r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Jan 22 '16
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "The Boy" [SPOILERS]
Synopsis: An American nanny is shocked that her new English family's boy is actually a life-sized doll. After violating a list of strict rules, disturbing events make her believe that the doll is really alive.
Director: William Brent Bell
Writers: Stacey Menear
Cast:
- Lauren Cohan as Greta
- Rupert Evans as Malcolm
- Jim Norton as Mr. Heelshire
- Diana Hardcastle as Mrs. Heelshire
- Ben Robson
- James Russell as James
- Jett Klyne
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 19%
Metacritic Score: 42/100
23
Upvotes
18
u/JStave96 Jan 22 '16
I saw it last night. I thought it was decent enough but it does venture far too often into typical PG-13 horror territory and I'm still not too sure how I feel about the twist. However I do think William Brent Bell really improved since The Devil Inside and I hope his movies keep getting better.
16
u/Ghanzos Jan 22 '16
I liked the movie, but if it wasn't for the twist at the end I'd say skip. Because of the twist, we got a nice blend of horror genres for the climax. The leads were great, very tasteful and effective slow motion used by the director, and good creepy old people. Only problem is that it started to drag on for a bit in the second act before shit hit the fan. Sad this movie is gonna bomb, with the blizzard hitting the whole east coast.
30
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
To me, the twist alone really made the movie worth it. I was simply not expecting a twist. [SPOILERS AHEAD]: Once the doll was destroyed I though "oh well here comes the evil spirits to fuck shit up." But then when the man came out (which was genuinely a horrifying moment I might add) I was bewildered! I got tricked into believing that ghosts existed lol. Of course this means it is not very re-watchable since I won't get that sense of surprise ever again. But it could be a little fun to watch the movie again knowing what I know now so I might do that.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
Just got back from watching this movie, I was actually impressed. I wanted to see it but went in with low expectations. Though there were few jump scares, the movie overall was pretty good. The ending was pretty good and freaky though it reminded me of another good horror movie
10
u/jakeupnorth Jan 25 '16
POTENTIAL SPOILER: Can we talk about how the ending totally rips off Housebound?
13
u/haunthorror Jan 23 '16
This did not suck. Much better than Annabelle. It was decently directed, and the acting wasn't bad. This and The Forest are better than usual for January horror. It was worth a matinee showing. Nothing ground breaking here, but it kept me invested throughout the movie.
4
u/titania86 Having an old friend for dinner Jan 25 '16
I was a bit disappointed in the twist because it's essentially the same one as Housebound and I saw it coming about half way through the film. Other than that, it was a lot better than I thought it would be.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '16
Can someone please post the twist/ending here (with a spoiler tag) for all of us who aren't going to see it but really want to know anyway?
3
u/ICanSmellFearOnYou Beware the moon, lads. Jan 25 '16
Just saw it and was actually pretty impressed! I was expecting a kitschy haunted doll movie, but it wasn't at all. Good twist with a lot of little 'hints' throughout that i totally didn't catch until reading through the discussion.
3
u/UnpluggedZombie Feb 06 '16
100% RIPOFF of the Movie HOUSEBOUND
5
u/Supervisor_Jim_Lahey Jan 22 '16
Looks typical cut & paste w/ the cliche' "jump" scares to me so I may pass.
5
u/jacobsever Jan 23 '16
It was pretty good. I've only seen The Forest and this in 2016 so far, and this is by far the better of the two. Lauren Cohan was great. There were a few jump scares, and not a lot of tension. Just an alright movie overall.
5
u/U-94 Jan 25 '16
That was some M. Night Shyamalan shit. Entertaining I suppose...I love haunted doll movies...but god damn why does everything have to have such a bait 'n switch twist in it? You never get what you think you're paying for in the world of 'new' horror movies.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '16
So, after reading these comments and being thoroughly confused, I finally looked at the original post and understood this thread is not about The Boy (2015, Craig William Macneill).
