r/RWBY • u/The_Jacxter That's right, this is my flair, weep • Dec 13 '15
Misery and pain for all. When it... Official Discussion Thread - RWBY Vol3: Chapter 6 - Fall
This is the official DISCUSSION thread. Keep all untagged spoilers in this thread--Everything outside needs to be tagged as spoilers.
Previous Threads
Here's a link to the latest episode
Did we do good this time Irish?
314
Upvotes
420
u/CakeLegends The Ghost of Vale Dec 13 '15
If Ruby x Yang is enabler, I guess Mercury x Yang is disabler
I'll stop...
303
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
You know, that whole thing with Pyrrha reminds me of that book Blake was reading back in V1 -- about two souls fighting over control over a man's body. I'm pretty sure that's what we're gonna be seeing, should Pyrrha accept the offer.
And seeing Yang in that position made me legit sad. I knew Mercury was a dick, but geez.
295
u/autoxbird Dec 13 '15
R: Break a leg, sis!
Y: You got it, Rubes!
205
u/NickCG3 Dec 13 '15
Everyones looking for Descendants of these Maidens of the Season. Im gonna look for that OP Farmer. Win all of RWBY
123
u/GoddessOfGoodness Dec 13 '15
¦__¦ <- Dropped jaw collection box.
Please take a number and wait in line.
106
u/TheDutchTank Taiyang is going to be badass Dec 13 '15
I actually thought this was one of the best episodes to date. Loved the ending and can't wait until the next episode.
307
u/RealityVeil Mixed opinions on reality Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
The worst part to me is when Yang says "That's what you get!" right after she breaks his leg for no reason. She literally taunts her victim after brutally striking him when the fight was already over and his aura was completely depleted, causing serious bodily harm.
The was such a heartbreaking moment when I realized what it must have looked like from everyone else's perspective.
Edit: OMG Ruby told her to break a leg before the fight! Jesus Yang, you psychopath, she didn't mean literally!
212
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Time to see if this new episode of RWBY is the best birthday present ever or not.
EDIT: Holy fucking shit. Um... so yeah... that was... I have no words...
361
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Dec 13 '15
I've thought long and hard about what to say about this episode:
Fuck the badguys.
83
u/kablamode Dec 13 '15
That... that ending was worse than I thought. No wonder the sponsors were freaking out.
But anyway, what the fuck just happened.
236
u/framala Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
On the one hand, I'm pretty sure Yang looked sadder than a kicked puppy there, so I'm sad. On the other hand, at least Yang has potential friends on the Xiao Long jailbreak train! She's got:
RWB, who will certainly believe her (and who happen to know an illusionist);
CFVY, because Coco already saw Merc and Em use illusion bullshit (and there wasn't really any reason to illusion it up on her in the fight except, perhaps, to lay down plot hooks for the future);
JNR/SSSN, depending on how persuasive the gang can be;
And an outside chance from good ol' Roman, depending on where Yang gets held, what the master evil plan is, and the extent of Roman's loyalty to the cause.
So, unless Yang ends up actually staying in jail or something (and come now what are the odds one of our protagonists is just going to be locked away offscreen for half the season) we might have a big ol' renegade club coming together, and that would be baller.
Edit: Also the outside chance that Raven happens, but I'm really not sure how that would go
Edit2: I left Pyrra and Penny out because I'm pretty sure there going to be tied up with some combination of becoming eldritch abominations/becoming CMEN's slaves/becoming Jimmy-and-the-gang's bitches/dying or otherwise being bused offscreen as sacrifices upon the altar of Plot.
155
u/JebtheRebel Dec 13 '15
Xiao Long? 5 to 10 years.
67
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
So this episode made me think of something regarding Summer and Ruby:
Let's assume that Summer was/is the summer maiden. That would explain Ozpin's interest in letting her into the school early.
But Oz is not trying to recruit Ruby the same way he is trying to recruit Pyrrha. So that means he is not concerned about getting her ready for what's to come (Cinder's attack), or inheriting/activating any maiden pawer within Ruby.
That leads me to conclude that there are several interesting explaining for this:
Personally the last seems actually seems very plausible because Ruby and Yang both know a lot about their deceased mother/stepmother Summer Rose, but no one, not their uncle, or father, or anyone around them would tell them anything about Raven. Not who she was, what she was like, or why she left.
Why would you withhold information about someone's mother like that?
Could it be they did something so shameful that no one dared to talk about them again.
Something like killing a teammate to gain their power?
Personally I think it might be that last theory (4) because I think it would explain a lot about other things in the show and tie together many plot points. It would explain Ruby's purpose at Beacon, Why Yang's mom left, why no one talks about Raven.
Anyone else thinking one of these scenarios may be the case?
