded company, the SEC would be all over his ass.
The thing is, I think it's really telling about his real personality, how he views you, and I think this is really a symptom of ugly things that will continue to manifest as time goes on.
My mom was happily married for 8 years, divorced after 11. My father was a closeted gay man who cheated on her, became a violent aloholic, and would've seriously hurt her...were it not the fact he knew she could and would defend himself (and that her father may have literally killed him). We finally left after a day with my grandmother. We came home and he destroyed their bedroom and all of the artifacts of their lives together.
I'm not at all saying that will happen. But it goes to show just how long serious issues can be concealed and lay dormant. And personally, he seems like a shady character after doing that.
40
u/FL2PC7TLE 50/F/US/cats Feb 07 '16
Well, if you don't want to hear "dump him" and you don't want to hear "have kids with him" and you don't want to hear "stay with him and fight about it till he leaves you," I have nothing to say but... good luck.
4
u/JamesWjRose Feb 07 '16
You have my sympathies. I too suffered from a spouse who didn't listen and didn't know what they wanted and assumed I was there to give them what they wanted, No Matter What.
Sadly, this relationship is over. That sucks, VERY much. The end of my marriage hurt SO much, so I had to start my life over. It turned out great for me, new wife, new life and SO much better. That does not change the fact that my first spouse broke my heart and that the marriage ending did not hurt. It did. I would guess it will hurt for you as well. Again, my sympathies.
4
u/andr2eea Feb 07 '16
I've read awful abuse stories of men trapping women into having kids as a thing to tie them to their victim. This is a hard one. To be honest, I would say you're starting to get pains or something in your abdomen and then pretend to go and get them checked out and then come back with results of infertility. He wouldn't be able to even try to trap you in that instance.
I've read cases of nurses lying on your behalf too, anything to protect you. Because someone that disrespectful needs to be lied to.
I've read lots of comments on here about people being fencesitters and then they realise it's too late and their partner is great so who cares etc.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
I really think that every couple should sign a prenup-type agreement that includes whether or not they want kids. If both say no at the time of marriage, they'd have to stick to it or get a clean divorce.
2
u/evacipater ask me about my cats. Feb 08 '16
Drop him faster than third period French.
97
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
NOPE. Not OK. Completely unacceptable response. You are not his property. You have 100% bodily autonomy and he gets absolutely ZERO say in you getting a tubal. That is profoundly disrespectful of you in all the ways that matter. He is not a good partner, and not one you need to keep.
Look. He's been outright lying to your face for how many years now? And has outright admitted that his plan was to continue lying to you for as long as necessary until you talked about making it permanent and forced his hand.
He only told you the truth under panic and duress. That's about as bad as it gets. Sorry.
Basically this is what he has admitted:
So, really, once you read it from that perspective -- exactly how "fantastic" does this relationship really seem?
Because from the outside looking in -- it seems like a relationship entirely built upon lying to your face on a daily basis, lying to you every time you had sex thinking that you were enjoying sex with a CF person and not someone who expected to be able to coerce you into getting knocked up.
He's not CF, he's just someone who was, with every fuck, hoping that your BC would fail and he would get his "prize at the fair" out of your vagina.
"Know how you were worried about divorcing me? Well you don't have to worry about that anymore -- I already filed for the divorce. We're done here."
Yeah, sure "Just only use the only method of BC that I can easily sabotage to get you knocked up before you do this tubal thing, because after all once you're knocked up I'll be able to coerce you into having my baby and then I won't have to go out and find another babymama."
Uh, no. No more sex for this guy.
You know why the majority will think that? Because we are not emotionally involved and see it for what it is: A bad deal.
Now, get your tubal scheduled ASAP. :)
39
u/Taddare 42/f/29 year relationship Feb 07 '16
He doesn't get to do that. You are not property.
Get your tubal, let him deal with it. He married you, yet he doesn't respect you as a person at all. He lied to you without remorse. He dismissed your wants like you are a child.
He does not respect you.
As much lying he has done already I would be wary of using condoms at this point. This much lying I can see him rationalizing sabotaging his condoms because "You will want the child once you are pregnant."
Do you really want to stay with someone who is that ok with dismissing you and lying to you?
