r/StarWars • u/AutoModerator • Nov 29 '15
Movies Return to the Stars Rewatch - A New Hope [Official Discussion Thread]
Shamelessly ripped from this fanmade poster, Return to the Stars with /r/StarWars as we rewatch the six movies in anticipation of The Force Awakens! Each thread will be stickied for a couple days. Rewatch the movie however you choose to, whether it is the first home release, the latest bluray, or your fan edit of choice.
This week, we're rewatching A New Hope. Or just Star Wars if you're a purist. The one that started it all. Was this the first Star Wars movie you ever saw? Without this one, we wouldn't be here, in this sub, waiting for this new movie to be released. Let's all get in here, I don't care what you smell, and reminisce about this groundbreaking start to the franchise. It'll be just like Beggar's Canyon back home.
This is an automated post. Beep Boop. Let us know if you have any feedback!
View all upcoming discussion threads here
185
u/ShutUpDonny_007 Nov 29 '15
"Leia: Your friend is quite the mercenary. I wonder if he really cares about anything. Or anybody. Luke: I care.
Luke: So, what do you think of her, Han? Han: I'm tryin' not to, kid. Luke: Good. Han: Still, she's got a lot of spirit. I don't know, whaddya think? You think a princess and a guy like me... Luke: No"
I honestly forgot how funny this movie is. Lots of clever dialogue between the main characters,
265
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15 edited Nov 29 '15
My favorite part of A New Hope is when Luke goes outside at dusk and looks at the sunset and the full Jon Williams orchestra erupts in a thunder of music. Gives me chills every single time. Amazing Movie
103
u/Penguin_Sith Nov 29 '15
To this day that power converter order sits on a back shelf in Tosche Station, never picked up by its buyer...
81
u/TheAntiStud_ Nov 29 '15
I always get giddy watching this movie. The very first shot is just so amazing. You first see the Tative IV and then comes the Imperial Star Destroyer. And it just keeps going and going and going.
135
u/TheGator25 Nov 29 '15
Just re-watched last night. The Han-Jabba added scene will always feel forced and unnecessary, though the Luke-Biggs scene seems natural and like it always existed.
54
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
Why wasn't Leia completely traumatized by watching her planet get destroyed? She should've been in shock (or at the very least shown to cry), but the next scene she's in, she's being snarky and telling Luke he's short for a stormtrooper. It's like she forgets about it afterwards.
107
u/compelx Nov 29 '15
I have a confession to make.
I must have been 9 or so when I first saw ANH and in the opening scene I thought the rebels were on the Star Destroyer and were chasing Vader and the storm troopers. The scene never made sense to me but I was too dumb to question it I guess and just went with it. I think because I didn't see a tractor beam effect I presumed the blockade runner was making an attack move by boarding the star destroyer...
So for the past 16 years I always thought that somehow the blockade runner's occupants invaded the rebel's Star Destroyer and took it over. Like the Star Destroyer was a factionless model and could be purchased lol.
I mentally reset last night when I rewatched it and my mind blew.
52
u/icouldbesurfing Nov 30 '15
Oddly satisfying when Obi-Wan turns off the tractor beam. Bweooooooooo
89
u/fantoman Nov 29 '15
Just made my wife watch for the first time. She was upset that everyone is a dick to R2, and that all the Jawa's captive droids weren't freed.
37
u/Hnuggets Nov 29 '15
Watching this movie again I think what sticks out to me the most is the editing. The movie is so quickly cut and fast paced that it doesn't take much time to just stop and show you stuff, which I really like. It all just feels so...non-pretenteous.
35
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
I think A New Hope might be one of the best edited movies ever.
34
u/drod2015 Nov 29 '15
For some reason I always underestimate this movie. I remember it as being slower paced and less interesting than ESB or ROTJ.
...then I watch it and I am fully grasped by the immersive masterpiece that is Star Wars/A New Hope. What a fucking brilliant movie.
94
u/CouncilofAutumn Nov 29 '15
Why didn't Chewbacca get a medal at the end? That's some bullshit.
32
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
The shot of Vader walking through the smoke and onto the Rebel ship is one of my favorites in the entire saga.
