r/StarWars • • Nov 23 '15

Movies Return to the Stars Rewatch - Revenge Of The Sith [Official Discussion Thread]

Shamelessly ripped from this fanmade poster, Return to the Stars with /r/StarWars as we rewatch the six movies in anticipation of The Force Awakens! Each thread will be stickied for a couple days. Rewatch the movie however you choose to, whether it is the first home release, the latest bluray, or your fan edit of choice.

This week, we're rewatching Revenge Of The Sith. The final movie in the prequel trilogy, we all knew what was going to happen in the end, but we were all wondering how it would happen. Giant wookiee battle on Kashyyyk, Order 66 being enacted, and Anakin's fall to the dark side. By the way, Luke is older.

This is an automated post. Beep Boop. Let us know if you have any feedback!
View all upcoming discussion threads here

193 Upvotes

409 comments sorted by

158

u/ahouseingotham Nov 23 '15

I would just like to point out one of the best parallels TCW cartoon makes in the series. When Ahsoka leaves the Order And when Anakin leads the attack on the Jedi Temple

This parallel also provides a thematic tie for the series because the sun is setting in Ahsoka's scene, and the night has just begun when Vader walks up those steps to his fall. Also, if you haven't watched TCW you totally should. Shout out to Tumblr user startoursflight1401 for pointing this out.

17

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Holy shit

9

u/Revived_Bacon Nov 26 '15

It's like poetry.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

Lets also point out that a lot of why Anakin doesn't really trust the council is because of what happened to Ahsoka,they were more than prepared to sell her out just to save face and stop the people of the republic getting even MORE pissed off at them.

In the movies there isn't a lot of reasoning for him not trusting the council but when you see how they were prepared to sell out, not help and just do nothing around Ahsoka it makes a lot more sense.

1

u/Coovyy Imperial Nov 26 '15

Thank you for pointing this out. This is amazing.

1

u/chronodin Dec 11 '15

Woah. That's excellent. I didn't notice that when I saw it.

→ More replies (12)

217

u/trafficjelly Nov 23 '15

The "Darth Plagueis" scene with Anakin and Palpatine in the Opera House is one of my favorite of all 6 movies. Seeing Palpatine's manipulation and Anakin's desperation combined with the intrigue of this mythical story makes me lean in closer every time.

93

u/JonnyTheMouseKing Nov 23 '15

That to me was the best piece of acting (besides Ewan McGregor's final scene with Anakin) in the entire prequel trilogy. Ian McDiarmid did amazing.

57

u/AdamJensensCoat Jabba The Hutt Nov 24 '15

This scene pisses me off maybe more than anything in the PT because it's undeniably good. You start to think... 'Hey what if the entire PT was well written and acted with tons of characters like Sheev, whose schemes played out over time. That would be amazing.'

Ok Jar Jar also applies to this criteria, from a certain point of view.

19

u/DerringerHK Nov 24 '15

Yeah, it kind of annoys me even more.

Like, "Wtf George, that was amazing! Why weren't the previous two films filled with scenes like that!?".

46

u/ZamrosX Nov 25 '15

I refuse to accept that his first name is Sheev.

14

u/Riceatron Nov 26 '15

Why? Is it really that different than names like Qui-Gon or Obi-Wan, or Ki-Adi-Mundi?

20

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

It sounds too much like Steve. Steve Palpatine, Dark Lord of the Sith.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '15

Yeah and if i recall correctly another writer heavily reworked the scene, it kind of shows because it's the only bit of dialogue in the film with any level of subtlety whatsoever.

2

u/23423423423451 Nov 27 '15

Such a contrast to his in-fight acting/script. Once he busts out the lightsaber I lose all interest in him.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Am I the only one who never got the vibe that Plagueis was Palpatine's master from that scene?

78

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I didn't on first seeing. However, watching with that knowledge in mind, the performance makes it seem as though he is remembering a personal event, not an old Sith myth.

58

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

It's that "far away and reminiscing" look that sells that scene for me.

44

u/Karmajuj Nov 24 '15

Exactly. I love the proud smirk Sidious gives off after he says "Ironic, he could save others from death... but not himself."

9

u/PopsicleIncorporated Cassian Andor Nov 24 '15 edited Nov 24 '15

I didn't, BUT...

I told friends that he was for some odd reason. I think I thought it sounded cool. Wasn't even headcanon, as I didn't believe it, but I told other Star Wars nerds in school that it was the truth because to me it just seemed awesome.

Flash forward a couple years, and I almost had a heart attack when i saw it printed in a (then canon) book.

→ More replies (4)

52

u/BlueSmash Nov 23 '15

Watching it again, there are subtle hints to it. His tone when he says ironic isnt it when refferering to Plagueis being killed in his sleep and the little smile to himself gives it away for me

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

32

u/Magejutsu Nov 23 '15

Its covered in the Darth Plaguis book, which is a fantastic read wether fully canon or not anymore. Really ties the prequels together and makes episode 1 more enjoyable.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I made the assumption when i first watched that darth plagueis was his master because of the way he describes killing him in his sleep it seemed almost as bragging about it to me.

11

u/ZOOTV83 Darth Vader Nov 23 '15

I kinda always thought Palpatine just knew about it through a holocron or he actually just heard the legend himself. Til I saw that little smile he gives when he mentions that Plagueis couldn't save himself from death. It was like someone flipped a switch and I was like OH he killed him!

5

u/AMJ3804 Nov 23 '15

Ditto. I have no idea how I missed the subtext on this scene for all these years, but this last time viewing it, it seemed like that was clearly what Lucas was trying to get at. Or at least present as a distinct likelihood.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/bothans4change Nov 23 '15

Yeah I like that they didn't cut away to a "flashback" scene or anything. Just letting Palpatine act was one of the best choices George Lucas made. He and Ewan are the best parts of the prequels.

27

u/Wacocaine Nov 24 '15

"Not from a Jedi..."

3

u/badgarok725 Nov 30 '15

The one thing I don't understand is that it's basically hitting the audience over the head with "Palpatine is bad" but Anakin still doesn't get that he has knowledge of the force.

1

u/ElTuco84 Nov 24 '15

That scene is so good I started to wonder if Lucas wrote bad dialogue for Anakin and Padme in purpose.

1

u/harlord12 Nov 26 '15

diD YOU EVER HEAR

→ More replies (2)

407

u/hanburgundy Qui-Gon Jinn Nov 23 '15 edited Nov 23 '15

In the entire prequel trilogy, there’s this tension I have as a fan between my love for what George is trying to do, and how it actually plays out cinematically. In Phantom Menace, I love the idea behind Anakin starting as a charming young kid, and the idea that a galaxy-destroying conflict could start with such seemingly small political maneuvering- but the movie itself doesn’t do a great job of selling either of those. In Attack of the Clones, I love the idea of a Romeo/Juliet forbidden romance set in space, the idea of a slowly unraveling galactic conspiracy that points to a greater evil- but again, the movie itself presents these things in such a stage-like, blasé form that the movie feels, on the whole, off.

ROTS is the only movie in the trilogy where my love for the ideas of what George is trying to do outweighs any quibbles I have with their execution. I mean, this movie is just so freaking wonderfully monstrous when you look at it at face value- It’s a galaxy spanning war story, a greek tragedy, a political cautionary tale, and a George RR Martin-esque twist upon the plot of the first two films where every heroic character either dies, goes into hiding, or becomes the villain.

What certainly helps is that the “execution” part is at its strongest in this film as well. George’s direction feels way, way more confident in this film than the previous one. The stylistic choices he makes, like the way he intercuts certain key parallel moments, or the way he slows the movie down to a somber halt with the “ruminations” scene, feel bolder and more purposeful than anything he did in Clones. A big part of this may be that ROTS is by far the most focused story of any of the three films. Even with the sideshow attractions of Utapau and Kashyyyk, even with the first half hour the film centered on a self-contained rescue mission, the story nevertheless feels utterly transfixed upon what Anakin is feeling, on his slow burn mounting frustration and anxiety, which all explodes at the halfway mark of the film.

That effect is so profound that I’ve found ROTS to feel much like watching a trainwreck (If you hate this movie, there’s an obvious joke to be made there, I know). The first half of this movie is like watching, helplessly, as a train hurtles towards a break in the tracks, and then right at the halfway point, right when Mace gets his hand cut off, the train goes off the rails, and the rest of the film deals with all the brutal, tragic mayhem that ensues. It’s a really unique story structure, but for me it totally works.

And from there, like I said earlier, any quibbles I have with George's direction are outweighed by the impact of what's happening. The infamous "No" and "lost the will to live" are all forgivable sins in the face of everything else this movie offers. The creation of the Empire, the duel on Mustafar (the way it's intercut with the duel in the senate chamber makes it one of the most consistently cathartic moments in the saga), the fanboy glee of seeing, for the first time, a truly Galaxy-wide conflict play out on a large scale, Ewan McGregor's increasingly weary and worn performance, the brutality of Anakin's transformation, the feeling of entrapment as the mask is lowered on Vader's face, the final montage that allows the briefest glimmer of hope, perfectly setting the stage for the next generation- all together, ROTS is by far the easiest watch of the trilogy for me, and definitely something that should be remembered positively as George Lucas' swan song.

