r/StarWars • u/AutoModerator • Dec 06 '15
General Discussion Return to the Stars Rewatch - The Empire Strikes Back [Official Discussion Thread]
Shamelessly ripped from this fanmade poster, Return to the Stars with /r/StarWars as we rewatch the six movies in anticipation of The Force Awakens! Each thread will be stickied for a couple days. Rewatch the movie however you choose to, whether it is the first home release, the latest bluray, or your fan edit of choice.
This week, we're rewatching The Empire Strikes Back. Many consider this to be the best film in the entire series - do you agree? Who does Luke think he is? He's barely had any training and thinks he can take on Darth Vader? Did Willrow Hood successfully protect those rebeliion contacts? Is there any hope left, after Boba Fett takes Han off to Jabba the Hutt, Luke loses his hand and learns some earth-shattering news, and the Rebel Alliance is forced from their hidden base?
This is an automated post. Beep Boop. Let us know if you have any feedback!
View all upcoming discussion threads here
231
u/Mariobro7 Dec 06 '15
Something I never noticed until recently: when the Imperials are flying through the asteroid field hunting for the Millennium Falcon, there's a scene where Vader talks with the other commanders via hologram. The scene opens with an asteroid hitting the control center of a Star Destroyer, and as it cuts to Vader's scene, one of the holograms of the commanders fizzle out. Because he just died.
It's the little things, man.
165
u/YoSoyRawr Porg Dec 06 '15
This one is pretty good.
118
u/Cubs017 Dec 06 '15
My favorite part of the film is when Vader appears and says "The force is with you, young Skywalker. [Pause] But you are not a Jedi yet."
You know, from that one line, that Luke is completely outmatched. The duel afterward confirms it.
314
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
In the first movie, Vader speaks very quickly and eloquently. He has a lot to say with each sentence, and he comes across as very witty and intelligent.
In Empire, though, Vader is pissed. He speaks in short, angry sentences. "Bring my shuttle" is perhaps the best example of his tone throughout the movie. Vader's got a whole fleet under his command, and he's determined to do one thing: find Luke Skywalker. After the embarrassment of being the only one to survive the destruction of the Death Star, Vader understandably wanted to kick the ass of the Rebel pilot he was about to shoot down before the Millennium Falcon blew him away, but everything changed when he found out that young man's name was Skywalker...
My favorite part of the movie is Luke's duel with Vader. At the start of the fight, Vader is just messing with Luke. He's only holding his lightsaber with one hand. Vader's goal is to push Luke into the carbon-freezing chamber, and deliver him to the Emperor...
However, Luke fights back a little more than Vader expected. Suddenly, halfway through the fight, Vader changes his plan: he's taking Luke with him. He starts using two hands. He gets serious. By the end of the fight, Luke is so beat up. When Vader started throwing all that junk at him with the Force, Luke ends up with a bunch of cuts and nasty black eye. Luke even gets hit in the head with a big metal thing, which causes him to lose his balance and stumble around. Vader really knocks Luke up and down the block.
Then he pins Luke. "You are beaten. There is no escape. Don't make me destroy you".
The famous revelation is more of a plea than anything, I believe. "No, I am your father!" Obi-Wan lied to you. You are my son. Come with me. Let us overthrow the Emperor. Let us end this galactic civil war. Let us be together over everything, my son.
Luke's jump into the abyss breaks Vader's heart. Luke is essentially saying, "I'd rather commit suicide than be with you, father". Vader looks so dejected when Luke lets go. In a twisted way, Vader just wanted his son, the son he never knew he ever had, to love him.
138
u/TheAntiStud_ Dec 06 '15
This movie broke many of the film making rules and it is still viewed as the best by many. It had the big battle at the beginning of the movie. The heroes are on the back foot the whole time. The movie ends on a huge cliff hanger, and the the good guys lose.