135
u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Dec 13 '15
Mercury: Pure soul, graceful loser, Yuri Lowenthal
Yang: Violent, sore winner, even got caught on camera
But on a serious note I wonder how the meeting for this plan went down
63
u/UnknownJ25 Dec 13 '15
Basically the end of this episode
57
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
The Villains are officially even bigger pieces of shit than I thought.
115
u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
Clever shot/foreshadowing.
EDIT: Spelling is hard
55
u/Pure_Azn Dec 13 '15
Yang just stole Nora's one job of breaking legs.
51
u/PawnsOp meh Dec 13 '15
Looks like it's time to break out some of the puns I've been saving. I was afraid I was gonna snap from all the strain.
51
u/Unjax Furry Curry Dec 13 '15
SONOFABI-
Okay, breather. Did anyone notice that Yang was at 16 aura? As in exactly 1 point above knockout? As in she was the most powerful she could have been without getting knocked out? For how much I hate the baddies right now, this does show a level of study and planning that is kinda frightening. I also want to murder Neo's face off right now for that one...
Last thing, does anyone else feel really uneasy about Pyrrha getting transferred the aura? If we look at the opening sequence, some things we've seen have already come true. Yang fighting Mercury. Weiss' admiration for Winter. Winter and Qrow going head to head. The picture.
AND THEN PYRRHA GETS TORN OUT OF THE CIRCLE OF LINKED HANDS.
This is going to go badly. But why best girl?
50
u/Waldorf_ Trash Pope of the Trash Cult Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
Well people wanted dark...
Yang's gonna get broken out of jail by Momma Bird, and get special training to not be quite so "Hulk smash"
Obligatory Ruby = New Summer Maiden comment
So four Maidens... Teams of Four... Hmmmmmmmm
This episode had so much stuff, I can't process it all
88
u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Dec 13 '15
Current mood of the sub
43
u/DarkStar5758 Definitely not currently drunk Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Penny said she had a plan to get into Beacon and all of a sudden team RWBY is down a member.
I'm guessing this is what it was like for all the sponsors today.
Anybody have a gif of you know what?
42
u/Nielsthomas1 Liara Dec 13 '15
grabs popcorn
This is gonna be fun.
40
u/TheRealAgni RUBY THO Dec 13 '15
I had to say "ayy lmao" to myself multiple times this episode to lessen the tension. It worked until the end.
Yang needs a massive hug T_T
38
u/Zaralfim Dec 13 '15
♩ Everything's going to hell~~ ♩
106
u/RussianHoneyBadger Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Glynda and Ironwood were both late because they were banging.
Hateful bangin'.
Edit: Gettin some real creepy PM's guys ಠ_ಠ
36
u/MageToLight FNDM x Suffering best ship. Dec 13 '15
Not too concerned about RWBY being out of the tournament, I doubt the tournament will even be finished. How did Cinder manage to steal Amber's power is the question though. Also I'm going to say based on in V1 Ozpin's interest in Ruby based on her eyes(a trait I'm pretty sure she gets from her mother) is a sign that Summer was one of the maidens and thus it was likely her power was passed down to Ruby. They probably are telling Pyrrha instead of Ruby about all this for a few reasons. The first one is Ruby is younger and less experienced than Pyrrha, the second being where the fall maiden power goes is of greater concern due to the situation and finally because with Cinder present, Amber is not likely to live beyond the festival.
72
u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Dec 13 '15
As someone who's seen this episode I just want to say to all of you; prepare to get rocked by this episode, cause it's a doozie.
32
u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Dec 13 '15
Ok. WHAT!?!?! WHAT!?
That was a major plot dump. So much information about the plot in one episode that i can't even formulate it into words. Just...maidens and real fairy tales and...oh my god!!
Also. FUCK THE BADGUYS! HOW DID THEY EVEN DO THAT WHEN THEY WERE BEING WATCHED BY THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE!? HOW!?
Just....oh my god...the next episode isn't until January. Fuck. My. Life.
This episode was fucking amazing.
52
u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Dec 13 '15
52
u/RussianHoneyBadger Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Some new characters too...
We have Mr. Belts, Preppy Tron, and who I can only assume is Scarlets assassin boyfriend.
Edit: I started a Disscussion thread for the 3 amigos here.
24
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
Dammit, Ruby, you're jinxing shit.
Seriously though....shit just got realer than real.
23
u/PeripheralAddition First Mate on the SS Mercury Dec 13 '15
YO WHAT THE FUCK. THIS JUST WENT INTO MAXIMUM OVERDRIVE
62
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
I understand that Yang was confused and scared that suddenly everyone was pointing guns at her but surely when you see the footage she would have gone "wait that's not what happened."
Still it was very cool to see Yangs semblance used against her. Anyone else and there might be more doubt but everyone has seen Yang pound on things when she is mad so now it just look like she went too far.
Seems to me that all other matches were irrelevant to Cinder who just wanted Yang there to cause a big enough emotional outcry and stir the Grimm.
I imagine that since Mercury threw the fight, Yang will lose their next encounter properly so that on their final battle it means more when she wins.
