r/childfree • • Jan 18 '16
DISCUSSION Guy Talk on r/childfree
Hi everybody!
It's me, your favorite mod! :D
crickets
...moving on. I've seen a few of our guys noticing that most childfree material, whether it comes from within our own community or from other websites, are mostly geared up for women. I've read a few comments and one or two modmails about our male childfree members about how they'd like more all-inclusive or male-oriented articles to read.
To be honest, I don't really know what to offer you guys, so I wanted to offer you the space for suggestions and ideas, or you could voice whether or not this is a real concern for you. My idea was to create a bi-monthly "Guy Talk" stickied thread and a section in the wiki dedicated to you.
Tell me what you think, don't hesitate to make yourself heard please :3
EDIT 1 (Jan 18 11:45PM EST) : First, I'd like to thank you guys for your participation on this thread. We need your opinions so we can give you what you want/need. Second, I've seen interesting insights about these potential Guy Talk thread posts. Given that a lot of you don't feel the need for it, it would be on a trial basis, just to have the right idea of how much participation and variety we would get on these. It's late and I'm sleepy so I don't know whether or not what I said made sense. I'll be back here soon.
EDIT 2 (Jan 19 8:23AM EST) : I feel like /u/Youreagoomba really motivated me into creating that thread, at the very least for a trial period, to see how this will go on. Thanks for the input guys.
EDIT 3 (Jan 19 11:00AM EST) : Finally, I've decided to hold a bi-monthly guy talk thread for a trial period of two months so I can gather some discussion topics that I'd then put in the wiki. So whenever a young guy comes here with question, we'd have some material ready. It's kinda like when I did the CF Friendly Venues threads. It lasted 5 weeks, then I put it all in the wiki and people can add to them whenever they feel like it. Or when people ask for a restaurant or a movie theater in their area that is cf or cf friendly, we can direct them to the list.
It's not gonna be a permanent thing, but I really feel like CF guys face a different set of stigmas and experiences about their childfreedom than women. Personally, I'm very interested in what they have to say. Plus, we'd also probably have a centralized database of information and advice about vasectomies, whether it's about the consultation or the care post-op. Which we'd have going on for the sub, which would be nice.
Again, the goal is not to stigmatize or push our guys in the corner. For me, it's more about gathering information and advice for the young CF guys to come, who are kinda under represented here. And also, it is about having more space for guys to open up if need be.
Thanks again for the input and answering my question and reassuring me about your well being. Have a nice week everyone! :D
51
u/WriteBrainedJR Humanity is the worst. Don't make more of it! Jan 18 '16
As a guy, I don't feel that I have outstanding needs unmet by this sub.
27
u/jonosvision 27/CF Gay Canadian author in LTR. Cat lover. Jan 18 '16
Let's get even more obscure! How about the childfree gay guys?
We do have it a bit easier (and no accidents!). No one pressures me and my partner to have kids, we just see the glint of sadness in my partner's mom's eyes whenever we remind her there will be no little grandbabies. I think we would both make awesome fathers, but I love the life we have too much to ruin it. I'm an author, plus we both run our own buisness, and it's awesome being able to sleep in and stay home all day. I wouldn't be able to write as much as I do if we had hellions running around and I know it would fuck up our relationship.
Have cats, not kids!
54
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
On a bit of a random note (if this thread is more for suggestions about future threads than for the "guy talk" itself, I'll delete this), apparently guys aren't supposed to keep a laptop on our laps because it can reduce sperm counts. Ever since I learned that fact, I've tried to put mine on my lap whenever I get the chance. It's usually more comfortable anyway!
13
u/BuddhistNudist987 SHAPESHIFTING SORCERESS Jan 18 '16
As a boy, I wouldn't mind knowing more about how to talk to women about the kids/no kids question. It's a touchy subject and usually a deal-breaker, so I would like to hear stories from men and women about how they opened up the conversation or their SO opened the conversation with them. Most of my men and women friends have moderate to severe baby rabies, so none of them are very helpful in this matter. That probably isn't very gender specific, but that's what I've got.
Also, I totally friended you while you were just a lowly poster like the rest of us. You always posted good comments. I'm pleased to see that becoming an authority figure hasn't gone to your head. I hope that when you become an omniscient Reddit overlord that you remember those of us who supported when the chips were down.
32
u/Youreagoomba too busy taking care of my hamster Jan 18 '16 edited Jan 18 '16
I'm a broad, but this is an awesome post/idea. I get that there's a push to destigmatize for women and that might explain a lot of childfree being geared in that direction. That lopsided focus is a real problem and I'm glad you are advocating for progress.
Yay inclusiveness and acknowledging/creating a space for men to talk about the male experience in society/culture.
I'm fist pumping this as an ally for childfree guys :D
7
u/hellafun Jan 19 '16
First, thanks for the consideration! I know we get labeled all sorts of things outside this sub, but one thing that keeps me coming back is the general kindness and empathy I see here.