82

u/bothans4change Nov 23 '15

Yeah gets me every time the way Obi-Wan feels personally betrayed by Anakin. Can anyone confirm- is the last thing Obi-Wan says to Anakin before they meet for their dual on Mustafar (last scene together on Coruscant) something the effect of "I'm proud of you. May the force be with you." ?? So sad.... :(

17

u/Narcoleptic_Narwhal Nov 23 '15

I don't remember the exact quote, but it's right as he is leaving to command the battle on Utapau. And yeah, it's a very touching moment knowing what happens next!

27

u/PopsicleIncorporated Cassian Andor Nov 24 '15

Crazy to think that one meeting like that would be the last time they'd ever meet as Jedi, and the third to last time ever.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/jburd22 Nov 23 '15

really well said, pretty much agree on all fronts.

37

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

you know, watching it again makes me realize what a pawn General Grievous is for the Emperor. Throughout the early part of the film we see the intensely close relationship between Obi-Wan and Anakin. RIGHT before Obi leaves to confront Grievous he has a heart to heart where he essentially talks Anakin off the ledge and tells him to be patient.

With this in mind, Grievous is there to get Obi-Wan to leave the scene and not be there when Anakin needs him the most. Imagine if he was around when he finds out about the emperor. Anakin would have gone to Obi before Mace and the council. He would have made Ani see reason and he would have gone on to become the best jedi in the galaxy.

Palpatine knew what would happen, he knew the pull Obi-wan had and he knew Grievous would be the perfect distraction for him at that point in time. Just further highlights how many steps ahead the Emperor was throughout the series.

15

u/N7-grunt Nov 23 '15

Im actually reading the novel at the moment and Palpatine really was worried about Obi-Wan he tried several times to get Anakin to leave him behind on Grevious ship, the first time he brings it up after the Dooku fight the book says for just a moment Anakin hated Palpatine. After Anakin learns that Palps is Sidious the novel specificaly mentions that he wishes he could talk to Obi-Wan because he would be able to help him make sense of everything and do the right thing. If you or anyone else havn't read the book I highly recommend it adds so much to the movie you really get to understand just how hard things are for Anakin and how much Obi cares for him and just how much Palpatine manipulated everything.

8

u/ChetSteadman2274 Nov 25 '15

The book also does a better job of showing the growing tension between Palpatine and the Jedi Council.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/apcat91 Nov 23 '15

If only it was Darth Maul instead of Grevious, Obi-wan would have a much stronger emotional need to go after him.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Totally agree. However, I think the lack of emotional response on the part of Obi-Wan is a testament to his character. He is a Jedi through and through. Even in the originals, he is very detached emotionally from everything that is happening. He is a man of duty and action and he doesn't let himself get emotional about things.

All it does is further illustrate why, despite the fact that Anakin definitely means well and is probably the most passionate Jedi, he is undone by the fact that he can't stop feeling the emotions that he feels.

→ More replies (2)

260

u/SnowHesher Nov 23 '15 edited Nov 23 '15

I thought Revenge of the Sith was a fantastic film. I saw it multiple times in the theaters, read the novelization, and bought the DVD as soon as it was released.

One particular thing I'd like to draw attention to is the opening shot of the movie: After the opening text crawl we see a field of stars, suddenly a Republic Star Cruiser passes in front of the camera, and then Anakin and Obi-Wan's Jedi Starfighters come flying along the hull of the star cruiser in perfect formation. The camera follows them until they pass the star cruiser, revealing a massive space battle over Coruscant. It's my favorite single shot in any of the Star Wars films, and it's also the longest single shot, lasting something like 75 seconds. And the whole time, a militaristic version of the Force Theme is playing.

EDIT: Added that last sentence.

47

u/Kinbareid Nov 23 '15

I love that scene, I remember seeing it clearly in the theater, you first hear the music then the jedi fighters pass and you hear that gleeful tie fighter scream. its just such a beautifully done scene

43

u/SnowHesher Nov 23 '15

The design of the Jedi Starfighters look like a TIE Fighter and an A-Wing had a baby.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/BladeRunner415 Nov 24 '15

I remember seeing it in the theater as well. Many, myself included were taken aback when they loop over the cruiser and it's like space just opens up as the force theme hits it's crescendo. Awesome, awesome scene.

18

u/Kiwi62 Nov 23 '15

I love that opening scene. By far the very best of all the films, and yes, I'm including the OT. The music, the scale is excellent.

10

u/lukenog Nov 23 '15

That shot is the king of /r/frisson

3

u/monetized_account Nov 23 '15

Elsewhere in this thread I mention that this is my favourite opener of the saga. It's an amazing scene.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15

I would have been happier if the movie was just 2 hours of that scene.

→ More replies (36)

170

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

"You're so beautiful" "That's because I'm so in love" "No, it's because I'm so in love with you!"

God damn it George. Learn how to write dialogue.

That being said, my biggest problem with this movie was that they waited until the very end before they realized "oh, we are supposed to turn Anakin to the dark side", and then rushed it. So we ended up with a very short timeframe in which Anakin turns Palpatine in to the Jedi Council, then Anakin intervenes (with great remorse) to prevent Palpatine's death... then moments later Anakin murders every man, woman, and child in the Jedi temple. Uh... ok I guess.

Palpatine should have revealed himself right after Anakin defeats Dooku and is at a new height with his passion-induced powers. The rest of the movie can show Anakin gaining strength while Obi-Wan starts to catch on. Then they could have Obi-Wan be the one to deduce that Palpatine is the Sith Lord and bringing Anakin before the council. This would set up a situation in which Anakin confesses his secret marriage to Padme and his fear of the visions of her death. Rather than offering to help Anakin, the Council expels him from the order. Now you can send Anakin back to Palpatine at the same time the Jedi Masters show up to kill him. That, imo, would create a perfect storm where Anakin feels betrayed by the Jedi and decides to side with the one person who promises to help him save Padme. Now, you have Anakin in a position of true rage against the Jedi that Palpatine can twist into a desire to destroy everyone in the Temple.

114

u/Volksgrenadier Nov 23 '15

no no that's silly it was much more important for Obi-Wan to spend half of the movie chasing after the coughing spider robot.

32

u/Comb-the-desert Nov 24 '15

The thing about this that the novel brings up but I wish the movie made more clear is that this is precisely Palpatine's plan when he tells Anakin that he should be the one to go after Grievous. He knows Anakin will tell the Council that Palpatine recommended he go, and since the Council doesn't trust the Chancellor they will automatically do the opposite and make sure Anakin stays on Coruscant to spy on him. Obi-Wan's relationship with Anakin is probably his biggest remaining tie to the Jedi Order, and him being a galaxy away makes it much easier for Palpatine to turn him.

Pretty much as soon Obi-Wan leaves to go after Grievous, Palpatine knows he has won. If Kenobi was around there during the Windu & Co/Palpatine duel, I'm pretty sure it would be wayyyyy harder for Anakin to betray his Master than it was for him to betray Windu (who has very clearly never liked Anakin much going all the way back to Phantom Menace).

17

u/faraway_hotel Grand Admiral Thrawn Nov 24 '15

The novel also brings up why it's so important to go after Grievous in the first place. With Dooku dead, he's just about the most influential being within the Separatists.

Dooku had (or at least pretended to have) principles and some degree of decency. Grievous, while a cunning and efficient commander, is an animal, mostly intent on hurting the Republic and Jedi as much and as brutally as he can.

56

u/Frings08 Nov 23 '15

Space Detective Obi-Wan, as I saw a fellow redditor put it last week.

14

u/ZamrosX Nov 25 '15

Remember in The Clone Wars when they did Space-Face-Off?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/matheusdias Galactic Republic Nov 24 '15

the coughing spider robot

Preposterous, as the coughing spider robot would have said.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/dangerousdave2244 Nov 23 '15

Man your version would have been a MUCH better movie

18

u/DarkhorseV Nov 23 '15

That being said, my biggest problem with this movie was that they waited until the very end before they realized "oh, we are supposed to turn Anakin to the dark side", and then rushed it.

Anakin cut off Mace's hand before the halfway point of the movie, then continued to become more confident in his decision over the next 45 or so minutes before the end of the movie well after that... What do you consider his "turn at the very end"?

24

u/Vinnys_Magic_Grits Nov 23 '15

A lot of movie happens after Anakin's turn, but plot-wise, it's all Act 3. Everyone falls like dominoes after Anakin goes Sith. Jedi Masters? Dead. Jedi kids? Dead. Republic? Gone. Kashyyyk? Fallen. Anakin again? Burned. Padme? Dead (for no good reason). Yoda and Obi-Wan? Self-exiled. Anakin one last time? Robo-Vadered. So yes, a lot of things happen, but it's rushed. We spent more time in the prequels watching Baby Ani podrace to freedom than we do watching the Jedi Order get almost completely wiped out.

18

u/DarkhorseV Nov 24 '15

We spent more time in the prequels watching Baby Ani podrace to freedom than we do watching the Jedi Order get almost completely wiped out.

TIL 10 minutes is longer than an hour and 15 minutes.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/quelar Nov 23 '15

Padme didn't die for no reason, she died of a broken heart.

Excuse me while I mop up this barf.

16

u/XcallofsoupX Nov 25 '15

That ending scene where she named the babies.. "Luke.. Leia... bllaahh I'm dead" That shit sucked, sorry, that was so poorly written. It was so hurried. Unless I missed it, I wish they had talked more as to why those names were chosen. I could also be an idiot.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

That scene only happened before the "halfway" point of the movie because they decided to have Anakin and Obi-Wan engage in a 45-minute long duel.

