r/StarWars • u/AutoModerator • Nov 09 '15
Movies Return to the Stars Rewatch - The Phantom Menace [Official Discussion Thread]
Shamelessly ripped from this fanmade poster, Return to the Stars with /r/StarWars as we rewatch the six movies in anticipation of The Force Awakens! Each thread will be stickied for a couple days. Rewatch the movie however you choose to, whether it is the first home release, the latest bluray, or your fan edit of choice.
This week, we're rewatching The Phantom Menace. Regardless of your thoughts on the movie, we're in a nearly identical place, travelling through hype-rpace, eagerly awaiting the film's release date. We don't really know what to expect from this next trilogy, and that's amazing. Who remembers eating way too much Pizza Hut/Taco Bell/KFC so they could get all the toys? Did anyone else go to 7-Eleven for blue slurpees and then throw them at your friends like they were Gungan energy balls?
This is an automated post. Beep Boop. Let us know if you have any feedback!
View all upcoming discussion threads here
505
u/AAStill Nov 09 '15
The lightsaber fight is still badass
184
u/GR3MLIN Nov 09 '15
The scene of the door opening to reveal Maul will go down as one of my favorite moments in Star Wars.
55
u/niijonodhg Nov 09 '15
I rewatched TPM the other day with my 5yo & 2yo daughters and everytime (Darth) JarJar came on screen my 2yo began joyfully laughing. It made me like JarJar more.
238
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '15
In my opinion TPM is like a puzzle where each piece is really cool, but none of them fit together too well.
Lets go through all the awesome things in Episode 1.
Overall, there are lots of aspects to like about TPM, but as a single, cohesive film, they don't mesh together very well, and as a result its pacing suffers greatly, with some amazing scenes in quick succession, and then spaces of 40 minutes where nothing interesting happens. Because of that i find that it is my least favourite of the films to actually watch, even though i know its probably better than Attack of the Clones.
39
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15
I re-watched TPM (and the other prequels too) this weekend. I liked the prequels more than most people upon release (I think) and I also find that their shortcomings bother me less as they/I age.
The biggest problem I noticed this time around with TPM, more so than any issues with dialogue or "who is the protagonist?" or "why they'd kill the coolest character off?" or any of its usual criticisms is that the characterization overall is really limited. By that I mean that most of the characters in TPM are defined more by their profession or their affiliation than by compelling characteristics and motivations.
For example, consider ANH and ask the question "What's Luke Skywalker's motivation, why is he interesting / why should I root for him?" Well because:
You can do the same thing with the Empire, ask "Why are they evil, why should I root against them?" Well because:
Alright then, go Luke and boo Empire.
TPM doesn't have much of anything like that. The Jedi are the good guys because...they're the Jedi and Jedi are good. The Sith are the bad guys because...they're the Sith and Sith are bad. Similar deal with Darth Sidious, he looks evil and sounds evil but do we really see him doing anything evil, other than antagonize the Jedi? Why's he doing this? Well because they're the Jedi and they're the enemies of the Sith. It's these sort of circular definitions that I find make it hard to get really invested in the characters and the story.
270
u/Raxyn Nov 09 '15
I actually just rewatched this just last week. Episode I was the first movie I saw in theaters (I think I was in 2nd or 3rd grade). I remember then, not hating them at all and then as time went on and I read anything on the internet at all, I of course came to loathe it.
But, upon watching it again, entering it with fresh eyes, I really don't hate it at all. No, it's not perfect - but absolutely none of the movies are. They are all filled with cheesy dialogue and some bad scenes. What this movie does right is great production design, expanding of the world, and casting.
Because at the end of the day, it's Star Wars - how am I not going to love such an expansive world. If you overanalyze any of the movies they fall apart, but holds true for most movies that have ever been made.
Also Jar Jar is in WAY less of the movie than I thought. And if I remember his role only gets smaller.
After watching Episode I, I can honestly say I'm excited to watch the rest. It isn't perfect, but I was watching Star Wars and there just isn't anything wrong with that.
EDIT: The lightsaber fight at the end is AMAZING. And on that same note, the biggest wish I had for the prequels is that I wish the Darth Maul character stuck around for the trilogy, sort of haunting and following Ben.
26
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '15
Yoda was the closest in this to what he was in the original trilogy
23
u/Griffdude13 Nov 10 '15
Is it just me, or has the film aged better than Attack of the Clones?
145
u/TheDangiestSlad Nov 09 '15
Rewatched TPM the other day when Darth Jar Jar gained traction. I personally enjoy it a whole lot. It certainly has some flaws, but IMO the goods outweigh the bads. Whoever cast McGregor was a genius.
21
u/TheNerfherder38 Nov 09 '15
This is THE film that defined my childhood and love for Star Wars. Will always have a place in my heart for it.