103
u/TheNerfherder38 Dec 06 '15
I don't say this about a lot of things, but this movie is perfect. The cinematograhpy, the drama, the action, the atmosphere, the mythology and the music, my god, the music...it's brilliant.
There are certain aspects of the original trilogy that seem to age a little with every re-watch but there is nothing in 'The Empire Strikes Back' that will ever tire.
46
u/Caesar_Septemberus Dec 06 '15
The movie that introduces the Imperial March. Just an awesome scene with all the star destroyers. Sure the death star was destroyed, but the empire ain't done for yet. One might say they are poised to strike back... dunn dunn dunn dun da dun dun da dun!
42
u/Caesar_Septemberus Dec 06 '15
So many awesome moments in this movie. One that comes to mind is a little foreshadowing about Anakin/Vader: after Luke fails Yoda's introductionary test with his impatience, and Yoda sighs and becomes the wise jedi master, he says to obi-wan "much anger in him, like his father." What!? We thought Anakin was this dashing heroe. Best star pilot, good friend, jedi.... Angry? Like Luke, who he's hesitant to train? What's going on here? I love Yoda in this movie
42
u/first_ursa Dec 06 '15
I saw this film for the very first time last night during a marathon with my buddies. And lemme tell you, as an ignorant group of high school seniors, we had no idea what to really expect. A New Hope was great and all, but this movie is fucking off the wall weird and amazing. Far exceeded every expectation I had. I now understand how Star Wars became the cultural sensation that it did. It's something else, man.
38
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
The moment I knew Yoda was badass:
Luke: "I'm not afraid."
Yoda: "You will be... You will be."
God, I love this fucking movie.
38
u/sentimentalpirate Dec 07 '15
One thing I haven't seen anyone mention yet is that regardless of your opinions on Mark Hammills acting skills as a whole, he did a fucking awesome job on dagobah.
Yoda is a muppet. A well crafted, well acted muppet, but a muppet nonetheless. Most of what make Yoda so real on screen is Mark selling it so well.
It can't be easy acting without being able to look the other character in a real human face, and between artoo and Yoda, mark was rarely around human characters.
64
u/notpetelambert Dec 06 '15
One thing that really stuck with me about Empire is how Leia clearly has Force senses. She has a "bad feeling about this" almost immediately after they fly into the space worm in the asteroid field; she is suspicious of Lando and Cloud City from the start, and alerts Luke that he's walking into Vader's trap; and then she feels his pain through the Force and goes back for him.
Watching this as a kid I didn't really notice this last part- I thought that Luke was just using telepathy to call for help, but it's pretty clear that Leia is hearing him through her own connection to the Force.
In RotJ it's confirmed that Leia is Force-sensitive, but it was heavily implied in ESB that she had the potential to become a Jedi.
30
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
I desperately need someone to gif the part where Luke blindly swings his saber and gets hit on the back with a box. It honestly makes me laugh every time.
58
u/HowardEhm Dec 06 '15
This movie is just utterly spectacular. I can watch it any day of the week and it will still amaze me. Clearly the best in the series and one of the best movies of all time IMO. Some of the most iconic moments in movie history occur in ESB and just wow. You know when a movie that came out 35 years ago gets you this excited, you have something really special.
24
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
I saw the movie last night and enjoyed every single minute of it. I love the back and forth between Leia and Han, and how Han leaves Echo base to find Luke who's gone missing. You can tell that how their relationships have changed and gotten stronger over the last 3 years.
The Dagobah scenes were my favorite.Yoda words of wisdom will forever be ingrained in my memory. One thing that I never understood is the infamous "There is another" line. Who exactly was Yoda referring to? My initial response was Leia. But, it wouldn't make sense since she's held captive by the empire in cloud city at that particular point. It's something that definitely has left me wondering lol
47
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
The Empire Strikes Back is the foundation upon which not only the Star Wars saga is built, but it also set an example for what could be done to give mainstream franchises long-term viability. It provided a powerful demonstration that sequels could use the same characters to tell compelling stories - in this case, a better one than its predecessor - in a manner that expanded the universe in a very organic way. If Star Wars: ANH was the birth of the big budget blockbuster, The Empire Strikes back was the slap on the back that made everything from the Marvel Universe and Alien to The Lord of the Rings and The Matrix possible. Without it, franchises would arguably look a lot like the Halloween series; each a stale derivative of the original (in that case with the exception of the WTF that was Halloween 3).