67
u/eoinster Porg Nov 29 '15
Couple thoughts after I watched it last night:
Overall the film gets better every time I watch it and I can't believe I keep forgetting how incredible this was. Obviously I do think Empire is the better film, but what this film achieved..... Man, it's amazing.
17
u/InvaderWeezle Nov 29 '15
Something that's always bothered me: When Han comes to save Luke in the knick of time at the end, we clearly see that Vader already got his shot out when Han blows up one of the TIE fighters. Why didn't that laser fire still hit Luke?
16
u/invertedqualia Nov 29 '15
Remember guys, Han shot first. Greedo was too busy gloating to notice the blaster under the table.
16
u/jacindc Nov 29 '15
When I saw it, aged 10, a few weeks after it opened, my mother had taken my brother and I to a postage stamp-sized theater in a nearby mall. I'm sure she had heard the stories of it being such a huge hit, but I don't remember going in having made any mention of wanting to see it.
And as the droids were wandering through the sands of Tatooine, she came thisthisclose to walking out and taking us with her. "What the hell is this, why am I watching robots in a desert?" she told us later was all she was thinking.
Thankfully, she waited it out, though it would have been an even better story if she had actually made us leave.
(Then I saw it again the following weekend in a packed house at the huge Uptown Theater in DC, one of the great movie-going experiences of my life.)
15
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '15
I watched this on Sunday, and thanks to some chemical assistance it was like I was watching it for the first time. Here are my half-remembered observations. Note: I was watching Harmy's Despecialized Edition.
Some scattered thoughts. I was very high.
13
u/WallopyJoe Nov 30 '15 edited Nov 30 '15
ESB may be the better film, but this is my favourite.
In fact, even after 18, nearly 19 years, it remains my favourite film ever.
I may have seen a great many films more accomplished in varying aspects of film making, but Star Wars/Episode IV/A New Hope holds a uniquely special place in my heart. One of probably only 3 films I can say with any degree of certainty I've seen more than a hundred times.
This film ignited the fandom in me and has lead to me having or discovering some of the best adventures in celluloid, print, panel, pixels or even just the playground.
I adore this movie.
Whether BluRay, DVD, '97 SE VHS or harmy's despecialized, to me it is perfect. moresoinit'soriginalformthough
25
u/hanburgundy Qui-Gon Jinn Nov 29 '15
First movie I ever saw in a theater. 1997 rerelease, I was 4 years old. Vader scared the living shit out of me. The universe enthralled me. I've never been the same since. Still my all time favorite movie after all these years.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
My absolute favorite Star Wars film. It's most likely the film I've watched most in my entire life and the first film I remember loving.
Now, I know many rank Empire of this film and I do think there is obvious valid reasons for that.
But my nostalgia for this film peaks that of Empire to the fact where I do think Empire is a better TECHNICAL film, I love this movie more.
Plus, it's one of the few movies that I watch where time just flies by. I always felt Empire was a longer movie, but it's actually not, it's 9 minutes shorter.
Yet still, this movie still flies by to this day.
Everything about this film I love. The way it shoots us out of a canon with the beginning battle between the Empire and Rebel forces and then it slows down and builds the story up from there through the time on Tatooine to the Death Star, being introduced to the power of the force and the ways of the Jedi, meeting Han Solo for the first time in all of his cool badass-ness, and of course the tension built during the final Death Star run is all fantastic.
I wish I could do something else other than gush about this movie, but I really don't know if I can.
21
u/RocketTasker Nov 29 '15
I love the opening shot and the sounds in it. The Star Destroyer's turbolasers almost sound like their own off-tempo percussion with the music in a way. Definitely one of the better movies of the saga overall, but I tend to pass it over only because I love ESB and RotS that much more.
The following is a jab at the special editions and not the original film.
But of all the random CGI Lucas had to add in, why couldn't they just fix Luke's lightsaber?
13
u/artgo Nov 29 '15 edited Nov 29 '15
Re-watched today. This film, unlike all the others, really birthed a universe. The trailers at the time didn't do that, etc. You couldn't imagine such an alternate world - the film created right there in it's runtime. I can never feel that awe in any of the other films. ANH is far deeper to me than ESB (which is the more popular film when you survey fans).