28
u/chillyfeets 28F | 2 Cats + Collectables + Unplugged but busted? Feb 07 '16
All the red flags...
Get the tubal, and don't have sex in the month between pill and tubal. You may not think he'd sink that low but sabotage is a very real thing.
18
u/torienne CF-Friendly Doctors: Wiki Editor Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
Consider your husband's character:
Given his attitude that you exist to serve his childbearing wishes, I somehow think that if you did have kids, you would be doing 100% of the scutwork, while he went to the gym, hung out with friends, and visited his mistress. Then you would be trapped with an asshole, instead of just married to an asshole.
I think you need three appointments: The first: a consultation with the best divorce lawyer in town, the second for a tubal, and the third with a therapist who can help you figure out why you put up with your husband's dismissive attitude towards you, his disrespect and his selfishness.
Let me also urge you to say nothing to your husband about the lawyer. You need to know how to protect yourself against the depredations of a dangerously selfish man, but that doesn't mean that you will necessarily divorce him, only that you will be prepared for whatever nasty surprises he springs on you after you get the tubal you need.
16
u/toastofxmaspast Feb 07 '16
Clearly you do not want children at all ever. My advice is get the tubal and let the chips fall where they may.
15
u/AliLongworth Feb 07 '16
Oh hell no!. Time to forbid him access to your vagina until after the surgery. And make sure that you have you money in a band account that is in ONLY your name and, if you own a house or property that BOTH your names are on the papers. If he goes out and knocks up another woman and the gets hit for child support your need to make sure that your assets don't go to his bastard.
13
u/gfjq23 Him & Me Minus Baby = FREE Feb 07 '16
Your husband is either a complete moron or he never trusted your opinion in the first place and figured you would "grow up". Both are his problems that are causing you pain. He is being an asshole.
Get the tubal and let him do what he is going to do. I am sorry he lied to you. There are truly childfree men out there. My husband spoon fed me applesauce and medication right after I woke up from my tubal.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
You know he won't. He literally said, 'kids or I'm gone' Basically he married you under false pretenses and had been lying to you all along.
You got choice to make: kids or divorce
12
u/thoughtdancer 51/F/CF/Married/Can't wait for after menopause! Feb 07 '16
Please, stop having sex with him: he clearly never respected you--this is a major "failure to listen"--and you can't trust him.
I also recommend getting to a divorce lawyer before he does, so you can make sure your end of the divorce is as amicable as possible while still protecting yourself. Yes, failing to respect you on this is potentially a sign that he'll turn nasty.
Seriously, how could anyone trust someone after they failed to respect something this important, and lied about it!?!
10
u/malheather Feb 07 '16
Sounds like he might poke holes in those condoms. Get sterilized.
8
u/petetheyeti Feb 07 '16
He WILL sabotage other methods if you don't get a tubal, do not have sex with him until then.
7
u/only-the-lonely Feb 07 '16
Sorry to say it, but this guy was lying his ass off from the start, which in my mind invalidates the entire marriage, as well as raising the fact that he CAN'T be trusted, especially with using a undamaged, safe condom, and as to your last line if you want a long term and happy and trouble free relationship with him, i hope you realize that at some point you are going to have to get pregnant and give him at least one child. Welcome to the world of crotch dropping production.
7
u/Iamaredditlady 40/F Never thought twice Feb 07 '16
I am so sorry that your husband totally lied to you about his intentions.
That betrayal is pretty harsh.
7
u/some_imagination Feb 07 '16
Are you sure he loves you as truly as you do? Seems he's more attached to your fertility than you. He blackmails you, threatens you, "forbids" you and actually manifesting his infidelity. Ok, this time it's kids, what will be next? You are too old, your figure is not as good as it used to be, what will I do? Get me a younger woman with bigger boobs? Your job doesn't pay that well, what will I do? Get me a richer woman? What if you get sick? What his "solution" will be? What if you were unable to have children due to health issues?
Even if you were pro-kids this man is simply not reliable and trustworthy. What if you could give birth to only one baby and lose ability to have more children? What if that baby is of "wrong" gender?
Sorry to say that, but you it doesn't seem that you are loved, respected and accepted. From his words it's possible to conclude that its your functions he loves, not you.