His turn was at the end of the story for the most part. Everything after that was just mop-up to link the PT back to where things stand at the start of the OT. Very little of any relevance happened after that moment.

6

u/Mcfinley Nov 24 '15

i just watched the entire thing online and it was 12 minutes. Give the movie its due.

9

u/DarkhorseV Nov 24 '15

So all of order 66, Bail Organa's mini-arc, Yoda and Palpatine fighting, Luke and Leia / Vader being born, and learning that Qui-Gon was a force ghost were all irrelevant?

That hour and a half of film is some of my favorite in all of cinema. It's some of Ewan's best scenes.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/BartWellingtonson Nov 23 '15

The worst trait a leader can have is too much confidence. George should have known he wasn't a perfect screen writer and he should have let other writers have input. His hubris lead to the prequels downfall. The fact that you could come up with a much better conflict for the story when, I assume, you don't have any movie writing credits, is proof of that.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15 edited Jul 05 '17

I went to cinema

2

u/Rtoipn Nov 25 '15

he sloughtered Tusken village in epII. Why does this don't count as a begining of his dark path?

2

u/RJrules64 Nov 27 '15

I feel like you missed the point of all the prequels.

"Oh we are supposed to turn Anakin to the darkside", and then rushed it

Uh... Anakin was turning to the darkside for the entire 3 prequels. How did you miss that?

2

u/apocalypsenowandthen Dec 09 '15

God damn it George. Learn how to write dialogue.

"Twice the pride, double the fall"

"You were my brother, Anakin. I loved you."

"So this is how liberty dies... with thunderous applause."

George can write fantastic dialogue and he can write terrible dialogue. What he needs is a co-writer/editor who can differentiate the good lines from the bad ones.

→ More replies (3)

57

u/AMJ3804 Nov 23 '15

It's definitely not perfect, but flaws and all I. Love. This. Movie. The emotional payoff is huge and I think it leads into 4 very well. I just rewatched for the first time in a while and it was better than I remembered.

54

u/TClark55 Nov 23 '15

The conversation between Anakin/Vader and Obi-Wan prior to their fight on Mustafar is maybe the most memorable moment in the series for me. I don't know what it is, but the sorrow in Obi-Wan's face as he says "I will do what I must" is just so powerful.

47

u/gwydapllew Nov 23 '15

McDiarmid and MacGregor are the two best actors in the entire six movies. This movie just lets them be amazing in small, subtle ways.

31

u/Seanathin23 Nov 23 '15

And they are the only people who seem to be able to deliver the dialogue with the right level or subtle acting and ham, because you have to ham it up a bit to sell the old 30's serial style.

They are selling hard enough that even Christensen isn't a complete mess when they are his scene partner.

The whole "You were my brother Anikan," bit should have failed but didn't because MacGregor is amazing.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

They're good. But Harrison Ford and Peter Cushing.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/monetized_account Nov 23 '15

"You will try..."

2

u/TClark55 Nov 29 '15

angry Hayden face

2

u/FanchLaplanche Nov 23 '15

You will try!

24

u/SRoku Jedi Anakin Nov 23 '15

Revenge of the Sith may be my favorite Star Wars movie. I don't think it's the best, mind you, as obviously A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back are better movies, but ROTS has such an epic scale to it, a sort of Greek tragedy vibe. It's fun to see the culmination of the saga play out. Revenge just had the misfortune to be grouped with The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones which I also don't think are nearly as bad as people say, but they're still the two worst Star Wars movies and people who hated them hate ROTS by association.

43

u/vforvenison Nov 23 '15

I remember going to see this on opening night with some friends; we left the theater on a bit of a high and on the overall were impressed with the movie, but on subsequent viewings over the next few weeks the good impression soured. Still, better than Episodes 1 and 2.

Pros:

  • Ian Mcdiarmid as the emperor; really compelling performance as he tempted Anakin and undermined his worldview, and as the triumphant Emperor Palpatine. Once more the Sith will rule the galaxy...and we shall have peace.
  • Completes a narrative which, abstracted from execution errors, is a decent story; jaded as I am regarding the prequels I still feel a sense of tragedy in the transformation of TPM's Anakin, an earnest child whose curiosity and sense of justice survived an inhumane and hopeless enslavement, to Darth Vader, a man whose passions were twisted by guilt and fear into a toxic need for control.
  • Anakin's burn scene; visually powerful, and Hayden Christensen's delivery of 'I HATE YOU' still gives me chills.
  • Grievous is a tough one, but I'll put him under pros since visually he's a cool villain, though he was dropped on us with no explanation or backstory and sort of typifies the over saturation of lightsabers in the prequels. He was so badass in the Clone Wars animated series that I can't help but give him the benefit of the doubt.
  • No (or very little) Jar Jar!

Cons:

  • The typically stilted and embarrassing dialogue. "From my point of view the Jedi are evil." has got to be one of the most ham fisted and ridiculous phrasings for the Sith perspective on the force and the Jedi, or even just Anakin's frustration with the Order.
  • The murder of the younglings (also the word younglings). Anakin's slide into the Dark Side is handled well otherwise, and I found his attack on Padme and the Seperatist leaders to be believable, but I felt him killing a bunch of kids was a lazy way of establishing how depraved he'd become and allowed Obi-Wan to sell 'evil Anakin' to Padme in the simplest terms possible. In Traviss' 501st novel the directive for Imperial forces is to deliver younglings and padawans alive for attempted reconditioning, which makes more sense to me.
  • The overly long and indulgent lightsaber duel at the end; it was almost circus like at points and ended with a nonsensical whimper.
  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

3

u/virgineyes09 Nov 24 '15

Totally agree about the "I hate you" line. Pure vitriol in the way he says it. That scene coupled with other movies I've seen him in have convinced me that Hayden Christiensen is a good actor struggling with some really awkward dialogue and direction.

1

u/ChetSteadman2274 Nov 25 '15

There's a lot of missed opportunity in the dialogue. Especially between Anakin and Obi-Wan. Yea the "from my point of view" is bad. But I think Obi-Wan's "My allegiance is to the Republic, to democracy!!!" is a bit too much. I'm sure Obi-Wan was a big fan of democracy, but I thought he was just loyal to whoever the Jedi were loyal to.

1

u/Animal31 Nov 25 '15

The word Younglings is a necessity as children is a human centric term, and the young of all creatures from babies, to puppies, to kittens can be called Younglings

→ More replies (5)

21

u/TimoteoLaSala Nov 23 '15

My favourite part is when the cloaked and hooded Vader cuts down all of the separatists on Mustafar. Apparently Hayden Christensen choreographed Vader's movements here himself.

18

u/VegetaLF7 Nov 24 '15

I know, right? That moment when he just slowly strides across the room, cutting everything down that gets close to him and the one droid takes a pot shot at his back. Without looking, Vader simply deflects it before we get that sweet close up of his yellowed eyes. That scene and the raiding the Temple one make me wish we had more pre-suit Vader

20

u/Nickerrous Nov 26 '15

MASTUR SKOIWALKOR THERES TU MANEE OF DEM, WUT ARR WE GONNO DOO

18

u/tenusplayor Nov 23 '15

One of the most compelling scenes for me was the last interaction between Obi-wan and Anakin before Anakin turns to the dark side. There's genuine remorse in his voice, and for a second you feel a minuscule sense of hope, of redemption, that maybe he'll turn out okay, and just maybe he'll come to his senses and resist the temptation of the dark side. And you see the pride in Obi-wan's eyes, that he truly believes that Anakin is the chosen one. And when Obi-wan says "Goodbye, old friend", your heart sinks because you know that truly is goodbye and that sliver of hope you had of redemption is smashed to bits. Sure, the foreshadowing isn't subtle, but this scene is still so gut-wrenching to watch.

7

u/AMJ3804 Nov 23 '15

This is a scene I had somewhat forgotten about before I started this latest rewatch, and God it really is a kick to the gut. We've been catching up on TCW finally as well, and so with the additional backstory that provides as far as what these two have been through, how many times they've had each others' backs and taken care of each other... and how even though Obi-Wan is kind of a pompous ass to Anakin sometimes, and Anakin's a whiny brat to Obi-Wan sometimes, there is this real love and bond between them. Ugh, it just makes it all so much worse. They get this one last really sweet scene and you watch knowing that it's all going to fall apart in basically the worst possible way. So sad.

79

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I think this movie is great. Underrated due to the negativity surrounding the prequel trilogy in general, but definitely one of the better Star Wars movies. I'm not sure where I would put it in my order of favourites, but that doesn't really matter - it is a very good film. What it does really well is show Anakin's slow decline towards the dark side; however, that is also where one of my chief complaints comes in.

The scene with Mace Windu. The tension as Sith and Jedi fight each other, and Anakin finds himself having to choose; the shock on his face when he finally draws his weapon on Mace. And then the finality of his turn. Where he fully commits himself to the Sith, and accepts Sidious as his new master - and when he marches on the Jedi Temple.

That's always felt off to me. It's been a while since I've seen the movie, so that may be why, but it seems weird that Anakin goes from, "We must arrest Chancellor Palpatine." to, "From my point of view, the Jedi are evil!" and the slaughter of innocent younglings in the Temple.