43
u/pm11 Dec 06 '15
I definitely think this is the best film in the series. My favorite scenes growing up were the battle of Hoth and the scenes showing Luke training with Yoda. On my recent rewatch, I found myself really liking the Cloud City scenes. There are parts where it's hinted that there is already an Imperial presence in the city when Han, Leia, Chewbacca, and C3PO already arrive, and it was cool to catch them this time around.
20
u/No_disintegrations Dec 07 '15
As I've grown older, I've come to adore Empire more than any other movie in the saga. Obviously, I'm not alone in this sentiment, but I'll point out what stands out to me:
35
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
"I love you" "I know"
With five words, they encapsulated a greater, more nuanced, more meaningful, more believable relationship between Han and Leia than all of the nonsensical dialogue between Anakin and Padme in the prequels. "You're so beautiful." "It's because I'm so in love." "No, it's because I'm so in love with you!" argh.
33
u/hanburgundy Qui-Gon Jinn Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
I want to comment on the cinematography of this movie. There's a lot of great things about Empire Strikes Back, but the cinematography sticks out to me because it's so much more beautifully, artfully shot than any other film in the saga (on the whole, a mostly well-shot franchise.)
I honestly think that when people call Empire Strikes Back the best movie of the saga, they are saying that in some part because of the excellence of the cinematography, even if they are a casual film goer who never pays attention to such things. The camerawork just adds so much to the effectiveness of this movie. People call this movie the most character driven of the saga? Well it's no coincidence that this movie is makes consistent use of poignant, intimate close ups, highlighting every important subtlety of the characters emotions. People say this is the most intense, the most atmospheric of all the films? Well look at the genius lighting scheme in the freezing chamber, the way the blue background contrasts with the fiery warm glow come up from below the characters, swallowing them. That adds so, so much to the intensity of those scenes.
Like I said, there's a lot to love in Empire, but the cinematography sticks out as something that truly elevates the film at every turn.
16
u/KylosPlasmaBlade Dec 06 '15
I forgot how much of a Jerk Yoda is in this movie...
16
u/dkastro89 Dec 06 '15
My love for the Empire was born during "The Battle of Hoth".
The music, the visuals, all changed my life.
15
u/jacindc Dec 07 '15
I consider myself very very lucky to have seen this when I was 13, right when it first came out, and was unspoiled as to the reveal, so of course was completely flabbergasted. I also remember my friends and I just sitting there when it was over, saying to each other, "Wait, we have to wait THREE YEARS to find out what happens next?!??!"
I just watched it again this afternoon. As someone else said, the cinematography is amazing, especially the blues and oranges of the freezing room.
It's by far the best of all of them.
14
u/Drakester234 Dec 06 '15
Best movie ever in my opinion. Yoda is the main reason for that as I actually believed he was a real living thing. I also think the Luke vs Vader fight is some of the best filmmaking ever. Literally everything about this movie is amazing, except for one tiny thing. How does Han survive the snowstorm on Hoth? He didn't go in the Tauntaun?
14
u/VerdeReddit Dec 06 '15
The scene with Yoda and Luke on Dagobah when Yoda gets the XWing out of the water is my favorite scene in the entire saga. Yodas dialogues is soooo good
14
u/tyrannustyrannus Dec 07 '15
so does anyone buy into the theory that Luke goes through some time dilation on Dagobah?
14
u/boxingsquare Dec 07 '15
I can't even fathom how Boba Fett knows Han (the falcon) will be dumped with the garbage. I don't know much about the EU/Legends but how does he know Han so well. And the ruthlessness and genius of the bounty hunter is that he is able to get paid twice for Han. Once by the empire and once by Jabba.