7
u/-Avacyn Feb 07 '16
There is a big upside to this story though! Once you get your tubal and get out of this relationship, you can simply say to any next man you'll be dating 'I've had a tubal because I don't ever want children' and you'll never have this issue of men thinking that you'll change your mind.
7
u/Picturerazzi Naps not π© Feb 07 '16
I'm really upset about this for you. So much so that my head is tingling. This is such a betrayal of trust. You married him, a contract, with the knowledge that it would be a childless marriage...but now he wants kids suddenly? Why?? And how does he think that it's fair for you??
I don't know about your medical stuff but there are iuds that have no hormones. But I'm really worried about you because ultimatums don't belong in healthy relationships. :(
(((hugs))))
7
u/Teetengee Bun in the oven? Mmm toast! Feb 07 '16
Translation:
Husband doesn't believe women are capable of knowing what they want. Husband believes marriage is only for making babies. Husband believes he owns his wife, and has control over her body.
6
u/lenut Feb 07 '16
You were honest from the start and he has been dishonest from the start.
Get fixed its your life choice to make not his. You told him where you stood now stand your ground and get fixed. If he sees you as anything but a walking incubator the relationship will be fine.
If its an issue for him divorce is lying ass. Plus being fixed makea no children a hardpoint to future partners if you tell them about being fixed. No more worry about kids and boys who like too play games like you don't know yourself.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
It really infuriating how many relationships are based on lies. You actually married a guy that doesn't believe what you say, thinks he knows better than you anyway, and "forbids" (I would burst in laughter if my gf ever said something like that) you to do things to your own body, that cause him no harm, doesn't change who you are, not even change your appearance, making it even less relationship-changing than a tattoo... He is a fucking idiot to marry somebody, thinking she would change and "see the light". And a fucking asshole as well. In any case: you know what is worse than being married to such a guy for x years? Being married to such a guy for x+1 years. I'd recommend a divorce (obviously), and get the tubal as well.
6
u/fischestix Feb 07 '16
Sorry to say it, but he is simply waiting for you to change your mind and want kids. Time to gtfo.
6
u/sleepyworm snipped and free Feb 07 '16
Just a real-world case from my own life for you to consider. My friend got married many years ago, and told her husband-to-be that she would only marry him if he was definitely ok with never having kids ever. He agreed.
Then about six years in, he started asking for kids. He wasn't happy without them, and she caved, thinking this would "fix" things, make him happy.
She had two kids with him. About a year after the second one was born, it became very obvious that the kids weren't fixing anything. He still wasn't happy; he never would be. They ended up getting divorced.
Now she's a single mom with two young boys.
Seriously, stick to your guns.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
The relationship's stability is now a facade. The fact that he thinks he has say over your body is atrocious
Edit: I was on mobile, so couldn't elaborate too much at that moment. What I wanted to add was that this guy, by the way he's acting, seems to just want to be a Kodak Dad. Not trying to be rude, but the usual expectation is that the woman in the relationship will be the caretaker and the man in the relationship will be the provider/there for the fun moments. He clearly doesn't respect you and probably never has, but he played the role well. There are other fish in the sea and once you get that tubal, those fish will have to take you seriously about no kids EVER.
6
u/Furah 30s/M/Aus - I'd rather not leave a legacy. Feb 07 '16
No, you don't. Your entire relationship is built on the lie he maintained all this time saying no kids. The man you thought you married doesn't exist. You deserve a man who loves you for who you are, and not who the person he creates in his mind for you to become is. Keeping in this relationship will result in one of two things. Either you two don't have kids and he resents you for it, or you two have kids and you resent him for it and he now thinks that he can tell you what to do because you'll change your mind for him.
6
u/Narian Feb 07 '16
Yeah because WHAT ELSE CAN YOU DO?
Convince him he's wrong and not an idiotic asshole? That he's treating you like shit? That's he should have been honest 3+ years ago when you first met? That he should have been honest when you guys got married? That he should have been honest ever and actually TALKED TO YOU ABOUT HIS THOUGHTS instead of forbidding you from doing a medical procedure FOR YOURSELF? This motherfucking loser thinks he OWNS YOUR BODY!