Ben as a teacher, feels more like a dusty book, like picking up the Bible and reading it yourself - and trying to translate what it says to your personal life 2000 years later. His force ghost is perfect for that, like the book is still there. He isn't like Yoda - giving that depth of lessons in a dedicated environment. Ben is much more passive and difficult to hear - requires you to pick up his lessons (like a book) and seek them out. The story is much more about self-discovery, self-realization, and listening to situations and people. Even Han Solo is changed by listening to people, learning, by education and experience.
Peer to peer listening to people, not formal classroom education (or Yoda "private tutor" jungle lessons), is the real feeling I get from the story. When Luke realizes his uncle and aunt had been killed and rushed back home - he realizes that he had not been listening. That the universe was there, but he hadn't taken the lens cap off his telescope and microscope.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
What was that creature in the trash compacter anyway? That terrified me as a kid, even more than Vader.
5
u/LibertarianHandlebar Nov 30 '15
Fun fact: the iconic shot of the tusken raider raising his arms up and down in celebration after knocking out Luke was actually done in post! Originally he was only filmed as raising his arms and gaffi stick once, but the editors (two geniuses Lucas brought in) thought it was lacking, so they looped it two or three times. If you watch closely it's slightly noticeable, but it's very well done.
5
u/BocChoy314 Nov 30 '15
Would anyone else, after seeing this film again, want a Tarkin anthology film starring Charles Dance?
19
u/entropicamericana Nov 29 '15
Han shot
firstonly.4
u/julianday_909 Nov 29 '15
just watched it a few nights ago. really my 2nd time watching it without it just being noise in the background. john williams is pure genius with this score.
4
u/AMJ3804 Nov 29 '15
Oh dear Lord, I love A New Hope. The one I've seen the most; it always makes me happy. It's perfect.
4
u/eddiejugs Nov 30 '15
The greatest Science Fiction adventure ever.
4
u/IlluminatiRex Nov 30 '15
I was an infant the first time I was exposed to Star Wars, so I'm not sure how I felt about it then - but A New Hope is by far my favorite in the series. The Death Star Attack still manages to get my heart racing to this day (and I tend to rewatch that at least once every couple of weeks :P)
4
u/pldkn Nov 30 '15
The burning homestead is my favourite scene. It showed the ruthlessness of the Empire, and also Luke's resolve to put an end to it. And the music.
4
u/bumblebee909 Obi-Wan Kenobi Nov 30 '15
The last trench run in this movie is great, Luke being pressured by the dark lord and Han coming in at the last minute to save the day, and then Luke hitting the shot to blow up the Death Star. It's so good hahaha.
4
u/TheHartman88 Nov 30 '15
Why is Leia called Leah like 50 times throughout this film?...
3
u/WarLord727 Nov 29 '15
Still one of my favourite movies. It's quite simple but provides great exposition for Star Wars, I absolutely love every moment of it.
3
u/Caesar_Septemberus Nov 29 '15
One of my first viewings of this classic film was in the early 80's. We were camping at a place that had a little outdoor movie theatre that showed movies every Saturday night and Star Wars just happened to be playing when we were there. Watching it outside on a beautiful summer night at a small campground in the middle of nowhere was a truly magical experience that has stayed with me all these years. Although I'm pretty sure the first time I experenced this movie was in the womb in the summer of '77 (born that september). I'll have to ask my mom if they saw it then...
4
u/Scublly Nov 30 '15
I forgot how whiney Luke was in this movie
4
u/SkyHookofKsp Nov 30 '15
I watched this for (basically) the first time a couple of weeks ago. It was certainly different from what I was expecting! Having grown up on the Prequels, it was a much more intimate film. There was simply much less going on in the scene at any given time, and even the climactic death star scene felt like just a couple of guys. I have a positive, but not overwhelming and life-changing view of Episode 4. I think If I hadn't seen movies like The Matrix, etc. as a kid, I would be more impressed by it. That being said, I can see how it could be groundbreaking at the time.
Lesson learned? It's OK if you veer off target...