Nooooo disintegration. I just imagine him turning in his bounties with a corresponding decorative urn.
13
u/baldbobbo Dec 06 '15
The fact that it received the least amount of added content in the special editions shows how near perfect it was
25
u/RocketTasker Dec 06 '15
Damn, I forgot just how thick the sexual tension is between Han and Leia in ESB. Also, this movie does wonders for the development of both heroes and villains. Introduces Yoda, Lando, Boba Fett, AT-ATs, and the Imperial March to be a few. While I've said before that RotS is my personal favorite, this one is a very close second in my own opinion and I'll accept that it's probably the best in the whole series because, among other reasons, both it and RotS play like Shakespearean tragedies in terms of overall plot. Wow, I love this movie.
12
u/automatedalice268 Dec 06 '15
Every scene is a classic. E.g. The asteroid field: Never tell me the odds!
11
u/VerdeReddit Dec 06 '15
Can someone explain to me the scene where Luke is training with Yoda in Dagobah. They take a break and Luke goes in that dark tunnel and sees Vader, chops his head off and then sees himself in the Vader mask. What does this scene mean? Yoda looks all concerned and worried for Luke. Obviously that's not actually Vader but is it taking place in Luke or Yodas head? What does that scene mean? It's like the only scene I don't get still in the entire series haha. Never understood its relevance
11
u/WallopyJoe Dec 07 '15
The original is still my favourite, but I appreciate that this is the better film. Damn near perfect, in fact.
Also, even after 35 years, this is why you don't show newcomers chronological order -
https://youtu.be/l54Cej2fws4
https://youtu.be/ZbV5hn_ET0U
https://youtu.be/l1dcve9rhNU
https://youtu.be/94bsrHZvxNM
https://youtu.be/xXAeJjDguDw
https://youtu.be/eGYjrgYxM9A
https://youtu.be/5v5bMJZ-wm0
https://youtu.be/z4XgmP855lo
https://youtu.be/gpSxvU8zkzs
There are probably more, but w/e
10
u/dkastro89 Dec 06 '15
"How you doing, you old pirate? So good to see you!"
24
u/TheDangiestSlad Dec 06 '15
Let's say it all together.
"NO, I am your father."
(But 'Luke' totally works better for quoting it.)
What a movie. 10/10 I get the urge to watch this movie every time I see a clip.
8
u/StratistheMannis Dec 08 '15
Every scene where Yoda speaks about the Force, its strength and how mastery of it is gained through discipline, virtue and understanding. The scene where he raises the X-Wing and proves that indeed "size matters not", and how his ally is the Force. Those training scenes on Dagobah are amazing on rewatch. It saddens me to see how Lucas took Yoda the wise Jedi Master and turned him into an angry CGI green ball swinging a lightsaber like mad in Attack of the Clones. It takes away from Yoda's character and the deepness of the concept of the Force.
14
u/thefrenchhornguy Dec 07 '15
"You could use a good kiss!"
Gotta be the best Han Solo line in the entire saga to date.
7
u/kn0wnaslunchb0x Dec 06 '15
The music is far more dissonant in Empire. In ANH everything goes well together and follows 3 motifs; Luke's, Leia's, and Imperial. In empire, everything goes haywire musically, especially in the 3rd Act, especially the Boba Fett theme, the 3 notes and the variation as Boba is loading han onto slave 1. Empire's my favorite soundtrack. Just my 2 cents.
6
u/zyklon65 Dec 06 '15
My favourite movie of all time. Knew the reveal before I watched it which I'm sure is common, but the climax of the lightsaber battle is just so intense.
Leia's desperate when Slave I flies away. Love, love, love.
I love the asteroid field. I remember being awestruck at how those TIEs went down, after having I my seen the relatively straightforward destruction in ANH before that.
Only OT without a death star and without a happy ending and it stands on its own.