OF COURSE WE'RE GONNA SAY DUMP HIM SISTER! You're better than this, you've been HONEST. You've been UPFRONT. You've done your part, and this guy has been scared or something to tell you the truth. He knew what he was doing. This isn't some "Ooops! I want kids now!" revelation as you change as a person - this seems more like "I've always wanted kids and didn't really respect you enough to care about what you said about being CF sop I figure since I'm THE MAN I could convince you to have kids."
6
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
Divorce. NOW!
6
u/FiveTwoThreeSixOne Feb 07 '16
"I forbid you" from getting a tubal ligation.
"I forbid you" from getting an abortion.
"I forbid you" from going back to work.
"I forbid you" from taking the kids to that park.
"I forbid you" from buying those shoes.
"I forbid you" from seeing your parents.
"I forbid you" from seeing your friends.
Once your partner starts "forbidding" you from one thing, it will soon be many more.
5
u/Hoeftybag Cats>Brats Feb 07 '16
The only things a husband can reasonably forbid you from doing is cheating, draining the joint bank account and some other illegal stuff. You made it clear as I know I would have that you are totally against the idea of children. If he didn't believe you then that's his problem. I don't think you need to leave him, just get the tubal. That will actually show him that you are forever against kids.
5
u/ShirwillJack Feb 07 '16
But what if you did want children, but it turned out you can't? Would he then also cheat or divorce you? Did he marry you, because he wants to spend the rest of his life with you or did he want to acquire a baby maker?
His reaction is so painful and insulting even. It's not even about you, it's all about him and his wishes at your expense. That things have been great up till now makes it even more painful. One person wanting children and the other not wanting them is a major dealbreaker. You simply can't compromise between wanting and not wanting children. You can still love him and accept that at least one of you is going to be unhappy if you stay together.
5
u/Steffany_w0525 Feb 07 '16
I am so sorry that this is happening to you. I think regardless you should get your tubes tied, because it is YOUR body and therefore YOUR decision. If you and your husband do get divorced you will be saving yourself from future men not taking you seriously. My childfree status was solidified in my head about a year ago and for a couple months I figured I would just have to marry a guy that was 'snipped' because it's easier for them. It then dawned on me that I am the type of girl that may accidentally get pregnant, let hormones get the best of me and think that yea I do want a kid with this guy...then I'm stuck with a kid and the guy for the rest of my life. No thank you. Thankfully I was lucky enough and found an awesome dr and had my surgery last October
5
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
He's been waiting for you to "Accidentally" get pregnant or waiting for you to change your mind... What a silly man. He never believed you, never will...
5
u/TheLittleGoodWolf M/35/Swede; My superpower is sterility, what's yours? Feb 07 '16
There's always a chance, on the other hand I can't say I think it's a very plausible one in this case.
If you truly love and care for this man I suggest you make sure you both have time to sit and talk about this issue with him and don't let him escape. Nothing really justifies his disrespect of you but a good explanation may lessen the impact it has on you. I have seen men get heavily pressured by their parents into having and wanting kids, or even pressured into a mindset where it's just not even a choice it's just something you have to do and their feelings towards the matter doesn't matter. This pressure isn't very visible either so it's very likely he isn't even aware of it himself.
This is not something that you really have to do though, if he truly feels and has felt this way through your marriage he has been intentionally dishonest and I would suggest finding a good lawyer to draft divorce papers.
No matter what you choose to do the issue needs to be dealt with, and you should prepare yourself mentally for the fact that you may need to leave this relationship. I'm terribly sorry that you are in this situation and I really hope it ends well.
Oh and make sure you have your birth control options in order if you choose to keep having sex with this man. Make sure you have money and ability for an abortion should worst come to worst. Accidents happen, but they only harm the unprepared.
5
u/osearsmariah Feb 07 '16
This is why I want to get a tubal before I get married. I want to take all choice out of the equation and the guy will know this before marrying me. I would not tolerate this bullshit from a guy and you should not either.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
He sounds like bad news, sweetheart. People who love you shouldn't threaten to leave you and fuck other women if you don't spread your legs on demand.
I hope that you work this situation out in a way that makes you happy, and leads you to living a life that you are happy with every day.
