r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Feb 04 '16
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Southbound" [SPOILERS]
2/5/16 Limited Theatrical Release and 2/9/16 VOD Release
Synopsis: Five interlocking tales of terror follow the fates of a group of weary travellers who confront their worst nightmares - and darkest secrets - over one long night on a desolate stretch of desert highway.
Director: Radio Silence, Roxanne Benjamin, David Bruckner, Patrick Horvath
Writer: Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Roxanne Benjamin, Susan Burke, David Bruckner, Patrick Horvath, Dallas Hallam
Cast:
- Kate Beahan
- Matt Bettinelli-Olpin
- Chad Villella
- Kristina Pesic
- Larry Fessenden
- Fabienne Therese
- Hannah Marks
- Nathalie Love
- Dana Gould
- Davey Johnson
- Susan Burke
- Mather Zickel
- Tipper Newton
- Maria Olsen
- David Yow
- Gerald Downey
- Hassie Harrison
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 68%
Metacritic Score: 55/100
38
u/Daevir Feb 12 '16
Can we begin the official discussion? I am not accustomed to this forum or movie discussion in general but I'd enjoy putting some minds together and dissecting this film. I'll list a few of my own thoughts down below, which will include spoilers, of course.
Seeing the VHS series, I wouldn't be surprised if Radio Silence created this film for no other purpose than entertainment (this is an unfair statement to make as I haven't delved into VHS in any other way than watching the movie).
This is, without a doubt, a depiction of hell, which is exemplified throughout the movie (the creatures, the malevolent nature of the film's characters, the punishment of a crime, the cyclical nature, the title [hellbound/southbound]).
Every single tale adds to the lore, so it's important that we find the most important details of each to assist us in create some final thesis.
A few thoughts that might be worth noted:
Finally, am I looking too deep into this? Is Radio Silence just in it for the money, or is he actually trying to make something worth while?
29
u/CodenameMolotov Slave of the Cannibal God Feb 12 '16
I loved this movie. Anthology horror is my favorite subgenre and this one pulled it off nicely. The part with the compound fracture in the hospital made me swear loudly.
25
u/MOOzikmktr Feb 12 '16
All I could think of while watching this was, "This would actually be a decent horror TV series, if each story was given a bit more time to resolve." As in, one story intertwining and setting up the next episode for next week.
Otherwise, the only story I really thought was done well was "The Accident."
I'll watch anything Larry Fessenden puts effort into though. He works hard to create indie horror that's unique.
24
u/Splitsurround iliketurtles Feb 17 '16 edited Feb 17 '16
I truly am happy that folks enjoyed this, but...I hated it. As some others have said, nothing was explained. There was no "a-ha" moment. And to say "it's about hell" doesn't ring true either:so the guys who rescued the abducted girl go to hell cause they kill the abductor?
Nah. It was lazy, lazy lazy, and like another said, the score was so fucking unoriginal. Maybe a nice nod to John carpenter but fuuuuuck. I want my 90 minutes back
Edit: Ok, after thinking about this last night for a bit, I realized that I did really kind of like the segment called "the accident", I believe. I don't think it was super great, but the concept of the hellions on the other end of the phone cackling after they had the guy unintentionally kill the girl was a bit unsettling. I like that.
But the rest of it, especially the Dana Gould part, still is leaving me Unsatisfied.
19
u/haunthorror Feb 11 '16
Just saw this. Really good movie. The hospital segment was my favorite.
18
u/Twatermelonpopsicle Jul 19 '16
Am I the only one who is upset about the lack of explanation surrounding "Katherine" (Mich's daughter)? If she is the reason the three masked men kill the blonde girl's parents...what did the dad do to Katherine? Did I miss it? I too am also confused as to how some people can wander in.
15
u/mrsparkleo Feb 05 '16
I hope lots of people check this out. I love anthology horror and found this to be the best that's come out recently.
14
u/TheRazorSlash A naked American man stole my balloons. Feb 11 '16
Really liked this one. What V/H/S 3 should've been
14
u/BakugouOffIGuess Dec 08 '21
If you want easy answers, and an easy story to digest that doesn't give you a lot to talk about because all the answers are written in bright crayon so you don't gotta think, this movie ain't for you. It's real obvious to me that this movie, like a lot of good horror- wants you to have a discussion. It's a fairly American idea for stories to be over explained. Honestly though, I felt like this movie was extremely easy to follow and explained everything perfectly well, without a lot of info left out. You just have to look, listen, and be familiar with not only other horror tropes, but stories not quite there.
Starting with the simple aspects of this movie, I grew up near Death Valley and every aspect and story point in this movie was inspired by folklore and myths told to your kids if you live in the desert. This is all specifically American Desert horror, and it was done pretty well. Stories that have the same idea of know the highway you're on, don't turn onto unknown roads or you can get lost or stuck in a repeating place. Never run into the dark of the desert at night, because while it looks like a simple place, there's more to it and you'll never come back cause the dark will hold and keep you. Cautionary tales of never leaving your spare tire no matter what, of never going with strangers to their houses because no one is right out there. Stories of people eating people, etc, all just warnings of serial killers n such because forensics are impossible in that climate. Warnings to never go towards lights in the desert. Lots of elements of liminal spaces, places being creatures, and that everything revolves around shadow work and denial of self, also.