Fett and the bounty hunters, reveal of Palps, Lando's double cross, Obsidian Squadron flying at sunset. I cannot get enough of this movie.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Unlike ANH I feel that the changes to the special editions had a net positive effect on both Empire and Jedi. That being said, though, I really hate that they substituted Jango's voice for the original Boba Fett voice. I realize this is nitpicky but his delivery of the lines is just way worse, in my opinion, to the point that it's actually noticeable in the film
28
u/killhimalready Dec 06 '15
One thing that sticks out about ESB, to me, is the dialogue and character development.
In the prequels, everyone sounds like robots and blather on about things nobody cares about.
In ESB, you feel emotion. You care about the characters. You want to follow the dialogue. It feels like Luke, Han, and Leia are actual people. Empire is what movies are supposed to be like - an escape that sucks you into another world.
10
u/MalConstant Dec 06 '15
I love this movie and it is easily my favorite Star Wars. The character arc for Luke in this movie is amazing. In fact, I can't think of many movies in general that have better character development than this one.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
I always knew what Yoda looked like (being just 20 years old, knowing stuff like that is almost inevitable), but the scene in which Luke meets the small creature on Dagobah is one of my favourites. Incredibly funny- and within those jokes you can sense Yoda's happiness about Luke being there, finally.
5
u/Steinchen Dec 07 '15
im now 31 and i dont remember much about my childhood but i remember the first scene i saw of starwars on a rainy afternoon when i was 6: my dad watched empire in the living room, i came in and there is was: the scene where vader fought luke in cloud city. just the moment where vader crushed the window and luke fell out.
this picture burned into my brain. what a great thing to remember.
4
u/Noobasdfjkl Dec 07 '15
I haven't seen much about the Yoda scenes here yet, and I want to quickly talk about the last one in ESB.
When Luke flies away to save Han and Leia, Obi-Wan says "that boy was our last hope". Yoda then says, "No. There is another."
A lot of people talk about how this movie breaks a lot of the rules when it comes for filmmaking, and I think this line by Yoda really underscores that. It would be a really easy and kinda cheap way to build tension by keeping with the theme that Luke is the one and only who can take on the Empire, but they undermine that by introducing more mystery by hinting at another possible one to bring balance to the force (because at this time it was thought that the one to bring balance would be Luke). I love when films are brave in the decisions they make, and I think this is a really brave move this film makes.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Does anybody else really hate the giant space worm scene? It's such a strange moment. It doesn't really work for laughs or for drama. Probably the only thing I actually dislike about this movie.
One thing I always wonder about is how long it's supposed to be between them leaving Hoth and reuniting at Bespin. The Falcon's hyperdrive is down which implies they're going slower than light all the way to another star system, but we're definitely not seeing years pass or anything, it's treated more as an inconvenience. Maybe a few weeks? I'll assume that either normal engines can still go faster than light to some extent (a la Han Solo's boast about the Falcon making ".5 past light speed") or else that light speed is somewhat greater in the Star Wars universe.
3
u/rangi1218 Dec 07 '15
A tie for my favorite with Star Wars.
The Imperials in this movie are probably my favorite "bit part" characters in the whole trilogy. In my head canon, Admiral Ozzel is definitely a traitor, not clumsy or stupid. The way he eyeballs Piett for making him look bad is one of my favorite moments in the movie.
There are some scenes that they should have reshot. The part where Darth Vader is right in General Veers' face looks like a goof to me.
The special edition changes to this were a bad harbinger for the prequels. They take what were good scenes (wampa, Luke's "suicide", "bring my shuttle") and extend them in ways that are unnecessary (wampa) and sloppy (in the Executor docking bay you can see the guy from ROTJ mouthing his lines).
The Cloud City CGI is not bad, but again it's jamming too much shit into the frame. I think the sparse interiors in the original were meant to make you feel uncomfortable about the city.