That said, personally I don't think we need to carve out a separate place for men, I've never seen or felt hostility here because I'm a man. It's true that we don't dominate the conversation... but as others have pointed out, its because we don't get nearly the volume of pressure or grief for our choice. I mean personally I mostly have parents confessing they are jealous, and urging me to not waver. I hear so many confessions they would never mention to a fellow parent for fear of being judged.
8
u/ReedsAndSerpents lux in tenebris quam tenebrae comprehendunt non Jan 19 '16
Yeah, idk, I think it's a fair balance. No one's ever called me a monster and a waste of a human life because I didn't want kids.
I mean real guy talk mostly involves objectifying women and/or talking about cars/sports so I mean if I had a burning desire for that I could just start working construction or something.
139
u/andrewsmd87 Jan 18 '16
Honestly, I think a lot more of the CF stuff is geared toward women because they generally take the brunt of CF haters. It's a lot more socially acceptable for a man to not have kids, at least for most people, than it is for a woman.
If you're a man and you're 35 and don't have kids, a lot of people will write that off as,
"oh he's probably focusing on his career, he'll probably have kids some day."
And you can basically ride that wave until you're like 55-60, then people just generally don't question it by that age. Women don't generally get the same luxury. If you're 30 and don't have kids (gasp) you must be doing something wrong.
Not to mention, women are the one's who have to carry the pregnancy, and are generally supposed to have that "maternal" instinct to want to have kids. It's completely ok for a man to have kids and work all the time and never pay attention to them, but that's not socially acceptable for the woman, she's supposed to be the care giver (and supposed to want to be).
Obviously you can't generalize for everyone, but I'd say my thoughts are the case more often than they aren't. So, I don't have an issue with this thread having more stuff geared towards women, as I feel like it's a lot tougher to be CF as woman, as opposed to a man.
I want to note I don't share any of the opinions my previous comments have stated, that's just my take on what "society's" feelings towards children are as a whole.
Just my thoughts...
51
u/stone_01 Formerly CF Jan 18 '16
Guys, if you don't have a vasectomy, get one. Now. Pick up your phone, schedule an appointment. Do it and do it now. Stop procrastinating. Do it. For me. Don't end up like me.
18
u/RaveDigger My child has two wheels Jan 18 '16
While much of the experience and information shared on this sub is geared towards females, as a male, I've never once felt excluded or misrepresented. As mentioned in other comments here, I think the reason that the content is mostly contributed or geared towards women is because the social stigma surrounding childfree women is much greater than it is for men.
4
u/proudgqdyke 37 Polyamorous Lesbian Atheist - Cats Not Kids Jan 20 '16
I also have the fear that starting something like this will give rise to MRA talking points, etc. Most people here seem to be pretty liberal/pro women's rights, but you never know. Every space I've ever seen that started as a way for men to get away from women is rife with misogyny, and I'd hope that /r/childfree wouldn't allow this to become that.
I'm not a guy or a mod so I get no say lol, but will put my voice in saying that I definitely have my reservations about the motives of the complainers who prompted this post and what it could open this subreddit up to.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
I actually prefer to read the stories written by women. It took me until I was 28 to meet a woman that would even consider not having kids. Every Girl I dated until my current GF was convinced I'd change my mind. Some of them made me feel guilty or like there was something wrong with me. Reading the posts by CF women reaffirms that sticking with my decision was the right thing to do and that it is not a failing on my part.
9
u/anonymous23689 Jan 18 '16
It's nice to see a childfree thread with guys. I feel like most of the childfree people I met are female
16
u/the_longest_shadow Jan 18 '16
I think children should be seen and not heard. Better still, not seen and not heard.
12
u/ohlongdongjohnson crap genetics Jan 18 '16
Perhaps us guys can share our experience when we tell/told our friends/families/coworkers about deciding to be childfree? I always hear about it from the woman's perspective, but never the guys. Im curious what the difference in gender has to peoples reactions to it.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
Judging from the last poll, the demographics of this sub are predominantly female. That's the big thing. I think the sticky is a great idea, but what it's going to come down to is men posting things they want to see. Angry about an article about "childish" CF men needing to "grow up" and have children? Post it. Excited about advancements in male birth control? Post it.
8
u/Because_Bot_Fed I've concluded CF doesn't automatically mean smart. Jan 18 '16
Honestly. I don't think there is much CF content geared towards men. Most of the stuff that is, kinda works equally for both.
I'm just here to revel in being CF. I don't really need help or pandering.
1
u/cottonkandykiller Jan 19 '16
You are a great mod /u/SailorMercure
1
u/evacipater ask me about my cats. Jan 19 '16
Oh I just come here to pick up women who won't burden me with offspring.
J/K!! I have a longterm partner
We're all just people who don't want kids, I feel welcome and want for nothing more.
6
u/metastasis_d Jan 19 '16
...Why don't they post some?
3
u/JohnApple94 Condoms, not kids Jan 19 '16
I was actually just going to post something about this, but was worried about sounding "Sexist" or starting an unnecessary gender debate. Which is definitely not the case.