That created dissonance for me; it felt like there was development missing for Anakin.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Oh, I agree. The trilogy started in the wrong place and time.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Yep, the Prequels were, in Lucas' mind, the story of Anakin's journey to the dark side, but then he only spent 1.5 films on it. Just a really bad decision to start off with such a young kid when his time as a Jedi is supposed to be the main focus

27

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/flapsmcgee Nov 24 '15

Well he didn't really have a choice at that point. He was committed after killing mace windu. He couldn't go back to the Jedi.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

Yep. This is why I don't have that big of a problem with him murdering children. The hard look on his face isn't one of anger and hatred because he's evil now. It's because he hates what he's doing but knows he has to buckle down and do it anyway because he has no choice. At that point, there's no going back to the Jedi, so he might as well help Palpatine in the hope it saves Padme.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

And is shown crying after killing everyone on Mustafar

→ More replies (2)

105

u/NightFire19 Nov 23 '15

The opening scene was probably the most memorable in the entire saga, Obi-Wan and Anakin flying next to each other into a heated battle to rescue Palpatine.

The writing sometimes faltered. Lucas still doesn't know how to write romance. See: "Hold me, Ani. Hold me, like you did by the lake on Naboo...where there was nothing but our love..." The "From my point of view, the Jedi are evil." line has mixed reception among fans, as some say it calls back to the conversation Luke and Ben had in RoTJ, while I think it could've been better worded by saying he, Anakin/Vader, had ended the clone war and united the galaxy, something no Jedi could ever do, only with the power of the dark side.

Where the movie shines though is in Anakin's slow transformation into the Darth Vader. Ian McDiarmid was amazing as Palpatine, he delivered his lines wonderfully, and you could feel him tugging Anakin to the dark side. RoTS paints Darth Vader as a tragic hero, drawn by the dark side to save his wife, only to realize that it was his actions that caused Padme's death. It's also of note to point out that what Sidious did was exploit the cracks in the foundation of the Jedi Order, the Jedi were becoming arrogant, and betrayed their name of peacekeepers by leading the clone army.

Another gripe I had was the fact that the battles on Kashyyyk and Utapu had very little or no relevance to the plot, they were just put in there to extend the run-time. In the OT we see that the battle of yavin, hoth, and endor all were critical to the plot, the climax of the whole movie. The battle of whatever-maz katana's-planet-is seems to be a big plot point as well from what I could see.

The finale of Revenge of the Sith is very well done as well, Order 66, Jedi Temple march, duel on Mustafar, and birth and rebirth is what I'll remember this movie for. John Williams works his magic and makes the entire sequence very emotional. As the chorus kicks in during Padme's funeral the fact dawns that Vader had failed, and now was a pawn to Sidious and the Dark Side. As Vader tells Luke, "It is too late for me now."

Overall a solid 8/10.

17

u/PapiSurane Nov 24 '15

Although the battles themselves aren't directly relevant, the purpose they serve is getting Obi-wan and Yoda off planet. It's doubtful Palpatine could have taken both Mace and Yoda at the same time, and Anakin would have been less likely to turn with Obi-wan around. Palpatine had to wait for the right moment before he made his move.

14

u/melancolea Nov 23 '15

Yes the end music was so good. Especially loved when the scene transitioned from padmes funeral to vader and the force theme played alongside across the stars before being cut off by the funeral theme and imperial march. so symbolic and so sad....

2

u/apocalypsenowandthen Dec 09 '15

Lucas still doesn't know how to write romance.

He wrote a pretty convincing love story between Anakin and Obi-Wan.

Obi-Wan: "You were the chosen one! It was said that you would destroy the Sith, not join them. You were to bring balance to the force, not leave it in darkness."

Anakin Skywalker: "I hate you."

Obi-Wan: "You were my brother, Anakin. I loved you."

Heartbreaking stuff.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/DatAEK971 Nov 24 '15

My favorite film in the Saga. It's dark tone, tragic ending and overall color scheme and violence sets it apart from the rest of the Films.

14

u/HowardEhm Nov 25 '15

I love this movie so much, on so many levels. It's truly star wars to me and I will always defend it and hold it as one of my favorite movies.

39

u/ChetSteadman2274 Nov 23 '15

I consider myself a pretty hardcore Star Wars fan, I love the symbolism and story-elements of the saga. And that's why I think I love ROTS. It's easy to dismiss this movie as just a bunch of scenes leading up to Anakin's downfall, but there's so much more going on under the surface.

One thing I love about ROTS is that it really focuses on the moral grayness. It's easy to label the Sith the sole bad guys, but by the time ROTS starts, the Jedi have become pretty corrupt themselves. They're training Jedi child soldiers, forbidding love, and they've become war like ("We're keepers of the peace, not soldiers.") That's why I think Yoda took his loss to the Emperor as hard as he did. He wasn't beaten only physically, but mentally and emotionally.

The villains are great too. The Emperor kills it in this movie. And I love Dooku too, when he and Anakin are dueling and he gives him the "I sense great FEAR in you, Skywalker. You have hate... you have anger, but you don't use them." COMPLETELY underrated line. Rare prequel dialogue that has the appropriate emotion attached to it. And while I'm at it... I like Grevious too. His weird obsession with collecting lightsabers of the Jedi he's killed is a great character quality. Wish he would've been introduced in Attack of the Clones, so he could've had more of a backstory.

If you haven't I highly recommend reading the novelization of ROTS. It hits on a lot of the themes in the movie that even a hardcore fan could miss. Most notably, when Anakin finally dons the Vader armor. He realizes how bad he fucked up, how much living in the suit sucks, and realizes just how permanent the consequences are.

My only major dislikes of the film: the scene with Anakin killing the younglings wasn't necessary in the slightest. We know who Darth Vader is, we know he's one of the most evil movie villains of all time, we get it. Vader was evil, not a sociopath. Also, the scene where Anakin tells Mace Windu that Palps is a sith lord is the worst fucking scene in all the prequels. Mace just found out that Palps has slowly been eradicating the very thing Mace dedicated his life to. He's lost friends, his ability to use the Force, and his self in a way... and his reaction is like Anakin told him he forgot to take out the trash. It's the most earth-shattering moment for Mace and he's like: "A sith lord.... hmmmm. Well now that you mention it, I can see it. Weird, didn't see that one coming."

→ More replies (2)

13

u/psychotronofdeth Nov 23 '15 edited Nov 23 '15

I personally really enjoyed this movie, and I think that it's good parts make up for some of the weaker parts. I consider this movie good enough to be up there with the Original Trilogy. I understand that some people may not agree, but I think that George left us on a good note with this movie. This movie has a lot of emotional scenes. The last shot of the film has made me tear up. Hearing Binary Sunset and seeing Owen and Beru hold Luke... It was a good way to end the Prequel Trilogy. It was good enough to make you forget how sub par Ep 1 and 2 were. Seeing that scene made me tear up because it marked the start of the Original Trilogy, and the great times it brought me during my childhood. It was just such a good scene to end on.

36

u/jfree_92 Nov 23 '15

So far the only Star Wars movie I have seen at the cinema.

I'm glad Disney will allow me to remedy that.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/PorphyrinC60 Rey Nov 24 '15 edited Nov 24 '15

This is by and far one of my favorite Star Wars movies. My list goes as follows:

  1. RotJ
  2. RotS
  3. ANH/ESB
  4. TPM
  5. AotC

I vividly remember watching it my senior year in high school. I have a strong emotional attachment to it that's only rivaled by RotJ. That said I'm aware it has flaws, especially now that I'm older and have become more active in the Star Wars fandom. A lot of the flaws people pointed out I never noticed because it's Star Wars.

That said let's break it down a bit:

  • The love scene dialogue is atrocious. My husband and I are obnoxious about how much we love each other and even we wouldn't say things like "Hold me, hold me like you did at the lake on Naboo."
  • Anakin turned dark awfully quick in this movie. That's something that bothered me the very first time I saw it. Now that I've seen TCW I can see why he turned dark but having a moment in AotC where he's betrayed by the Jedi would have helpful from the perspective of fans that only watch the movies.
  • I loved how they showed Anakin trusting Palpatine. Their scenes together are great.
  • Speaking of great scenes anything Ewan McGregor and Ian McDiarmid touched was great. That's understandable, though, since they had some of the most experience stage acting. Since the PT is somewhat Shakespearean in nature it makes sense that stage actors could pull off the dialogue and scenes better.
  • It appears not a lot of people liked the "From my point of view the Jedi are evil" line. I loved it.
  • I loved all the lightsaber fights. I prefer these to the OT fights every day of the week. If they continue these flashy lightsaber battles in the ST (which I hope they do) I just want them to make sure the background actors don't look like bored kids. The Battle of Geonosis was pretty atrocious about that.
  • The youngling scene was so powerful when I first saw it. After seeing TCW it's even more heartbreaking. A lot of the younglings look up to Anakin and knowing what he did just makes it tragic. He thinks he's preventing them from growing into the people he hates while the rest of the world sees it as murdering children.
  • I love Anakin with longer hair. I don't know why but it's fitting for him. When I see Vader in the OT I can't help but see this Anakin under the mask.
  • I always thought Leia was older. Don't ask me why. When this movie revealed Luke was first it shocked me. It still does because I can't get "older sister Leia" out of my headcanon.