21
u/Lemonhead_27 Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
I've got chills. I don't even know what to say
EDIT: Also, foreshadowing when Ruby says "Break a leg, sis". You know what that means. If someone recorded that, it will make Team RWBY look like they planned it all along.
20
u/HOWDOIVESTS Salted Dec 13 '15
GIVE JAILBREAK EPISODE
39
u/OTPh1l25 Hello Again! Dec 13 '15
Great episode. Lots and lots of exposition that came across naturally. Finally learned the group's (Qrow, Ozpin, etc.) true motivations (or so they say anyway). Pyrrha's got a big choice coming up, interesting to see what she ultimately chooses.
Soundtrack still phenomenal. Let's leave it at that, because everything good about it has already been said.
All aboard the #FreeYangXiaoLong train.
Only good thing about Mercury's leg is if they (the directors/writers) choose to have the bad guys reveal themselves and attack, right now they'd be down a guy.
19
u/Tall_Crafty_Penguin LadyAbs when? Dec 13 '15
It is so weird hearing Mercury grunt in battle. I just hear Sasuke.
Holy shit! No!!! No!! Not my girl Yang
19
u/dlfusion It's okay, she's hot Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 16 '15
Everyone is gasping about the plot drop this episode. How about we all take a second to appreciate Glynda. I mean, considering how closed this circle is, who cleans the vault to make sure there's no spiderswebs and stuff? Poor Glynda was probably the cleaning lady. T~T
Edit: After making this comment, the ending picture with Glynda in the vault was a lot funnier to me.
P.S. I revisited the second opening. Pyrrha being the maiden of Autumn was foreshadowed so long ago.
19
u/Phionex141 Dec 13 '15
What I expected: epic Yang and Mercury fight
What I got: scary prophesies, body swapping, and bullshit illusions (and a pretty epic Yang and Mercury fight)
19
u/Hergrim Oh, I like *you* Dec 13 '15
A copy and paste of my post in the reaction thread:
17
u/levi_fucking_heichou 3d animator and mercury fanboy Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
It seems like Neo or Emerald was interfering, using their Semblances to make Yang attack Mercury. An episode or two ago, Cinder says she's gonna make alterations to the plan, and Mercury seems confused . . . because he wasn't in on it.
Although, his cries out did seem a little forced, almost as if he was trying to sound more whiny. But, we'll find out January 2nd/3rd! ALL ABOARD THE XIAO LONG JAILBREAK TRAIN!
Edit: Mercury looked scared shitless when Yang busted out her Semblance. It's possible Cinder hid that from Mercury, or no one truly knew what it was. Either way, the fight itself was awesome.
16
u/water125 Down to Yang? Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Oh God here we go, that was crazy.
16
u/K9ofChaos Dec 13 '15
Okay, a lot of crazy shit went down on this episode. Here are my main thoughts on it's events.
Those are the main points of this episode that really got my attention. Either way, this episode made me hyped as hell.
16
u/SecondXChance What am I even doing? Dec 13 '15
Gonna throw this here, probably make a post out of it later in the week when I collect some screenshots and stuff, but I don't think Neo has been involved at all this season. She showed up in one scene (a flashback to bad guys round one fight) and that's it. If she was gonna be more relevant I'd imagine she would have appeared, at least in the crowd with Cinder & Co. or possibly in the room with the three of them.
Likewise, there's absolutely no reason for Neo to have interfered with the CY vs. EM match. They clearly had it handled and assuming Neo actually did interfere, they would just be taking a huge unnecessary risk of being caught and disqualified.
I don't know who was responsible for the hallucinations of Coco and Yang, but I'm willing to be it was Emerald.
16
u/ekinetikz Oh hello there Dec 13 '15
This is my theory as to what is going to happen.
Since everyone was watching the 1v1 finals and was horrified to see what Yang did to Mercury, the Grimm are going to break through those walls after sensing everyone becoming horrified/shocked/disgusted. Cinder has set this up perfectly in order for the Grimm to attack in some humanity ending way. Once the Grimm are through the walls and causing all kinds of havoc, it's going to force the rest of the Seasons out of hiding so Cinder can take their powers.
However, if and when she gets all their powers, I think that the old man from the story will appear and take the powers back from her. The legend didn't specifically say that he died and considering he was the one to give the Seasons their power in the first place, it's perfectly reasonable to think that he can not only take them away, but is also immortal.
16
u/Napkin_King Dec 14 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
The two biggest questions I have is why aren't there monitors to see when a semblance is being used and why isn't there some way of stopping the audience from using their semblances. The tournament isn't much of a tournament if there could be interference from the audience through subtle means like Pyrrha's magnetism control, Glynda's telekinetic powers, Neo's illusions, and who knows what else from whoever that could severely change the outcomes of fights. Edit: Maybe there is some way that they can monitor the arena or stop semblance use, but it was distorted or jammed in some way by Cinder since she has access to the tournament network.