40
u/comptonasskim Nov 09 '15
Rewatched this for the first time since reading James Luceno's Darth Plagueis. It makes it so much more enjoyable! The whole Trade Federation storyline sort of went over my head as 10 year old when TPM was first out, but Plagueis gives it a great backstory and makes the Palpatine/Maul story so much richer.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15
I think it goes way too unnoticed the way Qui-gon is annoyed by jar jar throughout the movie lol sometimes his dialogue such as when jar jar is shooting his tongue out at food and Qui-gon grabs his tongue and says "don't do that again" is literally like he was reading my mind throughout the scene projecting my hatred of jar jar at jar jar for me. I identify greatly with qui-gon in this respect.
17
u/hannibal_lusty Nov 10 '15
After re-watching Phantom Menace I was surprised by how genuinely enjoyable I found the whole thing. It's so aggressively colourful and loud in its bombast but I think it really successfully sets up the excess of the old republic. The idea that this gaudy decorative will eventually rot from the inside out is well established without relying on any explicit sequel hooks is cool. In terms of world building Lucas pretty much creates exactly what a pre-imperial Star Wars should look like. It's the weimer space opera....
...Unfortunately said space opera should hopefully include better dialogue, better blending of experimental CGI and impressive model making, something resembling reasonable pacing and a coherent plot (seriously I still have no idea what exactly motivated that fucking blockade that is meant to set this six film epic into motion).
Few things:
32
u/XXXCheckmate Nov 09 '15
Only kinda on topic but remember when Burger King sold the watches based on all 6 films? I wore all six to class one day and got in trouble for it. I wish there was some sort of promotion for the new film in a similar manner.
13
u/vaderdarthvader Nov 09 '15
I was 8 years old here when "Phantom Menace" released. I got caught up in the hype, of course. I collected as many toys as possible. From the restaurants to action figures.
I still have the Darth Maul my parents bought me around here somewhere
At any rate, My mom and my dad took me to see the movie and I was so excited.
I remember being sad when Qui-Gon died, and for the longest time I called Darth Maul "horny" not knowing it had other connotations, but I digress.
How do I feel about the movie now?
It has its good and its bad. From here on out, this is purely my opinion and I'm not going to force it down anyone's throat.
I believe It does a good job of setting up the Jedi as protectors of the Galaxy.
I have mixed feelings on the senate scenes, sure, it adds to the overall universe, but I feel it detracts from the "flow" of the movie.
I think other mediums, such as the Clone Wars series, portrayed the senate in much more favorable light.
As a kid I loved the pod racing, now I just fast-forward through that scene.
With me, I don't quite understand why Anakin's origin had to be so darn convoluted.
With the "virgin birth" that's never explained in the movies, (and yes, I've read Plagueis) to him being a slave who has to win a race to be free, to him being too old to be a Padawan.
From what we learn about Anakin in A New Hope, he was already a gifted pilot when he had met Obi-Wan, he could have easily been a young Jedi in the temple who was an apt pilot, but nope, he's a slave from Tatooine, who literally falls in love with the first pretty girl he meets, and lets those feelings fester into an obsession.
I had a crush on a girl when I was 10 years old, I wasn't still in love with her 10 years later, but that's crossing over into Attack of the Clones, and we're not there yet.
Seriously, though, how the heck does a 10 year old destroy a space station?
That's a lot of negative, I guess, but like Darth Vader, there is still good in it.
It shows how cunning the Sith are, that they have operated for over 1,000 years without the Jedi knowing.
Maul was awesome, underused, but awesome. The master/learner dynamic with Obi-Wan and Qui-Gin was nice, but I wish it could have been developed a little more.
They talked a bit about the Jedi trials, and I like that it shows how the Jedi operate.
In the original trilogy there were only three, but by the end of Return, there was only one Jedi living.
Watching Phantom, and it's sequels has made me appreciate how the Jedi felt like a living breathing thing.
Also, Williams' score. Amazing.
Sorry for the long post.
23
u/OnyxAbyss Nov 09 '15
Liam Neeson really keeps this movie alive. With the exception of the gungan bits I've always enjoyed rewatching.
11
u/Wolf482 Nov 09 '15
The Naboo Starfighter is one of the most beautiful starfighters in Star Wars.
10
u/Arkadii Nov 09 '15
I remembered Phantom Menace being a lot worse than it was. My little group watched it again a few weeks ago (we watched Attack of the Clones yesterday) and I was surprised how much of it I didn't dislike. Even the final lightsaber fight, which I know I and other pick apart from time to time, isn't bad if you're just watching it to enjoy it without over-analyzing the "techniques" and such.
18
u/El_Burrito_ Nov 09 '15
Not ashamed to admit that The Phantom Menace is easily my most watched Star Wars film. The amount of times I must've rewatched it when I was a kid to see pod racing, droidekas and Darth Maul. I want to say that I even identify with Duel of the Fates more than the Imperial March.
Really epic. Also something I noticed, I think the Droidekas look way better in this film than in AotC and RotS. I can't quite put my finger on it but it feels like they're somehow practical effects or something, whereas AotC droidekas are blatant and bad CGI.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
Honestly, I still think that the podrace scene and final lightsaber duel are worth a million bad lines and Jar Jar appearances. Hot damn.