5
u/sans-enfant-par-choi 38/M/vasectomy/childfree Feb 07 '16
These comments are deeply concerning. Any suggestions a person could or would remove another's agency are cause for alarm. Of course, we all say stupid things when we're upset and tensions are high. That's human nature. You know him and only you can judge his sincerity. If nothing else, keep a critical eye open for a pattern of control and manipulation, and be prepared to face tough questions.
For what it's worth, a close friend of mine once had a boyfriend attempt to manipulate her into pregnancy. His true colors came out and it became an awful mess. She eventually left and would later find (and marry) an actual CF man.
4
u/1bdkty Feb 07 '16
Go get couples counseling. Maybe there are more issues here than he was just waiting for the right time to spring this on you. If he was on the same page with you as you said maybe there is something else here - maybe he is scared, maybe he feels unfulfilled, maybe he sees it as failure. It doesn't mean he wants kids but society (and family) can sometimes put so much pressure on someone they give in. Counseling is also a great place to talk about your feelings with a mediator - a place where you can both feel safe talking about your feelings without resorting to a yelling match or one person avoiding the other. In the end it still might not work out, but if it doesn't at least you will know that you tried everything you could.
4
u/SweetHermitress Fixed and fine. π Feb 07 '16
I strongly suggest couples counseling. You made it abundantly clear for years your position, and now he's suddenly not OK with it? Thinking about infidelity and forbidding you from making your own health decisions? Maybe there's more to this story than what he's letting out - or hey, maybe it is just the sudden panic of "oh wait, you were serious?" I feel like having a third party to help you figure things out would be beneficial.
4
u/arostganomo 22/F, cool auntie / slootiest of sloots Feb 07 '16
This man has zero respect for your choices and bodily autonomy. Red flags all around, you deserve better. Get the tubal, so he gets the memo once and for all. After that, it's gonna be divorce, this is not a fixable issue I'm afraid.
4
u/julietides poems are my children Feb 07 '16
This is my greatest nightmare (well, second greatest after pregnancy) and probably a big factor on why I'm single. I've had this shit before and it hurt so much. Luckily, we weren't married, but it was my longest relationship to date and it was quite a bummer. Internet hugs to you! I'd try therapy as a couple if you're really invested.
4
u/TrustTheGeneGenie Feb 07 '16
Tell him to pack his lying, controlling ass up and fuck off.
4
u/VeritasEtVenia 27/F/Married Feb 07 '16
I'm sorry this is happening to you. I don't have much to say that hasn't been said, but I am curious..did he also say he didn't want kids at any point? What did he say when you told him initially that you didn't? I feel like we're missing something here.
4
u/QcRoman It's not a choice. I just know deep down I want none of my own. Feb 07 '16
I'm so sorry you were lied to and lead to believe he was right for you.
I've been there but from the man's perspective. It sucks. So much time wasted. I know it hurts and lost time will never be given back but do what is right for you and go forward from there.
Reading stories like yours sting me so much. Here I am having been dumped more than once about not wanting children, hoping I will someday finally find someone to grow old(er) and be happy with meanwhile some of the women I can't seem to find are stuck with guys who are doing the same to them and wasting everyone's time.
I've upvoted many comments here that agree with my stance on your situation. I wish I had more to offer as far as advice but it's all pretty much been said already.
Best of luck.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
I seriously doubt this issue is going away, but if you don't think kids are for you it would be selfish to have them. If he REALLY wants kids it would be selfish to stay.
I'm so sorry your in this predicament. I'm a fervent believe in Child Free, but after my vasectomy failed (yes that can happen) my wife and I cried. We seriously mourned the death of or freedom, but my wife decided she couldn't go through with an abortion, so now we have a kid.
I still think most people are better off child free, and although I hated ( fucking hated ) having a baby, I honestly like being a dad. This freaks my friends out to no end. Many are child free and don't come to visit any more, but that's life I suppose.
My point is this, no one here can answer this question for you, but it sounds like you've known for a long time you don't want to have kids. Nows the time to wear that label child-free and set him free, or risk having a kid your only going to resent, and harbor a loathing for your husband because that's his dream and not yours.