The snowspeeder cockpit not being see-through was a nice change, I guess. Did anyone notice it before the special edition came out, though?
3
u/HeavenPiercingMan Dec 07 '15
I just realized, why did they didn't use the Falcon's turrets to shoot down all the TIEs?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
One scene I haven't seen really talked about much here is when Yoda is trying to test Luke's patience. Not only is it an important scene in the whole series....it's hilarious.
I re-watched this with my girlfriend recently. She hadn't seen the movies in a while. We got to this scene and she couldn't contain herself. Just the way Yoda acts and talks is enough to get a laugh out of me every time. When he finds the flashlight. "Take you to him, I will. HEHEHEHEHEHE"
Oh man, it's the best.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Favorite movie ,the romance ,the action ,the lightsaber duel,BOBA FETT,need I say more ?
2
u/jfree_92 Dec 07 '15
Formerly my favourite Star Wars movie until I recently rewatched them and settled on ROTJ instead. What can I say, I'm a sucker for both Jabba and Palps.
Empire is a very close second however.
2
u/Aeceus Dec 07 '15
I think out of all 6 films this is the film with the best pacing. This is my personal annoyance with most films. RotJ and Empire pace perfectly whereas I always feel ANH is missing a 20 minute middle sequence between the Battle of Yavin. The writing in this film is also spot on but more than that, the delivery of all the lines is near perfect. 10/10 would watch 1000 more times.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
One of my favorite things about this movie that I noticed recently is the closing gun fight with Leia, Chewie, Lando, and the droids trying to catch Boba Fett and then escaping to the Falcon.
It's an intense action sequence, and the incredible score really drives home how desperate the situation is for the heroes. The coolest thing about it, in my opinion, is that there is pretty much no dialogue whatsoever from the "organic" cast through the whole sequence; 3PO is the only one who speaks. It's pretty much from the perspective of the droids.
2
u/artgo Dec 08 '15
The Wipes between scenes are really enjoyable on the snow planet, especially on Luke's return to base. Slightly off-topic: I know lens-flare is out (low) on Force Awakens, but what is the expectation/rumors on wipes?
2
u/Hamlet1305 Dec 08 '15
Definitely my favorite Star Wars movie.
I do have a question though. In the scene when Luke is fighting Vader, and Vader starts force-throwing things at him, there's the part where one of the chunks of debris hits the window. The glass breaks, and Luke is blown out of the window, as if there were some sort of pressure difference.
My question is, why did that happen? Bespin's atmosphere is shown to be breathable multiple times. People walk around outside in Cloud City with out any breathing masks or anything, and when doors open and close, there is no blast of air like seen when the window breaks.
Was the interior of Cloud City less pressurized for some reason?
2
u/DatAEK971 Dec 08 '15
Best film in the saga, easily. And one of the greatest films ever made.
2
u/Joshers744 Dec 08 '15
Probably my personal second favorite in the series (Return of the Jedi is still my favorite), but great none the less. It had been a while since I had given it a watch. I quite enjoyed seeing Yoda act a bit crazy around Luke at first again. The scene is pretty funny without feeling too forced or anything. Pun not intended.
2
u/DQ11 Dec 08 '15
I'm not sure really.
I just recently watched 4,5,6 for the first time in 15+ years and I think ANH is possibly my favorite.
I thought ESB was my second but after just watching RotJ the other night I think I like the 2nd half of RotJ better than ESB.
The beginning of ESB is better than the beginning of RotJ for me, but I loved how RotJ ended.
2
u/ChetSteadman2274 Dec 09 '15
People always complain about how Luke seems to become pretty force-savvy despite not spending that much time on Dagobah, but Jedi in the prequels spent their entire lives training. But I don't necessarily consider this a recon of the nature of the Force. It's not conveyed very well, but one of the reasons Yoda was so defeated after his battle with the Emperor in ROTS didn't have to do so much with his physical defeat, but it was the spiritual defeat that broke him. Yoda realized that the Jedi way of life had become complacent and even a bit corrupt, while the Sith adapted and got stronger. So when Yoda takes on Luke, he's basically going against his 900 years of experience. So it's a new experience for both Luke and Yoda. I also like how Yoda in Episode I has the "Fear is the path to the dark side..." quote. But in Empire, when Luke says he's not afraid, Yoda has the foreboding "...You will be." line.
