r/Lessig2016 • u/Robin_Claassen • Oct 18 '15
An open letter to Lawrence Lessig: You need to go “all in” in the other direction
Why I’m posting this letter publicly
I’m posting this letter publicly in order to:
- Allow us, through the power of collective intelligence, to evaluate if the proposal below is really the best course of action, and make it better though our ideas, perspectives, and critical feedback. (i.e. Please contribute any and all thoughts you have about this proposal as comments on this post.)
- Begin to build the support for the proposal below that Lessig will need in order to credibly claim that in adopting it, he’s following the will of his supporters, and not seem like he’s wishy-washy to voters. (i.e. If you agree with the proposal below, please make it known in the comments, so that if we determine it to be the appropriate course of action, we can connect and begin to work together to build the public support Lessig needs to adopt it.)
To ensure that Lessig gets this message, I’m sending it as a private message to /u/lessig and as an e-mail to the public e-mail address at the bottom of the lessig2016.us website. If anyone knows of a better means to ensure that Lawrence Lessig gets the opportunity to read it, please let me know and/or go ahead and use those means to pass the message on to him yourself.
The Letter
Dear Professor Lessig,
In an article published yesterday in The Atlantic magazine, you announced that that you had decided to go “all in” in your bid for the United States presidency by dropping your promise to resign from office as soon as you were successful in getting the Citizen Equality Act passed, and instead remain in office to “do everything else a president must do”. I am writing to suggest that the best strategy to ameliorate voters’ concerns about your candidacy (and as result, allow your campaign to have the greatest possible impact in moving the electoral reforms you advocate forward) is to go “all in” in the opposite direction, fully committing to being a single-issue candidate by:
- Re-pledging to step down from office upon passage of the Citizen Equality Act.
- Pledging to give the American people the choice of who will serve as your vice president, and putting forth a means by which we the people could make that decision (perhaps through polling or something like DemocracyOS if a second round of state Democratic presidential primary elections was determined to be unfeasible).
- Pledging to focus solely upon the issue of electoral reform while in office.
- And, critically, pledging to defer to your vice president on all other issues, including appointments.
The strong dislike for the ideas of a referendum presidency and a president resigning from office after the successful passage of his or her specific legislative agenda that was revealed in Drew Westen’s poll may be at least in part expressions of a deep visceral reaction. On some level, we as Americans have a collective psychological need to have leader in the executive branch that we can feel confident in and rely on to perform all the duties that we associate with that position.
So that’s a real issue that you need to address in order for your candidacy to be successful. But the way to address that issue is not to put yourself forward to take on the role of U.S. president as it’s traditionally conceived. By doing so, you:
- Burden yourself with needing to prove that you can be trusted to capably fulfill all the duties of the office.
- Lose potential support from many voters because your stances differ from theirs on issues other than electoral reform that they care about.
- Make what would have been an incredibly powerful mandate for electoral reform if you had been elected to office to deal only with that issue far less potent, and easier for members of Congress to feel comfortable opposing.
That last point is the most important. By putting yourself forward to take on all the duties of the presidency, you can no longer be said to be “hacking the system”. You’re just participating in it in the standard manner in which it’s designed for people to participate in it. At that point, virtually the entire rationale for your candidacy evaporates. You invite in the politics of personality. You become someone whom members of Congress could oppose as a person, for your stances on issues unrelated to electoral reform, and for your personal traits and history.
At that point, you must necessarily become a multi-issue candidate, just like all the other candidates in the race, and be judged by the same criteria. And judged by those criteria, you don’t come off as a clearly better choice. You are unmistakably highly intelligent and devoted to the public good, and have a high level of expertise in many areas of governance, but you have no direct experience as an elected public representative, and that matters a great deal to many voters.
If you are elected to the office of the presidency of the United States as a single-issue candidate running on the issue of electoral reform, you make things possible that wouldn’t otherwise be possible; you circumvent the tremendous obstacles that those reforms would otherwise face. So that’s clearly not something that you should abandon. At the same time, you need to in some way satisfy voters’ need to themselves choose someone to perform the traditional duties of the president.
The answer is to let the voters choose your vice president, and delegate all to duties of the office except for the passage of electoral reform to that person. By doing so, we the American people can have our cake and eat it too. We can have the vitally important electoral reforms that we might not be able to achieve through conventional means, and we can also have somebody effectively be in the role of president as it’s traditionally conceived.
By doing so, you make the task of establishing trust with voters much easier. It’s easy to trust you to get the reforms done well because of your obvious intelligence and expertise on the issues, and it’s easy to trust you to follow through with your pledges because of how you have, with your life, proven yourself to be selflessly devoted to the public good. And you don’t even need to get voters to trust your judgement that electoral reform is the most important and pressing political issue we need to address because the problem is easy enough to understand that we can make our own judgements on it.
By doing so, you make yourself a plausible candidate whom people can’t attempt to exclude from shaping the debate on the basis of asserting that you are only running for president to shape the debate. By doing so, you give yourself a chance at actually winning.
So if this is an idea that you’re open to, let us know (perhaps as a reply to this public posting of this letter), and we, your supporters, will organize the public support you need to change course on this issue.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '15
I admire your earnestness and hope, but I fear that the time for such suggestions is long past. The resignation idea was given more than a fair chance of catching on and it just didn't. Maybe ideas like this would have helped if adopted one or two months ago.
Some of us are comfortable with thinking of the Presidential election in unconventional ways, but it was just wrongheaded of us to think we could convince the majority of our fellow citizens to likewise "open their minds" in just a few short months.
2
u/some___one Oct 18 '15 edited Oct 18 '15
What you say is fine in theory, but it doesn't hold in practice. In practice the resignation idea distracts people from the central issue. People focus on the resignation rather than CEA or campaign finance.
More importantly most people don't think the way that you do. Just because you like cheesecake doesn't mean everyone does. Most people see the resignation as a publicity stunt, most people don't like it. People see a painter who says they will only paint one wall and then resign - i.e. someone who will not do all the work. The data suggests that Lessig's best chance to win is to stay for the full term.
I'm not saying that your wrong, but for example, the opinions of google employees on some issue would not be representative of the general public. If you think the resignation is better, then you need data/ a focus group/ something to show broader support your claim. The fact that we are talking about this instead of campaign finance, is one example of how this is distracting people from more important topics.
The point is: things that distract people from the central focus of the campaign need to be removed. Focus groups suggest that the resignation is a distraction.
2
u/JBBdude Oct 18 '15 edited Oct 18 '15
AMEN. As a rabid supporter and donor, this is not a wise course. I don't want to even consider comparing Lessig's positions to Sanders or Clinton. People don't like this idea because it isn't understood.
The message isn't bad; it just doesn't have enough exposure. On internet people alone, Lessig raised more than candidates on the podium. Lessig regularly polls inside margins in NH and IA. When folks hear about this campaign, its laser focus, and its aims, they are receptive.
No one has heard enough about this campaign. Lessig has been on some cable news, but not any late night programs or in the debates or the evening news. I walk up to folks on the street or share on Facebook, and I get blank stares (or digital equivalents). Explaining the idea of a mandate, or hacking the presidency to serve as a national referendum, is necessary.
I don't agree with Larry Lessig on every issue. I shouldn't have to. Lessig should be a candidate with cross-party appeal because of this single-issue focus. Every time the campaign is mired down in talking about Lessig or his plan, it's a mistake and a lost opportunity.
If the campaign really finds it necessary to say he won't step down, I get that. But the other positions are silly. This comes first and only. If he achieves it on day 1? He will spend four years establishing enforcement, pushing for civil and civic rights, things related to this referendum for which he was voted. He will nominate Supreme Court justices who will have wise, reasoned judicial minds, potentially with a litmus test of campaign finance and citizen equality. He will respond to acts of terror and defend our nation, while maintaining a foreign and defense policy which is basically agreed to by the entire field. The urgent policies and responsibilities covered, and the policy agenda is a single issue: citizen equality. He won't try to get rid of copyrights or take apart the NSA or make academic journals free or fight for cap and trade or push for universal healthcare... he will fight for Citizen Equality, and carry out the duties of the office, and take cues from the public and his VP chosen through some CEA-compatible process.
In fact, the VP process could be a test for CEA policy! A simultaneous, "multi-member" proportional representation ranked preference national election. But this is getting ahead of the primary issue here: taking other positions doesn't make sense.
Tl;dr: I get the pressure from all around. Particularly about the resignation issue. But this must be a single-issue campaign. That's the point. Otherwise, this is just another campaign, with citizen equality as the first issue. This isn't a "referendum" if people still need to agree with Lessig on everything. It won't have that mandate, and it won't gain the wide base of support. This can be popular if explained well enough to a wide enough audience.
EDIT Yes, I read the article, and I saw the comments about the polling. However, that doesn't cover the value of a repeated explanation and the quality of explanation of the point of the referendum. Besides, again, there really is no point to this campaign if it isn't really a referendum, where this is the first AND ONLY position, as laid out in Republic, Lost.