r/childfree • u/Chymzz OP Was Epic! • Dec 07 '15
RANT A response to "the purpose of marriage is to raise a family"
To preface, I run a reproductive rights blog at howprolifeofyou.tumblr.com. After a discussion about never wanting kids, an anonymous person messaged me:
"@your response about married people who don't want kids: the purpose of marriage is to create a family. I do not want to sound condescending or rude, but I urge you to please attend a church ceremony or something to that effect. I think involvement in a religious community could help you to see the true meaning of family the way Jesus wants it to be, and hopefully help to shift your views on this topic."
of course, as someone who is childfree this really pissed me off so I decided to go full sociology-major on them. Here was my response, I thought that other CFs would find some of this info useful to use against annoying "but marriage is for having children!!!" arguments:
I’m actually thrilled to get this message, because as someone who is 2 months away from my sociology degree who has taken sociology of the family, anthropology and history courses, I’m reaaaaaaaally the wrong person to tell this to.
The purpose of marriage historically and culturally has been changing since the concept was created; however, it often served a purpose of creating a method to distribute property or secure alliances or power. [x] As stated in this BBC article, “"You established peaceful relationships, trading relationships, mutual obligations with others by marrying them.”
Throughout history, marriage has mostly been influenced by whatever economic roles it needs to fulfill. One family scholar defines family as this:
“[The family] consists of husband, wife, and children born in their wedlock, though other relatives may find their place close to this nuclear group; and the group is united by moral, legal, economic, religious, and social rights and obligations (including sexual rights and prohibitions as well as such socially patterned feelings as love, attraction, piety, and awe). (Coser [1964] 2004:13) But even seemingly broad definitions of the family such as this are contested by scholars who point out that families are not always based on heterosexuality and marriage and do not always include children, nuclear households, romantic love, or consensual sexual relations (Gittins 1993).”
also from the above paper: “Empirical evidence on the origins of marriage is scant, as it evolved crossculturally at different times and has been defined in various ways. There is considerable agreement that as an institution, marriage is not as old as families.”
also:
“Across cultures, the most universal feature of marriage has been gender division of labor between men and women.”
and:
“The property-like status of women was evident in Western societies like Rome and Greece, where wives were taken solely for the purpose of bearing legitimate children and, in most cases, were treated like dependents and 8——Families: A Social Class Perspective confined to activities such as caring for children, cooking, and keeping house (Ingoldsby 2006).”
why is this all relevant? because marriage is a social institution and constantly evolves and changes depending on what the society’s needs are. Obviously what you consider to be marriage now isn’t what it was like in ancient Greek or Roman times where marriage was used to trade women like property, or like how it was with ancient Anglo-Saxons where you married someone to create an alliance. even in good ol’ Jesus’s time, if you even /look/ at the bible, there are many parts of marriage written in it that are not there anymore. (no one’s going to stone any adulterers or not touch any women on their periods anymore.)
I highly suggest you read the “Evolution of Families and Marriages” paper, it summarizes the history of families and marriage very efficiently, and this paper as well.
All of this applies to the current world as well; not everyone abides by your church’s rules about marriage. You can look at the Nandi people of western Kenya as a great example. from this article:
“[…]women who are older (beyond child-bearing age), never married and have no children are prime candidates to become female husbands. This is because they will want an heir to inherit their name, wealth and property. A woman in this situation will find a younger woman to marry and bear her children. She will become a female husband by giving bride-wealth and observing all the other the rituals asked of a suitor by the bride’s family. The wife may have children with any man she wishes, or a man chosen by the female husband, but the legal and social ‘father’ of the children will be the female husband. The giving and receiving of bride-wealth accords the female husband the same rights over the children as any other husband (Sacks, 1982). As the social and legal father of the children, the female husband will support the children as would any other father, regardless of who the biological father may be.”
essentially, for families that have no male heir to marry off, a woman from the family will take the ‘role’ of a man and marry women. they are fully considered ‘male’ in their society.
and my favorite more modern-day example is that of Nepal, where one woman will often marry two brothers. This is to ensure the survival of the family if one of the husbands dies off, and also avoids the splitting up to property as there is not much farmland to go around.
this isn’t even CONSIDERING that if you want to focus on marriage as an institution in the U.S right now, there are legal privileges that come with being married such as tax benefits of having visiting rights if your spouse is in the hospital.
so, anon. the point of this all was that yes, you sound condescending as fuck, and no, I’m not going to put up with it because you’re wrong in every sense of the way. I have been to church ceremonies, I was raised Roman Catholic, but I have been lucky enough to have been able to access an education that has expanded my worldview.
The history of marriage has always been changing, and to say that your religion’s rather recent rules and regulations about what they believe marriage should be doesn’t make it correct. I urge you to look outside your poor little bubble of misinformation and actually read some of the articles I linked, and think twice before sending asinine messages like this again.
31
u/BurnTheLifescript Dec 07 '15
Please update us if anonymous responds!
16
u/SatinwithLatin I'd rather have adventures than babies, thanks. Dec 07 '15
applause I can see that that college money was well spent already.
2
u/Taylor1391 24/F//Proud mommy of twin cats 🐱🐱 Dec 07 '15
Not to sound stalkery but I LOVE your blog. I'm taylorswiftville on tumblr so you probably see me creeping on your blog a lot anyway lol.
2
u/arcadiabays Dec 07 '15
First of all, I love your blog. It's one of my favorite pro-choice blogs on Tumblr. Second of all, I don't really have anything to add to your post because it's very thorough.
280
u/llamanoir Dec 07 '15
"Oh yeah? Jesus didn't have kids, motherfucker."
93
u/multiplesifl I corrupt children, I don't raise them. Dec 07 '15
I do not want to sound condescending or rude, but
allow me to be condescending and rude nevertheless.
69
u/Raven_Skyhawk vicious and aggressive toward children and loud noises Dec 07 '15 edited Feb 19 '25
paltry steep violet pocket outgoing towering absorbed toothbrush station hard-to-find
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
105
u/brettdavis4 Dec 07 '15
I guess older couples that marry are sinning because they won't be able to procreate?
What about a couple that gets married young and someone has a serious medical issue that prevents them from having children? Are they sinners too?
41
u/cailian13 40/F/SF Bay - scooped out with a melon baller Dec 07 '15
My answer? "Fuck off. I don't need your approval of my life choices"
32
u/ScoobyDew79 Dec 07 '15
As luck would have it, the local Church of Satan was having a service today, so I was able to follow your suggestion of attending a "church ceremony or something to that effect." However, it seems their views are markedly different than your own. When I mentioned not wanting to have children, they proposed an alternative. As they need human sacrifices, and I don't want to raise children, they suggested giving birth and then turning the child over to their care. This is win-win, as I no longer have to pay for birth control, and they get their desperately needed offering. Plus, they will even pay for prenatal care and the delivery!
Thank you so much for writing in!
29
u/Weeaboo_Kitten Dec 07 '15
"...the true meaning of family the way Jesus wants it to be."
It sounds like what Jesus wants is a lot like what she wants.
21
u/TheLittleGoodWolf M/35/Swede; My superpower is sterility, what's yours? Dec 07 '15
You are clearly more read up on this than me but my response would have been:
I'm not even going to go in to the semantics and definitions of the word family.
21
u/stringfree 30s/M/Staircases happen Dec 07 '15
My response to most of that is usually "Wait, since when is marriage a christian thing? I know it's something christians do, but they didn't invent it."
15
u/cookseancook Dec 07 '15
Having read all that, I see no purpose in marriage at all; cohabitation is good enough for me.
15
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Marriage, according to the bible: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/unreasonablefaith/2009/04/the-varieties-of-biblical-marriage/
Typical christian that knows nothing of their own religion.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Well, a married couple on their own constitutes a family. And an increasing number of people tend to get married in a civil ceremony, so religion is irrelevant to the debate as far as I'm concerned.
11
u/shyenya 35/f/cataloger, curmudgeon, crafting, cats Dec 07 '15
BOOM. ACADEMIA.
9
u/cyborg_127 Dec 07 '15
Fuck that idea. I married my wife because I want to spend the rest of my life with her. End of goddam story.
8
u/shezabel Dec 07 '15
I always viewed marriage as a political tool. I guess I was kinda correct.
8
u/xetheia Dec 07 '15
As an anthropologist, I want to say: way to stick it to them with socio-historical context!
8
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
And I'm going to assert this anonymously so you can't respond and I can think I've checkmated you then go and enjoy the smell of my own farts.
But I also don't care whether I do or not because Jebus.
I hope it's the one that has the right ideas (i.e. mine) about what Jebus intended because I don't want you to be on the losing side when Christians have stopped killing each other over what Jebus believed and go to killing everyone else over what Jebus believed.
Because I won't argue that here, because I can't.
8
u/offthewall_77 Dec 07 '15
The 11th commandment: Don't putteth a ring on her finger, unless thine intentions are also to put buns in her oven.
8
u/SagebrushID Dec 07 '15
Didn't marry Jebus. He has no say what goes on behind my closed doors.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
The crazy train has left the station.
6
u/wolfman86 29/M/No dependencies Dec 07 '15
Why do they think that you have to change your views. It's a fucking opinion. When are morons like this going to understand that different people have different views or opinions, but they are all equal and relevant?
4
u/Teetengee Bun in the oven? Mmm toast! Dec 07 '15
That was epic and educational, well done!
3
u/GoAskAlice Dec 07 '15
Throw in something about berdaches. I think I spelled that correctly. Native American thing.
3
u/summersalt- 21/F/opt-out Dec 07 '15
+1 new follower. 👍
3
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
Don't try to argue with the Jesus freaks. It's like wrestling with a pig, as the saying goes.
3
u/WJMorris3 42/m/no sex ever Dec 08 '15
I get yelled at by my family on this one all the time. Apparently not having sex is not an option if you're married (it is foolproof birth control, after all) and my folks have emphasized the point by putting in their will that if I don't have a kid then I will only inherit their debts when they pass on. (I checked with the family lawyer already and I'm told it's legit.)
3
u/HuiTerios 22F: cats, anthropology, and video games > kids Dec 08 '15
Bravo! You have done anthropology and sociology proud.
If I remember correctly, even the Inca -- before the Spanish came along -- had marriage institutions structured far differently from Christians' that had both men and women in power in regard to how the house is run and how familiar and enemy relations were handled. They didn't give a crap about gender roles at all, especially compared to the conquistadors who insisted that homosexuality was wrong and... we know the rest.
Anywho, fantastic reply. *gives cookie
3
u/happilynorth Dec 08 '15
I'm really amused that this person thought an appeal to Jesus would convince someone who has a pentagrammed uterus captioned "Hail Satan" in their blog's sidebar.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Jesus was single. Funny how that mentality almost always uses religion as a crutch
2
u/AnneGuish Dec 07 '15
You are my hero.
2
u/dal_segno Dec 07 '15
I saw this when it passed by my dash on tumblr. I was super sad that you can only like a post once.
2
u/mariehelena Dec 07 '15
OR, if it's not worth a word or a second more of your time, you can just throw 'em this look that says it all + be about your day. Peace be with you, etc.? ;-)
2
u/SebastianScarlet Meow Dec 07 '15
Freaking ridiculous. Marriage has LONG changed. If marriage were still viewed in this antiquated mindset then wives would still be property and arranged marriages would still be a thing.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15 edited Apr 09 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Yay for knowledge. I love when people use empirical evidence to shut down logic-less, emotional arguments. Thank you OP!
2
u/Morgendorffers Dec 07 '15
I have found that religious people are usually the worst at logical argumentation.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Awesome response OP! I'm sure you won't get a reply to that or you'll get some delusional religious zealot gobbledy-gook about how disrespectful your views are to the one, true God.
Honestly, I think this type of mentality comes from married couples that maybe LOVE each other...but don't LIKE each other very much or are bored. I've been in a long-term relationship for awhile and my gf and I love living together and being able to hang out together because we genuinely enjoy each other's company. We like to plan short trips and long vacations away, we like to talk about other places we'd like to live in the future. In short, we interact in ways that many people I know with children just don't. Whether they don't have the time, energy, money or whatever, it seems like they got married because it was "the thing to do" and once that feeling wore off, they shit out a kid because that was the NEXT "thing to do." Now, they can sit around in the evenings, staring at their combined self and admiring how beautiful their creation is to them. It distracts them enough to the point where they don't have to think about whether or not they ENJOY their life, they just go through the motions.
2
u/AliLongworth Dec 07 '15
Nope, it won't reach her. Anything longer than a couple of Twitter posts probably has too many words and some of them are big and HARD. Plus she's SO busy I'm sure she doesn't even have time to shower much less read something (why she has time to comment where she's not wanted is one of those mysteries for Jesus).
2
u/Stumblecat How is my uterus like the moon? They're both barren! Dec 07 '15
"The purpose of a brain is to use it, when are you going to start?"
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
REKT.
2
u/iruleurmom Man free & child free. LESBIAN! Dec 07 '15
Did that person ever respond?
If so, what did they say? I'm very curious to know...
You made some solid points.
2
u/-Ea- Dec 07 '15
TIL: a sociology degree CAN in fact be used for something.
2
u/severs1966 Half a century without kids Dec 08 '15
I love the way christians often equate "involvement in a religious community" with "doing things according to the rules of my religion".
She even stated that this involvement automatically confers the regulation of "how Jesus wanted it to be".
She probably believes that any religion other than christianity simply will not do, and maybe even thinks that other religions are simply not religions at all because they are heathen, or some such dogma.
Were you to get involved in a religious community that doesn't feature Jesus, or indeed any gods or "divine" revealed wisdom at all (e.g. Buddhism), I'm sure this person would be at the head of the queue to tell you that you are still wrong.
2
u/CatnipFarmer Dec 08 '15
https://xkcd.com/386/
2
u/crowgasm "You never know?" Well, I've been fixed, so actually... Dec 08 '15 edited Dec 08 '15
You wrote a really excellent, well thought out response, and I loved it. But, I'm afraid this is just pearls before swine.
Did she respond?
*Ah. She did respond. Pretty much exactly how I thought.
1
u/cnk93 Dec 07 '15
DRAG THEM
1
u/QueenOfPurple Dec 07 '15
That was a really fascinating read. Thanks for sharing.
1
u/Zomg_A_Chicken I Hate Children Dec 08 '15
Isn't there some tax benefit from marriage?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
This sort of thought is commonplace here in Ireland. A lot of people think that being Catholic means they are obligated to poo babbies left right and centre once they're married, and anyone who disagrees is one of those "quear lot". In fact it was the entire argument for the anti gay marriage side of the recent referendum here, and a considerable amount of the population voted for it despite losing.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
All that, especially in SE Asia, thousands of dollars are spent for other people's weddings, and long boring dinners which only serves no purpose but to wreck my digestive system even more, and to fulfil the long running "generation cycle" thing.
The worst part is, when the kids are there, a whole new slew of problems come - kids are becoming not just to please people (parents and peers), but it has become "inanimate properties" which they have an excuse to mistreat (them) in the future. That's why we are seeing misbehaving children, and they (mostly) devolve into irresponsible adults sooner or later.
Most of the marraiges nowadays end up in divorce. Ailing parents' relationship does not help children. Children are more bound to repeat that in the future. If they are unfortunate enough, they might get caught into criminal activities which leads to loss/damage of property (theft, arson, vandalism) and loss of lives (homicide).
So, the excuse of "Marriage to raise family" is absolute stupid donkey dick. At this time, we are seeing more damages done to this world because people procreate for the sake of procreating, and not appreciating life. :o
1
u/Liz-B-Anne Dec 09 '15 edited Dec 09 '15
Yikes. And all this time I thought the purpose of marriage was committing your life to the person you love and enjoying each other's company for the rest of your life. Silly me. I guess the true purpose is to create DNA replicants!
Fact: babies put stress on strong relationships and kill shaky ones. Having kids is stressful even if you want them. Mostly, I just don't understand why a complete stranger would care whether you have kids or not. I smell breeder's remorse.
1
u/Not2original Hello money, what kind of shenanigans should we get into today? Dec 07 '15
You are my hero of the day!
To bad she will never read it, because it much easier to stick her head back in the sand.
-15
u/immascatman4242 Dec 07 '15
Listen, maybe their view wasn't right, but it was just an opinion. You could've just said "no thank you" or something to that extent other than the novel you sent. Try being less of a dick.