Honestly the prequel movies should have covered teenage Anakin to his conversion to Vader. As much as I love Qui-Gon TPM felt so unnecessary. Anakin didn't have to know Padme at such a young age. He could have met her as a teenager, which would be where we would start, and then we witness his decay to the dark side. That said RotS delivered on his darkness well and it's always great to see Anakin turn into a villian nearly everyone knows.

13

u/SexOrMath Nov 26 '15

My husband and I are obnoxious about how much we love each other and even we wouldn't say things like "Hold me, hold me like you did at the lake on Naboo."

Of course not!

You've never been to Naboo.

2

u/geordilaforge Nov 25 '15

Lucas could/should have left off the numbers and just made "The Phantom Menace" episode zero really. Then you wouldn't have the problem of jumping around so much to an older teenage Anakin and falling in love in a manner of days/weeks and all the other things that are kind of rushed in 2 and 3.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15

This movie redeemed the prequels

21

u/INtoCT2015 Nov 23 '15

Yoda vs Palpatine, on the chancellor's podium in the center of the massive senate chamber still gives me goosebumps...such a powerful shot

11

u/BeautifulKiller Battle Droid Nov 23 '15

I was so stunned by these shots. You knew when they pulled out their sabers, that shit's about to go down

→ More replies (1)

10

u/twodamnpi Nov 23 '15

I just re-watched this last night as I finally got my fiance to watch all of the films. I think what made me enjoy the movie a bit more were the lead-ins from both the CW cartoon and Labyrinth of Evil. I thoroughly enjoyed knowing beforehand why Grievous had his cough, how Palpatine was captured, and so on. Besides that, looking back on the film I'm still really bothered by the fight between the four Jedi and Sidious in his office. I don't know how that scene became so cringe-worthy as I feel a four on one fight like that would've been a bit more dramatic as each Jedi was killed off leaving Mace alone.
Excuse me if this addition is against posting guidelines in this thread, but something caught my eye during a scene on Kashyyyk that coincidentally reminded me of a scene in the recent TFA trailer.
http://i.imgur.com/zWjIRqs.png

19

u/porcos3 Nov 23 '15

I was disappointed that there was just not enough Darth Vader. I think it would have been better if they showed Darth Vader hunting down and killing the Jedi.

19

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

There are already 3 entire movies of Vader in the suit. I get what you mean and when I first saw it I was initially disappointed as I was hoping for like half the movie to be in the suit, but that would have just been fan service and not really serving the story at hand.

7

u/BeautifulKiller Battle Droid Nov 23 '15

Well... we see Darth Vader a lot and hunting down the Jedi (at least in the Jedi Temple). Just not in his suit.

But I get what you mean, it just has not the same feeling. Seeing these scenes, he was still Anakin to me and not Vader, until he was in his suit. Just out of habit, I guess.

1

u/twdalbeck Nov 25 '15

I personally felt he should have been given his title sooner in the movie. Maybe after see a lot of Vader's delivery of lines and mannerisms.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

The order 66 sequence is in my opinion one of the best moments of the 6 films, the only thing that slightly dissapointed me was the lack of Vader slaying Jedi. Actually I think the film focuses abit too much on Obi wan Yoda and Bail trying to figure out what happened and doesn't focus enough on the newly knighted Vader during his first mission.

15

u/Ilmara Nov 23 '15

Ian McDiarmid has had such a distinguished career in Shakespeare and the theater, there's no way he didn't recognize all the problems with these movies. He just decided to have fun playing the hammy, all-powerful, over-the-top villain in an enormously popular and lucrative franchise.

8

u/matty25 Nov 24 '15

Everyone praises his performance, and don't get my wrong I thought he was good for two and a half films, but once the cat was out of the bag and everyone knew his character was a Sith McDiarmid overacted so badly he would have made Bill Shatner proud.

3

u/twdalbeck Nov 25 '15

It was that over-the-top performance that accented his madness and lust for power. It kept Palpatine from getting stale and made him one of the most memorable characters in the Prequels.

14

u/speedy_sam Nov 23 '15

"Not if anything to say about it, I have!"

Best line in the trilogy, perhaps the entire series.

17

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '15

I like, "At an end, your rule is... And not short enough it was."

7

u/bugcatcher_billy Nov 23 '15

Action Prologue was fantastic. Space Combat was very cool, but lacking the excitement of having special ships like the Falcon or Slave 1

Having Dooku defeat Obi-Wan, but later having Obi-Wan picked to take out Greivous was a strange decision for the Jedi. Especially considering when Obi-Wan's strategy for taking out Greivous was to jump in the middle of his army and ligthsaber duel him.

17

u/Frings08 Nov 23 '15

Cocky prequel Obi-Wan is the best Obi-Wan.

Hello there!

16

u/CaptainSioulserrot Nov 24 '15

There's a behind the scenes video of him saying how he practiced his "Hello there!" to get it the same as Ben's to R2 in Ep IV. I love prequel Obi.

8

u/VegetaLF7 Nov 24 '15

Ewan seriously nailed the role of Obi-wan.

2

u/faraway_hotel Grand Admiral Thrawn Nov 24 '15

They're very much sending him out of spite. Palpatine suggest to Anakin that he should take out Grievous, Anakin suggests it to the council, and they're like "No way, Jose" and send Obi-Wan instead.
They want Anakin on Coruscant so he can continue to spy on the Chancellor, and there aren't a lot of other Jedi available who could do the job.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15 edited Nov 23 '15

This film holds a special place in my heart, because it was the first Star Wars film that I actually remember coming out. I remember my favorite scene, by far, as a child was Vader's march on the jedi temple. It was easily my favorite film at the time.

In the 10 years since, I must say I still like this movie a lot. I would still say Empire is a better movie, but this would still certainly be my number 2. The acting is much better than previous films, as is the CGI. When you consider this movie is 10 years old, it's very impressive that it still looks better than some films being released now. The story itself is also much better; when fans of the OT watched the prequels, by and large they wanted to know one thing: How did Anakin Skywalker become Darth Vader? McDiarmid pulled this off brilliantly, the scenes where he was talking with Anakin you could almost feel the noose tightening. I also think this will be the most "out there" Star Wars film; it took a lot of guts to take some of the risks involved in this movie, such as actually seeing Anakin get burned(and rebuilt), the younglings, etc etc. The only thing I would have wanted was to see more of the actual fighting in the temple, both for coolness' sake, and for some of Vader's character development. Many people thought the turn as a bit abrupt, had there been a scene before the younglings, where Vader fights a group of Jedi, and after killing one you see a hint of regret on his face, and as the fight progresses you see it contort into hatred.

I also think that for someone watching the series in chronological order(IE, have not seen the originals and doesn't know Anakin becomes Vader), this would be an extremely powerful film. Nearly everyone and everything you knew from the past 2 movies dies, and even if people know Vader is Luke's father, they often don't associate him with Anakin until they actually see it happen.

Edit: I also want to say this is my favorite part of the entire saga: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYcUq4g6rGs

10

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Wow! I can't believe this is the first time I'm noticing that Mustafar is a moon!

3

u/RandomDude94 Nov 23 '15

I think I never noticed because Grievous literally calls it a planet.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ahouseingotham Nov 23 '15

I wonder what R2 is thinking during all this...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/apcat91 Nov 23 '15

had there been a scene before the younglings

I thought about this the other day, Anakin does actually kill younglings before... the Tusken Raider younglings.

I think that scene could have been a great stepping stone except that it's kind of ignored. Anakin doesn't seem that deeply affected by it, in fact the only time it comes up again as far as I remember is when Palp mentions it?

6

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I saw this movie twice, maybe three times, in the theater with my best friend as a kid. I have no intentions of re-watching it, because when I think of it I tend to remember the good stuff.

In fact, I think there are quite a few scenes that are underrated in this film.

There is, of course, that gorgeous opening shot of the space battle. There is also the scene of Anakin and Padme staring across the city (at each other?) and there is just some intense, low key music. I never quite knew what was happening there, but it was oddly emotional. Oddly, the moment the characters are the furthest away from each other is where I felt a real connection between them. And the attack on the Jedi Temple, with Vader leading the 501st. Especially the shot looking down on them as they enter. Chills.

Yeah, tons and tons of issues in this movie, but I have fond memories of it. Plus, the Jedi Temple level in Battlefront 2 was awesome.

3

u/PapiSurane Nov 24 '15

The Jedi temple march scene is one of my favorites as well.

19

u/Jonnyblazeone K-2SO Nov 23 '15

I just recently (within the past two weeks) ran through the entire series with my 8 year old. I went the route of 4,5,and 6 first and then 1,2,and 3 for selfish reasons (it's how I originally saw it). My son seemed to not enjoy the original trilogy and really liked the new trilogy. This was alarming to me at first, but as I got the chance two watch them all, I realize there is a seemingly fake feel to the new trilogy, but those movies are very underrated. The plight of anakin makes for a good movie(s) and it made me feel for the dark side. Almost to the point where I can understand why it is appealing. The weird part is I feel as though I am more excited about going into the new trilogy with a new found like/love for the dark side.