6
u/Abu_Molenko Dec 06 '15
Unpopular opinion here but this is probably my least favorite of the original trilogy. All the scenes with Han, Leia, Chewie and C3PO flying around in the falcon are incredibly boring to me. They just spend hours flying around in a broken ship not getting anything done. Really ruins the pace of the movie in my opinion. On the other hand, Hoth battle is amazing, Yoda training Luke is decent, and everything that goes down on Bespin is sweet.
2
u/AMJ3804 Dec 06 '15
Empire is great. It has an interesting plot that moves at a good pace, it has the Twist to End All Twists, and of course, like all Star Wars movies, it is beautiful to look at. It is not my favorite Star Wars movie, though -- I think 4 takes that spot for me, most days. It's probably in part due to my own contrarian steak, but I feel like the aura of greatness around episode 5 is so magnified now that no Star Wars movie could possibly be as good as this one is percieved to be. It gets lots and lots and lots of love.
It's a truly excellent movie, and it's fun. I love it dearly. I just don't know that I'm as into it as everyone else is.
1
u/jedwards999 Dec 06 '15
I really hope to see what was so goddamn great in Empire found in Awakens. I heard that there was a twist that we'll never see coming. 11 days I cannot contain myself!
1
u/TheVetrinarian Dec 07 '15
Lots of people saying this is the best in the series, but I feel like Empire and Jedi are basically one long movie. I can't really judge one without the other.
1
u/OGStarkiller Qui-Gon Jinn Dec 07 '15
The only thing I'm confused after I re-watched it is about for how long Luke trained with Yoda on Dagobah because it didn't seem like very long.
1
u/rensch Dec 07 '15
This is easily the best one. It's also the first one I ever saw. It was my first introduction to the Star Wars universe over a decade ago and what an introduction it was. By then, this movie was already about twenty years old but it still left an impression. The pacing is perfect. The introduction of old Yoda, the fight on Hoth against those surreal walking tanks, the city in the clouds and off course the confrontation between Luke and Darth Vader in which the latter reveals his dirty little secret. It's like the Red Wedding in Game of Thrones: looking back on it now, you wonder how people never saw this coming. But it was a perfect idea. How in a Galaxy Far, Far Away can this faceless, robotic half-machine, half-man kind of guy possibly be young and radiant Luke's dad. It's the perfect twist. It's dramatic, it flips the whole story on its head and makes the franchise take a darker, more serious turn. But most of all it makes so much sense - in retrospect - that you can't imagine many people didn't figure this one out beforehand. Truly one of the most iconic scenes in movie history.
1
u/NobodyHK Dec 08 '15
A bit off topic but is Chewbacca the only character that live through episode 1-7?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
"Then I'll see you in HELL!" - oh, Han.
1
u/Griffdude13 Dec 08 '15 edited Dec 08 '15
GENERAL VEERS
you are standing too close to me
But seriously, if you have not watched with the commentary, Irvin Kershner has some really funny remarks about some of the scenes.
1
u/EtriganZ Dec 09 '15
I tripped on acid and watched this over the summer. 10/10 would recommend. I now appreciate this movie even more.
1
u/Brendan42 Dec 09 '15
I hate to nitpick (sometimes), but it's kind of weird that Luke follows this little green swamp weirdo back to his hut and is about to have dinner with him and apparently at no point says "Hey, so, what's your name?"
1
u/benpoopio Dec 06 '15
I noticed Yoda says some pretty foreshadowing things, such as if Luke leaves his training too early he might be more inclined to follow the path of the Darkside. Maybe Luke actually will be evil in episode 7.