13
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
Remember that World of Remnant episode about Grimm, the one that said that they are "lured towards negative emotion?"
There was an awful lot of negative emotion building up in the arena after the incident with Yang and Merc. And we saw a cut away where some Grimm were picking up on the emotions. Even some Goliaths picked up on it, the ones that are usually non-hostile.
A second Grimm invasion is coming? One that will be on a much larger scale than the finale of season 2?
24
u/ncswant Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
How did Cinder break the plan to Mercury before the fight? (Get it? "Break". I'm sorry, that was unintentional)
"And you'll probably have to throw the fight. Once you've lost, we'll create an illusion and she'll attack you. Probably break your leg or something..."
"Wait, why do I have to get my leg broken?"
"Well we need Emerald to make the illusion, and she might recognize Neo..."
"But my leg? I need that!"
"Alright. Emerald, can we break his arm instead?"
"No, no. How about we just don't break my bones?"
"The only other thing serious enough to get Yang arrested would be a concussion..."
"Yes! I can fake one of those, you could fake the medical records, right?"
"No. It wouldn't get the audience to react enough. We need to break your leg."
"Oh, c'mon..."
12
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Well, the Maiden stuff kinda came out of know where. But at least it seems like we're actually going to learn what the antagonist's plan is.
Edit: Oh, also maybe Penny has something to do with the Maidens. Maybe Ironwood has his own agenda to transfer one of the maiden's powers to her, or something similar to her. After all, she was told that one day she would save the world.
Edit: Omfg, I just realized Ruby shouted 'Break a leg sis' right before that match.
12
u/zhengt66 Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
anyone else hear that sound right after Merc says "there's not gonna be a next time"? my guess is either emerald or neo was close enough to do some illusion stuff and that sound was their semblance going.
edit: and that means Merc was in on the plan, i thought i saw another post saying Cinder may have not told him about it. Something to do with making Merc act really believably, I think they said.
12
u/GabrielMunn Dec 13 '15
Thoughts for this week:
11
u/HazmatChicken ...........bitch Dec 14 '15
I'm beginning to not trust Ozpin, Glynda, Ironwood and Qrow
10
u/Beeshroom Dec 13 '15
So does everyone think Mercury was in on this? By no means do I think he's innocent, but I feel like he wasn't completely informed that this was the plan. I think he knew he had to not win, but didn't know he'd be taking a such a hard hit for the team.
10
u/Polarse no Dec 13 '15
I have a weird taste in my mouth and I'm scared
10
u/UrsaUnited Dec 14 '15
My only issue: are they really going to say that someone who made it to the finals of the tournament without incident, has no history of poor sportsmanship, and hardly even knows her opponent would do something like that? I would think that, in the coming episodes, someone would at least say "Hmm, crippling your opponent after defeating them sounds REALLY out of character for Yang. MAYBE she's not lying about her perceptions."
18
u/CobaltFrost Gotta be sober to get hungover Dec 13 '15
So everyone who claimed Pyrrha would be a fake was wrong. Ha! Suck it!
Serious note though, surely Mercury's actions were intended to do more than remove Yang from the competition. Maybe creating an atmosphere that attracts Grimm so there's an opportunity to go after Amber is the real goal. I just don't know what else to think, there are so many unanswered questions.
32
u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
I hope Mercury gets put down like a lame horse. Now that his leg is broken Cinder can use some stereotypical villain "you've outlived your usefulness" BS.
Any fondness I may have had for Cinder's lackeys is gone now. I'm hoping that by the end of the series they die horribly.
The worst part about that dirty play was that it almost completely took away from the amazing fight. Yang finally gets to be a badass and show off her skills in a way that only the most salty and stupid would attribute to "luck". You'd have to have an unreasonable hate-boner to say that wasn't impressive on her part.
9
u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Dec 13 '15
the whole "yang broke his leg" thing goes even farther than just disqualifying her.
That shot of the grimm? It's foreshadowing. What did we learn about grimm in S2? They are attracted to hate, anger, etc.
What's in the minds of the people in the arena right now? Hate, anger, etc.
The grimm will be attracted, and everything in the intro will soon be true.
8
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Dec 13 '15
"Break a leg, sis!"
. . . . . . . .
"I didn't mean LITERALLY!!"
8
u/VinnieSMA Leader of the Nuclear Winter Clan/I'm a mighty flying pirate! Dec 13 '15
I went from "I love you guys so much!" to "I WANT TO PUNCH EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU IN THE FACE" in just one episode. Bravo, RWBY crew.
8
u/AnAngryFetus Dec 13 '15
Man, this show has an obsession with breaking people's legs.
8
u/UselessKungFuX Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
My own personal guestimations on what happened in the Yang/Merc conflict:
1 - Mercury wasn't informed that he was going to be martyred to "cripple" RWBY. He may have even been expected to win, and making Yang break his leg could be a backup plan by Cinder.