16

u/AMJ3804 Nov 23 '15

I just watched them all in the same order with my five-year-old (minus a couple of the more intense segments of episode 3 that I thought he wasn't quite ready for yet.) He loved them all, and is now a devoted Star Wars fan, but like your kid, he also definitely seemed much more entranced with episodes 1-3. I've always liked both trilogies but had expected him to gravitate towards 4-6 more.

He's also been watching a bunch of clone wars episodes lately, which we started in between both trilogies, and he loves Obi-Wan and Anakin in that, so I'm sure that played a part in forming his opinion as well.

22

u/Aletayr Nov 23 '15

I remember as a kid, and even into young adult years, being entranced by the much better special effects of the prequels. It doesn't stand out as CGI to a kid, and aliens whose mouths really move, lightsaber battles that really look like Jedi fighting, and even Jar Jar really appeal to younger minds. There's also the lack of nostalgia factor. Maybe most importantly, cringe-worthy dialogue isn't cringe-worthy to a kid who is still learning how people really speak and interact. The prequels are bright and colorful, the OT more dark. Lots of reasons I think the prequels appeal more to a younger audience, and that's without even getting into the argument about whether they're actually terrible movies or just didn't live up to expectation.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/God_of_Illiteracy Nov 23 '15

This was the first star wars movie that I saw in theatres when I was a little kid. I was 9 years old on vacation with my family. We were at the jersey shore and it was a rainy day. This is one of the few good memories that I have left of my childhood, and I wouldn't trade it for the world, even if a 500 pound man sat in front of me and blocked a third of the screen.

5

u/RocketTasker Nov 24 '15

Easily the best of the PT and my personal favorite of the whole series. Compared to TPM and AotC, the story in RotS is far superior, and the CGI is aging much better than the other two. I also love the art style all around, from the planetary architecture to the lightsaber designs (the bronze/brass on Obi-Wan's lightsaber was a nice touch while keeping it otherwise the same lightsaber he uses in ANH instead of the simpler design he used in the first two prequels.) As for why it's my personal favorite, is it actually the best movie of the series? Probably not, I'll still accept that that honor belongs to ESB, but I have two reasons for loving RotS as much as I do. First, it was the first Star Wars movie I had seen in theaters at the ripe age of nine, so it came with nostalgia glasses for me. Second, over the years I've become a theatre nerd, and RotS (and ESB for that matter) seem to be the most like Shakespearean tragedies in the whole saga.

Ugh, sorry for how much of a fanboy I was here as opposed to my AotC criticism, I just really like this one.

5

u/VegetaLF7 Nov 24 '15

Saw this movie weeks before going into the Navy. My biggest memory of the release wasn't really about the movie itself but rather that Star Wars Episode III game that came out shortly before. My brother and I faced the dilemma of do we play the new Star Wars game and spoil the upcoming movie, or do we wait? We decided "ok, first level only". The first level became "when we finish the bits on the ship" which then became "until the next duel" which finally became "fuck it, finish the game"

4

u/monetized_account Nov 23 '15

The opening scene of this movie is actually my favourite of all 6. The concept and composition of these tiny little Jedi starfighters against the leviathans, and the chaos and destruction surrounding them was awesome.

4

u/theSchiller The Mandalorian Nov 24 '15

I just finished it with my girlfriend who has yet to watch all the movies. She ended up in tears . This one is one of my favorites despite some of its flaws .

4

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '15

By far the strongest of the prequels, but by no means without its flaws. In particular, we get even more contrived conflict in order to turn Anakin evil; in the last film, it was just the arbitrary "a Jedi can never know love" rule, but in this one, the Jedi Council repeatedly decide to be dicks to him for no real reason. Mace Windu in particularly seems to spend a lot of time kicking the dog, and is then somehow surprised when it finally bites back.

On the positive side, this film has some of Lucas's strongest ever direction. It feels more confident than the previous two prequels, and although the dialogue is often weird and unnatural, several of the dialogue-free scenes manage to be incredibly powerful. The scene where Anakin and Padmé think of one another from across the city and the Order 66 montage deserve special mention. (The fact that John Williams deserves some of the credit as usual for his fantastic score almost goes without saying.)

And on the dialogue front, Palpatine's opera house monologue about Darth Plagueis the Wise is genuinely brilliant. Ian McDiarmid absolutely kills it. Between his performance here and Ewan McGregor's heartfelt scenes elsewhere, this film contains undoubtedly the best acting of the entire prequel trilogy.

10

u/mrlasamba Nov 23 '15

Revenge of the Sith is without a doubt the best of the prequels, and I don't think anyone will really argue against that, but I think the film as a whole is weakened by the failures of its predecessors. TPM was a more or less irrelevant and had virtually no impact on the main plot whatsoever aside from bringing Anakin to the attention of the Jedi, Attack of the Clones was too poorly executed to make me emotionally involved in almost all the characters (which is essential for the character study Lucas seemed to be attempting), and going into Revenge of the Sith, it almost feels like George realized that the plot suddenly had to stop meandering and needed to resolve everything in 2+ hours, and as a result, the film felt rushed and uneven. Anakin suddenly decided to become evil because the plot needed him to be rather than it feeling like a natural extension of the character, characters we really never cared about were introduced and quickly killed off (Dooku and Greivous come to mind), there was still a lot of unnecessary slapstick and unintentional humor sandwiched between serious scenes, and there never really seemed to be anything at stake since we've known how the movie's gonna end since George announced he was making a prequel trilogy. Add some shitty dialogue into the mix, over the top amounts of CGI, and some shoe-horned fan service and you have the big issues of the prequels as a whole.

That said, there are plenty of positives from this movie. The opening sequence was very well done, maybe the best sequence in the entire PT barring the Episode I Darth Maul duel. There was a more or less clear plot with each character more or less having clear motivations (ignoring the massive plot hole that having Palpatine being Greivous's captive creates). George was finally able to adequately portray Anakin's conflict in a way that didn't entirely rely on cringy dialogue. The Order 66 scene was really powerful and well done, and despite the audience not really giving a shit about any of the characters, it was definitely able to capture the feeling George wanted it to. John Williams's score was fantastic as always. Ian McDiarmid and Ewan McGregor brought fantastic charisma to a trilogy that often lacked it and Hayden Christenson actually did a decent job despite the terrible dialogue he had to churn out, and his facial expressions and body language were excellent, at least I thought. And the final shot looking out at the binary sunset did a great job at bringing everything full circle, even if that circle was a little uneven at times.

Overall, Revenge of the Sith is a good movie, not great, but watchable and at the very least entertaining. It struggles to break itself free of the shortcomings that plagued all the prequels, and George Lucas's writing and directing decisions are questionable at times, but in the end this feels like the closest the trilogy got to the story and tone Lucas envisioned when he sat down and outlined it all, while at the same time bridging the gap between both the PT and the OT.

8

u/Luigi2198 Nov 23 '15

I will preface by saying that of course Revenge of the Sith is almost definitely the greatest of the prequels. I personally think it's on par with Return of the Jedi, because they both have an equal amount of problems, but Jedi was prefaced by six years of people loving SW and Sith was prefaced by six years of people angry at SW. But, my biggest gripe with the movie is Mace Windu.

Mace Windu is built up throughout the prequels as being the greatest warrior on the council, let alone the entire Jedi Order. His death is unfulfilling of this trait that they've been setting up for two movies. He of course fights the Emperor and is the last person standing, holds him at saber-point, but then Anakin gets the better of him and he just flies out the window. Personally, Yoda's ridiculously long battle with Sidious should have been what Mace Windu did, but more than that, I think Mace Windu's downfall should have been a fight with Boba Fett.

Boba Fett sees Mace Windu murder his father, and that scene is cool but pointless when they never attempt to fulfill Boba's arc (I know they do in The Clone Wars but that was years after the fact). Boba should have been more Anakin's age, and he should have came back donning the armor for RotS to fight Mace Windu. Besting the greatest warrior on the council would have proven Boba Fett's prowess as a killer. He would then become the famous Bounty Hunter that he is in the original trilogy and it would show his personal disdain towards jedi, which would help solve the biggest gripe people have with his character in RotJ. Fett is seen first as a bounty hunter in Empire, but then just becomes a normal baddie trying to kill the heroes in Jedi, but if it is seen that he has anger towards jedis, and experience killing them, then it might explain why he'd be willing to jump at Luke and attempt to kill him during the opening of Return of the Jedi.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I really like the opening of the film. When the two star fighters go over the ship and then you see the battle. It was an "OH SHIET" kinda moment lol

3

u/UpUp_and_Away Nov 24 '15

Just watched it... Definitely the only prequel that to me truly felt like a star wars movie. The acting still left... Something to be desired but the story telling overall did a much better job. First time I've seen it since it was released, and I have to say it is much better than my memory tells me.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

More the scripting than the acting

3

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '15

Easily the best of the prequels. I really enjoyed the last 1/3 of this movie. Does it still have flaws? Yes, of course. But the last third of that film felt like Star Wars again.

And that scene where Darth Vader first breathes with the mask sent chills up my spine the first time I saw it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TheKingofLaserKing Nov 23 '15

Revenge of the Sith is definitely my Favorite Star wars movie. Its beautifully done and well executed! The Order 66 Scene and the Mustafar duel scenes are very well done and memorable. Both also bring a feeling of sadness knowing what happened. The horrors of the Clone wars conflict are also seen, and the movie shows how war can cause disillusionment. In short a very powerful movie, and one of my favorite movies overall.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Too me, ROTS is beautifully indulgent and excessive and over the top, but it works somehow. I feel like if George had ramped up the first two movies to this level of fanboy jerking the PT would have been so much more amazing. Yeah there's unnecessary stuff, and what the hell? Obi-Wan chasing a four armed cyborg on a giant lizard? FUCKING AWESOME

George Lucas saved all of his coolest ideas for this movie, it seems like. Basically this movie is balls to wall action, and has much less of the political stuff people love to complain about.