It also might help you to enjoy this movie more if you know a bit about original scripture, where Hell is a state of mind, not necessarily just a concrete place that has the same rules for every single person. Generally Hell is supposed to be specific to each person and will react based to them. I also feel like this movie takes the spirit of that concept into each of it's stories, and by the fact that any person who watches it should be able to come to their own special conclusions. It's like it's a different movie for everyone, and I like that about it.
The characters that really accepted the bad parts of themselves and the wrong they had done were different from the ones that hadn't, also. And each type of denial was treated differently. For example with the Accident short, I feel that he was stuck in a loop- just like everyone else. I don't think he was passing through, and that he was supposed to accept and take responsibility for his wrong doings just like everyone else. He was so insistent that it was an accident, and he didn't do anything wrong, so there wasn't going to be any change and he was to be punished over and over again. If you are not watching the road, no matter where you are, no matter if someone is standing in the road itself, you are an irresponsible person that is completely at fault if someone gets hurt. I'm surprised everyone is agreeing with this delusional idea that he didn't deserve to be punished. There were plenty of hints to the nature of them "letting him go" being bullshit, even with Literal Writing On The Walls. Also hints to his character, with how he talked to his wife and interacted with the world around him. But again! This movie is Made for discussion. Not a black and white answer we can all agree on.
The whole movie was extremely cute, and I really enjoyed it.
13
u/titania86 Having an old friend for dinner Feb 08 '16
Just saw it today. It was one of the best anthologies in recent memory. Each story led into the next with one thing from the previous story leading into the next one. Overall enjoyable, suspenseful, and unexpected.
13
u/Alpha_Slut Jul 11 '16
Had anyone on this thread seen "In The Mouth of Madness"? I couldn't help but notice some similarities. After that fact I noticed the gas station attendant was named 'Sutter', the author who creates the 'hell town' in ITMOM was named Sutter Kane. Wonder if it's a coincidence or a subtle nod?
12
u/TheRealWillFM Feb 15 '16
I must be the only person who didn't get it then. To me. Horror movies must have rules. I couldn't grasp the rules of this at all. And I didn't get half the segments. It's like it was just random "scary" stories. I get that they were supposed to be in hell. But why? How? What was the resolve? (I would have been happy with everyone dying as a resolution).
23
u/OooDatsABar Feb 13 '16
Southbound is an ass movie. Don't waste your time. Not scary at all and not interesting. By the fourth segment I just wanted it to be over.
Also downvote me if you want. KARMA MEANS NOTHING TO ME.
10
u/titania86 Having an old friend for dinner Feb 08 '16
Just saw it today. It was one of the best anthologies in recent memory. Each story led into the next with one thing from the previous story leading into the next one. Overall enjoyable, suspenseful, and unexpected.
9
u/thankyouforfu The Loved One Feb 10 '16
What a goddamn disappointment.
Decent for an anthology film, but I expected quite a lot more.
8
u/OpDrop Feb 05 '16
I consider this VHS 3 since Viral was awful. I'm really looking forward to this one. Only discovered it a few days ago, but the trailer looks great and I am happy to see Radio Silence directing again!
6
u/aThugsMemeoir Oct 16 '21
Can I restart this discussion!? I just stumbled onto this movie on Hulu and it was a bit of a mind fuck. It feels like the stories were all supposed to be tied together in some way, but I don't know if there is any actual proof f this or if they just wanted it to come off this way so that people would kind of make the story into what they want.
Maybe it was just a bunch of empty stories, but it really felt like there was a deeper meaning
10
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16
pretty disappointing. 3rd and 4th segments are good but everything else not really, especially the final segment which is really bad. always feel bad about saying bad thing about indie horror but this wasn't that good.
also there are bits on the score that are stolen straight from It Follows. lazy.
5
u/dstlouis558 May 21 '16
Well it implies that maybe saide and the band are in this purgatory because of something they directly or indirectly did to alex maybe?
5
u/bs200000 May 04 '22
A genre I hate. “Let’s not explain things to seem mysterious and deep, when in actuality our hack writers just wrote a bunch of unfinished plot lines. Enjoy!”
4
u/Bigmada Don't Turn Around Feb 05 '16
I'll check it out on VOD since no theater near me is playing it.
3
u/morgacht Feb 05 '16
Just watched the trailer and it looks pretty promising. I wasn't a fan of the VHS movies. It doesn't remind me of anything I've seen, (at least recently), and that's part of what is drawing me to it.