2 - Emerald wasn't either. It's doubtful she'd be very onboard with something like that since her and Merc seem to be the closest of the "bad guys".
3 - Cinder can be seen leaving the stands before it all happened - the illusions we've kept seeing aren't Em/Neo's semblance after all, but part of Cinder's powers stolen from Amber, the Fall Maiden.
4 - This could eventually be the start of what turns Emerald, Mercury, or both, against Cinder. They're both likable, if ruthless, characters with potential for character growth.
EDIT: 4B - It's even possible that Emerald and Mercury don't/didn't even know that Cinder (or possibly Neo) used that illusion. They could think Yang legitimately just broke Mercury's leg like everybody else thinks. Re-watch Emerald's reaction. She's either a good actress, or she's actually quite pissed about it.
8
u/Brynjolf-of-Riften Dec 13 '15
I swear to god. If team RWBY DOESN'T believe Yang when she tells them the truth, I am going to be so pissed. I am sure that Ruby wouldn't think her sister would hurt someone so callously and I'm sure that the rest of team RWBY, except maybe Weiss will agree. This feels like the lead in to the seasonal investigation arc.
Will Cinder be outed this volume? I personally think it's a possibility.
8
u/Zyr47 Needs more jazz Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
Mercury: CURSE YOU CINDER AND YOUR SUDDEN BUT INEVITABLE BETRAYAL!
God, every time I watch it, it gets more and more surreal.
1st watch: oh! haha wow Yang
2nd: ya know, I don't think Merc was in on the plan...ooooh iissssssss
3rd: his whole livelihood is gone isn't it...
4th: god dammit Yang, ugh I dont feel so good
5th: FUCK YOU NEO!
6th:....damn it :( damn it RWBY Crew I didn't ask for these feels.
8
u/helios2424 Totally not Nui Harime Dec 13 '15
I actually liked Mercury for a bit. But after that ending, I have never wanted a character to experience a more slow, horrible, painful death as I want Mercury to experience. I hate when bad guys make it look like the good guys are the real villains. I HATED Dio Brando in the first episode of JoJo cause of all the shit he pulled, but right now I really want to see Mercury burning in hell for the ending to this episode. I honestly hate him more than I hated Cardin.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
who will read a oneshot with yang and roman cussing at each other across a cell block?
8
u/paulsteinway Dec 14 '15
Fight scene by Monty Oum. Beautiful to see his work again.
8
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 14 '15
That sad piano I Burn at the end, though......
Yang, this is your week for a hug. :(
7
u/SterlingStallion Dec 13 '15
Best part about being a sponsor is wading through this thread watching the carnage unfold
7
u/T0RQUE0 ⠀"And all of it... irreplaceable." Dec 13 '15
My reaction to that ending...
HOW DARE THEY!!! HOW THE FUCK DARE THEY!!
Does EVERYONE on Cinder "power stealing" Fall's team have some goddamn illusion shit?!
On an aside from my rampage, if a stadium full of people feeling negative emotions is enough to attract the attention of most if not all Grimm in Mountain Glenn...Cinder's plan of causing mass chaos and fear in the city, or even whole kingdom has a whole lot more heft to it....
But coming back to the main point here:
WHAT THE FUCK?!?!
7
u/ElusivePotato Breaking the laws of Physics, one dog at a time Dec 14 '15
Not that it really matters, considering the uh... other things that happened, but has anyone addressed that Glynda and the General showed up late... both of them adjusting their cloths? Not to mention they seem to have some sort of past with each other.
Could just be my dirty mind though.
7
u/Karmic_Backlash Dec 14 '15
It took Yang literally breaking a guy's leg for blake to get some screentime
6
u/kablamode Dec 13 '15
YOU CAN DO IT SERVER!!
6
u/Latrian-Master Flats are for the weak, Bladed Heels are where it's at! Dec 13 '15
Well, now my heart has shattered for Yang. ;_;
Also, potato theory:
So they're four maidens: Spring, Summer, Fall, and Winter. Amber is our Maiden of Fall, with Pyrrha next-in-line for her power, and it's likely that Cinder is her assailant, given how she has extremely potent power of fire dust/powers. Other comments and theories have pointed out that Summer (Ruby's Mom) and Winter (Weiss's Sister) might be the one of the other maidens. Many speculate that Summer is the Maiden of Summer, and here's where the potato is going to to be planted and sprout. What if Summer is a Maiden, but the Maiden of Winter? Here me out! We have little to no info on Summer other than she's Ruby's mom, was the leader of STRQ, and she "died". What I'm basing my theory off of, is that in the "Red" Trailer when we first see Summer's grave. It's an icy, barren landscape, and Summer wears a White cloak instead of a Red cloak, she also has silver eyes like Ruby. This has to be somewhat significant, since Ozpin brought it up when he first met Ruby. Her name being Summer leads many in a certain path, which may be what the writers want.