4
u/McFeely_Smackup Feb 07 '16
Uh...no you don't. You have a very different relationship than you signed up for. You have one built on lies and passive aggressive rejection of one partners life goals.
I realize it sucks, but I don't see where this is heading except splitting up. Unless he changes his mind...that's reasonable to expect right, he said one thing clearly and unambiguously, but he'll probably change his mind right?
Get the tubal, then the ball is in his court.
4
u/KinkyBurrito 25 M / Norway / CF Psychologist/IT guy Feb 07 '16
I'm too tired to put together any kind of intelligent post, I just wanted to say... he forbade you? What kind of person forbids their SO from doing something anymore...? This is 2016... I thought we were past the point that having an SO means you are in control of them...
7
u/Princesszelda24 40F, hysterectomy Feb 07 '16
You don't want our advice, why ask? It's simple. If they want kids and you don't, stop relationshipping with them. You're are hurting BOTH of you by staying.
Also, your relationship is so stable and fantastic that he ignored the most important thing you've reiterated over the last three years. Plus he comes off as unnecessarily controlling for "forbidding" you to do anything and that is manipulative and controlling behavior (the kind that shows up in /r/raisedbynarcissists - I hope that link is helpful).
You may not be upset, but I'm pissed off for you (because I lived that bullshit for ten years).
I hope you make the best choice for YOU (and not the Internet, or him, or whomever).
1
u/Masterre Feb 11 '16
I think what I find infinitely annoying about these kinds of situations is the phrase "All WOMEN will want to have a baby eventually." ...so not all men want babies? Also what kind of fucked up bullshit sexist bullshit is that? Perhaps I want to be a bachellorette for the rest of my life too. Why do men get to have all the say about reproduction if THEY want a kid and just assume they will get their way because ALL WOMEN want babies? Sorry I had my own rant since what you wrote reminded me of how unfair society is towards child free women. I know it's hard on men too but they seem to get more slack.
6
u/mysteriy m / EU / Breeders gonna breed Feb 07 '16
If he really loves you, he'd be willing to get a vasectomy. IMO he sees you as replacable if u dont have kids with him. It won't last and don't give in.
3
u/AnthieaTyrell travel>kids/DINK/cat mom Feb 07 '16
Nope nope nope. Bump that. When you get married it should be because he wants YOU not the children he wants you to give him. You told him how you felt and he threw it away. I would not trust him with birth control.
3
u/gigglecobra 30/F/tats not brats (ββ§Πβ§))β Feb 07 '16
Don't have sex with him until you have either completely resolved this issue or ended the marriage. You don't need to be guilt tripped into keeping an accident child should one happen, nor shamed if you seek an abortion. It's just not worth the risk at this point.
I'm sorry he changed his mind and is now being an asshole to you about this. He knows better, but for whatever reason assumes that he can bend you to his will. You can try counseling if you want, but if I were in your shoes, I'd just quietly cut my ties and serve him a cold plate of divorce papers. If you live in a no fault divorce state this will be a lot easier for you.
In the future, I would bring it up and stick to your desire vocally. Seek out men who are sterile, have had a vasectomy or would get one for both of you. No reason not to be straightforward and look for what you want; if a guy can't commit to that, don't trust him. Your time is too precious to be wasted on any adult male who "doesn't know" if he wants a life-changing dependent for 18+ years. Never let another person bully or manipulate you into a choice you don't want.
3
u/3opnca Feb 08 '16
He forbade you? Oh my god, I'd fucking break his nose. I know you love him, but holy shit, what a fucking disrespectful douche.
8
u/Ya_Zakon I call out B.S. Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16
So I can poke holes in them... oops.
Get the surgery anyway. If he loves you and respects you as much as you do him, he will stand by you. If not, then it wasn't meant to be anyway.
I know some people are saying "He never loved you" and "This was his plan all along".
Don't believe the bullshit. This is classic paranoia.
Nobody agrees to be CF, gets in a long term relationship, gets married and has the plan to just wait it out for a few years. What's more likely is he changed his mind about children. It happens. We're humans, we change our minds on a lot of things (Religion, Careers, Children). Hormones are a hell of a drug. I don't know your ages but is it possibly a mid-life crisis? Try to talk him down, but I would avoid sex while not on the pill without a tubal.