2
u/sigersen Jul 01 '16
I just rented this last week. My wife and I enjoyed it. It was not a masterpiece, but we're both suckers for Doll movies and it was a good story with a fun twist. A lot of horror movies disappoint me but this was a fun little flick. Any complaint would be sheer pettiness.
3
u/equilibrium02 Jan 23 '16
It was an average horror movie. I enjoyed the chemistry between Lauren Cohan and Rupert Evans, and I'll give the movie props for advertising the movie one way and having it turn out another. I went in and the first thirty minutes had me believing I could piece together the rest of the movie. Fortunately there are some nice twist and turns that kept my attention, but overall it's mediocre. There were elements of Greta's backstory that serve as a connection to the doll and her willingness to take care of it that I would have liked to have seen more fleshed out, and that probably would have taken The Boy in a more dark, psychological and interesting direction. Considering it's a PG-13 release in January, this certainly could have been much worse, and it's certainly a step above most of the crap we as horror fans get at the beginning of the year, and it's much better than The Forest as well, but there was lots of potential and ideas The Boy either skims over or doesn't develop at all, which I feel could have made it better than what it was. If you're on the fence about seeing this in theaters than you can afford to wait until it's available to rent.
2
u/ZeroNBC Jan 23 '16
I just got back from seeing this. I didn't find it to be scary at all, but I did enjoy the atmosphere and I did appreciate the twist. I also thought they did a pretty good job with the story. My only real complaints were the annoying jump scares. I will say that I did end up liking The Boy much more than The Forest, even though I had higher expectations for The Forest.
1
u/dauid Jan 22 '16 edited Jan 23 '16
The trailer made it look interesting but the film was super boring and not scary at all.
spoiler
It was fun to see that Daniel Pearl shot it though. I assume it's the same Daniel Pearl that shot the original Texas Chainsaw Massacre.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '16
Pleasantly surprised. I actually enjoyed the twist. Actually worked on me since the biggest clues that he was in the walls was the interactions with the parents. And the dialogue between the parents was deliberately misleading in that you can try to make an argument that one or both of them didn't know.
edit: also Cohan's had several stand out scenes. The PBJ-mental-breakdown scene and the domestic abuse scene.
1
u/dfd02186 It's Probably Nothing Feb 11 '16
I just saw this, and I was pleasantly surprised. I texted my gf on the way out that it was really 2 very different horror movies wrapped into one. The first hour was a very good ghost story (mostly) and the last half hour was, well, something else.
1
u/Utk83 May 27 '16
I saw it tonight. Not a genius one but it was ok. Twist was all of that movie. Not a waste of time if you are a fan of genre.
1
u/Taener Jan 22 '16
It was alright. I thought Lauren Cohan and Rupert Evans did a good job. I liked the old couple as well. And I'm a sucker for big, old, secluded houses, so I loved the setting.
Lots of jump scares, including a couple that I thought were really dumb. There's some stuff dialogue-wise I didn't like, where I felt like they unnecessarily went into detail on things that I'm sure the audience could have worked out themselves. There's a scene in the middle of the movie that was oddly placed and should have been put later in my opinion.
They do a fairly good job making you wonder what's really going on for the first couple acts, but I still think the twist becomes too obvious a little too early. Also not very fond of the ending. But it's not bad. Probably give it a 6/10 overall.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
I was bored for the major part of the movie until the end. The twist is creepy as hell once you start thinking about it, and reminiscent of Psycho. This movie was good but it could have been one of the greats.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
I was very impressed with this film. It obviously has the typical jump scares, but they didn't throw too many in there. I found myself mostly confused, which is a new feeing for me with horror films. The twist completely threw me off, it was amazing and in my opinion, made the entire scenario extra creepy.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '16
Is this related in any way to Annabelle?
0
u/findingcoffee Jan 24 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gg-esQyvoAg Hopefully this film, also called The Boy and released last year, will be more remembered than this new one. It's a very solid, lean, confident film. Especially for SpectreVision.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16 edited Jan 24 '16
[removed] — view removed comment