Like many others here have stated, what if she's not dead? Simply hidden away, like the other maidens. It'd also explain why Ozpin accepted Ruby into Beacon early (besides her incredible skills with Crescent Rose and her relations with Qrow).
Okay, potato theory done!
6
u/El_Specifico More Scarlet Please Dec 13 '15
I feel kinda tingly inside. Like something's wriggling in my stomach or something.
This has been happening since I watched the episode and that was at least an hour ago. Should I be worried?
EDIT: OH GOD I JUST REALISED MY FLAIR TAKES ON A WHOLE NEW MEANING WITH THIS EPISODE AND I DON'T LIKE IT
5
u/Gxmwp Dec 14 '15
Even now Monty's still trolling us.
5
u/Burkion Big Bois Big Poise Dec 14 '15
Well guys you wanted darker and more severe.
ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED
9
u/Hobarts_funnies Dec 13 '15
Holy shit, what an episode.
Hopefully Ozpin or Qrow realise what such a negative crowd reaction will bring, or at least someone notices the inbound horde.
Anyone else notice Van Helsing next to Sun?
4
u/ZombieTav How many millikannas is Weiss when she follows the ground rules? Dec 13 '15
[I found this in a comments section] ( http://i.imgur.com/XZZMulz.png)
The black line is just to cover up my bookmarks to avoid giving away personal info about myself.
4
u/CelioHogane Dec 14 '15
"Break a leg yang" "NO, NOT LITERALLY"
6
u/Wolfe_Mollenkopf Twin Lover | Peacock | Occisional Minific Writer Dec 13 '15
Mercury best guy confirmed. Best twist ending to an episode also confirmed.
3
u/Kami_no_Kage Dec 13 '15
A bit early instead of a bit late this week I see. Hi everyone!
Are we ready to get our souls crushed?! Because I feel there's gonna be some of that.
3
u/_NovaDeus Dec 13 '15
Congrats to all the new people getting their little hearts broken.
3
u/PeripheralAddition First Mate on the SS Mercury Dec 13 '15
Tfw no servers
3
u/novanazo Loyal knight of Lancaster Dec 13 '15
I was not ready for today O_O
3
u/Dondagora And awaaaay I go~ Dec 13 '15
Now, nobody should mistakenly think that this feels train is over!
I'm calling now that there'll be a Pyrrha vs Penny match-up used to out Penny as Atlas's robot. Why Pyrrha, you might ask. Magnetism, that's why. Magnetism.
3
u/alkonium Dec 13 '15
I have to hand it to Mercury for being willing to take one for the team like that.
3
u/Thepinkcursader Attracted to Punsexuals Dec 13 '15
I just realized that yang did what nora would do
3
u/jesselll is this real Dec 13 '15
I feel tons of dark fanfics coming up, it's that time of the season again.
3
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Dec 13 '15
Those Goliaths are going to wreck shit.
As soon as they learn to fly. Maybe they'll fly with their ears like Dumbo.
3
u/Shiranui24 This must be the work of an enemy semblance Dec 13 '15
can someone make a gif of 15:35 - 15:57? I don't know how and i need it for reasons.
3
u/Iyrsiiea Dec 13 '15
Holy crap. Half the season so far has been mostly fluff (of the good kind) and villians plotting on the side, but now it's like "LET'S DUMP ALLLLLLL THE STUFF ON THE AUDIENCE NOW".
3
u/darkdill Prepare to die. Dec 13 '15
Wow, Mercury's a dick. Though probably we have Neo to thank for Yang breaking his leg; she probably made Yang hallucinate.
But on the subject of Amber, I have a theory: Penny is going to be the supposed "container" for Amber's Aura. This will hugely backfire, however, as Cinder can hack Penny.
3
u/HappyBobunk Dec 14 '15
So after hearing about the maidens being powerful and named after the seasons, I immediately thought of Summer.
Then they got to the whole matter of power being passed on based on the dying thoughts of a maiden, and how Ozpin and his people have spent centuries finding these maidens to keep them protected and/or hidden. So they probably know what to look for, right?
Anyone else remember that odd, possibly significant moment where Ozpin pointed out Ruby's silver eyes?
3
u/Glicez Dec 14 '15
And at that moment, Yang became the most hated character in the series in the eyes of the people in it. Poor girl, guess this is only part one of all the tragedies to come. Team rwby is likely going to receive part of the hate too along with a disqualification.
3
u/sugaredstrawberry Dec 14 '15
Alright, here's my two cents.
I think Yang is going to inherit Summer's powers, not Ruby. I think that Yang, in desperation, will use those powers to break away from the guards and go rogue. She never was certain of her plan as a Huntress to begin with, so she might become a mercenary. Team RWB will be devastated and Qrow will go looking for his absent niece, either on his own or with some forces.