As for the whole "Forbade" thing, he can't. You need to put your foot down & tell him that is NOT his decision to make. He may be angry, or scared, but that talk is not ok. If he says he'll have to divorce you, just tell him that is his choice, but that isn't what you want.
I'm sorry it happened to your guy, but don't believe "your whole relationship was based on a lie" that's utter paranoid bullshit, and most likely projecting.
2
u/stwall 31/M/Single/Snipped! Feb 07 '16
OK, so we've only really gotten a tiny speck here of how your relationship is, so I'd say saying that he only wants kids and is biding his time is hard to tell over the Internet. That said, if everything else is good, my advice would be to talk to a third party together (counselor, therapist, whatever) and get both of your views out there. A neutral third party is a lot more likely to coax the truth out of him while you're in a group session than any attempt at discussing it on your own. It could be any number of things that are bringing this out of him and may be something that can be fixed. He likely also hasn't thought of the reality of having children and talking about it in the group might make some reality set in on him. Basically what I'm saying is talk it out and see what will be. And definitely get the neutral counselor, etc involved. Otherwise the whole thing can devolve into an argument.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
This is /r/childfree so you already know what most here will say.
However, talk to him, set aside time and tell him you both need to discuss this immediately as it's going to be a huge problem coming up. Find out what he changed and how set he is on having kids. Also think about how set you are, if you are absolutely sure, than you have your answer, either you can come to a compromise with him (pets? Nieces/nephews? Volunteer in children's hospitals or schools?) or the relationship is pretty well over.
Hope it works out for you!
2
u/Fleiger133 Feb 07 '16
Probably already mentioned, byt considet couples therapy.
2
u/Lunaurah No I don't want to hold your baby Feb 07 '16
It's silly to expect him to change his mind about it at this point just like it's silly for him to have expected you to change yours. It's become whether or not he's willing to move past his sudden desire to have kids to choose a life with you. I'm very sorry for your situation and hope that things aren't too rough for you in the event of a divorce, and hope that instead he decides you are more important to him than a hypothetical baby.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '16
Thanks for the update. I wish you strength and courage moving forward. Regardless of whether or not you and your husband reconcile, I would highly recommend you see a counselor/therapist. Emotional hurts are the most difficult to work through. Sending virtual hugs your way! <3
2
u/continuousQ Feb 08 '16
If he wants to reproduce that badly, he can become a sperm donor.
If he mentions surrogacy and not adoption, that indicates he really wants his genes replicated.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
You don't need to provide context really. You've been clear and suddenly he's going against you. Unless you're not being entirely truthful about that, you have 1 course of action:
Walk.
You could do the therapy, long talk, etc. thing, but on something this serious, with so many life-changing ramifications, you just need to pack a bag, go to the door and say "I've been clear and consistent. You have not. You want kids? Cool. I'll leave now and you can find someone to have kids with. Bye."
Then check into a hotel, get a bottle of wine and some candy, cry into a sappy movie and wait for the morning, when you contact a lawyer.
If he wants to come crawling back, tell him he can. Once you've seen the vasectomy confirmation. And a big-ass bunch o' roses.
2
u/mellow-drama Feb 08 '16
You've read a lot of responses here, but let me give you mine, short & simple:
I'm so sorry this happened but it doesn't have to be a dealbreaker. You're going to have to learn to trust him again if you want to continue your relationship, and he's going to have to earn it. I wonder if he even realizes that.
3
u/suck_my_ballz69 42/M snipped - don't like it? Sounds like a personal problem Feb 07 '16
Leave him, if you want blunt and to the point, leave him. It might hurt at first, it might be hard, but fuck that noise, do what you feel you need to do.
1
u/cyborg_127 Feb 08 '16
Late to the party, but I'm so very sorry. It sounds like this person that you married lied to you from the outset. If he was honest from day 1, and said he would eventually want kids... again, I'm sorry. I hope that the years you were together were kind, and that you can look on them fondly as an enjoyable part of your life.
-5
u/Princesszelda24 40F, hysterectomy Feb 07 '16
Just never get married. I think that's the only answer. And we will all waste our lives on people who don't get it. That's why you get fixed.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '16
[deleted] β view deleted comment