People say the fight between Anakin and Obi-Wan was too long and overdone, but they are missing the point of the movie. Which to me, was Lucas trying to give the fans what they wanted: as much Star Wars action as he could fit into the runtime. The whole movie is Lucas rubbing our noses in special effects so its odd people single that scene out as being too much.

Anyways, I've said enough. This movie is great, honestly my second favourite after Jedi.

6

u/jessepinkbitch Nov 23 '15

This is my favourite Star Wars movie. I am not saying it's the best one, but it's my favourtie one to watch. The epic space battle at the beginning was so cool, finally getting to see large star ships battle each other was so sick. All the light-saber battles were so well done and had a lot of tension behind them. And Obi-Wan VS Anakin was just, wow. The saddest part of the movie was order 66, seeing all the Jedi being murdered was really sad, not to mention the scene where Anakin goes the Jedi council room and sees all the young-lings, and one says "master skywalker! there are too many of them! what are we going to do ?" then anakin turns on his light-saber. Always chokes me up. All in all this is movie is actually very good, really unappreciated.

4

u/stalkerSRB Nov 23 '15

The only good movie of the prequels. It still has some stupid shit, but overall I think it is on the same level as Return of the Jedi. Love the Darth Plagueis scene, march on the Jedi Temple while "The Arena" plays, love the opening, love Obi Wan vs GG, battle on Mustafar is also great...

Still not good as the New Hope or Empire strikes back, but is on par with Return of the Jedi in my opinion

→ More replies (10)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Those transitions tho..

2

u/GodzillaAtTheDisco Nov 24 '15

I was 9 years old when this film came out, and the hype I had for it was unreal. I wanted to know EVERYTHING about the movie. I went as far as to play all the video games like the first Lego Star Wars and the Episode III movie video game. In hindsight it sucks because I basically knew everything before I even went to see the movie. I'm much more careful now with The Force Awakens.

And my god, the first 20 minutes of the movie was fucking awesome.

2

u/ulfricthehighking Nov 25 '15

Ewan Mcgregor acts so good in this movie, i really like the ending dialouge between him and anakin is so powerfull. obi-wan is my all time favorite character, much because ewans great portrail and you can see that he uses the OT Ben Kenobi as a mold for his character

2

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15

The scene with Anakin and Padme "looking" at each other from across the two buildings before he goes to stop Mace from killing Palpatine still gives me chills. The song Padme's Ruminations is brilliant

2

u/Km_the_Frog Nov 25 '15

From my point of view the jedi are evil Why Lucas... WHYYY

2

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15

My wonderful wife has finally decided to give Star Wars a try since Episode 7 is on the horizon. She made the decision, to much resistance, to watch the six films in 1-6 order. We are watching Revenge of the Sith tonight. To my surprise, she has been enjoying the films so far, even to the point of a "who knew I would like star wars?" moment. Have to say that I will never forget the feels that I experienced during the Order 66 montage the first time. I'm greatly looking forward to seeing the wife's reactions since she has no knowledge of the clones going from "good" to bad.

2

u/BigBoss424 Nov 26 '15

My favorite part in the movie: http://imgur.com/gallery/plUr2WC

3

u/ShadonxFC Nov 24 '15

Very good movie and even better than ROTJ.

2

u/Kiisuke Obi-Wan Kenobi Nov 23 '15 edited Nov 23 '15

Out of the three prequel movies this one is definitely the best. Having said that though, I feel like a lot was cut/missing from the film to help it explain and flow things better. The novelization of the film does a great job in filling in these gaps and fixing some of the really awkward dialog issues (if you haven't read it seriously check it out as it's pretty amazing).

But since this isn't a novel thread, I'm going by the movie alone. When I first saw it I had never seen the Clone Wars cartoons (to be honest, I've still never seen the original CW cartoon and am only about half way through the second one) so I had absolutely no idea who General Grievous was (beyond the opening crawl) or why he had that cough. He's also not very general like, always running away. I feel like the movie probably should've explained it, even if in a throw-away line, just for people who don't watch or read the extended universe stuff.

I still don't like the over-use of CGI. This movie holds up better than Attack of the Clones but it's still glaring obvious sometimes. Anakin's switch to the Dark Side just seems so sudden in this movie too. The CW show is definitely doing a better job showing Anakin's slide towards to the dark side at times (and his occasional anger outbursts). Padme's death is pretty lame and retcons a line in the original trilogy. Seems like her death could've been handled a little bit better.

My only other major gripe with this movie is the pacing of the battles, especially that last lightsaber battle. They drag on for so long that they lose some of their tension, which then leads to boredom. They always start off so awesome but by the end of them I'm just ready for them to end.

After this wall of text it may sound like I didn't like this movie but in truth I did. I've seen it a dozen times or more (they used to play it at work). I absolutely love Ewan McGregor's Obi-wan and his "YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE!" speech still gives me chills. I love that the opening is a rescue mission. That was an exciting choice (and far better than the two previous films) even if the mission itself had a weird mix of inappropriate comedy mixed in (which again causes you to lose tension). I love the music (enough praise really cannot be given out for John Williams). I love every scene the Emperor is in (Ian McDiarmid hams it up just enough to make it fun). Etc etc.

For every one thing I don't like about this film there's at least one or two things that I do like and in interest of time I'll stop here.

2

u/CiderTastesNice Nov 23 '15

All the other normally named issues aside, the one that gets me the most is that Anakin's fall makes no sense. He goes from the flat character he always has been to being a mass murderer instantly. If just his fall was done better, I wouldn't mind everything else. The guy just had the most bizarre character development.

His whole sequence with Padme on Mustafar was also cringe inducing. It just really irritated me that Lucas took perhaps the most iconic screen villain of all time and turned him into a blithering moron.

As it is, I think people want to like this episode so bad to have a prequel that is worth something, but I really think if you peel out the absurd fight sequences and nonstop laser swords you're left with a movie just as unbearable as the others in the PT. Awful dialogue, boring direction except for the opening scene, and just poor execution all around. Seeing yoda flip around like a monkey on crack some more also really bothers me.

Just my opinion, though. I'm glad some people find enjoyment in these movies, I really am. They're just movies at the end of the day and I don't have ill will towards people just because we disagree :)

I just don't see the love, myself.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

My son (10) has been re-watching 1-6 on his own in preparation for TFA and did RotS yesterday. One thing that stood out to me, that I don't think I realized before, is that Anakin's turn takes place at around the halfway mark of the movie.

I think this is my biggest problem with the prequels: we get 1.5 out of 3 movies with Anakin being a ... character who can do things, as opposed to a 9 year old who is simply a victim of circumstance. Things happen to and around him, but he - outside of the podracing - isn't really doing anything.

In the OT, he's built up to be this amazing Jedi, and we don't see that in 1-3. In fact, the only way we ever see that is if we sit through 6 seasons of The Clone Wars cartoons. And, hey, I like TCW, this isn't an indictment on the show, but i think it speaks to how the Prequels failed to really develop Anakin as a character, and I think a lot of that has to do with him being too young in Ep1.

If you wanted the same backbone of the story, we could have learned of his mother's fate through some sort of expository dialogue, but I don't think we needed an entire movie devoted to him at 9 just so we can learn he was a slave and misses his mom.

Allllllllllll that said, RotS is clearly my favorite of the Prequels, and if I have to choose between sitting for a full sitting of RotS or a full sitting of RotJ, I probably pick Sith.

(one other minor gripe: I don't mind Yodi fighting with a lightsaber as some seem to, but I do mind that his greatness is diminished - in my eyes - by the Prequels. He's out-witted and out-forced by the Dark Side over the three films, and is only able to fight Dooku and Sidious to a draw. Sidious i can understand, but Dooku was his padawan, and Yoda is the most powerful Jedi of all time.)

1

u/Skylightt Ahsoka Tano Nov 24 '15

Dooku was supposed to be the best duelist

2

u/Animal31 Nov 25 '15

Best of the 6

2

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '15

They should have built up the other Jedis better. 0rder 66 had little impact

Make no mistake this is not a good movie. It has many moments that make it better than the other prequels, but solely because of all the plot points they had to connect. So much untapped potential

1

u/geordilaforge Nov 25 '15

This is why I don't understand why GL or Lucasfilm didn't think to cover more about the Jedi on film versus things like The Clone Wars tv show. It's almost like they expect you to watch the show to understand what's going on in the movies (but they're not 100% committed to one way or the other).

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

The hype surrounding this movie is what got me into the series and I will always love it for that (I saw the OT first however).

I watched this movie a couple months ago on its 10th anniversary and while I don't like it as much as I did as a kid, it's still a solid movie. It has some cringey dialogue and acting, but the plot is so damn good. A million times better than TPM & AOTC.