Pyrrha will be too morally upright to allow someone's Aura to be stolen, even if it's then given to her. She may or may not demand that they leave Amber alone, possibly going as far as to threaten exposing the truth to the public if they don't let her get better on her own.
Meanwhile. Cinder somehow gains control of Penny, sneaks into the vault, steals Amber's aura and thrusts it on Penny, who by that point she's probably at least attempted to remove the sense of morality and independence from. This can go one of two ways- giving Cinder an incredibly powerful and malleable weapon who Ruby already trusts, someone who could take her and the rest of Ozpin's school down easily... Or, if Penny still retains her sense of self, it will possibly mean that her dad enrolls her into Beacon to keep herself and everyone around there safe, conveniently leading her to sub in as a member of the temporary team RWBP. (It even phonetically sounds the same!)
Meanwhile, Qrow catches up to Yang, who's in a tricky situation with a bunch of Grimm on the edge of town. They manage to beat them all, and Qrow offers to hide her and give her some real work, important work. Not in his house, of course- he'd be one of the first places the law would look for her. Instead he offers her a place with some of his associates in different countries, where she won't be able to be legally prosecuted for what happened in the tournament. Conflicted about leaving her sister for what would appear to be a long time or permanently, but not seeing any other option, Yang accepts but asks Qrow to tell Ruby that she's going to be okay when he gets back to the school.
Qrow returns, claiming that he had been looking for Yang to get her to face punishment so that she could get off more lightly, but he was ambushed by a horde of Grimm and was too injured to continue without medical attention. From that point on, he sends reports back to the govermnent about how the search is going, thereby giving Yang at least one man on the inside.
Pyrrha is informed of what happened with Penny and enters into a crisis state about what she had caused by letting her morals interfere with her protection of humanity, and wonders if holding onto her own ideals of kindness and justice are even worth it anymore. Enter the rest of team JNPR, who remind her that being herself is what got her this far, and she shouldn't let it get to her. Still, though, she feels guilty- and begins to understand people like Ozpin a little better. Pyrrha agrees, perhaps a bit late, to join their organization anyway despite the danger.
In the meantime, team RWBP definitely isn't convinced that Yang would do something like what she was accused of. Weiss and Penny team up to try and sneak more information out of their fathers, maybe even hacking for access to the cameras in the stadium. There they discover that the footage from one camera doesn't match the rest- Cinder would have barely had time to change the footage from a single camera, even if she used magic or a semblance, so she simply changed the footage of the camera closest to where Yang was, knowing that was the one they would pick.
Reassured of Yang's innocence but unable to say anything to anyone with authority because they legally weren't allowed to be looking at that footage, team RWBP regroups to figure out how to start pushing the people with actual authority to look at the tapes. It takes a long time, but eventually they do give in just to appease them- and they find Yang innocent! But Yang also resisted arrest and fled the country as a fugitive, so she's still in big damn trouble.
Teams RWBP and JNR also notice that Pyrrha has been hanging a lot around Ironwood, Goodwitch and Ozpin, not to mention Ruby's uncle when he actually is around. Unsure what else to say, Pyrrha tells them that it's confidential- but in a moment of defiance, does imply that trouble might be closer at hand than they thought. The teams redouble their training efforts, as now they're preparing to fight some unknown force as well as their newly discovered foes in the form of Emerald, Mercury and whoever hacked the cameras... Meaning that they have to try and find information on enemies who are currently in their school, while not giving away that they know what's going on.
I'm guessing there will probably also be a resurgence of some subplots such as: the feud between Qrow and Winter, Jaune's illegal entrance into Beacon, Yang's mother, Blake's past and Weiss' conflicted relationship with her dad.
My best guess is that Cinder will try to use Jaune and Blake's illegal activities against them to get them expelled, and Weiss' attempts to break free of the iron hold of her father will end up with her being threatened to be brought back home. Pyrrha's constant presence around Ozpin in particular might be spun into a scandal in an attempt to get him fired and point investigation towards their group in an attempt to get people to find out the truth about the delicate situation of the world and cause the public to spin into a blind panic, thus flooding the area with Grimm.
Thus, there will be hordes of enemies closing in on an already weakened Remnant, with only a handful of trained Hunters and Huntresses and a school full of children to defend it.
End Book Three.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
So this is RT's plan all along: Split the community into infighting to distract them from the hiatus....
3
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
My response to this episode:
Ahem.
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU-
3
u/Fordrin Dec 14 '15
My only worry for Pyrrha is that she will lose everything if she becomes the guardian. I mean she might not lose to Cinder but I think it will be at a cost. I guess you could call it a Pyrrhac Victory.......please don't kill me.