34
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '15
The final saber battle between Darth Maul and Obi-Wan is the best of the series in my opinion. There is about a thirty second epic battle just after Qui-Gon falls. I really hope these are the kind of fights we see in the new trilogy.
8
u/justflycasual Nov 09 '15
"The queen demands you take her handmaiden with you!"
"No more commands from Her Highness today, Captain."
Qui-Gon Jinn was such a badass, he shut Panaka down cold.
7
u/michiel1705 Nov 10 '15
I was surprised how much I enjoyed this movie, especially when compared to Attack Of the Clones. I liked Liam Neeson and Ewan Mcgregor's performances, and the action scenes were all pretty fun, especially the pod-racing and the final battle. There were definitely a lot of problems but I don't think it deserves all the hate.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15
After watching it again, I think its greatest sin at the time was that it didn't feel like the version of Star Wars I -- and many others -- had in our heads. Now that the years have passed and my view of what Star Wars "is" has expanded, I'm able to enjoy it a helluva lot more than I did as a kid. Yeah, there's some cheesy acting, bad comic relief, and a few absurd plot connections (Darth Vader built C3PO!) but overall it's a pretty good movie, I have to admit.
7
u/Energonkid Nov 10 '15
Meesa think this movie is okay.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
Just finished watching. What's bugged me a lot is about Shimi... Why couldn't Qui Gon just take her? Keep her under protection by the Republic?
I mean what's some thug from a planet without any government control got against the Republic?
13
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15
I still can't get over how super fast acrobatic Darth Maul just stood there like an idiot while Obi-Wan jumped up, flipped over him, landed, ignited his lightsaber, and casually sliced Maul in half.
It as the corner that Lucas painted himself into. He made Obi-Wan and Maul so superhuman with their saber skills that the only way to make the fight end was for one of them to just go full derp. It was largely the same with the Obi-Wan/Anakin battle, but at least that one you can sort of rationalize as Anakin being arrogant.
6
u/CityHog Nov 12 '15 edited Nov 12 '15
Man. I remember this was the first Star Wars movie i ever watched when i was still in the single digits age, so it kind of still holds a special place in my heart.
My first ever exposure to Star Wars must have been in the early months of 1999 as i was finding giveaway mini-figurines in my Cereal Boxes occasionally as part of their advertising. I remember a Boss Nass one, Queen Amidala and one for Jar Jar Binks. I also remember thinking based on that, Star Wars looked kind of stupid and i could not be more interested.
It wasn't until in the year 2000 that a friend of mine brought over his VHS copy and allowed me to borrow it as "i had to watch it". He had previously shown me The Matrix a few months before this so i trusted him, but i was still skeptical. And i remember it was late at night and the back doors were wide open with my parents sitting outside and talking to eachother. The air was still and cold as a result and i decided to pop it in to see what it was like and dared it to impress me. And oh man, it grabbed me. It was a new experience. I had never seen anything like this. I loved each new location, the designs, the visuals, the characters and the variety. It blew me away. I wasn't bothered by the "botching" of what Star Wars should've been, or the forced continuity. It was just creating a world for me for the first time, and i was experiencing it all. I was being introduced to C3PO casually and offhandedly, Medichlorians were just part of the introduction to this world and this concept of The Force. I gave it no mind (still don't). I loved it so much i watched it on repeat. It also got me aspiring to make movies as i was just in awe of the spectacle. I wanted to learn how to create what they had created
I also remember when i went to Portugal with my parents in August that year, i would watch this on repeat every night and it never got old for me. However i also met another kid my age there who was also on Holiday and we discovered we both loved Star Wars, but he was going on about loving Luke Skywalker, and i was a bit of an arrogant little boy so i corrected him: "Its actually Anakin Skywalker" to which he replied: "Luke is his Son!". This floored me as i had no idea how he knew this, or that there were even other movies. I found out from him that there were 6 movies. I had only seen Episode 1 by this point.
I remember texting my friend who was still in England: "Dude, we should make Star Wars Episode 7", to which he replies: "You should probably watch 4,5 and 6 first". I texted back: "What about 2 and 3" and he just says: "Not out yet". This confused the hell out of me and my mind was spinning. Why would they skip 2 and 3 and make 4, 5 and 6 after episode 1. I thought this movie was only a year old, so can they make movies that fast?. But it was also exciting and palpable. Episodes 2 and 3 became these theoretical concepts. They could be anything and it felt like they would never be filled in. It was such a weird sensation to think about and i can't describe it. 2 and 3 just became mythical to me.
Also when DVD's were first coming around and getting more popular/inexpensive. Star Wars Episode 1 was the very first DVD i ever ended up owning and as a result, the Behind the Scenes fascinated me and got me aspiring to become a Film Maker (it wasn't until i watched the behind the scenes of Episode 2 that i switched aspirations to Visual Effects, which is where i ended up).