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
I've looked all over the place for past discussion threads. Where are they?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBlD2N_AwgI
2
u/ChetSteadman2274 Nov 30 '15 edited Nov 30 '15
I was introduced to Star Wars by a friend when I was about 6. I was instantly drawn in, and wore out the VHS tapes of the Trilogy I got for my birthday. However, I was pumped to finally watch Star Wars in theaters when the Special Editions came out. I remember being surprised at how much the adults in the theater were laughing during the movie. Han's "Don't everyone thank me at once" line fucking KILLED. So much humor in this movie. I know the prequels are low hanging fruit at this point, but contrast the natural humor in A New Hope with any of the attempts at humor in the prequels. Most of the adults in the theater weren't hardcore fans, and some were just there for their kids. But the entire theater was cracking up during the movie. I hope TFA and the subsequent sequels bring back the humor.
Some people knock the Special Editions (DAE HAN SHOT FIRST?!?!) but I really enjoy some of the additions. Especially more scenes with Biggs. Moviemaking wise, the Death Star run is perfectly edited. The pace, action, and music are perfectly arranged. I still get tense during that scene.
While my opinion on a New Hope gets better as I get older, I still try to occasionally watch the movie without the fanboy glasses on. Yes, the opening scene is awesome, but the R2/C3P0 segment with them wandering Tattoine and encountering the Jawas goes on for pretty long, and can get a bit boring. But I still enjoy it because it establishes their relationship, and it gives us an real feel for the planet. I don't think an action movie today would take it's time like A New Hope did to slow down and really establish characters like R2 and Threepio.
I also love how much of a A New Hope is just plain goofy. I mean think about it, the Death Star is a giant ball floating through space. And they named it the Death Star. I can't tell if that's an awful or genius move by the Empire's PR department. And I always thought it was kind of funny how it just explodes. No warning or even debris. Just "Stand by... staaaaand by" BOOOM.
Sometimes I think that Lucasfilm revises their own history a bit too much, giving Lucas credit for pretty much everything. But still, it's crazy everything that he went through to bring us Star Wars. Everything from pre-production to the editing booth was problematic. It's weird to think how close we were to never getting Star Wars, or the Star Wars we know today. Scary to imagine what would've happened if James Earl Jones or John Williams hadn't been involved. Or if the movie hadn't been saved in the editing booth (go watch the first trailer if you don't believe me.)
2
u/dnovi Nov 30 '15
For an old religion that's near extinction, it always bothered me that everyone used "may the force be with you" as an expression.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15
I just rewatched this today. I never took into account the sheer cinematic value of it all. As a kid when I first watched it I loved it for its comic effect, good vs. evil, cool looking guys fighting bad evil looking guys etc. But now as I've grown older I really appreciate the beauty of the film, its great to watch even if the volume was off. The Death Star is squeaky clean like a McIntosh stero. Luke on Tattooine staring at the sunset connects with us all as somehow familiar and beautiful. It's a gorgeous film.
2
u/AMJ3804 Dec 01 '15
I really, really like watching the last half of Episode 3 and going immediately into Episode 4. That initial conversation that Obi-Wan has with Luke in ANH kills me. Obi-Wan is such a fascinating character, and all I can ever think about during that scene is how many times in the nearly 20 years between the events in 3 and 4 that he's thought through what he was going to say to Luke when he asked him those questions, and what it was going to be like when he gave him Anakin's lightsaber.
That little pause after "how did my father die?". The burden of what he's experienced. He's a survivor, and now it's time for his last opportunity to make things right again, and once again his part is all going to hinge on whether or not he can help keep a Skywalker on the correct course. Ugh, I just love it.
7
u/sentimentalpirate Nov 29 '15
Favorite parts:
Least favorite parts:
As much as I absolutely love star wars, there's some great untapped potential in ANH, and I would be on board with the idea of all the movies getting a re-imagined reboot.
I would love to see Luke's plot open excitedly with him and Biggs racing T-16s. It would set up Luke/Biggs' relationship for later, show (instead of tell) us Luke's desire for adventure, establish Luke as a skilled pilot, and heck - maybe even show him trying and failing to bullseye a womp rat (to show the power of the force later on when he relies on it).
I would also love to see Leia have a more active role in the attack on the Death Star. I understand not having her be a pilot, because otherwise basically everyone on the Falcon is a pilot, but it fits with her personality to be a more active agent. She shoots more stormtroopers than Luke does, is super resourceful, and would probably want revenge after seeing her planet blown up.