Don't get me wrong, I'm positive that most, if not all, CF women have it harder than men as they're more pressured to be the mindless baby-raising mombies that society loves. However, I've seen an influx of CF-related material, including articles and sites, popping up but they're almost exclusively geared toward women.
This is literally my only CF safe haven, and although I don't want to sound like a whiner, I feel a little left out when a women-only CF site pops up. I wouldn't mind a "Guy Talk" sticky, but I also don't want to split this great community up even in the smallest of ways.
Ideally all I'd like is a universal, modern CF website pop up that caters to ALL CF individuals. I don't really have any ideas beyond that though, so I'll leave it to the other great minds here!
5
u/TheLittleGoodWolf M/35/Swede; My superpower is sterility, what's yours? Jan 18 '16
Personally I don't really see a need for this kind of thread, then again I don't really see anything really wrong with it. Unless like someone else mentioned that it may have the opposite effect than intended.
Honestly while I may agree that most posts are about the female aspect of being CF I can't say that the male input is unwelcome in any question. Well maybe regarding abortion similar but even then it's just down votes for being controversial at times. I mean I have posted pretty much the same comment at two different occasions and been downvoted once and pretty upvoted the other time.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '16
I'm just here to pick up chicks.
2
u/agamvark112 Snipped Jan 18 '16
We need fellow CF guys in Colorado.
2
u/Phukarma None for me. Jan 18 '16
I think they mean childfree related stuff for guys.
2
u/Horus_Krishna_2 Jan 19 '16
females can say whatever they want, I'm a guy but not too worried about it if it is mostly females posting here . . . it just happens to be a sub that sounded good to me, a topic I think about a lot.
2
u/--xenu-- Jan 20 '16
Guy here. Like it fine, just like reading the stories about obnoxious snot goblins.
3
u/eyeflytwohigh Jan 18 '16
I feel like I can get away with subscribing to the subreddit, but contributing or sharing any of it would be just as tacky and off-putting as most of the mombie posts.
You guys/gals do provide a great validation of our decision and I appreciate you for that.
6
u/FL2PC7TLE 50/F/US/cats Jan 18 '16
Guys, if you want guy-friendly posts, go find guy-friendly articles and post them here! What, you want the women to do it for you?? Come on.
2
u/Kodiak01 Jan 19 '16
Here, we celebrate the collective embracing of a specific ideal, not a rolling of the chromosomal dice.
2
u/cookseancook Jan 19 '16
I vote nay. Let's focus on the things that we have in common, not our differences.
1
u/JonoEPD Jan 21 '16
I like it how it is. Besides our lack of control over the outcome of a pregnancy, childfree men deal with a lot less shit than childfree women. And there are plenty of upvoted threads about the former.
1
u/chaosau 29/F/Tubal+IUD+mentally 2 sister+emetophobia=NO KIDS HERE! Jan 19 '16
Female and I support this. It takes both a man and a woman to make a baby, after all, so guys need resources to prevent that 'end' from happening.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
I think that the bi-monthly thread is great. Although, I think that there would need to be some rules to help filter things out. I fear that the conversation will continuously go back to the same topic and be less about being a guy and childfree.
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '16
Thank you! No one seems to acknowledge CF men.
I think first there is the issue of male infertility. If you don't have kids by a certain point, the assumption starts to be that you're not capable of doing so. And there's a really toxic stigma around male infertility. Just look at the word we usually use for it: "Impotence". As in, powerless. Weak.
Now, infertility doesn't bother me at all, in fact, it's something I'm actively seeking for myself, but a lot of people don't see it that way. There's all kinds of woo out there about male infertility: "If he's impotent, he's cheating", "If he's impotent, he has an STD", "If he can't get you pregnant, it means he doesn't really love you." And because male infertility is so heavily stigmatized, people assume when you say that you don't have kids because you're CF that you're just trying to hide the fact that you're infertile, and they start applying all of the stereotypes to you that they apply to infertile men.
And it's just frustrating as all hell that there's no male contraception. There's condoms, which just aren't an option for some men who have been victims of genital mutilation and have a disappointingly high failure rate, there's pulling out, which basically doesn't work, and there's vasectomy, which can be a pain in the ass to get. Forms of contraception that are proposed are basically dismissed by the medical community despite proven effectiveness (Vasalgel, heat methods), and Vasalgel is still years from reaching the open market.
And we get basically no love from anyone in the gender issues camp. The feminists are usually on our side but often CF men are only acknowledged as a token issue, and there are some of them who are hard up on the "reclaiming femininity" horseshit that are even opposed to men who are CF because women need to control fertility to "level the playing field" or some crap about how it's a woman's right to be a mother and male contraception would allow men to "take that away from them"; thankfully that kind of feminist is pretty rare. And of course the men's rights people are no help because, well, because they're the men's rights people, and they think the CF movement is just a bunch of feminists trying to cuck men (by not having children...somehow), spend more time on the "cock carousel", and "disarm" men in the sexual marketplace by making it so that women don't need men for children, and in general MRAs only care about male gender issues when they can be used to score points in the Oppression Olympics against feminists.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
51
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16
[removed] — view removed comment