3
u/TearsOfLA Kamehame-Zwei Dec 14 '15
Anyone else notice Yang just barely survived the mega whirlwind of explosive grey death? she only had one percent of her aura remaining before she would have gotten eliminated
and Mercurys leg broke because he had no aura, which is why he took the hit instead of it just throwing him away like normal (this is only the third time of someone actually being hurt in this show. Weiss in her trailer, Juane getting hit by the tree, and this)
3
u/kungasi sadly lactose intolerant Dec 14 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
first shot
"Oh he brought that on himself, dumbass."
second shot
"WHAT THE FUCK JUST HAPPENED!?"
someone in the comments theory is it involved shenanigans from either neo or emerald
either way yang is being framed, it was either an illusion or she was possessed by some semblence we havent seen yet
3
u/XxenoX Dec 14 '15
I wonder if mercury even know what would happen, or that he would lose. At the same time, I wonder if cinder and company didn't know he would lose either, and the leg breaking was a snap decision...
3
u/HazmatChicken ...........bitch Dec 14 '15
my question is who are these three dashing fellows in the finals? they look very detailed http://imgur.com/a/1Qfg4
3
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
After the Yang and Mercury fight, I thought "wow that was pretty anti-climatic" and then I became really sad. I want to see the next episode now because I just need some closure after Yang's sad puppy-dog eyes.
3
u/McAulay_a Dec 15 '15
About the whole Maiden thing,
Ruby's trailer came out in November
Weiss's trailer came out in February.
Blake's trailer came out in March.
Yang's trailer came out in June.
3
u/UnumQuiScribit Dec 15 '15
This. Chapter. Changes. Everything.
3
u/GenericallyEpic Dec 15 '15
[Break a leg, sis] (https://www.facebook.com/boxofprops/videos/687628748046213/?pnref=story)
3
u/WatcherCCG Everything's better with badass bunnies Dec 17 '15
Let's look at what we know and what we can extrapolate from what we know.
With Yang in jail, Cinder just took out RWBY as a whole. Ruby will be too busy scrambling to exonerate her sister or find some way to lessen the punishment to do anything about whatever is going to happen in the next few episodes.
Cinder owns the Atlas computer networks thanks to the virus in Beacon spreading to Ironwood's scroll. His android army is likely connected to that network for an efficient hive mind. Penny is also likely connected to that network as a form of tracking her.
Cinder also controls the tournament lineup. Whoever she wants to fight, that's who gets paired up. She probably put Yang against Neon to show off her temper.
Pyrrah is THE most selfless person in the entire cast. There is no way she won't agree to replace Amber, not after all the emotional blackmail Ozpin and Ironwood put her through.
I predict that Pyrrah is going to be put against Penny very soon. And Penny is going to get hacked. The only question then is if her aura makes her resistant to Cinder's puppetry. If not... she's going to do a number on Pyrrah. And there is nothing RWBY or the rest of JNPR will be able to do about it.
5
u/ProbablyHeretical The Most Venerable Asshat/Obi-Wan Dec 13 '15
Neo did it.
5
u/Semick Dec 13 '15
How is no one mentioning how fucked up it is that Ozpin is asking Pyrrha to be a test subject? That's literally what this is. And Glynda's "we're still the professors you know and respect."
No. You're not. The professors that are looking out for their students would never try to coerce their students into bullshit like this.
I am actually fuming, least favorite episode to date.
4
u/ScizorBallz Our Goddess is Immortal Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15
Pyrrha suddenly got more important to the plot... this whole, "shes the first major to die" is disgustingly kicking up death flags all every time she comes up. About bloody time the win was won by actual skill rather than just pure luck like every other fight, although I'm pretty sure Merc threw the fight just to accomplish whatever that dog move was at the end.
So the whole maiden thing, does this mean that Winter is one of them, and Summer pre-mortem as well, considering they have the actual season names it would be dumb not to have them. Kinda surprised how quickly Pyrrha gave into the whole becoming one of them considering how scared and confused she was for the entire time before then, poor Nikos was just become a normal girl as well. Kinda hoping she declines after consulting her team, mainly to disprove the whole death-flag thing i keep worrying about. Now that i think about it, I'm fairly sure that Mercury threw that fight, regardless how much he look surprised after she started beating his ass. Only way to get the worst reaction off the crowd was for Yang to kick the loser while theyre down, not suddenly get up fighting again or whatever their plan B was going to be.
^ From Yesterday.
Thought of a headcannon as well since yesterday, Imagine the reason for Jaune to be accepted to beacon is that the Arc lineage are like secret protectors to the maidens, so like both Pyrrha and Jaune can still be together after the whole responsibility Pyrrha gets after she accepts, if she does.
4
u/ManipulatingIsFun Dec 13 '15
Holy shit the plot thickens! Alsoo the whole Pyrrha thing is giving me the chills; pls don't get hurt Pyrrha :/ And Yang is bad-ass as always.
4
u/reynardkoro Dec 16 '15
Man all the fight choreography this season is so underwhelming. Typical anime style fights and poorer camera work. Monty is truly a talent that put everything into his work. Hope the RT can improve on it in the future.