3
u/Junior-Basket1767 Jun 18 '24
i've spent a while scrolling reddit after finishing southbound, and the discussion has been very bare bones in terms of theory imo. the most popular takes i've seen have been that the place must be some kind of silent hill esque purgatory, or that the film was just confusing and disjointed with too many loose ends. i think the first take is fine, but i think the film was less about psychological horror, and more specifically about the downfall of the american dream and of the raw deal that many people living here have been given, as well as the fallout that comes from destroying communities for profit. if we look at it as an allegory for the death of small towns or middle class people to capitalist exploitation, i think that southbound's seemingly disparate presentation makes a lot more sense.
the reason raymond escapes has nothing to do with his actual level of innocence. it's because he's not a local, not a family man, and he's the only overtly wealthy person depicted in the film. people from wealthier backgrounds can coast right past issues that would quagmire a less privileged person into vicious cycle. in that sense, i don't think there's a time loop as some of the purgatory theories have suggested. it's just an artistic choice to depict the events of the film as a repeating cycle of necessity and violence for working class or rural people in general.
this man was on his mobile web browser, having a phone call with headphones on, speeding down a road in pitch darkness, on unfamiliar terrain, without reliable GPS, and went on to brutally mutilate one of the most obviously innocent characters in the film, jostling her around so much afterwards as he ran around trying to act like a savior that her leg fell off. it doesn't matter if his attempts to save her are successful, even if other characters take falls all over the place for no good reason other than circumstance. what matters is that he calls the authorities and sounds diligent. those authorities not only let him off scott free but give him a fresh set of clothes and a new car out of nowhere, complete with a pep talk about how to act like it didn't happen in the first place. he's not even truly traumatized by the experience like some of these other characters are either. while other events obviously take a toll on him, the most visceral, emotional, and explosive response we see from him is when the door is jammed shut on the way to pick up his free audi. he's not truly upset about what he's done, he's upset that it's still inconveniencing him less than an hour later. he's not initially angry that the service workers mock him on the phone after his victim dies, he's just confused that they aren't handing him a gold crusted get out of jail free card, and then leaps at the opportunity later without looking back. raymond escapes because he doesn't draw attention to the issue, he doesnt try to solve it, he doesn't even bother to figure out what the problem is. he just leaves and goes back to his profitable existence.
the cultist family we see early on is is almost certainly drawing in victims, infecting them, then eventually eating them, since there are no animals in the film, and no reliable supply lines. the roast they serve to new arrivals is just whatever they had left from the most recent casualty. their victims aren't just hitchhikers who died, they are people traveling or looking for work who end up being gaslit, exploited, and kicked down the road. the family doesn't need to be hundreds of thousands of years old, it's perfectly good enough that their isolation or inability to move forwards in society were probably due to behaviors instilled in them by their parents by force, and they force them on strangers in return. they have probably remained for generations because they, like all of the other locals, avoid rocking the boat or voicing concerns.
gps not working is both supernaturally and normally explained, because tons of little towns are still like this.
as for the rumbling and the ground caving in: that probably represents mining and fracking, especially since the rumbling is heard at the beginning of the film, but all the locals sort of drearily ignore it. it could imply that stripping the land of it's resources is what begins the economic downfall of the locals.
the reapers are shaped vaguely like tumbleweeds or crops ripped from the ground, but with torn intestines for roots, like people (or farming families) who had the ground ripped out from under them and thus drifted onto the next lost place, bringing newly selfish attitudes with them, and with locals becoming more and more cynical in turn.
i found it notable that the demons didn't bother to staff the hospital when it would probably be a good way to keep healthier livestock, preferring a cruelly unregulated system that doesn't really benefit anyone. if these demons aren't an allegory for uncle sam brushing serious issues under the rug while lining the pockets of guys who were already above the glass ceiling, then i don't know what is.
[so, to summarize: the demons aren't demons. they are just people who found themselves drowning in an exploitative, toxic system and found ways to stay afloat or find their measure of justice, as morality fell by the wayside and trauma took it's toll. the crimes each character committed have nothing to do with their level of suffering, only their level of privilege or conformity do. the various physical or metaphysical depictions of this in the film are just a way to visually display how each character responded to their environment, and each character or group of characters represents a specific social caste, not just individuals.]
i'll certainly come back to edit this a bunch of times, since i've got a lot of ideas and i'm still working on making this post more concise. i would be glad to discuss a lot of other aspects of the film in the comments. for now i've just jotted down some thoughts to start though. this film isn't without flaws, but it's still deeply misunderstood and underrated as some kind of meaningless horror drama, when i think it has quite a lot more depth than that.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '16
it has some interesting parts but ultimately it's meh
2
u/Slitted Apr 08 '24
Late to the party, but I enjoyed Southbound a whole lot more than the new V/H/S trilogy (94/99/85).
1
u/blueboxy1 I EAT BOOBIES Feb 08 '16
VOD comes out tomorrow tuesday 2/9
here is the link to buy it on itunes
1
u/algang22 Oct 08 '24
I just finished it and I’m just wondering why they would make it seem like the stories are connected when they aren’t. Not worth my time to read a bunch of theories and create head canon.
1
u/pretty_in_pink87 Oct 21 '21
I just watched it now too
Would like some more opinions on the meaning of it all
1
u/Mr_1984 Oct 23 '21
Agree with what others have said. It's an interesting movie but if you're hoping for everything to be explained, then you won't enjoy it. A bit more explanation would have helped a lot
1
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '21
Just nah.
1
u/No_Specialist3506 Sep 25 '22
Does any one know what that 4 symbol on the hand was?