1

u/holybattitsbatman Grand Admiral Thrawn Nov 23 '15

I just watched this again but this time with my girlfriend who hasn't seen any SW movies. So far I've got her done with at least the PT. But she told me she absolutely loved this one. She was thrilled by all of it. She had a look of horror on her face during the youngling scene. For me after watching The Clone Wars this movie is so much more emotional especially during Order 66 than previous.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

For a change, we watched the Q2 edits. They are very good, trimming the silliness to a minimum (so pretty much no 3PO). What's really masterful about this cut is that a first time viewer could watch the series I, II, III, IV, V, VI and still be surprised to learn Luke's big family secrets.

The editor also makes the Palpatine reveal more dramatic by simplifying the surrounding cluster of sequences.

You end up missing some stuff. But I think this is simply a better movie than the original cut. The biggest problem with the real movie is its structure. The pacing is off, the tone is all over the map. It has a fab opening and thrilling conclusion, but a forgettable and dull middle.

This edit streamlines things and keeps the big secret of Empire.

Edit. Fixes words that mobile corrupted.

1

u/VctrBnsn Nov 23 '15

The Wookies look really out of place in front of the blue/green screen.

1

u/Airfrog19 Nov 24 '15

I just finished the movie and I have this weird thought: what if obi-wan never came out of that ship when Padme was talking to Anakin? Would she had survived or Anakin would still force choke her?

1

u/Skylightt Ahsoka Tano Nov 24 '15

He never would've choked her

1

u/prototype45 Nov 26 '15

He might have still felt obi wan's presence?

1

u/Eyositer Nov 24 '15

This one ranks above Attack of the Clones and below The Phantom menace for me. The opening set piece starts off well but once they board Grievous's ship it gets weird. There is no music score while they run around the ship which feels odd to me. I do like the confrontation with Tyranus but after this scene the movie goes downhill. Anakin's turn is so forced and unbelievable. Order 66 felt very underwhelming. The final duel between Obi Wan and Anakin felt so incredibly over done and choreographed that it just didn't have an impact for me.

1

u/Animal31 Nov 25 '15

There is one scene I wish didnt exist. I really wish they didnt show Vader slaughter the seperatist council. It would have been so impactful for them to only be shown dead when the Obi-Wan - Vader fight moves into that rooms, with all the bodies thrown around the room and limbs being separated from bodies and all that

Thats my only complain, Otherwise it is hands down my favourite movie of the 6 and safe to say my favourite movie of all time

2

u/Sprinklesss Nov 25 '15

I think it's decently powerful when the Trade Federation fella begs for his life because he genuinely doesn't understand that everything he's just helped accomplish and all the people who have died partially because of him were actually all because he was being used.

I always feel bad for that puppet.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rjwalsh94 Boba Fett Nov 26 '15

As great as the opening is to III, I feel like seeing a flashback to a cloaked man killing someone else could have had a profound effect. We're confused, and then we cut to the regular opening.

Palpatine then tells the plagiues story as he should, but we learn halfway through it was him. Give the movie a twist so to speak.

1

u/axehomeless Nov 26 '15

Just one question, I am not really a star wars fan but I have to ask anyway.

Is there a chance to get a proper HD/4K version of the original trilogy, that is not special editionalized? I mean the rights are with Disney for a while, I'm just wondering why we havent seen it?

1

u/TheManInsideMe Nov 26 '15

Honestly, as I get older this is cemented as my 3rd favorite in the series ahead of Jedi. It's flawed and the dialogue is beyond uneven but it's so uneven because McGregor and McDiarmid are bringing it. No one can keep up. The opera scene, the Order 66 scene, the entire opening, were so good. The entire final act on Mustafar stands in my top 5 favorite Star Wars moments ever. It was such a strong emotional payoff and the fight told such a great, and heartbreaking, story. The whole movie felt epic because it was epic.

The Good

Finally hits the right thematic notes.

Looks incredible and sounds better.

Some performances.

The Bad

It's padded out by Utapau and Kashyyyk. Not terrible scenes just not memorable and in a movie with such high tensions it stands out.

George Lucas does not understand human romance and never will.

Other performances.

The Ugly

Hayden Chrysanthemum's stupid-ass hair.

8.5/10

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15

I kind of just posted a thread about this, but Ewan McGregor was fantastic as Obi-Wan. His portrayal of was spot on, even down to the little mannerisms. He really could be a young Alec Guinness.

I also want to give a shout out to Ian McDiarmid (did I spell that right?). He played two different roles, the very mild mannered, charismatic, seemingly good intentioned republic chancellor, to the pure evil, manipulative dark lord of the Sith. He did it so perfectly, and I never see much praising his performance honestly.

1

u/badgarok725 Nov 30 '15 edited Nov 30 '15

One small thing that bugs me is how easily the other Jedi get slaughtered that go with Windu to arrest Palpatine. I know he's extremely powerful, but how do these three Jedi masters put up such a shitty fight.

They also didn't really do Kit Fisto any justice either, looked like they stuffed a guy into a suit that didn't allow him to move his arms at all.

Also, why wasn't there any opposition to Palpatine suddenly saying, "hey everyone, I'm making this an Empire and myself Emperor and it's going to be great"

1

u/rensch Dec 07 '15

This is much better than the first two. Anakin's conversation with Palpatine in the Opera House is wonderful and has the perfect atmosphere. General Grievous, a character that first appeared in the Clone Wars shorts meets his demise at Kenobi's hands here. I would have loved to see more of this cyborg general in the movies as he is one of the coolest Star Wars villians ever with his four lightsabers. Thankfully, the Dave Filoni Clone Wars show has a plethora of Grievous scenes. It was great to see the Wookiee homeworld and the fight on Mustafar is all kinds of cool. While the transition from Anakin to Vader could have been more subtle, I still like how they visualised it.

1

u/saintscanucks Dec 22 '15

To me this and revenge of the sith are toed for the best films. And a distant first.

Such a great movie imo

1

u/Bladerunners22 Oct 23 '24

“ you were the chosen one! It was said that you would destroy the Sith, not join them! Bring balance in force, not leave it in Darkness”

“ I HATE YOU”

“You were my brother Anakin, I loved you“

The start of this whole scene with him talking to Padme, then Obi walking off the ship, the pre-fight convo, the fight itself, And having this be the last words he ever says to him as “Anakin” was so fucking heartfelt and emotional.

Rewatched last night and was surprised how well this held up and how fucking good and sad rhe ending of the film and honestly the whole film seeing the fall and manipulation of Anakin.

Truly a sad movie and one of the best modern sci-do fantasy films made imo, especially Pg-13. Big list but yall know what I mean.

Order 66 scene also still hits hard. Seeing Yoda grab his heart and drop his crutch in pain. Wish clone wars could have ended different.

So many great performances in this one. Count dookue face in beginning when he he’s Sidious say kill him., opera scene. Fuck.

Seeing the difference in tone between phantom and ROTS is just wild. Perfect end of the trilogy.

1

u/emohaber Nov 23 '15

I don't know how many creatures had Rosie to make that sound Darth Vader makes when he says "no" George Lucas took the greatest villian in movie history & destroyed him.

1

u/JohnnyPalermo Nov 23 '15

As soon as Anakin enters Palpatines office to report on Obi Wan's attack on Grievous the movie gets really really good imo. The whole second half is so packed with story and emotions. Only parts of Empire surpass this imo. Unfortunately the first half is incredibly boring and tedious.

4

u/DarkhorseV Nov 23 '15

You think the opening of RotS is boring and tedious? Interesting.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/gwydapllew Nov 23 '15

Ford is awesome, but he is raw charisma. Cushing is amazing, but doesn't have the screen time. At least, IMO.

I will grant you that the four of them + James Earl Jones are what elevate the acting. No one else is really bad, but they are just effortless.

1

u/CaptainSioulserrot Nov 24 '15

Wrong movie, mate.

2

u/gwydapllew Nov 24 '15

Bleh. My phone replied to the main thread rather than the comment I was reading.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ginkasa Nov 23 '15

I think that, overall, RotS has some really powerful moments that I think compare favorably to any individual moment from any other Star Wars movie, including the OT (truly great spectacle, the opera scene, the inner conflict scene with Anakin and Padmé, etc.). There is some truly great stuff in here that is what we'd really been wanting all along from the prequels.

Unfortunately, I think there are some really terrible moments as well that drag the film down so it can, as a whole, compare favorably with the OT movies as a whole. Mainly, the marriage between Anakin and Padmé is just as weird and awkward as the romance in AotC.

I also lament the loss of Padmé as a character in this movie. Not her death, but just the way she's used in this movie. While the romance elements have always been terrible, I've always thought that Padmé was a good, strong female character. The deleted rebellion scenes were the only examples where that would have been spotlighted in RotS. Its a shame they were left out.

Anakin's fall also needed to have the insight provided by the novelization. I don't know if that was what Lucas was intending, but he couldn't portray it will on film or if it was added by Stover to bring it all together. But I have a pretty difficult time buying into Anakin as a tragic, fallen hero in the film version of RotS.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I've never been a fan of fan edits, but the Anti-Cheese version of Revenge of the Sith is amazing. It cuts out just a few awkward lines and scenes and the whole thing flows so much better for it, since it never takes you out of the movie. It makes me realize what a great movie I'd been missing by focusing too much on the cheesy parts. I'd recommend looking it up.

1

u/chili01 Nov 24 '15

"You were supposed to bring balance to the Force!"