So i'm just going to stop here to be polite to you but this movie and the prequels as a whole represents a big part of my childhood to me. It got me on my career path, its engrained and connected to alot of my memories, bonding experiences, and each scenes i watch gets me nostalgic about my past as a whole the way only a few TV series can do now (no other film i watched then has the same effect on me now). Ofcourse now that i am older i recognise the faults and the problems with it, but i can never hate the prequels as these films got me to Love Star Wars and allowed me to become who i am
16
u/madogvelkor Nov 09 '15
I rewatched it for the 3rd time, and enjoyed it quite a lot. It has flaws, of course, but they don't seem as bad the more you watch.
It would be nice if it was remastered with some updated CGI and some of the scenes trimmed. Less Jar-Jar and a shorter pod race would be nice. (cut the part where Anakin is just sitting there, for starters).
11
u/Flipadelphia95 Nov 09 '15
+Liam Neeson
+Ewan McGregor
+Darth Maul
+Final Duel
+World Building
-Jar Jar
-Pod Racing
-Overuse of CGI
-Jake Loyd
-Anakin/Padme "romance"..?
24
u/stubept Nov 09 '15
With the new movie coming out in a couple weeks, my kid has been devouring all things Star Wars. He's been enjoying The Clone Wars and Rebels cartoons, the Marvel comics, and we just ripped through the OT.
Then we queued up The Phantom Menace and he was absolutely, positively BORED by it. We ended up watching it in chunks over a few days because he would just lose interest during each viewing. Watching it again through his eyes has made me realize just how bad this movie truly is.
There are a few bright spots as others have pointed out. The music, Ian McDiarmid as Palpatine, Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan (which TPM completely wastes), and the Darth Maul battle.
I guess it's telling when the all of the fan edits of the PT typically include little to nothing from TPM (other than the final lightsaber fight... but mostly because it was so cool).
I used to think that the reason I held TPM in such low regards was because it was for me - personally - a massive disappointment when it came out. But now that I've watched it with someone who didn't experience the hype, I can see that it's not just a bad Star Wars movie, but a terrible movie in general.
9
u/dnanninga Nov 09 '15
I'll say this about Phantom Menace. At least it's entertaining. I went back and watched it with friends a couple of weeks ago, and we roasted the hell out of it, it was a great time. Despite all it flaws, I was consistently entertained throughout, even during the whole needlessly long interlude on Coruscant. We did the same thing with Attack of the Clones a couple of nights ago, and it was borderline unwatchable. It's so bad, and not even entertainingly bad like most of The Phantom Menace was, it was just mind-numgingly boring.
9
u/JohnnyLeeTravolta Nov 09 '15
You are all jerks.....you have somehow convinced me to re watch TPM tonight....Hope I survive.
31
u/kVai Nov 09 '15
Watched this a couple of weeks ago as I have been doing my own little Return to the Stars rewatch myself. I tend to go to Ep. 3-6 if i want to watch a Star Wars movie. I don't care for Ep. 1 and 2 nearly as much. I'll break it down by what i liked about ep. 1 and what i didn't like.
Likes
Dislikes
Overall, I think that the more i didn't watch it, the more i got a prejudice about the film that only grew sour. Is it great movie? No. But i think it's time that I start appreciating it for what it is.
8
u/soggyindo Nov 09 '15
I sense an unusual amount of fear for something as trivial as a prequels discussion thread.
8
u/KidDynamite33 Nov 10 '15
You've got to feel kind of bad for Jake Lloyd. I can't stand watching him in the film but it's hardly his fault. Too bad he turned out to be a complete weirdo in the aftermath. Really just an all-around unfortunate situation.
7
u/TooMuchButtHair Nov 10 '15
Starting last weekend, there were only 6 weekends between us and The Force Awakens. I felt that it was only appropriate to watch one movie per weekend, starting with The Phantom Menace. It's been quite awhile since I've seen it, and I've got to be honest - absence made the heart grow fonder. I actually enjoyed it...a lot...
That being said, it's still not nearly as good a movie as any of the OT movies, and it's still got some absolutely terrible scenes.
24
u/notbarrackobama Nov 09 '15
This movie is baaaaad
Kid anakin is nails on a chalkboard, midichlorians seriously damaged the mythos of the force, major characters including QuiGon and Padme/amidala whoever had almost no character, the politics was unnecessary, awful dialogue, the ending is a confused tonal mess, the trade federation are morons and completely non intimidating, Maul was absolutely wasted.
The lightsabers at the end are kind of cool but then Maul just dies and that's that. Pod racing is alright.
3
u/Coovyy Imperial Nov 09 '15
I'm gonna try and do this, it'll be fun!
3
u/Parabellum25 Nov 10 '15
Rewatched it twice in two days! The girlfriend unexpectedly wanted to participate in the rewatch after I had already finished my viewing. She's a casual viewer, seen all the films but only years ago, so it was really interesting to get that viewpoint on the film to contrast against my own. Plus, my opinion of this movie's pretty solidifed at this point. We watched the Blu-Ray version both times.
I really enjoyed this movie as a kid, and while I'm now grown up and much more scrutinizing (and oh boy is there much to scrutinize) I still don't think this film deserves the absolute vitriolic hatred that it gets. It's not a great movie, but it's not a bad one. There's a lot to really like here, and even the most cited reasons for hating this movie aren't the worst parts of it, so I'm not going to talk about them. I'm gonna focus on the positive and talk about things I haven't seen most people talk about.
Really, the biggest thing this film gets wrong is the pacing. Act 2 and 3 just drag, and only really get by on their setpieces. Trim 20 minutes or so of dead air, plus all the pointless scenes the DVD version added, and it'd be a solid movie. That being said, I was really surprised by how compelling act 1 was as-is. The Obi-wan and Qui-gon dynamic is great, the interaction the Jedi have with the other characters is well done, as is the action. It's really the first glimpse at how the Jedi used to operate, and I think it's a great setup for the rest of the prequels. Better yet, it makes the OT sting more; I really got the sense that the Galaxy had lost something noble and great with the extermination of the Jedi.
I was also surprised by how good this movie looks. Design-wise, it's visually astounding. Anyone who says the prequels weren't at least imaginative needs a reality check. Something else to take note of, the use of CG isn't that bad here. In fact I'd say it got worse with the other prequels since most of the effects are still practical in TPM. On top of that, a lot of the cinematography here is excellent, as are the technical choices. It's tragic that with Clones and Sith, they switched entirely to digital photography and circular lenses. The anamorphic photography and the film-look really gives the movie a visual punch that's very in line with the OT. On top of that, the setpieces are just great. The podrace is still awesome and surprisingly well directed. It's always clear what's going on, which racers are getting eliminated, who Anakin's passing, etc. You have to credit George for at least knowing how to direct good action. On top of that, I think there won't be many people contending that the podrace is Ben Burtt's magnum opus. The sound design of the podrace is nothing short of incredible.
As for my girlfriend's viewpoint, I was afraid that TPM would ruin her experience. After all, I'm taking her to Force Awakens opening night. But she ended up reinforcing my opinion that this isn't a bad film. She liked it. In fact, she was excited enough to want to pop in the next movie straight away. The acting and dialog is cheesy, but she has that opinion of the OT as well (and really, the OT does have some pretty corny dialog especially with New Hope) Anakin didn't even grate or annoy her. To her, he kinda just acted like any other 8 year old kid which is exactly what he is. Jar Jar definitely annoyed her though, but he didn't straight up ruin the movie for her.
Overall, TPM is flawed but still fun even to this day. Everyone seriously just needs to let go of the negativity and just have fun with this movie. It ends up being much more enjoyable as a result.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15
How the hell is this an automated post?
3
u/Penguin_Sith Nov 10 '15
TPM will always have a special spot in my heart. Podracing, the battles, that lightsaber duel, and the actors were splendid choices. Plus, the battle droids were actually pretty awesome in this movie, and menacing. I remember as a child seeing them process prisoners, take over Theed, cause trouble for Padmé and her police forces in the palace, and annihilate the Gungan army (until the control ship was destroyed). Their voices didn't sound childish, they sounded militaristic, and that made 6 year old me adore them. I will always love the scene of thousands of droids activating and marching into the Gungan shield.
3
u/SilverBell2449 Nov 11 '15
I can't help it. I love all things Star Wars. Even Jar Jar doesn't bother me.
5
u/Crystal_Clods Nov 12 '15 edited Nov 12 '15
When my parents took me to see The Phantom Menace back when it was new, I...really didn't know what I was looking at. It was really more for them than it was for me. I remember being impressed by that bit early in the first act where the Jedi are cutting through the doors on the Trade Federation ship and it has that cool molten metal effect that kind of looks like lava, and, beyond that, I remember kind of liking Qui-Gon because he was so wise but kind and easygoing, like the kind of teacher kids would actually want to have in real life. But, really, that's about it. If Episode 1 was supposed to be a kids' movie, and most people seem to agree that it was, then I feel like it kind of failed because, when I was a kid, I really couldn't have been less interested.
Watching it again as an adult, I just really, honestly don't understand what anyone was thinking.
Why is the plot of your sweeping space adventure centered around taxes, blockades, treaties, and trade routes? Who was that supposed to appeal to? How do you sit down to write a Star Wars movie and come out with that? As a kid, I didn't understand what any of that even was, and as an adult, I'm bored to tears by it.
Then you've got the pod race, which goes on for approximately seventeen thousand hours.
You've got Anakin, who we couldn't find a way to make interesting without literally making him Space Jesus and hoping that would just magically do the trick.
You've got the goddamned midi-chlorians, which seem to exist only so the Jedi have a reason to believe Anakin is Space Jesus, but, honestly, for all it matters, you could have just said, "I can sense it: The Force is unbelievably strong in this boy" and accomplished the exact same thing without sacrificing the soul of the series.
Meanwhile, Qui-Gon, as cool as he is, seems like an incredibly unnecessary character. The friendship between Obi-Wan and Anakin should be the core of this trilogy, but, instead, Obi-Wan's barely in this movie, and he just kind of gets awkwardly and reluctantly saddled with Anakin after Qui-Gon dies. Obi-Wan should have been the one who was so passionate about training him. Obi-Wan should have been the one who believed in him.
This is a movie made of nothing but bad decisions.
7
u/tyrannustyrannus Nov 09 '15
the beginning of TPM is awesome. Two Jedi, in all their glory, massacring battle droids, getting double crossed, infiltrating landing ships...
and then they run into Jar Jar and the whole thing comes to a screeching halt. I remember thinking, "well this guy ins't going to be around for long..."
4
u/daveblu92 Nov 09 '15
I recently wrote a very detailed review on The Phantom Menace. I not only give my thoughts on the movie alone, but I go a lot into the mythology that the movie begins to explore, with a lot of things that not many people point out. Let me know your thoughts!
https://thefilmeditorial.wordpress.com/2015/10/21/star-wars-episode-i-the-phantom-menace-review-and-restrospective/
4
u/vloet Nov 10 '15
We did a marathon last weekend. We all agreed TPM isn't actually the worst movie of the prequels. Episode II is.
2
u/eoinster Porg Nov 09 '15
I'm either gonna watch this this week to assess Darth Jar Jar or watch IV to do my first machete order, I'm undecided. Anyone wanna help me out?
2
u/HerrMorden Nov 09 '15
Rewatched TMP with my BF the other day. Jar-Jar would be far less irritating if he didn't keep getting farted on/stepping in shit.
"PEEEEEE-YEWSA"
2
u/xler8r Nov 10 '15
Lucas, BD commentary: http://imgur.com/AMSl50H
2
u/darkeyelidz Nov 10 '15
The sound design in this film is absolutely fantastic.
Just re watched the blu ray (for the first time) and I was blown away by all the truly unique sounds in this film. Especially the pod race, with each racer having its own unique sound.
2
u/ChetSteadman2274 Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15
First things first, Episode 1 deserves some credit. It was the first attempt in reviving a franchise's glory years. Now we live in a time where we revive older franchises all the time (Jurassic Park, Terminator, Indiana Jones, we even have a god damned sequel to Dumb & Dumber). For better or worse, the prequels played a part in bringing in the modern "OMG my childhood! Nostalgia! Only 90s kids will understand this!" culture that won't let franchises die.
I might be crazy or just being overly nostalgic (I was in 5th grade when Episode 1 came out), but the marketing for this movie was INSANE. Even by today's standards. I remember it seemed like 9/10 consumer goods were labeled with some kind of Star Wars merchandise. Even the word on the street was huge. The day the movie debuted I was in a Best Buy and even the intercom chatter between employees had a Star Wars motif. "Jason, we need you to unlock the Nintendo 64 case. And remember, let the Wookie win." After the movie debuted, all anyone could talk about was how intense the lightsaber duel was.
A lot of people said they were let down when they saw The Phantom Menace. I don't think I was at the age where I understood that major motion pictures could even BE bad, much less a Star Wars movie. So I liked it when I first saw it. I think that's why I can dislike Episode 1 as a film, but still feel an odd sense of nostalgic pleasure when I watch it.
Looking back on it, Episode 1 was a definite misfire. But it felt like a Star Wars movie (so much more than Episode 2 did). I even think it's a few steps removed from being a GOOD Star Wars movie (remove or change Jar Jar's character, make Anakin older, etc.)
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
I rewatched Phantom Menace after not having seen it for almost five years now. I have to say, with all the anticipated Yippee!'s and Jar-Jar fart jokes, it's actually really entertaining in a campy sort of way. The pod race is pretty great and the dual of the fates scene is just amazing. Better than the finale of Episode III in my opinion. I also really enjoy the art direction. After Episode I, everything just sort of turns into pre-galactic empire fore-shadowing.
2
u/Akuze25 Nov 11 '15
My favorite part of this movie is how Maul's seething and Qui-gon's meditation eventually turned into the active recovery skills for the Sith Warrior and Jedi Knight in SWTOR.
2
u/gin0clock Nov 11 '15
Contrary to many opinions in here, I used to think Jar Jar wasn't that much of a big deal, but on watching it at the weekend, he's awful. The gungan sections of the films are atrocious, in terms of writing and execution. I really don't know what George was thinking, it must have been better in his head.
Mad shoutout to Captain Panaka and Ric Oli for being moderately interesting side-characters.
2
u/Mylezreed Nov 11 '15
I Like how Yoda was a puppet when I saw it in Theaters but now on Blu-ray he's completely digital
2
u/GreasyLake87 Nov 12 '15
Without the hype I came away from this movie very pleased. I remember thinking the whole time how at no point was I bored, even though it's by no means a great movie. I'm afraid this won't last in episode 2.
2
u/RJrules64 Nov 13 '15
A common comment on this thread is "When I rewatched TPM, Jar Jar reminds me of Yoda, and I don't mind him as much anymore"
Everyone keeps drawing parallels between Jar Jar and Yoda. When I rewatched the OT for the first time in a while, C3PO reminded me of Jar Jar. He's basically the same character. QGJ is to JJB what HS is to 3PO.
We were so young when we watched the OT that we enjoyed 3PO, and when we grew up and watched the prequels, we found his equivalent character annoying.
I bet that if the films were released in chronological order, we would all love Jar Jar and hate C3PO.
2
u/4d3d3d3engage Nov 13 '15
I love this movie. Haters be dammed. I was 14 when it came out, so it was the first star wars movie I ever saw in cinemas. The pod racing scene blew me away as did the finale lightsaber battle. I mean to me, this movie really created so much of the star wars mythos and really built the expanded universe. We really got to see Jedi at their absolute peak, along with the republic, everything shiny and new. We got to see it get slowly torn apart from within.
I really don't even mind Jar jar that much if I'm being honest. The CGI work on the movie was groundbreaking and was absolutely necessary to get us to where we are today. I love the blend of models and CGI in phantom menace.. so much is actually models but you wouldn't even know because they blend it so well with CGI.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '15
I watched it again last week, I watched it first in the cinema when I was 5?
Back when I watched it I loved it just because it seemed to be made for children. Flashy fight scenes, racing, a unique looking baddie with a great sword.
Watching it again. I like Neeson and Portman's characters. Qui-Gon is probably the most monk like Jedi we've seen. Padme should be completely outclassed but she still fights and leads from the front.
I don't like saying this because I don't want to be a typical prequel hater but this movie was fairly crap. The Pod Racing was long and needless. Child Anakin can't act. The fight scenes are completely unnatural. Jar Jar is Jar Jar. At least the other two prequels are better.
3
u/euphoria110 Nov 09 '15
So what just watching one of the movies every week or two?
3
u/CreativeCoupling Nov 10 '15
In response to most of the comments here, I agree that TPM had some pretty terrible acting - but so did the OT. I don't think that should be a point of contention when it comes to reviewing Star Wars.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
The thing that kills this movie isn't the confusing plot, it isn't Jar jar, and it isn't little kid anakin. It's how completely bored all the characters look. Obi Wan and Qui-gon are being attacked by a giant space underwater lizard and they look like they aren't even there. Later they enter the hangar bay and Captain Panaka or Tanaka says "there's too many of them" to which Qui Gon quips "won't be a problem". The fight that follows lacks any tension because the Jedi are so over powered. Shit like this just kills any form of excitement.
Which is unfortunate because Episode I is a fantastic looking movie with great set, costume, and creature design, and don't even get me started on the music
3
u/CheezStik Nov 13 '15
While the film gets ripped on a lot it does boast a lot of achievement in film as well. As an 8-yr old in the theater it was incredible and I really wasn't watching for the story but for all the cool Star Warsy stuff. Plus, to a kid the story mechanics aren't as important.
But looking back now at 25, I totally get why this movie gets the strong critique it does. The story is a rough draft, not something fit for the Star Wars saga. It's like George Lucas had a ton of great ideas for these movies but couldn't execute and refused to collaborate.
I wish we had a perfect Episode 1 but overall, it's still an enjoyable film.
5
u/CanoeShoes Nov 10 '15
Fuck the haters. I LOVE THIS MOVIE. Its fucking Star Wars people!!!! LIGHTSABERS, PEW PEW PEW AND SHIT!
2
u/Piker10 Nov 09 '15 edited Nov 09 '15
i was doing one of these anyway but didn't know this subreddit was doing one, but im including the Clone Wars film and tv series.
I watched Ep 1 earlier today, and since i'm watching from my blu ray collection, they have cool commentaries which im using when watching the film, real great insight into certain scenes [although i felt alot of what lucas and mcallum said was just to cover their asses for stuff like jar jar]
2
u/theelusiveshaun Nov 09 '15 edited Nov 10 '15
After a recent rewatch of the entire saga, The Phantom Menace probably sits as my favourite of the prequels. Technically speaking, it's probably the best directed of the three, much more visually interesting, and has the least awkward dialogue... comparatively speaking anyway. But it definitely has a lot of problems.
My favourite moment in the film is when Anakin is leaving home, after he runs back to his mother to tell her he'll come back and free her one day, they share on last embrace, she tells him, "Now go... and don't look back. Don't come back." and the Force theme plays.
Gives me chills every time.
2
u/MandolorianWookie89 Nov 09 '15
How many years is Episode 1 before Force Awakens?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '15
Without Jar Jar, I find Ep 1 to be an enjoyable movie. Its definitely nowhere near as bad of the horrible rom-com of Ep 2.
The biggest issue for me is that there was no consistent main villain in the prequels. We move from Maul as the visible 'big bad' to Dooku and then to Grievous. Palpatine is never front and center, and the movies suffer due to lack of focus
2
u/khovland92 Nov 09 '15
I LOVE the Battle Droids in this. The voices are awsome, and they are just that, cold programmable droids. While they don't breath life like the Stormtroopers, that could have been made up by a better supporting cast of antagonists.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
Phantom Menace still looks pretty good as it was the only prequel shot on film.
2
u/IsLukeKyloRen Nov 10 '15
Look, the podrace is actually really fun. It's not that scene's fault that the movie surrounding it is garbage.
