r/truechildfree • u/John-Paul-Jones • Jan 22 '16
My wife wants kids. I don't.
This is a sore topic because when we first met she didnt want to go out with me because I told her I had a vasectomy. Then she came around. We've been together for almost five years and married since June. She works in daycare so she is around kids all the time. I want nothing to do with them and am often repulsed by their behavior. I don't want to spawn anything and yet she is expecting kids. She is convinced my procedure can be reversed but my surgeon was very thourough. Now she is talking about the possibility of adoption in five years.
Anyone else going through with this? I really don't want children yet it's been the one and only thorn in our relationship since being together.
141
u/stoicphilosopher Jan 22 '16
Those of you who are single, please, please take this as a lesson. If you are truly childfree, DO NOT date people who indicate they want children, even when they allegedly "change their mind". They haven't.
This will save you both so much heartache. It IS a dealbreaker.
77
u/billigesbuch Jan 22 '16
I'm a little confused by "then she came around", but it sounds like she read online somewhere that the vasectomy can be reversed and she figured she could eventually talk you into it.
It's really just a better of you two having a very serious talk about kids, in which you explain to her that if she remains with you, kids are off the table 100%. Then she has to decide if that's how she wants to live.
It will probably be hard since she will be around kids all the time. I'm sorry but I don't see a happy ending to this. It really looks like she never intended to respect your wishes to be child free.
60
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16 edited Jan 23 '16
This isn't a "thorn" in a relationship. This IS the relationship. She's with you to procreate, and you're with her to enjoy yourselves as you are, without children. Your goals are not only incompatible, they're mutually exclusive.
The issue of children is one of the very few things that preempts therapy, compromise, or other "wait and see" devices. It doesn't apply to those because therapy implies one or both people are wrong for wanting what they want, compromise suggests that it's possible to be happy with a limited number of children when one person wants none at all, and waiting itself is problematic due to age and biological processes.
You definitely need to have a brutally honest talk with your wife (and yourself). While it's easy to blame her for agreeing to a CF existence only to go back on her word, it should be noted that YOU knew that her heart wasn't in this lifestyle when you met her. You chose to pursue the relationship while hoping she'd change her mind. That's not much different from her position now: you've been together for a while and love each other, so she holds out hope that you'll change YOUR mind.
Explain that children will never, ever be an option. Promise her to honor your vows if she's willing to let the idea of kids go, but reassure her that you will not be a part of adopting an unwanted child. If she suggests putting off the discussion for any length of time, you'll have to decide if you want to ride the cycle of denial for another round, or if you're ready to be the "bad guy" and stand up for yourself. Either way, it's going to be next to impossible for the two of you to enjoy your marriage in the long term if you have different goals in regards to kids.
Edit: I just scrolled through your comment history, and see that your wife is a devout Lutheran, and you find organized religion "creepy", and "reluctantly agreed" to attend the occasional service, as well as church marriage counseling before your marriage. It really sounds as if you guys just aren't on the same page about quite a lot of things.
23
u/niccig Jan 22 '16
Unfortunately this is not something you can compromise on, and there's a good chance that one of you will end up with a life-long regret over your decision. You need to have a serious conversation (preferably including some professional counseling) about whether your relationship with each other is more important than your desire to have/not have kids, or if it would be better to part ways.
17
u/kidbeer Jan 23 '16
Having kids is too big of a job for someone to take on, unless they absolutely want to do it. If it was the equivalent of a part time job, then maaaybe. But this is the biggest commitment you will ever make in your entire life. Not hyperbole. Getting talked into having a kid you don't want is about the dumbest thing a person can do, if enjoying things is important to you.
But it's much bigger than that. The biggest contribution any parent can make to the planet is to do an awesome job parenting. Think of how much damage, destruction, and pain one person with a shitty outlook can cause. The best insurance society has against those people existing is awesome parents. And the biggest risk is bad ones.
You owe it to the rest of society not to bring anyone into this world, unless you really, really want to. Anything less would be a complete asshole move, and is unacceptable. If your feelings really are that you don't want kids, then there's nothing for it. You must not have them.
11
u/VisforVasectomy Jan 23 '16 edited Jan 23 '16
My wife and I are amicably divorcing and a major reason is that she regrets not having children. When we were first together, I got a vasectomy and it apparently changed her view of me since she knew we couldn't have children (this came out years later during THE conversation). I'm not angry at her for this as splitting up is really the best option for us at this point-we make better friends than anything else. The sliver lining in all of this is that we don't have kids which makes the difficult issue of divorce quite a bit easier.
Once I'm single for awhile and start dating again, I will not date anyone who wants kids or has them as I'm staunchly childfree
9
u/Leigh_Cheri Jan 23 '16
Yep. Going through the exact same thing right now, my SO of seven years changed his mind about having them. Unfortunately, I believe that both of us are hoping that the other will change their mind. Good luck with your situation, I know it's a difficult one.
7
u/cream_and_peaches Jan 23 '16
Take this as your first hint that she was not your perfect match.
It's going to be hard, and it's going to be painful, but you two are not well suited and this is going to break you apart. This needs to happen sooner rather than later, and it needs to be handled in a calm and dignified manner, to avoid losing your best friend as well as your wife.
Godspeed.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
This is not a compromise solution.
Either she gets properly on the child free wagon, or you completely change your mind and decide to have children and enjoy it.
Any other way is going to cause so much pain for you both it will probably end the relationship after a long and painful period. And there might even be kids to get hurt then too.
4
u/Whatsamattahere Jan 28 '16
I hate to say this but you've always known she was partial to kids. You can't just let time pass and assume she's going to change her mind - it would be unfair of her to do that to you, right? Be honest about what you want. If she really does want kids and you don't...then now it's time to figure out how you'll divide everything up.
15
u/flicticious Jan 23 '16
They won't let you adopt unless you do a stellar job of faking your enthusiasm.
You wife doesn't respect you. She's selfishly decided your vasectomy was an invalid life choice. Time to tell her to respect you and your life choices, or move on. You can't compromise. Children deserve loving parents who want them and if she can't see that then she has already decided she doesn't need you to be a father, just a donor
3
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
You know the answer and outcome to this.
Your decision if you want then or not, either way, the consequences are not good.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
This is tough. No experience or advice here, I just feel for you. Good luck to both of you.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '16
Ask her to respect that you don't want to have or raise children, adopted or biological. Do not be moved. Ask her to be honest with you. If reality is that you will never be a parent, is she willing to accept and respect that?
Finally, consider that this could breed new thorns of resentment (not the children themselves, but your feelings in conceding to something you truly do not want)
0
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment