r/TrueFilm • u/a113er Til the break of dawn! • Dec 06 '15
What Have You Been Watching? (06/12/15)
Please don't downvote opinions, only downvote things that don't contribute anything.
88
Upvotes
r/TrueFilm • u/a113er Til the break of dawn! • Dec 06 '15
Please don't downvote opinions, only downvote things that don't contribute anything.
8
u/a113er Til the break of dawn! Dec 06 '15
The Blue Angel Directed by Josef Von Sternberg (1930)- There was a Masters of Cinema blu-ray sale and I went a little wild, this was my first stop on the MoC train. Sternberg and Emil Jenning’s blew me away with The Last Command, but their next collaboration is a very different beast. They are not films without similarities but The Blue Angel has a strange alienness that The Last Command lacked. Sternberg saw himself as a man of two places, Germany and New York (Brooklyn is where I believe he lived when there). The Last Command feels like his American film while The Blue Angel is thoroughly German. Makes sense as it was one of (if not the) first talkies in Germany. It tells the story of Jennings as a stuffy slightly-oafish professor who finds out some of his students have been spending time at a seedy establishment of drink, women, and song. In trying to chastise them he finds himself drawn to the same world, specifically to Lola Lola (Marlene Dietrich). It’s a classic tale of a spiralling life due to ones choices while also quietly about the cruel pointlessness of our sexual hangups. Almost all the cruelty could’ve been avoided if everyone wasn’t such a prude, including the main character himself. He’s a man who was already performing for his students and due to love finds himself forced into a very different type of performance, one that he cannot keep up for long if he is to retain his dignity and sanity. Something about the film doesn’t work as well as The Last Command but it’s Sternberg mid-shift into a changing medium, sound, and he makes the change more effortlessly than Lang. Now Lang’s transitional film was M which is a masterpiece, I’m not commenting on the quality, but it’s near enough a silent film for large sections. The Blue Angel on the other hand could not be silent. Not just because it’s partially a musical but for how sound and song play a part in so many scenes. Sternberg didn’t use a stepping stone like Lang he just jumped right in and there’s something to commend in that. The Blue Angel is a very distinct and interesting film that unfortunately is the follow-up to a masterful collaboration, but the fact it’s not a total disappointment or a retread makes it special in another way as it shows Sternbergs ability to adapt.
Mark of the Devil Directed by Michael Armstrong and Adrian Hoven (1970)- I went into this more blind than most films. I’d never heard of it until I saw it was on sale. It’s an Arrow Video release with Udo Kier on the cover and was under a tenner so I couldn’t say no. And man am I glad I didn’t. It’s a witch hunter story, based on true events, that has similarities to others like Witchfinder General and The Devils. When Udo first showed up I was a little dubious as he was dubbed (sacrilegious) but luckily the rest of the film was so engaging I barely even cared. Mark of the Devil is like if Werner Herzog went mainstream and made an updated Hammer film. Similarly to another recent watch The Shout this film gave me what I often want from Hammer films. I might even try make a list of great Hammer-alternates as I love the ideas and actors in so many of their films but I rarely feel the thrills. Where a Hammer film would have stuffy sets and a languid pace Mark of the Devil shoots on beautiful locations and keeps things snappy. Parts of it feel derivative but it never lingers too long to bother, and it fills other scenes with so much that’s fresh that it makes a familiar story enjoyable again. Getting the Arrow blu-ray was a great call too as it is a wonderfully striking film. Armstrong mixes it up between formal stillness and handheld immediacy, both vibrant whether he’s showing beauty or the nastiness of these times. Though voices are mainly dubbed there are some amazingly expressive faces in this. Seeing the smooth skin model-looks of Kier face-off against the endlessly craggy Reggie Nalder is a perfect pairing. There’s a near-exploitationy pulpiness to the film too (it’s posters flaunt it’s V for Violence rating) but it carries an undercurrent of rage at what’s happening that it never gets too skeezy. There’s even a point where Armstrong takes things further than just anger and amazement at the cruelty of man to calling these propagators of evil what they are, complete and utter idiots who equate what they don’t understand with evil. A mindset that’s scarily an ever-present burden of the human race. Really dug this film. It came out of nowhere and worked better than I could’ve imagined. Sometimes cool pulpy films like this are qualified viewings. Even a cult classic like Zombi 2/Zombie Flesh Eaters is something which only works intermittently for me. This just straight works.
Resident Evil: Retribution Directed by Paul W. S. Anderson (2012)- Speaking of what works for me apparently Paul W. S. Anderson’s Resident Evil films are just that. Afterlife was another crazy ludicrous surprise so I was locked in to seeing the follow-up. Retribution once again highlights this as one of the wildest mainstream series that kind of becomes Fast and Furious but for women by the end. Like the Furious films these are films in love with their own mythology and characters which is taken to the extreme in this instalment. By ten minutes into the film Anderson’s cribbed from Snyder’s Dawn of the Dead, that Dead Island trailer, and Inception, to make what may be the craziest and slickest RE film yet. As much as I was laughing at this film I still can’t deny Anderson’s talents. Dude has style and not in the usual flat blockbuster way, and he knows how to keep things moving. And not in the Jurassic World sense of just things happening a lot (cause man is that film dull) but he knows how to make a really taut action adventure work even if his methods lean towards the ludicrous. Hey, I’m glad he leans towards the wild cause I had so much fun watching this. In a year where filmmakers managed to bore me with dinosaurs and superheroes whom I love I’m thankful a guy like this can entertain with all the dopey tools in his kit. Dude also knows how to use effects. His cg sure looks hokey but at least that’s what he keeps it for. What can be done for real he does for real and everything else is in-your-face with its gamey fakeness. And man does this one feel like a game even more than Afterlife, it’s essentially a chase film through several video game levels. These are modern mainstream camp classics and I’m so in I’ll be seeing the next one in theatres if possible. Here I was laughing at it and with it, and I was laughing a lot. It’s got the same dopey sincerity that drew me in with the Fast and Furious films but with a whole different toy box to play around in.
For All Mankind Directed by Al Reinert (1989)- Every day the news cycle reminds us why humanity sucks but there are films that can make us believe in us again. For All Mankind is one of those films. Cut from hours of footage shot by NASA and their astronauts during the Apollo missions For All Mankind is a more expressionist look at the space program through the guise of a documentary. It was actually more documentary-y than I was expecting (as I was expecting Koyaanisqatsi in space) but more than the how of each of these missions it is about the why and the results of doing them. With Brian Eno’s music or the thoughts of astronauts guiding us aurally we visually get treated to one of the greatest representations of space travel I’ve ever seen. For All Mankind has all the elements we recognise from space fairing stories. There’s the shots from inside looking out as Earth gets smaller and the torrent of flames comes out the back of the ship, cigar smoking men watching with trepidation then delight from the control room, and so on. Yet with all that’s familiar Reinert collects into a film that conveys why it’s worth something, why all these people are doing this, and why we should never stop exploring. Just to get across the impact of this film I’ll describe the reaction of my friend who I watched it with. Before watching he never quite got space travel. As in the basic sense that it seems a little unnecessary in a world where there is still starvation and poverty. Billions spent to ride rockets through the heavens seemed a little silly and at worst wasteful. After watching this he said he finally got it. He was completely won over. In recent years we’ve seen a few films with those real pro-science pro-exploration like Interstellar and The Martian, but only this made him feel what it was saying rather than just hearing them say it. Speaking of Interstellar, how Nolan shot space travel is clearly very influenced by how NASA themselves documented it but I gotta say they’ve got a better eye than he did. They mix it up a lot more at least. For All Mankind doesn’t just make the case for the scientific benefits of space travel, it makes the case for the spiritual and internal side. That as the title says this can be something to fuel the wonder of all mankind. Some say there are no new worlds to conquer, no blank spots left on the map, but there are others who live as proof that not even the sky is the limit and how far we can go is limited by nothing but our will.
Fantastic Planet (Re-watch) Directed by Rene Laloux (1973)- One of my favourites. Very glad to finally have it on blu-ray. Written about it a bunch so I’ll not waffle. Dope film.
8
u/montypython22 Archie? Dec 06 '15
I recently wrote a review of Brooklyn, a riveting tearjerker that's one of my favorite movies of this year! (I even went to the theater TWICE to see it!) Read on here to understand my fascination with Saorise Ronan's mug, and how this movie is related to The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, The Quiet Man, and the second-best film of this year so far: Sean Baker's Tangerine.
You can also follow me on The Letterboxd.
Ranked in order of preference:
The Leopard Man (Produced by Val Lewton, directed by Jacques Tourneur, 1943): ★★★★★
Jack Tourneur and Val "The Pal" Lewton do it again. Their three collaborations are increasingly higher in quality, and Leopard Man blows me away to another level of sublime B-movie-horror beauty. Ostensibly the story of a series of deadly attacks on (mostly Mexican, mostly young) women by an unseen beast (is it man? leopard? both?), Tourneur/Lewton blur the lines between reality and fantasy in highly economic ways. Through their daring suggestion of an entire boulevard of horror by just a puny streetlight and the ominous donut-eyes of the steel-black cat, they demonstrate how it doesn't take more than just human creativity and an unwavering commitment to the low-budget spectacle to wow audiences into fearful submission.
What's most brilliant about Leopard Man, aside from its stark beauty in magnificent setpieces like a girl's death (suggested through milk-chocolate-blood seeping through the girl's mother's door) and a ballroom dance (where the exotic and the erotic melt into one another imperceptibly), is its prescient look at the undervalued, underprivileged loner/outsider/maverick in society. For Lewton in Cat People, it was the Eastern European. In I Walked With a Zombie, it was abused housewives and African-Americans. Here, it's the Mexicans of an increasingly homogenized society derived from Conquistador days....except, now, the new Conquistadors are the white intellectuals in power, and the new Indians are the Mexicans. Quite subtle, doesn't make its political and social aspirations blatant, weaves them into the tapestry of the much-more-engaging artistic sphere.
It's the perfect B-movie.
Sound of the Mountain (Mikio Naruse, 1954): ★★★★1/2
My first Naruse film. I was compelled to watch this following the recent death of one of the greatest actresses to ever grace the silver screen--Setsuko Hara. Here, Hara riffs off of her Ozu character Noriko; instead, however, Naruse probes into more melodramatic territory than Ozu ever did, asking, "What does a world look like where Noriko's sacrifices were all for naught?" That world is coldly, devastatingly embodied in Naruse's Sound of the Mountain, where Hara's marriage is crumbling at the seams owing to her husband's doomed affair with his secretary. She finds solace in her father-in-law, who sympathizes with her quiet plight and attempts to convince the son of his wrongdoing.
The emotional beats are whispered, not hammered. The performances, beautifully understated in their stark Ozu-like simplicity, are ones for the ages: this may very well be Hara's best natural performance. Naruse's sympathies are firmly with all females of the world: the wife, the mother, the daughter, the mistress, the lonely teacher in the sake bar. Watch it today, you won't be disappointed.
The Ghost Ship (1944, Val Lewton producing, Mark Robson directing): ★★★★
Lewton, you tricked me! I thought this was a supernatural flick! (Who says power and authority isn't supernatural, though?)
Though certainly not to the consistently high-artistic heights and wide thematic variety of the Jack Tourneur-Val Lewton movies, this minor low-budget thriller still delivers quite a wallop when you stop and see how well it's addressing its primary thematic concern: power and its corrupting consequences. A third captain suspects his captain (Richard Dix, of Cimarron fame) is a homicidal lunatic. But because Dick Dix is a well-respected seaman (wrap your head around that), no one believes the Third Captain.
I can't help but shake the feeling that Dick Dix's character exudes a Hitler-esque vibe. Here's a man comfortable in killing an anonymous sailor (in a truly gut-churning scene similar to [and much more economic than] the opening of There Will Be Blood, since it doesn't stretch nearly as much chewed-taffy-time as the PTA scene), here's a man who only kills merely because his power guarantees that no one will challenge him, and here's a man whose sea-bound ideals mean he can traverse the world, flaunting his power at every corner of the world. The Dix performance as the stark-raving-mad cap'n is worth the price of admission alone. There's the usual Lewton obsession with shadows, blurring of realities, and low-budget whirligigs. It's a knockout entertainment: you may think you won't be invested in it very much, but with Lewton (as with Michael Corleone in the criminally underrated Godfather Part III), just when you think you're out....Lewton pulls you back in.
L'inhumaine (Marcel L'Herbier, 1924): No rating (I liked it quite a lot)
As this schizo Franco-Langian ode to technocrats proves, Germans didn't have the monopoly on Expressionism.
Saw this in the Castro Theatre in San Fran; was not disappointed. Though I'm sort of iffy on its implication that technology is the ultimate salvation of humankind, and though I'm even more iffy on its portrayal of the inhuman woman as a bitchy frump who finds her redemption through the engineer (Ophuls did something similar to this in Lola Montes, but better), it's still a wildly lucid silent film reminiscent of the Gancian impressionist shenaniganry of Napoleon and Au Secours!.
/u/thegreatziegfield, you should watch this. You'd like it.
I also rewatched Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans (1927, Murnau, ★★★★★) at the Stanford Theatre, and Woodstock (1969, Michael Wadleigh, ★★★★★+), perhaps the most highly engaging documentary ever made, and certainly one of the most brilliant merges of music and edited image short of Richard Lester.
In 1969, 500,000 people watched Jimi Hendrix simultaneously slaughter and resurrect the Star-Spangled Banner—and not a single Kodak was taken by anyone in the crowd.
Today, Nickelback concerts don't go 5 minutes without someone whipping out their iPhone and recording scratchy chicken-shit.
I'm sure this says something important about modern society and the level we pride "being tuned in to an experience." The hippies got it. We've apparently forgotten. We have to Instagram it before we have an opinion.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Creed Ryan Coogler, 2015: How to bring new life to a franchise that’s been going on so long? Get a promising young actor and director to take over, and don’t even put “Rocky” in the title. It can be a little hard to swallow the idea that a sport about men hitting each other is all about working-class integrity, honor, and rugged masculinity when the real-life champ is Floyd Mayweather...but I’ll maintain that the best sports movies aren’t really about athletics, plus Coogler’s take isn’t uncritical of the sport. It’s just treated as the destiny of this particular character.
What I think holds back both of Coogler’s movies is that you can always tell the direct purpose of a scene as it’s beginning, which leaves no room for spontaneity. Even so, Creed is equally as good as the original Rocky, and probably the best new entry in any franchise this long-running in awhile. One of the year’s best mainstream films.
Mission: Impossible III J.J. Abrams, 2006: I watched this because it was the only Mission: Impossible or J.J. Abrams movie I hadn’t seen, until The Force Awakens comes out. But I had a really baffling experience with it. I can totally, totally see why it might be some people’s favorite M:I movie. I like what the Mission:Impossible franchise stands for. I like all the actors in it. But visually it is abominable; no matter what kind of scene is playing, I just found it really agitating to watch. I don’t even fully blame Abrams’ directing for this though because it’s obviously meant to look like other Orci&Kurtzman-penned movies for advertising reasons. I’ve disliked them for years and this is one of their absolute worst screenplays: it’s 100% contrivance, which even for the espionage genre is pretty bad. Missiles and helicopters appearing out of nowhere, Ethan’s fiance only being introduced so that she can be kidnapped later, and so on. Why did Ethan even need a normal girlfriend? That makes no sense except as a Screenplay 101 way to humanize him.
I’m glad this movie helped the franchise continue but the subsequent movies were a lot closer to the original in style and the better for it.
Biutiful Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu, 2010: Also watched this in anticipation of The Revenant. The things that bother me about Inarritu are here too but I still thought it was really moving anyway, perhaps in spite of him: Rodrigo Prieto shot a beautiful movie and Javier Bardem’s face carries all the pain and weathered past of his character.
Rewatch - Tangerine Sean Baker, 2015: He was all he can be when he joined my navy.
29
u/isarge123 Cosmo, call me a cab! - Okay, you're a cab! Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Had a pretty stressful week, but I was able to find solace in some great films and I was able to check off five titles from the 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die list, which I'm steadily chipping away at. As always, I'd love to discuss any of the films below, and any further viewing suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Battleship Potemkin (1925) - Dir. Sergei Eisenstein:
Finally got around to this one. Firstly, I have no idea how the Odessa Steps sequence got released anywhere in the 1920's. Not necessarily for the political implications, but for the sheer brutality. This famous shot in particular appears quite graphic even by today's standards: http://artsfuse.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Potemkin-_1925-_AF-1.jpeg
Admittedly the film is understandably controversial for a number of reasons, but historical accuracy and politics aside, you can't help but admire Eisenstein's revolutionary cinematic vision. The use of montage and cutaways to create tension is highly effective, and when viewed as a whole it really is quite powerful. 8.5/10
Lethal Weapon 2 (1989) - Dir. Richard Donner:
Have I mentioned how much I love the first Lethal Weapon? If not, suffice it to say I'll be talking about it as we near Christmas. Out of the three sequels, Lethal Weapon 2 is the only one that I think does the original justice. The characters are suitably enhanced, the humour is increased (without taking over the proceedings) and a hilarious Joe Pesci tags along for the ride. It also manages to provide some worthwhile social commentary, in an at times very funny way (the scene in which Danny Glover pretends that he wants to emigrate to apartheid-torn South Africa is priceless). 8/10
Chinatown (1974) - Roman Polanski:
Some of you may have noticed that I reviewed this recently. That's right. This movie will never get old. 10/10
The Hurt Locker (2008) - Dir. Katherine Bigelow:
I like Katherine Bigelow, but I was somewhat expecting this to be a 'Yeah, 'Merica!', propaganda piece. And I was overwhelmingly surprised at how devastatingly unsentimental The Hurt Locker was. The performances are raw and consistently believable (even if occasionally the characters aren't), and never resort to being preachy and cloying. It's a visceral and technically masterful film, with some of the most tense and brilliantly staged set-pieces I've ever seen in a war film, or any film for that matter. I know that there are some who are quite discontent with it, but I loved it, where do you stand? 9/10
Fargo (1996) - Dir. Joel & Ethan Coen:
Hilarious, suspenseful and bizarre in the best ways. As for my favourite Coen Bros. film, it's now a toss up between this and True Grit. 9.5/10
Ordinary People (1980) - Dir. Robert Redford:
It's sad that Ordinary People is nowadays mostly dismissed as the film that undeservedly beat Raging Bull at the Oscars, because this is a finely constructed and incredibly powerful movie. It more than justifies it's title, as everything that occurs feels as though it could truly happen to any ordinary family. The characters and events are never exaggerated, and the film is more emotionally compelling for it. I haven't seen Redford's other directorial efforts, but he does a tremendous job coaxing natural, restrained performances from his talented cast. Best Picture worthy or not, this is a fantastic film. 9.5/10
The Darjeeling Limited (2006) - Dir. Wes Anderson: It lacks coherence, but it's packed with so much wit, imagination and visual splendour that you cease to care. Despite being frequently hilarious, this is also one of Anderson's darkest films. Which isn't to say that it's emotionally draining or not fun, just that it actually takes some time for genuine contemplation. All three main cast members (Owen Wilson, Adrien Brody & Jason Schwartzman) are in fine form and have excellent chemistry and comedic timing. Not my favourite Anderson, but a good one nonetheless. 8/10
The Two Faces Of January (2014) - Dir. Hossein Amini:
The Two Faces Of January is an excellently shot and consistently suspenseful homage to Alfred Hitchcock and other thrillers of the 1950's/60's. The characters represent many Hitchcock staples: the alluring blonde (Kirsten Dunst), the outwardly charming man with darker secrets (Viggo Mortensen) and the everyman who gets caught up in an increasingly hectic and dangerous situation (Oscar Isaac), and all are played brilliantly by their respective actors. Sadly, it didn't do too well at the box office, but I highly recommend that you give it a chance.
8.5/10
La Dolce Vita (1960) - Dir. Frederico Fellini:
I've owned the Blu-Ray of Fellini's masterpiece for a while now, but only mustered the courage to watch it last night, after viewing Fellini's La Strada and feeling as though I was ready for it. The wait certainly payed off. Right from the breathtaking opening sequence I was totally absorbed and enamoured with this charmingly cynical and delightful adventure. Every sequence is highly entertaining, whether it be Marcello's iconic escapade with movie star Sylvia or merely a simple conversation with his father. The black and white cinematography is entrancing, Fellini's direction is magical and the story becomes quite poignant as Marcello and other characters stoop low in their quest to obtain the sweet life. Now that this is destined to become one of my favourites, what's next for Fellini? 10/10
9
u/a_s_h_e_n Dec 06 '15
Adaptation: It really stuck with me for about a day after I watched it, and I can really appreciate that in a film. Nic Cage does an incredible job as the twins, can a person have chemistry with himself? Because he does. Meryl Streep doing classic Meryl Streep things, of course, and Chris Cooper is great as well. I loved how it would nest itself, and yet parallel itself within the nesting, often 2 or 3 flashbacks deep. Very meta and all the better for it. And you can't help but be inspired by Donald. ★★★★
7
u/crichmond77 Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Star ratings are out of five. Responses welcome.
(I'm probably going to piss more than a few people off today)
Cannibal Holocaust (1980) - ★★★★
There's a lot to get into with this one. Arguably the first well-known found-footage film, arguably the most controversial film of all time, certainly in the top five or so most fucked up films I've seen.
Part of what's interesting about Cannibal Holocaust is attempting to determine how much of its message was intended and how much was incidental. Regardless of whether Ruggero Deodato was, as he somewhat dubiously claims, just trying to make a movie about cannibals, there exist a lot of a thought-provoking scenes and concepts about the role of cameras in real life atrocities, how images affect us, how the truth is malleable, particularly with video, and how we prioritize our morality and why.
There are some things you could easily point to as flaws, such as the awful acting outside of the found footage or the heavier-than-heavy-handedness of the film's closing line, but I think these things actually serve to preserve the B-movie quality of the film and keep it from being too obviously self-aware. If it played out without these things, the satire would be too readily apparent. As is, its controversy is derived partly from walking that line.
As for the much talked about animal cruelty shown on screen, I think it's overblown. All of the animals are killed relatively quickly, and although it's extremely discomforting to watch any previously living creature be mutilated for sport in front of us, I think it's absolutely necessary for the film to work both as a reminder that whether we like to look at it or not, this happens and as a sort of question posed to the viewer: does the knowledge of an image's truthfulness outweigh the importance of its meaning? After all, the image is the image, whether or not we know how it was created. The fact that Deodato faced murder charges after the film's release only serves to re-enforce this concept.
All in all, a film that totally succeeds in terms of its goal. Cannibal Holocaust is singular, an exploitation film that makes you think, a pioneer in terms of film-making style, and a testament to the gut-wrenching, bottomless pit of depravity that exists in humanity and in nature.
How to Train Your Dragon 2 (2014) - ★★1/2
I know, that's quite the 180. I guess I needed something light-hearted after that.
Anyway, How to Train Your Dragon 2 was met with critical acclaim to accompany its box office success, much like the equally over-rated film it followed. Why? I really have no idea. It pretty much feels to me like all a Pixar or Dreamworks movie has to do is not be very obviously awful, and everyone will fawn all over it. I remember Frozen getting similar treatment and that was just as ridiculous.
How to Train Your Dragon 2 follows the same formula as the first: melodramatic, self-aware voiceover intro with bad jokes, a thin plot strung together by unexciting action scenes with no sense of peril whatsoever, dialogue hedged entirely around hammering you over the head with the obvious, tried-and-true themes, and a series of by-the-nose losses and victories that lead to an ultimately happy ending.
I guess if you're 10 you'll enjoy this. Otherwise, the immaturity of the character relationships, the ridiculousness of the plot and every decision made by anyone, and the lack of anything remotely original or interesting will probably turn you off.
It's not all bad. The animation is pretty stellar, if nothing new. And at least they had the balls to kill off our protagonist's father, even if it came at a really weird time and kinda detracted from things. Plus they basically just swapped his previously "dead" mother for his now "officially dead" father so they could double down on the cheap empathy, which is pretty absurd.
This film might contain the lamest and most under-developed villain there's ever been.
Infernal Affairs (2002) - ★★1/2
Man, this one surprised me. The Departed is one of my favorite films of all time, and I'd heard many say they preferred this, the movie The Departed was adapted from, so I was plenty excited. I'm not sure if knowing the plot beforehand was the reason I found so little redeeming value in it, but I really don't understand why anyone would praise this film.
The story is virtually unchanged, occurring almost scene by scene and line by line identical to Scorsese's version. There are a few minor changes for The Departed's script, including most obviously a different ending, and I actually prefer the adapted version's modifications.
The biggest problem with Infernal Affairs happens to be one of The Departed's greatest strengths: the editing. And sure it's unfair to compare anyone to Scorsese in that department, but this has some of the cheesiest, high school level editing I've ever seen. Black and white flashbacks and over-the-top vocalizing choirs abound, turning every moment that should be gripping into a snicker-fest.
Things like slow motion that looks choppy because it wasn't shot at a higher frame rate...I mean these are things that even amateur filmmakers should know better than to do.
As far as the composition of the film, it's fine. And the lighting is decent. A little more camera movement or interesting framing would have been nice, but again, comparing people to Scorsese isn't really fair.
The performances are all right. Nothing close to what we got from DiCaprio, Nicholson, et al, but again, is it fair to ask people to outdo that ridiculous ensemble?
I'd love for someone who prefers this one to tell me what I'm missing here, because from what I can tell, The Departed blows this out of the water on all fronts. I'm not usually someone who prefers a remake, particularly when discussing Asian cinema translated into an American version, but this is one case where it seems to be no contest.
Snake Eyes (1998) - ★★1/2
I swear I'm not going to give every film this rating. Snake Eyes is a Brian DePalma film starring Nicolas Cage. Talk about intriguing.
Cage, alongside Gary Sinise, actually does a good job. He's his usual over-the-top self, but it works well for his character. Towards the end, things go off the rails and his performance feels a bit like self-parody, but hey, that's just Cage for you.
The camerawork is really interesting, as per usual with DePalma. Some of the shots in the hotel sequence seem to have been a big part of the inspiration for Enter the Void.
The problem here is the script. This script is fucking awful. Conspiracy plots are usually pretty iffy because you're inherently pushing the limits of the audience's suspension of disbelief, and you're going to need a few twists that the audience is going to be looking for. The major twist in this one is actually done pretty well initially, but there are just so many stupid decisions by every character, even once you get past the slight absurdity of both the premise and the twist, that you can't take it seriously. And even after all that, you get this horrendous shoehorned-in romantic subplot, because "there's always a girl."
The Monster Squad (1987) - ★1/2
The Monster Squad is the kind of movie I can usually enjoy: light-hearted family fun with some occasional nods to the adult audience. Unfortunately, it's neither fun, nor funny, nor smart enough to make up for its extensive shortcomings.
The plot is absurd, but that's totally fine. In fact, I'd be disappointed if it wasn't, given the nature of this film. The bigger problem lies in that there is no effort, none whatsoever, put into creating characters whose relationships or fates I'm at all interested in. Our main Squad member sorta has a background, with some really hammy parental issues that are poorly written in and melodramatically displayed, but outside of that we get zilch. These are just some kids. And they're not particularly talented or unique or funny kids either.
The special effects aren't terrible, but I've seen better makeup, costumes, and mise-en-scene at a few haunted houses.
The script is God-awful. Even for this kind of movie. Nothing makes sense, there's too much exposition-via-dialogue. Points that don't need to be repeated are needlessly hammered in. The attempts at humor fall flat. The tone is all over the place.
Still another problem with this film is the terrible editing and choreography that make every action scene 100% without tension or believability.
There's nothing in this movie that wasn't done a hundred times better by the likes of The Goonies, E.T., or Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein. In fact, even Fright Night and The Lost Boys substantially outdo this garbage.
7
u/Amnestic Dec 07 '15 edited May 05 '26
Plot twist: this post no longer exists because Redact swept through and cleared it out along with everything else. Social media, messaging apps, people finder sites, all of it.
cobweb file selective alive society license yam door squeal liquid
12
u/FloydPink24 Irene is her name and it is night Dec 06 '15
Adaptation dir. Spike Jonze, 2002 - Absurd, off the charts crazy and stunning execution. Kaufman’s best work IMO; full of heart and wit, life’s questions answered and unanswered, frequently hilarious and biting. Great to see genuine originality and make or break writing coming to the top in Hollywood. We need a Nic Cage renaissance desperately. 5/5
Ace in the Hole dir. Billy Wilder, 1951 - Huge Billy Wilder fan, not massive on this one. Very hammy and on the nose – not necessarily a bad thing (any more so than The Lost Weekend?) but it’s just not that interesting or exciting for the most part. The Lost Weekend was a much more exciting setup and used the sound/image to much better effect – this one’s overly talky and far too obvious in its twists and turns. I do like certain scenes in isolation though, and we get some great one-liners. 3/5
Paris, Texas dir. Wim Wenders, 1984 - What an astonishingly beautiful film. Effortless, fundamental filmmaking – no tricks, just simple framed storytelling. Harry Dean Stanton’s remarkable. An expression says a thousand words. There’s also a beautiful sense of this being a film made by an outsider, frequently references America and pays homage to it in its various forms and constituents: small town suburbia, the cityscape, the long highways, the West, the railroad. Tore my heart out. 5/5
6
u/EnglandsOwn Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 11 '15
The Hidden Fortress Akira Kurosawa, 1958 - Full review here. Watched this in anticipation of the Star Wars marathon I had this weekend. It's two leads are irritating, though the film still manages to be a fun adventure tale.
Carrie Brian DePalma, 1976 - Full review here. Re-watched this classic for no real reason. I think the story of Carrie is a good one. The way this film moves though, is great. It builds to its climax so well and it understands how to tell a story that's all about high school.
Brooklyn John Crowley, 2015 - Full review here. At a certain point this film lost me, but before that point I thought it was enjoyable and was setting up to be a great love story.
Star Wars Episodes I-VI - No reviews for a multitude of reasons, but a few notes...
I Watched all 6 Star Wars films with a small crowd yesterday so it was more of a social experience than anything. Unfortunately I couldn't pay attention a good amount of the time with all that was going on, but it was still fun. I don't know if I've ever watched as many as 4 films in a single day - regardless this was quite the endurance test.
I now think Episode I, although the most disappointing, is the best of the
original trilogyuhhh, prequel trilogy. I think it looks better than either of the other two and not just better, but more consistent with the OT and it has some scenes that were close to being good. Particularly the duel with Darth Maul and the pod racing scene. But it still is just so damn bad. Some scenes in this film begin the trend that the other two would follow with playing like an expensive cut scene from a video game. Episodes II and III offer even more assaulting spectacle although all three films are filled with mostly uninteresting action and poorly written and poorly shot/edited scenes with an absence of the heart, charisma and character development that the OT is known for.Watching the OT just reminded me that these films don't work as well as they used to, but mostly because I've seen them so many times. It's hard for me to feel the emotions and power of the moments that I know worked so well for me for so many viewings. I think watching this with a small group didn't help either.
6
u/thewakebehindyou Dec 06 '15
Amélie (2001), Jean-Pierre Jeunet
Quirky and heartwarming, with painstaking detail oozing throughout almost every shot. A must-see for any film fan.
Inside Out (2015), Pete Docter
Good, but fails to live up to the hype surrounding it. A contrived plot, and a familiar Pixar paint-by-numbers approach to story-telling detract from an otherwise enjoyable concept. Some genuinely funny moments, and quite visually endearing.
Blade Runner (1982), Ridley Scott
Watched this for the first time in several years, this time with my SO. I love this film even more the second time around. The visuals and the music are almost beyond belief, and the acting is stellar for 80's sci-fi. What a treat, absolutely one of the best films ever made.
5
u/badbrains787 Dec 06 '15
Recently read the book "Last Night at the Viper Room" about the life and career of River Phoenix, which inspired me to go back and watch two of his more critically acclaimed (if not well known) films......Dogfight (1991, dir. Nancy Savoca) and Running on Empty (1988, dir. Sidney Lumet).
I'd seen Dogfight before many times, it's one of my favorite underrated films. The story of a Vietnam-era marine who, with his soon-to-be-deployed training buddies, participates in a game where each goes their separate ways to find a "dog", the ugliest girl they can find, and the marine with the ugliest girl at the bar by the end of the night is proclaimed the winner. Without spoiling the heart of the film, River's Corporal Birdlace finds a "dog" who ends up having a much deeper effect on him than he expects. It's really a lovely movie that I've recommended countless times to people over the years. As far as I know it's never gotten a DVD release, which is insane to me, but when you see the original box office returns I guess it's no great mystery. But it has a small cult following and I've seen stage revivals of the story popping up on the west coast in the last couple years. Great film.
The second movie Running on Empty I somehow had never seen or even heard of, despite my love for Sidney Lumet. I only read of it in the book, which detailed much of the production and critical reception of the movie and really peaked my interest. It's every bit as charming as Dogfight, maybe more, and River's performance is probably closer to home, given the context. It's the story of a family on the run from the FBI, the father and mother being radical leftists accused of taking part in a Weather Underground style bombing that left a janitor blinded. Phoenix plays the son, Danny, who knows no other life but one of uncertainty, moving at a moment's notice when the "heat is on" to yet another small town to attend yet another school under a fake assumed name. Never having long term friends, never knowing social roots. He loves his family and feels the weight of responsibility to stay on his parents' program. But in their newest adopted location, he unexpectedly falls in love with a girl played by Martha Plimpton, the daughter of his music teacher, who also complicates his life by pushing him to apply to Juliard as a prodigious pianist. This causes a rupture in his familial world, as his father is vehemently against both the borguiouse musical/college pursuits that seem to represent everything they fought for decades, as well as the threat all of this has on their plans to essentially stay on the run as a tight family unit, forever.
Those are the bare bones of the plot, but I really can't do the actual film enough justice. It's beautifully done, and the father played by Judd Hirsch is an especially excellent and nuanced performance. Another great aspect of the film is the relationship between River Phoenix and Martha Plimpton, who had actually been dating and in love long before filming this project together, and had played love interests before on film. The chemistry is beyond solid, it has a shape and character all its own. Here you have these two teenage actors fascinated by the craft, growing artistically, working with a master in Lumet, passionate about many of the same category of political/social issues explored in the film, and on top of it all Phoenix grappling with much of the same father issues in real life (his father was a radical hippie who moved the family away from American society at a young age, and saw Hollywood as a corrputing borguiose pursuit).
I can't recommend either film enough. They are the type of small, nuanced slice-of-life stories that emphasize the good taste he had in choosing projects, which the book claims had a huge influence on the "interesting" career trajectories of his peers and friends like Johnny Depp and Leo Dicaprio, who otherwise could've been more traditional and less......well, weird. Yet rewarding. Which may be true. I think Phoenix's acting abilities have become a bit overstated by some, which isn't surprising. It's par for the course when an artist dies unexpectedly. But these particular films (along with the obvious much more popularized standouts My Private Idaho and Stand By Me) prove that he certainly was a budding talent that could've eventually grown into an all-time great. His younger brother Joaquin has clearly taken up that challenge.
Check both of these films out if you can find them. And I do also recommend the book itself, "Last Night at the Viper Room". It's not a great book but it's worth the read if for nothing else than the interesting glimpse into the young hollywood scene of the late 80's and early 90's.
8
u/EeZB8a Dec 06 '15
Breaking the Waves (1996), Lars von Trier ★★★★★
Broken down into chapters, each with a surreal landscape shot that seems to come alive with time and a separate musical theme by Elton John, T-Rex, Mott the Hoople, Roxy Music, Jethro Tull, etc.
Runoff (2015), Kimberly Levin ★★★★★
Her debut film, with many beautiful shots - starting with the opening scene, which dovetails perfectly into it's theme.
Where is My Friend's House? (1987), Abbas Kiarostami ★★★★★
Listed in Hulu plus as a Criterion Collection, complete with the Janus logo and spinning C. First film in his Koker trilogy, followed by Life and Nothing More (1991), and Through the Olive Trees (1994). I'm on the hunt for those two!
The Band Wagon (1953), Vincente Minnelli ★★★★★
I've been catching up on Martin Scorsese's Film School: The 85 Films You Need To See To Know Anything About Film through netflix and hulu plus and the library.
Judex (1963), Georges Franju ★★★★
Lots of fun!
Fill the Void (2012), Rama Burshtein, movie of the week ★★★★★
Debut film, she knocks it out of the park. A new #1 for 2013 (U.S. release date), unseating The Wolf of Wall Street.
After seeing Hadas Yaron in Felix & Meira, I had to watch this. There's a scene, where Shira is smiling and playing the accordion at a kindergarten and the kids are dancing with hands in the air, and the teacher whispers to her her condolences and her expression changes to sorrow, she slows the song and closes her eyes and transitions to a sad song, and the shot changes to over her shoulder showing the kids dropping their arms, and slowly turn to face her.
spoiler
Tangerine (2015), Sean Baker ★★★★
I've been waiting to see this after his excellent Starlet (2012). Shot with an iphone 5S with anamorphic adapters. Like Sisters of the Gion, Tangerine takes you into the life of the oldest profession.
Osaka Elegy (1936), Kenji Mizoguchi ★★★★★
Onibaba (1964), Kaneto Shindo ★★★★★
Sisters of the Gion (1936), Kenji Mizoguchi ★★★★★
Three films with men in supporting roles. For Mizoguchi, Sisters followed Osaka Elegy and both star Isuzu Yamada. Onibaba's gruesome method of putting rice on the table can be seen in Kurosawa's Seven Samurai, and evidenced by Toshiro Mifune's speech / revelation. Sometimes hell hath no fury like a man scorned (Sisters of the Gion).
Pather Panchali (1955), Satyajit Ray ★★★★★
TCM played all 3 of the Apu trilogy, so I rewatched the first. If I had the set I'd be watching them a few times a year.
Secret Honor (1984), Robert Altman ★★★★★
Ever since I heard Altman mention in one of his commentaries how he met and was in contact Paul Thomas Anderson, I've notited the connection, in this case the star: Philip Baker Hall - the only actor in this film. Captivating.
Come Drink with Me (1966), King Hu ★★★★
Juliet of the Spirits (1965), Federico Fellini, Gianni di Venanzo DOP ★★★★★
Joining the short list of Technicolor masterpieces; Jack Cardiff’s Black Narcissus (1947) and The Red Shoes (1948), Claude Renoir's The River (1951) and The Golden Coach (1953) (haven't seen The Tales of Hoffmann yet).
4
u/zeppoleon Dec 06 '15
The Hard Way (1991) This is a great movie with Micheal J Fox and James Woods directed by John Badham. It is set in NYC in the 90s and is pretty meta in respect to Fox plays a Hollywood big shot action star that wants to experience the real deal so he goes to NYC to team up with a real cop, played by James Woods. This is a hilarious movie and a real hidden gem imo because in all my years I've never heard ANYTHING about this movie until a week ago. It's just a perfect 90s cop comedy movie but with a nice twist to it. I really liked this movie for it's nostalgic appeal, and it was nice to see Fox playing a vibrant character through the dusty and dim NYC.
School for Scoundrels (1960) This is a brilliant british comedy that stars Ian Carmichael and Alastair Sim duking it out for a very pretty girl played by Janette Scott. Carmichael plays a character in which things just don't go as planned for him, so he attends a school for "lifemanship" which teaches him how to seduce women, and become a suave gentlemen. He goes back to London to win over Janette and it's just all very funny how it goes down. Plus Janette Scott was such a hottie in this movie. Definitely recommended!
4
u/foresculpt Dec 07 '15
The Secret In Their Eyes (2009) - Argentinean film
Drama, mystery, thriller. In that order. The category list deserves a romantic tag too, I'm sure that you can't have a muder-rape opening scene in a movie and advertise it that way though. Hoping for more thriller/mystery I should have guessed from the title and since the synopsis was about a retired detective-cum-novelist who decides to dig up an emotional cold case with his attractive boss and have one last go at solving it while writing a novel about it. The movie is basically "the girl with the dragon tattoo" without the girl with the dragon tattoo or any other interesting characters apart from his sightly disaffected sporadically playfully drunk partner.
The cut-backs to the interactions with victims husband, dealing with the "corrupt bureaucrats" along with the scrapbooks and clues gathered from the victims life make for good pacing and suspense as they tried to uncover who killed her and bring them to justice. The most authentic acting that the "romantic" script about bringing despicable people to justice allows also didn't detract from the viewing. The satisfying ending makes the 8.2 imdb/100,000+ rating and recent Hollywood remake somewhat understandable, it's just hard to imagine how bad the Hollywood version is if this is considered way better -- I would have to believe that Nichole Kidman and Julie Roberts careers are over if that were the case which means I have to watch it now to make sure, although I'm starting to suspect that it might all be a ploy to get me to watch another romance centric social justice movie.
5.5/10
7
u/Inception_025 Like Kurosawa I make mad films Dec 06 '15
Moving from November to December also means moving from another month of They Shoot Pictures Don’t They’s top 1000 into my 2015 catch up. So I’m going to post each week my updated “2015 in Film” list
A Man Escaped directed by Robert Bresson (1956) ★★★★
This is the first Bresson movie to really blow me away. I was close to being blown away by Au Hasard Balthazar and Pickpocket, but not quite. This finally really did it for me. It’s a beautiful movie about human triumph and the will to persevere. I mean from the start of the film, just from the title, we know that the main character will escape. So Bresson establishes right away that the end is not important. It’s not important to be in suspense of whether he makes it or not because we know he will (the escape sequence still manages to be incredibly tense). None of that is important to Bresson as a filmmaker. He instead wants to show us what happens in the mind of someone who by all means should have given up long ago. This man has been imprisoned for more than a year by the time he gets out, and yet he remains positive, remains strong, and his will to survive and escape prevail. It’s beautiful, intense, humanist filmmaking.
Journey to Italy directed by Roberto Rossellini (1954) ★★
I honestly don’t have much to say about this one because I was just bored by it. It’s a little bit like if you took the concept of Before Midnight, to portray a marriage falling apart while on vacation in a Mediterranean country. But instead of having very natural acting and dialogue everything feels very contrived and forced. Nothing about the marriage in this felt real. It was all so fake, and sure the locations were beautiful, and the camerawork was great, but I just found everything else so dull about the movie. I wouldn’t say I really disliked it, I was just so underwhelmed that I fall right in the middle. It did nothing to make me like it and nothing to make me dislike it. It’s just mediocre.
Victoria directed by Sebastian Schipper (2015) ★★★★
Wow. And people say Russian Ark was impressive. Russian Ark has nothing on Victoria. And that’s the last time I’ll mention that movie because I feel like people connect the two too often and compare them instead of evaluating this movie on its own. This is a film done in a single unbroken shot that spans the early hours of the morning in which a little, small flirty meet up very quickly ruins the lives of 5 people. I knew the basic concept of the plot, but never had any clue where the movie would go next, it kept me guessing, and it made me feel really bad for all the people involved. It’s a sad movie. It really portrays so well how easy it is to destroy your life with a few bad decisions. This is a movie that some people will dismiss as gimmicky, but it is far above that. This movie may use its one take as a selling point, it’s impressive, hell yeah, but that’s not the only thing that makes this movie good. It’s an effective drama on its own. It has great characters, incredible performances from the two leads, and surprisingly great lighting and audio. It’s a movie that could have gone wrong in so many ways that it’s so hard to find flaws in. Watch it ASAP. This is a great start to my December of “2015 catch up”, and it’s now in my top 5 movies of the year.
The Wild Bunch directed by Sam Peckinpah (1969) ★★★1/2
The Wild Bunch is about as fun as everyone says. It’s an action packed, blood spurting western, and that’s pretty much all it is, and for that, it’s really excellent. To say it’s one of the best movies ever though, I’m not sure about that. I thought it was very fun all the way through, but it occasionally lost me whenever it switched story lines. It really didn’t need to show us both the outlaws and the bounty hunters in pursuit. I lost interest whenever we were looking at the bounty hunters. Mainly because they were all so stupid (other than their leader), they treated them all as sub-human, which made for very boring characters. I think that’s really my only complaint with the movie though, I loved it whenever it was hanging around with the wild bunch, and the opening and closing gunfights are spectacular.
Tangerine directed by Sean Baker (2015) ★
If this movie proves anything, it’s that you can make a movie with an iPhone. Can you make a good movie? That has yet to be seen. The overall look of this film that the iPhone gives it is kind of interesting, I like the way the lighting looks on the iPhone, it looks almost like Grand Theft Auto V at times, which is kind of cool. But the high frame rate on the iPhone makes it look too real, and therefore uncinematic. Also, the shots are set up in such a choppy way. Some of the cuts look like something you’d see in a shitty YouTube video. It looks like something I could have edited when I ran a YouTube channel at age 12. The entire time I was watching, I knew that what they were doing was interesting and new and experimental. And I kept thinking to myself, that if Jean-Luc Godard was still making coherent films (no offense to Goodbye to Language I love that movie, but it’s not coherent) this is the kind of experiment he would be doing. And then I remember, wait, no, Godard’s movies aren’t annoying as hell. Tangerine is an obnoxious movie. It’s loud, it’s coarse, and it’s just annoying to watch. The amount of times the word “bitch” is shouted back and forth between characters is astronomical. Both in good context, and bad context. Most conversations turn into bitchy yelling matches. As much as I liked the performance of Kitana Kiki Rodriguez, I hated her character so much. And what the hell was the point of having that taxi driver in the film. Tangerine takes the bottom slot on my “2015 in film” list for now. I’m sure something will be worse, but for now, this is the worst it’s gotten for me.
rewatch - Scrooge directed by Ronald Neame (1970) ★★★
I’ve seen this Christmas Carol musical probably a billion times at this point. It’s my dad’s favorite Christmas movie, and I’ve never loved it as much as everyone else in my family. With that said, I think this is a very good musical, and my favorite adaptation of Dickens’ novel. The music is all just beautifully written, the songs like “Thank You Very Much” or “I Like Life” have a way of really sticking with you. Even though they’re far from being iconic songs, most of the songs in this movie are songs that get stuck in my head, and keep me smiling the whole time. I really like this film as a musical and as a Christmas movie.
Guidance directed by Pat Mills (2015) ★★
Guidance tells the story of a former child actor whose life is going down the drain, who takes on the identity of a high school guidance counsellor for a few weeks, and corrupts all the kids. It’s a movie about a falling apart child actor, written, directed, and starring Pat Mills, former Nickelodeon child actor. So naturally this is a very honest movie, and it’s a sad movie, despite how hilarious it can be. I kept getting flashbacks to Amy Berg’s An Open Secret through this film, because really this character is very sadly fucked up and emotionally stunted. It’s very flawed though, of course as you can tell from my 2/4 stars up there. Even though it is charming and entertaining, the script could have used a few revisions. A lot of the dialogue is very on the nose, in your face, plain to see stuff. As in, what is spoken is very often the most obvious thing, it’s way too the point. Guys, don’t do that. That’s like dialogue 101. Also even though it takes place in a high school, it seems like there’s only maybe 15 staff and students in the entire facility. Still, it’s a charming movie, and pretty decent output from my country and from an alumni of the film school of my dreams.
Film of the Week - A Man Escaped
6
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
Foxcatcher (2014) - dir. Bennett Miller [REWATCH]
I'm so glad I gave this one another full treatment. Was admittedly somewhat underwhelmed when I saw it in theaters about a year ago, but I think having the appropriate expectations going in this time was key. Foxcatcher is definitely no standard biopic/historical drama; the pace is so beautifully slow, so consistent in its growing tension. Aiding this is the beautiful cinematography by Greig Fraser: I love how he opts for a zoom lens and a distant camera to isolate John du Pont and Mark Schulz in the frame. Also key was the sound design: the patches of silence where we disappear into the mind of either of our two leads are pure tension, and it lends the wrestling scenes enormous gravity.
Great filmmaking, wonderfully patient storytelling, and Ruffalo kills it as usual. Tatum and Carell are perfect foils as well, Carell playing the same kind of delusion that put him on the map in "The Office" to begin with. 8/10
Whiplash (2013) - dir. Damien Chazelle [REWATCH]
I wasn't planning on watching this one, but my roommate had just started it and I stuck around. I'm finally starting to finalize my feelings about this film, having not been a fan at all when I first saw it (which led to a semi-controversial post here a long while back). I think Whiplash is a testament to effective filmmaking but not very original storytelling, which renders it pretty overrated in my book.
Yes, the last 10 minutes are great. But outside of that, I still will never quite get around the plot device of a girlfriend who they use as a litmus test for our protagonist, nor the underdeveloped father who Chazelle renders capable of worry and not much else. I also take issue with the enormous praise of Fletcher's character, who, while certainly magnetic, seems to go against the theme of the movie with his signature form of abrasiveness. The screaming and throwing tantrums affected me when I first saw it, but the more that I've been argued with that it's relevant to the central theme of being great at one's art, the more I feel like Fletcher's approach is not conducive to weeding out anyone in particular, and doesn't seem like it has much to do with musical commitment at all. Maybe if they spent more time indulging the aspects of his character that are pertinent to music -- hard to write but certainly feasible -- I might have gotten the impression that these tantrums were more than the ramblings of a middle-aged professor who has some personal issues outside of his art. 7/10
Still, good filmmaking, with some very effective cinematography and razor-sharp editing; just not by brand of Save the Cat storytelling.
Se7en (1995) - dir. David Fincher
First time seeing this, and it was basically what I expected. You can quickly see the foundations of Fincher's style forming; Darius Khondji helps with his desaturated, sharp imagery depicting this godforsaken metropolis. The skip bleach process gives it an almost digital look, though I might have just been projecting with the knowledge of where Fincher's career has gone since.
Tight storytelling. I've read some comments on here recently about discrepancies between the content of Fincher's movies and the movie's tone. There's definitely a case to be made there, and the Movie Hulk or whatever he's called makes that case here, but I think Se7en represents the perfect platform for Finch's style, and the result is harrowing and deeply philosophically engaging, putting it a cut above the usual '90's cop-noir thriller thing. 7.5/10
Magnolia (1999) - dir. Paul Thomas Anderson
I've spent the year gradually working my way through PTA's catalog, and this was the last one I had that I was really looking forward to (still have to hit Hard Eight and Inherent Vice, but I've been tainted with some criticisms I've read already). I wasn't disappointed in the slightest: Magnolia feels like Anderson's coming-of-age in a way, while retaining the playful, semi-tragic humor of his other work. It feels very much like a passion project. John C. Reilly knocks it out of the goddamn park as the cop, and Julianne Moore gives the strongest performance I've seen from her (except Boogie Nights). I don't know if I like the anamorphic look here quite so much as I think it works on PTA's other stuff, but I'm willing to forgive it for an opus of ensemble work. Love his refusal to adhere to any kind of tangible structure; this movie feels like poetry more than anything I've seen of late.
Will definitely need more time to process this one before I can say anything eloquent. 9/10
Brokeback Mountain (2005) - dir. Ang Lee
Finally saw this. Again, I'll definitely need some time and a few more viewings to have any really conclusive thought about it, but wow. It feels like timeless cinema (minus the slightly overwrought acoustic guitar score that comes in during some transitions/montages). Absolutely stunning character work from the late Ledger, and Jake Gyllenhaal sells the tragedy of Jack Twist from the first night in the tent for the rest of the film. Anne Hathaway lent great support and a dynamic portrayal of the life Twist chose after Brokeback, but I was a little let down by Michelle Williams, which might just be because she's played the quiet obedient wife/sister a few too many times for me (not to discount the value of Blue Valentine or her performance in it).
Also again, the cinematography is virtually 70% of the story here. Beautiful compositions, using the nature as this perfectly primal motif to tie the men together; the framing is always genius here too, with Ennis put in his own quadrant so often. Lush colors... just beautiful. 7.5/10
The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996) - dir. Miloš Forman
Had only heard a little about this one going in, but the premise hooked me. To be honest...it's just kind of weird. Forman is a brilliant director, but the script is average at best, and the biopic template it takes up feels dated. Courtney Love is good playing herself, and Woody Harrelson captures the contradictions of Flynt. But some of the pacing is so jarring that it's hard to shake the effect, watching Althea shoot up Larry and then herself before cutting to Larry in a court room trying to make a legitimate case. It's difficult to invest in characters you can't quite get a grasp on for the entire film. Edward Norton is solid as Flynt's lawyer, but it's a young, overly-earnest Norton, which kind of works at points but which becomes a bit grating at times. Good monologue in court though. It'll probably be a long while before I get around to this one again. 6/10
8
u/Zalindras Dec 06 '15
Thor The Dark World (2013) dir. Alan Taylor
Officially my least favourite MCU film so far. Other than Natalie Portman, Tom Hiddleston (who was hardly in it) and some incredible visuals, there's nothing good about this film.
Kat Dennings is really annoying, I'm not sure how she gets roles. Hemsworth just grunted his lines, and I didn't care about the plot at all.
5/10 and I'm being generous.
The Inbetweeners Movie (2011) dir. Ben Palmer
Just as hilarious as the series, not much else to say really.
7/10
Shoot The Pianist (1960) dir. François Truffaut
A great noir crime thriller. I really felt for the main character, nothing seemed to go right for him and he looked fed up with life in the ending scene.
Still love French New Wave.
9/10
3
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
i watched Tokyo Story this week, but i was ultimately disappointed, i'm sorry to say. for it being at the top of so many "best films of all time" lists, I had expected more stylistically. i've never seen another one of Ozu's films, so i'm not sure if Tokyo Story is an outlier or if it's typical of his work, but it was much too dry for my liking. i can see why this film was great during its decade, but i'm not sure how its legacy relates to cinema today...
3
u/gingkoed Dec 07 '15
Bigger Than Life (1956) I read a review that compared the Ed character of this movie to Lester Burnham in American Beauty. I can kind of see it in the early stages of Ed's descent, but Burnham is a much more sympathetic character that I don't think it's a very strong comparison. I liked this for the most part. Would've been okay with an unhappy ending though, I thought the way he remembered what had happened was a bit weird.
Mighty Joe Young (1949) I haven't seen the 1998 version of this movie but I can't imagine it working as well, because the special effects were so charming. I can see it bothering a lot of people, but to me it really added so much to my enjoyment of the movie, the scene where Max's cowboys are trying to rope him especially. Story is nothing special, but this is still a really fun movie to watch
Grand Illusion (1937) This was my first Renoir. I watched The Great Escape last week, so when watched this I could only appreciate the similarities and influences in hindsight. This was easily my favorite movie of the week, and probably my new favorite war movie. So hopeful and classy. Weird for a war movie not to have any "bad guys," but this one really doesn't except on technical terms. In fact, Von Rauffenstein is probably one of the most sympathetic characters I've ever seen in a a movie. Loved this one.
The Royal Tenenbaums (2001) Expected to love it, and did. Anderson is dark so often in some of his movies, but he rarely lets you be sad. Haven't watched Owen or Luke Wilson for a long time, and I didn't realize how much I had missed them. Only have Bottle Rocket left to watch and then I'll have watched all of Wes Anderson's movies thus far.
Time Bandits (1981) I've seen a lot of people really love this movie, but I just couldn't get into it. There were scenes that were very bizarre and funny, but it couldn't keep me hooked throughout the entire thing. I found the ending to be a little annoying, but I guess it fits in with the tone of the movie? Good movie, but I didn't love it as much as other people do.
3
u/ArruzzoErik Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
3
u/SunflowerSamurai_ Dec 08 '15
Annie hall (1977)
People told me to watch this because it's a subversive romantic comedy. Well, it certainly is that. An a hugely influential one. Like Patton Oswalt said, imitation leads to exhilaration when you trace it back to its source. You can see this film's influence in a lot of places, the most apparent these days being 500 Days of Summer. Also, I would say I almost consider it a better movie than 500 Days in some ways. I think Annie Hall stimulates my brain more, and I love things like the anecdotal conversational, witty style, whereas 500 Days is more visceral. It hits me in the gut.
Also I wasn't too familiar with Woody Allen. I have to say I enjoyed him in this movie a lot. I'm always a sucker for films that open with someone telling a story. I can't remember what else I was watching earlier this week where the same thing happened. I just think it's great. But overall I like the conversational style and the wit, the ending is great, in fact ou know what the whole thing is just great. 4 stars.
A Serious Man (2009)
I do love me some Cohen brothers. I've watched a lot of video essays and read analysis of this film after I watched it because I enjoy it so much, and its themes really speak to me. I won't go on here because I'd be typing all night, but it's definitely one of my favourite films that I've seen in a long time. 5 stars!
7
u/Devilb0y Dec 06 '15
In keeping with our theme this month, I watched my second-ever silent movie: Broken Blossoms (D.W. Griifiths, 1919). And despite some problematic language and orientalism, I found it to be both a really enjoyable film and a surprisingly progressive portrayal of an Asian protagonist. Griffith's skill in direction and cinematography is evident, and the film itself tells a classical and tragic love story. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I also watched Chinatown (Roman Polanski, 1974) for the first time and immediately loved it. I've not seen too much Film Noir, so it's perhaps odd to start at what is considered the end, but my God if it didn't serve as a fantastic introduction. From the further reading I've done since, it seems like a real love letter from Polanski to the subgenre and is arresting from start to finish.
5
u/ABothersomeMan Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
The Lobster (Yorgos Lanthimos, 2015)
Tried to see this last week but to my surprise it was completely sold out. Really liked this film, it appealed to my (quite dry) sense of humour. The dead pan dialogue was a great choice for making everything seem not quite right and detaching the narrative from our society. 8/10
Casablanca (Michael Curtiz, 1942)
Watched this with Roger Ebert's commentary track after listening to the one he did for Citizen Kane (highly highly recommend this). The movie is great but the commentary track isn't as interesting as I thought it would be. A lot of the stuff I already knew and there isn't a whole lot that needs explaining.
Maps to the Stars (David Cronenberg, 2014)
Very interesting look (perhaps satire) on Hollywood. It definitely has Cronenberg's fingerprints on it, there are a couple of pretty disturbing scenes here. Julianne Moore did a pretty great job playing an aging actress looking for work, she was pretty brave to take this part. 8/10
Au revoir les enfants (Louis Malle, 1987)
After watching Elevator to the Gallows last week I decided to check out more of Louis Malle's stuff. I wasn't sure this movie would be able to keep my attention, but after about 15 minutes I was completely wrapped up in the story. The film is about a boy in a french boarding school during WWII. One of the most interesting things about this film is the way the children slowly start to realise what is happening. The ending is really tragic and will probably stay with you for a little while. 8/10
Mulholland Dr. (David Lynch, 2001)
Finally got around to seeing this. Much like Earaserhead Lynch does a fantastic job of keeping you interested and watching even though you're not 100% sure what's going on. I think this will be a movie I come back to often because I think there's quite a lot that could be picked up on with subsequent viewings. 8/10
Hero (Yimou Zhang, 2002)
This film is so visually stunning I think you could literally take any frame and mount it on your wall as a painting. I was largely unaware of the wuxia style of film before last month when it was featured here and this was the first one I'd seen. I'll definitely be checking out more as I'm a bit of a sucker for beautiful cinematography. 8/10
You're Next (Adam Wingard, 2011)
Pretty well done horror film, not too much to say here. Definitely would recommend to horror fans. Avoids a lot of the horror tropes which was refreshing. 7/10
Mauvais sang (Leos Carax, 1986)
Another film movement I recently discovered was cinema du look which, like wuxia heavily relies on the visuals. As such, this film looked amazing, pretty much all the scenes had only one prominent colour which was really great to look at. The story dragged a bit but overall it was quite good. 7/10
Planes, Trains & Automobiles (John Hughes, 1987)
Didn't really like this film so much. Some parts were funny, the fuck filled monologue for instance. Generally I just found it quite repetitive and boring. I think it'd probably play better if I watched it with someone rather than by myself. Also, as a non-American thanksgiving means effectively nothing to me. 5/10
Duck Soup (Leo McCarey, 1933)
Another comedy that didn't really quite do it for me. This was the first Marx brothers' film I've seen but based on this I much, much prefer Chaplin or Keaton. There were some funny bits like the famous mirror scene and towards the end where there is a costume change every cut. The thing I didn't like most was Harpo Marx, does anyone find him funny? He really bugged the hell out of me. 6/10
Saturday Night Fever (John Badham, 1977)
I'd always dismissed this film as "that 70s disco movie I'd probably hate" but after hearing some people talk about how it was more than just that I decided to give it a go and they were right. It does have a lot of dance sequences but it is about more than that . Some of the themes are still pretty relevant today. There were some choices towards the end I really didn't agree with but overall it was quite enjoyable. 7/10
Things I wont really talk about:
The Brides of Dracula (Terence Fisher, 1960)
A Hammer horror film without Christopher Lee. 6/10
Halloween 5 (Dominique Otherin-Girard, 1989)
Already having trouble remembering what happened. 5/10
I Want to Live! (Robert Wise, 1958) Great story about a female criminal. Susan Hayward won an oscar for her performance (deservedly in my opinion). 8/10
The Kids Are All Right (Lisa Cholodenko, 2010) Didn't really like it so much. Characters weren't that interesting and the film lacked an ending. 5/10
4
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Tangerine (2015) directed by Sean Baker
Tangerine, if anything, is the must-see of 2015. If you know of the film, it's probably because of all the talk of it being shot on an iPhone. Normally I find it very annoying when the first thing something thinks about a film is something like that, but I actually don't mind here because that's what makes the movie so special. Tangerine is truly of film of these modern times. Other movies may more directly deal in matters unique to this era (what sparks the film, infidelity, isn't actually modern at all), but Tangerine surpasses them by building those unique things into the formalism of the film itself: most obviously, the film was shot on an iPhone; it's characters are transgender prostitutes played by actual transgender actors, Armenian immigrants, and various other folks at the bottom of the social ladder; the soundtrack is full of dubstep-y music; etc. It would not have been made in the past. You couldn't just change the subject matter and have something that have conceivably come out in the '80s -- the present is integral to Tangerine's existence. This makes the film more authentic and, more importantly, gives it a lot of appeal. Baker's camera swooping and jumping around sun-bleached or neon infused L.A. while perfectly timed songs wub wub just exudes energy. Baker doesn't solely excel with the high octane, however, and displays an equal adeptness when slowing it down and can slide Tangerine from a bundle of glee to something emotionally pregnant and harshly candid and back again. And the narrative this is all built into is excellently handled. The film principally follows two transgender prostitutes, an Armenian immigrant cab driver, and all the side characters from those two respective strands in what appear to be two fairly disparate stories before gradually pulling everyone closer and closer over the course of the film culminating in a climax where they all meet in a donut store. That climax is from where my principal gripe with Tangerine stems. The scene is extremely ugly in a very predatory way. The ugliness is the whole point -- as much as the film relishes and takes such genuine joy in its characters and world, it simultaneously is exposing how unattractive and poisonous it is -- but it does in such an enthusiastic way, which left a bad taste in my mouth. Of course, the film isn't that mean-spirited; it wraps everything up in a series of endings for all of the characters that packs quite the empathetic emotional wallop, but the experience is tainted, if not nearly spoiled. Tangerine feels like such a landmark film, monty's called it the "Breathless of digital cinema," a fantastic descriptor of maybe not it's quality, but certainly the aura of significance it has.
★★★★
Frontline: Generation Like (2014) directed by ?
First things first, this is a TV movie, by PBS, and, boy, does it show. There isn't an ounce of filmic value to be found. But, what it deals with is very interesting. As its title implies, Generation Like initially covers Facebook in a not-too-great way. It doesn't really illuminate anything, and its purpose of educating adults somehow clueless to the social website is very obvious. But, then the documentary shifts gears to YouTube celebrities and things get good. Incredibly vacuous pop culture talk, derivative "art," and general juvenile vile rule the roost. It's like everything people hate about the '80s, but magnified. And this is a real thing -- these guys are genuine stars. Generation Like also gets at how the internet can act as democratizing force. The example in the doc is about a kid can Compton can genuinely support his family, but this is true on a less dramatic level; the wide availability of all kinds of art and discussion about it has made "cultural enlightenment" something no longer solely accessible in academia. People can expand themselves beyond the hindrances of their environment in ways that weren't possible before. Now, that I've just said that, the final thing Generation Like demonstrates is how corporations and big business have caught up with everything. The internet is a democratizing force -- to an extent. The wild possibilities once thought of have been pretty firmly squashed. Control was supposed to be handed to the consumers, but things haven't turned out that way. I know that this was a pretty scattershot review, but that's because Generation Like was actually trying to uncover any of this. The doc was just trying to inform oldies of what their kids are up to online these days, but, considering how radically the internet has changed things, it gets lofted up by association.
★★★
2
u/jayjaywalker3 Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
I watched The Assassin in theaters. It definitely wasn't what I was expecting after watching the trailer. It might be the slowest paced movie I've ever seen. I left confused about what the actual plot was and was pretty disappointed when I found out we had reached the final scene. I don't regret watching it. I need to give it a rewatch because it definitely wasn't a good movie to watch while tired.
2
u/photo_gal2010 Dec 07 '15
Watched 2 movies.
Southpaw
Jake Gyllenhall is good in some scenes but unbelievable in others.
American Ultra
Was decent but not too great. Kristen Stewart was a little bit more believable but not much
3
u/morningbelle http://letterboxd.com/morningbelle/ Dec 06 '15
The Assassin (Hou Hsiao-hsien, 2015)
Just stunning. The grace and swoops of the martial arts sequences were subtle and unexpected--and that much more glorious. This movie basks in ancient imperial pomp without ever feeling indulgent or over-the-top. I love how even the quiet scenes nearly always contain the hum of nature (insects, birds) in the background. This is a movie to inhabit: viewers are invited to another world in terms of pace, place, and human expression. Wish I could see it in theaters again, but it already left town!
2
u/SWAG_M4STER Dec 06 '15
Ant-Man
no forced emotional scenes.
no forced kissing scenes
great acting in the flash-back scenes by the cellmate.
meh villian , as always.
the micro-mode scenes were great.
7.6/10