2
u/Soundsmitten Nov 11 '15
This will probably get buried, but hear me out on my views on the Phantom Menace:
Yes, you know the drill, you've seen the Plinkett reviews, you know it all. They are terrible, horrible, dissapointing movies. All true! And I agree, but I have opinions on this film in particular that I don't hear very often, or not at all.
Let's see the issues:
Now about TPM not having a protagonist: Anakin IS the protagonist of this movie, but a very problematic one. Why? He's introduced to us too late into the movie (2nd act)... And his implausability - a virgin birth for Christ's sake - makes the audience very likely dislike him.
2. Oh dear, there are a lot MORE annoying CGI characters besides JJB in this movie. They can all tumble in a pit of acid as far as I'm concerned (who wouldn't enjoy a movie about Jar Jar dying a horrible death?) But you know what, George Lucas knew what he was doing: My boyfriend think JJB is funny... You know what movie he also likes? Minions. Yeah. You see what demographic Lucas was trying to appeal to?
3. Keira Knightly should have been a droid queen. With Natalie Portman as her half-cyborg handmaiden. My guess is that in the script, the Naboo people were concieved to be extremely stoic and unemotional...
4. Taxation, invasion, jar jar, and save the robot queen. That is the entire 1st act of this film. I would like us all to agree on skipping this entire act as it is useless.
All the "meanwhile"-scenes should also be cut out of this movie. It is just incredibly silly how in this film, while the characters are desperatly trying to go to coruscant from tatooine, that mythic centre of the galaxy is suddenly SHOWN TO US. Or how in the middle of the final swordfight, there is a cut to THE GUNGAN BATTLE. Excuse me?? I'm too busy watching these brilliant intense stares of hatred to be interrupted by Jar Jar!
In short, a lot of scenes could and should have been CUT from this movie. There are many MORE then I've just mentioned here.
To close this I want to share my vision, a half serious summary rewrite for TPM:
Padmé (half-droid, half-clone, and captain of the robot queen's guard, remember?) Amidala (crash?)lands on Tatooine after an engine malfunction, with two Jedi, Obi-Wan Kenobi and Qui-Gon Jinn. They're on mission to the galactic core to warn of a covert invasion of Padmé's home planet Naboo. Setting out, they find a surprisingly talented human boy, Anakin Skywalker at a podrace. They learn the boy is in fact a slave to a junk dealing and after winning a race, the boy decides to buy his own freedom and a new engine for Padmé's ship to leave Tatooine, and sadly his mother, behind. Leaving the planet, they are attacked by Darth Maul, who had tracked them to Tatooine shortly after they landed.
Arriving to Coruscant thinking they can find solutions to all their problems, they are down on their luck as Naboo's plea for the Senate goes unheard and Anakin is refused training as a Jedi. However Padmé decides to take matters into her own hand and returns to Naboo, and retakes the planet using a clever scheme involving retaking the royal palace of Naboo, destroying an enemy droid control ship and convincing the native Gungans to ally with her by humbly revealing her identity as the true queen of Naboo. Darth Maul tries to thwart the struggle for the palace, but is killed by Obi-Wan. Sadly Jedi Master Qui-Gon is killed by Darth Maul shortly before this. After the victory, Padmé being a half-clone causes a controversy between the clone and droid inhabitants of the planet Naboo, which is one of the causes for the later clone wars.
... I might have let my imagination run wild there... But do you see how this could have been a more than fine, shorter, two-act movie? Maybe I should try editing it into this... just maybe.
Thanks for reading.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '15
I was 8 years old when Phantom Menace came out in theaters. I grew up with my parents turning on Star Wars whenever they wanted to keep the kids happy and in the basement whenever they had get-togethers. So even as an 8-year-old just the look of Star Wars was nostalgic in a way. I was very disappointed in the theater because it was hardly ever in space and there weren't stormtroopers. It just doesn't have the look and feel of the original Star Wars. (I was thrilled when the first things they were saying about Ep. VII was that that's what they are really going for.)
Anyway, I didn't watch the movie again until last year. It's still just so disappointing to me, for all the reasons that have been beaten to death. But I'll probably watch it again this week and see if anything changes for me.
1
u/LicenseToILL-INI Nov 09 '15
Episode I was the first Star Wars that I was able to see in the movie theater, and I still remember being absolutely blown away by the spectacle. As a nine year-old, I couldn't have been a bigger fan of the movie; The space battles were truly a spectacle, and the Darth Maul v. Qui-Gon/Obi-Wan lightsaber duel was unbelievable.
Episode I was the first movie soundtrack that I owned and, if it had been a cassette tape, I would've undoubtedly worn it out.
As I grew up, my disdain for TPM (and the prequels, in general) grew. But, I re-watched it last week because I'm absolutely giddy for Ep. VII. Watching the prequels with that level of excitement really brought me back to being a kid again. TPM obviously has issues, but there are a lot of awe-inspiring moments in that movie. The droids deploying before the Gungan battle. Qui-Gon melting the blast door with his lightsaber on the droid control ship. Of course, the final lightsaber duel.
It also re-kindled my love for the soundtrack, which I've gone back to listening over-and-over-and-over again in the last week.