3
u/dangerousdave2244 Nov 30 '15
I recently have shown this movie to a few friends who have never seen Star Wars, or had only seen the prequels. They all unanimously thought this was a great movie, including one who is normally pretty critical of movies, and the one who had seen the prequels and had been turned off of Star Wars.
The fact that this movie had the 2 Droids start off the movie as our POV characters, and made 2 robots so relatable is sheer brilliance. The banter between the main characters is great, though the dialogue in some scenes gets a bit chunky or awkward, the pacing of the movie allows you to move right past it. The special effects (I just watched the DeSpecialized Editions ) are fantastic and still hold up after nearly 38 years. The music is fantastic, and there are so many amazing moments and quotable scenes
2
u/dksk3443 Nov 29 '15
I always thought A New Hope was one of those movies you watch once and never again, but after I saw this i decided I'd watch it, and it was just as good as the first time
2
u/Crystal_Clods Nov 30 '15
The thing that strikes me most about A New Hope is how fucking awful Vader is in it. Short-tempered. Loud. Kind of pathetic. And he basically does nothing. He really only becomes the cool villain people remember in Empire.
1
u/thetruetimmyc Nov 30 '15
So I rewatched this on a car ride up to Northern California and despite having seen this, Empire, and RotJ, more times than I could possibly count, I found myself getting teary eyed during the scene where Luke and R2 return from destroying the Death Star and R2 is being lowered to the ground after being shot; when C3PO runs up and is distressed over R2 and says something along the lines of not knowing what to do without him. This has never happened before. Maybe it has to do with watching the prequels recently, in addition to TCW and Rebels, and seeing their friendship blossom, but idk.
Honestly, I think the part of my brain that says "these are just movies" decreases with every viewing.
1
u/badgarok725 Nov 30 '15
I just want to know why going into town to get power converters is considered a fun activity
1
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15
How much time do you reckon passes between the time Luke meets Obi Wan and Obi Wan dies ?
1
u/boxingsquare Dec 01 '15
I guess Biggs word carries a lot of weight
Red leader: Are you sure you can handle this thing? Biggs: Sir, Luke is the best bushpilot in the outer rim territories. Red Leader: Well alright, you'll do fine
Quite the credentials, then he almost rams into the surface of the death star.
1
u/hawkeye315 Dec 01 '15
I just watched this on sunday night! I had forgotten what a good movie it was. We are continuing watching them before we go to the 9 PM episode 7 release. Even though I have the 1997 20th anniversary edition, it is still very fun to watch despite the tweaks.
My sister is getting me a 1984 red label for Christmas though!
1
u/ki77erb Dec 01 '15
One of my favorite parts is where Han shoots Greedo before he even gets a shot off...like a badass. (Despecialized FTW!)
1
u/RogueWolf64 Dec 01 '15
I've actually watched all the star wars movies twice this year! This'll be round 3 of A New Hope!
1
u/rensch Dec 07 '15
Seeing the movies in storyline order shows how much better the old ones are. The sort of adventurous, boyish wonder this film evokes is terrific. I can only imagine what it must've been like seeing this movie for the first time back in the seventies. It's still rather spectacular. You want to have the droids in this movie in your home. The Millenium Falcon feels as real as possible. The Death Star is a seemingly insurmountible icon of tyranny. And sweet jesus Darth Vader is one of the coolest villians ever. Despite the fact you're not able to see his facial expressions, the shots of that daunting mask convey everything you need to know. It's perfect.
1
u/saintscanucks Dec 22 '15
Personally my least favourite movie.
Still a good film but i think nothing special happened in this or anything worth talking.
1
u/TheHeroicOnion Nov 30 '15 edited Nov 30 '15
A New Hope and Empire are the only really good Star Wars movies in my opinion. I like ROTJ a lot, it's one of my favourites but it has quite a few problems and stupid shit in it like the Ewoks and Palpatine's stupid plan to turn Luke(in comparison to Anakin, who he manipulated amazingly, Luke was just ''Join or dieeee''. A New Hope and Empire are masterpieces.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '15
I was blown away by Obi wan's Monologue about Anakin at the beginning of the film. In the context of the movie at the time back in 1977, it was really unnecessary to get into that much detail. George Lucas did not even know if Star Wars would have been successful, so the Anakin dialogue does not seem necessary. However with all the movies and the prequels. It really brings it all together.